>red team Iran>bro, we're just going to lure a CBG into littoral waters>then we'll ambush them in an act of perfidy signaled by a call to prayerNo wonder the actual war turned out like it did if this Hollywood brained war plan was what their best mind in unconventional warfare could come up with role-playing Iran. How do you miss "just pound their bases and hqs to rubble with ballistic missiles lmao" or, "don't set the tone with a war crime"? Why is the American military mind so solipsistic?
>>546297230What blew up?
why can't i make a hunting thread?
>>546297231light speed motorcycles, 2-ton fishing boats armed with 1-ton missiles, and teleporting attack boats
>>546297233I'm annoyed that people think this guy was Nostradamus was when the actual Iranian war plans don't resemble his discount Tom Clancy bullshit at all.
What has /pol/niggers so riled up? Is just the usual midterms bullshit?
>>546297230>>546297233>>546297234My dudes. The point of wargames is to push systems to the limit. So if you can survive a scenario where the enemy can do comms without emitting via instant motorcycle message (so you can never find their HQ's and can't dergarde their command and control) then you're going to fucking DOMINATE a war where the enemy is, in reality, kinda retarded. Which is what happened irl. Iran has been preparing for this conflict for 40 years and they got raped, and then re-raped, repeatedly for very little cost.
>>546297230>>>/pol/>>>/jeet/muzzie/schizo-containment-board/>>546297231US midterm elections.
>>546297235>Noooo you can't talk about one of /k/'s favorite topics
>>546297231>>546297235>>546297237Samefag
>>546297239Take your meds and do your skin-bleaching routine.
>>546297239Lol
>>546297236motor cycle messagers wouldnt be an issue if everyonee agreed on their capabilitiesbut what happened was that he was told he could use them, then because he wasnt told what they couldnt do, made them transmit information instantly and without any way to be interceptedof course in reality, motorcycles have travel time and can be killed off their motorcycleeven the proposed method of using light signals could be detected with the technology of the time and has inherent lagan honest simulation would have been to model that, but that would mean his epic out-of-the-box tactic would be actually defeatable
Someone post the video of that US sub torpedoing an iranian ship and all the dudes flying up in the air.
>>546297242I actually don't mind it. Depends on the purposes of the exercises. If it's a doctrinal stress test let's get as absurd as possible to see how long it takes something to break, and when something breaks, then how. The reason we're so good is that we wargame shit into oblivion and those wargames will often get redone if they are determined to be too easy.
>>546297236There is a difference between pushing the limits to learn what you can do while on the backfoot and the endless midwit circlejerk over teleporting motorcycles and the US navy spawning into saturation fire already underway.
>>546297230I hate being in the timeline where I think the war with Iran is comically retarded because of the "forever war all over again" (not because Iran getting the everloving fuck bombed out of it is actually losing or some stupid shit, but because our government seems to have no real plan beyond "bomb them here and there and hope they surrender) thing and not because I think Iran is heckin wholesome Chungus Friends with us, or that a botched intel causing a civilian bombing of a school is Hitlerino 2.0I hate that there is nobody in American politics that I can even remotely agree with at large in the big 26 in any geopolitical senseNuke Israel, nuke Iran, nuke Russia>>546297244peak pseud
>>546297236>they got raped, and then re-raped, repeatedly for very little cost.very cool but this is meaningless when they need next to nothing to keep the strait of hormuz closed and cause massive economic damage to the rest of the world and the US military is unable to stop them.after all this raping and re-raping, the strait remains closed off and iran hasn't capitulated yet.meanwhile the US military got its bases in the middle east destroyed, trump lost the midterms and can't pass legislation anymore, and the war made everyone poorer.this was in no uncertain terms extremely retarded and pointless
>>546297247One wonders how far gone or brown one has to be to interoperate what is happening as an epic Iranian win
>>546297244>So how did it break?>It broke because it's literally impossible to intercept enemy comms>Well... uh... we learned that... comms are important
>>546297249Satan backs team red
>>546297230I am the only faggot in this thread who read the whole Millennium Challenge. This is what I remember>win 95 clipart>tons of misspellings >so many acronyms it made my eyes bleed>von Riper is not mentioned by name once, and its noted his tactic hamstrings the Iranian navy in the long term
>>546297247Economic damage to the rest of the world? Sounds good. Fucking hate every country that’s not the USA
>>546297247>trump lost the midterms and can't pass legislation anymoreDoesn't matter, Democrats are already committed to the Iran war
>>546297247Don't bother the delusional retards on this board will tell you we needed and won yet another sandbox war
>>546297253I cannot believe anyone ever expected anything else
>>546297249It may seem obvious to you but remember that it took Hegseth 11 months to learn that sailors on an aircraft carrier need food.
>>546297236The issue isn't the plausibility of the scenario, the issue is van riper going off script and interrupting the exercise for his own ego. It would be like running a first aid course and some retard keeps pulling the fire alarm, saying "but what if there was a fire as well, huh? didya think of that?". Its like yeah, nobody is disputing that that could happen, but were training CPR right now.
>>546297256They had food retard
>>546297251Yeah, "so we pretend to be fishing boats and then strike the colors and throw everything at the CBG that's we were able to lure into littoral waters as our opening plan and uh hope there are enough assets left to control the bottleneck" is the kind of gamble that someone who watches too many action movies would come up with, and is bad politics. Starting a war with an act of perfidy is not a good look for winning the diplomatic PR war.
>>546297230>just ignore the 30+ iranian warships that got sunk irl saaaarCurse vishnu right now.
>>546297236>Very little costDiesel is like $10 a gallon, everything is expensive, and the sitting GOP president managed to lose almost the entire South, Texas, and more.
>>546297261>decapitate Venezuela and Iran with no boots on the ground>China spiraling>Russia lmaoThis is fine.
>>546297236We can rape them as much as they want, the retardation that is the global economy and the absolute weakness of our population mean that everyone wants to pull out rather than finish the job. It even has the retard mega-chud entity that is the Hegseth Pentagon cautious to just finish the fucking job, which only prolongs the economic problem. Yeah, Iran is dead. Even if we completely pulled out tomorrow their already ailing economy was dealt a mortal blow. The coming decades will either have them lose their borderlands to rebels or rival countries, or have them get completely cored out by the Chinese into a puppet state if they're stupid enough to repeat our mistake of getting hard committed to the Middle East. Maybe it'll descend into warlordism or full blown thirdie failed state. It's gonna be ugly either way.The problem is that nobody is going to perceive it as a win, because really all Americans actually care about is being materially comfortable, and this war only exacerbated the extant decline in that material comfort. But the longer we keep it in this protracted siege state, the longer the economic squeeze will go on for. I don't know how the U.S.A hasn't figured out how to fight a war of foreign interventionism in the 70-ish years since Korea.
>>546297262>China spiralingTwo more weeks, amirite?
>>546297260Hindu Indians wouldn't be posting pro-Iran stuff. Hindus fucking hate Muslims on account of all the horrible stuff the Mughals did to them. They hate them so much, that they're some of the only people still unironically in Israel's corner. It's Pakistanis that are the keyboard warriors for Jihadis. Because, for whatever reason, they're the biggest ummah (a muslim term for the international brotherhood of muslims) glazers of all the Muslim countries. Which is funny, because the other Muslim countries tend to look down on them. Partially because their hajjis are famously provincial and annoying, praying in the street and shit. Basically, most internet political arguments nowadays are actually Indians vs. Pakistanis, with both pretending to be white people.
>>546297245>and the US navy spawning into saturation fire already underway.I dont know the full story but could that have been the point of the exercise? Start the strike group in a worse case scenario and told to recover, while keeping losses to a minimum?
>>546297264Considering their real estate and AI bubble just took another massive hit, things aren't looking great for the global south currently.
>>546297265Yeah and rightwing Americans wouldn't be posting pro-Russia stuff, but here we are.
>>546297267>American AI bubble is collapsing too>Oh no buying a place to live is cheaper this is just like the late 80s Soviet UnionI'd argue their youth unemployment rate is a worse indicator than either but that would also mean the West is fucked.I wouldn't say China's in trouble until their manufacturing declines or they have bread lines at minimum.
>>546297269>Sure China is in trouble, but West is in less trouble- in fact, I won't say China is in trouble until they collapseConvincing stuff nigger
>>546297266because the manner in which he justified getting so close, which was to use disguised fishing boats to sail to close range, required a highly contrived setup that could only exist by exploiting the abstract nature of the wargame and would immediately fall apart in real life he only managed to get that close because his justification was that he used armed fishing boats that couldnt be identified as a target until it was right next to the vessels and they were too numerous to be interceptedthe problem is that each fishing boat was armed with a missile that weighted almost as much as the fishing boatthe second problem is that the disguise was modelled as simply appearing at identification range, which would be implausible in real life because 1000 fishing boats all making a beeline to the battle group would look suspicious even outside of their identification rangeand obviously iran would invite a war to a ridiculous level of escalation that they would never realistically ever try by sending in a hundred suicide bombers
>>546297271you misunderstand my post, I'm not saying the situation wasnt completely contrived it absolutely was, what I'm asking is if the point of the exercise was to see if the carrier group could survive a scenario where they were ambushed by a saturation attack without a clear target to counter attack to end it. basically a stress test of point defense, missile intercept and damage control. Think of it like those wargame F-22 dogfights where they have to tie a hand behind its back. Now if that wasnt the case and it wasnt the intent then yeah he basically just wasted everybodies time.
