>Well-regulatedWhy do these two words makes the Republitard seethe?
>>546413342Looks like you're the one seething.
>>546413342They don’t. Shall not be infringedCope seethe and dilate
>>546413342Why are you a retarded faggot?
>>546413342They don't because you have to have the right to own guns in the first place to have a well regulated militia.
>>546413342>Well-regulatedlooks like you don't understand what that means lmao
>>546413508This>Only well regulated Militia can have guns! How do you start a militia without guns?
>>546413342
>>546413342because its one of the few words they can read
Oh another leftist pretend they don’t know what you’re talking about disingenuous argument. Here they pretend Scalia didn’t prove what this meant in his brilliant ruling Heller v DC. Why can’t leftists conduct discourse in good faith?https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep554/usrep554570/usrep554570.pdf
>>546413342Because you don't know what "well-regulated" even means, faggot. "Well-regulated" was a common phrase from that time that just means "good".
>>546413342>Why do these two words makes the Republitard seethe?Not as much as "free white person" makes every Amerilard seethe
>>546413562>>546413562Leftshits don't read, and function purely on emotions. It was ruled in court by SCOTUS that the people is "the militia". The debate is over.
>>546413670We were once a proper country
>>546413605>Why can’t leftists conduct discourse in good faith?Because if they did, they would lose everything since there is nothing good about any sort of leftism.
>>546413647No. It meant that the arms should use a common caliber to ease supply restrictions so they wouldn't have to scrounge up a hundred different sizes of balls. As well as having regular supplies and equipment, such as packs, mess kits, etc. So equipping everybody would be easier.It didn't mean tons of red tape to buy a gun.
>>546413342>militiawhy did you leave out how it is to be regulated?If the government can use it so can you, that is the intetion
>>546413427>>546413445Well regulated militia.It's the militia that's regulated.
>>546413952>expend enormous amounts of energy in talmudic dispute over reading the minds of ancient founding faggots on guns>carefully ignore their extremely clearly stated views on which races could be american
>>546413342But are guns not already well regulated?
In the Revolution the most effective troops were the Mountainmen recruited as freelancers, they were allowed to NOT join the army, operate according to their own schedules and chains of command, got extra pay (3x the pay) etc. because these were experienced mountain men and Indian fighters (AND fuckers) who were much more effective than the line-formation doofuses of the day, who were basically not trained in doing more than regulation exercises involving loading and firing their weapons and then charging in for bayonet fighting.But these mountain men were irregular and each brought their own gun, so they were much harder to equip. They didn't like cotton or woolen uniforms, they liked buckskins. Etc.It was a problem so that's why they wanted a well regulated militia, rather than what the Mountain men were, irregular.
>>546413584this
>>546413342“Well regulated” didn’t mean the same thing in 1790 it means today.What it DIDNT mean was regulated by the government, but that individuals should have an orderly , well equipped militia by and for individuals to be called up.The “bill of rights” was about individual rights, not any government right.
>>546414268In practical effect it meant the militia should have boots, coats, a pack, a cook pot, and a rifle in one of the common calibers of the day. Today it means you should have a rifle in 5.56 or 7.62 NATO, or .30-06, a shotgun in 12 gauge, and a handgun in 9mm NATO or possibly .45ACP.
>>546414107>In the Revolution the most effective troops were theFrench
>>546413342"Well-regulated" is a synonym for "bad-ass"
>>546413342>JUST GIVE UP YOUR GUNS, WHY DON'T YOU TRUST US? WE WANT TO HELP YOU, WE CARE ABOUT YOU, WHY WON'T YOU TRUST US? WHY WON'T YOU LET US?Shit I don't know, maybe because trust is a hard-won commodity and giving up your ability to defend yourself is non-negotiable when the average Leftist talking point is to remove any and all law enforcement?
>>546413342You are a dissimulating bitch.
>>546414505This, op should develop an understanding of the English language. Nigger
>>546413342>Right of the people.Why can't you read?
>>546414493Funny you don't mention Federalist #29>If a >well-regulated militia >be the most natural defense of a free country, it ought certainly to be under the regulation and at the disposal of that body which is constituted the guardian of the national security. If standing armies are dangerous to liberty, an efficacious power over the militia, in the body to whose care the protection of the State is committed, ought, as far as possible, to take away the inducement and the pretext to such unfriendly institutions. >To oblige the great body of the yeomanry, and of the other classes of the citizens, to be under arms for the purpose of going through military exercises and evolutions, as often as might be necessary to acquire the degree of perfection which would entitle them to the character of a >well-regulated militia, >would be a real grievance to the people, and a serious public inconvenience and loss. It would form an annual deduction from the productive labor of the country, to an amount which, calculating upon the present numbers of the people, would not fall far short of the whole expense of the civil establishments of all the States.Huh, almost like it means something like "a standing army in regular training"...
>>546413342XX XYWhy do these 2 letters make the Democrats seethe?
>>546414581You won't do shit anyway. The only thing you'll ever do with your gun is kill yourself with it. Even Britain is better at mass protests and resisting a shit government than Americunts.
