Nobody talks about how conscription is the worst kind of slave labor. Forcing you to die for a cause you may or may not support.
>>85980487The second someone puts a gun in my hand I'm turning it on them and then myself. No hesitation. No sympathy for someone >>Just doing their jobShould've thought of that before you tried to force someone to fight
>>85980722I'd probably just booby trap my house imo
>>85980487Everyone taIks about it
>>85980722While Pvt Pyle was an inspiration, you should have higher aspirations than that anon. Think about it, if you're deployed to the sandbox you might get the chance to shoot an Israeli or two before killing yourself.
>>85980722>circumcised>no prospects>khhv They already made me want to die living under the conditions they created normally in peacetime. Now with nothing to fight for, the idea I'm going to become action goy is laughable
>>85980487To understand why conscription has to exist, you first have to understand what the primary purpose of the state is. The primary purpose of the state is to protect your rights. But sometimes your country faces an existential threat. Meaning that if the state fails to protect itself, your rights cannot be secured any more and what happens to you will be entirely up to the whims of the invading force, which will likely violate your rights wantonly as it has no obligation to respect them. So some of your rights have to be suspended to prioritize the state's survival. You may get emotional watching watching videos of people being captured off the street, but it's the better alternative to what will happen if the state falls (e.g. cultural genocide, actual genocide, mass rape, mass pillaging, etc.).
>>85980938It's to protect capital nothing more.
>>85980894you forgot the part where the officer get shot first. the only whole point of doing this is to scare other officers into doing their job and sparking revolt against the evil cannibal bastards demanding war but refusing to fight with us
>>85980487Im upvoting this thread because i agree
>>85980948Do you know about the Norman invasion of Britain?
>>85980948I don't know whether you've ever read e.g. the American constitution or the federalist papers, but no, you're dead wrong. The entirety of the way the American government is structured comes back to the natural law philosophy, which is a deist idea that presuposes the existence of natural rights as something that exists independent of the state, which the state has to then protect and which aren't subject to democratic revisions. You may disagree with that particular moral realist framework, but you may still realize it's something that has been pretty useful in practice as far as the general success of the state goes.
>>85980938To understand why conscription has to exist, you first have to understand what the primary purpose of the state is. The primary purpose of the state is to protect landowners. (Note that by "landowners" I don't mean small families who own a house, I am specifically referring to ultra-rich oligarchs who own absolutely massive tracts of lands, in some cases as big as entire nations.) So, sometimes your country faces an existential threat. Meaning that if the state fails to protect itself, the property of landowners cannot be secured any more and what happens to their property will be entirely up to the whims of the invading force, which will likely seize their land wantonly as it has no obligation to respect them. So some of your rights have to be suspended to prioritize the well-being and prosperity of landowners. You may get emotional watching watching videos of people being captured off the street, but it's the better alternative to what will happen if the state falls (landowners losing their property and money).
Conscription may or may not be bad, but there's more important issues to fix first. Gender paygap, glass ceiling, basic human rights, access to healthcare, genital mutilation. These are the real issues, but women are the victims so strangely enough nobody wants to talk about it. Rather get mad because they put a female character in a videogame or cast an actor one shade darker than is biblically accurate to the holy canon comic book or whatever. Yeah, totally, this is the real issues we have to outrage at.You want to talk about slave labor, look no further than the nearest married woman or single mother.
>>85980938Conscripts didn't exist for a long time because lords were afraid peasants would rise up or aid other lords who offered them better prospects.The few times conscripts were used before the modern era practice, they got wiped the floor with by smaller professional armies. Only after nation states began emerging and something like patriotism, distinct from tribalism, was instilled was conscription effective enough to get people to go into battle without complaining out of a sense of duty. Reminds me of the byzantines who demanded conscripts from the recently reconquered Italian lands. The men just left for other areas and the cities fell into disrepair.
>>85981025Your commie bullshit doesn't actually track reality, bro. Riddle me this: what happens to people of states historically when those states get conquered? Is it just wealthy people losing material possessions? So what happened to people in communist states that got conquered? Nothing? Let's look at some examples. Go ahead.
>>85981060>Only after nation states began emerging and something like patriotism, distinct from tribalism, was instilled was conscription effective enough to get people to go into battle without complaining out of a sense of duty.So what if patriotism isn't allowed and/or your country is an economic zone filled with foreigners?
>>85981064Honestly? I don't care. If I can't own property then the State can fuck off and die for all I care. Not my problem.
>>85980999Ukraine is not founded on American principles. It's an ex-soviet union country that only believes in the communist agenda of infinite race mixing and getting infinite welfare from other countries. They would have you believe that they are defending themselves from another ex-soviet union country so you have to give them money and accept refugees from Africa. This somehow will allow them to win the war against the ex-soviet union. All part of the greater khazaria plan.
>>85981074>So what if patriotism isn't allowed and/or your country is an economic zone filled with foreigners?:)
>>85980964>the officer gets shot first I'm not working for them and I'm not working for youNO PUSSY NO WORK SIMPLE AS
>>85981060Typically when you fight a total war, meaning you get genocided if you lose, countries that are otherwise unassuming put up much stronger fights than ones that fight against opposing forces with limited war objectives. So while a conscript won't be as effective as a professional soldier, the difference is that in a state of total war where you're facing general mobilization you get an army that's orders of magnitudes greater then just strictly a professional one, and that's simply much stronger than whatever you can get with just a professional army. If the matter is existential for the state, again meaning you get genocided if you lose, the state will of course maximize for survival and that means pulling out all the stops and suspending some of your rights.