>>546297230damn bro at it with his 2024 AI slop. Bombay that far behind?
>>546297261>Diesel is like $10 a gallon, everything is expensive, and the sitting GOP president managed to lose almost the entire South, Texas, and more.I'm sorry that inflicting generational damage on one of our oldest enemies has caused you some expense at the pump.
>>546297253this. They will be putting HUGE pressure on Trump (and give him a blank check) to go all out and finish it. They will only start getting antsy if he drags it out beyond the end of next year.
>>546297272>>546297271I decided to look into this myself and basically everybody involved is retarded holy. Not just Van Ripper but Blue as well as when they decided to refloat the fleet to test the viability of the rest of the exercise they rigged red to the point that they ended up learning nothing from what they could salvage from the exercise (Ripper probably did some bullshit for that too but still).TLDR it wasnt a stress test it was just plain retardation.
>>546297248>We lost trillions of dollars, but at least we killed a bunch of sand people and made israel happy
>>546297254>delusional retardsJust say JIDF shills and Mossad glowies
>>546297254Iran should have been attacked decades ago BTW
>>546297231Russian hopes of Trump saving them
>>546297253how many more dead ayatollahs will the US need before iran surrenders and the strait is reopened?
>>546297255>find iraq and afghanistan on a map>what's between them?>now imagine a world where pro-us governments were installed in both of them and remained stable>us now has secure air bases in iraq and afghanistan>remember gwb's speech about the global axis of evil>what logically follows?They've been teeing this up for literally decades at this point. The only people surprised by it are kids and midwits with the attention span of a goldfish. Unfortunately this encompasses most American voters these days.
>>546297230The Iranians only didn't commit a perfidious ambush because they weren't given a 24 hour ultimatum, and they didn't have the capability to bomb American bases throughout the region without masses of shasneeds, which they didn't have in 2002. Also, they did set the tone with a war crime by immediately bombing civilian hotels throughout the region.
>>546297236>and they got rapedIs that why they own the strait and every US base between Jordan and Diego Garcia is inoperable now? FFS, we've reached the point of them having enough control to go out in small boats and literally fuck up tankers trying to pass without their okay with goddamn limpet mines now. Like, that's literally where we are: The USN is proving powerless to stop the Iranisn from literally driving speedboats into the strait and sticking bombs to tankers by hand.>for very little costGo tell that to american people paying six dollars plus per gallon at the pump, I fucking dare you.>>546297263>finish the jobIf the US were able to do that, Hegsie would've done it months ago. You're coping.>muh economy>muh mortal blowYou are vastly underestimating just how much economic hardhsip a nation can endure, especially when it has a scapegoat for all its problems to stare at.>warlordism or failed stateWell you better pray that's not happening, because then the strait is gonna stay closed for a generation or two at a minimum. And that's if they don't do the spiteful thing and bomb the Gulf states' desalination plants as a final Fuck You.
>>546297248One wonders how mentally brown and projecting it someone has to be to look at the clusterfuck of a thirdie nation literally consistently preventing the US from fulfilling one of its primary global policy objectives for decades by use of military force and call it a total US victory.When a thirdie nation stands up to a superpower and holds its ground (or, in this case, vital global waterway), that's generally a pretty damn epic win. Sorry about pointing that out.>>546297252Damage to the global economy means even greater damage to the american economny, as the latter is entirely structured around profiting off of the former.
>>546297284>every US base between Jordan and Diego Garcia is inoperable nowanon. anon look at me and tell me you genuinely think this. please.
>>546297264>saaaar nothing bad ever happens in china saaaaaaarsI curse and shit on vishnu.
>>546297284>every US base between Jordan and Diego Garcia is inoperable nowWrong>FFS, we've reached the point of them having enough control to go out in small boats and literally fuck up tankers trying to pass without their okay with goddamn limpet mines now1 ship...at the narrowest point in the strait...that has been repeatedly shutdown since...that caused only minor damage.>The subsequent detonations triggered a fire in the engine room and temporarily disabled the vessel. However, the crew extinguished the fire, there had been no environmental impact and the tanker continued its voyage.Jesus fucking christ get out of here with this talk of "control."
>>546297263>because really all Americans actually care about is being materially comfortableNo you're entirely wrong here. Americans don't care about this jewish war at all so any discomfort that comes from it is magnified because none of us want anything to do with Israel and we certainly don't want our military might, tax dollars, and lives of our soldiers going towards a war that has nothing to do with us.
>>546297272>what I'm asking is if the point of the exercise was to see if the carrier group could survive a scenario where they were ambushed by a saturation attack without a clear target to counter attack to end it. basically a stress test of point defense, missile intercept and damage controlIt just so happened that the real ships were near civilian shipping lanes so when the exercise started they had their defenses turned off to avoid locking on to civilians. So they couldn't even test that scenario because they were completely caught with their pants down. Damage control was indeed part of the exercise.>>546297276>they decided to refloat the fleet to test the viability of the rest of the exercise they rigged red to the point that they ended up learning nothing from what they could salvage from the exerciseKind of missing the point because the exercise wasn't about who won, it was a test about the viability of coordinating the exercise itself with so many moving parts (they had aircraft in the Nellis bomb range firing live ordnance to sort of run an "augmented reality" exercise where the simulated hits in the middle of the Nevada desert were taken into account and introduced into the wargame occurring near the shore) and test the viability of concepts like "net centric warfare". Which they figured out was kind of a mess and hierarchies are important because running a war like an IRC room gets confusing if you don't separate the information at the appropriate levels.The exercise was salvaged because it was entirely about boring shit that nobody cares about. Seeing who wins or loses wasn't the point so telling Red Team to stop fucking around and just stick to the script was justified.
>>546297264Implessive
>>546297287>eglin glowie jeetposting in a completely unrelated topicyou shills are so bad at fitting in lol
>>546297292Where are the sunk carriers thirdie
>>546297292Denounce vishnu right now fecaloid.
>>546297232Why can't you make a hunting thread on /o/? You drive a car/truck to go hunting, don't you? :^)
>>546297253>can't pass legislation>didn't ask for congressional permission or a declaration of war in the first place>only used the resources at his discretion as the chief executive which is why faggots were screaming that that use was out of missiles/bombs/planes/x when are massive stocks in the reserve which Trump cannot legally access without congressional approvalI want to glass Israel then glass Iran just to make a point, so lets be clear here regardless of what you think about the Iran adventure Tump hasn't had access to what congress could deny him thus far and for that reason nothing really changes.
>>546297268TRS faggots will post pro-Russia or pro-Palestine shit either because they are libtards who turned into internet nazis and therefore have empathy for the more retarded party of any conflict or because they are being contrarian because they think it serves their purposes.I want to kill everyone on the planet darker than milk and torture every jew to death. Nobody hates these post 2012 racism tourists more than I do.
>>546297251>>546297259Also whatever retard was programming the exercise fucked up. IRL they navy couldn't position assets in the shipping lane and parked them close to shore. This wasn't accounted for. Riper's bullshit still would have "worked" within the confines of the simulation because his simulated boats were within spitting distance of where the Naval assets were to be simulated to bet sitting. But instead of their intended simulated position their actual positions were put into the simulation. Thus they and Riper's boats were nocliping into on another. Thus when the silkworms launched they immediately scored hits on the targets because their simulate position wasn't thousands of meters away but tens to hundreds.TLDR: boomer naval officiers hired Xer programmer and didn't properly instruct him so the entire simulation was fucked up.
>>546297269>I'd argue their youth unemployment rate>officially 40% in China and if you work 2 hours a week that doesn't count as unemployedNigger by your own criteria the only place doing okay is Rural America.
>>546297236>gas prices>munitions stockpile>destroyed equipment>deferred maintenance>allies pissed off (especially those relying on gulf LNG, aka Japan and Korea)But ok for arguments sake let's say that's chump change. So let's look at the other side of the balance sheet. What *DID* america get out of this? Was Iran overthrown and has joined the US as the 51st state? Is Phalavi the new puppet in charge? Is america getting a cut of Iranian oil and gas? Did the US even get so much as pinky promise they won't build a nuke?
>>546297230>Why is the American military mind so solipsistic?Like any other big organization, you only climb if you agree with the powers that be, so any truly outside-the-box thinker will never be in a position to think.
>>546297300>Was Iran overthrown and has joined the US as the 51st stateWhy is the only indication of winning a war is taking land? Iran can no longer power project over the middle east that they have been causing problems since the 80s.
>>546297302>Iran can no longer power project over the middle east>meanwhile saudis and their proxies are losing ground to houthis in yemenlol
>>546297236>they got raped, and then re-raped, repeatedly>for very little cost.besides the midterm election? lmao
>>546297279The problem should've been solved 50 years ago the second they radicalized.OR not have multiple suicidal administrations in a row that gleefully gutted and raped the domestic energy industry to ensure you can never divorce yourself from the Middle East.
>>546297300Gut another Chinese ally that you've been in a proxy war with for 50 years, weaken BRICs and OPEC's control on the global economy, and prove you're committed to enforcing freedom of navigation.
>>546297302they hit the head quarters of the Saudi national oil company in Riyadhso it's safe to assume that they can still fuck around in their region
>>546297306>and prove you're committed to enforcing freedom of navigationhahahahahahahahahahahahha
>>546297302Something like 10% of VLCCs have been hit by missiles lol
>>54629730910% is a failing grade retard.
