[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/pol/ - Politically Incorrect


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: russia.png (7 KB, 3840x2560)
7 KB PNG
I've done it, I've figured out how to fix Russia. Here's the plan:

(Part 1)

FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF RUSSIA

1. The country shall be named: "Federal Republic of Russia" (FRR). At the federal level, abolish everything and create these posts/institutions: Parliament of the FRR (consisting of the Assembly of Representatives and the Assembly of Lands), Government of the FRR, Prime Minister of the FRR, Ministers of the Government of the FRR, President of the FRR, Local Courts, District Courts, Land Courts, Supreme Court, District Administrative Courts, Land Administrative Courts, Supreme Administrative Court, Constitutional Court.

2. Rename the federal subjects to "Federal Lands" ("Lands"), and equalize all of them to a single type.
>>
>>539956013
(Part 2)

ASSEMBLY OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE PARLIAMENT OF THE FRR

3. The Assembly of Representatives of the Parliament of the FRR (i.e., the lower house of Parliament) consists of deputies, the number of whom is recalculated after each census (which must take place every 10 years, preferably in years divisible by 10), using the formula ceil(0.1 × sqrt(pop)) or the formula ceil(cbrt(pop)), where sqrt is the square root, cbrt is the cube root, ceil is rounding to the nearest whole number greater than the resulting number (i.e., rounding UP), and pop is the total population of the country according to the latest census. According to the latest census, the first formula gives approximately 1,214 deputies (121,244 people per deputy), and the second gives approximately 528 deputies (278,769 people per deputy).

4. Deputies of the Assembly of Representatives of the Parliament of the FRR are elected in universal, direct, free, equal, and secret elections. I will leave the choice of electoral system to my colleagues, but it must not be garbage. I suggest looking at Mixed-Member Proportional Representation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixed-member_proportional_representation), as used in Germany, or using Single Transferable Vote (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_transferable_vote), with electoral districts of 5, 7, or 9 seats each. Of course, in both cases, all deputy seats must first be distributed among the Lands proportionally to population according to the latest census; I suggest using the "Sainte-Laguë method" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sainte-Lagu%C3%AB_method) for this.

5. Deputies are elected for a term of 4 years. There is no limit on the number of terms.
>>
>>539956013
you created the russian EU?
>>
>>539956090
(Part 3)

6. The Assembly of Representatives of the Parliament of the FRR makes all decisions in the presence of a quorum of a majority of all deputies of the Assembly of Representatives. However, decisions themselves are USUALLY made by a majority vote of only those deputies who are present and voting, EXCEPT in cases specified in the constitution (for example, when electing the Prime Minister, as described below). For example, suppose there are 1,214 deputies in total. Only 700 of them are present at the session. There is a quorum, since 1214 / 2 = 607, and we have more than that. Therefore, the Assembly of Representatives can make decisions. Suppose a question is put to a vote, and 352 vote in favor, 248 against, and 100 abstain (i.e., simply do not vote). The decision is considered adopted and the "For" option wins, since only 352 + 248 = 600 voted, and 352 is a majority of 600. If there is a tie (an equal number of votes For and Against), the "Against" option wins, since "decisions are made by a majority vote of only those deputies who are present and voting," and that has not been achieved, so the option that preserves the status quo is chosen.

GOVERNMENT OF THE FRR

7. The Assembly of Representatives of the Parliament of the FRR nominates exactly one candidate for the post of Prime Minister of the FRR, who is the chairman of the Government of the FRR, by a majority vote of all deputies of the Assembly of Representatives, from among themselves. This is done via secret ballot. If no option receives a majority, the procedure is repeated until one of them receives a majority. Candidates are not eliminated from the ballot between rounds, since any of them could turn out to be the winner in future rounds, even if they have few votes in the current round. Exception: if a candidate personally announces that they no longer wish to participate.
>>
>>539956177
(Part 4)

8. The President of the FRR, within the nearest possible timeframe, appoints the nominated candidate for the post of Prime Minister of the FRR to the post of Prime Minister of the FRR itself. He has no veto whatsoever, cannot delay, and cannot choose someone else. The Prime Minister of the FRR is the head of the Government of the FRR.

