[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/news/ - Current News

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: news.png (253 KB, 640x472)
253 KB PNG
Large-scale study finds no link between crime and unauthorized immigration

Watch this thread for a bunch of unsupported cope from ESL shill

https://socialecology.uci.edu/news/large-scale-study-finds-no-link-between-crime-and-unauthorized-immigration

For more than two decades, Charis E. Kubrin has followed the data wherever it leads. As UC Irvine Chancellor’s Professor of Criminology, Law and Society, she has built a career studying one of America’s most politically charged questions: does immigration drive crime?

Now, in one of the most geographically detailed studies of its kind ever conducted, Kubrin and colleagues have an answer.

“Consistent with the research base more generally, unauthorized immigration does not drive crime rates in U.S. neighborhoods,” says Kubrin, the study’s lead author. “Honestly, I wasn't too surprised.”

What they found: neighborhoods where the share of undocumented residents grew actually saw greater reductions in property crime and no significant change in violent crime, contrary to what many claim.

The gap between what researchers know and what the public believes is nothing new, Kubrin notes.

“Nearly 100 years ago, the Wickersham Commission published a report showing that involvement in crime is lower among immigrants than the native born,” she says, “a finding that made its way onto the front page of the New York Times in an article titled, ‘Wickersham Board Frees Foreign-Born of Big Crime Blame.’ That title says it all.”
>>
>>1529249
>UC Irvine professor

100% she's a liggeral. This is a fake study with faked data.
>>
>>1529249
>Large-scale study finds no link between crime and unauthorized immigration
Lmao lol even
>>
>>1529249
What variables did she leave out to get this? Cos there's about 200 studies that found immigration and crime are a 1 for 1 link.
>>
>>1529281
what university did you go to, esl shill?
>>
>>1529282
the shill cope was foretold
>>
>>1529282
it went to the U of I (you guess what the I stands for)

there definitely is a link between unauthorized immigration and domestic crime.
the more unauthorized immigration there is, the bigger the crooks that get elected.
>>
>>1529249
>actually, letting in huge numbers of unvetted people that you literally cannot track is a good thing and results in LESS crime
Yeah, sure.
>>
>>1529249
Not really.
>>
>>1529249
>Large-scale study finds no link between crime and unauthorized immigration
>as every illegal commits a crime just by being in the country illegally
Really makes you think.
>>
>>1529328
Its funny because the study shows that property crime decreases while robberies go up and their conclusion is
>its the poor immigrants being robbed by the horrible indigenous population!
lmao.
>>
>>1529249
>Large-scale study finds no link between crime and unauthorized immigration
That is pseudoscience.
>>
>>1529276
You don’t need data - Just look around to see all the good immigrants do for us!
>>
>>1529249
Illegal immigrants want to keep their heads down because they know that if they get caught doing some shit they're on a one-way ticket back out.
>>
>>1529371
That’s why the more light they get shed on, the better it is for the country!
>>
>>1529249
>Watch this thread for a bunch of unsupported cope from ESL shill
lmao
>>
>>1529388
Immigrants are good for the country thoughbeit.
>>
>>1529365
This but unironically
>>
>>1529399
They are even better for the countries they initially came from
That's why India has a bigger tech sector compared to California
>>
>>1529249
Uh, gay faggot bros, isn't illegal immigration a crime?
>>
>>1529413
Not in the way that you want it to be. It’s more akin to jay walking than something like rape or murder
>>
>>1529414
Isn't Jaywalking a municipal offense, while crossing the border illegally is a federal offense?
>>
>>1529413
>isn't illegal immigration a crime?
No. Overstaying your visa is not a criminal offense.
>>
>>1529414
So? Fuck you.
>>
>>1529417
Oh lawd here we go with the fucking hair splitting.
>>
>>1529417
What if you don't fly into the country legally and overstay your visa. What if you cross the southern border illegitimately and break into the country?
>>
>>1529422
Its not breaking in when Republican businesses invite you in to work under the table jobs
>>
>>1529249
>We created a change in residential stability measure as a mean of z-scores of the average length of residence and percent owners. We accounted for neighborhood racial/ethnic composition with measures of change in Latino/as, Asians, Blacks, and other race (with White as the reference category). For each time point we also computed levels of racial/ethnic heterogeneity as a Herfindahl Index of one minus a sum of squares of these five racial/ethnic groups and computed the difference. As vacant units provide crime opportunities, we computed the change in vacancies. Likewise, high population density often creates crime opportunities, so we computed a change in population density measure. The age crime curve suggests that adolescents and young adults are the most crime prone age groups, so we computed change in population aged 16 to 29. Finally, we include a change in population (logged) measure to account for the fact that larger populations generate more crime opportunities.