Iran has the strategic advantage as in once the global oil and food storages are emptied, both America (which cant take prolonged high oil prices due to being #1 in diesel and gas consumption per capita) and the gulf arabs (who cant handle high food prices because they import all of their food because they live in an actual desert) will have to chose between a settlement, skedaddle or invade. The iranians know that which is why they arent quitting. Another pucker factor that works in the iranian's favor are the rising bond rates across most of the world, once they become high enough, governments who run a budgetary deficit financed with bond sales will have to make a balanced budget with some money allocated to bond paybacks or they will enter a bond doom loop. For some strange reason the saudi arabians decided to duke it out with the yemenis, probably because they appeared to be easier to deal with than the iranians, but then they promptly got rekt.
>tom clancy thread>not a single post about PREGNANCYshame
>>546297230>don't set the tone with a warcrimeyou're right, iran shouldn't have stuck those civilian hotels, then they wouldn't have been bombed flat.
>>546297244>i actually don't mind itwhich is why people consider you a retard.
>>546297247>the strait remains closed offfor iran only, actually, everyone else can go through.>got it's bases in the middle east destroyedthey didn't.
>>546297298That isn't what happened. No boats were equipped with Silkworms in the simulation no matter how much OP lies about it. In the wargame, Van Riper had his speedboats sit on the horizon from the American fleet until the last 4 hours before the end of the surrender ultimatum, then they salvoed off their Exocets right as the shore based Silkworms were approaching. The total number of missiles exceeded what the Aegis system at the time could track, and so the simulation assumed that no missiles were intercepted. I believe this was a quirk of the simulation but I'm not entirely sure.There were lots of assumptions built into the simulation going both ways. For example, all of the American ships were assumed to have infinite missiles, and REDFOR was not allowed to attack American aircraft because it was assumed that they wouldn't be able to track the F-22s (which didn't actually exist yet). On the other hand, it was an assumption of wargame that BLUFOR would not be able to intercept REDFOR's communications because it would be too easy if you just handwave the entire game away with "we hack your comms and then respond to everything you do instantly, gg," and this was rationalized with motorcycle couriers and such. However, the simulation had no way to account for communications lag, which is where OP's "teleporting motorcycles" bullshit came from.
>>546297230was there ever a war that was planned for so long that still ended up being a shitshow?Forget about the war right now for a moment. I just want to talk about the planning. Like we've seen ad-hoc planning go wrong where you have lack of training, resources or time and that's why things either go bad or you don't really get what you wanted for.But the americans had a hard-on for the iranians for like 40 years. How do you not have every eventuality planned out, with every t crossed and so on?At this point wouldn't there have been decades of planning documents sitting in a drawer? Shouldn't there have been entire graduating classes from west point or annapolis that wrote papers on how to fight Iran?
>>546297317I'm sure sure there were lots of plans in place for a war. I doubt any of those planners "large scale unsupported strategic bombing operation with limited notice where we're not allowed to touch power and water infrastructure and our 'allies' go out of their way to bomb anyone who might negotiate with us" on their bingo cards though.
>>546297230The Millennium Challenge was held 25 years ago, before the IRGC had the ballistic missile capabilities that they have now, and before shaheds were even on the drawing board. >>546297236>very little costThe US has had to withdraw from all of its bases in Iraq and the Gulf states. There's no longer a permanent USN base in the ME, the "war" is being waged out of Diego Garcia. Oil is moving through Hormuz but it's permanently constrained and requires constant escort/intervention and it's very expensive. Unilaterally fucking over Asian energy markets and withdrawing strategic assets from Korea etc has undermined those relationships (so much for the pivot to China). There's no longer any meaningful effort to overthrow the IRGC, limit their missile production, etc and there have been only sporadic bombings for months now. America killed far more people and destroyed far more hardware, but the reality is that American power and influence has suffered.
>>546297274>I'm sorry that inflicting generational damage on one of our oldest enemies has caused you some expense at the pump.I wonder who could be behind this post.
>>546297319>before shaheds were even on the drawing board.Technically it was designed in the 1980s, but Iran only got access to the plans in 2005 or so.
>>546297320>daaaaaa jooooosFucking retard, Iran has attacked and killed far more Americans than they have ever killed Israelis you fucking third world fecalderm ass licking subhuman.
>>546297322Ok grandpa, let's get you back to bed
>>546297322>Fucking retard, Iran has attacked and killed far more Americans than they have ever killed IsraelisGee, I wonder why. Maybe it is because Israel keeps dragging America into Middle East wars like a fucking shoulder devil with infinite lobbyist bucks to bribe our politicians with. Almost like 95% of our beef with Iran goes up in a puff of smoke whenever we aren't acting as Israel's sugar daddy / attack dog.
>>546297231What blew up? Neocons hopes and dreams.https://youtu.be/khtWPycU-PA?si=9EkDZ3C4vM0iDALr
>>546297319>the US has had to withdraw from all of its bases in iraq and the gulf stateswrong.>t-there's no longer a permanent USN base in the MEwrongwhere do you get all of these fanfics from?
>>546297324no, maybe it's because they chant death to america daily over there, you fucking twat.
>>546297327I believe they chant another countries name alongside America in those chants, I wonder which it is. Perhaps the country that is always getting America to bomb them and invade their neighbors against America's interest. How much money and lives were sunk into fighting as Israel's proxy in the Middle East?
>>546297324>>546297328>the heckin' wholesome Iranarinos have their nuclear blackmail, something something jewsNo.
>>546297329Exactly, another 50 billion to support our greatest ally Israel. Pay no attention to the prices on the gas station, it's for a good cause.
>>546297330The middle east being under the nuclear blackmail of Iran would be even worse for gas prices, so we're not letting that happen. Your personal feelings about Jews were not a factor.
>>546297331>The middle east being under the nuclear blackmail of IranLol, the Middle East is under blackmail now because Israel convinced Trump that wiping out their countries leadership would cow them. It took a total decapitation strike for them to play the Hormuz card. If it wasn't for Israel relations with them would have been normalized years ago. If they did get nukes then they'd just be another Pakistan, it would be unlikely though since without Israel whispering in our ear the nuclear deal would have held. Let's be real too, 90% of the reason they want nukes is because Israel illegally got them.Every fucking issue with Iran comes back to Israel stealing territory, getting nukes and buying politicians.
>>546297331NATO is under nuclear threat from russia. china and india are at war but refuse to use conventionnal weapons to avoid nuclear escalation. No one wants to be the one starting a nuclear escalation because they would be the one losing it.Iran having nuclear weapons would just mean the US or israel can't bombard them with impunity, that's it. and that's why there's a war now, because Iran know very well that once they have it, the US won't attack as easily as you do now (why else haven't they attacked north korea ?).They also know they will only lose if they start a nuclear war, politicians and leaders aren't as retarded as you are (except trump and his administration, what years of not funding schools does). And no, religious extremism doesn't change shit about that.As for muh gas prices, they didn't have the bomb and the retard you have at the head of the US fucked it up anyway, them having the bomb and blackmailing would have been significantly cheaper
>>546297266Might have been, also might have been the reason his retarded ass got kicked off the field.>you spawn>1000 anti ship missiles capable of 1 shotting your ship already mid-air to your location from 1000 different vectors all within spitting dstance>you're dead>hurr durr why didn't you teleport behind them?!?!?!Is not a learning scenario.
>>546297332>If it wasn't for Israel relations with them would have been normalized years agoPure hopium.>If they did get nukes then they'd just be another PakistanAnd did you fucking miss how Pakistan used Operation Cyclone to create the Taliban, allowed Bin Laden to set up his hiding spot there, etc?>90% of the reason they want nukes is because Israel illegally got them.I don't think they care about the legality of Israeli nukes, what matters is that they inherited a nuclear program, they beefed with Saddam, and generally speaking nukes would deter US attacks.This is textbook concern trolling. Israel could have obtained the nukes in a 100% legit way and they'll still be pursuing them.
>>546297326The US withdrew all forces from Iraq in September, minus embassy guards. The source of this fanfic is the White House. The 5th fleet headquarters in Bahrain was badly damaged by Iranian missiles and hasn't been used to service or supply US ships since the beginning of the war. It can't provide meaningful support (read: it was destroyed) and the US will not risk mooring ships there. The source of this fanfic is the NYT. Many bases around the region are running on skeleton crews and not supporting combat in a meaningful way, because it's too dangerous to park anything expensive out in the open. This has been widely reported in American news outlets, dunno why it's worth it to you to argue the point.If it makes you feel better, you didn't do the retarded Russian thing and keep parking your strategic assets where they could easily get hit. Impressively low casualties, low vehicle and aircraft losses, etc. Chalk it up to a plan of getting off the X.
>>546297332>illegal Israel didn't sign the non-proliferation treaty. So how was their acquisition of nuclear weapons illegal?
>>546297333>north koreaBecause North Korea doesn't attack it's neighbors or fund terrorist groups that attack it's neighbors? Possessing nuclear weapons DOES NOT make you immune to conventional attack, look at the utter assraping Ukraine is doing to Russia. >iran>we'll nook ook you Great Satan!>us >bet>launches preemptive nuclear strike on all launch, storage, and command and control nodes>iran>ACCCCCCCCCKTurns out the winning move is not to fuck with your neighbors.
