[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/pol/ - Politically Incorrect


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1546073861580.png (1.24 MB, 1240x1031)
1.24 MB PNG
normalfags are going to ban AI like they banned nuclear energy and caused five decades of technological stagnation
>>
>>546356992
Well, more like the companies will just develop it in private while the public is stuck in the dirt
>>
>>546356992
̶n̶o̶r̶m̶a̶l̶f̶a̶g̶s̶
Democrats....ftfy
>>
>>546356992
Good
Then I can buy a gpu and ram
Ban cloud computing.
>>
>>546356992
post five reasons AI should be allowed to thrive, without making any references to culture war nonsense
>>
I hope they ban jews pretending that autocomplete is the same thing as AI.
>>
>>546356992
good, fuck you, you can exert the effort yourself you slob
>>
>>546357166
>>546357224
>you have to justify using that computer software to me >:(
What a couple of absolute ape nigger retards
>>
>>546357092
this is the exact problems with normalfags
just complete disregard of anything but their own selfsh petty wants

you'd cause technological stagnation just to be able to play games a few hours a day with a 5090, then get bored of it after a month and never ue it

when that same chip could have gone in a data centre and be used for automated cancer research, and have 100% 24/7 utilisation.
you'd rather that be illegal so you can get your 2% utilisation more easily
>>
>>546357166
>so jews can still compete despite their numerical disadvantage
>so jews can make more money
>so criticism of jews and israel can be punished
>so jews can make more white men unemployed and destitute
>so jews can remain masters of humanity
>>
>>546357244
You can have your own local ai.
Cloud computing however should be illegal and the punishment should be the death penalty.
You want everyone to own nothing, so you should die, simple as.
>>
If it halts the beast system then maybe that's a good thing.
>>
>>546357296
there's a severe chip shortage

companies like apple locking up production devices to make more shitty consumer devices is making the problem worse
>>
File: IMG_3475.jpg (162 KB, 640x960)
162 KB JPG
Ai is good it’s humans that are the problem
>>
>>546357360
Jensen created AI start ups to back order chips and create an artificial shortage. You should be drawn and quartered in the town square.
>>
File: 1538703244893.jpg (63 KB, 922x900)
63 KB JPG
>>546356992
Luv me egg. Simple as.
>>
File: IMG_3473.jpg (234 KB, 969x632)
234 KB JPG
>>546357453
>pencilslop human “art”
gross
>>
>>546357381
False comparison
>>
>>546357360
And the simple solution to the chip sortage problem.
Ban cloud computing.
No you shouldnt be able to buy up all the components for your faggy datacenter.
>>
>>546357571
there's an even simpler solution
you shut the fuck up and get out of the way
>>
>>546357571
The datacenter isn't faggy. The violent temper tantrum your on is.
>>
This mf doesn't know about the suppressed patents list lmfao
>>
>>546357653
>>546357642
Your cloud computer cant even say nigger.
>Noooo I need my spyware device at a monthly subscription.
Genuinely kill yourself.
>>
>>546356992
If you cared about ai your filename wouldn't be a unix timestamp
>>
>>546356992
Why are we dragging normies (centrists) into what is clearly an issue on the left ?
>>
>>546357508
Can’t tell if glowing shill that still doesn’t understand how to meme or if the AI has really gone rogue and is trying to minimize its costs to life.
>>
>>546356992
i have been preparing explicitly for this, even as a middle class fag. i'm tanking the high GPU costs to get 48gb VRAM on two 3090's and 128gb DDR4 seeing it as an investment in the future. either they don't ban it and i have a decent system to use it especially as local gets better and better, or they do and at least i have the best set up and local models already downloaded that i could want.
if there's any serious movement in that direction i'm probably going to fill my external 14tb drive with every model and accessory i can get my hands on.
though also in reality it is far too late. already way too many people have a passable setup and architecture to train their own, and if they ban it in america they absolutely won't in china or other countries and so people will just get it from there.
>>
>>546357296
>You can have your own local ai.
You can even run a local AI on a phone or SBC. You can run it offline entirely.
It can't be shutdown. The cat is out of the bag and it's pissed as hell

https://github.com/off-grid-ai/OGAM

https://github.com/tsingliuwin/autoclaw
>>
>>546357244
Is the technological stagnation not caused by RAM producers? Would it not be better to spend capital increasing ram and cpu manufacturing in America rather than building datacenters? Or is that a bad use of capital because it lowers the price of ram and cpu so you make everything cheaper?
Does that not mean that by chasing profits we are stagnating technological progress as well?
>>
>>546356992
Just run your own open source model
>>
>>546357912
Thats why they want all the computing components, they dont want you to be able to use computers without their approval.
With our own components anyone can have ai without a monthly subscription and without sending them the data
>>
>>546357912
*the cat*
Nobody is here
>>
>>546357962
We were on an exponential energy growth curve,
then,
the brakes got slammed on it in the 1970s. Right when they banned nuclear energy. Not a coincidence.

