[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/pol/ - Politically Incorrect


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


Not using Hydrogen as fuel is one of the greatest crimes in the history of mankind.

All the debates about climate change and carbon emissions could have been concluded decades ago by building electrolyzers and fueling stations.

Hydrogen creates abundance of fuel and thus low prices for transportation, farming, heating.

People opposing hydrogen, such as Elon Musk, should be labeled enemies of mankind.
>>
it's a bit finnicky
>>
>>546396123
Water vapors are green house gases,
moreover hydrogen from leaks is going straight into space.
If you're bitching because of water and data centers- world wide hydrogen economy would be much more worse.
>>
>>546396123
Fuel hydrogen comes from cracking water. A company that produces hydrogen can technically pick any source, whether sewage or ocean. What they will realistically pick is the source of the freshest water they can find, so they don't have the expense of dealing with disposal of the extras. Corporations are in it for money. If everything ran on hydrogen, you would compete with your car for fresh drinking water.
>>
File: 69825472493875243.png (244 KB, 500x555)
244 KB PNG
>>546396123
Thank the Jews. Yet another problem caused by kikery.
>>
>>546396123
Hydrogen is a glorified battery.
>>
Can't have degrowth if you have limitless, clean, free energy.
>>
>>546396349
watervapor can be collected and used for new fuel

>>546396424
a single 3mw wind turbine can generate over a metric ton of hydrogen per day

>>546396635
batteries need to be charged, which creates high demand on the grid
millions of cars recharging will break the grid
batteries tend to spontaneously combust (thermal runaway)
batteries will create mountains of toxic landfill
>>
>>546396635
A reasonably efficient battery, but also a little more than a mere "fire hazard".
The main problem is its low density and propensity to pass through solid substances, or embrittle them, meaning it needs to be compressed, which in turn requires cryogenic temperatures.
>>
>>546396796
>batteries need to be charged, which creates high demand on the grid
Almost like electrolysis, eh?
>batteries tend to spontaneously combust (thermal runaway)
Compared to exploding (hydrogen explosion)?
>>
File: 1790091864408791.jpg (136 KB, 960x940)
136 KB JPG
>>546396830
metal hydrides store hydrogen at ambient pressure and temperature
it stores more hydrogen than liquid hydrogen
no embrittlement no leakage
fraunhofer developed a paste that releases hydrogen by adding water
>>
>>546396932
>Almost like electrolysis, eh?
no, it's a calculated load
electrolysis creates hydrogen 24/7 and the hydrogen can be stored, creating a surplus of fuel
>>
>>546396258
Thread
>>
>>546396796
The wind turbine generates electricity, that is used to turn clean water into hydrogen and oxygen. You would be better off just using the electricity without the hydrogen middleman using up the water.
>>
File: 1794339473486628.webm (3.7 MB, 1080x1440)
3.7 MB
3.7 MB WEBM
>>546396932
>Compared to exploding (hydrogen explosion)?
hydrogen tanks do not spontaneously combust meanwhile battery fires have become such a problem that they have to develop means like webm related
>>
File: 1790091777312110.jpg (54 KB, 960x517)
54 KB JPG
>>546397162
hydrogen created by wind turbines/solar power can be stored, creating a surplus of fuel
>>
>>546396976
But such a drive system including fuel cells and so has no advantage in energy density to a li-ion system, at least at the scale of personal vehicles.
>>
>>546397397
Water is not infinite.
>>
File: OIP-2020635190.jpg (46 KB, 474x570)
46 KB JPG
>>546397451
hydrogen powered vehicles keep winning guinness world records
>>
>>546397517
Anyone can buy one of those.
>>
File: 1790088622912273.jpg (116 KB, 1200x800)
116 KB JPG
>>546397504
this car drove more than 2,500 km at 45km/h on 1kg of hydrogen

