Tier List EditionPrevious: >>98663937>Newshttps://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-banned-and-restricted-february-9-2026https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-brackets-beta-update-february-9-2026>Current Banlisthttps://magic.wizards.com/en/banned-restricted-list#commander-banned>Bracket Informationhttps://files.catbox.moe/4tbvzw.pnghttps://files.catbox.moe/r62yfy.png>Former Commander Website: Learn the basics, and read the format philosophy laid down by the rules committeehttps://mtgcommander.net>Card Searchhttps://scryfall.com>Card Statistics: See what everyone else puts in their Commander decks based on what is posted to the Internethttps://www.edhrec.com>Deck List Sites: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck strategy and card choiceshttps://www.archidekt.comhttps://www.moxfield.com>Manabase Information: Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen color identityhttps://managathering.com>Proxy Guidehttps://pastebin.com/9Xj1xLdM>Preconshttps://magicprecons.comTQ: Do you have a personal tier list for casual edh archetypes? Lands would probably be at the top, but what about the others?
In my regular pod?Control is SSS+ tier because they idiots don't remove removal beyond things like aura shards and farewell because they are GCs
This should be a colorless instead of green like come on let the others have ways to mana fix themselves too.
Haunted One + Volo is such a silly rube goldberg machine
>>98669353There's two ways to build her:>voltron and laugh as you can swing for lethal with only 7 power if you have double strike>goad and watch people seethe
>make a Shantotto deck >friend constantly calls it shit because I run 4 cost spells>"its just shittier Vivi">every single game I did the izzit thing, made her a +30 and crushed his face
>TQMill is Baby's First Control, so it's firmly D-tier.
>>98670127I don't get why this is a card. I thought it was because the original wasn't legendary or something (like Istvan) but it is.
I did it guys, I break Emiel
>>98670167this is missing a third card
>>98670170Plenty of soul sisters to trigger off to.
>friend says he doesn't play combo decks>is the guy who has a million optimized decks, won't proxy anything>every deck he plays is a threat because he'll have a full board by turn 3>got mad that I targeted his ramp cards while he was playing Dinosaurs>got pissy when I played will and took 5 extra turns
Thirty (30) starting life is objectively superior to fourty (40)
>>98670104>Loses to Mill>Goes on four channel dot org slash tee gee to call mill D-tierEvery time.
>>98670002It's amazing how they made a set of entirely bad cards except for one shit common
>>98670193Except all of the real people who actually play testing it out and proving it's shit. You ritual post about shit. You worship shit.
>>98670221not so fast
>>98670002>TQ>S tierLands, artifacts, dedicated combo>A tierAristocrats, blink, graveyard, tribal (strong creature type), sacrifice, spellslinger, big mana>B tierVoltron, lifegain, enchantress, cascade, tokens, theft, pillowfort>C tierMill, +1/+1 counters, control, planeswalkers, stompy, goad, -1/-1 counters, poison, aggro>D tierStax, burn, tribal (weak creature type), energy, monarch, morph>What the fuck are you doing tierChaos, discard, group hugcasual list my opinion
>>98670256>What the fuck are you doing tier>discard,>Hey pod. I'm playing Tiny Bones, Bauble Burgler, are you all okay with that?>Yeah, yeah sure.>3 turns later they're all scooping in a rage.I'm farming the easiest wins of my life in bracket 3.
>>98670308maybe if you commit to it totally, I've done like turn 1 hopeless nightmare scoop within 3-4 turns because everyone at the table agreed to team up against me first the second I touched their hands
If this resolves, who gets the priority to tap the lands first?
>>98670378You put the spell on the stack. Prio passes, They can respond by tapping their lands.The spell resolves, prio passes, they can respond by tapping their lands.After that, they don't have any moment to tap their lands to deny you if they didn't for whatever when they had the chance.
>>98670378Active player non-active player. So you presumably. But they'd probably tap before this resolves.
>>98670378This was only good when mana burn was a thing.They can take the risk of whatever you are going to play, or take damage. Now this is just a shitty blue silence.
>>98670404>shitty blue silence Eh still good enough in lower brackets
>>98670386>The spell resolves, prio passes
>>98670421Yes. Prio passes as spells are put on and resolves, its not yugioh where it it all resolves at once. >Rule 116.3b>the active player receives priority after a spell or ability resolves (other than a mana ability).
>>98670421You have priority not your opponent
>>98670430Anon...
>>98670454Yes anon, you get prio, then you must pass prio. You don't get it then nothing happens if you don't do anything and just moves to the next thing. Don't be a retard.