>>546297337They literally stole the fissile material from the US, for one.
>>546297335>This is textbook concern trolling. Israel could have obtained the nukes in a 100% legit way and they'll still be pursuing them.Right back at you. Israel has nukes so it can kill all its neighbors at the push of a button. This whole nuke business is because they are terrified of Iran evening the playing field. They want to have the capability to nuke with impunity without facing the same threat back and they've wormed their way into US through bribes and lobbying to ensure we foot the bill. All these wars, the trillions of US tax payer dollars spent, the damaged international relations, the high gas prices now, all of it is to maintain Israel's dominance in the region.>b-b-but IranWe wouldn't even think about Iran if not for Israel, they'd be like Tanzania or Zimbabwe to us. Nobodies. What has Israel given us in return for all this grief, nothing.
>>546297338Nobody has ever said it's impossible to attack a nuclear state, just that it's impossible to invade and conquer one.
>>546297339>no charges were ever filed and no material was found missing Hmmmmmmmmm
>>546297340Wrong.
>>546297340If Israel didn't make Iran a concern then Saudi Arabia would.
>>546297344>wah, wah Iran, solve our geopolitical problems US and pay for itNo.
>>546297342Who went looking? Did he have a large nose?
>>546297266>>546297334See: >>546297316>be American admiral>give Iran an ultimatum to surrender within 24 hours or you'll bomb them into the stone age>20 hours later they fire 10,000 missiles at you all at once>half your fleet is sunk>"How could this have happened to me? We're supposed to win everything because we're the good guys!"Notice that we didn't give them any warning in the actual war. That's because Van Riper's play was actually 100% on point.
>>546297346The FBI. >be da joos>own america >option a>ask the cia and they slide uranium under the table >option b>use someone who isn't israeli and who is easily traced and tracked to steal materials you can get for freeGee I fucking wonder.
>>546297347>if we ignore physics and game the simulation, we can do anything
>>546297349That is Islam in a nutshell.
>>546297342The whole origin of the story is that they found almost 600lbs missing out of a facility in Pittsburgh. You know this, but you need to pretend otherwise because you're a shill reading from a script. Now go on, spin us another tale.
>>546297349Physics says you have to wait for the end of the 24 hour ultimatum to be attacked instead of attacking just before it ends?
>>546297333>why else haven't they attacked north koreaA few reasons.>they're not a thread to the us>they have nothing anyone wants>propaganda aside, they basically keep to themselvesBut the biggest reason?>they haven't pissed off israel
>>546297318But that's the point of the question: You plan for something so fucking long, you should have options planned from Defcon 5 to Defcon 1. It's not like the pentagon was unaware of the neocon/israeli intentions for decades. They knew that any day someone from the white house could come knocking and asking for their pitch on what to do. I actually think the Midnight Hammer thing was exactly such a plan. But where was plan B, C and D? >Uhhh like we bomb them and they surrender because the ayatollah is now a piece of cardboard and we paid the kurds to riot? Ok Mr. General, what is your plan B for when that doesn't happen?>>546297348Now goodle pentodes, MILCO and krytron
>>546297354Well, what happened was that Hegseth floated this plan, was told it wouldn't work, and then started firing generals until he got one that would try it.
>>546297347No it wasn't, no enemy is given 24 hours to surrender and gets to mobilize, and deploy 10,000 boats and missile launchers to within striking distance while a carrier group sits on its thumb and counts down because they can't do anything until the time is up. Not that the time limit even mattered anyways because it was a simulation and Riper had already preplaced his boats within striking distance to where the carrier group would spawn in the scenario. He could have fired as soon as the ultimatum was delivered and the outcome would be the same. It is not a learning scenario and he was rightfully kicked out. We didn't give Iran a warning about their ayatollah getting greased because we didn't do it and were in the middle of negotiations when Israel, correctly, decided that they were just playing fuck fuck games and stalling. If Riper's play was on point at all Iran would have probably done more than put some shrapnel in a pilot's ass and bitch on twitter.
>>546297356That's exactly what happened lmao, go read the MC02 report. He had 20 hours to position his boats exactly where he wanted them.
>>546297353>>they're not a thread to the usiran is even less of one, no ? at least best korea has the range to some stateswith ICBMs to my knowloedge>>propaganda aside, they basically keep to themselvesmostly due to being weak, no ? they want to get south korea at least, and used to frequently launch missiles in the direction of japan>>they have nothing anyone wants>>they haven't pissed off israelfair
>>546297336You just admitted the US still has permanent bases and all Iran managed to do was make holes in the sand. Congratulations, you played yourself.
>>546297299That sounds completely reasonable yes.
>>546297303>Muh landDefinitely Russian.
>>546297308Post tolls and sunk carriers.
>>546297311And other stories you tell yourself as Sunni militias literally take over Iran.
>>546297359Iran has killed lots of sand. The sand was very Jewish.
>>546297364Is that why Anakin said that? Now it all makes sense...
>>546297363>Sunni militias literally take over IranIs this the new JIDF fanfiction?
>>546297359guess the competency crisis has hit Eglin too if the best their shills have to offer is to go "LALALA I CAN'T HEAR YOU EPIC OWNAGE" when confronted with the truth
>>546297367So the USS Lincoln was sunk in the straight?
>>546297345So there would be 100% peace in the middle east and eternal low gas prices in the west if Isreal just didn't exist? You can prove this?
>>546297358>iran is even less of oneJust ignore how they have been politically hostile since the 80s and have caused thousands of deaths and millions in damage unlike North Korea
>>546297370You people are pathetic, clinging to a decades old bombing and pretending Iran made the EFPs even after US troops found all the machine shops in iraq.The Iranians dindu nuffin. Even after they got bombed last year, what was their response? Gave a warning and dropped a few missiles into an empty corner of a US base to save face. Meanwhile it wasn't the Iranians telling Bush about WMDs in Iraq. Wasn't the Iranians flying those planes on 9/11. They were even fighting ISIS when we were fighting ISIS. Their "nuke" even if they actually made one would have been a fuckhuge undeliverable Hiroshima bomb that they'd couldn't get to tel Aviv on a flying carpet, let alone threaten the US. And the second they flex their nuke muscle with the gulf states guess who'll show up at Uncle Sam's door with a blank check and a request for nuclear material?Meanwhile the republicans sacrificed all their political power for this shit with nothing to show for it.
>>546297371>Iran didn't fly a plane into New York and kill 6 million Americans so you should be nice to themshut up *ranian
>>546297359You just admitted that there isn't much left at many of those bases except sand, because they're largely abandoned and don't house anything important anymore which was my original point.Your brand of cope is bizarre. NO NO NO WE ARE IN A BETTER POSITION THAN EVER WE TOOK NO DAMAGE WE HAVE NO PROBLEMS is retarded. Just do the normal zogbot rationalization, revel in the K:D ratio and complain that your lost cause was sabotaged by liberals.
>>546297369>So there would be 100% peace in the middle east and eternal low gas prices in the west if Isreal just didn't exist? You can prove this?Israel is more hated then ever, not just around the globe but now even in the US so we'll be withdrawing all our money and support sooner or later. Guess we'll see what happens.
>>546297352I will just say yes instead of pointlessly arguing with a reformer
THIS IS A TOM CLANCY THREADWHERE IS THE PREGNANCYWHERE IS ITIT IS CONTRACTUALLY OBLIGATED TO DISCUSS HIS PREGNANCY FETISH IN EVERY THREAD RELATING TO HIMGET TO ITTHAT IS ALL
>>546297375Explaining the factual sequence of events makes me a reformer?
>>546297230Millenials ruin everything.
>>546297376Based fellow Clanyesque preggo enjoyer.
>>546297376Care to elaborate? I re-read Clancy's books a few years back, and I still have no idea what you're talking about. Did my eyes just glaze over whenever he got too Catholic for my taste?
>>546297380Not that anon but off the top of me head:>whole preggo Icelandic arc in RSR described in lurid detail>Patriot Games, pregnant Dr Cathy Ryan's oiled up body described in what was probably typed one-handed, her co-worker admiring her body when they're scrubbing up for surgery>Rainbow Six, Ding's wife "caught a silver bullet" and a little bit of preggo description>impreg fantasy in Sum of All Fears>I think there's a couple of references in Cardinal of the Kremlin Tom was hyper based.
>>546297381It’s a shame that his type of conservatism is basically dead.
>>546297382>It’s a shame that his type of conservatism is basically dead.His type of conservatism is pretty much my type of conservatism. I grew up from about 12yo reading Tom Clancy and Biggles books and I think those two pretty much formulated my world view lol.
>>546297383I'm a dirty hippie, so when I read Rainbow Six, I thought, "my god, that jingoist fool wrote the finest tragedy of the 20th century, and he doesn't even know it."
>>546297384kek The mirror reflects ourself
>>546297377>factualdefinitely a reformer
>>546297372Yes anon, national defense ranks threats based on their actual relevance. People burning a US flag in a mudhut 10000 miles away isn't worth the hellfire missile it would take to shut it down.It's just Iraq again. Wasting US blood and treasure with nothing to show for it.
>>546297382>>546297383His type of conservatism got us into this mess. He ironically thought the Russian people would rise up against KGB mafia thugs attempting to seize power after a few years of democracy and that the Middle East and China would also become liberal democratic nations as a result of the inevitable course of history.That sort of politics died in an Iraqi ditch.