imagine an ebike or scooter with that range
>>
>>546396123
there's hydrogen in this bussy you little faggot.
>>
>>546396796
>watervapor can be collected and used for new fuel >>546396424
>>
>>546396123
>Not using Hydrogen as fuel is one of the greatest crimes in the history of mankind.
oil is free you just have to dig it out of the ground
hydrogen requires electrolysis or burning stuff or chemical bond release, all of which require more energy than you get back by making hydrogen. About the only thing it is good for is spacecraft
>>
>>546397635
Imagine 1 billion humans, turning drinking water into fuel for homes and vehicles.
>>
>>546397504
ocean water can be desalinated
water from fuel cells can be used to make new hydrogen
>>
>>546397772
imagine 1 billion people recharging their BEVs
>>
>>546397867
imagine 1 billion people in this bussy.
>>
>>546397805
No energy producer is interested in the expense of dealing with salt. They will want clean uncomplicated water, just like the data centers do. The stockholders of the corporation will force them to use fresh water, no matter how anyone feels about it.
>>
File: 1794231323709345.webm (2.81 MB, 1248x720)
2.81 MB
2.81 MB WEBM
>>546397926
>bussy
>>
>>546397948
now we're talking about the enemies of mankind
>>
>Alpine Alpenglow Hy6
>3.5l V6 engine
>twin-turbo charged
>740 HP (544 kW)
>fueled by hydrogen
>>
File: 1794137161728042.jpg (482 KB, 1920x1080)
482 KB JPG
>'61 chevy impala with V8 engine
>fueled by hydrogen
>>
>>546397805
Ocean water can be distilled also by parabolic solar cookers.

China and Nevada had made solar power plants off this concept of using mirrors to direct the solar rays to heat up a medium to generate steam to spin turbines.

The same concept can eliminate the grid tie and be used to isolate hydrogen itself for private use.

Sounds like a waste though because allot of energy goes into cryogenics for hydrogen storage
>>
>>546398512
hydrogen can be bound to magnesium creating a powder that can be stored at ambient pressure & temperature
no need for cryogenics
>>
>>546398652
>doesn't know about ammonia as a hydrogen transport which holds more hydrogen than liquid hydrogen and is transported easily daily
>>
>>546398790
true
i prefer magnesium hydride because once the hydrogen is released the magnesium can be used to store more hydrogen and the process requires less energy than cracking ammonia
>>
>>546398652
That's good for portability and on-demand usage, but the production still has an energy factor. Even though I do feel hydrogen paste or hydrogen pucks should be a market entirely i dont think it's feasible to outright replace entire energy dependent markets like cars or airplanes
>>
>>546399182
the energy factor becomes redundant when you realize that hydrogen gets produced 24/7 and stored
every town could produce more hydrogen than they can spend
>>
>>546397593
anyone can buy hydrogen fuel cell vehicle but their means of refueling it are very limited so they will not buy it
and thats on purpose
>>
>>546398790
ammonia looks very interesting though
>>
>>546396123
Hydrogen:
- Low energy density, requiring large fuel tanks running at high pressures to store it.
- Embrittles and seeps through metals, because naked protons are so small they can pass through solid objects.
- Requires one-tenth of the electrostatic spark (ignition) energy to ignite compared to traditional hydrocarbons.
- Broad volumetric concentration range (4% to 75%, petrol is 1.5% to 7.5%) as it can explode at almost any oxygen density, whereas petrol or diesel ignite and burn.
- Hydrogen flames are virtually invisible in daylight and burn with high-velocity laminar flame speeds, increasing the risk of detonation if trapped in confined spaces.
>>
File: 1774104193147309.png (1.48 MB, 1200x1464)
1.48 MB PNG
>>546396424
>Fuel hydrogen comes from cracking water.
that's a meme way of making hydrogen
most of it comes from methane
>>
>>546401941
i would add very expensive equipment to produce, purify filter and compress as well as store gaseous hydrogen - that needs total rebuild of expensive parts every few years because of embrittlement...
its opposite to cheap - its currently the most expensive fuel you can use today to power a car... and its effectively a waste product of natural gas processing....
>>
>>546402945
Hydrogen simply doesn't work for these purposes on this planet.

However, hydrogen need not be integrated as a direct fuel or storage medium. Instead, hydrogen can be used as a transient (zero-storage) chemical intermediary for the production of e-fuels / e-hydrocarbons/oils/lubricants.

Hydrogen would need to be produced and consumed on-demand via the SOEC stacks and routed directly into the Fischer-Tropsch reactors alongside captured CO/CO2.
The gas is consumed almost as fast as it is generated, the active internal inventory (hold-up volume) within the piping and reactors at any given second is relatively low.

Alternatively, for intermediate buffering, a modest buffer storage (a few hours of production capacity in high-pressure or cryogenic pressure vessels) is kept on-site to handle load-shifting. Or you look to avoid load shifting at the planet altogether.

Mitigation architecture:
- Open-air modular layout where e-fuel synthesis modules are engineered as open-air, skid-mounted skiffs. Hydrogen is 14 times lighter than air, atmospheric leaks would immediately rise upward and disperse into the atmosphere.
- Zero-confined spaces where gas could pool under a ceiling. Also, use continuous forced ventilation and high-set catalytic hydrogen sniffers.
- Have all electrical arrays, pumps, and valves within the hazardous zones carry the highest explosion-proof ratings to eradicate stray static or spark sources.
- Forge all piping and vessels from austenitic stainless steels or aluminum-alloy barriers, which are engineered specifically to prevent hydrogen embrittlement under high-pressure or high-temperature steam conditions.

