https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/dueling-claims-of-riemann-hypothesis-proofs-emerge/This morning Anthropic employee Levent Alpöge posted a Claude-generated proof that he claimed solved the Riemann hypothesis, the most famous open problem in all of mathematics, using a large language model. The claim goes even further, stating that the proof has resolved the much stronger and harder generalized Riemann hypothesis.But now two top mathematicians are saying that a human may have produced just such a proof months ago, purportedly without any assistance from artificial intelligence. Such a proof would be the most remarkable mathematical achievement in decades, all the more notable for being accomplished by a person amid the ongoing AI arms race to conquer math. But the proof has not actually been verified by anyone—and other mathematicians are already expressing skepticism of its validity.The human claim was posted by Ravi Vakil, president of the American Mathematical Society and a mathematician at Stanford University. He said in blog post on Friday that the prover was Alessandro Masullo, a young mathematician, also at Stanford. According to the post, the proof was in the hands of Brian Conrad, a Stanford mathematician and an expert on the subject, who has been giving Masullo feedback over the past few months. Conrad has confirmed to Scientific American that the details of the blog post are true.
>>546571214>the AI stole it againits all so tiresome
>>546571214it was proved on pol long ago using a 72B parameter local model
>>546571214>I suddenly care about this thing that I didn't even know existed until today
>>546571214Does this actually do anything for the betterment of humanity? Or is this one of those useless math problems with no real world application like visualizing a 17 dimension inverted toroid foreskin in Mathematica?
>But now two top mathematicians are saying that a human may have produced just such a proof months ago, purportedly without any assistance from artificial intelligence.Why didn't they then? It has been a million dollar open problem for a century.
That's amazing, my haitian neighbors are going to be so excited for the benefits of this historic breakthrough to improve their daily lives.
>>546571308>Does this actually do anything for the betterment of humanity?Do (You)?
>>546571214Explain "mathematical proving" like I have retardation and post on /pol/ unironically
>>546571308There is no tangible benefit. But you should still appreciate accomplishments at the utter apex of human reason, that being mathematics. Even if it's only an exercise in thought, it is testament to our abilities.
>>546571289Without any evidence to support your claim, I believe you anon.
>>546571370>a < b, b < c, therefore a < cBasically scale this up 1000x. It all relies on fundamental rules of logic and builds on itself to produce results incomprehensible to the average person.
>>546571315Probably wanted to make sure it was correct. Nobody wants to humiliate themselves by arrogantly pronouncing they have found the answer to a long unsolved problem only to have a mistake pointed out within minutes
>>546571395>There is no tangible benefit.There is though. But not as much as normal because Riemann has been assumed for so long. There would have been more tangible benefit if it was disproven.>>546571465Yeah, being a chickenshit cost them the million dollars, same as how they cuck and don't say nigger and go along with whatever their peer group thinks yeah?
>>546571465>but what if im wrong everyone will think im a retard
>>546571343In my own small way.
/sci/ is mocking it though, says it's garbage
>>546571308no, this changes everything. the methods used are revolutionary, and number theory will never ever be the same. if there is a universal language, this is it. before yesterday, earth's best plan for first contact would be prime number sequence. now it is RH. if there is an intergalactic hypernet, this is the encoding. all LLMs will be rebaselined onto prime encodings built on top of these trace functions and theta lifts. the whole world is about to change. all pre-quantum encrytion is useless. all post-quantum theoretical physics too. this is the largest breakthrough in pure math in 200 years at least, if not the entire past history of our planet, and future history.
>>546571569Why is it so small instead of big?
>>546571370Sure, I'll prove that there are an infinite number of prime numbers.Let's say N is the largest prime number, i.e. all numbers larger than N have a prime factor up to and including N. For example 6 has prime factors 2 x 3.Consider the number P = 1 x 2 x 3 x ... x (N-1) x N + 1.This has remainder 1 when divided by all the numbers 2, 3, ... N-1, N. So it doesn't divide any of them.This implies that either P is prime, or it has a prime factor that is larger than N.Therefore, N cannot be the largest prime number, and since there can be no largest prime number, there are an infinite number of primes.