9. The Prime Minister of the FRR personally and without anyone's consent (except that of the candidate themselves, of course) nominates candidates from among the deputies of the Assembly of Representatives for the posts of other Ministers. These Ministers also belong to the Government of the FRR. The President of the FRR likewise appoints them, without veto, etc.

10. Which Ministries exist is determined by the laws of the FRR. Each Minister heads their own Ministry.

11. The Prime Minister may request the dismissal of any Minister at any time. In that case, the President of the FRR is obliged to do so, without veto, without delay, etc. However, this does not remove them from the Assembly of Representatives (since they remain deputies).

12. The Assembly of Representatives of the Parliament of the FRR may request the resignation of the Government of the FRR at any time by a majority vote of all deputies of the Assembly of Representatives. In that case, the President of the FRR is obliged to do so. Most likely, in the interest of stable governance, the Prime Minister and Ministers will nonetheless be required to continue serving even after resignation, until a new Prime Minister of the FRR is elected.

13. One person may serve as Prime Minister of the FRR for a maximum of exactly 2,922 days (8 years) over their entire lifetime. Each day counts if that person was Prime Minister for more than half the day (more than 12 hours). This also includes service by that person as a temporary, interim, transitional, and/or acting Prime Minister of the FRR.
>>
>>539956224
(Part 5)

ASSEMBLY OF LANDS OF THE PARLIAMENT OF THE FRR

14. After each census, the number of deputies of the Assembly of Lands of the Parliament of the FRR is determined, as well as their distribution among the Lands, based on degressive proportionality. The following algorithm may be used, though it is probably too complex for an actual country:

14.1. Initial number of deputy seats = 3 × number of Lands.

14.2. Each Land is initially allocated exactly 3 seats (Base seats).

14.3. The number of remaining seats is calculated: Remaining seats = Number of deputy seats − (3 × Number of Lands).

14.4. The remaining seats are distributed among the Lands using the "Sainte-Laguë method" (algorithm), but proportionally to the square roots of the Lands' populations, without taking the Base seats into account in the calculations — that is, in the Sainte-Laguë quotient formula, the variable s must not include the base 3 seats.

14.5. Look at the Land that received the maximum number of seats (if there are several, pick any of them). If it received 12 seats or fewer, increase the Number of deputy seats by 1 and return to step 14.2. If, however, it received 13 seats, and in the previous iteration there was no Land that received 13 seats or more (i.e., at this step we have the first value of the "Number of deputy seats" at which a Land appeared that received 13 seats), then roll the Number of deputy seats back by 1, recalculate from step 14.2 up to this step, ignore this step, and obtain the final result: the Number of deputy seats is the number of deputies in the Assembly of Lands of the Parliament of the FRR, and the resulting distribution is the distribution of seats among the Lands.
>>
>>539956273
(Part 6)

15. All deputies of the Assembly of Lands of the Parliament of the FRR must be members of the Government of their Federal Land. That is, a Land must send a number of deputies equal to the number of seats allocated to that Land in the Assembly of Lands, and each of them must be a member of the Government of that Land. It is permitted to create posts in the Government of a Land whose sole purpose is participation in the sessions of the Assembly of Lands.

16. The Government of a Land and/or the Minister-President of a Land may instruct their deputies on how to vote in sessions of the Assembly of Lands (since the actual purpose of the Assembly of Lands is to represent the Lands, or more precisely, their Governments). Political sanctions (intra-party sanctions or removal from the Government of the Land) are permitted if these instructions are violated. Criminal or civil punishment for this is not permitted.

17. These deputies may be replaced at any time; they have no fixed terms. The Chair of the Assembly of Lands is elected for a term of 1 year.

