[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Roll dice with "dice+numberdfaces" in the options field (without quotes).

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 3984093843.jpg (122 KB, 736x920)
122 KB JPG
Weird Hands Edition

>2024 Core Rulebooks
https://mega(dot)nz/folder/d2ohSCSL#5HnqSMJncr9Queh8KDzbSQ

>2024 Official free rules
https://www.dndbeyond.com/sources/dnd/free-rules
>2014 Official Free Rules
https://www.dndbeyond.com/sources/dnd/basic-rules-2014

>2024 UA
https://www.dndbeyond.com/sources/dnd/ua

>2014 Errata
https://dnd.wizards.com/dndstudioblog/sage-advice-book-updates

>5etools (2024)
http://5e.tools
>5etools (2014)
https://2014.5e.tools/

>Resources:
https://pastebin.com/X1TFNxck

>List of changes between 5e and 5.5e
https://pastebin.com/p5jwkihk

Previous thread:
>>98893744

>TQ
What's the ideal D&D schedule to you? For example weekly, 5 hour sessions etc

>BTQ
What's your hot take on alignment?
>>
>>98936485
>TQ
When alignment is prescriptive and has strong mechanical application, it is an objective good for dungeon fantasy style gaming.
>>
>>98936485
>What's your hot take on alignment?
I prefer them as cosmological forces
>>
Necromancer
>>
>>98936582
post character sheet
>>
>>98936485
>TQ
A session less than six hours in length isn’t a session worth running or playing in. Ideally, eight-hour in-person sessions every two weeks. You can push it to every three if everyone has secondary characters that are used for between-session text roleplays.
>>
tfw im a LVL 19
213hp
21AC
Sorcerer
>>
>>98936613
How is this relevant to Alignment?
>>
>>98936613
We do a 16 hour every month, done so for years now. It's a hold over when we all used to do shift work and were able to all get on the same rotation.
>>
>>98936485
>What's your hot take on alignment?
For PCs, it's better to have a list of character traits than an alignment. Writing down that your Fighter is honest and honorable tells me more than just marking down lawful good, because it's more specific.

As for spells, effects, or magic items that depend on alignment, those are better served by looking at specific actions. Instead of a sword that can only be wielded by someone Good, the weapon can lose magical benefits if the bearer tells a lie.
There are already some monsters in the game that basically do this where they can automatically sense lies or if someone has broken a law.

For Evil items, you can also do this via curses. Every day you're attuned to the cursed item, it'll summon a monster somewhere nearby. That can be a weak monster that poses little threat to the party, but now the player has to consider if the item is worth the random villagers suddenly getting ambushed by a random undead in the middle of the night.

There's a ton of room to basically use Paladin oaths as the template for most of the direct mechanical effects of alignments.
>>
>>98936926
Wonder if they should bring vows back for Monks as well, could make some fun magic items that require them to keep their vows to use.
>>
>>98936485
>tq
Weekly, 6 hour session is fine. More with a little break in the middle.
>btq
its a quick label, not sure it even matters

For example, long running campaign, my lawful evil guy is a wizard that looks like grima wormtongue from the lotr movies and speaks like emperor palpatine. He's evil, sadistic, wants to be feared and respected, but is leashed by his knowledge that if he does evil, he'll be destroyed by adventuring parties because he's noticed a pattern that all bad guys (no matter how powerful) in the history of this universe end up being destroyed by adventuring parties. As such, his self-preservation instincts have motivated him to create a set of "rules" and he ends up kinda just being the "I may be a monster, but I only prey on other monsters" type of character. A bit ago, he took over a town run by warlords by killing the head warlord (a very bad guy). The group showed up during the remaining warlord meeting as they were bickering about who's the next warlord. The whole good-aligned team was onboard to murder them all, but I told one of my party members to assassinate the most "evil" one of the remaining bunch. At the end of the meeting, my character loudly congratulates teammate assassin for being so merciful, and having so few deaths during the meeting, to the confusion of the remaining warlords. My character just looked back like "Oh, did you this team was here for my protection? Many make that mistake. No, they're here to protect you from me". The town has since improved since. The lawful good cleric, the neutral good barbarian, they all can't find any way to fault my guy, as he is geniuinely making the world a better place, and will contine to do so.

p gud time except one player (who's been playing for like 2 years now) still has no fuckin clue how to play and he's being handheld by the DM. as a human fighter. a standard, stock, normal ass human fighter. what do you even do with that shit man.
>>
What would a good character concept for a human GOO warlock be that isn't just "crazed Cthulhu cultist"?
>>
>>98937004
The flipside maybe, make them a Call of Cthulhu protagonist who has scraps of eldritch knowledge and walks the fine line between using it to stop other evils and potentially allowing eldritch horrors to learn the existence of their world if they learn too much.
>>
>>98937004
Tour guide for your existence. Great Old One is just genuinely curious about your existence or universe and is also actively studying it, gaining bits of insight every time you call upon it.

I've always disliked the casual callousness being the crux of EVERY Lovecraftian spooky guy. Some will care, even if it's the equivalent of having an ant farm.
>>
File: IMG_3751.jpg (1.1 MB, 1313x2005)
1.1 MB JPG
I half-asked this last thread, but does anybody have ideas on how to style or conceptualise pic related? New WoW book, companion rules.

