[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/pol/ - Politically Incorrect


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: images.png (21 KB, 304x360)
21 KB PNG
NATO was largely created in the 1940s to prevent a German resurgence. The USSR was also considered a threat, but at that point, only the United States had nuclear weapons, and it was clear that if anything happened, the Russians would simply be bombed. By 1949, when the Russians first tested their first nuclear bomb, the United States had already conducted six training tests and two live tests. Germany, however, was feared, both because of its rapid resurgence in the 1930s and the phenomenal effectiveness of the Wehrmacht.

Therefore, the United States had well-founded concerns that the Germans, if left unchecked, would rebel even more viciously. When the Russians also acquired nuclear weapons and it became clear that the carnage in Europe could erupt again, after some reflection, it was decided to revive the Wehrmacht. Essentially, the Bundeswehr is the direct successor and heir to the Wehrmacht: the core of its officers and senior generals were veterans of World War II. The Americans revived them because they knew that only they knew how to defeat the Russians, and had extensive experience doing so.

NATO had already completely abandoned the goal of containing the Germans and became a purely defensive alliance against the Socialist bloc. At the same time, the newly created Bundeswehr, like many European members of the Alliance, was viewed as a proxy force—massive and cheap infantry that would absorb the brunt of the attack. Moscow, for example, had created the GDR army for this very purpose. This is the simple logic of major wars, where large numbers matter: in a major war, where heavy systems are constantly at work, there are always large losses.
>>
Even with a successful offensive, your losses can amount to 30% of your forces. No one ever wants to risk their regular forces—not only for political reasons, but also simply because they are trained forces that need to be conserved. Therefore, everyone always fights with proxy armies. Even if your main forces are forced to take a hit, all these proxies hold your flanks or take the brunt of the attack somewhere, so you can deploy your main forces.

In 2022, Donbas acted as such a cheap and massive infantry force for the Russians—essentially a miniature version of the USSR and the Socialist Bloc. Donbas took on the task of pinning down the Ukrainian Armed Forces head-on, grinding them down, while elite Russian airborne forces made the main effort—outflanking and encircling Kyiv. On paper, it looked good, and the plan almost worked, but in the end, luck didn't work out, and they got beat up. Then the Russian Armed Forces replaced the slaughtered soldiers from Donbas with prisoners and other poor people willing to sell themselves for thousands of dollars.

Incidentally, this is one of the key problems of the Ukrainian Armed Forces—there is no source of cheap infantry capable of withstanding losses (which are fundamentally unavoidable). Kyiv partially solved this problem in 2022 by creating the Territorial Defense, which was essentially light infantry. This decision wasn't made out of a good life, but simply out of desperation (remember the axiom of a great war—losses are inevitable). But that doesn't make things any easier for anyone: Zaluzhny even had to apologize, declaring in 2022 that he was asking forgiveness from those already at the front for the equipment being sent to newly created units.
>>
File: images (1).jpg (21 KB, 678x452)
21 KB JPG
Returning to NATO—all this is to say that its architecture is outdated, and it's now unclear who in Europe is ready to serve as this cheap infantry. Let me remind you, no one asked the Bundeswehr. Everyone is a hero in the war, but in reality, it's usually 98% bullshit. And again, this is the reason why everyone is pissing themselves off Putin (except the Ukrainians)—he demonstrated that he has this cheap infantry and is willing to lose it.
>>
>>546454290
>Germany, however, was feared, both because of its rapid resurgence in the 1930s and the phenomenal effectiveness of the Wehrmacht.
Bullshit.
>>
>>546454779
Just read how large was fearmongering about Germany in late 1940s. Bullshit like this
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgenthau_Plan
Came from this fearmongering.
>>
File: russia_culture_of_serf.png (119 KB, 1080x920)
119 KB PNG
imma copy/paste another trvke from earlier thread
>Finnish poster: Russians on this board know the war is wrong otherwise they would've volunteered
>Russians
>know
>wrong
you start with false assumptions.
the default for the rusnigger is that they don't know anything, can't know anything (are unable to check for and verify the facts at hand, trading reason for emotion and what personally appeals to them more)
2ndly, they do not have the concepts of right or wrong (like other Asiatics, such as chinks or jeets). that's where whataboutism comes from. "russia isn't the only one doing X" (something along these lines, regardless whether it's actually true or completely false). they muddy the waters, but initially it's their regime muddying the waters (for them)
so not only they are unable to distinguish right from wrong, they also simply don't care. they never left the primitive dog-eat-dog stage of world development.
when the militant Maori farmers from 2 particularly aggressive Maori tribes massacred the peaceable Moriori hunter-gatherers on Chatham Islands, including cannibalism and then enslaving the rest of the population, not only did they not see anything wrong with that, they explained that it was part of their custom and nature.

