[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/pol/ - Politically Incorrect

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
Flag
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor acceptance emails will be sent out over the coming weeks. Make sure to check your spam folder!


[Advertise on 4chan]


As long as i hate it, you can't have any anti communism arguments without gorbillion dead (whose authors write about holocaust btw), and rageous ad homiem.
>>
>>539763879
Now, who does that person support in the Ukraine war?
>>
>>539763879
>43 000 suggestions.
how many were listened ?
>>
File: th.jpg (29 KB, 474x454)
29 KB JPG
constitutions dont matter
>>
>letting 55 representatives of their communities do their job is less democratic than forcing everyone to go to moscow
>>
>>539763958
Russia action is capitalistic imperialist but Ukraine backed by imperialist Nato is not better bla bla, and everything would be solved if the world is communist
>>
>>539763879
What happened to the USSR?
>>
>>539763879
the revolutionaries never step down from power, always becoming the new nobility.
Communism in practice is always just a form of Moharchism
>>
>>539763879
>>
>>539764041
All of the Jewish ones yes
>>
>>539763879
if OP could read, he would understand all of the ironclad arguments he has undoubtedly seen before and would no longer be a communist, as he would recognize that Marx himself was an incoherent retard who was also an illiterate jew
>>
>>539763879
yeah, marxism is so perfect it's never been tried -- all those 'famous failures' weren't true marxism.
>>
>>539763879
Remember when smart people used to come here? Now we have 12 year Olds like op.
>>
>>539764160
Human speech is not for you go eat some steamed spider monkey in banana leaves stay out of economics/politics, shitbird
>>
>>539764160
lol
Eastern Ukraine had referendums and the people voted to leave in a similar scenario to what is depicted in your tweets.
You're either a troll or retarded.
Stop using 4chan as a comments section just because Elon won't let you say 'nigger' on his gay site.
>>
>>539763879
>>
>>539763879
There is no point in arguing with communists. The only thing to do is kill them.
>>
>>539764554
You don't argue with them for the same reason you don't argue with a wolf or bear. Its just making noises at you and hearing your words as noise. Its going to attack you and eat your shit because its a hungry and wild unthinking animal.
>>
>there are no actual, logical arguments against communism/marxism
How about it's fundamentally incompatible with human behaviour? Or trading financial elites for social elites? Or the transition to stateless Marxist communism being fundamentally impossible? Or that communism has been tried a myriad of times in a myriad of countries under a myriad of cultures, and they all turned into autocratic dictatorships?
>>
>>539764182
All the jews moved to the US. Then it dried up and blew away.

>>539764554
We can do that after they kill the jews. Till then, not my problem.
>>
>>539764357
bots, niggers, shills, retards, rertards only pretending to be retards, it actually reminds me a little bit of the very very early days of 4chan when it was just /a/ and /b

i need a new hobby.
>>
File: 1783095077763.png (426 KB, 970x645)
426 KB PNG
>>539763879
>42 million people making 43,000 suggestions and the end result is "Shut up and do what I say."
>>
File: download (12).jpg (7 KB, 190x204)
7 KB JPG
>>539763879
who you vote for counts less than who counts the votes
>>
>>539763879
voting under communism is even less real than under representative democracy capitalism
>>
>>539764146
It says "across the country", retard. You're shit at this. I can see why the CIA started with the layoffs.
>>
Marx’s logic in Capital is verifiably indisputably riddled with logical contradictions, fallacies, and blatantly incorrect mathematics.

Furthermore, he never addresses the market feedback and input pricing problems or the vanguard incentive misalignment of a communist state, which have caused mass death and economic faltering in literally every single communist state without a single exception.
>>
>More rights and freedoms
Did this include the right to have a secure border?
Or the right to decide to not let rapefugees or scabs into your country?
What about the right to self-determination and segregation?
The right to say nigger?

Actually, if this constitution was so great they'd just post these rights.
>>
>>539763879
>150 years and the invention of telegram, telephone, and radio
Whodathunkit
>>
>>539763879
Communism is profoundly retarded. Micromanaging every aspect of the economy, and going as far as banning small business is just stupid. There is no good argument against people being able to run small businesses.