The options are things like Aquatic, Undead Elemental, Magic, and Humanoid companions, and a few others. They have some general guidelines, but what from WoW is this trying to represent, and how would you implement it? Especially the humanoid companion option. A human companion, that appears via Magic action, comes back if blown up by a fireball? Are they a magic slave? Or, well, what?

I am the GM in this case, I'm just struggling to see what I could equate it to since I never played WoW myself.
>>
>>98937546
It's been a hot minute since I've played WoW, but I recall you could get smaller pets and things.
For humanoid companions specifically, the examples the book gives are imps, kobolds, and baby murlocs, so the intent feels pretty clear there. Reading over that I do have a more distinct memory of a baby murloc pet being something you could get in the game.

And at least how they're mechanically represented here, it seems more akin to a Familiar. That shares very similar mechanics, at least as far as being dismissed when they take damage goes.
>>
i went to a LGS to play after some years of not playing, and just didnt vibe at all with either the DM or the other players, very disappointing
>>
>>98937634
How come? Were they weird or something? Were you weird?
>>
>>98937637
i didnt think i was weird but i probably was anyway without noticing
the main issue was the dm just seemed uninterested and kept acting like he was distracted
>>
>>98937628
>>98937546
>you can get a kobold
Time to hire a kobold bard companion to follow me around and herald my character to the tune of Dragonforce Through The Fire And Flame.
>>
>>98937546
https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Companion i assume
why they made them not cosmetic i dunno, to give non-pet classes something to do maybe? justify selling a new feature when familiars already exist?
>>
>>98937004
Variant of an Ur-Priest. You've determined a means to siphon a skerrick of power from a being too distant to be bothered. It'll be fine.
>>
File: sddefault.jpg (53 KB, 640x480)
53 KB JPG
>that player's turn comes around
>"Okay, so... where is everyone? What's going on?"
>"I want to attack. What do I roll again?"
>"Am I adding this to the roll- oh, this one instead?"
>"Okay how much damage do I do?"
>"Oh, I have to roll these dice here?"
>*takes forever to count*
>"Okay, I did 12 damage-"
>*dm asks if he remembered the ability modifier that gets added*
>"Sorry, 15 damage."
>*dm asks where is his sneak attack damage*
>"Oops, okay... what do I roll for that?"
This fucker has been playing 5e for years.
>>
>>98938580
I was going to say simulacrum cannot learn, but apparently the verbiage of the 2024 version is different.
>>
File: HWiaOatXQAAW9f2.jpg (183 KB, 1030x1200)
183 KB JPG
Lol
>>
>>98938580
unironically caused by the system being noob friendly and you guys reminding him of everything he forgets.
stop telling him and he'll either
>realise his character sucks and try to understand why/see what he is missing (or leave)
>not realise it and you gain time
>>
With the release of the great big large World of Warcraft sourcebook for 5e we now have not one but TWO official variants of living machine gnomes for players to build their characters from.
>>
so did 5eg move to 5.5e or are you guys still on 5e ? my DM moved to 5.5 but I'm really feeling improvements outside of weapon masteries
>>
>>98938871
Eh, I've been running a customized homebrew of 5e for most of a decade, so when 5.5 rolled around I just took things I like from it and discarded some of the more retarded changes.

I think you'll find that almost everyone is running a version of the game at this point that is customized to them and their player's liking.
>>
>>98936485
I use cropped gay furry bara porn as character art. Which classes should I play?
>>
Is there any defense against Polymorph? Like with Sleep, if you're a race that doesn't need to sleep or are immune to exhaustion then you automatically save against Sleep, is there anything like that for Polymorph?
>>
>>98939525
Immunity wise, no. There's a species that get bonuses to saves against magic like Gnomes and Mechagnomes, but no outright immunity. The Transmuted Anatomy feat gives you permanent Advantage against polymorph/shape shifting effects. But once again no outright immunity.
Some creatures/NPCs (Mostly constructs) do have the Immutable Form trait which says:
>Immutable Form. The creature can't shape-shift.
Which counters Polymorph completely. Everyone else can be turned into suffocating fish or dogs or whatever.
>>
>>98939525
In 5.5, no.
In 5e, yes, but it may require some DM interpretation. 5e Polymorph doesn't work on shapechangers. That generally means monsters with the Shapechanger subtype, but also changeling PCs (confirmed by JC in Sage Advice, for whatever that's worth), possibly level 10+ transmuter wizards (the feature is called Shapechanger), and with the DM's permission, level 2+ druids and other characters with non-spell based ability to change forms.
>>
>>98938871
Most people already have their own 5.5e after 10 years. That's why it bombed.
>>
>>98938871
/5eg/ isn't a community of people who game together or run their games the same way.
>>
Let's do another poll.