>>85981074>I'm a racist sexist antisemite that masturbates to anime girlsYou didn't have to post, we already knew that from the smell
>>85981082I accept your concession. But I have one question. I don't understand this obsession with owning property. Maybe because I live in Europe, where many more people rent and are fine with just renting. Isn't it more important that you have your own place to live rather than the actual structure of legal ownership? You still have to continually pay for using the land even if you own the place.
>>85981121Total wars are far and few between throughout history, you wouldn't even need that nowadays because it would include nukes if you are a westerner at least, making conscription effectively pointless. An army marches on its stomach and unless you have modern logistics you were dependent on local farms if you conquered an area. Moving in your own people would take centuries, and even then the potential tax base you just gutted was a huge waste of effort. You would have conquered empty lands, your own people would certainly hate that because it means a costly war was fought for nothing. This is the pre modern era. Modern era had conscription because men had a sense of patriotic duty. If men don't have it they will be even more demoralized than the usual conscripted army, and get wiped the floor with by a small professional regiment. The state should not have forgotten to foster that sense of duty if they did care.
>>85981142Ahh Europe where more people love being slaves. Anyways I'm deserting to South America and there's nothing you can do about it
>>85981084>Ukraine is not founded on American principlesIt was an example, little bro. It's a democratic free market state. All such states rest on a set of common small-L liberal ideas. It's not perfect, but it's clear that's the kind of state enterprise they are working towards aligning themselves with, as opposed to the authoritarian nations of the east such as Russia or China.
>>85981064This, conscripton is basic human decency.
>>85981137I am happy you dont need to be conscripted but will serve willingly. Let this be noted by your government.
>>85981142Rent = pay ten times as much and you aren't allowed to do anything you wantOwning means you can do whatever you want, taxes are but a tiny fraction of rent costs, you pass it on to children, and build established roots in an area.It's a uniquely American perspective, but we really do like the idea of being able to have a pet dog without asking for permission from our governess or nanny or whatever. We really do like having some herbs and vegetables growing in the garden. We like our beer, cars, guns, and we like our privacy and safety. It's a freedom thing. We're just built different from you.
>>85981153>Total wars are far and few between throughout historyThe vast majority of wars throughout history have been total wars. They haven't always resulted in genocides of the losing side, but the losing side can always be genocided by the winners. Which is why you pull out all the stops to not let that happen.
>>85980722Omg, just like in my action movies. This is the most blatant cope that comes up in threads like this.In forced conscription, there isn't a guy, its always several. And they're the closest thing to inquisition torturers our society can muster. And because their job is to prepare cannon fodder to defend the estates of politicians and judges, they get away with anything if the country is in a situation to need forced conscription. One in 100.000 kills an officer, one in 1000 gets killed at the first move and is made an example.By the time you get to touch an actual loaded gun, you'll be genuinely grateful your country offers you the opportunity to get some sleep and food.
>>85981200They havent, unless you think most people today are descendants of conquerors and not peasants.Fighting a total war destroys your own people too, you will give up your own men to destroy the other. What then will you propose? Inviting a third group of men to recoup numbers? This is just giving away your country with extra steps, which is the only option if you fight a war in the modern gdp must go up world.
>>85981214If people just start killing the officers carrying out the conscription with roadside IEDs what would happen
>>85981192>Rent = pay ten times as much and you aren't allowed to do anything you wantThat's not actually true. The profit margins on renting homes tend to be very thin in high-demand areas. It's expensive to own a house e.g. in a city center.
>>85981200>The vast majority of wars throughout history have been total wars.A rudimentary google search debunks this. Stop shilling your gay taxcattle nation state propaganda.
>>85981175Try again, dronemeat. I'm a woman. I'll be giving out white feathers and calling the recruiters on any stray moids I see. We need boots on the ground in iran.
>>85981228I have dual citizenship to Brazil
>>85981228>America pulls out billions of dollars of equipment from asian and european partners to protect centcom>Europe spends billions of euros on arming not themselves but ukraine>Anons think they are worth more than billions of dollars of equipmentYou will march if ww3 breaks out
>>85981142I'm European, retard. No one here is OK with renting forever. Literally all the property is owned by a extremely small minority of ultra-rich people, the same minority that brings in inmigrants by the dozens of MILLIONS in order to make living space even more valuable.When the Nazis occupied us, only the ultra rich had their property seized and ended up in camps. The rest of us were fine.
>>85981249Arent they floating conscripting childless women in ukraine after western pressure?
>>85981249I will leave this fucking country by boat or by plane. Whatever is closest and I know people who will smuggle me out of the country
>>85981225>That's not actually true. It is.A 17sqm2 apartment costs thousands of euros to rent where I live.
>>85981215>>85981227To be clear, we are talking all wars, not just ones that have existed once civilizations started to develop. So no, you're wrong. The default state of humans is genociding and enslaving each other. Sophisticated concepts such as "limited war objectives" started to be more common with maritime civilizations whose wealth depended much more on imposing a rule-based-order that facilitated trade rather than simple land acquisition and pillaging those lands.
>>85981214highly doubt that. you get guns on the range. yes they break you down a little first and all that but it takes 2 seconds to just turn the gun and shoot someone. this is not unheard of
>>85981269Yes>>85981270You will get arrested and sent with the penal batallion. You are not worth more than billions of dollars of equipmeant meant to protect trillion of dollars of trade. Even old men get conscripted and they are as weak as foids. You will march.
