I used to think that phrase meant "make the truth powerful by speaking it", because it was so clumsy and ill-constructed that its apparent real meaning is not even conveyed. The real meaning is apparently "speak the truth to oppressive people" or something along those lines, which does not even make sense for multiple reasons. The first being that power is not an entity, it's a *thing* that someone can possess. The second being that having power is not synonymous with being oppressive, so it's just creating a false equivalency that implicitly condemns having power. The third is that even if the phrase were "speak the truth to oppressive people," what would that accomplish? They probably already know the truth, and if they don't, then all you're doing is giving them more knowledge (which is itself power). Speaking *out* against oppressive people can be a worthwhile thing, but the chances are slim that it will convince them to change their ways. The real audience someone should be aiming for when they share knowledge and speak out against someone is their own allies.Other neologisms I hate include "my truth", "your truth", "their truth", etc. and "privileged" (to mean someone who holds more power), because there is only one truth and privilege implies some kind of gift granted by a ruler (it characterizes all forms of power or advantage as gifts given by a more powerful individual or group). I think this is political because a lot of these phrases characterize the modern day political landscape, so which ones do you hate?
It's a fancier "Stick it to the man"
Speak truth to power proclaims the virtuous dissident, imagining truth stands outside power and courage consists in bringing the two together. But beyond good and bad, the greater political art is to recognize truth has no audience independent of power, and power no legitimacy independent of truth it permits to be heard.The enlightened leader does not demand silence, nor does he mistake dissent for disloyalty. He invites contradiction, welcomes scrutiny, and makes room for every voice, even those that question the necessity of his own. Power that must silence its critics has confessed its weakness; power that can afford to listen has not surrendered anything.Thus, speak truth to power. And let power learn to speak truthfully in return. For the final irony is that the freedom to challenge authority and the authority to define the meaning of that challenge have never been opposite.
>>546573491People dont possess power, the sum unconscious/conscious pathology of man shits itself into an entire mountain where the peasents waterboard the crown. People dont wear the crown, crown wears the person
>>546573491"trust the science". It implies that because something's scientific it is correct. I feel like it also comes from the mindset that drugs all the kids without ever asking themselves why drugging so mamy children has never been necessary in all of human history. There are others where almighty science and opinions of experts should be taken as absolute gospel in spite of the disturbing trends industrial history has and quickly forgets about. Cocaine was supposed to be good for you. Electro-shock therapy, etc.. All people trusting the science until, whoops!
>>546573491What is this phrase "shooting fish in a barrel?"I do not understand. You already have the fish.Why do you need to put them in a barrel, and then shoot them?Where do you even get a barrel from these days
>>546574209It's a tradition from the midwest. After a fisherman catches the fish he puts them in a barrel and shoots them to celebrate American gun culture.
>>546573558I can tolerate "stick it to the man" because it at least identifies a subject without metonymy. This one is exponentially more annoying.>>546573793>truth has no audience independent of powerThis is a self-evident statement, since the concept of an audience for truth necessitates subjects, and all subjects technically have some form of power. But the phrase does not mean "power" as a thing that someone can possess, it specifically means oppressive entities like authoritarian governments or institutions. To say that truth has no audience independent of oppressive entities is again technically correct in the sense that all entities are (however many steps removed) in some way interdependent, but in practice it is just mad.>Thus, speak truth to power. And let power learn to speak truthfully in return. For the final irony is that the freedom to challenge authority and the authority to define the meaning of that challenge have never been opposite.That implies that it's a lack of people speaking the truth to oppressive entities that is causing them to not speak truthfully themselves. That's not true though. It also implies that speaking the truth to them is challenging them, which I pointed out is not necessarily true. Speaking the truth to other people is typically challenging them more than speaking the truth to them is, and since knowledge is a form of power it is typically more advantageous to keep it from them.
>>546574035Physically they do. Power can be measured at least in some forms. The ability to persuade, manipulate, and rally people can also be considered a tangible form of power. So can money, alliances, etc.
>>546574346>it specifically means oppressive entities like authoritarian governments or institutionsthat is a formalist illusion encoded in cultural biases and a hegelian dialectic (fight to the death for pure prestige over the other), and no longer valid since deconstructionism. power of that sense is self-defeating; necessarily dependent on the preconditions of its own collapse and failure. that is not power, that is weakness.
>>546574346It should just be speak truth. Why do you need to be reminded to speak the truth? That's right, because it's yo troof. Just speak the truth. The biggest problem with "speak troof to powa" is that it means someone's going to list their entitled demands that are entirely unreasonable. Reparations for centuries old history and excuses for why a country shouldn't have a border or a believed systematic oppression when les system is breaking itself to acquisce. It's people that can't see themselves as part of les system even though they are.
>>546574121Yeah I hate this one too. The funny thing is that science is inherently about doubt and questioning at its core, and testing hypotheses through empirical research. It's a hallmark of someone who has started treating the concept of science like a religious organization. Vaccines are great until 50% of the population is autistic lol.>>546574209Apparently something about sailors packing salted fish in barrels so tightly that when a barrel was shot, it was inevitable they'd hit a fish. Idk if it's true though.
>>546574685Ah you're a deconstructionist. That explains a lot.
>>546573491truth: dismantle the illegitimate state of israel
>>546574705I agree, to an extent. It probably wouldn't even be a saying if it were that general.>It's people that can't see themselves as part of les system even though they are.In practice I only ever really see people with victim/vengeance complexes and those who pander to them saying it. Funny that Wikipedia lists its origin as a saying by Mohammad.
>>546574999Real. And while we're at it dismantle the Islamic states too.
>>546574896It isnt me, its the entire postmodern world. Truth is dead (God is dead). Life is death. This contradiction is an internal tension of language itself. Kojeve explains it all in his Introduction. The commies cant move beyond power encoded as an institution. Because of State schools, imo.