>All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United StatesLiterally how is that even debatable, in plain text, right there, birthright citizenship is part of the Constitution. Why is it even 5-4 at all? This is a 9-0 decision,
One of the guys who wrote the amendment said something in his diary and we should just go off of that instead
>>538119570>Why is it even 5-4 at all? It was an amendment that clearly stated no aliens and no foreigners in very clear 19th century language (and subject to...) that means Pedro and Maria are literally subjects to another country, Mexico, that their ambassador is also a subject to another country.They just reinterpreted it cuz agenda back then to have manifest destiny and nobody cared cuz white majority all immigrants were kinda white. That obviously changed, but too late, you already interpreted it that way.
>>538120055Children of illegal immigrants are subject to the laws and jurisdiction of the United States. There are some rare cases where that’s not the case with people born on Indian reservations or the kids of diplomats. That’s why the language is there.
>>538120055If we’re going by that logic the Second Amendment is null and void because the people who voted for that didn’t intend it to be for modern weapons You can literally apply this logic to anything
>>538120235>The entire world is subject to American law whether they know it or not.lel
>>538120390> Illegal immigrants are exempt from the laws of the United StatesLol
>>538119570Conservatives claim to be Constitutional Originalists right up until they run across a social issue that confounds their position. It's peak hypocrisy.
>>538120331Well, yeah, there is nothing stopping a rouge court from that reinterpretation of 2A. For the 14th, Nobody cared in mid-20th century boomer minds cuz all the propaganda showed ellis island full of white immigrants and "hey we need cheap white labor," and nobody challenged it. If anything the precedent is of busing illegals and their children born here (still Mexican citizen only) back home.Everyone was ok with that clearly 180 interpretation of the original intent.
>>538119570It was 6-3, not sure where you are getting 5-4 other than cope to make you feel better.
>>538120457>The entire world are subjects of Americacmon Pedro, it's ridiculous
>>538119570>third world diaspora enter nation>pump out kids and use them as a legal and ethical shield to not get deported>diaspora remains and becomes a tumor on the nationThat’s how it’s debatable. Naturalization requires an individual to show that they will actually be a benefit to the nation. Not just remain in a perpetual state of retardation and then spread it on.
>>538119570>I like the change the country went through over the years >why are you attempting to debate me! >accept the change, chud!Fuck you.
>>538121814If you don't like the amendment, write a new amendmentThe president can't just weasel away laws he doesn't like with an executive order
>>538119570Holy shit, this kid trolls hard!!I bet he gets so much pussy
>>538119570>If we imagine there's no borders then it's legalis the argument FOR birthright citizenship
>>538119570'Subject to the jurisdiction of' depends on what the legal meaning of multiple words is. It is not plain text.
>>538121935Shut the fuck up idiot they were adding shit to the constitution during the same time they were rewritten the naturalization act. The country got subverted big time during the 19th century
>>538120457Wasn't that the result of the other case? Seems weird to say that illegals have no federal rights but are subject to federal laws...
>>538124105Are you an american citizen? then your kids are americans. Are you a jungle bunny imported by other illegal jungle bunnies? you're a fraud
>>538121935>The president can't just weasel away laws he doesn't like with an executive orderI mean Lincoln changed the laws and the Constitution itself by executive order and held an election only his jewish friends could vote in.
>>538120235So are children of ambassadors.
>>538119570>Why is it even 5-4miggers are compromised
>>538124311Notice the jew lawyers long jumping to stones like their life depends on it lol, oh wow an ambassador's kid so confusing, DUH ACTUALLY AN AMERICAN EMBASSY ISN'T AMERICAN SOIL SO DUH UHM INDIAN RESERVATIONS... UH.... UHM.... just open the borders
>>538120055No, that's a selective reading of it.
>>538119570>Literally how is that even debatable, in plain text, right there, birthright citizenship is part of the Constitutionany alien, being a free white person, who shall have resided within the limits and under the jurisdiction of the United States for the term of two years, may be admitted to become a citizen thereof, on application to any Common Law Court of Record... and making proof to the satisfaction of such Court, that he is a person of good character...
>>538124460>the state is a corporate enterprise, you have no rights and are just tax cattle I wish they'd come out and say it, but until then
>>538119570bro chuds also believe that the founders created a Christian nation, they are not rational or honest people.
>>538124584We also thought we had the Right to freely assemble, with who and how we saw fit. Turns out we are NOT allowed to freely choose who and how we assemble with (another commie reinterpretation on semantic wordplay to undercut the original meaning) and can't just decide that you don't want to employ niggers or rent to niggers, or choose a roommate that's not a nigger.
>>538120390Literally yes. If you come here you have to respect our laws. To not be subject to laws goes both ways, meaning anyone can kill or rob them and they can rob and kill anyone and it’s outside the legal system entirely, which is absurd. The only exceptions are diplomats who have diplomatic immunity. This is an insane ruling having any dissent at all. Alito and Thomas do clearly do whatever their handlers tell them to do, because they completely pissed on our constitution today.
>>538119570So you're saying women should be able to break into someone's house and have their baby there, and from that point forward the baby is a co-owner of the home?
>>538126262you sound retarded