>>546297388You can see the life leave his eyes when the post-9/11 world left his worldview in shambles. He was phoning it in with ghostwriters for every book afterwards. Kind of sad that he didn't follow the wacky alt-history universe he was building in his books right up to 2000, would've been mega kino.
>>546297387except Iran isn't just burning flags retard, they're actively arming and funding terrorists who have the intent to fuck with the global economy. Dumb Iranian shill
>>546297233If a simulation can't take into account such basic things, then it's a shit simulation with questionable results, and causes flawed conclusions, plans, and doctrine. Not entirely erroneous, but flawed.
>>546297389>>546297388I have some sympathy for this worldview because it was a product of the Cold War. This was the world that had defined his entire adult life. When it was over, it really would have seemed like that was it, the end of history. One superpower, perhaps a few delusional terrorists here and there, but no dangers from other states, which were only just getting back on their feet and would eventually transition to liberal capitalist democracy.
>>546297243>>546297248>>546297390https://youtube.com/watch?v=Lz-kjq0E79Ehttps://youtube.com/watch?v=hUx3-IIVMjY
>>546297392There was this brief moment that we thought things could only get better from here, that the gleaming shiny Star Trek future could be a thing, and then 9/11 happened to fuck it all up. It was simultaneously the biggest windup and letdown of all time.
>>546297394Let's say we put the false flag and inside job speculation to the side,Imagine how retarded you have to be to invade 2 countries, and even occupy them for 2 decades, because of 9/11??
>>546297394It was mostly just a lack of information and blissful ignorance about what was going on in the rest of the world (beyond maybe the UK) at the time. A lot of popular 90s social commentary made out being bored with your 9 to 5 office job as the great crisis of the age, which ended up sounding pretty ridiculous after the recession.
>>546297396Like, it's hard to understate how fucking wrong and out of touch they were. It's the equivalent of a guy who's never been shot wishing and praying to get shot in the face.
>>546297393>10 years ago
>>546297230What's the status on the "Iron Gate" anyway? does it even work?
>>546297397The existential crisis is literally explained in the movie. It was about being an anonymous cog in the machine with a predetermined purpose of life, which is waking up, work, consume, sleep and repeat till death. The protagonist yearns for a life in which he himself having the freedom to give meaning to his existence.I agree that these problems seem luxurious for the following generations, but they aren't less of an existential crisis then the problems the following generations have.
>>546297395and those 2 countries weren't even the culprit, the culprits are currently US allies lmao. American lives mean jack shit in geopolitics
>>546297401Just ignore how the US experienced less casualties than any nation lmao
>>546297386>Red received an ultimatum from Blue, essentially a surrender document, demanding a response within 24 hours. Thus warned of Blue's approach, Red used a fleet of small boats to determine the position of Blue's fleet by the second day of the exercise. In a preemptive strike, Red launched a massive salvo of cruise missiles that overwhelmed the Blue forces' electronic sensors and destroyed sixteen warships: one aircraft carrier, ten cruisers and five of Blue's six amphibious ships.
>>546297403>Leaving out reds use of ftl messenger bike communication, speed boats arbitrarily determined by game rules to be too small to show up on radar, and using said civilian speed boats as launch platforms for silkwormsFair and unbiased breakdown
>>546297404It was a handicap agreed on before the exercise that Blue wouldn't be able to read Red's communications. The simulation didn't have the ability to handle communications delay, but Red members delayed their own responses to compensate.Red used militarized versions of civilian speedboat models just like Iran does in real life, and they were armed with cloned Exocet missiles just like Iran does in real life. There were no speedboats armed with Silkworms.
>>546297400Yeah, those are problems. Consumerism sucks, but like people aren't going to feel sorry for him.
>>546297400>It was about being an anonymous cog in the machine with a predetermined purpose of life, which is waking up, work, consume, sleep and repeat till death.All a voluntary choice they made. They could of easily just got a more fulfilling job or went out in nature.
>>546297407>They could of easily just got a more fulfilling job or went out in nature.Yea, just like the millennials and zoomers could pull themself up by their bootstraps.Tyler Durden is the literal personified (imagined) steam valve for young men in this generation. The domesticated men in the film seemingly reclaim a fulfilling lifestyle for themself: making soap, beating the shit out of each other and project mayham.
>>546297407>They could of easily just got a more fulfilling jobAs someone who did exactly that, it's not so simple. Those jobs pay a fraction of what office drone jobs do and are more heavily contested despite that. Most people are not cut out for living on $18k per year.
>>546297408>just like the millennials and zoomers could pull themself up by their bootstrapsthis but unironically, Im so sick of losers my age complaining every damn day about how they're apparently on the verge of losing it all, as if they weren't ordering insanely expensive fast food slop multiple times a week
>>546297408Gen X is never going to convince subsequent generations that being bored with their high paying job is le bad because they feel like a sellout according to some grunge buttrocker
>>546297396>>546297397>>546297406>>546297405For rural America which was mocking this faggotry throughout the 90s, even the kids, and which still has not suffered the effects of the things which ended the era for the urbanite trash its pretty amusing. Why not just begin scheming? Why not turn away from society and social faggotry and sink yourself into your family? Why not make your own undermanagement mafia with dozens of your makes agreeing to cover for each other and fuck over anybody else. As an example if a CFO needs something to keep his job but he is an asshole who everybody hates it just happens to get lost(stolen and discarded by somebody without direction connection to it) over and over so he cannot do his job. They even bring this up but rather than act on it they just fuck around. You could be a lone wolf killer or a nepotistic brotherhood, instead the solutions presented by pop culture and the elite were to be morose faggots and the Xers seem to have actually embraced that shit. It's like the way the Boomers thought they were rebelling against the system in the 60s by doing what jews and libtards in authority told them to do, as if their parents who had zero power were the real elites of society. The internet ironically destroyed all that now everybody is a conspiracy theorist and they have lost the ability to create a zeitgeist.
>>546297408Chuck Palahniuk is a gay libertarian who’s part of an entire community of gay libertarians, want to know what Project Mayhem looks like in real life? Well, this is it.https://www.7x7.com/project-mayhem-inside-the-wild-world-and-history-of-sfs-cacophony-soci-1786507185.html>>546297409but that's the issue. Seeing someone in their 90s, living comfortably, complain about the emptiness of life while having enough money to waste on expensive junk for their condo and how none of it brings them happiness, doesn't really resonate with people who can't afford any of those thing or have a condo or an apartment.
>>546297413>blows all productive time on shittok or doomscrolling and the money on avocado toast and matcha green latte>why don't I have a high paying job or at least least enough money?
>>546297413The 90s were coasting on an 85% white America(vs the 70% today yes it is higher than they say) so productivity was much higher. Every time anybody complains about anything just point out that blacks cost the federal government a Trillion dollars more in entitlements out than tax dollars in every year of their lives and spics also cost about a Trillion. Even white women only break even. So when they started fucking with white men and they are a smaller component of the tax base is it any surprise that things start to fall to shit?90s media was mostly the libtard taste-makers and writers bemoaning that they weren't seeing society disintegrate into libtard shit yet and instead were just well oiled gears in a corporate machine which even then was mostly run by white-haired white men. Through the 2000s they destroyed that through a combination of corporate infiltration and government interference. Once the government was by and for whites only, then the corporations were by and for the profit of the white men on top who knew which workers generated that profit. Nations were taken over by anti-nationalists and corporations were taken over by anti-racists who had no interest in profit. This shit was underway in the 80s but like everything it just took time.
>>546297413Chuck Palahniuk suffers from the same retardation as Verhoeven, who made Starship Troopers, thinking he made a movie owning le patriarchy and the men while showing how men should reclaim their masculinity and how fascism is actually awesome.
>>546297414So, are all the people I went to school with just morons when it comes to money, given that they can’t afford to buy a house either? And no I’m not out here buying avocado toast or matcha lattes, I did everything exactly right, like most of us did. My job was snatched away because an Indian guy was willing to work for peanuts and we weren’t.
>>546297416Feel free to peruse the imagined masculine ideal of a gay libertarian.
>>546297390So now we're shifting goal posts from Iran being a threat to american lives to being a threat to the global economy. And how has that worked out? Has the US fight against Iran brought down oil and gas prices? Or has it literally done the exact same thing those darn iranian terrorists did?Which aren't even the Iranians themselves but the houthis, which begs the question why not fight Yemen instead of Iran, because unlike the strait of hormuz US gulf allies and friends in asia don't depend on the bab al-mandab not being a fireworks show. And US allies are on BOTH sides of the BAM that not only are hostile to the shia muslim sect, but also have a shared interest in keeping the strait open AND can interdict potential weapon shipments from Iran.And that's not even counting that the US and the houthis had already agreed to a ceasefire back in 2025 that only had the condition of not launching strikes on Iran. Even by your renewed goalposts you only made things worse.>>546297395Imagine not only being so dumb, but then also being so dumb that as you are spending trillions on that war you're fighting in the world's gas station, and you end up with Iraqi oil fields in the hands of...chinese and european companies.
>>546297414ragebaitthe nepo babies and the older third of millennials were able to slide in during the brief house pricing drop. the rest are as fucked as the zoomers, except balder.
>>546297271>required a highly contrived setup that could only exist by exploiting the abstract nature of the wargame and would immediately fall apart in real lifeUnlike real life where spamming lawnmower engines with plastic and explosives attached wins simply by saturation via actual good defence systems
>>546297421Yes, basically. van Riper was a vidya game cheater while modern Iranians are practical fighters; but ignorant idiots who have never read past a headline or clip think they're the same.