18. All decisions of the Assembly of Lands are made in the presence of a quorum of a majority of all deputies of the Assembly of Lands, usually by a majority vote of only those deputies who are present and voting, except in cases specified in the constitution.

ADOPTION OF LAWS

19. Laws of the FRR are normally (by default) adopted only by the Assembly of Representatives of the Parliament of the FRR. In that case, after the law is adopted by the Assembly of Representatives, the law is sent to the Assembly of Lands, which may either declare a veto or do nothing. If it does nothing, the law is adopted. If it declares a veto, that veto can be overridden by a majority vote of all deputies of the Assembly of Representatives. If the veto was declared by a vote of 2/3 of the deputies of the Assembly of Lands, overriding the veto requires a vote of 2/3 of the deputies of the Assembly of Representatives.
>>
>>539956013
I have a better plan: Putin.
yes thats the plan.
>>
>>539956326
(Part 7)

20. Laws of the FRR that 1) affect the constitutional powers/rights of the Lands, 2) concern the organization or administration of the Lands, 3) affect the finances of the Lands, 4) regulate the procedure for the Lands' implementation of federal laws, 5) impose financial obligations on the Lands, and/or 6) affect the distribution of taxes between the federation and the Lands, MUST be adopted by both the Assembly of Representatives and the Assembly of Lands of the Parliament of the FRR. In that case, after the law is adopted by the Assembly of Representatives, the law is sent to the Assembly of Lands, which may reject it entirely (with no possibility of override by the Assembly of Representatives), amend the law, form a joint committee between the two Assemblies to find a compromise, adopt the law as is, etc.

21. The Constitutional Court decides which provision (19 or 20) applies to any particular law in case of disagreement. In any case, after a law is adopted according to the rules above, the President of the FRR must sign it within 14 days. Instead, he may refuse to do so and send the law to the Constitutional Court for a review of the law's constitutionality. If the court confirms its constitutionality, he is obliged to sign it within the following 14 days. If the signing/referral-to-court is not carried out within the deadline, the law is automatically considered signed.

PRESIDENT OF THE FRR

22. The President of the FRR is the head of state of the FRR, the guarantor of the constitution.

23. The President of the FRR is, for the most part, a ceremonial post. The person holding the office must be as neutral and non-partisan as possible.
>>
Get rid of that libshit blue and almost perfect
>>
>>539956380
(Part 8)

24. The President of the FRR is elected by the Federal Assembly for a term of 5 years. One person may serve as President of the FRR for a maximum of 2 terms over their entire lifetime. Serving in office for more than half a term (2.5 years) counts as the use of one term. This also includes service by that person as a temporary, interim, transitional, and/or acting President of the FRR. Also, serving two terms of less than half a term (2.5 years) each also counts as the use of one term.

25. It is desirable that there be some restriction on the President of the FRR's participation in political parties.

26. The Federal Assembly is an assembly that convenes solely to elect the President of the FRR, when necessary. It consists of all deputies of the Assembly of Representatives and an equal number of delegates (equal to the number of deputies of the Assembly of Representatives) elected by the Parliaments of the Lands. The seats for these delegates are distributed among the Lands based on degressive proportionality using the "Sainte-Laguë method" (algorithm), proportionally to the square roots of the Lands' populations (with no base seats at all). The President of the FRR is elected using the same procedure as the Prime Minister of the FRR (i.e., by the same procedure), but the President of the FRR is not required to be a member of the Federal Assembly.
>>
File: owl.png (135 KB, 625x508)
135 KB PNG
>nato invades russia
>dismantle the government
>take a prince from scandinavia and make him tzar
>allow the russian people to have fun again
>>
>>539956457
(Part 9)

FEDERALISM

27. All Federal Lands must have a constitution that copies the institutions and posts of the federal constitution, with the following changes:

27.1. The Parliament of a Land must be unicameral. This chamber must be like the Assembly of Representatives.

27.2. There is no President of a Land; instead, the Prime Minister of a Land is called the Minister-President of the Land. The rights, duties, and powers of the Prime Minister and the President are combined in the post of Minister-President.

