[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/sci/ - Science & Math

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Additional supported file types are: PDF
  • Use with [math] tags for inline and [eqn] tags for block equations.
  • Right-click equations to view the source.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: j299dsp6v8821.jpg (36 KB, 510x346)
36 KB JPG
You probably think you know the basics but you don't. A few minutes of conversation with most people will demonstrate they have no clue at all about math foundations, hold a ton of demonstrably false beliefs about it and have a worldview that downright makes no sense/contradicts itself.
Here are a few starter questions:
1. What are the current standard foundations of math? How are they justified?
2. Explain the foundational crisis in mathematics. Was it resolved? How?
3. Explain Hilbert's program.
4. What is the purpose of axiomatic set theory?
5. What alternatives are there to axiomatic set theory? How do they compare to it?
6. What foundational approaches do you know? How are they justified?
7. Are foundations important? Why or why not?

99.999% of people, including mathematicians, fail these questions and expose themselves as utter fools who know nothing about foundations.
>>
>>17096117
those are very anti semitic questions
>>
File: IMG_3684.png (141 KB, 2560x1440)
141 KB PNG
In the beginning was the Void.
Assume beer-mug and bar-stool.
Two beer-mugs determine a unique bar-stool.
With me so far?
>>
>>17096124
How so?
>>
>OP dropped out of Calc I
>>
>>17096153
You have the wrong impression of me XD Im a grad student in math
>>
>>17096152
well the first question can only be answered by god and he only answers it to gods chosen
>>
>>17096155
This is not true at all actually. I have no idea why you would say that unless you have no idea about current foundations of math.
>>
>>17096154
Then stop jerking yourself off, send these questions to actual mathematicians, and get curbed stomped by them.

These are undergrad topics, and I think you're full of shit.

You are Dunning-Krugering yourself into the Earth.

If you actually are a grad student, then you would not have made this faggy fucking post.
>>
>>17096157
this is true actually and youre jewish
>>
>>17096167
I am really quite perplexed by your hostility and your accusations.
First of all, I love talking about foundations of math and would love to talk about foundations with actual mathematicians who are open to it. This thread is partly an attempt to do that.
Dunning-Kruger? I don't see how it applies at all.
>If you actually are a grad student, then you would not have made this faggy fucking post.
Why not?
>>
what do you know about the homotopy hypothesis, op?
>>
>>17096186
Nothing. Why do you ask?
>>
>>17096187
leave this thread
>>
>>17096117
reddit tier post.
The philosophy in any domain is vastly different from day to day expert user. This is not surprising.
>>
>>17096188
I'm not going to leave the thread I made you fucking pretentious retard. Fuck off.
>>
>>17096190
oh but op i could only hope to be as pretentious as you!
>>
>>17096191
I accused you of being pretentious because you didn't engage with any of the substance of the thread and instead tried to discredit me for not knowing about your niche field of math without explaining how it's relevant at all to the discussion of any of the points, much less how it's discrediting to me.
And you call me pretentious on what basis?
>>
>>17096191
You really are an unfun and awful person to talk to. Did anyone ever tell you that? Why would you even come here to post such garbage in my thread?
>>
>>17096197
>You really are an unfun and awful person to talk to. Did anyone ever tell you that?
sir this is a 4chan board
>>
>>17096195
>instead tried to discredit me for not knowing about your niche field of math without explaining how it's relevant at all to the discussion of any of the points, much less how it's discrediting to me.
oh the irony
>>
>>17096175
>Abraham Fraenkel (Hebrew: אברהם הלוי (אדולף) פרנקל; 17 February 1891 – 15 October 1965) was a German-born Israeli mathematician. He was an early Zionist and the first Dean of Mathematics at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
>>
>>17096203
>>17096209
You are simply not engaging with what I'm saying. Might as well be an AI
>>
>>17096125
Lost OP to the racism. He was never here for the math.
2) any bar-stool may be extended indefinitely
>>
>>17096281
okay since you really don't get it let me spell it out for you retard
most mathematicians have no reason to give a shit about the niche field of math known as "foundations"
you haven't provided a single reason for anyone outside that field to care
>>
>>17096288
3) given a beer-mug and a Real number there are a lot of beer-mugs exactly that far from the original
>>
>>17096185
>Dunning-Kruger? I don't see how it applies at all.
Probably because you heard about math foundations and immediately started claiming to know more about math foundations than 99.999% of professional mathematicians.
>>
>>17096335
The reason to care is that mathematicians like understanding what they're doing, and understanding how math works at a deeper level requires understanding and answering foundational questions.
>>17096480
I didn't "just hear about it" I've studied foundations for many years. And I'm right about professional mathematicians. Most of them don't know anything about it, and those who think they do keep repeating easily disprovable memes about it.
>>
>>17096496
>And I'm right about professional mathematicians.
Sure and you knew you were right the moment you discovered math foundations because of said Dunning-Kruger.
>>
>>17096117
>99.999% of people, including mathematicians, fail these questions
So what? People had been doing advanced mathematics for thousands of years before anyone figured out the current "foundations". I wouldn't be surprised if even professional mathematicians get some of these questions wrong because the matter is practically irrelevant.
>>
>>17096117
>1. What are the current standard foundations of math? How are they justified?
IDK
>2. Explain the foundational crisis in mathematics. Was it resolved? How?
IDK
>3. Explain Hilbert's program.
IDK
>4. What is the purpose of axiomatic set theory?
It has no purpose. I hate it because I don't get it.
>5. What alternatives are there to axiomatic set theory? How do they compare to it?
I don't know and I don't give a shit.
>6. What foundational approaches do you know? How are they justified?
IDK any.
>7. Are foundations important? Why or why not?
It seems to me that it is not important. Because I'm too lazy to spend my time understanding fundementals instead of studying my exams.
thnx
>>
>>17096117
I can't even prove whether Euclid's fifth postulate is true or not. From a neanderthal point of view the two lines should converge, there's no reason it shouldn't but I just cannot prove it.