Nuclear energy was the prerequisite tech to unlock the next level civilisation.
We've been stuck on the same tech level for 50 years. Abundant, cheap energy would have enabled an endless amount of tech we can't even imagine. Like how gas turbine electrical generation enabled refrigeration with enough electricity generation. Without sufficient electrical generation, refrigeration would have never been invented, or just never deployed on a mass scale.

It would have enabled scaling up heavy industry because energy would no longer have been a bottleneck. It would have enabled scaled up cities, with huge workforces with higher population densities, which in turn enabled even more scaled up industry, and millions of people working specialised roles just in one city. We would be doing mega projects right now, and there's no imagining what else. They took it all from you. A countless litany of tech we would have right now that we can't even imagine.

We've been technologically flat since the 1970s. Innovation has been in efficiency due to the energy bottleneck. It stagnated and crippled our civilisation
>>
>>546357968
>just build your own nuclear reactor
oh
that's illegal
>>
File: 1665412094297843.jpg (16 KB, 450x450)
16 KB JPG
>>546357224
go live with the amish, prude bitch
>>
File: 1793190687384903.png (77 KB, 383x376)
77 KB PNG
>>546356992
>AI is comparable to nuclear energy
>>
>>546358669
It definitely is.

Both are huge technological boons. You can only get datacentres up on grids with a huge amount of excess capacity, like what a nuclear reactor would generate. The whole grid was supposed to be nuclear by the 90s. That would have enabled massive data centres and chip fabs.
>>
>>546358669
The point of his posts is because people already have a bias against nuclear energy as dangerous due to media. He's playing a fake pro nuclear stance in order to make computing sound dangerous by association.
He's a glownigger, its easy to tell because he's not even pro AI in concept, he's pro datacenter and cloud computing.

See >>546358498 as he replys to someone saying he should run his own open source AI with a nonsequiter about how running your own nuclear reactor is illegal. Because thats what he wants for personal computers, because he's a glownigger.
>>
Boyy, I wish, but no, they're just going to make local models illegal because heckin evil hackers o algo, only trusted megacorps are trustworthy
>>
>>546358863
>He's playing a fake pro nuclear stance in order to make computing sound dangerous by association.
you absolute dumb fucking faggot
Nuclear energy is not bad.
It would have been the greatest achievement of our civilisation up until that point but it was completely squandered by retarded fearmongering. Don't you lump me in with these people.
>>
>>546358966
I agree nuclear energy is not bad, but I see exactly what you're doing. You're trying to conflate the two so that people who are anti nuclear become anti computer. Glownigger tricks, your opinions arent your own, you get paid to post here, you are fake.
>>
>>546358829
>You can only get datacentres up on grids with a huge amount of excess capacity
nigger you don't need datacenters to run LLM's lmao.
you can run a 200B quantized MoE local model that is as good as non-pro proprietary models like gemini and GPT on as little as 48gb VRAM and 128gb DDR4.
most serious people and businesses already have way more than that.
there are local models with almost 2 trillion parameters
>>
>>546356992
They won't ban it, they'll regulate it and surveil it and nerf what's available to the public until it's only useful to governments and elites, like they did with the regular interwebs
>>
>>546358863
>>546359036
>he's not even pro AI in concept, he's pro datacenter and cloud computing.
You don't get AI without vast amounts of compute
you're not going to have enough compute with fucking apple mini macs with fucking local generation to change the world

you need the data centres
you need central computing
you need the compute to have 100% utilisation
not distributed in the homes of normalfags with 2% utilisation
This AI models need to be running at 100% 24/7
any less than that is a waste of compute
>>
File: 1747380661770310.png (60 KB, 500x397)
60 KB PNG
>>546359119
you only need a bunch of computer to TRAIN them.
>>
>>546359119
>you need the data centres
>you need central computing
>you need the compute to have 100% utilisation
>not distributed in the homes of normalfags with 2% utilisation
Incorrect, what you want is for kikes to have a monopoly on computing.
You're a glownigger.
>>
>>546356992
Call it an database algorithm, specifically a query-refactored compression scheme. They can't ban adding up.
>>
File: well now.gif (1.58 MB, 320x240)
1.58 MB GIF
>>546359119
lol, lmao.
go to bed Sam
>>
>>546359036
>>546359175
If the compute is just going to end up in some faggot's macbook,
I don't give a shit about the compute. It may as well be thrown in a landfill. it's worse than useless.