>>98670456Priority 'passing' means that it moves from one player to another. When a spell resolves the priority does not pass. Don't call me a retard because you don't know the rules.
>>98670458>Prio does not passNo. It goes to you. Then you pass prio like any other fucking game action moving to the next step, phase, or spell on the stack.R E T A R DETARDTrying to argue with the fucking comprehensive rules, because he's too much of a dumb fuck to take the L.
>>98670462When the spell resolves, you have priority. You then get to tap the opponents' lands (if they left them untapped before the spell resolved). They do not get priority to tap them.
I'm so fucking mad they killed Thalia. She didn't deserve it. She didn't deserve to die. She deserved to live. She is so courageous and brave and clever and she wouldn't have gotten killed. I am so sick of Wizards of the Coast and their disgusting hatred for beautiful white women. Real white women are insufferable, I've dated several and none of them are anything like Thalia. Just let me have my fantasy. Just let me feel that special way about her without it being ruined by her being killed off when she did so much for her people. She doesn't let outsiders get near her fellows, she protects them, she isn't a moron, she would not have let herself get ambushed or betrayed.FUCK Wizards of the Coast for letting her die and FUCK whatever artist drew art of her dying and becoming a ghost. That shit had better be far in the future when she is at least 95 years old and lived a long life, or I'm gonna be pissed off.
>>98670548Welcome back, king.
>>98670558I'm not a king, I'm a worthless dysgenic piece of shit who would never be loved by Thalia. But I do love her and I am so angry that they killed her. I should have died instead. if I lived on Innistrad, I would have sacrificed my life for Thalia. It is such a disgusting injustice that she dies while an ugly weak retard like me lives on.
I still like Tataru.
>>98670611she cute :)
>>98670616She is!As is this Dorna lass, I never really played Neverwinter Nights so I did not know her.Still, she is cute.
>>98670127
>>98670633Not sure what the right style is for that card frame
>>98670097That sort of patron is what would be called a 'scrub', so the only correct recourse is to open the wounds with lots of salt to rubOooooohohohohohohoho
>>98670548Anon that's the fake AU Thalia. The real one mpregged Quintorius.
>>98670548>she isn't a moron, she would not have let herself get ambushed or betrayed.she saddled the gitrog monster though, which tells you what jace thought of the whole thing
Can't decide if I wanna build Aerid or Lyna as my next commander
>>98670767big if true
>>98670880what does aerid do that meteor cat don't
>>98670885Aerid's meteors aren't tapped and it pays for it's own tax even if it gets instantly removed
>OK let's just throw in cool cards to this deck I'm making and cut, easier than starting small and building for me>mfw made a 210 card pile that I now have to chip away at for the next like 3 days
>>98670917Reminds me of that old tripfag. Glad he's finally fucking gone.But for real how do you do this shit to yourself? I can see the count as I go along and I adjust. I've never gone over 120 cards
>>98670880Aerid seems like simple fun. Spam your artifacts and hit someone really hard while ramping crazy. I say go for it anon
>>98670009Honestly how can control be good when there are 4 people.
>>98670972I'm really bad about silver bullet cards, too much commander redundancy and trying to do too many concepts at once, like token and extra combat steps
>>98670917Oh do I have the commander for you.
>>98671070yorionbros..
>>98671057Do you use EDHREC? I heavily build from that first, and skip any cards I think are too expensive to buy or too high in mana value to bother running. That limits the amount of cards I add to begin with cos that's less likely to hit 100 in the first place, and then I add cards I know of or do a Scryfall search keeping in mind how many slots I have left.
>>98664288I've been a Golgari chud for all my life, never touched Selesnya once ever because that was always my bro's color pair. This Miku deck is literally the only reason I've ever had to drag me into playing GW in my 13 year EDH career and to be honest it hasn't been that bad. It all focusing around good old populate makes it feel very nostalgic to me and him.
>>98671091>I've been a Golgari chud for all my life,STINKY
>>98671116I'm more of a shoe connoisseur
>>98670654The mixture of pre-modern and post-modern wording is jarring.Should beLim Dul's Dick Puncher - 3BRSummon LegendLim Dul's Dick Puncher is unaffected by summoning sickness.First Strike, TrampleOpposing players discards a card at random when Lim Dul's Dick Puncher enters the battlefield.Opposing players lose 3 life when they discard their second card each turn.
>>98671124https://www.youtube.com/shorts/R-tku5TqfDk
>>98671091She's fun in general, since you can optimize the deck by taking it into multiple routes. Myriad cratures are a free way to populate, and stuff like battle angels or chittering dispatcher become extremely nutty in a single turn with populate.
>>98671344> chittering dispatcher become extremely nutty