>>546571527You have said nothing empirical either way.
>>546571612Grok, explain it to me as if I'm a golden retriever
>>546571703mathematics isn't empirical shitskin
>>546571420pol archives has it, AI found it in its training data, qed (if true) and it is. you'll see. the old proof was built on modular arithmatic, the new proof on fourier transforms. very similar, much harder, and much more useful this proof than that proof, but nonetheless, that was the map.
>>546571612Word salad. You don't know quantum nothing.
The human proof is unfinished they said it themselves, they'd been working on it for over a decade but felt pressured to push it out now since the claude announcement dropped.
>>546571680Ah yes, of course
>>546571214They call it the 'pls buy our stock' solution.
>>546571308apparently it implies something about the distribution of prime numbers so it'll probably just let cianiggers bypass encryption easier
>>546571706woof woof woof (primes)hi how are you (GRH)you can hit chat with your dog in dogso can your AIso can your bankso can proxima centaurianswe cant hear because we didnt have good mathnow we do
>>546571214This is a top signal, by the way. If they ever get so desperate they claim they solved the millenia problems, it is because they are really scared.
>>546571612That’s pretty neat anon, thanks for sharing.
>>546571846You're asking to be murdered. That's what your post means. You're saying "someone please kill me I'm too much of a faggot to do it myself".
>>546571214Proof were living in a simulation.
>>546571602sci are a bunch of coping redditors who hate AI because it hurt their feelings
>>546571819only one tiny part of it is unfinished, but it is atill frameworked in and fully mapped. the key issue is numerical analysis of a singularity in the zeta function--this type of analysis is exactly where theoretical physics has been stuck since hawking could not develop quantum gravity and explain beyond the singularity horizon of a black hole. now we can. both proofs are valid, and compliment each other. without both proofs extant, i would say it was impossible to be true. but now im certain. you can chat with GPT thru the human proof and it will crash on the missing step after confirming its eureka finding of the finished trace function. releasing this hidden piece would unlock the destruction of prime based public key encrytion and would release the nuke codes, eauivalently.
>>546571952People who think they're going to unlock quantum computing and antigrav tech with it are faggots too though. Both camps think man has shoved God's consciousness into a plastic square. They're all going to die.
>>546572036No. You just die of a brain tumor calling out to a god who just ignores you for waiting till the last minute.
>>546572120Yes, indeed.
>>546572209No talky. Sleepy time now.
>>546572233Thansk for the update.
>>546571612>all pre-quantum encrytion is uselessSounds like foreverial typewriterized monkey Shakespeare. Just because you can't prove something won't happen doesn't mean it will happen.
>>546571706Imagine you're a golden retriever and prime numbers are tennis balls scattered across an infinite field.Nobody knows exactly where the next ball is. But 167 years ago, a guy named Riemann said, "I think there's a secret rule controlling how all these balls are scattered."Nobody could prove it.Then yesterday, a mathematician and an AI named Claude may have finally cracked it.Claude wrote 17 MILLION lines of mathematical proof. Too much for humans to check, so they fed it into a computer that verifies mathematical logic step by step.Computer says GOOD DOG. Independent verification is still underway.Here's the interesting part.Imagine humans have been trying to open a locked door for 167 years.The robot dog opened it.But it might have also invented an entirely new kind of key that opens thousands of other doors.THAT is potentially revolutionary.Now the guy in the original post is claiming aliens will communicate using tennis balls, all encryption is dead, physics is obsolete, and every AI will be rebuilt around prime numbers.BAD DOG. TOO MANY TENNIS BALLS.None of that follows from the proof.The actual mind-blowing possibility is that AI solved one of humanity's hardest math problems by constructing a proof too enormous for humans to understand directly.We may be entering an era where computers discover mathematical truths faster than humans can understand them.Humans might no longer be the smartest mathematicians.Our job might become deciding which tennis balls to tell the robot to fetch.
