[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/pol/ - Politically Incorrect


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: .gif (443 KB, 506x516)
443 KB GIF
How do Holocaust deniers cope with Himmler's Posen speech? I'd expect them to just call it fake, because it's unassailable evidence, but most just insinuate it's mistranslated and Himmler was speaking metaphorically or about deportations which makes no sense.

>inb4 ausrotten/Ausrottung
They'll argue it meant "uprooting (Jews from power)" or that they changed the definition of the entire word in the German language, but this is stupid. It does mean extermination and not uproot which is entwurzeln and so do its equivalents in other Germanic languages like the Dutch equivalent uitroeien and Swedish utrotning and it was listed as extermination in centuries old German dictionaries like the Deutsches Wörterbuch. This is a moot point anyway since he explicitly clarifies by "auszurotten" he means "umzubringen", which means only one thing and that is killing.

>Ich hielt mich nämlich nicht für berechtigt, die Männer auszurotten- sprich also, umzubringen oder umbringen zu lassen - und die Rächer in Gestalt der Kinder für unsere Söhne und Enkel groß werden zu lassen
>I did not consider myself entitled to exterminate (auszurotten) the men - that is, to kill (umzubringen) them or have them killed (umbringen zu lassen) - and allow the avengers in the form of children grow up for our sons and grandsons
But that doesn't explain the rest of the speech. Himmler says a lot more on the topic which can be interpreted in one way, an ongoing extermination of Jews.

>the need for secrecy just like the Night of the Long Knives
>it will be a page of glory in German history never to be written
>the audience will know what it's like to see hundreds of corpses lying side by side
>they had the obligation and the moral right to "kill this people that wanted to kill us"
>the public wouldn't accept it because they all think they know one good Jew so it must be hidden
>it's good that the Jews are gone now because it would hinder the war effort if they were still around
>>
File: kwab.png (754 KB, 1154x829)
754 KB PNG
>>540021666
who cares
>>
My wife ryuko
>>
>>540022000
*grabs u by the balls*
Back the fuck off.!?!?!? She's mine!
>>
File: 1750452913638271.jpg (99 KB, 545x596)
99 KB JPG
>pilpul
Oh sorry, were you saying something?
>>
Let's look at actions not words. Why have maternity wards? Why have swimming pools? Why have have a dental office? Why do multiple inmates get transfered from death camp to death camp? Why are only Russian discovered camps death camps? Why are there not enough crematoriums to dispose millions of bodies? Why do tattoos go up to 5 digits? Why were jews sent by Germany to Palestine? Why has every story jews claimed of torture and fantastical methods of death proven wrong? Why would wood doors be used on a gas chamber? Why would there be no mass grave sights found with underground scanning radar? Why did the total Jewish population grow?
>>
File: 56353.jpg (66 KB, 698x719)
66 KB JPG
People deny it mostly out of contrarianism, not because it serves any real purpose. Conspiracy theorists always need some grand scheme to be against, because this gives their otherwise meaningless lives some purpose. Thinking they hold some deep sacred knowledge that 99% of people are oblivious too uplifts them from just another nobody to an enlightened being that is miles ahead of all the "sheep" just because they know that 9/11 was an inside job or that vaccines are a secret government plot to cull the population. That is all that is to it, same with Holocaust denial - it makes them special in their own minds. Ironic thing about Holocaust is that even if they somehow do convince everyone that Nazis killed 500,000 people instead of 6,000,000 or whatever, this would still not make Nazi regime any less terrible, they have tons of crimes to answer for, and this revisionism is not going to make anybody view them favourably. But they hold on to it anyway because it gives their lives a meaning.
>>
File: 1785598644967815.jpg (124 KB, 680x484)
124 KB JPG
>>540021666

Yhe Holocaust is an extraordinary claim, it requires extraordinary evidence.
>>
File: 1750372374116553.jpg (85 KB, 1024x590)
85 KB JPG
Why should I, as an american whose roots go back to colonial times, be culpable for what Germans did to jews on the other side of the world in the 20th century?

