[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/pol/ - Politically Incorrect


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


This is the best ideology ever made all resources belongs to the people and managed by the people eland everyone lives communal yeah based
>>
so.. collective farms? they tried that and it didn't work, turns out landlords were just intelligent people good at managing farms and replacing them with some communist party shill didn't really help the farm workers
>>
>>539596369
It belongs to the people not party members
>>
>>539596442
>farming equivalent of the HOA is a great idea
kek
>>
File: 1618366089944.jpg (30 KB, 500x504)
30 KB JPG
>>539596369
>landlords were just intelligent people good at managing
>>
>>539596224
And where do the oil and antibiotics come from? Ma's garden?
>>
>>539596442
>It belongs to the people
Most people don't deserve food
>>
File: 1781539846642643.jpg (84 KB, 780x1000)
84 KB JPG
>>539596224
everyone on the verge of starving death except a wafer thin percentage of the people, and only they eat well because of bribes and corruption, here in USA even our extremely poor people and even the homeless are usually FAT lol, they eat, I have never had to wait in a breadline, instead I go toe grocery in a vehicle I personally own and choose from hundreds of different bread types, and I can buy as much as I want
>>
>>539596224
nigger just wheat?
>>539596533
Oil could probably be avoided by just having lots of manual labour instead, but why do you need antibiotics? If your body isn't a mess you don't need it ever, just some alcohol for disinfecting minor wounds.
Anyways you'd need a way more diverse farming community that just fucking wheat, do they want another potato famine?
>>
>>539596533
From your anus nigga
>>
File: ministry of plenty 3.jpg (62 KB, 640x403)
62 KB JPG
>>539596224
Communism really do be like dat.
>>
File: no_work_no_eat.jpg (22 KB, 474x355)
22 KB JPG
>>539596578
correct
>>
>>539596619
Nigga we could produce many more it is an example lol
>>
>>539596369
why do you think so many politicians have worked at kibbuz in their youth?
>>
File: pizz.jpg (3.25 MB, 4000x3000)
3.25 MB JPG
>>539596675
your example sucks.
But I like the idea, you'd probably miss out on lots of modern development like medical as mentioned; and jews will poison your well to prove you can't live in a commune.
>>
>>539596224
Okay, what if you own a plot of land that is bad for wheat but really good for, say, grapes or raising sheep?
Or if this collective farm was located in a place where you can farm excellent tea but wheat goes rotten?
>>
>>539596971
Wtf we can use it the thing with grain is an example
>>
>>539596224
I don't get what this is supposed to improve, we already feed everyone for free.
>>
File: soyviet union 5 year plan.jpg (482 KB, 1100x1204)
482 KB JPG
>>539597038
Post picture of your farm with timestamp, comrade.
>>
>>539597146
Shut up faggot
>>
>>539597132
Freedom from capitalism you goy ass nigga
>>
File: 81626_v9_ba.jpg (13 KB, 218x280)
13 KB JPG
>>539596224
Remember in school when your teacher had you all do "group projects", and you found yourself in a group where there were a few of you who would do the work, and there were those who wouldn't?
Remember how you suggested they participate, but they just blew you off and decided to spend the class time screwing around and talking? That's what happens to communes. The jackasses and meatheads see that there is unpleasant work that needs to be done, and they let YOU do it while they talk up the cute girls. The cute girls have never gotten so much attention from the cute guys, so they decide to let YOU do the unpleasant work while they talk and pretend they are participating because they are at the table and talking, or whatever.
Real work always comes down to the person who has the mental discipline to do it.
So if we look at the teacher as the "government" in this sense, did they enforce universal participation, or did they look over and see your table was doing something, and left you alone? All the while, the jackasses were talking with the cute girls, and YOU were doing the actual work? Who gets credit for the finished project? The teacher gets to pat themselves on the back for "organizing group work". You did the work. The talkers still get an "A".
>>
>>539597230
For what? Why the fuck would I want to work on a farm?
>>
>>539597334
Mhm ok what do you want to do in my society
>>
>>539596369
>jeet enters thread
>erm SAAAR did you considers the gdp, immigrants, also the wellbeing of landlords?
>>
Leftists look to the future and essentially want to bring the Kingdom of Heaven into reality through merging with AI in a matrioshka brain.

Right-ists look to the past and want to tear civilization down so we can all labor in the fields like medieval peasants.

The former group believes in constructing decent public infrastructure. The latter group wants to bulldoze the Amazon rainforest to make room for parking lots.
>>
>>539597038
No, you can't. And you mustn't. You can't grow food everywhere and you need to have meaningful exchange between people, otherwise it all breaks down.

>>539597322
I'll teach my kids to value their time and charge for the work they've done on shitty teams.
I lost patience in an Uni group project once and I told them "This one is for free, the next one is € 20/hour and I won't fix your shit again". Things started working pretty well after that.
>>
>>539597478
I want to do whatever I get paid most for.
>>
>>539596224
move to North Korea then
>>
>>539596224
who is this "we" though? this "we" is always other people, who ironically also think that the "we" is other people.
at least with private ownership you know who is responsible for any given thing.
>>
>>539597801
Shut up lol

What does it have to do with north korea
>>
File: 1784903472719855.jpg (17 KB, 331x385)
17 KB JPG
>>539597536
>>
>>539597871
because it perfectly resembles you OP pic.
go live dirt poor while the political elite suppresses you there.
also you are underage, you need to be 18 to post here.
>>
>>539596442
>It belongs to the people not party members
In this system, how do "the people" manage the constant decision-making needed to operate complex farming and social coordination?
>>
>>539597953
Pahahahaha shut up niggaa
>>
I'd say let the people who know how to work farms and run them keep doing just that
>>
Best thread ever made unbelievable
>>
>>539596224
>AI generated image
Is this the Real Communismâ„¢ everyone has been talking about?
>>
>>539599318
Hahahaha come on almost every picture is ai generated these days
>>
>>539596442
>>539596526
landlords didn't starve millions to death like party members, the people still owe the state a grain quota under communism

try opening up a history book

>>539596763
are most german politicians from israel?

>>539597480
I denounce gandhi
>>
>>539599502
>are most german politicians from israel?
no but a good chunk of the current day leaders did voluntary work at kibbuz its not just Germany every single western country has a high % of elites that did this.
>>
>>539599502
Holy shit you guys dont undrrstand my goals wtf
>>
What a based ideology wow amazing
>>
>>539596615
Easier to get fat on poor nutrition goyslop loaded with basedbean oil and corn syrup, great job exposing that you know nothing about nutrition and the cost of calories
>>
>>539597536
Why should i be a right winger lol
>>
>>539599625
oh I see, the kibbutz is different from collective farms under stalin and mao because the surrounding economy is a free market which the kibbutz has to compete with or people will just leave

>>539599877
then logically explain these goals instead of posting some meme AI infographic, I already know wheat can be made to make bread, noodles and pasta
>>
>>539596224
is there still compounding interest in this society?
>>
File: 1737580280687386.jpg (93 KB, 915x1024)
93 KB JPG
>>539596369
>turns out landlords were just intelligent
>>
>>539596224
How does one obtain funding for something they wanna do that others may not wanna do? Is this just some hive Borg society where everyone is the exact same? We already have Amish.
>>
>>539601462
NAAAZBOOOL GAAAAANG
>>
Buuuuumpp
>>
>>539596224
Hot hot hot



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.