>>546297422>van Riper was a vidya game cheaterIt's funny how every time I point out that this isn't true (such as >>546297405) you stop responding and then begin repeating your script at someone else.
>>546297423NTA but can two things be true at the same time? van Riper unfairly exploiting flaws in the simulation is one thing and the other is that the simulation then became worthless as they scripted it to a foregone conclusion.I feel like the latter is far more worthy of discussion than the teleporting speedboat memes.
>>546297286>His foot is across the foul lineCheating fuck
>>546297419>So now we're shifting goal posts from Iran being a threat to american lives to being a threat to the global economy. And how has that worked out? Has the US fight against Iran brought down oil and gas prices? Or has it literally done the exact same thing those darn iranian terrorists did?Iran is willing to destablilize the economy AND kill Americans and any allies we may have. I don't what kind of dumbass argument you're trying to argue, Iran itself will admit this to you.>noooo you can't just attack the country that's been fucking around for years without finding out
>>546297417idk man zoomers deserve to not own a house when they consistently vote to bring in as many competing home buyers as possible from the global south
>>546297409>Those jobs pay a fraction of what office drone jobs doPoor or happy or rich and miserable? Not a hard choice. Just have to live within your means. For example I personally pay for 0 streaming services and still watch TV with an antenna getting all the basic channels.
>>546297427>100% of zoomers voted for mass immigration Retard.
>>546297429better figure out your living situation, Pedro is coming
>>546297230Why is he so oily? Did someone throw rapeseed oil into his face before the photo?
>>546297428And what if I want to have a home of my own? I'm a high school teacher and I still live with my parents. Do you know how fucking embarrassing that is?
>>546297424Red didn't exploit the simulation any more than Blue did. Our resident anti-Van Riper shill talks about muh teleporting silkworm speedboats but not about how Red wasn't allowed to use any of its air defense assets because it was assumed that they would all be instantly destroyed by aircraft that didn't exist yet. The only untoward thing Van Riper did was complain to the press. I won't make excuses for him for that, but he certainly had reason to be upset after the way he was treated to that point, and attempts to publicly discredit him afterward were even worse than anything he did.
>>546297432Swallow your pride. Be grateful you still have parents you can live with.
>>546297434You think I hate my parents or blame them? I blame billionaires and politicians who wanted infinite growth.
>>546297425believe it or not this is why watergate actually happened
>>546297435Then ask your parents to help you put down a payment and take out a loan to buy a house.
>>546297426>destabilizing the economylol no you did that when you started a shootout in the worlds biggest chokepoint for oil and LNG and despite van riper's boat memes the Iranians going after the strait once things kick off was widely expected even decades ago.>kill americansDidn't kill a single american over the last 40 years till the war started. Actually helped the US post 9/11 til Bush put them on the axis of evil and then still had an enemy-of-my-enemy-is-my-friend going on when ISIS was wreaking havoc. le EFP story in iraq was widely overstated, US marines found the machine shops making them in Iraq. (and the US didn't have to overthrow the world-record holder in killing Iranians, but oh well)> I don't what kind of dumbass argument you're trying to argue.The point that you're a dumbass that thinks Iran was an enemy where the juice was worth the squeeze. It wasn't.
>>546297438I thought the Iranians were proud of supporting the Houthis, who fucked over global shipping for like 2/3s of a year while the USN had to play goalie because Europe and China are incapable of securing their own trade? Amazing how now we're pretending like that never happened.
>>546297439Hence my previous argument >>546297419 The houthi situation was essentially solved in 2025 until the war started with Iran. And it's the much easier candidate if you truly did care about the global economy. Think about it: Everyone between China and Portugal wants the Houthis to stop shooting at their ships. US, Saudis and Egyptians roll them up. You can even share the workload and have them do the ground invasion with the US doing the air war for the voters.Easy victory and instead of being the cause of additional economic strife you're the solution. And you just removed the terrorgroup that Iran is supporting thereby weakening them and leaving *them* in the position where they can either chimp out in which again the US can be the hero saving the day rather than the instigator trying to bomb a 90 million people country into submission that's the size of Texas and Alaska combined.
>>546297440>Iran wasn't destabilizing the economy>except for that time they did>and it was solved anyway>pay no attention the cost the US incurred in doing so>and that the Houthis weren't solved and can chimp out again at any time>oh yea, they actually are doing that and did attack shipping again>but that's uncomfortable for me to admit, so Iran wuz good boys who din do nuffinThe irony of Ahmed complaining about the jews while pulling the same disigenous bullshit from the jewish book of tricks never fails to make me laugh. The funniest part for me is that you shills could actually make good points about how the war is being conducted in stupid half measures and in a shit manner all around, but then you overextend into acting as though Iran didn't deserve every last bit of pain they.
>>546297440>please just Ignore that Hamas and the Houthis are directly propped up by Iran, these are non-problems anywaydie
>>546297391He was intentionally abusing the system. It was 2001 and largely reliant on an honor system and rational actors because half of the simulation was graph paper and printed charts.
>>546297342Oy vey
>>546297441>Iran wasn't destabilizing the economyIt's literally a speck of dust compared to the way the US destabilized the economy with this war.>and that the Houthis weren't solved and can chimp out again at any timeIt *was* solved. All the US had to do was not start a war with Iran. That's it. And if the war withdrawal symptoms are too hard for the US then go after Yemen directly. Easier win, less risk and so forth. You're pretending like the US is this innocent bystander when in reality it's the top reason for all of this happening to begin with.>pay no attention the cost the US incurred in doing soYeah right, you're billions of $ into a war that has achieved nothing except replacing the moderate boomers in Iran with more extreme leaders. good job>and that the Houthis weren't solved and can chimp out again at any timeAs opposed to today where the US has secured an official pinky promise™ from both Iran and Yemen to be good bois now?>but that's uncomfortable for me to admit, so Iran wuz good boys who din do nuffinPeak projection. Americans are the ones with cognitive dissonance on this one. The US destabilized the global economy by starting this war. After ignoring every off-ramp possible. The houthis just made everyone take a detour around africa that raised transit times and costs. Nobody paid risk premiums, had to account for war-time insurance or faced actual supply problems beyond short-term delays. Unlike what the war against Iran created instantly.All the wargames predicted all of this to the same degree of newtonian physics. Without van ripers magic boats. Which is why every advisor that was an honest broker said "don't fucking do it"
>>546297442>hamashaven't killed americans, haven't been a threat to americans. They were even denounced by AQ for not being extreme enough jihadis. They are also confined to a tiny place in Israel. They are relevant to the security of the US how exactly?>houthisI'm really not sure what the fuck your argument even is? The Iran war has somehow placated the Houthis into submission? Having a ceasefire with them and resuming shipping through the BAM was bad for the economy? The US needed to start a war that had a 100% chance of fucking with the other even more important chokepoint in the middle east? None of this shit had to happen. I will be proven right purely by time. The US will gain nothing and will have spent a lot of money for that privilege.>>546297443 It was also one of THE most expensive wargames ever. I don't even know what the hell they spent their money on to come up with that figure if it was all paper and charts.
>>546297433Van Ripper was a butthurt reformer tard that wanted less technology and more human wave tactics. He complained to the media that it was super unfair Blue refloated the navy and that it was rigged for them to win when the takeaway of the exercise with the refloating and all was that Red won the simulated engagement. And the actual reason Blue was refloated is because these were REAL actual war games in real life with real personnel and real ships and they weren’t just going to tell those guys to pack up and go home they were testing brand new technology and command and control infrastructure. The actual takeaway that Van Ripper was actually butthurt over the army took to heart is that informational warfare and modern communication and interlinked systems are awesome and we need 5x as many radio officers and IT guys and the ability to track and kill people by their cell phones and now the CIA can track your heart rate off your wifi router
>>546297446> It was also one of THE most expensive wargames ever. I don't even know what the hell they spent their money on to come up with that figure if it was all paper and charts.Because the other half was live fire actual ships and men performing the exercises being simulated you grapefruit.
>>546297448I am aware. Still the pricetag seems high if you compare regular exercises like RIMPAC or so that involve more people and more live-fire and it's mostly within training budgets. It seems the MC02 pricetag includes the whole 2 year preparation phase as well. And was the pen and paper aspect of it that each of the simulation locations did everything by hand and fed that into the computer? This would also have explained the simulation limitations as any unconventional tactic would probably not fit into any particular box.
>>546297236>Iran has been preparing for this conflict for 40 years and they got raped, and then re-raped, repeatedly for very little cost.The cost has been very high. The US failed all wargoals except assassinate a few leaders. All for the Regime to continue, for the IRGC and others to continue to attack shipping without needing leadership, communication or radar.>same color of regime, decapitation strike failed to do anything meaningful>IRGC continues to be powerful and influential>shipping through the gulf strangled>economic damage to US consumer because gas jumped 30% from $3/gal to $4/gal, even worse as diesel went from $4 to $6.>loss of credibility with gulf states as they recieved direct attacks to their production and refining>damage and loss of US bases in ME, withdraw from Iraq. Loss of lives, equipment and aircraft.>no reason that Iran cannot continue to build drones and missiles in small bunkers and fire them at hormuz shipping forever.>yemen no better and can continue attacks on shipping and saudi arabia>russia slightly stronger because their source of income (oil/ng) is in demand at a higher price, and Trump puts pressure on Ukraine and lowers sanctions. (And EU pretended to be upset, despite them wanting the same)There's no upside. The only people who benefit are refiners who are far outside the ME and use non-ME crude feedstock. They get higher margins and realistically don't increase production by much.