>>85981225The problem with lying is you have to actually try to make them believable. I never said that you profit by renting instead of just having a house. Profit margin has nothing to do with anything because you don't profit from being a renter or a homeowner. I said it costs more money to rent. This is true. Renters pay infinitely more rent for the place they live in than a homeowner pays in rent for the home that they own. Unless for some reason they charge themselves rent, but that would probably raise a few eyebrows at the tax office and be considered fraud. And obviously you aren't going to be growing a garden in the middle of the inner city. I'd rather live somewhere rural where my neighbors are a timber lot or cow pasture. We have this thing called space in America, you don't have to live in big cities surrounded by brown people. Well we don't at least. Don't feel bad though, at least 600 years ago Europe was relevant and had culture and stuff. That's something you can be proud of next time you get run over by mohammed or stabbed by ngjbubbdbieqzbt.
I encourage people to dodge the draft by fleeing to Uruguay and or Chile. These two Countries refuse to extradite on military offenses
>>85981292No I won't. I'm smart enough to leave before the going gets tough. I'll be sipping beer in Montevideo before long and if they revoke my passport I'll get a green card. I'm two steps ahead
>>85981282Yes! Thank you for supporting War as it were. We all must give ourselves to War in one way or another. It's only natural.
>>85981282You are now moving goalposts and pre-civilization wars were a small percentage of the total amount that followd after. Only cultures can create armies. Risking 15 men in a tribe of 50 would mean possibly not surviving through winter. That is aside from tribes not meeting as much to be able to fight over resources for obvious reasons.>Fight modern total war>Lose large swathes of men>State is weakened because not enough men to project military power>Gdp must also go up>Quickly need to raise numbersIn the modern day, you can only fix the issues by importing a third party of men. You have given away your people for free.
>>85981265I hate to burst your bubble, my economically illiterate young person, but owning the house you live in wouldn't result in a substantial reduction in your bills. It would be something like 4% tops in high-density areas and maybe 6% if you live in the countryside.>>85981276And it wouldn't cost much less if you owned it.>>85981295>Profit margin has nothing to do with anything because you don't profit from being a renter or a homeowner.It does, my retarded friend, because it tells you how much cheaper it would be for you to own a home as opposed to renting it. And it's not much cheaper in an area that's in high-demand, let me tell you that much. It's something like 4-6%. So let go of this notion that suddenly you'd be swimming in cash from your paychecks, if only you owned your flat. That's pure fantasy.
>>85981306You will not be smart enough lol.Thats without mentioning that if global supply chains break down, the global south will go hungry.South america has positive import export food ratios because they export so many luxury items like wine, chocolate, coffee, beef.A lot of them are still food insecure. Why would they give you gibs if supplies become harder to get?They wont, you'll end up in a video.
>>85981340Ending up in a cartel torture video sounds bad
>>85981357That anon should enjoy the lovely weather in south america and not worry about that when food insecurity increases because of lack of imports and fertilizer
>>85981336Lmao. Renting costs more than owning, because owners do not pay rent. You're retarded.
>>85981282And conscription is just a concept that was invented with civilization, so what is your point? If two tribes are fighting each other they aren't conscripting their men, there is no bureaucracy to force men to fight. A tribal community is ruled by personal relations so the men fight willingly to defend their tribe, they are not being forced to by a bureaucracy. When every place turns into an economic zone there are not such drastic stakes, it's just impersonal bureaucracies acting as a proxy for .0000001% of the population (the elite) duking it out. It doesn't exist to protect rights or whatever gay shit you're claiming, the state exists to extract resources from tax cattle, and they spread the kind of gay neo liberal propaganda you shill in order to get suckers to willingly die for them. Getting invested would be the equivalent of getting invested as a pleb in a company when the management changes, going out of your way to "fight" for whoever currently rules you. Do you not see how embarassing that is? It doesn't make a difference for the lowly pleb. It's analogous to how nation states are because that's what they basically are, they are just large businesses. The only people with real stakes are the elites, which is why they need to spread patriotic propaganda to galvanize the plebs to die for them. You don't own shit, you don't have any rights, they could take everything from you, they own everything, how cucked can you be to spread this kind of nonsense?
>>85980948Only today where your dying for Jewish interests
>>85981336You are full of shit. My "flat" is measured in acres. Taxes for the entire year are less than you pay in rent for one month because it's considered agricultural. How many acres is your flat? Do you even have a well or do you drink the same water you and millions of others shit and piss in before it's recycled with a splash of fluoride and chlorine to be drank again? The fuck kind of gay ass yuroism is flat anyway? >oi mate just popping over to me flat and having a cheeky drink with me wanker before the gay refugee parade. You want to join me innit?Owning is way cheaper than renting. Always has been always will be. Your kids if you ever have any will be paying rent if you try to bequeath the estate or flat or whatever to the same landlord because you don't actually own it. You can rent for a thousand years and it will still be exactly 0% yours.
>>85980487So long as there is civilisation, you will be a slave in some way.
>>85981370Not only that. Countries with extradition treaties WILL send you back on a whim
>>85980487>Nobody talks about how conscription is the worst kind of slave laborMost men are slaves though, that's just how it is, they have slave genes.If they're not slaves to the state they are slaves to lust, women and the pussy. Modern men are literally begging for women to enslave them.