The Scorpion and the Frog parable is relevant here. Patton was right when he said that the problem in understanding the russian stems from the fact that he's not a European but an Asiatic, and therefore thinks deviously.
They were like this already before the Judeo-Bolsheviks made further mush of their brains
>>
>>546454290
>the phenomenal effectiveness of the Wehrmacht.
the what now
>>
>>546454290
no one wanted to be part of your shit alliance and no one still wants to be
no one wanted to be part of usa's shit alliance and no one still wants
I piss on russia and i piss on usa
both of you kill yourselves and leave us all alone
you can however take germany with you to hell when you leave
>>
>>546455157
>oh shit i copied the wrong paste
>heres the correct one

Rusniggers are so subhuman they literally don't have the concepts of objective truth, fact
They're like an MK-ULTRA victim on national scale, where they no longer believe anything is real and everything is "shades of gray" and relative.
The worst thing though is that they try to spread their rot around. Truly, they're cancer.
But before you call out this tactic as demoralization/active measures, keep in mind they were the first to be demoralized very long ago.

You simply cannot respect such "people" they aren't even people, more like cattle. Nothing racist or xenophobic or bigoted about this. Im not dehumanizing anyone or name-calling them "orcs." They have dehumanized themselves lol. They're disposable livestock in human form and are OK with being treated like property by their regime as long as the myth of being part of a "greater whole" is being upheld by the regime, and themselves.

I know chinksects have "face saving culture" and likewise have issues with objective truth, reason, sincerity. But I do believe even chinks are more grounded and less detached from reality than rusniggers at this point kek. Rusniggers have surpassed even the chinks in the Asiatic mankurt mindset. Imagine being so helpless and retarded as rusniggers are. Literal cattle that can be beaten by their owners and they wont even know what hit 'em (the vast majority at least)
You would think a normal human being wouldn't be stupid enough to fall for these misdirections but rusnigger cattle unironically are. They're almost too dumb to breathe and with their shilling (along with JIDF and globalist "make the forum boring to turn users away" shills) have reduced the average /pol/tard to their level of idiocy
their continued existence is an insult to mankind, reason and all human dignity in addition to being a mockery of all 3
>>
>>546455197
wow what a proud gypsy! he's so european! so anti-american! AND anti-russian! such an EU enjoyer! how do you do fellow EU enjoyers on this politically INCORRECT board
EU enjoying is sooo politically INCORRECT gaise
like total globalist eurofederalism nao - thats so radical and anti-establishment. speak truth to power gypsy friend!!
>>
>>546455197
>Romanian flag
Nobody dragged your country into NATO, that are YOUR politicians spent 1990s begging Americans to let them in, even sending troops to Iraq and Afghanistan just to prove Romania worthy enough to invite.
>>
>>546454290
>the newly created Bundeswehr, like many European members of the Alliance, was viewed as a proxy force—massive and cheap infantry that would absorb the brunt of the attack
Except it was insignificant throught the Cold War. West Germany was defended by the United States, Britain, and France (to a lesser extent). The United States and Britain also formed the main part of the defence of Worst Korea, and the United States also pretty much shouldered the Vietnam War almost single handedly (sorry Straya), as well as the Gulf War.
The preoccupation with 'muh proxies' is a peculiar product of the demented and damaged Russian mind.
>>
>>546455270
i piss on eu too
i want all "great" powers to fuck off, i am tired of having people in power steal from under our own feet and give to foreigners, at least for once i want them to steal for themselves and have no foreign piece of shit involved
>>546455428
>Nobody dragged your country into NATO
yea and nobody wanted our dictator in the 89 for trying to give nukes to iran which is why he's still alive
>>
>>546455765
>). The United States and Britain also formed the main part of the defence of Worst Korea,
Besides the southern proxy?
>vietnam
Besides the southern proxy?
>>
>>546455765
Also curious you neglected to mention the Soviet-Afghan war
>>
NATO is created to kill puccian subhumans and their children. When the time comes, we are going to massacre you
>>
>>546454290
>Therefore, the United States had well-founded concerns that the Germans, if left unchecked, would rebel even more viciously.

that didn't happen tho
and USA got moar and moar cucked
>>
>>546456185
I think you're extending the meaning of the word proxy to breaking point by using the term to define the nations on which the conflicts took place. The point is that the United States did not try to avoid combat by using other nations to fight for them - the traditional definition of a proxy.
>>
>>546455197
>both of you kill yourselves and leave us all alone
If only there was a certain 3rd positionist country that led NAM during the entire cold war which everyone except Lukashenko and some Arab dictators abandoned.
>>
>>546455765
>was insignificant throught the Cold War
By the 1980, Bundeswehr had nearly 500k troops, 4k tanks and accounted roughly 50% of NATO land forces, while British Army in Germany was barely 55k troops sitting in the north and France wasn't even part of NATO military command after 1966.
>The United States and Britain also formed the main part of the defence of Worst Korea
South Korea has mobilized over 600k troops and suffered roughly 137k deaths, 4x from American casualties and 100x from British.
>>
>>546456251
The Afghans were fighting a Soviet invasion. The West helped them, but they weren't anyone's proxies.
>>
>>546454290
yeah the usa always finds excuses to start wars around the world
>>
>>546456377
>that didn't happen tho
Because containment strategy worked, genius.
>cucked
>permanent military bases around the world, nuclear weapon and operational command over Europe for 80 years
Very strange definition of "cucked". Why self-hating Americans are like this?
>>
>>546456504
Now you're just being retarded. You've gotta be more on the level here, this is t reddit. https://m.youtube.com/shorts/LF0qiGMf_2Q
>>
>>546456740
I'm not watching your retarded YouTube link. Use your words, Cletus.
>>
>>546456830
It's Hillary Clinton saying we recruited Mujahideen from all around the middle east to defeat the Soviet Union, because we didn't want them controlling central Asia, and it worked.
>>
>>546456945
So, you could say that those foreign Mujahideen were US proxies, but it doesn't track to apply the term to the Afghans as a whole.
>>546456450
Sorry, Ivan, I missed this. I concede I underestimated the strength of the German army during the majority of the Cold War. However, I maintain that helping a nation defend themselves from Soviet (or Russian) aggression does not make them proxies.
>>
>>546457353
>helping a nation defend themselves from Soviet (or Russian) aggression does not make them proxies.
During Cold Wa Bundeswehr wasn't even allowed to have its own General Staff and entire structure was subordinated directly to NATO integrated command (which meant American).