>>546571214Stanford jews are kvetching and now they are trying to steal the muslim turk work
>>546571308it could be the catalyst for TKD and TND
>>546572363Claim in the quote AssessmentThe methods are revolutionary Plausible, if the argument introduces reusable techniquesNumber theory will never be the same Quite plausible if the proof holdsRH is a universal language for first contact Speculation, not an implication of RHIntergalactic networks would use this encoding No mathematical basis establishedAll LLMs will switch to prime encodings Unsupported predictionAll pre-quantum encryption becomes useless False as a consequence of RHPost-quantum theoretical physics becomes obsolete No logical connection demonstratedBiggest pure mathematics breakthrough in 200 years Defensible as an opinion, if validated
>>546571214Does solving this equation make jews and other minorities disappear?No?Then I don't give a shit.
>>546572363>BAD DOG. TOO MANY TENNIS BALLS.wrong. it is 950 pages and about 6 radical analytical breakthroughs. the human proof i mean. it wouldnt be believable without the Claude based proof in Lean, but both proofs use the same plumbing, and both proofs have revilutionized (human) Math forever. tennis balls are a lie. were really talking about evey ball in the universe, even black holes, even human brains, even fusion reactors, and planets and stars, and photons, etc.
Its pretty ironic that Apoge was the one claiming AI stole his work last time. And now he is getting the same treatment.
will it get me laid?
>>546571308No. It is literally a problem invented by one retard for other retards to try and figure out for 1000 years. It'd be like trying to figure out which blade of grass feels best when shoved in your cock hole. Is there an answer? Probably yes. Does anybody on the planet care? No.
>>546572363singularity era is uppon us indeed
>>546572438Not an implication of RH i agree. But an implication of the analytical methods is a certainty. Ask your GPT to look for and explain the eureka moment in the unfinished portion of the human proof and you will see. It is under 1000 pages and fits in modern context windows. your got will crash when the eureka moment hits, for a reason, youll see. just have it keep explaining it to you until it clicks: whatever your level of math education, these methods used by LLMs can translate it for you specifically.
>>546571214>the rugpull hypothesis
>>546572363>The actual mind-blowing possibility is that AI solved one of humanity's hardest math problems by constructing a proof too enormous for humans to understand directly.Once Luo Zi met a sage from the south, to whom he asked why doesn't the sky fall upon the Earth. The sage had to explain of the nature of Earth, the nature of the sky, the order of things, and so many other essential piece of knowledge that by the end Luo Zi was as oblivious as when he asked.Then he pondered of the nature of wisdom, and if man is not misguided in their seeking to understand the Universe that they do not ponder if the truth is far too invest to understand or to complain.
>>546571287>The human claim was posted by Ravi VakilHe's just trying to redeem izzat.
>>546571214I was on board until I saw a jeet name. Fuck em. Not my problem.
>>546571287nope, that's not whats happening here. A mathematician for the last 12 years, in secret, had been trying to prove it and failed. His proof has mistakes and errors, claudes doesn't. He panic released it because otherwise those 12 years have been for absolutely nothing.
>>546571214jew pilpul about jewish physics and jewish math.Curious why physics stopped since big jew Ed Witten made kike string theory a thing.So tired of jews talking but cancer isnt getting cured, aging isnt reversed and fusion power still isnt happening.As to Ai proving anything, yeah, its always stolen shit. Nothing novel comes out of GayI
>>546571214nah bro
>>546571308the sum of all positive integers being -1/12 has vast repercussions for quantum mechanics and somehow it is related to riemann hypothesis
>>546571612if advanced aliens caught wind of us making AI and it was a serious technology they'd probably roll up here and blow us up
I don't care , indians still exist and gas is still expensive
MEN *CAN* ALSO BE WOMEN. IT IS SETTLED!