27.3. In cases where, in the federal constitution, the Prime Minister asks the President to do something, in the constitutions of the Lands the Minister-President does it directly.

27.4. The judicial system of the Federation and the Lands is unified; the Lands do not have their own separate judicial hierarchy.

28. The Federation has the right to pass laws only on topics specified in the constitution; all other laws are passed exclusively by the Lands. There are topics on which the Federation has exclusive rights. There are topics on which concurrent legislation applies: both the Lands and the Federation may pass laws, but if there is a conflict between the laws, the Federation prevails in the conflict. There are framework laws, in which the Federation establishes something in general terms by law, and the laws of the Lands provide more detail.

29. Examples of topics on which only the Federation has the right to pass laws:
29.1. Foreign policy;
29.2. Defense;
29.3. Citizenship;
29.4. Currency and money;
29.5. Air transport;
29.6. Customs;
29.7. Etc.

30. Examples of topics on which concurrent legislation applies:
30.1. Civil law;
30.2. Criminal law;
30.3. Labor law;
30.4. Etc.
>>
>>539956504
(Part 10)

31. Federal laws are implemented and enforced by the governments of the Lands, not by the federal government, by default. It should be noted that if such federal laws require significant funding to implement, and the Federation does not commit to providing it from its own budget, then such a law probably falls under the laws of the FRR that must be adopted jointly by the Assembly of Representatives and the Assembly of Lands of the Parliament of the FRR (under item 20).

32. Exception 1: if the implementation and enforcement of a federal law amounts merely to the creation of a single central entity (an "office"/"building," roughly speaking), without creating entities/units throughout the country, then such a law may be implemented and enforced directly by the federal government.

33. Exception 2: The Constitution grants the Federation the right to enforce laws of the FRR on certain specific topics directly through the federal government, rather than through the governments of the Lands. For example, for the creation of a customs service or a federal police force.

34. A law may establish that it is implemented and enforced "via a federal commission." In that case, the law is still enforced by the government of the Land, but the federal commission has the right to 1) issue general administrative regulations, 2) issue binding directives, 3) demand reports and documents, 4) send commissioners in person. The adoption of such a law probably falls under item 20.

35. Local Courts, District Courts, Land Courts, District Administrative Courts, and Land Administrative Courts operate under, are funded by, administered by, and controlled by the Lands. The Supreme Court, the Supreme Administrative Court, and the Constitutional Court operate under, are funded by, administered by, and controlled by the Federation. Nevertheless, all of them follow federal procedural codes and apply both federal laws of the FRR and the laws of the Lands in their decisions.
>>
>>539956013
>fix Russia

They’re winning their war, why would they need to fix anything?
>>
>>539956554
(Part 11)

COURTS

36. There are three judicial systems: Courts of General Jurisdiction, Administrative Courts, and the Constitutional Court.

37. Courts of General Jurisdiction: Local Courts, District Courts, Land Courts, and the Supreme Court.

38. Administrative Courts: District Administrative Courts, Land Administrative Courts, and the Supreme Administrative Court.

39. Constitutional Court: the Constitutional Court.

40. Local Courts are courts of first instance for minor cases; District Courts are courts of first instance for all other cases.

41. For cases initiated in Local Courts, appeal from Local Courts goes to the District Court. Further cassation goes directly to the Supreme Court.

42. For cases initiated in District Courts, appeal from District Courts goes to the Land Court. Further cassation goes to the Supreme Court.

43. District Administrative Courts are the court of first instance for administrative cases. Appeal goes to the Land Administrative Court. Further cassation goes to the Supreme Administrative Court.