Call them "allies" or "proxies", reality doesn't change - local state provides cheap mass infantry and hegemon provides logistics, command and strategic umbrella.
>>
>>546457353
>helping a nation defend themselves does not make them a proxy
Whats your opinion on russia helping defend Syria from ISIS
>>
>>546454327
>>546455157
Yes that was the old Cold War doctrine things changed quite drastically these last years
>>
File: EbilNATOExpansion.png (77 KB, 830x2730)
77 KB PNG
>>546457604
>local state provides cheap mass infantry and hegemon provides logistics, command and strategic umbrella
If by 'local state' you mean the country threatened by Russian aggression, you're correct. Why shouldn't they contribute to their own defence? The point is that the United States wasn't seeking to avoid fighting themselves. U.S. Army strength in Europe peaked at approximately 475,000 active-duty personnel in the late 1950s, and wound down to about 100,000 military personnel as tensions eased. As I've already mentioned, they weren't shy about committing their own forces in subsequent conflicts either.
>>
>>546457353
They are a vassal they still pay occupation cost to this day
>>
>>546457702
>Whats your opinion on russia helping defend Syria from ISIS
I think Russian forces were there to prop up a friendly despot. If they'd had somehow convinced Cuba to do the job for them, you could argue that those Cubans were acting as their proxies. As it was in reality, I'm not sure why you'd have to mention 'proxies' at all.
>>
>>546454327
>No one ever wants to risk their regular forces—not only for political reasons, but also simply because they are trained forces that need to be conserved
The problem is that we have pretty substantial confirmation that formations like the VDV and many of the Guards have been extremely heavily attrited. So the idea that Russia is holding back an elite corps of trained troops doesn't hold up.

The initial invasion force was additionally composed entirely of regular army units. They were the best conventional infantry/armor force Russia could muster. They got rebuffed.

I don't think there's good evidence for the idea that Russia has a secret reserve it's holding back. I think Russia wants us to THINK that's true, hence the threats towards the Baltics and Poland, but this war is existential for Putin.

By all outward appearances, Russia is eating hand-to-mouth in terms of personnel.
>>
>>546458127
Just wanted to check something. Got my answer, cheers Nigel Shillberg good talk
>>
>>546457991
>vassal
Another peculiar Russian preoccupation. I visited Grrmany during the Cold War. I completely failed to notice Americans (or the British) behaving like occupying forces. You think what the Germans did in the Netherlands during the Second World War was similar to what the Americans did in Germany in the 1970s?
>>
>>546458294
What was it you checked, Cletus? Run out of words again?
>>
>>546454290
don't worry ivan, germany won't make a comeback this time.
>>
>>546457973
>If by 'local state' you mean the country threatened by Russian aggression, you're correct. Why shouldn't they contribute to their own defence
Because see this
>>546454369
Western Europe spent the last 30 years abolishing conscription and turning its armies into tiny, high-tech expeditionary boutique forces. No one want to be cheap infantry anymore.
>Army strength in Europe peaked at approximately 475,000 active-duty personnel in the late 1950s, and wound down to about 100,000 military personnel as tensions eased.
Because Bundeswehr finished standing up. Entire purpose of its existence was to replace American conscripts in Europe with local German cannon fodder.
>>
>>546458450
I'm not sure you even know what your point is. You seem to think there is something wrong with people defending themselves against Russian aggression.
>>
>>546458574
My point couldn't be simpler - in real land war against Russia in Europe, someone has to sit in the trenches and take massive casualties. Until 1990s, that was Germany. Today, Germany has approximately 60k troops, zero conscription and zero ready for body bags, while Putin has shown he can throw thousands of recruits each month into meatgrinder.
>>
>>546458368
Who gives a fuck about the 1970’s good music tho
>>
>>546458825
The irony is that NATO was sliding into irrelevancy until Russia reinvigorated it. Good job!



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.