For compute to be able to do sweeping changes all over the world, compute has to be centralised in massive datacentres. That's where the compute should be and where it belongs.
>>
>>546357242
>using that computer software
No one is trying to ban local models, now answer anon's question or admit that you're just a shill.
>>
File: 555.jpg (20 KB, 500x313)
20 KB JPG
>>546359256
Sam, go to bed.
>>
>>546359256
>In some faggots computer.
Sam Altman is literally a faggot, like you.
>>
>>546359326
he's quoting exactly what sam altman said and wants to be taken seriously as regards the ideal future of AI as it relates to people, it's incredible
>>
>>546359306
>>546359326
There is a huge compute shortage.
I don't care about stupid petty bullshit.
you can get your consumer toys when the shortage ends
Right now,
we need every bit of compute,
in data centres,
utilised at 100% working on automated cancer research and model improvement.
>>
>>546359381
Its just further proof that he's a glownigger who doesnt have his own opinions.
He's now faking being anti gay in order to try and fit in.
>>
>>546356992
You can’t ban AI
There’s plenty of free models now, literally any faggot with a computer can start selling AI tokens from his basement if he wishes so
>>
>>546359397
Tell your boss, I said you're shit at your job
>>
>>546359437
I was saying the same shit for a long time

Here's a post of mine from 6 months ago

https://archive.4plebs.org/pol/thread/538260609/#538260609
>>
>>546357092
If you ban cloud computing then what are you going to use your ram and gpu for?
There won’t be any new games to play since most of software and game development highly depends on cloud

It is true that you’re a normalfag
>>
>>546359529
>I've been getting paid to post here for 6 months.
That doesnt prove that you arent fake.
Why do you pretend to be anti gay? Just to fit in right? Despite shilling for a faggot's company.
>>
>>546359538
Jesus christ, you AIshill niggers aren't even trying at this point.
I hope the Democrats ban construction of any new data centers and make allocating hardware to data center construction fucking illegal.
>>
>>546359538
If you need to use the cloud you shouldnt be making software, and even worse if your game needs the cloud to run it shouldnt even be released.
>>
>>546359579
I didn't say anything anti gay, faggot
find where
>>
>>546359604
Cool, but say goodbye to your video games then. Enjoy your sega
>>
>>546356992
I'm okay with that. Ergonomic extension-of-the-self technology that allows humans and machines to work in sync with human agency, was always the inevitable path forward for advanced tech.
The way I see it, the AI stuff, while novel and having some use, is the real mark of the luddite.
Any tech that strips human agency that much instead of bolstering it is ultimately doomed to fail.
>>
>>546359397
you are a stupid faggot and are completely wrong.
businesses and research bodies should be given free access to training repositories so that they can train their own, which they largely already do anyway.
you don't need a fucking data center to train models or improve them. they are there to handle traffic mostly and then to train massive general models that are largely unnecessary.
the entire AI industry needs to go in the opposite direction where there are maybe a few massive data centers that do nothing but development, and then everyone else fine tunes those models that are developed in any way they need locally.
>>
>>546359661
Kill yourself, nigger.
>>
>>546359636
Again, normalfag spotted.

Most development tools depend on cloud. Even Git is cloud. How the fuck are you going to code and share code with your team? Through an USB stick?

Off yourself moron
>>
>>546359676
>you don't need a fucking data center to train models or improve them. they are there to handle traffic mostly and then to train massive general models that are largely unnecessary.
Yes you do
Most of the compute is for training, not inference. Training requires huge amounts of compute.
>>
>>546359640
>I didnt say anything anti gay, faggot
LMAO Try calling your gay boss a faggot and see how he responds. You're just further proving yourself to be a paid shill without any of his own opinions.
I hope you get fired for doing such a shit job mr glownigger.
>>
>>546357962
>Would it not be better to spend capital increasing ram and cpu manufacturing in America
They've built an entire TSMC fab in Phoenix since this whole thing started. That'll be your real win in this entire thing since you now have both Intel and TSMC fabs on US soil.
>>
>>546356992
how are we gonna live without cat dancing videos
>>
>>546359734
shut the fuck up you stupid faggot
I didn't even mention gays
you're the one talking about gays
>>
>>546359690 is right
>>546359710 you should kill yourself.
>>
>>546359789
Glownigger melty
>>
>>546359833
So you have no answer?
>>
File: 1794498397545205.png (874 KB, 2200x2164)
874 KB PNG
AI trannies lost. And they'll continue losing.
>>
>>546359864
I already answered you.
If you need to rely on the cloud you shouldnt be making software in the first place.
>>
Without cloud you won’t even be to order food home, as all GPS maps depend on cloud to download the maps to navigate through.