>>85981370South America is all jungle. Pretty sure he could just get some chickens and plant some potatoes. It's not like winters are particularly harsh down there. Humans were doing agriculture just fine before petroderived fertilizers were a thing. The invention is less than 100 years old. Literally every country in the world managed to figure it out except Africa.
>>85981386What are you even talking about? You have to pay for mortgage, maintenance and repairs, utilities, property taxes, etc. The rent you pay is only a low single digit percentage more than it costs to own the place. The difference is that you just pay rent and you don't have to worry about any of that other stuff. What, you thought that if you buy a place then it's just free?>>85981425It's cheaper to own, but it's only a tiny bit more cheap to own. Again, single digit profit margins. Low single digits in high-demand areas. You people are so delusional this whole landlord hate starts to make more sense to me. If there's one benefit to owning it's that you truly have no fucking idea what things cost until you actually own a place.
>>85981446He wont get too. He will be forcibly extradicted and forced to charge drone with a stick.
>>85980487>Forcing you to die for a cause you may or may not support.You're not allowed to "withdraw your support" for your country. That's the literal definition of treason. You can be subtle about it and dodge the draft, but you can't be saying stuff like that, man.>>85981214 >By the time you get to touch an actual loaded gun, you'll be genuinely grateful your country offers you the opportunity to get some sleep and food.Like those ISIS beheading videos where they've psychologically tortured the vicitms for so long, they think every time they're dragged to an execution will be their last, but most of the time it's just to fuck with them and reduce their will to resist until they just let them chop off their head.>>85981223Civil war.
>>85981306No you wont. Uruguay will send you back. You will be forced back to your country and will die to defend it. You dont get a choice in the matter. You will be in a trench and be forcibly drafted in a penal battalion whether you like it or not
>>85981498>most of the time it's just to fuck with them and reduce their will to resist until they just let them chop off their head.Nothing wrong to do this to incels
>>85981453Why don't you break down some of these costs and actually explain with examples? You've lied multiple times so dude trust me won't quite cut it when you say it's only a percentage cheaper. Taxes are higher on rented properties than homeowner dwelled ones so you can't use taxes as part of the example. The only difference in cost is the actual rent. Use the fictional city of Pretendsville as your example. My yuro geography knowledge is a little shaky as is your understanding of American culture so this gives us both an equal blank slate to compare. I want a place big enough to have a garden, be able to have a bonfire whenever I want, I have animals and will one day God willing have a wife and as many kids as God gives us. So an 18 acre flat in the downtown city center of Pretendsville. How much does it cost over the course of a lifetime to rent vs own, item by item? I want my kids to inherit the place so to make things equivalent the lifetime costs has to include their lifetimes too.
>>85981556>Why don't you break down some of these costs and actually explain with examples?Can't you just ask ChatGPT to pull something up for you? It's really not hard to find this information.>You've lied multiple timesBefore I continue replying, I need you to tell me where I lied. I've been repeating the same shit about home ownership all throughout this thread. Go ahead.
>>85981446Xhe is an urbanized tranny and will not survive the jungle for obvious reasons. And what's stopping hungry locals from gibsmedatting. You'd need to go deep deep in the jungles where it is truly wild.
>>85981298They'll just extradite you for doing a antisemitism or pirating a movie or something. That's the whole reason behind having a billion different laws. You can arrest and imprison anyone on a whim by throwing the book at them. Jesus himself would be a criminal with infinite felonies to his name if he walked the earth today because with every breath a person takes they are breaking hundreds of laws per second at all times. It's simply a matter of if and when it becomes advantageous for the eye of sauron to focus on any one individual. Being alive is illegal and the justice system is just a fancy way of victim blaming to ensure none of the other slaves take pity when you get got by massa.
>>85981453This comparison only works if you assume the property is still being paid for through a mortgage. A lot of rental properties here in Europe today were already paid off 200-800 years ago and simply pass down from father to son LMAO. Also the way it works here is due to how much powers landlords have, renters have to pay for absolutely everything- maintenance, repairs, property taxes, utilities (seriously WTF? Do renters not pay utilities in the USA?) since renters have 0 bargaining power.
>>85981446The cartel will steal all of that and kill and torture anon and put it on Facebook live.
>>85981507No there are non extradition countries but the cartels there will kill you when food scarcity hits so either way you're ending up on Facebook live
>>85981682>tfw they add a phonk track before turning you into soup
>>85981498>You're not allowed to "withdraw your support" for your country. That's the literal definition of treason.I haven't given said support in the first place, they're unilaterally claiming it. Can't betray that which I never agreed to in the first place.
>>85981690There aren't, any country will immediately collaborate and hand over western draft dodgers. The will be sent to the frontline in massive human wave tactics whole women will chill in bali and theres nothing moids can do about it
>>85981699Indonesia won't send you back but would likely be a major battleground between the US and China. South Africa is a shithole. Honduras and Columbia has problems that I already explained. There isn't a safe country except maybe Morocco if you're Muslim
>>85981728Yes there are. Indonesia refuses to extradite citizens it's been in their constitution since their independence. I'd have to renounce my US citizenship though
>>85981742They will amend it and will force all nations to hand over western citizens. Then they will be shipped to the battlefield and serve as drone bait
>>85981605Artificial indian seems to agree that you are not just wrong but embarrassingly wrong. $48,000 each month vs $0 each month. I'm not a sore winner though. I will kindly give you a very good offer. Buy me another house and I will rent it to you. If rent is truly better than owning you would gladly accept such a deal. I'll even give you half off for the first year and only charge $24,000 a month. >>85981624When I rented everything was constantly fucked. I paid all utilities but when something broke we couldn't use the utilities I paid for, landlord wouldn't fix it, and it wasn't allowed to do any repairs. And rent went up every time come time to renew the lease which was every year. No lifetime option available where it is locked in permanently until I decide to move. Also couldn't sell the place I was renting. Could sublet it, but that costs extra in rent and somehow I would still be liable for all costs and damages to the place. Renting is beyond cucked.Something as small as changing the paint color was not allowed. Asking landlord to paint it himself if I buy the paint was ignored. Asked him to put in gas line so I could get a real stove and no. The air conditioner was broken the entire time I lived there and they said I had to remove the window unit air conditioner I bought because that's against the contract or something.
