Anyone who studies the history of culture from the Gravettians (30k BCE) until now will reach the same conclusion.The absolute apex of human culture is not sedentary. It is partially nomadic which forces gender egalitarianism in labour division by default. It is pastoralist with a high protein mostly meat diet. It has a single male dictator who is elected into a pool by democratic process and who then fights the other members in the pool for kingship. It has a philosopher caste of castrated men that act as a spiritual council. The king decides the how, the council decide the why. They cannot overrule each other except in times of war when the king takes control.This is completely compatible with modern technology and medicine. Partially nomadic does not mean you don't have permanent buildings or modern infrastructure anyone who defaults to the golden horde type culture is suffering from a failure of sight. Sedentarism is the tool of the devil.
Astroturfer, you really are unable to not identify yourself as an astroturfer the moment you type
>Anyone who studies the history of culture from the Gravettians (30k BCE) until now will reach the same conclusion.Wrong.
>>539993593not if you're vague enough but not too much
>>539993658Too afraid to state your opinion? Go on. I will bring up every example where it has failed and why you are wrong.
Figure it out yourself what words, themes and figures of speech identify yourself as astroturfing scum. Pro tip, its literally everything.You are the most incompetent advertiser that ever spammed the net
Delusions of grandeur.
>>539993569Go, do it. Go and wander through australia in your tribal confederation, live the dream. Whos stopping you, lil faggot?
>>539993822>discussion about culture>'go on do it' Retard.
I am going to admit 4chan, Leddit and Xitter as examples of sedentary cultural failures. A meat eating pastoralist culture with a warrior King would never create such cesspools.
I am going to admit the declining birth rates of sedentary cultures as further evidence of their inferiority. They naturally breed themselves out of existence. I will also admit the biggers killer as evidence. Heart disease. Proven to be caused because the people do not move around enough, and sit around eating shit all day. Sedentary culture at its finest.
>>539993909>>539993987Why are you typing such nonsense, sedentary jang wen li? Who hurt you?
I will further admit the social dynamics of sedentary cultures as evidence of their inferiority. The people having no outlet for their natural behaviours, turn them inward on themselves, and despise their fellow citizens.>>539994044Do you have a single argument that isn't essentially a cultural meme?>who hurt you>Go. Do it.You are repeating the commonly expressed online phrases of sedentary culture. And you are unaware that you are doing it.
>>539993822>>539994044This anon is a great example of the flaws of sedentary culture.He repeats cultural phrases as his own genuine thoughts. He expresses the platitudes, in a predictable manner, and is unaware that this is abnormal to anyone outside his sedentary subculture.
>>539993909>A meat eating pastoralist culture with a warrior King would never create such cesspools.It did tho
>>539994127Look... So basically I’m just gonna not take it (the job!!)I know….. UGH I know…. I’m sorry!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!It’s just that I’m not gonna take it is allHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAHAAHAAHA xDDDDDDDDD
>>539994291Now you provide your evidence. I could never trust the word of someone in a sedentary culture.
>>539993569>BCE
>>539993569go back mohamed
Thus far we have had no counter arguments and no evidence proven.I will provide the first example. This is not the best example, it is simply the first.The Gravettian culture of Europe in 30k BCE was nomadic. They would travel hundreds of km for specific burial items. They win first for:>numeral notation; lunar notation>agriculture; cereal milling technology that predates the sedentary Nafutians>aquaculture; invention of nets>domestication of dogs; twice>cartography; multiple maps found>ceramics; pottery>textiles; techniques used today>modern art; still controversial to this day for its perspective/shading >multi-ton multi-material architecture >music; first instrument And these were cave men hunter gatherers. They also spent 4 years (if working 40 hours per day 5 days per week) carving 13000 ivory beads to bury their dead kids with. Some speculate they used these as currency, others a type of co-operative industry that existed pre-industry. The earliest sedentary culture you have is nafutians in Africa. You cant compete.
Doesn't seem as much of a culture thing but more centered around large city centers over time. The city themselves is the empire.
>>539994989The citizenry must be forced to move. For whatever reason. Nobody should live and die where they were born.
>>539993746What a cunt!You see yourself as a king, and act like one of these proposed castrated
>>539995045Implying I would want to be king. Another one making a literal statement about what one wants in a thread I have implicitly shown to be archaeological anthropology.
Is there not a single person here that can defend the way of life they deem to be superior? Has your sedentary lifestyle inhibited your ability to express your opinions? It would certainly seem that way.
