[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/sci/ - Science & Math

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Additional supported file types are: PDF
  • Use with [math] tags for inline and [eqn] tags for block equations.
  • Right-click equations to view the source.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


what is the current best guest about what actually exists? is it strings? membranes? fields?
>>
>>17093765
what do you understand by "exists"? what does that mean for you? how do you define it?
>>
>>17093781
here I mean most fundamental structures building observable reality
>>
>>17093785
so the roll of cheese you are seeing on the table, that you eat, and powers you, could "not be real"? you see it, you touch it, you eat it, and it powers you. is it not real?

I'm asking because you said
>>17093765
>what actually exists
and I think cheese actually exists
>>
>>17093793
what is cheese made of?
>>
>>17093785
Fields are proven to exist. Strings might exist, but even if they do we have no way to prove it. There's lots of alternative ideas but again there's no experimental evidence for any of them.
>>
>>17093804
ah so you are going to act like a faggot. clocked you.
>>17093785
>observable
can't you observe the cheese? something wrong with your eyes? you can feel it. you can taste it. you can feel the power it gives your body.
but no, you want to play games and act like a faggot. you will try to make some retarded fucking point.
>>
>>17093811
fuck off Epicurus, don't tell me you don't want to know what allows cheese to be so cheesy
>>
>>17093821
being cheesy makes it real for me
I'm fine with digging deeper into cheese but do not forget the cheesiness of it while you do it. else you arrive at retarded conclusions like cheest is not even real, whatever the fuck that even means
>>
>>17093765
Since 1995 Witten basically proved that string theory is just one limit of M-theory, and in M-theory strings basically get replaced by 2-branes (and I think it also has 5-branes). It’s a real shame how the history of M-theory has turned out: one horribly oversimplified “Matrix model” by BFSS, and then two decades of “shrug let’s work on other stuff”. Hull and Townsend are horribly underappreciated in the whole story of modern fundamental hep-th
>>
>>17093830
*three decades, holy shit im old now
>>
Probably strings
>>
File: IMG_3619.jpg (149 KB, 800x531)
149 KB JPG
>>17093765
>>17093781
Both of you exist as nothing more than a stream of photons emitted by my phone.
>>
>>17093765
aether theory figured it our millenia ago
>>
Im not reading any post in this thread as it is likely all brainless retards making things up. But the Standard Model is the current best answer for what everything is made of lol.
>>
File: hume.jpg (474 KB, 1280x1550)
474 KB JPG
>>17093765
>what actually exists?
Experience
>>
>>17095177
how does experience happen?
>>
>>17093954
>everything is made of lol
It started with a Big Joke.
A huge burst of kek, then it was just kidding until the sides hurt.
They're still debating if it ends in a long fading sensible chuckle or an abrupt lmao.
>>
>>17093804
Moon rocks
>>
>>17093765
Fields and particles are pretty well established
>>
>>17093765
Dude, you are asking that when we still dont know if the reality is discrete or continuous. Continuous is highly favored at the moment but no one can prove it, and there are still solid arguments in favor of it being discrete. We have the Zeno paradox of Achilles and the Tortoise, and if you look it up nobody can provide a satisfactory answer. Nobody. So how the fuck can we expect to unravel the nature of the Universe if we cant get our heads around a simple philosophical argument proposed some 2500 years ago? Experimental break throughs, new theories placed on top of the old ones, or new technology will not break the deadlock of understanding reality. What we need instead are conceptual breakthroughs on a scale similar to the very first primitive animals achieving sentience. Yeah, that level.
But I am guessing you have already ascertained what the fucking joke this board is for asking questions like yours. The subhumans on /sci/ will not give you any clues, at best they just parrot what their 12th grade teacher said. You are better off finding somewhere where mature inquiring minds are interested in such matters.
>>
>>17093765
Math and physics is a description of our knowledge (or ignorance) of the world, it’s not the world. So no, I don’t think one can perfectly describe internally something that resides outside.
>>17093793
Cheese is the name we associate to a pattern. The pattern is in our minds alone, it’s limited by your human senses.
>>17093809
Fields don’t exist, they’re mere bookkeeping devices. And as a matter of fact, they obscure a more profound description of reality because they describe approximately discrete structures. See Fermi-Ulam-Pasta-Tsingou experiment.
>>17095243
They’re well established in your mind maybe. How do you even measure a field?
>>
>>17093765
Everything you see before you is the result of your brain parsing information carried by light, meaning reality as we understand it is a shared hallucination that we pretend is real for the sake of learning and development of ourselves. Think it a shared dream, and Death is waking up from it.

But while we share this dream, it is at our mercy to experiment and play while learning more about us and oneanother and the nature of the dream.