>well regulated was defined definitively in Bill and Teds excellent adventure
>>546414874Are we just jealous I'll have a gun to blow my brains out with to escape this miserable fucking existence?
>>546413562with a militia loicense
>>546414942The English aren't happy unless they are miserable.
>>546413342Well regulated as in the militia is well trained not "hey let's use pilpul to subvert the meaning of the constitution" you penny clipping yid
>>546414031They're talking about the militia because the Founding Fathers viewed maintaining a standing army as a lean towards tyranny. That's what's regulated. As far as the right to bear arms goes: shall not be infringed. Simple as.
>>546415027It didn't take them long to realise that militias were shit and they needed a standing army.
>>546415098doesn't your country exist solely because people were required by law to practice longbow archery?
>>546414780The Federalist Papers are arguments to convince citizens to ratify. They aren't the constitution itself.
>1pbtid >inb4 2pbtid replying to this
>>546415213Written by the same people and use language in the same way. "Well-regulated militia" means "standing army", it's right there/
>>546415195That's the reason the French nobility ceased to exist. Vikings teaching us ships is why we exist.
>>546413342a well-regulated militia means they got their shit together. the opposite would be: "A drunken, retarded, ill-equipped militia...
>>546415315No it doesn't. It's specifically differentiating itself from a standing army.
>>546415344Regardless, hardly a point against a militia's value
>>546415423The white house being burned down because the militia ran away is.
>>546413342>militiaWhy do these one words make the federal government shit and piss
>>546415423He doesn't know what he's talking about. A militia isn't the same thing as a standing army and if such evolves into one there is a specific rationale in the Federalist Papers that an armed citizenry checks it (thereby the "shall not be infringed" is referring to the right to bear arms and there's no argument that such is restricted to the militia).
>>546415400It's an army made up of called-up citizens in a state of training. Federalist #29 is arguing against the idea that a militia would be dangerous.>To oblige the great body of the yeomanry, and of the other classes of the citizens, to be under arms for the purpose of going through military exercises and evolutions, as often as might be necessary to acquire the degree of perfection which would entitle them to the character of a>well-regulated militia,>would be a real grievance to the people, and a serious public inconvenience and loss. It would form an annual deduction from the productive labor of the country, to an amount which, calculating upon the present numbers of the people, would not fall far short of the whole expense of the civil establishments of all the States.It does not mean "people with guns".
>>546413342> Independent Militiaswhy does this make glowies like OP seethe
>>546415582It means exactly the people with a fuck ton of guns, fuck off pansy
>>546413342Because that’s not what well-regulated meant when it was written./thread/all fields
>>546413342I raped OP.AMA
>>546415620So you can't read.
>>546413952I read that it meant “I’m working order” but I guess technically what you are saying would fall under that
>>546415666When did I become a supreme court justice? No I'm american
>>546415582>Federalist #29 is arguing against the idea that a militia would be dangerousNo, retard. It's about why a standing army is dangerous and, again, this isn't necessarily the same thing as a milita. 29 argues that there should be a small standing army and affirms the right of the general populace to also bead arms. 46 argues pretty much the same thing. They are not arguing the right to bear arms is restricted to a militia that is well regulated.
>>546413342>Why do these two words makes the Republitard seethe?Why do the Elites care so much what firearms we have? they have tanks and bombs en Sheet.
>>546415784Because trannies.
>>546415696No, it isn't. >It's about why a standing army is dangerous and, again, this isn't necessarily the same thing as a milita.No, it's an argument for the regulation of militias.>and affirms the right of the general populace to also bead arms.Where does Federalist #29 say that? Quote it.
>>546414780The necessity for people to be able to freely form a militia is the justification for the right to bear arms, not a limitation on it, you illiterate moron.
>>546415809Mentally ill people get guns, says on the paper
>>546413342why is it so hard for chuds to read and understand what they read?
>>546415832I think it would be obvious the general populace would have guns because they have bears and shit in the usa.
>>546413342>republitards seethe>it's been the sissycrats melting down this whole time about muh gun lawsI don't think you understand how this works. I can go buy a gun right now. And you can't stop me.
>>546413342>functioning and maintained with weapons up to standard K. This thread is over. Bye
>>546415809>Because trannies.That the Government made and also don't do anything about.
>>546415894And injuns
>>546415857If you don't bother to use your guns to defend your borders you probably should have some restrictions on who buys them when they get there.
>>546416023That's the Fed's fault. If this was actually the US every illegal would get a 50 bmg gift basket
>>546415849There's no such thing as people freely forming a militia in the founding conception. A militia is something the state forms and people are drilled and trained in a few times a year.Which militia are you a member of?
>>546415832>No, it isn't.Yes, it is. Maintaining a standing army was a huge concern for the Founding Fathers because they're tools of tyranny. A militia is not the same thing as a standing army. Their command and control is different. The Federalist Papers are arguing in favor of a small standing army that could be overpowered by militia and/or armed citizenry. Again, they are not arguing the right to bear arms is restricted to a militia that is well regulated.