Have you changed to 5.5e five eggs?

https://strawpoll.com/B2ZB9kmOAgJ
>>
Is there an edition which isn't fantasy superheroes but more classic fantasy?
>>
>>98940528
Where's the "some of my multiple games/groups use 5e rules and others use 5.5e rules" option?
>>
>>98940537
If you find 5e feels too much like fantasy superheroes you are welcome to try another general to discuss a different RPG. There are "hardcore" rules to make 5e more gritty but they can only do so much. Personally I recommend you check out WFRP if you don't want to feel like a superhero.
>>
>>98940541
Just put down partially for that
>>
>>98940543
Thanks, sorry to shit up your general.
>>
>>98939282
What did you take, and what did you toss?
>>
>start making new dungeon
>NOT pic related, but similar concept
>mausoleum for beholder who is now a death knight
>makes sense they'd build big mausoleums because they have tons of slaves and not much else to do with them
>however it makes more sense that they'd be fully underground because beholders can just disintegrate 10-foot cubes of stone with ease with their eye rays.
>realize that makes a lot more sense
>also get really frustrated with how line walls are unrealistic
>stone walls like that should be at least 5 feet wide i.e. the rooms should have space between them
>however almost all the dungeons I make are underground structures instead of above-ground ones that actually have to be contained to a building
>cannot decide which should be which
>also trying to draw it out so that each section is the size of my battlemap so I can fit the whole of each section onto 30x24 squares
>have larger one but it's hard to reach into the middle to draw stuff
>start getting autistically frustrated
>only make one room
>already want to start over
Please help me snap out of this autism
>>
>>98940996
Assuming you're the guy from last time, I'd note a variant beholder with different eye rays would also address why the beholder wouldn't make it underground if he had a different eye ray in place of the normal disintegration ray.

That said, there's also nothing wrong with a beholder deciding that he wanted to flex and create an above-ground structure. Especially since if it's meant to be a tomb, it doesn't really need to be quite as defensible.
Depending on the location, it could also be that the areas underground here are worse for tunneling for whatever reason. Maybe there's purple worms about and they moved the mausoleum above ground just to avoid the hassle.
>>
>>98941017
Well that was for the death tyrant. I assume the beholders that made his tomb for him (their lore is a bit different in my world where their paranoia and xenophobia is a bit less present for other beholders) that would have it.

Purple worms would make sense as a reason to keep it aboveground.
It's just hard to make a structure large enough for a big death tyrant to float around in along with other guardians.

Also not sure how to defeat my autism about how the rooms should have at least 5 feet of stone between them, and not be divided by a simple line like in that map I posted.

I swear as I get older I get more autistic and restrictive about how I make my maps, not less.
>>
>>98940996
Why not both? Mortuary temple on the surface, tomb complex below.
>>
>>98941045
Fair enough. Though the point stands that the beholders might not care that much about designing a tomb to be as secure as an underground beholder lair if it was simply a place to house his remains.
The Beholders do also have telekinesis rays, so along with whatever servants they have, making large structures can be relatively easy.

Depending on the height of the structure, thin walls might be fine, especially for the interior. 2-3 feet is still a relatively solid wall, and 2 feet is enough where you can get away with saying that the map simply overlooks how the squares immediately adjacent to a wall are going to be 4 feet rather than 5 feet, because 1 foot of floor space is eaten up by either half of the wall.
If you added on a 5 foot wall layer to the exterior here, it should be structurally sound regardless. There are already a lot of solid stoneworks near the middle here, so if there outer walls were also thick, then all of the other interior walls could probably get away with not being load bearing at all.


All this being said, if you were going to redraw the map and change anything, I would say to change the doors. If the place was built by beholders (and later taken over by a Death Tyrant), then presumably the doors should be 10 feet wide so a beholder can pass through them without squeezing. That probably wouldn't be as big of a deal when the tomb was being built, but the Death Tyrant would presumably change that as soon as he woke up.
Probably not every chamber either, but presumably the death tyrant would want to be able to access most of the larger rooms.
>>
>>98941068
I guess that could work.
How do I undo my autism about rooms being separated by paper-thin stone walls on my map?
>>
>>98941130
you can just make them 5 feet wide if you want.
>>
File: file.png (1.69 MB, 1920x913)
1.69 MB PNG
>Update Foundry
>Half the modules stop working
>Half the modules work incorrectly
>Modules do stuff beyond their scope (looking at you, Dice Addiction)
>Modules that do things that I want still don't exist
>Sit down with Grok and just vibe code everything that I want into the game

Reaction tracker alone is worth its weight in GOLD. Now I just wish there was a way to make handling AoEs easier without installing Midi-QoL.
>>
>>98936582
I want to romance her neck
>>
>>98939282
>>98940276
yeah not really surprised, from the places I looks for games on it didn't seem to have taken hold