Not to say that I support the current capitalistic system either. Communism vs capitalism is a false dichotomy. I support the third position, that being fair distribution of productive land. Nobody should be able to claim exclusive ownership over land and its natural bounty. This should be equally shared. But a man should be fully entitled to the product of his own hands and should be able to run business without restriction, as long as it is done within the confines of a fair share of land.
>>
>>539763879
How do you get people to comply with communism?
>>
>>539763879
Bump
>>
>>539772071
spoken like a true communist, you've got nothing to say, you're just here to be another brown shirt nigger.
>>
my argument against communism:
no thanks
>>
>>539764200
Imagine thinking that meme presents a good argument. Yes (((liberalism))) is as bad as your retarded materialist ideology. Both have done incredible damage to the world.
>>
>there are no arguments against it
it doesn't work
source: history
>>
>>539763879
reducing individuality to mere cyclical cogs with classist or identitarian quantification, as a means of falsifying current modalities as illusory captures driven by need and desire, simply allocates the communist as someone who, at their core, is not a human, but, rather, a captured picture of an ideologue.
communism's reductionism ensures it's a revolutionary modulation but, due to its same constraints, and insistence upon the destruction of certain traditions/ritualization, communism simply becomes a matter of societal manipulation for the raising up of certain ideals for social traditional constructionism, while casting down other non-communist traditions as ideological captures. This is why communism can really only manifest itself with socialist variants, for the dehumanization of communism always ensures an upper elite coming to dominate a lower class, whereas variants of socialism expands cogs into slightly more utilitarian aspects, as opposed to the constrained specificity of communism.
in the end, communism creates the same conditions which it hated but, this time, underneath communism, so the conditions do not seem as illusory.
>>
>>539768398
If you allow people to run businesses, then parasites jews foids and groids will all feel jealous and miserable. We can’t allow that, so we have to destroy the economy for them.
>>
>>539763879
I like it in theory but in practice the working class just trades in one set of elite overlords for another.
>>
>>539774300
Its silly, the only limiting factor is land. Someone else having a successful business within the confines of their fair share of land and resources does not in any way take from you.
>>
>>539763879
let me know when it's actually been tried
>>
>>539763879
>no actual, logical arguments against communism/marxism
how about
>it never ever worked in the past
don't mention China, as they aren't communist, but only a nominally communist plutocracy, as all leading people get rich by leading that shithouse
>>
Their constitution was merely paper because their government did not abide by it. Communism is inefficient because it puts a giant bureaucracy between the people and innovation. Capitalism works because if one person says no to something you can just ask someone else. In communism the question is dead. Capitalism hedges risk while under communism the state assumes all risk making it very likely to implode or have hyper inflation.
>>
>>539774593
China is winning, whatever they are.
>>
File: elite theory.jpg (96 KB, 1280x720)
96 KB JPG
>>539763879
Society is always ruled by a small minority called the ruling class. Not once in history has there been an exception to this. Small jungle tribes have chiefs too.
>>
>>539763879
Marx was a Kulak who did exactly zero labor in his life
>>
>>539763879
One argument:

The purpose of a system is what it does.
>>
>>539774822
This is true. Cultural revolution such as the formation of the USSR is like all revolutions -- an elite minority using the masses to overthrow the old elite minority.
>>
>>539763879
Jews.
>>
>>539774961
This, the idea of marxism was doomed from the very start
>>
>>539763879

Stalin was a Russian nationalist who only asked ethnic Russians to participate in writing a Russian ethno-imperialist constitution which genocided Ukrainians and other non-Russians. Only Jews should lead multicultural societies.
>>
>>539763958
there are many communists internationally that support russia over ukraine
a bunch of communist workers at an airport in italy and refused to handle arms shipments heading to ukraine
you just keep trying to equate communism with being an npc tranny, which is exactly what the elites want
why do you think blackrock had been pushing dei?
>>
Communism can sort of work, when heavily state controlled, but even then, majority of people get fucked. The stateless Marxist final stage communism is a fairytale, that gets crushed as soon as human nature kicks in, and theres no state to put them in check.
>>
>>539763879
>what happened throughout the 20th century: the post
>>
>>539763879
Why cant communism work without taking over the country
why cant communist just make a commune and share resources together from a unified means of production?
>>
>>539763879
My favorite bit about the law code under Stalin is that the plebeians weren't allowed to read it. Solzhenitsyn had a good ol' laugh about it when he finally got to read it a few years after Uncle Joe's brain noped out. So many rights on paper. Not a single one in reality.
>>
>>539774097
/thread
>>
>>539763879
the only arguments they have are "muh money" and "muh i don't wanna help anyone else except myself"
>>
>>539775704
>Not a single one in reality.
Well, according to Jewish yeshiva analysis, at least.
>>
>>539775277
Wasn't he Georgian?
>>
>>539763879
Democracy is not a virtue. it's merely a process, and not a particularly good one, especially at scale.
>>
>>539775543
No shit what makes you think most countries that have ever exist throughout the course of human history weren't communist in nature
>>
>>539775661
Communism works perfectly in families and some smaller communities where everybody cares about each other. Once you add outsiders, it all falls apart, because no one gives a shit about some unknown parasites, that should share your fruits of labor. Thats what Marxists fail to understand, is that theres too many people who abuse the system, to the point of it failing. They argue, that theres no such thing as a nature of man, and that it should change with proper education, but as we see with ussr, that raised like 4 generations under communist values and got progressively worse i would say, that is just impossible.
>>
>>539763958
>>539775502
Kys ziggers shills
>>
>>539763879
>>539764160
>>539764200
>>539764522
Go back toReddit Faggot
>>
>>539776029
And everybody that lived under it. My grandpa remembers when the commissars came around and stole everbody's food to redistribute it to the other mismanaged parts of the Communist empire. And he remembers getting laughed at by local beaurocrats when he was discriminated against for being Christian and bringing up his so called ((((constitutional rights)))).
>The Constitution is in Moscow. We are here.
Russia can be cool for a lot of reasons. The Soviet Union as a political structure is not one of them, бpaт



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.