I mean its pretty evident that the brain using chemicals (alchemy in your head so to speak) to process this information and assemble a view or what we think reality is, its not at all schizo to think that the shared 'hallucination' of machine elves on DMT are some form of real entity or collection thereof.

Consciousness is a well-constructed interface where the illusory universe around us is assembled to benefit our learning capabilities but is often taken for granted when we describe things as objective.

Everything is in a paradoxical state of objective and subjective.

Lets continue to play and experiment. Its a game we play as much as God plays, and God likes the technology we make. Its truly a shame tho that we make magical technology that is used to subjugate and kill others, ending their run in the dream early.
>>
>>17095491
OP here
I know that we don't experience reality as it is, everyone knows this at least since Kant.
I'm asking about our educated guess about building blocks.

Carlo Rovelli proposed not so long ago that even spacetime is a field, is it fields all the way down?
>>
>>17095522
>Carlo Rovelli
carlo is very cringe, anon. He’s like a Lee Smolin type character. His physics contributions are maybe a little significant, like 20 years ago, but then he jumped on the “I’m the ambassador to popsci of the marginalized physics community” and his shtick is the same as it has been for 20 years. Yes you don’t like string theory and yes you care about talking to philosophers, a lot. Bloviating to/for philosophers is very clearly a high priority for Rovelli.

But where is the substance? There isn’t any. He is a bloviator pure and simple. Even his tutor Lee Smolin is much better than Rovelli, but Smolin is an obvious profiteer as well. Very sad state of things in that camp
>>
>>17093765
Fields are the most fundamental thing that is conclusively observable. Really they are just a mathematical description though. They are not the "thing in itself". Or maybe they are, there's no way we can tell.
>>17095177
I agree with this.
>>17095198
Nobody knows. However it still happens.
>>
>>17095198
signals in the brain
>>
>>17095760
fields are approximation, they require the continuum to exist, which evidently doesn’t…
>>
>>17095986
this is low tier LLM vomit
>>
>>17095993
show me the field then
show me evidence of the continuum
put the money where your mouth is
>>
>>17095979
source: experience
>>
>>17095328
> Fields don’t exist
The Casimir effect, the Lamb shift, the anomalous magnetic moment, all would say otherwise. Hell, even particle anti-particle creation does too.
>>
>>17095760
I'd say fields definitely have substance, you can directly photograph the 3d globular structure of electromagnetic radiation.
>>
>>17095328
>How do you even measure a field?
NGS and NOAA, among other institutions, measure and monitor gravity and magnetism of the entire planet constantly
>>
>>17096051
signals in the CPU doesn't make the CPU experience

>>17096009
evidence of the fields are ... particles anon.
>>
>>17096073
okay, then how do you measure a field?
>>17096127
>measure and monitor
okay anon, i think it’s about time you tell me how a field is measured
>>17096131
that’s not even a sentence lol. how do particles prove that fields are real? real things can be measured. show me how a field is measured.
>>
>>17096381
> how do you measure a field?
> repeat question three times
Why are you so obsessed with this question? Do you think it's some science-breaking gotcha?

You measure them the same way you measure anything, by their effects.
>>
>>17093804
cheese is fundamental
>>
>>17096384
>obsessed with measurements
because it’s the only way to tell if something is real anon.
>You measure them the same way you measure anything, by their effects.
Good, so you must know then a way to measure something like the electric field. Let’s hear it then. Stop being vague and put an end to this debate. Tell us step by step how something like the electric field is measured and I will concede.
>>
>>17096386
to be more precise, cheese is fondue-emmental
>>
>>17096386
cheesons make up cheese
>>
>>17096524
>Tell us step by step how something like the electric field is measured and I will concede.
https://www.nist.gov/noac/technology/magnetic-and-electric-fields/electric-field-metrology
>>
>>17096706
oh anon, the measured signal comes from the atoms, not the electric field. try again
>>
File: 1734534263316.jpg (68 KB, 733x702)
68 KB JPG
>>17096747
>t.
>>
>>17096747
you really are an idiot.
>>
File: IMG_3715.gif (162 KB, 480x202)
162 KB GIF
>>
>>17096759
>>17096754
>troglodytes don’t understand direct vs indirect measurements
>>
>>17093765
potentials
>>
File: fag.png (225 KB, 603x332)
225 KB PNG
>>17096747
>fields arent real bro, they just aren't!
>>
>>17093793
tonight you will dream vivdly of the cheese roll. you’ll see it with closed eyes and eat it with a closed mouth, perfectly convinced of the illusion. is it less real once you wake up? what really differs is just that you wake up with memory.
>>
>>17093826
Cheesiness is just a chemical signal in your brain o algo
>>
>>17097363
>>17097366
your dreams don't keep your belly full anon. real has consequences. imaginary doesn't mean much for reality
try imagining you're drinking some water when you're thirsty. see how that works out for you in a few days.
>it's just signals in the brain bro
>>
>>17097368
this guy can’t recall any conscious experiences before age 3 but wants to lecture me on water (with literally step one of water drinking btw)
>>
>>17097372
>goes on schizo rant unprompted
>>
>>17097374
>says nothing of substance again
>>
>>17097376
address my argument you faggot. how does thinking about water keep your thirst at bay and keeps your body functioning and healthy? since your argument is that thoughts about shit aren't different than real shit. in your schizoid brain they are the same thing
>>
>>17097378
You pose a ridiculous question with an immature understanding of the topic and expect me to answer.
>Your dreams don’t keep your belly full
Except when you are dreaming that your belly is full. Don’t sneakily attempt to elude the problem. Every night you hallucinate reality and every night you believe it, until you wake up. WHAT makes you believe this one is any different from the others?
>>
>>17097380
since I am a healthy human I can discern between them.
again, there are consequences in reality. there are none in dreams. or in your imagination.