>>98940459
which is why I asked in a place where several peoples can answer ?
>>
>>98938871
Technically, what I run is far enough away from base 5e that it isn't really accurate to say I'm "still on" it, but it was built on 5e and takes only a smattering of rules from 5.5. Hopefully, I'll get back on my revision schedule when I'm done planning my next campaign.
>>
>>98936613
God I wish we could go back to 6-8 hour sessions but we're too old now and half the group has small kids so we really can't play on weekends so we have to fit it in on a weekday and can't play too long because of work the next day and we're too old to stay up till midnight.
>>
>>98940537
Don't know if you're still reading. If we're talking D&D, all WotC editions (3e onward) and their derivates (like Pathfinder) are fantasy superheroes. The OSR threads (shitty as they are) or non-D&D options may be a better place to look.
>>
>>98941961
>tfw DINK master race
>>
File: Eye tyrant lair.png (1.64 MB, 792x1200)
1.64 MB PNG
>>98940996
Probably won't help your autism any, but consider the beholder always flies. The slaves' convenience may be a factor to get the work done, but there should be a LOT of verticality, with areas inaccessible on foot.
>>
>>98942031
>immense, ornate above-ground structure
>houses nothing but a vertical shaft straight down into the actual complex
>>
Does anyone have a scan of the newest printing of Player's Handbook 2024? Meaning, printing including all or some of the erratas.
>>
File: 638657413411056007.png (213 KB, 1000x631)
213 KB PNG
Has anyone ever actually used an Apparatus of Kawlish?
>>
>>98941128
>Depending on the height of the structure, thin walls might be fine, especially for the interior. 2-3 feet is still a relatively solid wall, and 2 feet is enough where you can get away with saying that the map simply overlooks how the squares immediately adjacent to a wall are going to be 4 feet rather than 5 feet, because 1 foot of floor space is eaten up by either half of the wall.
Yeah that's what I usually do. I added some columns too but they're mostly for decoration honestly. And yeah the rooms would all be 10 feet wide, to the point that I might just use a 10 foot square scale for it to make it make the most sense.
>>
File: Half-Elf Druid.jpg (1.78 MB, 2529x3500)
1.78 MB JPG
Do you guys just port half races into 5.5 because it's backwards compatible? Seems like the only thing you can do at this point.
>>
>>98941600
she is cute
>>
>>98943144
>puckeeslop
>>
>>98942595
No, and I'm still salty the one time I saw a Lost Laboratory of Kwalish game on roll20 it never ended up happening.
>>
>>98943144
Yes
>>
>>98942031
good point. I will add some verticality, maybe not with passages that long, but still, your map gave me some good inspiration, thank you.
>>
>>98943144
Do the freckles make her appear more Half-Elven?
>>
Anyone thinks about the epilogue for their characters before the campaign ends?
>>
>>98943771
The DM should give you one I think.
>>
File: 1713848930080910.jpg (1.54 MB, 750x1334)
1.54 MB JPG
Question about the 'Universes Beyond' World of Warcraft book that's coming. Does it have the full rules set in it, or do you still need the PHB/DMG/MM to use it?
>>
>>98943979
It's a rather typical setting book, so you still need the other core rulebooks in order to make the most of it.
Mainly the PHB, since between it and the WoW book you actually have a decent handful of monsters that could probably cover an adventure or two.
>>
>>98943993
Can you use it with the 2014 version of the rules?
>>
>>98944021
It's not designed for it, but at a glance it would mostly work. There's some correcting you'd need to do with subclasses, since the 2024 rules assume that all subclasses are gained at level 3, but it's pretty obvious how things would translate over. A Cleric subclass at level 1, Druid at level 2, and so on.

Most of the Race options lack ability score bonuses, so that'd be something you'd need to account for if using the 2014 rules as a baseline. Some of the new feats are also set up differently, but that's relatively minor.
The only other aspect that immediately stands out is the crafting rules, which lean on the new 2024 updates which allow for much easier magic item crafting, but that's a pretty simple table to implement.
>>
>>98941524
>using jb2a free content
ngmi
>>
Here's the party so far, it's a 3 person game. I'm happy to play anything.
>Bard
>Rogue
>Sorcerer
I was considering Paladin but then I don't want to be a moralfag in a party of shady characters. I know these other players they tend towards more chaotic characters if you get my meaning. Maybe fighter but I find fighter kind of boring. Monk? The DM is a little odd and we're not using point buy, we're doing 3d6 six times. Here's what I got
>7, 10, 11, 12, 14, 16
Starting with a 16 seems decent. Not sure where to put the 7. If I put it into intelligence I'm sure everyone will expect me to roleplay him like he's a literal retard.
>>
>>98945190
*4 player game, 3 other players, fuck me
>>
>>98945190
you can be a paladin without being a moralfag, see the powderkeg of justice or the "lawful good is not lawful nice". You can apply your rules for yourself without preventing your allies from going against them too.
If you want to be a tank and lean toward being chaotic/murdery yourself maybe conquest paladin (dump WIS and have a really short fuse) or trickery cleric (dump CHA and be the drunkard cleric noone trusts fully) ? or any flavour of barbarian, really.
also battlemaster if one of the funniest class to play imho, if you meant mechanically
If you stay on the Monk, you could dump STR, someone physically weak who overcame it with technique
>>
File: file.png (48 KB, 323x637)
48 KB PNG
>>98941524
God, I love Foundry so much
>>
Is there enough source material in 5e (2014) that I don't have to upgrade?
>>
>>98945422
Yes. 5.5 really was adjusting features, feats, and spells and other QOL things. Monsters became a little more streamlined although caster monsters lost spell slots but gained X/day spellcasting and multi basic spell attacks. I think the only major thing they added was weapon mastery stuff which gives melee classes a little bit of crowd control .
>>
>>98941996
Ty, I had a look at early modules for first edition and really quite liked it.
>>
>>98945422
yes. And 5.5e having the warlock, sorcerer and paladin get subclasses at level 3 is alone a good enough reason to not upgrade.
Also calling races species and removing their ASI
>>
>>98945190
Ancients Paladin can lean more suitably chaotic. Similar case for oaths like Glory or Genies which are suitably vague and basically just boil down to 'do your best'.

Monk could be a good option, since it lets you stick the 7 into Strength and still have a 16+ Dex.
That can technically work for Paladin as well, since nothing stops you from pumping Dex and using a shortsword/rapier, though it does complicate things if you ever want to multiclass. Plus with a Bard and Sorcerer already in the party, you've probably got Charisma covered.