44. The Constitutional Court is the only court that can strike down a federal law of the FRR. It can also strike down a law of a Federal Land. Federal Lands may have Land Constitutional Courts to strike down Land laws.

45. All judges are appointed for life, but must retire mandatorily upon reaching the age of 70.

46. Judges of the Constitutional Court are appointed for a term of 15 years. After the term, they must leave the Constitutional Court. Repeat terms are prohibited.

47. Judges of the Supreme Court and the Supreme Administrative Court are nominated by the federal Judicial Appointments Committee. The Committee presents one or more candidates for a vacancy. The President of the FRR selects the judge for each vacancy exclusively from among those nominated, and formally appoints the judges.
>>
>>539956601
(Part 12 - FINAL)

48. Judges of the Constitutional Court are nominated by the federal Judicial Appointments Committee and by the Constitutional Court itself. The Parliament of the FRR appoints judges from among those nominated — half of the court's seats are reserved for the Assembly of Representatives and the other half for the Assembly of Lands — and only the chamber to which a given vacant seat is assigned appoints the judge for that seat. A vote of 2/3 of all deputies of the chamber is required.

49. Judges of all other courts are nominated and appointed by a similar mechanism, but only within the Lands — that is, they are nominated by the Land Judicial Appointments Committees and appointed by the Minister-Presidents. Exception: judges of the Land Constitutional Courts are nominated by the Land Judicial Appointments Committees and by the Land Constitutional Courts themselves, and are appointed by the Parliaments of the Lands, requiring a vote of 2/3 of all deputies of the Land Parliament.

50. The federal Judicial Appointments Committee consists of 3 judges (Supreme Court + Supreme Administrative Court + Constitutional Court), 1 attorney, 1 prosecutor, and 1 professor of law from a university of the FRR. The judges are nominated by the three courts themselves. The attorney is nominated by the federal bar association, the professor is nominated by a university chosen by the Minister of Education, and the prosecutor is nominated by the Prosecutor General of the FRR. The nominated members are appointed to the Judicial Appointments Committee by the Government of the FRR (by majority vote of the members of the Government) for a term of 5 years.

CONSTITUTION

51. Amendments to the constitution require a 2/3 vote of all deputies of the Assembly of Representatives and a 2/3 vote of all deputies of the Assembly of Lands.
>>
>>539956647
Thoughts?
>>
>>539956132
No, it's a design for a new constitution. It is almost entirely a copy of Basic Law for Germany, mixed with my ideas.
>>
File: police_in_russia.png (501 KB, 640x586)
501 KB PNG
>>539956013
>1. The country shall be named: "Federal Republic of Russia" (FRR).

There have been vaguely related case in Russia already.
Years ago, there was HUGE issue with corruption in Militsia in Russia. So government decided to do some theatrical firings, and renamed institution to Police.

So in that sense, renaming things are indeed in russian spirit.
>>
>>539956013
Bring back Stalin's constitution and the Soviet education system. That's it, e.z.p.z
>>
File: IMG_8113.jpg (49 KB, 603x766)
49 KB JPG
>muvva rasher
It’s basically a spacious meth lab terrorised by an out of control meth-test monkey at present. Try to Rasputin the Putin, leave a banan with a sticky label on it that says
>Banan Of Immortality!
stuck on it inside a cage. When Putin takes off his built up shoes and goes in after it (immortality is Putin’s other hobby when he’s not busy taking over the whole world very, very slowly at 1,300 lives cost a day - its more expensive in terms of sacrificed lives to keep Putin than it would be to keep the Emperor of Mankind on the golden throne of Terra in 40K - and that is a FACT) that is when you slam the cage door and lock it. Then you switch on the cyanide monkey calming gas.
I’m going in a shop to buy vit D now before it shuts so I cannot finish fixing russia just now. But we covered the main part.
>>
File: putin.jpg (59 KB, 567x563)
59 KB JPG
>>539956013
just call them gulaghomo LMAO
>>
>>539957117
Well what about other changes?
>>539957190
>Bring back Stalin's constitution
What's so good about it?
>>
Why in hell are you not reading what I wrote, I spent like 2 hours writing it completely manually, although I wrote in Russian originally, so this is a machine translation
>>
>>539958462
nobody reads walls of text.
you waste 2 hours of your life on nothing.
>>
>>539958548
>nobody reads walls of text
What kind of zoomer shit is this? Open TikTok if you need short video content
>>
File: 1772277610026927.jpg (213 KB, 720x1071)
213 KB JPG
most russians wont ever go along with that
they want ussr and putin
>>
>>539958636
too much work and if you cant explain your shit in a sentence or 2 max. then nobody is gonna read this here.
>>
>>539958636
because its you I fed your wall of text slop and asked the AI why your idea sucks. it says:

