[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/r9k/ - ROBOT9001


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Ten_piedad.png (238 KB, 441x434)
238 KB PNG
In your opinion, what do you think of Mercy as a concept? I would consider myself not a particularly merciful person. At least not always I guess. I have been working on trying to be more merciful but its is hard. Mostly because I am not wrathful for vengeful reasons. I am wrathful because I don't want a person to do whatever they did to me again. I know I can never change the past but I don't ever want whatever happened to happen again. This line of thinking has inherently made me incredibly unmerciful unfortunately. So in your opinion, why is mercy good(or bad) and what do you think about it generally? I don't understand how anyone can be merciful honestly.
>>
mercy is sometimes good if you're doing it because you don't feel like punishing someone. it is bad when people use it as a form of protest non-participation in the cycle of violence. someone has to sit in the throne of judgement
>>
It's like religiously mandatory
>>
File: oldanime_Marathon.jpg (1.23 MB, 2385x2295)
1.23 MB JPG
>>85997668
I get it. Sometimes I wonder why some say everyone deserves mercy. I think my issue with it is that I can't tell if someone wouldn't just try to fuck me over again once I grant mercy somehow. I play a lot of extraction shooter video games like Escape from Tarkov and sometimes you can encounter players and spare them. I do it from time to time and sometimes they leave me be and we go our separate ways. Sometimes they back stab you and kill you once you go to leave. I get that both things could happen but it always leaves a sour taste in my mouth because imagine if this had been something in real life and not a game. I'd be fucked. What is hard to tell is who REALLY DESERVES the mercy because it can't be everyone right?
>>
>>85997653
Reminded me of something I read recently

(Article 5)
>Whether the daughters of vainglory are suitably reckoned to be disobedience, boastfulness, hypocrisy, contention, obstinacy, discord, and love of novelties?
>... ... ...
(Objection 3)
>Chrysostom says (Hom. xix in Matth.) that vainglory is always evil, but especially in philanthropy, i.e. mercy. And yet this is nothing new, for it is an established custom among men. Therefore eccentricity should not be specially reckoned as a daughter of vainglory.
>... ... ...
(Reply to Objection 3)
>Vainglory is reproved in connection with almsdeeds on account of the lack of charity apparent in one who prefers vainglory to the good of his neighbor, seeing that he does the latter for the sake of the former. But a man is not reproved for presuming to give alms as though this were something novel.
>>
>>85997734
Interesting. Hadn't really heard of vainglory before. Had to look it up to get a better idea. But I understood it as soon as I read it.
>>
>>85997744
The reason I was reading about it was because I mistook it for pride and thought it was the same thing.
So apparently a capital vice is a sin that generates other sin as offspring and pride is like the queen bee of the sin hive.

Sins don't really have their own origin, they are derivative of virtues that they oppose (e.g. faith, hope, charity, etc). So mercy falls under the virtue of charity. So being charitable should feel specially taxing for OP.
Confusingly he says he isn't wrathful for vengeful reasons but then suggests a vengeful motive. Wrath implies a vengeful motive.

I think what he means to say is that he is simply wrathful because of a trespass made against him and therefore as a result of wrath he has lost the virtue opposed to it (temperance). Thus deprived, he can't become meek (forbearing under injury or annoyance), or clement (lenient; not being excessively harsh with punishment).
>>
>>85997704
it's not that people don't deserve mercy, but it's that people also deserve punishment. christian morality has made people afraid of being the one to cast judgement, but we really need it to feel like our lives have value
>>
>>85997956
This really made me think. OP here. I actually have a somewhat easy time being charitable. The only thing that bugs me is being unable to confirm that my charity is actually helping and isn't just throwing money at some shadow corporation. For example, I donate to a friends church fund for christmas gifts for low income family children. I trust that my charity is helping because he takes the money and even shows videos of the church giving gifts to the children at their function etc. Do I know for CERTAIN that is true. No. But I trust it. Now when a store asks me "Do you want to donate 1 dollar to breast cancer?" and I say no. I don't feel I am saying no from a hateful place. I am saying no because I don't believe that dollar even does anything in that case. Is that a weird way to think about charity?

As for the wrath stuff. You might be right. I truly believe I rarely feel vengeful though. I hardly feel like "I am doing this to get even!" and more like "I am doing this because I can't risk you doing it again."

I was always curious about pride too. It always struck me as a weird sin but I can see how it can lead to some bad stuff if out of control.