>The change variables allow us to treat immigration as a dynamic process. For the analyses, we estimate fixed effects models, which have the advantage of comparing within neighborhoods rather than only across them, accounting for all unchanging variables not included in the models. We estimated models in which the outcome variable was the change in crime (violent, property, robbery, aggravated assault):

>Δy=𝛽0+𝛽1ΔImm+𝛥XB+𝜀

lol What tripe. Bogus shit with bad data. Into the liggeral shitino pile it goes.
>>
>>1529399
Ones who come here legally or ones who wish to work and contribute, yes.
Ones who come here and do not try to integrate themselves with their neighborhoods or into American culture, who dont want to work, who expect handouts - they are not welcome and can fuck off to wherever they came from. No, i wont respect your culture if you fuck kids instead of women because it gets around some weird premarital sex rule.
>>
>>1529409
India also just has way more people
>>
>>1529417
Its a civil offense, though. So someone who overstays their visa is breaking the law. No two ways about it.
>>1529423
>Thinking American business culture is because of Republicans and not Democrats too
O i am laffin. They all want cheap labor through any means possible.
>>
>>1529431
>Ones who come here and do not try to integrate themselves with their neighborhoods or into American culture, who dont want to work, who expect handouts - they are not welcome
Its kinda weird that you understand that you're not welcome in America but still post all this shit
>>
Did you know every single person illegaly inside a country is a criminal?
>>
>>1529277
Committing a crime increases the odds they get sent home or worse. If they're here to work then they don't commit crime.
>>
>>1529432
If more Indian immigrants means more money India must have way more money because they have way more people
>>
>>1529399
Not really.
>>
>>1529711
No, read the article its true >>1529249
>>
>>1529729
>muh article
Still not really.
>>
>>1529249
Yeah, no shit. We knew that already.
>>
>>1529249
>>1529281
ur doing what OP is doing btw
>are a 1 for 1 link.
is disinformation. unauthorized immigrants commit crimes at lower rates than U.S.-born citizens, its not a absolute no link.
>>
>>1529744
You knew nothing of the sort.
>>
>>1529692
>Committing a crime increases the odds they get sent home or worse.
lmao lol
The judge will help them sneak out of the court room
>>
>>1529765
Hey, that's great! BTW, >>1529691
>>
>>1529249
>Turns out Immigration doesn't drive crime rates
Okay.

Run the same study.

But only with illegal immigrants.
>>
>>1529804
Anon it was done with illegals. Read.
>>
i read the shitty article that obfuscates things
>To estimate the undocumented population at the neighborhood level.... applied an imputation method
meaning: they had no fucking clue who illegal aliens were in this study nor explained how they came to determine it other than its "similar" to other methods
>While property crime fell and aggravated assaults declined significantly in neighborhoods with growing undocumented populations, robberies went up.
this part is them saying "you can't blame illegal aliens for robbing people since they also get robbed by other illegal aliens"

This one isnt in the article, but
>two decades
Any data before 2011 Arab Spring is pointless.

another Goodharts Law in practice.
>>
>>1529433
>Its a civil offense, though.
So not a crime.
>So someone who overstays their visa is breaking the law. No two ways about it.
Yeah. But the claim was crime.

>>1529419
>Whether or not something is a crime is hair splitting
The fuck?

>>1529422
Depends. If you get asylum then you committed a crime, but you aren't an illegal immigrant. Likewise if you cross the border illegitimately, but are already a citizen, that's still a crime, but you aren't an immigrant.

I'm not claiming you can't commit crimes while immigrating, but illegal immigration is not in and of itself a crime.
>>
>>1529829
>Any data before 2011 Arab Spring is pointless.
Why the fuck would the Arab Spring be a significant confounding factor? Are you mentally ill? Stop obsessing over Arabs.
>>
>>1529832
>why would Arab Spring matter
tell me how you think 'Syrian Refugees' were a thing in 2015 please.
>>
I don't even have to read that to be incredibly doubtful, no less continually in rejection of the suggestion the accompanying narrative would most likely be used to push on me. If anyones takeaway is that it's therefore ok, it's retarded. This thread also sets off my schizometer because I posses the pattern recognition to see when a symbol is co-opted from a peculiar and alien angle to create a false perception of group affiliation.
>>
>>1529833
There are 122,000 Syrians immigrants in the USA, of which about 60k came as a result of the civil war of which a small fraction are illegals.

Literally every fucking one of them could be a felon and our crime rates would barely change.

Stop obsessing, you fucking nutbag.
>>
>>1529831
It's a crime, fucker. Try getting ticketed for jaywalking and continue to stand in the street.
>>
>>1529249
Technically, it does. We brought over the first non-whites and they commit most of the crimes. They are "immigrants".
>>
>>1529973
>it's just a little bit of crime bro
>>
>>1530006
>it's just a little bit of crime bro

There is a 100% chance you hold some contradictory opinion like "school shootings are the price of freedom" or "jan 6th wasnt actually vioelnt because the police opened up a door which is the universal sign that were allowed to enter oh yeah, dont forget to BACK THE BLUE but not thos CORRUPT DC COPS cause they were actually antifa-fed crisis actors the whole time!"

If you dont understand how per-capita statistics work you do not actually have opnions on violence, you have MISCONCEPTIONS.
>>
>>1530254
>school shootings are the price of freedom

actual quote from Charlie Kirk
>>
>>1529434
I was born in America, why would i not be welcomed here? Is this a bot post?
>>
>>1529707
The rich in India are extremely rich, but most people in India arent rich.
And the people in India arent Indian immigrants so that explains why they dont have money
>>
>>1529249
Is this bait?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.