I could also see going for something like Artificer. A Battlesmith can do pretty well in close quarters, but uses Medium armor for AC and relies on Intelligence for attack rolls. And there are ways to focus on either melee or range there. If your DM is using encumbrance rules, you also get a Steel Defender which could help carry extra gear, and the pet also serves as a way to help enable the Rogue's sneak attack and otherwise give the party some extra bulk.
>>
>>98945934
NTA, but I'm going to have to disagree with you there.
>And 5.5e having the warlock, sorcerer and paladin get subclasses at level 3 is alone a good enough reason to not upgrade.
Level one subclasses would feel better for all classes, but if it comes down to Subclasses at level one with gimped features so they don't create a balancing nightmare versus having them at level three with their current level of power I'll take the latter. Remember, in 5e multiclassing was an optional rule, so they didn’t bother to put any work into balancing it because it’s on the dm. Now, multiclassing is a core game mechanic.
Level one subclasses are a design nightmare that no one (especially the pants on head retards at Wotc) wants to have to handle. There are literal build defining features unlocked in the current first subclass levels that would utterly fuck balance sideways if they could be acquired by a single level dip. Now you have to test and account for the hundreds of possible combinations of class dipping presented by the different subclass abilities interacting with one another, as well as the unholy combinations that can come from two different 1 level dips on the same character. Now you have three sets interacting to balance for. No designer is going to do this as it is an ungodly waste of time and a ton of cheese and dumb balance shit will end up making it through as a result.
By starting the subclasses at level 3 you can keep those front end build defining features easily accessible, which would otherwise have to be moved back to level 6 to stop this problem, while still making the subclass come online early enough to feel like a fairly core identity for a character. No one dips 3 full levels outside of stupid net builds that always assume a level 20 character because it will absolutely screw your character progression for most of the game.
You can and should know what subclass you player is going to use in advance of level 3, for flavor interactions.
>>
>>98945934
>Also calling races species
This is the most terminally online thing to worry about. It has literally zero impact on gameplay. Call it race if you still want to. My players and I do. Anyone getting hung up on this is either a no games or internet culture warrior.
>and removing their ASI
This one I actually kinda agree with. Wizards really played themselves with the race to species name change because unlike the races, species can and very much do have very different physical and mental differences, so the species asi’s actually make some sense with the change. Trying to have their cake and eat it too on the whole fantasy racism thing.
The system I ultimately opted for that my players enjoy is having a +2 racial score and either two +1’s or one +2 (which can’t go in the same category as their racial asi) that they get to choose as part of their background. It still allows the Min-maxers to get the maximum in their main stat if they want while allowing others to play the off-type race for a class if they want a fun roleplay experience.
>>
>>98946385
NTA, but it seems like the easiest form of design there would be for subclasses to get both a level 1 and a level 3 feature, with the level 1 feature being a ribbon feature such as extra skill/tool/language proficiencies, and the level 3 feature still being the more build-defining ones.
For example, a Fathomless Warlock could get their swim speed and underweater breathing at level 1, and then at level 3 you get the tentacles that allow for Bonus action attacks.

This allows a subclass to be a core defining trait of a character without the character suddenly figuring out that core aspect of themselves overnight. A level 1 Arcane Trickster Rogue could get Mage Hand before getting actual spellcasting. A level 1 Totem Barbarian could get Speak with Animals as a ritual.
There's lots of minor upsides that classes could give to sell the flavor without needing to rework the entire game.
>>
High Gnomes
Dark Gnomes
Wood Gnomes
>>
>>98946580
>NTA, but it seems like the easiest form of design there would be for subclasses to get both a level 1 and a level 3 feature, with the level 1 feature being a ribbon feature such as extra skill/tool/language proficiencies, and the level 3 feature still being the more build-defining ones.
Okay, but why? Like the first few levels of classes are already overloaded with features compared to later ones. This already makes dipping overly attractive since Wizards is still half-assing multiclassing. If they actually fixed class progression in general, then sure, this would work. But in practice, Wizards just doesn't really understand how to do proper class progression, especially multiclass progression.
>This allows a subclass to be a core defining trait of a character without the character suddenly figuring out that core aspect of themselves overnight.
See, this is the problem. Everyone who brings this up comes from the same place of thinking. That until you have a subclass feature your subclass just doesn't exist. But really, the players and dm should always know what subclasses their going to play from the get go. Just because your Cleric doesn't get a subclass till 3 doesn't mean they don't follow a god, or for a warlock to have a patron.
>Rogue, Barbarian
Strange choice of classes to use when talking about not wanting to rework the game as neither got subclasses at level 1 in 5e either. Allowing all classes to have level 1 subclasses would be fundamentally bigger change to the game than the level 3 route they ultimately went with. Can you do it, sure. Would it be a pain in the ass that would require redesigning every class's progression to account for it just to please a tiny amount of people that can't separate mechanics from flavor: also yes.
>>
>>98945934
>5.5e having the ... paladin get [its subclass] at level 3 is alone a good enough reason to not upgrade
What the fuck are you talking about?
>>
>>98946970
The funny thing is that the 5e paladin looks to be designed for level 1 subclass, too, even though it gets it at level 3. It's got the most lackluster level 1 base class in the entire game. LoH is strictly inferior to Second Wind at that level (heals less and refreshes on LR) and paladin doesn't get fighting style until level 2.
And, of course, the aspect of getting paladin stuff without actually having an oath that makes you paladin.
>>
>>98947016
NTA, but while I agree that their level 1 is lackluster, (and 2024 actually does fix that for all the shit I can give that edition) it sure as hell isn't because of LoH.
> LoH is strictly inferior to Second Wind at that level (heals less and refreshes on LR)
Skill issue and I'm not even being sarcastic. LoH isn't really meant to be a self heal in practice. What it is is the single most potent res in the entire game. You only need to dump a single point from it to get a downed player up. And given how exceedingly well it scales it quickly becomes a great secondary healing pool in general as the game goes on. Not strictly as effective as spells at higher levels, but absolutely amazing as it can be used with no waste what-so-ever since the player meters out exactly how much healing to give.
>>
>>98946799
>But really, the players and dm should always know what subclasses their going to play from the get go.
They should, but do they? For more experienced players they obviously will, but more experienced groups are more likely to just start the game at level 3 and sidestep the whole issue. Newer players might not realize that's something they should be foreshadowing.
>Strange choice of classes to use
It was to illustrate how this could be a beneficial change across the board for the flavor perspective you brought up, and how minimal of a change it would actually be because it's shit like a cantrip.
>>
Lay on Hands didn't need to be a bonus action.
>>
>>98947180
>Newer players might not realize that's something they should be foreshadowing.
Ah yes, the new players who don't have a page or 5 of backstory written for their character ready to go because they've never lost a character. Okay, sarcasm over, but seriously, this is more a DM issue than a player one. And frankly the overlap of new players who don't know to have a subclass picked out in advance and the people who will have the lack of level one subclasses break their immersion in a character are more a figure 8 than a Venn Diagram.
>>
So is any of the wow content any good? I'm reading it through myself but I'm uncertain and not familiar with the system enough to know.
>>
>>98946385
putting mechanics over flavour for a RPG is already bad as is, yet the math behind still sucks after.
Yes mutliclassing would be an issue, and the suggestion of >>98946799 is pretty good imho, but if the game is going to be as much of a clusterfuck as it currently is then you have no justification to remove the flavour that defines a class for balance reasons.
I'm not saying every class should have subclasses at level 1, but the ones I listed have no in universe logic behind having them at level 3
(also instead of multiclassing we should get class related feats that give you this flavour but that's an opinion I would understand disagreements on)