>>85981733Algeria would probably go (turkey) ham when they get the chance so not even there. Not to mention all the hergawi moving back which will give problems on its own.
>>85981763No they won't. They're not cucked like Western countries and they're aligned with China
>>85980487you should be in a warring army with conscription to actually have a proper PoV on the matteritt is just retards posturing with obvious shit and playing armchair warlords
>>85981787Do you even study geopolitics? In fact Indonesia and I mean the Sudanese regions are pretty safe
>>85981798And plus since my family is Indonesian I automatically have citizenship there.
>>85981787Yes they will. Beside white men are garbage so countries will happily hand them over
>>85981823I'm Indonesian so I automatically have citizenship there. I'm a dual citizen muah hu hu
>>85981624You're right in stating that what introduces a complication to this conversation is that the particular breakdown in costs of ownership depends on what country/area you live in. So I dunno, maybe you live in Russia and you have a mafia-like cartel running the place that's fleecing you for every penny every month with zero actual market conditions that would result in owning generally not resulting in being that much cheaper than renting. If that's the case, then my apologies. I assumed you live somewhere in the west.
>>85981682>>85981690Wouldn't it make more sense for them to go serfing? Threaten to cartel video xhim unless xhe gives them some of the eggs and potatoes xhe grows? That's how peasants and lords traditionally worked. Cannibalism only gets you one meal, but make a man be a farmer in exchange for protecting him from cartels gives a lifetime of french fries and omelettes.
>>85981839True. It's more likely they shake anon down
>>85981770>Artificial indian seems to agree that you are not just wrong but embarrassingly wrong. $48,000 each month vs $0 each month.If you set up an experiment scenario of "make up whatever conditions so that I'm right", then that's not really saying much. The questions is, on average, if you owned the house you're renting, how much cheaper would that be? And that depends on many variables but essentially boils down to renting not being that much more expensive than home ownership. But you already know that, since you typing such a specifically-worded and clearly infuriated question to the "Artificial Indian" tells me you didn't get an answer you liked with a more neutral and generally worded question. But again, it depends on the area you live in. As I said to the other guy, if you live in some corrupt shithole like Russia with a single-oligarch monopoly on a whole sector of the economy then it might be much different. But I noticed that you didn't answer the question I posed to you: where did I lie? You specifically said that I lied about something separate from the topic of our discussion in an attempt to discredit my stance on the topic of our discussion. So where is it? It's telling that you're running from this.
>>85981835I was under the impression Italy is a western country, but I guess you'll just keep moving the goalposts. Note how you completely avoided addressing the point that the comparison you proposed only works (well not really) if the owner is still paying the mortgage- because it completely destroyed your argument. Concession accepted.
>>85981892Every post you lied. Owning is cheaper than renting but you lie and say it's not. I asked neutrally and it still says RENT MORE EXPENSIVE SAAR.I do live in America so perhaps we are uniquely the only country in the world where having a house is good, but Europe and everywhere else it's better to not have a house. I am speaking only from my limited experience of being an American. Here where things actually matter it is hands down without question no exceptions always better to own than rent. And I'm honest enough and conceited enough to ask why the specific situation in some bumfuck European country like Russia is even remotely relevant when talking about housing on an American website while communicating in the American language?
>>85981905I mean, if you want to buy a house outright without having to pay off the mortgage, then nobody is stopping you. But it would be silly to not factor that in when comparing costs to renting. Could you remind me what it is that you're upset about exactly?
>>85980938I would say there is a case to be made for conscription if your nation is facing an actual land invasion but it is almost always completely uncalled for when it's to attack a foreign nation on their own grounds for dubious intentions, and I don't think I would be going out on a limb when I say that most people today don't trust their government to not be harboring such intentions when it comes to foreign intervention.
>>85981398>And conscription is just a concept that was invented with civilizationWasn't really a big thing until the french revolution, actually
>>85981937>Owning is cheaper than renting but you lie and say it's notWhere did I say that? I explicitly said all throughout this thread that owning is cheaper then renting, but it comes out to single-digit profit margins. Maybe I wasn't clear enough about it, but I want you pointing me to my words and quoting them. I want to see whether you're engaging with me in good faith, because so far it looks like the truth of the matter doesn't seem that important to you.
>>85981950>monthly costs of home bought outright>$0>monthly costs of home rented>(varies)Hmmmm, yes, totes worth comparing these two. Paying more for something you don't own may be better than paying nothing for something you do own in some scenarios like soviet Italy. Those damn spaghetti communists always seizing the means of linguine.