The risk is reduced by treating hydrogen as a tightly controlled, high-velocity intermediate fluid rather than a static bomb, keeping the architecture open-air and modular.

All of which goes into e-fuel production.
>>
>>546401941
hydrogen can be stored in solid state as a powder or paste

meaning no embrittlement, no leakage, no high pressure, no cryogenics
>>
>>546404483
Solid-state hydrogen storage varies in maturity, reliability, and sustainability depending on the material class.

Low-temp metal hydrides are commercially proven for niche stationary and industrial uses, complex hydrides and porous materials (MOFs) remain largely experimental in the lab stage.

They also have yet to be determined lifespans for the newer materials (complex hydrides), and the material sourcing is extensive despite attempts to simplify it.

Basically, it's unproven at worst and niche at best.

Your proposed use-case for hydrogen simply doesn't work on planet Earth. You need to use it as an intermediary.
>>
>>546405180
>Low-temp metal hydrides are commercially proven for niche stationary and industrial uses
exactly, they have been proven
but they can be used for more than just niche uses
vehicles for example
>>
>>546397770
You also need energy to extract oil. Nowadays to extract 2 barrels, you need to waste one. But yea, hidrogen right now is more expensive
>>
>>546405566
>hidrogen right now is more expensive
on purpose
the technology for producing a surplus of hydrogen existed decades ago
>>
>>546405495
Using hydrogen as such is as stupid as using oil as such. Both result in the same problem.

Look into e-fuel. It was invented more than a century ago now, right around where big oil took off. If you consider who it was invented by and how things would be different if it were scaled, then it makes you see WW1 and WW2 a little differently.

Some basic math:

At a conservative 15 kWh per liter (15 kWh/L), one e-fuel node supplied with 195 MW / 4,680 MWh / 4,680,000 kWh per day can yield a baseline of 300,000 litres per day.

Reducing it to 10 kWh/L would allow for a 195 MW powered node to yield 468,000 liters of e-fuel per day. One e-fuel node outputting 300,000-450,000 liters of fuel per day would cover 50,000-70,000 people.

Baseline 300,000 litres via 195 MW:
50,000 people require 1 node.
1 million people require 20 nodes.
100 million people require 2,000 nodes.
500 million people require 10,000 nodes.

Converting electricity into chemical bonds (power-to-liquid / PTL) incurs a thermodynamic tax compared to extracting ready-made oil out of a pressurized underground reservoir. However, that inefficiency ceases to be a liability and becomes an intentional design feature.

Power-to-liquid (PTL) e-fuels are thermodynamically expensive and inherently inefficient on a net-energy basis, but their production remains worthwhile simply because it reduces the need for oil.

The inefficiency is managed and weaponized by the 195 MW baseload provided by the closed-loop e-fuel node, which is decoupled from market externalities and yet integrated with the synthetic hydrocarbon chain.
>>
>>546397948
You need a very clean water, so you need to run it through filters and demineralize, or deionize. Essentially the same thing as any desolination plant does. A regular groundwater or lake/river water still has a lot of mineral that have to be remowed. Even rain water still contains minerals.
>>
>>546399034
You still need a lot of energy both to combine hydrogen with magnesium and to release hydrogen.
>>
>>546398790
Ammonia doesn't contain more energy or hydrogen than liquid hydrogen...
It's the best way to store hydrogen and to use it, but none of what you wrote is true.
>>
>>546400001
It doesn't tho. No windmill and no solar panel work 24/7. Electrolizers for hydrogen production usually run for 6 hours on a good day.
>>
>>546396123
>I always wanted a minor fender bender to take me out with half of the residential block the thread
>>
>>546405747
You do realize that electeolizers cost money and have to be replaced, as well as inverters to run them?
>>
>>546402308
>we can use hydrogen to reduce emissions
>where do we get the hydrogen? why, from emissions of course
>>
>>546396123
>electrolyzers
which require....?
>>
>>546396123
You are retarded.
Retard.

> We already don't have enough electricity
> It would come from fossil energy except for very few places (deserts, iceland)
> Hydrogen takes up a lot of space, so it is annoying
> Batteries are just better for the vast amount of applications and we would be stuck with useless infrastructure we just build.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.