>>98946970
>What the fuck are you talking about?
swearing an oath three levels after becoming a paladin when the class is about its oath is stupid
>>
Question about role playing. Sometimes I feel like my roleplaying a fighter unfortunately harms the group in some unforeseen way that I did not perceive. Prime example, last session our group finally made it to some almost flooded cavern while looking for some magical mcguffin thing. The group already weak is ambushed by an enemy mage and blows us the fuck up with what I assume is a high grade spell. The only ones left standing are me(fighter) and our Elf Wizard. I rush the enemy mage and wrestle a spell book from him and kick it away to disarm him. Which unfortunately the book falls to the bottom of a massive ravine. Enemy mage shouts "NO YOU FOOL! THAT WAS THE BOOK OF [MCGUFFIN FUCKING VOLUME 9!] which the party immediately assumed was what we were looking for.

So now, I feel bad but I played my fighter how I think he would have reacted if a mage hopped out and blasted our group of 5 and left only 2 standing. Me nor my character really even thought the book would have even been the mcguffin because my character knows wizards or mages carry spell books around because we have a wizard in the group. What do you think? It is very hard to roleplay but also not somehow screw the group over on accident.
>>
>>98947408
Your play was logical. Whatever bad came out from that is fully on the dm.
Either he actually planned for the wizard to possess the plot device book which means he had to account for that to happen.
Or he improvised that on the spot as a lame 'gotcha' which I think is more likely.
Either way, your play was perfectly fine
>>
>>98947403
>swearing an oath three levels after becoming a paladin when the class is about its oath is stupid
And what does that have to do with 5.5e and moving to it?
>>
>>98945290
>>98945936
I had a read of the different options. I'm going to be Oath of Ancients with my dump stat as Charisma. He's a paladin but not a charismatic one. I'll avoid any spells that involve a saving thrown. Monk, Fighter, and Artificer were all tempting but I think it will a bit different to play a Paladin with such terrible charisma while the bard and sorcerer both have very high charisma.

We're starting at level 1 so I'll see if the campaign fizzles before I get my oath. I remember wanting to play an eldritch knight in a game once but it never got past level 2. So I was just a highly intelligent fighter.
>>
Looking at the wow stuff now. Kinda surprised that DH is another WIS focused ranger with both their features scaling off WIS and getting a lot of unique spells. At least it gets to use its soul fragement stuff very freely
>>
>>98947639
>my dump stat as Charisma
Anon, please. Please don't do this. While the abilities generally do give you at least one use of bonus, a lot of your kit scales off of Charisma.
>>
File: jailbait farmgirl.jpg (1.51 MB, 2800x4352)
1.51 MB JPG
How do you suppose this young 14 year old farm girl would see your current party as if she saw them?
>>
>>98947639
Why? What's even the point of playing a Paladin if you're not using half the features?
Might as well just play a Zealot Barbarian at that point.
>>
>>98936485
TQ
What's the ideal D&D schedule to you? For example weekly, 5 hour sessions etc
>Fortnightly, Friday's for 6-10 hrs has worked, I like having people over for lunch or Dinner and taking a couple interludes.