>>85981964I never profited from renting in the past or from owning now. You say there's a profit margin. I call that a lie. How much are you profiting from paying rent? Give an exact percentage or yuro amount, I'm fine with either. How exactly does your capitalist venture of renting the place you live in even work? That's not a proper business in the American sense. Does profit mean something different in europe?
You people all think you're so tough. They will literally torture you and break your spirit
>>85981971So you're upset that you have to pay for the house you want to buy? And to be clear, the cost of a home bought outright isn't 0. You're just not paying for the mortgage. I don't know what exactly you pay for in Italy, but I imagine having to pay for things such as utilities, renovations, and land taxes. But hey, maybe in Italy the government swoops in and pays for your light bulbs whenever they break, idk.
>>85981960There's only a case made for conscription when all the politicians and their children have died on the frontlines defending the country first. Seems harder to get behind when they say we should die while they keep sipping caviar and champagne in their synagogue mansions in the capital.As things are I can't imagine things getting worse in any noticeable way if Russia, China, or Iran were to storm the beaches and completely take over America. I might have to learn a second language but otherwise literally nothing in life changes. I go to work, pay taxes, jerk my dick before getting five hours of sleep and going back to work because I don't have a wife or family or home or anything. If I were more spiteful I might even wish they would overthrow our country. Ni hao vodka inshalah, o algoroni
>>85981995You're not engaging with my question. I'll ask you again for the third time: You specifically said that I lied about something separate from the topic of our discussion in an attempt to discredit my stance on the topic of our discussion. So where is it? You then also said that I said "Owning is cheaper than renting". Where is it? There's no point engaging with you if you cannot substantiate those claims unless you admit to me that you lied and you wish to proceed with the discussion despite that. As I said, it already seems to me like the truth of the matter of the discussion we're having doesn't seem of particular relevance to you.
>>85982029You have to learn a different language anyways Spanish o algo
>>85982031*You then also said that I said "Owning is cheaper than renting but you lie and say it's not."
>>85982013>great outrage>happened a month ago>nothing actually happenedrepeat after me: nobody cares about male lives
>>85981950>I mean, if you want to buy a house outright without having to pay off the mortgage, then nobody is stopping you. But it would be silly to not factor that in when comparing costs to rentingThis argument was refuted earlier:>>85981624>A lot of rental properties here in Europe today were already paid off 200-800 years ago and simply pass down from father to sonConcession accepted.
>>85982048Think that won't happen in the West? It will and nobody will do a thing about it
>>85982029>There's only a case made for conscription when all the politicians and their children have died on the frontlines defending the country firstI agree. The political elite should also be the military elite like they were in the 19th century. Power and prestige should come with the expectation that members of their family will be on the frontlines personally leading troops. Hell, it wouldn't even be that great of a sacrifice for them in the modern era, what with warfare quickly shifting to favor drones and robotics.
>>85982031Since you are thicker than set concrete I'll give up. You win. You should keep renting, it's got electrolytes and profit margins. Personally I prefer my place so I'll keep doing the smart thing. You do the profitable thing and pay your landlord. Rents due on the first so don't forget. But don't worry too much about it, I'm sure he'll remind you if you miss a payment.
>>85981960That's fair and I agree with you. The one little nuance wrinkle I'd add is that a foreign intervention can theoretically be an existential matter for a country. For example, if another country is actually racing towards obtaining a nuke (so not like situations in Iraq or Iran), proclaims genocidal intentions towards your country, and your professional military doesn't have an overwhelming advantage against the opposing military. But it's hard for me to imagine another scenario where a draft would be justified for a foreign intervention.
>>85982053I don't know if it will happen, I do know that if it happens then no one will give a shit
>>85982073I know I'll be chilling in Bali because my parents are Indonesian
>>85982061>The one little nuance wrinkle I'd add is that a foreign intervention can theoretically be an existential matter for a countryI agree with that, though that is also why I added the bit about dubious intentions. Unless this hypothetical hostile nation goes on TV and announces their intent, I don't think the people would be willing to take the current government at its word. Maybe a more trusted administration could get away with it but not this one.
>>85982050If you want to rent a house in an area where all the properties have been paid off centuries ago, and there is an actual competition among landlords, then guess what? The mortgage is not factored into your rent neither. Neither do you have to pay off the mortgage if you want to buy a house in that area. So what's the issue that you have? It's paid off. There's no mortgage. What are you complaining about? It's a different matter if some houses are paid off and other ones aren't in that same area, of course, as that may introduce a more complex market rate calculation, but that doesn't seem like the particular scenario you're laying out in front of me.
>>85982090>The mortgage is not factored into your rent neither.Exactly! hence why owning is cheaper than renting.>Neither do you have to pay off the mortgage if you want to buy a house in that area.Wut? Are you saying the landlord who owns all the houses will gift me one for FREE? That's hecking awesome! LolIts kinda funny how you keep coming up with these nonsensical replies in a desperate attempt to keep the argument going (that you lost), lol you should definitely keep going, thank you for the continued engagement
>>85982073Only Jewish men's lives matter in the West. Nobody else.
>>85982118They had some jews drafted in Ukraine and Israel had to intervene to get some of them to work as frontline medics instead of being trench fodder. Only women's lives actually matter.
>>85982060Alright, I'll lay off. You just got a bit heated, that's all. Despite everything, it was nice talking to you. Have a good day.
>>85982129Still Jewish men's lives matter more than any other mans in the West. They got to leave first.