>>85998102
I'd agree. It feels next to impossible to be merciful for everything and its hard to use judgment.
>>
>>85998252
On the contrary, I donate $1 to whatever charity at the whatever drive thru because if at least 99 other people do the same thing, that's $100 going somewhere that matters. If it's for a charity like feeding homeless people or starving children, doubly so. For research and similar charities, $100 is basically a day's pay for one of those overpaid R&D scientists so
>>
File: 1774432597673953.png (1.56 MB, 1280x720)
1.56 MB PNG
>>85998252
If you have an easy time being charitable, then I imagine you have no difficulty with mercy. Mercy desires the good of others in lowly states.

Words like "pride" and "meek" make no sense to me in modern english so I've found online etymology dictionaries very handy. They explain definitions in a really pleasingly concise way.
>pride
>unreasonable self-esteem
In the context of Aquinas it's principally between a person and God. The appropriate response to considering yourself before God would be humility. Therefore the sin opposing humility is just called pride.

So at every junction and opportunity for a sin, pride is operative. The connotation of the word humble seems really diminished these days, like anyone can say anything is humble, but humility seems to be a prerequisite for any virtue possible.

There is also another dimension to it which is that it can change the nature of your will. Like we mentioned earlier ITT, Chrysostom's example of somebody using almsgiving as an excuse to cloutfarm. Augustine described pride as something that lies in wait to ensnare you in your good deeds. But you can stop pride by awakening to the unreasonableness of it.

Anyway for the actual relevant subject matter,
>As for the wrath stuff. You might be right. I truly believe I rarely feel vengeful though. I hardly feel like "I am doing this to get even!" and more like "I am doing this because I can't risk you doing it again."
I was being pedantic and trying to figure out what best to call it. Maybe it's better understood as "reactive."
Hatred for example is the desire to punish something simply because you despise it.
Wrath is a desire to punish something to restore balance from a perceived upset. All of the mentions of anger, wrath, etc even in Aristotle speak of it in terms of revenging something. (Ethic. vii, 6). The more nonsensical it is, the funnier wrath looks, like if a machine stops working and then someone gets angry and kicks it.
>>
>>85998419
Interesting. For humility, I had a hard time understanding it also. On the surface, I understood humility to mean like... I can't even describe it right. Almost like not thinking you are great but I have found it to mean almost like "I AM NOT WORTHY!!!" or something like that. Its fun to think about these words actually. I have felt like I know what it means for awhile but never actually tried to describe it in words. However, is there such a thing as too much humility? One thing I personally struggle with is self confidence but is having general self confidence actually insanely prideful or not really? Is having a lot humility basically the same as having no self confidence?
>>
File: 1765762310834447.jpg (215 KB, 850x637)
215 KB JPG
>>85997653
Mercy cannot exist without understanding; otherwise it's pity.
You are all retarded terminally online morons.
Read Thomas Aquinas and Immanuel Kant, not fucking xitter.
Kill yourselves.
>>
File: 1767160504839190.png (166 KB, 1895x648)
166 KB PNG
>>85998473
Self-confidence doesn't inherently concern God, or in a secular way of thinking about it, an objective ideal you're comparing yourself to. If you're confident you can do something, then that's just a realistic expectation that comes from doing something successfully multiple times. Trying to manufacture a low opinion of yourself would be a misunderstanding of what humility entails. Likewise, having a high opinion of yourself doesn't necessitate spiritual pride.

Pride and humility principally concern your relationship with God or an objective standard. You are prideful when you declare the standard to be relative, or you make yourself your own God. Then you become unhappy as the results of that are usually bad. You are humble when you acknowledge the standard is objective, or you acknowledge God's superiority. They say that the first step to wisdom is "fear of the Lord." So in a spiritual sense, pride and humility are like unreasonableness and reasonableness. In order to even feel sorry for wrongdoings and a desire to reform yourself, reasoning with you has to be possible to begin with. In order to will disordered thoughts and actions, you have to be unreasonable to a degree.

I think the confusion comes from mixing common parlance with old texts from centuries ago. When we say humility, false-modesty, etc we're probably not talking about humility and pride in the context of morality. In fact the word humility carries the connotation of humiliation, "getting humbled," and therefore sounds undesirable. "Pride" likewise has no spiritual meaning to us moderns, we say something like "my son is my pride and joy," where by pride is simply meant a sort of delight in an affectionate sense of belonging/relation.

>>85998689
Kant is a goofy goober sperglord autist



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.