I am going to admit another example of the inferior nature of sedentary culture. The LBK. The first sedentary agriculturalists into Germany 5500 BCE, explicitly practiced cannibalism for centuries and are the perpetrators of every uncontested neolithic massacre site in Europe. They ritualistically butchered and consumed the remains of humans with hundreds of specimens identified at a single site.
A recap.The evidence for partial nomadic superiority >>539994755The evidence for partial nomadic inferiority >none presented The evidence for sedentary superiority >none presentedThe evidence for sedentary inferiority >>539993909>>539993987>>539994127>>539995342>the photo I attached to this post
>>539995107>im a cunt pretending to have a historical conversation>b-because i s-so! Im the uh 'non king' heheh>i will continue to be a dumb bitch cunt and assert its a real discussion of merit and not another one of my tantrumsFack off cunt
>>539996013You cannot defend your own lifestyle and the failure to do so proves it.
>>539996258>says in a stupid cunty way i never talked about defending 'sedentary life'Have your tantrum somewhere else already ya daft cunt!You are incapable of conversation!My position is whatever leads to hearing dumb cunts like you more is terrible practice in policy
>>539996567The only one have a tantrum is you. You are unable to write without exhibiting emotion and are clearly too emotional to express yourself clearly.
The thread is almost 2 hours old and not a single objector has been able to articulate their position. I admit this as an example of sedentary culture inferiority. Clearly they disagree, but they are unable to construct any sort of an argument and resort to animalistic behaviours, 'seeing red' so to speak. On observation, thus far, all objectors have entered the thread, become emotional, and that emotion causes them to reply but they are unable to do so coherently because of said emotion. Sociologically this is common in sedentary culture, it is compared to somebody bumping into and your reaction is to 'see red' and attack or even shoot them.
>>539993569Pastoralists ate mostly dairy with some amount of grain. Meat was consumed rarely, mostly for special occasions. You wouldn't slaughter your animals all the time, they would generally be far more useful alive producing milk, wool, etc. You'd get some meat from hunting. But mostly milk, millet, and barley.
>>539993569
>>539993569I appreciate many of your ideas, but I take issue with your suggestion of a philosopher caste comprising castrated men as a spiritual council. Instead, I propose a council made up of experienced men – certain boomers who have amassed esoteric knowledge, encountered divinity, and now seek to plant seeds for future generations to enjoy in the form of wisdom and guidance.Ideally these individuals should have lived lives rich in experiences, including love, family creation, suffering, and personal loss. So their purpose is now limited to serving the next generation and shaping the King's mind with their wisdom.In my view, a King serves as the guardian of a dream, embodying its ideals and values. The people who follow him find a sense of purpose in his leadership, and he protects them with violence when necessary. This dynamic is crucial for the endurance of successful kingdoms. The idea of a castrated council does not align with this vision; rather, it would comprise yes-men.It can endure and work with castrated men, who devote their life to the cause, but it can also be rather limiting if such men have egos and are dissatisfied with life and seek personal gain.Which can be remedied with older men who no longer seek anything other than the preservation of a dream.What we have in the western world is rotten, not least because of the demographics issues and the loss of purpose and disintegration of identity that has directed the rise of consumerism and ultimately the rise nihilism.
>>539996748>n-no y-you!It never ends with you childrenYou conflate, presume, and flail around fighting your strawmen smugly. You are an intellectual clown and a petulant childThese are reasons to not like the eunuch class speaking Sedentary or otherwise, of course
>>539993569>high protein mostly meat dietHigh fat, mostly meat and dairy.
>>539997989I can understand your perspective and I want to explain where I disagree. I elect for castrated men for the following reasons>male general intelligence is higher than women on average>castration removes testosterone and therefore reduces competition >castrated men stop thinking about sex with women These three things are of paramount importance to a council that decides the 'why'. They must have their natural male inclinations cut out of them, physically, so they may devote as much of their resources to philosophy as possible.I want to bring up some reasons for why the boomer council is a bad idea. And it corresponds to my points for why we should castrate them; their status as the spiritual council and their working genitals will lead them to abuse their position. They will still have a sexual drive and will have to work to overcome it. We have seen this over and over again all throughout history. We see it right now, with all the pedophiles.The idea is that you get the best aspects of everything. The democratically elected pool of male leaders, who compete in a formal ritualistic competition of- maleness, it does not need to be to the death, paired with a spiritual class of testosterone lacking men. The masculine and the feminine together.