BTQ
What's your hot take on alignment?
> It's only relevant to holy classes or evil campaigns. Most players are chaotic good or neutral.

I have reached an unexpected campaign point I could use some help with.

Running a leveled up version of DoIP after LMoP where venomfang is an adult dragon and Cryovain is Ancient, the cult of the dragon are more involved and the Orcs who worship Talos have been running counter to them since they want to return to Icespire peak.

Well I had dropped that the CotD wanted a heart for a ritual involving dragons bones (the bones in the burial mound I made Venomfangs mothers.

Come to the circle of thunder and the summoning of Goretusk, well the cult show up afterwards trying to kill it off before cryovain swoops in to collect.

I'm running some CotD as dragonborn npcs with stat blocks from Fizbans.

The players sided with the Orcs and fought off the CotD taking 2 of them down to 1hp
the wizard teleported them out.

Cryovain swings in, and with proper positioning and superior numbers the players and the orcs took him down in 1 and a half rounds.
333hp shredded.

So the party to make peace with the orcs who were still to numerous to beat with the party low health help carve out the breath sack and fuck up taking the heart too, so that's destroyed.

I know that the Orcs will be off at the woodland manse or butterskull ranch.
I don't know what they will do with the breath sack of an ancient white dragon.
Goretusk is still alive.

The party have left for wave echo cave to get some magical smithing tools to the Rockseeker brothers.

Venomfang and the 4 dragonborn CotD members have impersonated Neverwinter guard which is the background of most of the party too.

Cont next post.
>>
>>98947797
>skinny, green-eyed creepy woman with a sour expression, in fancy clothes, just oozing bad murderous vibes (not the fun kind)
>dark skinned male model in fancy clothes, abscent-looking expression, except when he's holding hands with skinny creepy woman
>pretty elf-looking girl with white hair in red sun dress and ram horns (ornamental), bouncing around asking questions and running after butterflies or whatever
>boyish handsome guy with bandages on his arms wearing old peasant clothes under chainmail, extremely demure and passive
>tiny bearded man with wings, wearing a duster and cowboy hat, riding a spidercat like a horse, overall chill-looking dude

Confused?
>>
>>98948011
So I'm at a bit of a loss for Venomfangs goals now.

I know Venomfang is head of the CotD now.
I know she's not interested in continuing to lair at Icespire peak.

I know she would turn Cryovain into a Zombie Dragon if she can't get the heart of Goretusk.
I know she's turned the bones of Azdraka the ancient green dragon into a skeleton dragon.

I'm just not sure what her next goal would be.
Cryovains dead, she could go after the Orcs and remove them as a threat, maybe get the heart to become a dracolich.

Or would she lay low, return the ruins of thundertree set up the skeleton dragon and zombie dragon as guards.

Or worst for the party attempt to take over Phandelin. Using the undead dragons to terrorize the place while staying in disguise as Neverwinter Guards.
>>
>>98948038
Green Dragons are usually known to be schemers and manipulators. Though with the party and orcs having killed an ancient, I think Venomfang is smart enough to avoid a head-on assault.

If she turns Cryovain into a zombie, that opens up a good avenue for a scheme. Have the undead Cryovain conduct some hit-and-run attacks before fleeing in the direction of Icespire peak. It'd be pretty for the cultists to start a rumor that the orcs used the harvested parts in a ritual to turn Cryovain into their undead servant.
Coaxing the orcs themselves into attacking Phandelin or the party's allies could be another way to help stoke a conflict.

Otherwise, laying low at Thundertree does seem like a wise plan. A green dragon probably isn't so prideful to not consider simply getting out of the region if a party of dragon slayers is making a base of operations there.
>>
>>98948026
No one has a normal composition D&D party anymore lol.
>>
>>98948082
>tfw comp is sorcerer, warlock, barbarian, fighter, cleric
We just look funny
>>
>>98948071
Yeah, I think whats got me stuck is, Venomfang is smart enough to realize that bringing Cryovain back as a zombie dragon and having an ancient green skeletal dragon on hand doesn't make her less vulnerable. Just better guarded.

I think she'll use them to go after the Orcs and go for the heart of Goretusk herself to become a dracolich since now she isn't beholden to Cryovain.

If I just had her hiding out in Thundertree again the party set the tempo and I'm not sure how to keep the campaign going if they just decide to leave her there.

I was very surprised how quickly the party took down Cryovains hp and his premature death has thrown a lot in the air.
>>
>>98948112
I think those plans work together just fine. Cryovain's zombie can be used for the false-flag attacks that bait the party towards fighting the Orcs, and while they're busy, Venomfang is free to pursue Goretusk. Dragon cultists could be used as spies and to coordinate the framejob.
The skeletal dragon could either be used as a bodyguard directly, or could be left behind at Venomfang's lair in case the party comes knocking.

If the PCs don't take the bait, then she does still have cultists and Cryovain in a position to lay siege on the orcs, since Icespire isn't exactly a well-supplied fortress, and they could pick off some of the orcs who would be fetching supplies or reinforcements.