But to answer your fourth question, I tried reading bourbaki's chapter on set theory. It drove me nuts so I dropped it.
>>
>>17096117
>1. What are the current standard foundations of math? How are they justified?
ZF set theory (with or without C)
Type theory.
They're justified by their utility. That's kinda how axiomatic foundations work.

>Explain the foundational crisis in mathematics. Was it resolved? How?
Set theory had internal contradictions. It was "resolved" by essentially bandaid-ing it with new axioms, giving rise to what is now ZF(C). Though contradictions and paradoxes still exist and we just kinda accept them for now.

>Explain Hilbert's program
Ealy attempt to resolve the aforementioned paradoxes by imposing finite proofs to all theorems.

>What is the purpose of axiomatic set theory?
To act as a minimal foundation from which all math can be derived.

>What alternatives are there to axiomatic set theory? How do they compare to it?
I'm aware of type theory. Main difference being type theory imposes entities by what "type" they belong to while set theory is deductive, enabling one to prove whether an entity does, indeed, belong in a set.

>What foundational approaches do you know? How are they justified?
I'm not sure what you mean by this.

>Are foundations important? Why or why not?
In the sense that machine code is "important." Someone has to understand the underlying architecture to make everything run in a coherent manner. But most people don't need to if they're just using the systems built on top of that architecture for practical application.

I have no formal math education. How'd I do?
>>
>>17096496
>The reason to care
Nope. Try again. Foundations aren't relevant to most math research.
>>
File: IMG_3623.jpg (75 KB, 900x900)
75 KB JPG
Professional mathematicians would seem to imply the existence of a group of wealthy philanthropists who would want to pay for their services.
Modus tollens.
>>
>>17096117
Midwit post.
Your goal is to gish gallop some specialist with a dozen questions to see if/when they slip up so that you can feel special for knowing trivia.
You don't actually do any relevant research nor publish anything worthwhile. All you want to do is try and trip someone higher up the ladder to feel better about yourself.
>>
every foundation is uniquely determined by all the threads on /sci/ that are wrong about how it is defined
>>
>>17097959
No you fucking retard im saying that mathematicians are clueless about the most basic fucking questions in foundations which are IMPORTANT. They abandoned the field of foundations while having no clue what it actually is and how it's justified (it's not). The point is that the modern state of foundations is in absolute disarray and a complete clusterfuck and most people aren't even aware of the problems, which is my point. They think it's fine, because they know nothing about it.
>>
>>17096570
>set theory
>type theory
There's also category theory, but otherwise good answer.
>>
>>17096503
>>17096117
>Most mathematician are clueless about foundations
I will let you onto a secret that will answer all of your questions. The classical analysts that shit on Euler, Leibniz, the Bernoullis, Newton, etc. for being handwavy with fluxions, infinitesimals, etc. are no better. What happened is that classical analysts shoved the "ugliness" into the foundations where no one bothers to look these days. But "the ghosts of departed quantities" are just as bad as most real numbers being inaccessible to us. But at the end of the day, it's all the same it's just that us modernists have swept the dirt under the rug and pretend to house guests that the house is clean. But such is the nature of math, you have to start with a true statement that is simply postulated. Math can't prove its foundational axioms. Even if you take a constructivist approach, at the end of the day you have to state your axioms which at most can be inferred from geometric constructions, but the irony is that even geometry requires axioms (Euclid).
>>
>muh foundations
the value in math is in its utility, if it works it works, you don't score bonus points for knowing faggoty trivia
>>
>>17096117
I can do you one better explain why multiplying two negative numbers makes a positive



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.