>>546297447He's a Joe Kent type, he sees some sort of “noble savage” quality in Russian and Iranian ingenuity.
>>546297445The US only destablilized the economy by instigating Iran. Iran is the one shooting blindly at as many ships as they possibly can whenever they can with the explicit purpose of doing any damage they can to everyone. They are not innocent. It is not lost on me that you're shifting all blame off of them including acting like the Houthis are a nothing burger (which begs the question of why Iran invests in them)
>>546297450>The US failed all wargoals except assassinate a few leadersthis is cope
>>546297449Bluefleet was not informed it had been sunk for three hours after it occurred, yes. The main point of the exercise was to stress test systems and concepts that were brand new and completely untested at scale, figure out what broke and when and where, and then work out how to take the military going forward. It was not the biggest by manpower but it was the biggest and most encompassing in scope. And I think you’re maybe getting the wrong idea when I use hyperbole, because it was a very advanced for the day simulation system. It just had limitations and scope that was impossible to really model, and it’s not like the military of today isn’t still using graphing paper. There are just some things either too specific or too slow to model. Van Ripper was not run out of the military, he was allowed to leave because he was old and out of touch and didn’t like technology falling back on failings in Vietnam and thinking the army should get less technological, not more. With the benefit of hindsight any such mentality is clearly just wrong. The biggest failing of the current US military beyond just general graft and scope creep and naked corruption is ending up behind the curve on drones. Which almost everyone in the word ended up being and which Ripper probably would have also been opposed to anyways as he wanted more muhreens less screens. If anything, marines are obsolete now. Heavy shock infantry just die to flying lawn mowers.
>>546297447Van Riper wasn't upset that the fleet was refloated, he was upset about being forced to "command" a fully scripted event afterwards despite having been promised a free hand to run his team however he wanted. Which, yes, does make sense because it wasn't just a wargame but also a military exercise. But instead of lying to him, the exercises should have been separated from the wargame from the start, or they would have told him the wargame was over and then run the exercises. Restarting the wargame and telling him that this time he had to play in a way that ensures that his team loses was a complete fucking sham, and that's why he went crying to the press. Like I said, I make no excuses for him doing that, but he did have reason to be upset. And then afterwards, rather than telling the truth that they decided to run it through by the book afterwards to make sure everyone in the field got the training they needed, the response was to go out and lie about shit like "faster than light motorcycle couriers" when that had nothing to do with Van Riper at all, and was a result of (a) the decision that Blue shouldn't have an overwhelming advantage by being able to read all of Red's communications and (b) the limitation of the sim not being able to natively handle communications delay.
>>546297446>haven't killed americansJust ignore the Americans and other innocent civilians kidnapped and murdered at the concert supporting reconciliation on Oct 7th then sure.
>>546297456I don't consider dual citizens and evangelicals as real americans
>>546297457based
>>546297457>ha ha ha, I was trolling all along!Okay, then. Enjoy getting bombed, dipshit.
>>546297459I'm just chilling in my home, keep seething evangelicuck
>>546297460So why is it wrong to bomb Hamas again when they blindly kill random people irrelevant to the conflict and kidnap elderly and children?
>>546297452And the point is that "Iran shooting blindly" was a predicted outcome of said instigation. They 100% are responsible for every missile they fire or any ship they attack. The US just willfully and knowingly accepted that this would happen, so to pretend the US is fighting Iran "to prevent economic damage" is just a falsehood as the damage hadn't even been done.The Houthis are a nothing burger, especially for the US as not much trade goes through the suez canal to the US. Notice how gas prices didn't go through the roof the past 3 years when ships were taking the long way around africa because of the houthis. They are also the far easier target to deal with compared to Iran if one would choose so. It's completely illogical to 1. think that the houthis are damaging le world economy and then 2. go to war with iran over it when you could also just go to war with yemen instead and get a standing ovation for the effort instead of oil prices going through the roof. Creating strife in two trade chokepoints is worse than one. Simple as.>>546297457based, NTA if it wasn't obvious>>546297456It's completely different for an actor to deliberately target americans and pose a threat to americans in general than "americans" ending up in the crossfire in some other country when they are there on their own free will. The fix is as simple as issuing a travel warning to said country.>>546297461It's wrong for America to spend a single cent on bombing hamas because it doesn't affect the US or it's citizen in a meaningful way. It's wrong for America to go to war with Iran and cite hamas as a reason because they simply aren't a problem for the US.
>>546297457>evangelicals as real americansYou don't consider foundational Americans to be Americans?
>>546297462>t's wrong for America to go to war with Iran and cite hamas as a reason because they simply aren't a problem for the US.We went to war with Iran because (1) they won't stop attacking us and (2) the Jews were about to go all in so it's now or never.
>>546297462>The fix is as simple as issuing a travel warning to said country.The fix is to make sure whoever commits wanton acts of violence against civilians regardless of nation ceases to exist. As an American you live in my world. I should be able to travel anywhere for recreation without repercussions. You acting like violent niggers in your own country is still a problem because you act like violent niggers. Period.
>>546297462>And the point is that "Iran shooting blindly" was a predicted outcome of said instigationso what you're saying is>we knew the psychopath would start firing when we were going to enter his home to arrest him, but we did it anywayand so there is no wrong
>>546297464>won't stop attacking usAgain this isn't true. They haven't attacked the US for forty years and the best people have come up with is some weird game of six degrees of separation with "iranian made" EFPs in Iraq.>the Jews were about to go all in so it's now or neverOk, but then this wasn't about saving the world economy from Iran or dealing with a credible threat. It was about mitigating fallout from a potential response to an israeli attack>>546297465Incredible how the goalposts are not just shifting but in a quantum state at this point.By that logic you need to be at war with: Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Colombia, China and Haiti right fucking now because they're all mistreating Americans in one way or another. >>546297466More like the "psychopath" has a big dog on his porch with a warning sign posted to not trespass, his house is on the other side of the planet and the arrest warrant reads "to stop his dog from biting me". It makes zero sense. And psycho becomes somewhat subjective when one side says "fuck the consequences we're going in, no need to talk to allies btw", and the commander in chief posts insane essays/manifestos on social media where he proclaims he'll end the other sides civilization.
>>546297467The psychopath has trained its dog to kill people, and it did, after which he said "I'm glad it did, and I will continue to train it for the express purpose of killing more people," and we've decided he doesn't get to have nukes.
>>546297311Takes like this completely miss the pointThe US leaders do not care what the cost isDesolation is the goal
>>546297469>The US leaders do not care what the cost isThe people of the US do care what the cost is, and unfortunately for their leaders, the people are still able to choose new ones.
>>546297468>nukesI was wondering when the goalposts would shift there. So would you like to start at the part where Iran poured concrete into the Arak reactor, thus removing their only heavy water reactor and their only plutonium route to the bomb? Unless they want to turn their LWRs on and off and literally scoop scraps of plutonium out of them which would be obvious to even the laziest satellite recon pass.So they were limited to uranium nukes anyway. Which would mean the only thing they can develop relatively quickly is a gun-type nuke like Hiroshima. Which would be so fucking heavy and big that they'd have to put them on heavy truck and drive it to Tel Aviv. And this is only made worse by the fact that their HEU was at 60% instead of weapons grade 80-90%. Any sort of implosion testing would take upwards of a year even under normal conditions. This assumes that they were able to recover the HEU from Natanz and Fordow after the US airstrikes from last year. Just so we're clear: Those facilities didn't just have a bunch of yellow cake sitting in a bucket. Those centrifuges were spinning highly toxic UF6 gas and with the bombing everything from nasty byproducts, potential fires and so on makes only Chernobyl a worse place to grab nuclear material from. And even if they tried we actually have a benchmark under peacetime conditions: Project Sapphire in 1994 had a completely intact facility with no potential for air strikes or anything and it took 500 shipping containers and months of preparation to move 600kg of HEU.Any actual attempt by Iran to breakout toward a nuke would have been clearly visible and confirmed by US intelligence (unlike the claims being made that were actually denied by the US intelligence and the IAEA both).Finally one could argue this war made an Iranian nuke more likely. A younger more radical elite in charge, just got their teeth kicked in. That'd make me focus on getting a nuke ASAP if I was them.
Is there actually just some “Persian” nigger in here trying to pretend Iran hasn’t been a problem to the west for decades?lollmao
>>546297471So Iran made a major mistake when their negotiators walked into the conference and announced they had 460kgs of 60% enriched Uranium before the war during the 11th hour attempts to defuse the situation? Golly, that sure sucks for them that their bragging got taken seriously by the US and Israel because Iran has been quite open about their nuclear ambitions.
>>546297471didnt readyou dont get to have nukeswe said so
>>546297463Most of the evangelicals are post 1885 scandies and other types who moved to the midwest. The Evangelical churches are explicitly not racist. >>546297462>>546297461It's not wrong to bomb Hamas its wrong to do anything which benefits jews at all, including jews in Israel, because they act against American(only whites can be American) interests. A theoretical world could exist where the US murders every mudslime on the planet to seize the mineral resources under their feet, after glassing Israel of course.