If anything, we should be shown gratitude for sacrificing the best of a generation to liberate you.
>>
>>540021666
when politicians say they want to eradicate homelessness, what do you think it means? kill all homeless people?
how about eliminating criminal gangs? or illegal aliens?
>>
File: 1751244481683593.jpg (216 KB, 635x630)
216 KB JPG
>>
File: 1722347808082897.jpg (116 KB, 800x600)
116 KB JPG
>>
>>540022125
*detaches balls like a lizard detaching its tail and grows another pair*
>>
>>540021791
fpbp
>>
File: Landreth letter.png (590 KB, 729x938)
590 KB PNG
http://www.fdrlibrary.marist.edu/archives/collections/franklin/index.php?p=collections/findingaid&id=534&q=&rootcontentid=188585#id188585
>go to this website
>click [Series 3: General Correspondence of Roswell D. McClelland: January 1944-July 1945]
>download pdf for Jews in Europe (1), July-August 1944
>find this letter (pic 4, Landreth letter)

The US government official Landreth M. Harrison wrote this letter that confirmed that ‘Ausrottung’ and ‘Entjudung’ do not imply killing, and that to suggest they do would be a mistranslation.

The Posen speeches explicitly mention ”Judenevakuierung” (Jew evacuation) followed by ”ausrottung”. Unless you are autistic and so socially inept you cannot discern context you clearly don’t understand written German.
>>
If jews killed then why more jews and no jew bodies?
>>
>>540021666
Rotte is just an old german word for Gruppe (group). It's still used today in some fringe contexts. Eine Rotte Wildschweine is a group of wild boars, that live, eat and destroy backyards together. In military aviation Flugzeugrotte means a group of planes and pilots, that fly together. It's still used today, like Alarmrotte, s. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alarmrotte or here: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotte_(Luftfahrt)
Zusammenrotten means formation of a group with the conotation of doing shady or illegal things. Ausrotten means disbanding the group of shady or criminal people by external force.
>>
>>540021666
Zipperheads wish they had blue eyes.
>>
>>540022600
Nobody "denies" the holocaust. It just didn't happen. Conspiracy theorists (mostly Israelis) accuse white people of doing a holocaust, and the accusation is completely unfounded. Totally ridiculous.
The Nazis were rad af, very good and kind people. An example to follow. You being retarded at us will never change that fact.
>>
>>540023123
>when politicians say
Yes. When a politician says something, they're most likely up to murder. That would be par for the course. Especially when they say they're going to "eliminate whiteness." That 100% means population reduction on every front and eventual death-camps. That's the Israeli way.
>>
>>540027216
No bodies because they were all ground up to make soap. Duh. Don't you with you could wash yourself with a thick lather made from disgusting wretched people?
>>
>>540021666
I don't know about his speech because the Holocaust happened to the correct people instead of people I am related to, and it's not my problem
>>
>>540021666
I always liked the semantic jew arguments
>>
>>540021666
let the past be the past
what other proof do you need than what is going on in modern times ?
look at the u.s. government, the state of the european union, etc.
they say the protocols of the learned elders of zion had been a fabrication
that the kalergi plan was a conspiracy theory
apparently someone took these fabrications and conspiracy theories as instruction manual
otherwise you would not have the fifth column pac money influencing 89% of the u.s. senate including the president and washington d.c. staffers, or the european immigration policies.
we all live in the now and not 100 years in the past with 80 years of two way bias inbetween
are you going to deny the existence of mass manipulation programs by the cia ? war propaganda ? mkultra ? all the leaks , scandals and the ever repeating patterns ?
wake the fuck up
>>
>>540029555
All facts.
Also the holocaust is an evil accusation against good Germans. Identifying Israelis as fundamentally evil and responsible for everything you said is important. Its up to us to teach curious young minds the truth of the world.
>>
>>540021666
Holocaust deniers are fucking idiots, in their fanfiction Hitler killed 50 million whites amd was letting Jews have cocktails and pool parties while German civs got bombed and starved
>>
>>540030002
It was France and Englands decision to get involved, and they righteously paid for it with the destruction of their empires.
>>
>>540029836
those krauts are pure evil
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Corpse_Factory
>>
>>540021666
Nice Holocaust you have there. May I see it? As in First hand evidence that is no longer considered fake, somehow all of it seems to either disappear but what is really happening acedmically is a bunch of people are cross referencing the "facts" in a circular manner that eventually site the source asking for the source as the source.
It is not real. Get help for your inability to see through propaganda your critical thinking skills are broken or worse don't exist and you don't belong here.
>>
>>540021666
What Himmler did or did not say is irrelevant.

The Holocaust did not happen, and to believe otherwise is incredible offensive to the German people, as you are basically asserting that they were too incompetent to successfully kill people they had already rounded up in camps. If the Holocaust was real there would not be a gorrilan survivors.
>>
>>540030002
Britain declared war on Germany. Once war was declared the outcome was basically locked in. Also, Jews were put into camps for the same reason the US put the Japanese into camps, because that is what you do with potential enemies during war time.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.