"This plan is way too complicated with all its hyper-specific math formulas and overlapping court layers that would probably cause total chaos instead of actually fixing anything!"
>>
>>539958327
From my Baltic perspective, issue is with corruption. How to keep it in check.

Here we have somehow milder situation, because in nineties, a lot of racketeers and thugs were simply shot by some guys from paramilitary forces (kinda like territorial guards). It went as far, that later, when there was needed to do some serious contract killing, some guys from Russia got imported.
We still have significant issues with corruption, but it is WAY better than it was.

And for Russia, if it reorganizes structure, would those not be infested with glowies (like FSB) again, it is a good question.
I guess, several of russian guys have thought about it, and eventually get more depressed, as they have "bad feeling" in which direction most likely things eventually will drift.
>>
>>539956013
>FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF RUSSIA
trash name.
The only possible name is Russian Union where union means Russia+Little Russia (aka 'urine' or whatever its name is)+White Russia (aka Belarus).
>>
>>539956013
>>539958747
Here's your AI summary: https://publishmarkdown.com/fe201e47-6703-4704-9a29-4d1d3e968c06
>>539958930
>too complicated with overlapping court layers
That's bullshit, the proposal merely establishes ordinary courts, administrative courts and a constitutional court
>hyper-specific math formulas
Less so, but I think it's still bullshit. There are only three formulas: two formulas that propose how to calculate the amount of MPs from the population, and one formula to apportion the parliament seats between the Federal Lands (States). The algorithm to determine the amount of seats in the Assembly of Lands is complicated indeed, but I've said outright that it doesn't have to be used
>>
>>539956743
is that the russian superiority that you copy germany again?
there is a huge flaw in your plan, you dont have germans, you have corrupt russians
>>
First : no limit on the number of terms for deputies - maximum 2-3 terms anon, that's the democratic way preventing corruption
Second kind of mistake : There is a quorum, since 1214 / 2 = 607, and we have more than that. Therefore, the Assembly of Representatives can make decisions.
For important decisions there should be everyone present and a special corp of the parliament should decide what's an important matter and what not
Third : part 5 is what EU tried and didn't work out and by part 6, you are giving this people to much work and to much authority that can contradict their duties and work so it doesn't make to much sense to have the same person holding two offices
Other then this your points are pretty good but two things : it's to democratic and you need one or two apparatus to combat corruption from within and keep and eye on both houses. And also I want a provision in the new constitution that any Russian that simps for that mutt venti should be immediately accused of profound lunacy and burned at the stake
>>
>>539959222
AI said:
Even if there are only three main formulas, a lot of math always means a lot of opportunities for errors or debates, which leads back to my point about chaos! And even if his specific seat algorithm isn't mandatory, the mere fact that he felt the need to write down an entire mountain of complex rules just to explain how things might work proves my point—it’s total overkill! He might be able to defend his logic, but he can't deny that any system this detailed turns simple government decisions into a massive headache for everyone involved!
>>
>>539959222
the AI also said russians are too dumb for such a system.
"Most populations want something they can understand without needing a calculator and a PhD in mathematics just to vote for someone! If you give them a super-complex machine like this, most people will get overwhelmed and frustrated, leading to big messy mistakes or just ignoring the rules entirely"
>>
Russia cannot exist without being centralized
>>
>>539959314
What kind of claim is this, since when are you not allowed to copy the aspects of the constitutional design of a different country, when nearly all countries have a very similar governance system anyway
and I didn't claim Russia is superior to anything
>you dont have germans, you have corrupt russians
what does it change
>>
>>539959549
>what does it change
they arent capable of running such a complex government.
this is why Putin rules you, without him you would shrivel up an die.
>>
>>539959414
>maximum 2-3 terms anon
That can be done, although it seems term limits for the MPs seems not to be a thing almost anywhere, so I didn't want to innovate too much, especially since most politicians are career politicians, it seems
>For important decisions there should be everyone present
I think this will happen regardless because of party whips, but I mean the reason I initially chose that only a majority vote of members present and voting is needed to pass a law is that it's the rule in many European countries, like Germany, Finland, the UK, Austria, and is also the default rule in Robert's Rules of Order, which is my only source for any kind of parliamentary procedure, even though it wasn't designed for legislatures
>part 5 is what EU tried
Why not, what happened? The idea is that the more the Federal Land (State) has people, the more seats it has in the Assembly of Lands, but no more than 12, and no less than 3, so at maximum the difference is 4x, even though the population difference could be much larger than that, so it's kind of like US senate, but with degressive proportionality that hopefully still preserves the rights of small Lands (States)
>by part 6, you are giving this people to much work and to much authority that can contradict their duties
No-no, I mean that it is fully intended that each Assembly of Lands member will be a dedicated member of the Land's Government, their only job is to participate in the meetings of the Assembly of Lands
>that simps for that mutt venti
Who?
>>
Should the Congress of People's Deputies and the Supreme Soviet really be restored?
>>
>>539956013
Should just reinstate the monarchy. I am the last heir of the tsar btw.
>>
>>539959988
Understood, regarding part 5 there needs to be a voting system where more provinces need to join in order for something to pass. Like from what I understand your regions will all have veto power, correct ? EU tried that and due to Hungary we all became colonies of Goymany now without any veto rights . Like you really need to experiment a lot with part 5

