[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: SWRPGcoverJ.png (2.4 MB, 1200x1698)
2.4 MB PNG
Thanks for memeing me into another product i guess
>>
Define the worst part of it to you. It's not exactly so popular that everyone on /tg/ knows why it sucks to engage in conversation about it, like PbtA slop or Dnd 5e clones.
>>
>>98316291
>"spoonfeed me!"

www.google.com
>>
>>98316554
He's not going to be able to use google to find the subjective opinion of an anonymous poster on 4chan. I shouldn't have to explain that to you.
>>
>>98316554
If you're that afraid of having to give your own opinion why bother posting at all?
>>
>>98316117
>can't even pirate an easily available PDF and skim through it to see if he likes the product before buying
If you dislike your money, that's on you buddy.
>>
>>98316554
I tried to look you up on Google and just found a bunch of results for "faggot".
>>
>>98316291
NTA but it has that syndrome common to AD&D inspired games where it's just a kitchen sink of classes and skill systems, with more added in every supplement.
>>
>>98316117
>Thanks for memeing me into another product i guess
You're welcome dude. Be sure to support their crowdfunding campaign as well.

https://www.backerkit.com/c/projects/mugen-gaming/sword-world/launch_party
>>
>>98316117
Sword World isn't bad it's just very simple, roll 2d6, add ability modified, add class level and try to meet or exceed target number. You got dice controlled A.I. for helpful NPCs and different rules for JRPG style combat and more traditional combat. Also multi classing options out the ass.

At its core though, it is a numbers go up add a bunch of modifiers style of game. Arguably it was just using 2d6 to replace a d20 because d20s were not easily found in Japan during the early days of Sword World, so most of the inherent design flaws of a d20 system are still applicable with it just with math centered around a 2-12 result so /tg/ will argue it's less swingy when, in practice it's basically the same.
>>
>>98316554
I don't think Google can tell us about your personal experience with the game, anon.
>>
>>98316726
Never said i burned money on it. Not that retarded.
>>
>>98316117
You're a liar, OP.
>>
>>98317460
sir this is the lying website
>>
>>98317536
where else can you find the truth?
>>
>>98317972
Truth Social
am israel chai
>>
>>98316554
The best bait is the lowest effort ones
>>
>he thought the ttrpg that was inspired by anime which was inspired by jarpigs which were shitty adaptations of ttrpgs would be good
serves you right
>>
>>98320780
that's not the order
>>
>>98316554
That's weird. I googled why does OP think the way he does and all of the results were pictures of men with penises in their mouths.
>>
>>98320780
This. Sword World is like 7 or 8 degrees removed from anything resembling an original idea which is its core issue.
>>
>>98320780
>>98321201
Okay, I have an original system for you.
You stick a dildo to your chair and you have to get it inside as many times as the target number or above it. As you level up the dildo gets bigger.
The boxset comes with 4 pregenerated dildos and lube, but you can buy the pdf, roll your own dildos and homebrew your own lube.

There, an original system, thus your favorite one.
>>
>>98321247
>target number
shit system. Mine is roll under. Roll your tongue under my balls and I'll let you know if you pass.
>>
>>98316117
????
I don't believe you. Give reasons or I am just going to guess you're a no-games tourist fag.
>>
>>98320780
>inspired by anime
Which anime?
>>
File: images (36).jpg (41 KB, 351x569)
41 KB JPG
>>98325805
Record of brown skin elves
>>
>>98326390
>Record of brown skin elves
Was released 1 year after the TTRPG
>>
>>98327351
And years after the replays of the BX campaign that lead into the creation of the light novels that the anime follows. The history is more complex than you'd expect.
>>
>>98316117
What's wrong with it?
>>
>>98328360
The only legitimate complaint against Sword World RPG is that its not written natively in English. It's a borderline perfect game.
>>
>>98327361
Which means >>98320780 is just an uninformed faggot
>>
>>98326390
>>98327361
>>98327361
The replays came first, then the novels.
They also played it through Runequest 3 and Tunnels & Trolls, not just D&D. I forgot the exact reasoning but they didn't want the Lodoss and the setting to be tied exclusively to D&D, which is what motivated them to make their own TTRPG and Sword World RPG was born. This also gave them the opportunity to make an RPG more accessible to their audience. Trying to get people to play TTRPG's is literally the reason Record of Lodoss War exists in the first place. Then came the anime.
>>98328579
I assumed it was a troll post at first so I didn't know if it was worth the effort in correcting him.
>>
>>98329814
>I assumed it was a troll post
I still assume it is, but it is worth correcting these, to some extent, because people new to it might see unchecked information like this and start parroting it, or, on the other side, because new people might look at the corrected info and find it interesting enough.
>>
>>98329814
>I forgot the exact reasoning
TSR got pissy that they weren't making enough money off of the translation of BX so they pulled the license.
>>
>>98331779
If you're gonna tell the fake story at least do it right.
Group SNE had arranged a meeting with TSR to make Lodoss am official 2e setting, they even invited other big names from the same magazine who could be attached to the project like the creator of Slayers. TSR never showed up. The insutl was so deep they made their own game to show TSR and happened to make the most succesfull game in Japan.
>>
>>98331990
>they even invited other big names from the same magazine who could be attached to the project like the creator of Slayers
Lodoss War was originally published in Comptiq magazine, Slayers are published in Dragon Magazine. Not to be confused with Dragon in the US, which was actually published for a brief moment in Japan, but then the rights for the name were bought to create Dragon Magazine.
>>
File: runegroupS.jpg (96 KB, 736x528)
96 KB JPG
>>98337784
well, there is one sword world story that was published in Dragon Magazine...
>>
>>98331990
and group SNE said they believe, and in turn I also believe, that the snub was over TSR being pissed about not getting a big enough cut from the translation of BX.
>>
>>98331990
not 2e
>>98341097
not BX either, but BECMI.
>>
>>98340570
Later in the 90s, I know there's been cross pollination since lodoss is as fundamental to fantasy over there as dragon quest or books like guin saga
BTW I don't mean to sound like a pedantic retard, this is just a rare topic
>>
>>98316831
Statistically 2d6 is less swingy than 1d20, you're just a retard.

1d20 has a standard deviation of 5.8
2d6 has a standard deviation of 2.4



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.