>>546572631That was chatgpt sol and it's probably too pessimistic. There probably are actual encryption consequences to this but no one knows yet so the llm is just playing it safe instead of conjecturing. I would expect a "Riemann" memecoin will pop up based on this math
>>546574634There are better models. But these proofs are pure treasures. The AI version is decent but incomprehensible. The Human version has a hidden step. The AI version proves the validity of the Human analytical path. RH is done, and so is modern Math. Welcome to the dawn of a new epoch. Singularity analysis was born today and there is no such thing as an event horizons.
>>546571214yeah, still have to pay taxes to jews tomorrow, nothing changed
>>546571680I think that it's self evident that if numbers are infinite (as they obviously are), then forcefully any sequence will be infinite itself, as well.
>>546576665
>>546571214>just... months ago, purportedly without any assistance from artificial intelligence.SureJan.gif
>>546571646That's what she said
>all these retarded marketing attempts to save the IPO and the overall AI bubble is taking down the entire stock market with it regardlessCan "AI" give amerigolema back their foreskin?
>>546571214I solved it too desu. Just didn't wanna go through all the rigamarole to submit it to homo academics
>>546576967Haven't seen anything like this in a long time...>the newman hypothesis
>>546571214So, arrows can move through space or nah?
>>546571315>Why didn't they then?Do you know how long peer review takes?
>>546571680he stole my answer
Gentlemen! We find ourselves in an important epoch, in a fermentation, in which Spirit has made a leap forward, has gone beyond its previous concrete form and acquired a new one. The whole mass of ideas and concepts that have been current until now, the very bonds of the world, are dissolved and collapsing into themselves like a vision in a dream. A new emergence of Spirit is at hand; philosophy must be the first to hail its appearance and recognize it, while others, resisting impotently, adhere to the past, and the majority unconsciously constitute the matter in which it makes its appearance. But philosophy, in recognizing it as what is eternal, must pay homage to it.Hegel, Lectures at Jena of 1806, final speech
>>546576824If the container is infinite, so will the possible content (a straight line, by definition infinite, will forcefully contain an infinite number of segments).
>>546571680>no credit to Euclid for using his proofChuds will always be derivative thinkers.
>>546573046>claudes doesn't.You don't know that. It might be bullshit, the LEAN hasn't even been compiled yet. It runs at 17 million lines of code.>>546571214>Anthropic employeeI'm already having my doubts.
>>546572060If you stand in front of a mirror and say antigravity 3x Wayne Lambright will appear.
>>546577536gentlemen we appear to have entered a remarkable epoch in the development of mathematical consciousness in which infinity having established its unquestionable presence is now expected to extend its sovereignty over every sequence and every container that might claim its hospitality and yet surely the spirit of mathematics must make a further advance for the infinity of numbers does not compel every sequence to be infinite any more than the eternity of history requires every procession to continue forever a finite selection remains finite even when drawn from an inexhaustible domain and possibility however magnificent does not constitute actualityand what of the infinite container which must necessarily produce infinite content here too the understanding has mistaken the generosity of existence for the necessity of consequence an infinite straight line contains infinitely many points and admits infinitely many subdivisions but may nevertheless be partitioned into two three or any finite number of segments its extension does not dictate the cardinality of its partition the boundless kingdom need not populate every province and the infinite horizon does not oblige every traveler to walk foreverthus we must distinguish between what infinity permits and what it entails between the inexhaustibility of a domain and the cardinality of a sequence for the courage of mathematical spirit consists not in discovering infinity everywhere but in recognizing where it actually resides and perhaps the most extraordinary advance of thought is to discover that infinity requires no assistance from an argument that has mistaken its own conviction for necessity
>>546571214Even if a human solved it instead, what does this do?