>>85982141>Jewish men's lives matter more than any other mansthat's true, but it's still nothing compared to women's perceived value
>>85982114>Exactly! hence why owning is cheaper than renting.No? That's not why. Owning is cheaper than renting because the landlord has to make a profit, but my issue with you is that you're blowing this profit margin IN GENERAL out of proportion. Is there some specific area you have in mind where it's particularly cheap to purchase a house and pay its maintenance fees, but expensive to rent? At this point I'm genuinely confused what you're trying to convince me of.
>>85981839Diaspora will return to these countries too though. An outsider will have zero bonds if he can even get in
>>85982218Besides government will just torture draft dodgers, feed them a bunch of drugs and meds and send to to die in wars. Such is the life of a scrote. Sorry not sorry
>>85982218My parents are Indonesian so I'll probably just go to Bali at that point.
>>85982264Ukraine does it so I don't see why Western governments wouldn't
>>85982276Indonesia is dependent on foreign trade for staples and this will only further be strained if diaspora returns. This is even more so the case for oil imports.Indonesia is also one of the biggest importers of fertilizer. Sure, you can go back without but yields will be diminished.You will maybe get by in some volcanic jungle village tho, not Bali unless you have money money money baby
>>85980938The only purpose of state is to round sheeple up in the pen for the convenience of shearing their wool. Aka tax theft.
>>85982287Indonesia has an advantage due to volcanic soils. Most other countries not so much. If a foreigner comes to a different country in times of strain he'll be torn apart by the locals.
>>85982287If they do not ground all planes, otherwise this wont even matter
>>85981064They just got taxes imposed on them by a different entity. Functionally nothing changed. By the way, just in case you are not aware, in case of war locals of whoever is attacked will get raped and pillaged by their own "state" as well, and mayhaps even, MOSTLY by their own state.
>>85982292You need taxes to keep the state maintained. Who will pay for the roads? Who will pay for the military when the bad guys come to rape you? Who will pay for the disposal of trash? Who will pay the judge when you sue your neighbor for groping your ass? You need taxes for all those things. Plus it's not theft if it's a part of the social contract. As long as you're free to leave when you reach adulthood, then it's not really forced on you. You want to stay and be a part of the society? You have to accept the social contract which includes paying to maintain the state. Don't want to? You're have to leave.
>>85982309Maybe, it wont matter if indonesia imports most of its oil and the crude they import is from countries likely suffering at least a famine like nigeria
>>85982330*Note: if you try to leave the state will put you in prison. You can't actually leave and if you don't need or want the services provided by the government they are afraid of you and will kill you. Pay your taxes even if you receive exactly zero benefits from the government. It's a social contract. You signed it, and if you didn't, yes you did. It's against the law not to agree with the demands of the state that hates you and actively tries to make your life worse.
>>85982408>Note: if you try to leave the state will put you in prisonNo, you're actually free to leave. Nobody will stop you. Unless you live in some authoritarian nation that explicitly keeps you inside like North Korea (or the Soviet Union in the past). The question is: will the place you're going to accept you? And if not, you can always get a tourist visa to e.g. Brazil and fuck off deep into the Amazon and literally nobody will bother you there, because it's pointless to go looking for you.
>>85982440If the population doesn't accept you you'll end up on a Facebook live gore stream anyways so it's worth a shot
>>85982330All those service are just an attempt at vision of compromise to dull down your vigilance. They want you to trust them of course. So that when it actually matters, they have accumulated enough to fuck you over completely. You do not actually needs roads, internet and all this gay shit. Humans have lived for millennias without it all, and those who still can are desperate to preserve their lifestyles and keep globoschlomo away. Unfortunately, because the nature of state is violence, they are not allowed to do that and schlomo will try to undermine and make illegal every single attempt at independant life. You growing your own grain without giving a portion of it to a man with a gun is a crime against god or something.
>>85982509No, they will simply not let you into the country. No need to be overdramatic. So to sum up: if you want to live in a society, you have to abide by the social contract, which includes paying your share that's needed to keep the state functioning. If you don't, you're free to leave.
>>85982440You dont understand what you are talking about you dumb child. It is literally ILLEGAL TO BE HOMELESS in most parts of the world. Quantillionaires own every single piece of land on earth, a land that they DID NOT CREATE by the way, and will shoot you if they see you trespassing without paying . And they WILL see you, they employ fucking drones nowadays to nag over land that they dont even do anything with
>>85982546True. And if they have extradition treaties they'll simply kick you out shortly after getting the arrest warrant
>>85982579Its illegal to be homeless, illegal to camp, to sleep in your car, illegal to collect rainwater, illegal to collect already dead trees from the forest , illegal to put up solar panel if your house is not on X axis, illegal to grow crops that your country dislikes, et cetera millions of retarded regulations like this. You may have seen a girl here who had some weird pregnancy cult going on, and there was nothing actually dubious going on there and government still hunted them down. > free to leaveLeave where? "Society" has appropriated and stolen and gated every single thing in this world without actually creating most of it. You, we, I we are also owned, gated, appropriated, any freedom you have can only exist as long as it doesn't cause men with guns to lose money. You dont even own your children, if you dont send them to brainwashing institutions they will send child abuse services unto you and take children away to boarding schools. Free my ass. I don't even care about the actual monetary part of taxes, I dont lose that much from them on its own, but that is just their internal motivation, a reason for the state to exist - to make you pay to for the right to live. Not to make you pay for services oh no, that you do anyway when you utilize the service, but you have to pay for existing itself too. To men with guns. Or swords. Whatever mode of violence is in fashion right now. That is the problem, the fundamental principle, not the price.