Also venti poster, a faggot that post that mutt britanny venti
>>
>>539961033
>where more provinces need to join in order for something to pass
You mean more deputies need to show in the Assembly of Lands or something else?
>Like from what I understand your regions will all have veto power, correct ?
Well, basically, on "ordinary" federal laws, by default, only the Assembly of Representatives (the lower house of the parliament, like House of Representatives) need to pass the law to have that law considered to be passed. The Assembly of Lands can object (veto), but that veto can be immediately overriden if the Assembly of Representatives passes the law with a majority vote of all deputies of the Assembly of Representatives (that is, if more than the half of MPs in the Assembly of Representatives vote for the law). Exception: if, the Assembly of Lands, while objecting (vetoing) does so with a two-thirds (2/3rds) majority, then to override that veto, the Assembly of Representatives needs a 2/3rds vote also.

Now, I said:
>Well, basically, on "ordinary" federal laws, by default, only the Assembly of Representatives (the lower house of the parliament, like House of Representatives) need to pass the law to have that law considered to be passed
But IF the federal law that is being passed:
1) affects the constitutional powers/rights of the Lands;
2) concerns the organization or administration of the Lands;
3) affects the finances of the Lands;
4) regulates the procedure for the Lands' implementation of federal laws;
5) imposes financial obligations on the Lands;
6) affects the distribution of taxes between the federation and the Lands
THEN, the law needs to be passed by both the Assembly of Representatives and the Assembly of Lands, meaning that the Assembly of Lands has a total veto that cannot be overriden, they can do it by just rejecting it (or perhaps by just doing nothing, refusing to pass it).



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.