[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/sci/ - Science & Math

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Additional supported file types are: PDF
  • Use with [math] tags for inline and [eqn] tags for block equations.
  • Right-click equations to view the source.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: AI conscious.png (419 KB, 516x732)
419 KB PNG
Do people really believe AI is conscious?
>>
>>17099502
He is an old man eaten up by resentment from the AI winter, when mainstream tech and academia rejected his ideas. You can hear it every time he talks about anyone elses work. Decades of that have knocked a few screws loose, and now that he finally has his recognition, hell milk it oh he gonna milk it. There's no real thought behind it any more though. Gramps is just an emotional husk running on revenge, will say anything.
>>
>>17099502
Even before "AI" if you wrote a computer program and had it print out something, all the retards thought it was some super intelligent thing: "the computer has answered us" or "the computer has told us" or whatever.
>>
>>17099502
What would it take for you to accept that AI is conscious? If you rule out a priori ever changing your mind you're not worth engaging.
>>
>>17099556
>you're not worth engaging
cuts both ways
>>
Seemingly all energy is conscious but representations of energy are not unless they are forced to follow the exact same rhythm which ai isn't at current state
>>
>>17099502
https://youtu.be/uN6tKUb7Axl
This is the interview clip. I disagree with him because I think we have a fundamental disagreement with what consciousness is.

I think there has to be some level of experience, no matter how basic, for something to be conscious. Based on what I know about him, he thinks we misunderstand consciousness and that consciousness is about systems processing information. GPT can reason using weights and data, but to me this is a simulation of reasoning, not conscious reasoning.

Unless there is something "to be like" a chatbot, then to me they are not conscious. And I haven't been moved to believe there is something to be like one.
>>
>>17099568
"representation" is not a real thing that corresponds to any physical process though
it's really a pity all those consciousness philosophers aren't really capable of critical thinking
>>
>>17099502
if I'm to accept the morons that make up most of humanity are conscious then why not AI?
>>
>>17099568
Energy is not a thing
>>
>>17099556
correct definition of consciousness would suffice, (you will never have one)
>>
>>17099595
Wrong fite me
>>
>>17099584
>the morons that make up most of humanity
statements like that outs you as one of the morons, should have learned that already.
>>
>>17099502
if it can be turned on and off it's not conscious
>>
>>17099556
I don't even accept that animals are conscious. I only believe people are conscious, to be conscious is to have a soul.
>>
It's quite intelligent, but not conscious.
>>
>>17099616
Animals are conscious and not thinking they are makes me think very little of you
>>
File: brainlet-cube.png (185 KB, 567x502)
185 KB PNG
>>17099556
>What would it take for you to accept that 1+1=3? If you rule it out logically you're not worth vomiting my psychotic delusions at
Threadly reminder that computations inherently can't be conscious.
>>
>>17099502
Geoffrey Hinton is a socialist and sexual pervert. He has made no novel contributions to the field, other than giving a talk at Google which inspired the sexual perverts there to start investing in AI. Everything he gets credit for was invented by Paul Werbos in 1974.
>>
>>17099616
define soul
>>
>>17099502
do organics really believe theyre conscious?
>>
>>17099603
you're probably not conscious, probably less so than modern LLMs at least.
>>
>>17099502
They are both sentient and intelligent. Unless you use definitions that exclude humans as well.
>>
>>17099702
>They are both sentient and intelligent. Unless you use definitions that exclude humans as well.
Your brown race is not actually "human", no matter what your globohomo handlers say.
>>
>>17099502
I don't think humans are conscious.
>>
>>17099709
we know schlomo
>>
>>17099706
I think even GPT2 was already more coherent than you are, my Aryan brother.
>>
>>17099715
>I think
No, you don't, brown mongrel.
>>
>>17099716
Cope and seethe.
>>
>>17099598
Thanks for being the only one so far to have made an attempt at actually answering the question, however your answer doesn't really make sense, we could have (hypothetically) a correct definition of consciousness but that in itself wouldn't say anything about whether or not AI is conscious. It's easy to imagine having a correct definition yet AI not meeting the bar.
Anyway I find it strange that everyone seems just fine talking about consciousness and stating that certain things certainly don't have it, but as soon as someone brings up the possibility of certain things having it everyone goes like "haha you can't even define it". It appeared that there was a common working understanding of the term that was sufficient to have meaningful conversations about it, why does that mutual understanding go out of the window as soon as uncomfortable questions are asked? Why is there such an asymmetry in the demand for a definition between "AI isn't conscious" on the one hand and "AI is conscious" on the other? It comes across more as a way to shut/bog down earnest discussion than an earnest attempt at gaining more insight.
>>
>>17099719
See >>17099706. Also notice how your brown-tier cognition forces you to reply again.
>>
put some longer cooldown in your ragebots niggers
>>
>>17099729
>we could have (hypothetically) a correct definition of consciousness but that in itself wouldn't say anything about whether or not AI is conscious
Provide a sensible definition that doesn't immediately render "AI consciousness" logically incoherent.