>>546416075No the militia is formed by the local community. The problem is that gunfags assume that this organization will be spontaneous. Like one day everyone will wake up and realize "today is the day!"But in reality-land, it doesn't work like that. If the gun rights were tied to organized militias instead of free-ownership, then we'd be in a far better place. The militias would be huge, and under that leadership you could realistically organize and oppose the feds.
>>546416075Posse comitatus is a thing and vigilantism isn't exactly unheard of in the US
>>546416125They don't even mention a right to bear arms. A militia is something that's assembled and regulated by the government.>Little more can reasonably be aimed at, with respect to the people at large, than to have them properly armed and equipped; and in order to see that this be not neglected, it will be necessary to assemble them once or twice in the course of a year.
>>546413342Progressive Liberal-Socialist here.It doesn’t make republicans seethe. They don’t need to. “Well-regulated militia” doesn’t matter. The conservative SCOC .. who claim to be constitutionalists respecting founders words and intent and constantly virtue signalling about it … completely cut it out of their substantial and precedential judgement, ignored federalist papers and 2A debates, inDistrict of Columbia v. Heller (2008), and produced a wholly political majority opinion of such convoluted and disingenuous and dishonest interpretative jurisprudence as to make R.vWade blush. It’s so bad, and nonsensical, that Justice Antonin Scalia writing for the majority actually misquoted a key historical term that originality jurists used (Blacktone) “dangerous or unusual weapons" as “dangerous and unusual weapons." … that misquote becoming the basis of a judicial test of what weapons may be banned (private ownership of Nuklear, biological weapon, or Tank, is banned because it is “dangerous and unusual.” If it was “dangerous or unusual, the breadth of potential banned weapons expands significantly).All in all the hypocrisy is staggering.
>>546416159The idea back then was that states would appoint officers and train members while Congress would arm them and had the ability to call upon them to serve in the national interest. The militia is comprised of ordinary citizens. The idea is that a militia is well regulated AND ordinary citizens have the right to bear arms in general.
>>546416299>the Supreme Court made up retarded shitYes
>>546416262>They don't even mention a right to bear armsThe amendment they're discussing does, retard. >A militia is something that's assembled and regulated by the governmentYes, retard. HOWEVER, the point is that it isn't a standing army. Again, they are not arguing the right to bear arms is restricted to a militia that is well regulated. That's not what the constitution says and that isn't the rationale underpinning the Federalist Papers.
>>546416357>AND ordinary citizens have the right to bear arms in general.Yeah but there is an optimum level of gun ownership that balances safety and self defense. Even some european countries have it. The problem is today, gun lobbies are even opposing things like basic background checks, basic registration. If you had big, powerful, well organized militias, you wouldn't be counting on some spontaneous organization of citizens to fight the Feds. So you wouldn't be the grim reaper pushing us into these crazy unsafe situations.If you want to openly carry heavy weapons, you should be forced to join a militia, get trained, learn tactics, be vetted as a responsible member of society.
>>546416502That's not on the paper you commie
>>546416536Woops wrong field
>>546413342The people have the right to weapons analagous to their government's armaments.CIWS, anti-materiel weapons, air and land platforms and nuclear ordnance should be freely obtainable, prove me wrong fagets.
>>546416590>The people have the right to weapons analagous to their government's armaments.But you could have this through a militia. The militia would be organized, disciplined. There would be checkes and oversight, everyone would be vetted. Those people could be afforded the privilege of owning heavier weaponry. Practicing tactics with tanks, RPG's, maybe even mines and drones. The problem is when you decide that average citizens should have this armament, under the delusion that one day, all these people will "wake up" and spontaneously organize together, like a school of fish. It's just not gonna happen like that. I don't know why people keep believing this idea.
>>546416671Locke said everyone gets a squad automatic weapon and claymore, like the angles in their perfected naturalism
>>546416741Locke said that anarchy creates the need for power. So the more anarchy, the more power is strengthened.When everyone is armed, you create the situation of "anarchy" which ironically makes the central government far more powerful. Whereas if you had organized militias, you could see these communities becoming more self-reliant, more distant from Washington. They would provide stability and order, and community connection.
>>546416921>LockeSorry I meant Hobbes, I think
>>546413993Self regulated you retard that’s what a militia is by definition
>>546416947Yeah I was about to say, locke would love some anarchy right now
>>546413342Well regulated also implies it being capable.>not too strong, not too weakMeaning cruise missiles should be freely available for purchase, but not nuclear warheads.
>>546413342ah yes because the founding fathers surely meant well regulated as in regulated by law the government comes up with that infringe on the very right they held the most sacred and literally wrote papers on after the fact saying that this right needs to be used to kill tyrannical governments trying to infringe upon your rightsyou know, the same people they JUST slaughtered and overthrewdumb faggot op
>>546416502>Yeah but there is an optimum level of gun ownership that balances safety and self defenseSHALL. NOT. BE. INFRINGED.