reality is that which consequences you cannot avoid. stop pretending you don't understand my point. you do, and you have no answer for it.

reality IS real because you cannot avoid the consequences. reality means laws, which you must obey, like it or not. you don't drink water and you cannot avoid the consequences no matter how much you pretend they do not exist.

we call that "reality". exactly because you cannot avoid its consequences. you must obey this universe's laws, regardless of how much you piss and shit your pants
>>
>>17097381
You only experience reality through your consciousness. You think your belly is full because chemicals and electric signals in your body tell you so. I'm sure you heard about people that thought they were healthy, when in fact they were delusional.
For all you know you can be Zhuangzi sleeping on a stone and dreaming about being a faggot.
>>
>>17097380
>an immature understanding of the topic
calling the kettle black, tbqh
>>
>>17097467
He is right, the other guy doesn't understand that the very laws that you're supposed to obey about reality also say that whatever you know or you've learned before can be thrown in the trash at any moment, no matter how fundamental it may seem. If reality exists regardless of our ability to perceive it, we do not know if we have access to it, and if it's simply whatever we perceive then it's obviously not as rigid as it may seem
>>
>>17095756
So who in your opinion is the best specialist in this area?
>>
>>17097366
And where is chemical-signaliness at?
>>
>>17097468
the subjectivity of your perception doesn't change anything about reality. you either get it right either get it wrong. which is what science is supposed to help with, to get it right.
you're conflating your perceptions and experience with reality itself which is retarded
>>
>>17098218
which sense data tells you anything about reality itself?
>>
>>17098218
We indeed draw some smart conclusions from the data we see.
What I'm wondering is will we ever be able to say with fair amount of certainty we know what's out there where we cannot see. For example if everything is just fields or particles interacting in certain ways that we can detect or imply, how many are other particles is there interacting in other ways? How different structures can they evolve into?
>>
fields, and the states of matter are their standing waves
>>
>>17098354
Mathematics is not necessarily a description of reality itself, but a formal description of the relationships and structures through which reality becomes intelligible to us. The fact that the same physical phenomena can be represented through different mathematical frameworks suggests that our descriptions should not automatically be confused with the things they describe.
>>
>>17098224
any and all. depends how lucky or unlucky you are. if you're colorlind or deaf or blind you get less info about reality
>>
>>17098354
the senses are no different to any kind of measurement apparatus. theoretically you could plug a pair of scintillators into your brain and get a decent overview of the radioactive shit around you. provided the data is mapped somehow. senses have a natural mapping as it were, specialized for the data type.
eyes are also lower resolution and not the best shit out there. representation is not ideal, you see yellow when yellow photons strike your eye cells and also when red + green photons strike your eye cells. eyes were just good enough for their purpose
>>
>>17098749
Oh are dreams reality?
>>
>>17093765
Me.
>>
>>17098752
I agree, for all intends and purposes every sensors we can construct they can be just extensions of our built-in senses.
What about fields and particles we can't or or didn't think of building sensors for?
How confident can we be that there are particles outside the standard model that are undetectable for us? I'm not even talking about dark matter or dark energy, but could there be some forms of particles that don't happen to interact even with gravity?
>>
>>17093765
Fields but not photon, electron, quark...etc. A space field, a time field, a mass field...etc. Particles exist at the intersections of these fields.
>>
>>17093765
It finds the energy level then it nits 4 circles to intersect into a stable point particle.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.