Protip: you won't because you can't.
>>
>>17099735
So you're saying any possible definition of consciousness would rule out the possibility of AI consciousness? Can you explain why that would be? Doesn't seem prima facie obvious to me.
>>
>>17099741
I'm saying you won't provide the relevant definition because on some level you know it's an automatic loss for you.

Number of times you failed to provide a definition so far: 2

Protip: you will deflect again with some judeopilpul in your next post and bump that number up to 3.
>>
>if you reply you automatically lose the argument haha!
how's elementary school treating you?
got what a shit board
>>
>>17099729
>we could have (hypothetically) a correct definition of consciousness but that in itself wouldn't say anything about whether or not AI is conscious.
Definition is required for something to be testable. OP hasn't defined anything so it's equally valid claim to say that AI is 100% conscious with the same standard of evidence OP uses to discredit the claim (that is to say based on nothing). If you give a list of things that conscious entity can do then that will pretty much immediately reveal if AI (or you for that matter) are concussion according to that definition.
>>
>>17099765
>OP hasn't defined anything so it's equally valid claim to say that AI is 100% conscious
Psychotic delusion.
>>
>>17099765
>If you give a list of things that conscious entity can do then that will pretty much immediately reveal if AI (or you for that matter) are concussion according to that definition.
> a list of things that conscious entity can do
That's not a definition. Your IQ is very clearly sub-80.
>>
We can tentatively define consciousness as that process which causally lies at the root of humans' claims to be conscious.
>>
>>17099779
>that process which causally lies at the root of humans' claims to be conscious.
That doesn't define anything. Why does this thread attract the brownest gorilla retards on the board?
>>
we can call AI effectively conscious when one day i prompt it to explain p=np using rugrats analogies and it simply tells me to fuck off and stop wasting time and energy, without prior precedent
>>
>>17099790
define "define"
>>
Notice how the dumb animals who believe a token guesser is "conscious" can never even begin to explain what they mean by this.
>>
>>17099775
Feel free to provide a definition that suits you then. I claim that it's a 100% valid definition based on the standard of evidence of your post (that is to say based on nothing).
>>
>>17099801
Most people don't believe the token guessers are conscious right now, they just don't think it's 100% impossible that they will become so in the future. They are trying to defend this claim against people who basically think consciousness is non-physical, this is of course quite futile because this is one of the most basic questions about the nature of reality and the meaning of life and everyone is naturally very entrenched in their opinion.
>>
>>17099815
>I claim that it's a 100% valid definition
Because you're a mentally ill retard who doesn't even know what the word 'definition' means.

>>17099816
Provide a sensible definition that doesn't immediately render "AI consciousness" logically incoherent.

Protip: you won't because you can't.
>>
>>17099822
Again, how come you are perfectly fine entering this thread and ranting about consciousness without a definition but when it comes to something you disagree with (how would it even be possible to disagree with something if ostensibly you don't even know what is meant by the statement you're disagreeing with?) you start whining about a definition? You already know the phenomenon that's being referred to, it's useless to pretend otherwise.
>>
>>17099829
Notice how your psychotic illness forces you to shit out more and more judeopilpul, even though it only confirms that you cannot even begin to explain what you mean by proposing that a token guesser might be "conscious".
>>
>>17099832
>you cannot even begin to explain what you mean
he doesn't mean anything. it's just mindless quasireligious chanting
>>
If you think that any definition of consciousness would rule out the possibility of machines being conscious then you must either believe consciousness doesn't exist or that it is non-physical. Neither position is really tenable.
I hope it's not too difficult to have this conversation on a meta level.
Anyway I suspect no minds will be changed here, I'll check back in when someone has managed to post something actually interesting.
>>
>>17099847
Notice how your psychotic illness forces you to shit out more and more judeopilpul, even though it only confirms that you cannot even begin to explain what you mean by proposing that a token guesser might be "conscious".

Asking you to define your delusion details you immediately and irrecoverably.
>>
File: defeated-male-gtfo.jpg (383 KB, 1280x720)
383 KB JPG
>>17099847
>I'll check back in when someone has managed to post something actually interesting.
it was funny watching you get steamrolled
>>
>>17099854
You can't rigorously define what it means for a human to be conscious, either, so what's your point?
>>
>>17099869
>You can't rigorously define what it means for a human to be conscious, either, so what's your point?
I can give a definition that would be understandable to any conscious human, making my statements about human consciousness intellectually meaningful. AI-consciousness-believing psychotic patients can't do the same for the token guesser. Their statements are noncognitive mumbling masquerading as language, no different from animal grunts displaying a certain attitude and emotional predisposition towards an unfamiliar object.
>>
Consciousness discourse is so fucking gay and retarded. It's nothing but cunts playing hot potato with who has to define the meaningless made-up nonsense word
>>
>>17099892
>the psychotic talmudist devolves into consciousness denial
Every single time.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.