It’s hilarious how technologically illiterate normalfags are
>>
This obsession with AI is part of why Republicans will likely never hold any power in this country ever again, doing a complete 180 on the whole "You will own nothing and you will be happy" thing was one of the dumbest fucking strategies I've ever seen in my life, it pretty much proves without at doubt that they're just controlled opposition.
>>
>>546359960
>Defending cloud computing with uberjeets
Desperate.
>>
>>546357166
China, russia, iran, israel, India
>>
>>546359730
no, fine-tuning multi-terabyte models locally can absolutely be done in any respectable institution. building the foundational model does take a lot as i said, but past the architecture everything else WILL BE DONE locally. that is what is going to happen. you might WANT something else to happen where people don't have computers and everyone just has a square that connects to the good goy cloud, but that is not going to happen.
mankind craves autonomy, and autonomy is the foundation for all development and innovation.
fusion isn't going to be solved in a data center, it will be in a research laboratory running a highly specialized and massive LOCAL LLM
>>
>>546357244
Hey
Basically I'm just not gonna use the GPU
I know.... UGH I know ..... I'm sorry!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It's just that I'm not gonna use it is all
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAHAHHAHAHAHAHA
>>
>>546359919
Then your answer is that nobody should write any software anymore.

Everyone’s code is stored in the cloud, you fucking troglodyte, and it has been like that for a long time.

Every messaging app is on the cloud. Multilayer servers are on the cloud. And your cellphone is partially dependent on cloud. GPS as well.
>>
File: file.png (498 KB, 600x630)
498 KB PNG
>>546359919
>>
Pretty much any major communication system, including bank transactions also go through the cloud.
>>
File: honestly.jpg (52 KB, 714x547)
52 KB JPG
>ctrl+f
>cancer
>3 hits already
Fucking boomers and their dollar-a-(You) Indians. The benefit of nuclear power is measured in gigawatts divided by dollars divided by CO2 emitted. How many cancers has your trillion dollar autocomplete cured?
>inb4 some researchers paid to state that AI helped them on some trial (much the same way that Google and Excel did)
>>
>>546356992
Nuclear energy isn't banned but it must be regulated to shit because it's not as common as it needs to be. Holy shit it's like free unlimited energy.
>>
>>546357166
1. penis
2. penis
3. penis
4. penis
5. penis
>>
>>546360074
Cool pilpul
You know when people say cloud computing they dont mean dedicated servers in multiplayer games.
Yeah yeah "cloud just means someone elses computer" you know thats not whats being discussed.
>>
>>546359998
you're missing the point stupid faggot

fine tuning a model and actually advancing the capabilities of AI are two entirely different computational problems

yes, you can fine-tune models locally using LoRA, QLoRA and other parameter efficient methods
but you're not going to achieve frontier improvements in reasoning, discovery, or autonomous research by fine tuning some fucking model on a workstation.

pretraining, reinforcement learning, synthetic data generation, test time scaling, massive parallel inference, automated evaluations, and running millions of experiments all consume compute.

and the idea that data centres are just there to handle traffic is a joke
inference itself is becoming an enormous source of compute

a AI system isn't just a specialised LLM sitting in a laboratory answering questions

it's potentially thousands of agents working in parallel, generating hypotheses, running simulations, testing results, evaluating failures, and iteratively improving their models.

not one fucking computer in a lab

you want thousands of concurrent experiments, simulations, optimisation processes and reasoning trajectories running continuously.

you can pool tens of thousands of accelerators, exploit high bandwidth interconnects, distribute workloads across the cluster, and dynamically allocate compute wherever the marginal return is highest.

instead of having millions of isolated computers sitting idle most of the day.

the objective should be to maximise useful FLOPs delivered per dollar and keep expensive accelerators operating at the highest practical utilisation.

and if your respectable research institution has a massive local GPU cluster with the infrastructure to run all of this, congratulations, you've essentially built a fucking data centre.