>>546297230I think most hate for the guy comes from not so much from himself by the popularization of the incident in question by this faggo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Dolan_(writer) in the formative years of 4chan. You couldn't talk about naval strategy without somebody bringing it up, earnestly or not.
>>546297367>admits he was lying>w-well it doesn’t matter also you’re the shill not me!Just stop using hyperbolic statements and people will stop laughing at you.
>>546297473>quite open about nuclear ambitionsThey repeatedly said they were not building a nuke. But in fairness one can take the fatwa against it and their words with a pile of salt. What's more important is that they didn't have the capability to build a nuke without giving it away by virtue of the HEU disappearing off the radar.>major mistakeThey didn't announce it in the 11th hour. And the fact that they were trying to negotiate since midnight hammer to get this sorted shoult tell you that their ambitions weren't that important to them. They had announced the HEU to the IAEA ages ago, and the earliest potential for HEU existed decades ago when they had proven they had achieved the fuel cycle. Which coincided with the CIA assessing they were in fact not building nukes.The reason we know all this is that Iran was *NOT* hiding a nuclear weapons program. The IAEA safeguards agreement held and accounted for every gram of HEU.That's how we know how much HEU they have and that they hadn't diverted it into a weapons program. Of course in hindsight the Iranians should have not done any of that and raced to the nuke instead, but they were dumb enough to assume that not having nukes and being compliant little boys would save them. (BTW if the US hadn't torn that deal up none of this would have been an issue)
>>546297479>60% enrichment>not intended for a nuclear weapons programAlso, yes, having the negotiator state it at the start of the meeting behind close doors is announcing it
>>546297480Let me ask you this: you want to build a nuke and you clearly have the centrifuges to enrich to 60%. Why would you stop there? Why not run the centrifuges for a tiny bit longer and get *actual* weapons grade uranium that would be much more useful to you? Clearly this was a bargaining chip to bring to the negotiating table.>Also, yes, having the negotiator state it at the start of the meeting behind close doors is announcing it.Attention anon, I am officially announcing last years powerball numbers in this thread: December 31st, 2025 the numbers were 11, 18, 21, 24, 38 and the powerball was 26. It's technically an "announcement", it also has no relevance whatsoever.Here's the actual timeline:>13th of April 2021: Iran announces they will enrich to 60% (sidebar:why announce it if you're trying to break out to a nuke?)>17th of April 2021: Iran starts actually producing 60% HEU at Natanz>31st of May 2021: IAEA reports 2.4kg of 60% HEU>7th of September 2021: IAEA reports the stockpile is now 10kg>4th of November 2021: Iran announced it now has 25kgAnd so on and so forth.Even the 400kg figure was from before midnight hammer:>31st May 2025: IAEA reports 408.6kg>13th of June 2025 440.9kgSo none of these figures were relevant to 2026 negotiations and were known well in advance and this idea that it was announced at the last minute is a lie.
>>546297481Why enrich past 20% if you're not intending to make a nuclear weapon? It turns out retarded brinksmanship is retarded when you've proven yourself to be a nonrational and destructive actor after a year of picking the double down option on every bad decision starting from Oct 8th and every possible chance to disavow your proxies, instead of giving them more weapons and intel to the point they become enough of a pain in the ass the West neuters them, leaving you all alone and without your gray zone threat.
>>546297443Good. Hopefully history will reveal US planning diverged onto some dead-end course and gets black swanned up the ass.
>>546297482>nonrational and destructiveyawn. They've been far more rational than others would have been. See their "retaliation" to the midnight hammer bombing. Anyone even remotely less rational actor would have escalated right then and there.And as per the timeline there was ample time to negotiate even the first few kg's of HEU away. And the US could have just kept the JCPOA and just extended it for a fraction of the cost this war has cost already. The US could have bribed Iran 1 billion USD each year for the next 50 years to stop their nuclear ambitions and it would STILL be cheaper than the war so far has been.>being a pain in the assThey literally weren't. No American gave a fuck about what was going on in Iran until America went to war against it. (Except those who think America is their personal army/piggybank)You could have done the men in black mindwipe thing and removed the knowledge that iran even exists and no american would have noticed the change. That's how relevant Iran is to the security and economy of the US. It only becomes a headline news thing when america decides to waste it's money and arsenal on it.
>>546297484Yeah, no American gave a shit about the Red Sea being closed and then heavily slowed down for 9 months while the USN spent billion of dollars to deal with it. I see we're back again to the Houthis don't exist, and if they did they weren't a problem, and if they were they were solved part of the argument yet again where you pretend like Iran playing the geopolitical game of "I'm not touching you" shouldn't get their ass beat like a redheaded stepchild.
>>546297485You really can't into logic I guess. There's multiple options in the red sea:1. The US doesn't start the Iran war and the ceasefire with the houthis holds2. The houthis permanently close the red sea and America (and everyone else) does anything to stop them.3. The US intervenes again in the red sea to protect shipping. Result: the US incurs the cost and benefits of that operationNow the best option obviously is 1: costs nothing, produces no damage to the US.Now you might think option 2 would be catastrophic, but it really isn't. The French modeled a permanent closure of the Red Sea and came up with a 0.02% loss for large trading economies. For the US that would mean like $6 billion. Chump change. Shipping companies can easily adapt: The red sea/suez route is 11000 NM from China to central europe and takes 48 days, the roundtrip around the cape of good hope is 14500 NM and takes 57 days. The biggest loser ends up being Egypt because they charge the tickets for the suez canal.Option 3 is a tiny bit more interesting because the major issue wasn't so much the Houthis controlling the red sea, but the surprise effect of the initial disruption. If you just accept the closure we end up with option 2. If the US intervenes as it has, we're looking at a bill of 2.5-6 billion USD in costs for the military operation. But the benefit of that protection is estimated at 11-23 billion. Neither of those numbers are stupidly high and at the high end you could also just take the 6 billion loss from option 2 and call it a day. Meanwhile the Iran war not only cost almost $50 billion (not counting expenses related to defending Israel and so on), but it also PRODUCED economic damage to the US in excess of $130 billion. And that's without doing the research going after all the indirect costs and such that the Fed accounted for in their paper.TL;DR: Whether the red sea is closed or open, whether the US Navy patrols it or not, it doesn't matter.
>>546297486>it doesn't matter.So Iran isn't going to charge a "toll" and the Hothis aren't going to shoot and kill random ships?
>>546297487yes my friend, Iran has always been ally to free world, Death to Israel mushballa jallamalla
>>546297487Look at a map. There won't be ships going through the red sea for the Houthis to shoot at if you go with the second option. They'll just go around africa. That's what most shipping companies have already been doing. Now the strait is a separate issue, but the economics make even an Iranian "toll" worth it.The obvious move would still have been to just not start this war and thus have an open strait. But even now consider the oil price is at ~$100 and before the war it was ~$70. So an iranian toll of $10 a barrel would still be cheaper.Any economic argument for this war is retarded. It's a net negative across all fronts for the US.
>>546297455>he had to play in a way that ensures that his team loses was a complete fucking shamIf you actually read the report Red Team did not lose>>546297481>Let me ask you this: you want to build a nuke and you clearly have the centrifuges to enrich to 60%. Why would you stop there? Why not run the centrifuges for a tiny bit longer and get *actual* weapons grade uranium that would be much more useful to you?Let me ask you this: your geopolitical foe has demonstrated willingness to push past peaceful use of nuclear energy, why would you let them have that leverage over you?Everyone understands that trying to pretend to have a gun or brandishing a fake gun is actually just going to push the opponent into reaching for a real gun and firing. You can't rely on half measures.
>>546297490>Let me ask you this: your geopolitical foe has demonstrated willingness to push past peaceful use of nuclear energy, why would you let them have that I'd like to actually have the whole "geopolitical" point spelled out for once. Like is the idea that Iran will blackmail the middle-east with their nuke? Into doing what exactly? With what negative consequence for the american people exactly? Not to mention that you could watch the entire middle-east beg for US nuclear weapons to be stationed there in a week as an insurance policy and you'd be back to a standoff.And I'm not saying to that Iran having a nuke should be accepted as a foregone conclusion. I'm saying if this really was about iranian nukes, considerable ground forces would have been committed to Iran to secure the nuclear sites, US intelligence and the IAEA wouldn't constantly contradict the claims being made around non-existant nuclear weapons programs, and in the time it takes for the Iranians to create a non-deliverable lawn ornament of a nuke the entire world could be prepared and rallied around the cause. So it clearly it isn't about nukes.
>>546297491I don't know what to tell you man. Iran claims its about nukes, America says its about nukes. Only one saying it isn't about nukes is you, and you're a retard who thinks staging nukes around the globe after letting a terrorist funding schizo state develop them is a wise form of deterrent instead of just bombing them before they do something stupid with a bunch of uranium that's been enriched well beyond what you need for legitimate non-weapons based usage. I'd rather not wait for some desert death cult member to set off a dirty bomb before anything is done because neets on 4chinz are concerend about diesel now that their habbeding over gas prices proved a bust.
Is this from /k/? They sound just like ptg
>>546297683Yeah, you'll notice it's full of ZOG shills that dominate /k/. Here we can mock them without being banned.
>lol
>>546297231kek I though "this sounds a lot like a /k/ response" before I saw the question mark flags. No wonder the board is called /k/eddit.