>>85982546Leave to where exactly? If everywhere has a, state and they all make unreasonable demands in the name of le social contract, I don't exactly see how we are free to leave. Can't I just declare the current place I live independent and no cops, laws, or taxes apply? Understandable if no. So can I go to Canada and do this? No? OK what about Mexico? Still no? Guess that rules out North America. How about Europe then? No? Asia? Africa? Planet earth? I don't have a spaceship so it needs to be somewhere on that planet.What if I go to Antarctica and set up a colony for people who don't want a social contract? We can eat fish, dolphins, seals, whatever. Will anyone stop me if I go there? My intent would be leaving and you claim I am able to leave if I don't like the social contract.
>>85982579I don't know where you live, but it's very much legal or de facto permitted to be homeless in large swaths of America and Europe.>>85982602Again, get a tourist visa to Brazil and disappear into the Amazon. Literally nobody will bother looking for you because it would be impossible to find you.>>85982703>Leave to where exactly?While it's probably not feasible to not be within the borders of some state unless you're willing to live e.g. in Antarctica, it's feasible for you to not live under the jurisdiction of a state even if technically within its borders. Again, go into the depths of Amazon. Literally nobody has ever set foot there. Nobody will find you there. Or go live in some failed state in Africa. If the goal is to get away from abiding by any state's set of rules, then it's very much doable.
>>85982801There are no places anymore where it "would be impossible to find you". Maybe back in the 00 but that era is gone. Everything is now constantly scoured by drones. And amazon is owned by loggers so they can literally just ran a tractor over you one random morning.
>>85982837Not to mention facial recognition software that can clock you by your gait alone
>>85980487yes but this sentiment is considered woke so you gotta die in horrific conditions fighting in a "war", sorry wokey. (unironically what rightists think)
>>85982837>There are no places anymore where it "would be impossible to find you".There are. You don't know how much land that's tough to explore in poorer nations has never had anyone visit it. There are literal tribes living in the fucking jungle who have never been contacted by anyone. Go there and voilla, you're free from le state oppressing you (damn state).>And amazon is owned by loggers so they can literally just ran a tractor over you one random morning.There are logging operations, but even in those areas the state already loses its jurisdiction. The people there constantly murder each other for money, practice literal sex slavery, and so on. If you want to be free from le state oppressing you, then you don't even need to go that deep in the Amazon, just go live with the loggers.
>>85982929I'm starting to think leaving is a bad idea, "it's totally possible you just have to agree to the social contract instead of agree to the social contract".Revolution might be better. If the people who believe in le social contract are killed then life improves for 99.999999% of people. If statists don't want to be revolutioned they just have to abandon the social contract. If they don't like this they are free to leave and enforce their social contract in the Amazon.
>>85980722AFAIK you only get to touch a loaded gun when you're pretty much on the frontlines, so your only targets are other poor fucks like you.
>>85983082Nigger, the only reason you get to live in a safe and cushy society is because of a rule-based order imposed by a state with monopoly on violence. Look at failed states with constant war and atrocities committed by fighting gangs and militant groups. Look at the complete and utter degeneracy of places like the logging camps in the Amazon which are essentially lawless and anarchic. Those aren't the conditions conducive to human thriving. The state can have excesses, as many authoritarian nations have demonstrated throughout history, but the answer to that isn't total anarchy. It's building states that are run with the consent of the governed. States that have a set of rules that the governed agree to follow. Or accept that the guys living next door will come to rape your ass and there's nothing you can do about it, because the horrific social contract demanded that you give a portion of your income to fund the police, so you tore it up. That or you fuck off to your anarchist paradise where you can be freely raped by the guys with the biggest sticks for all eternity.
>>85983127And they'll torture the rebellious attitude out of you like they do in Ukraine and Russia
>>85983230Nothing about America is safe or cushy, so I think this is worth trying. Time for lampposts. My ass is already being raped. If the neighbors try to do it too once the enemy has been removed they can be strung up on the very same lampposts.
>>85983318>Nothing about America is safe or cushyThe fish doesn't see the water it swims in. And you won't realize that it's important until it's gone. So do it. Get a visa to Sudan. If you live in America, it's unfathomably cheap to buy the two flights you need to get there. Try to live there for a while. See what it's like.
>>85980722they dumped men on the frontline in vans then armed them
>>85980487Make one of those.
>>85983374You have it backwards. The people who believe in social contract need to buy a ticket to Sudan and hope they get to the airport before they get to the lampposts. They are free to leave and enforce the social contract in Sudan at any time. It's really easy. But I'd rather see them hanging. Sudanians would probably prefer this too.
>>85983433I'll be honest bro. You seem like some jigaboo retard. Go shoot at each other using real guns with your tard friends Darius and Jamal as a joke. I'm done with your retarded "woe is me" narcissistic dogshit. Argue with some other cretin about how terrible it is to live in the most prosperous nation in the entire world and how much better it would be to live in a state of total anarchy. Newsflash, retard: if you're not making it in lawful rich rule-based America, you're not making it anywhere else, let alone a "might makes right" tribal war zone. Fate gave you as much as it could to realize your full potential and you still fucked it up. It's a "you" problem, not a problem with the concept of a state.
>>85983585Very interesting. Done yapping yet? Up you go!
>>85984072Man, old timey lamp posts were nice.