the entire point is to maximise the amount of useful computation. not to distribute hardware inefficiently because you have some ideological obsession with local computing
>>
>>546360355
>ideological obsession with local computing
Lol you sound like a communist, people like owning things, who would have thought?
>>
>>546360355
>not to distribute hardware inefficiently because you have some ideological obsession with local computing
The more you post shit like this, the more I want AI and datacenters banned, and it has the exact same effect on everyone else as well. Your life is inefficient, so you should be fucking killed for the good of the world.
Thank god you autists don't understand how optics work, otherwise I might be worried.
>>
AI? You mean SI?
>>
>>546360540
if you're a capitalist you should want resources to be efficiently allocated

if you only want to pay $500 for a chip,
but there's a datacentre company that would pay $50,000 for the chip. that data centre should get it, not you.
the communist thing is you demanding to be sold chips below market prices
>>
>>546360657
>The more you post shit like this, the more I want AI and datacenters banned
Yep, he really sucks at his job.
I'd also add that DRM should be banned even tho thats alot less likely to happen.
>>
>>546360355
i'm saying it's going to be both you dumb fuck and it's not going to be one big data center, far from it.
think of the automotive industry, and consider how little of that technology is the fucking factory or massive company making the cars. are they big and important? no shit they are the foundation of the industry. are they the entirety of car use? transportation? modification? repair? no. looking at the technology you realize the manufacturers make up an unbelievably small portion of what the automobile is in society.
look at it this way: the massive data centers smash their shit together to develop better and better agents, where before a task that would take 10,000 agents only takes 100. the fusion research labratory takes that new 100 agent design and trains them specifically on the massive repositories of information they need as its foundation and conduct their research off their own "data center" they have at the university.
you're stuck on the idea that the only things that have significance or function in the world and future of AI is some massive multi-million GPU town sized data center and that is flat out fucking wrong.
another angle you haven't considered but is the same coin but a different side is information itself. should all information be collectivized into massive data centers?
owned by who?
do you think businesses like weapons research, international law firms with cases that have huge geopolitical implications, etc are going to let someone else have their fucking classified data on their servers?
you probably do because you are actually that puritanical about this collectivist jewish dogma around AI
>>
>>546360715
Capitalists and communists sound more and more alike every day. I'm Natsoc.
>>
>>546360779
see my post about nuclear energy

if it weren't banned,
car factories would be as big as large cities
car factories are small and distributed
because they are energy intensive and bottlenecked by energy
>>
File: IMG_6160.jpg (179 KB, 1242x1229)
179 KB JPG
>>546356992
They won’t, scumbags like Dario are saying AI needs to be regulated because they intend to make it so the plebs can NEVER access frontier models and that the government is their only customers. AI industrial complex basically, I cheer on China, they’re the closest we’ll get to open sourcing AI
>>
>>546356992
Difference is nuclear can't be sent to our countries over long distances from places where they don't give a fuck like say china but in theory a data center can wire you tokens from china
>>
>>546361091
>if it weren't banned,
>car factories would be as big as large cities
>car factories are small and distributed
you are completely fucking retarded, gonna stop here rather than waste my time spoon feeding the countless actual fucking reasons car factories aren't the size of cities nor would ever be the size of cities even if it were allowed.
>>
>>546361263
materials,
labour,
energy,
and all other inputs into factories are scarce because of the energy bottleneck

The energy bottleneck is the cause of it all for why factories can't scale.

with enough energy, you could scale a city to house a billion workers.

Energy is the common bottleneck for all the factory inputs
and if you're going to say some other input I didn't mention,
energy is the botleneck to that as well

so yes, it's because they banned nuclear energy in the 70s
>>546358239
>>
>>546361408
Should people have access to personal vehicles or should we be more (((efficient))) and have every car be a self driving taxi?
Because thats your argument for computing.
>>
>>546356992
Worse, they're gonna make AI unusable by putting so many restrictions on it that even the simplest of requests will throw up a flag about the question or topic being problematic.
And it's already started.

Normalfags ruin everything.
>>
>>546357244
when AI solves corrupt HR departments maybe I'll care
>>
>>546358239
>It would have enabled scaled up cities, with huge workforces with higher population densities, which in turn enabled even more scaled up industry, and millions of people working specialised roles just in one city.
Fuck you. This sounds like some kind of hellish bugman existence. I'm glad you faggots have gotten overconfident and gone completely mask off. It's gratifying watching this anti-human garbage getting hard rejected everywhere you try to push it.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.