I could also see a deception where Venomfang has the ancient skeletal dragon pose as the dracolich version of herself, as a way to trick the party into thinking they've defeated her. That might require some help from the cultists to create illusions of her voice. Even more ideally would be to have a fake spirit gem for the party to destroy, but faking that might be more involved.
>>
>>98947733
>>98947966
Alright, you make a good point. I put the 12 into charisma and the 7 into wisdom. My stats are
>Str 16
>Dex 11
>Con 14
>Int 10
>Wis 7
>Cha 12
I guess he'll just make some very unwise decisions. Like joining this particular party from what I've seen of the characters' backstories so far.
>>
>>98948255
I haven't chosen my race yet btw. Probably going to go variant human.
>>
Do you guys play with minis? If so, where do you get them from?
>>
Your character ends up on earth for a few days, with $200k cash on them
What do they buy or do while there before they're sent back to where they came from
>>
>>98948316
Drinking water and metal
Lots of it
>>
>>98948316
The answer depends heavily on whether he gets to bring his purchases back with him and whether they still function when he gets back despite the potential lack of technological infrastructure.
>>
>>98948323
Wonders why he has that much fire kindling, then probably ends up on world star within 10 minutes.
>>
What mechanical homebrew do you use in your games?
>>
>>98948297
I usually just make tokens using this guide https://youtu.be/LBZPi4oKlCQ they look pretty good but sometimes the glue they use on the epoxy smudges a bit. You need to find the right epoxy ones for sure. They have a great weight to them from the magnets and when I don't need them my wife and daughter like to put them on the fridge (neither of them play D&D)

I have a houserule that if you do bring a mini your character essentially gets 1 "fate point" a bit like in Dark Heresy. Essentially you get to save yourself from death once. It's to make sure someone doesn't buy a new mini then have it immediately die. I only had one player recently get a mini from hero forge. He printed it with his 3d printer. He did a great job with the paint job, he does commission painting. It can look a bit odd to have only one mini on the table though, the other players are thinking about getting some of the files from hero forge too. Might be cool to have the players have minis while all enemies are tokens, makes it visually distinctive.
>>
>>98936650
>farmer dwarf draconic sorcerer
>>
>>98947797
My current pc is a human cleric of chauntea.
He would pray for her and give her some sneeds
>>
3.5e is like every class having the Warlock's invocations mechanics.
>>
How would you build Green Lantern?
>>
>>98949317
Illusion wizard lvl 14
>>
File: IMG_7397.jpg (291 KB, 754x1100)
291 KB JPG
Is it morally acceptable to feed your high level fighter’s player a nigh endless stream 1HP enemies?
As a treat
>>
Wait if I'm reading this right the demon hunter subclass' soul cleave hits all creatures in a 10ft radius to you? Not just hostiles? And I'm assuming it only counts the heal once per cast instead of once per creature that fails the dex saving throw?
>>
File: 8v0u5390vooh1.jpg (876 KB, 2550x3300)
876 KB JPG
>>98949317
Wizard of some form. You want as many spells that create force/energy constructs or barriers. Abjurer, Evoker, or War Magic could work for example. The spells on this homebrew item work well for this. Also, make your Arcane Focus a crystal placed into a Ring.
>>
>>98949408
Yes, demon hunters are really bloodlusted
>>
Never played 5e
Only 5.5e
>>
>>98949385
It's terrible because dnd martials in any post 2e edition are terrible at dealing with large hordes
The removal of Heroic Fray is a travesty
If you want your group's fighter to feel cool you remove 2024's retarded idea of giving everything resistance to ALL BPS resistance instead of nonmagical BPS, and you give them big enemies to action surge into
>>
>>98949385
The issue here is that most Fighter's lack a method of actually mowing down a horde of individual enemies. Sure at level 20, you could maybe make like 10 attacks with Action Surge included, but thats only 10 guys for a few rounds! The spellcaster at this level could cast a spell that damages every enemy within 60 feet (Distort Distance or Circle of Death). That's hundreds of targets who instantly die. In the case of Distort Distance (A 4th level spell that they had since level 7), that continues to kill anyone who even attempts to get close to you.
>>
>>98949667
Speaking of which, here's the houserule I use (5e):
Killing Blow
At level 5, when a martial character hits an inferior opponent, he can choose to instantly reduce the target to 0 HP if it isn't immune to the attack's damage. Inferior opponents are creatures of CR 1/2 or less. At levels 8, 11, 14 and 17, the list extends to creatures of CR 1, 2, 3 and 4 or less, respectively.
For the purpose of Killing Blow, add all your levels in the barbarian, fighter, monk and rogue classes and half your levels (rounded down) in the artificer, paladin and ranger classes.

You can't quite cleave through the hordes, but you can one-shot even stronger opponents. In base 5e, MM CR 1/2 orc has 15 HP, potentially enough to survive a hit from level 20 fighter. Scaling is based on cleric's Destroy Undead.
>>
>>98949736
The Dirge spell (6th Level Spell for Clerics and Bards) also can do that, execpt its even better than Distort Distance since it moves with you.
>>
An ek fighter with fireball can deal with low hp hordes hehehe
>>
>>98950193
That's a spellcaster, but yes the EK Fighter could do that- or cast Distort Distance or Cacophonic Shield as well or since they have they have the Spellcasting trait pick up the Epic Boon of Magic School Mastery to cast Dirge and destroy the endless army of 1 HP goons. Magic Users are strong.
>>
>>98949385
Level 17 Mystic Brew Monk could drop more bodies than the fighter here. They could hit so many people with Intoxicated Frenzy.
>>
>>98950304
>level 17
No shit
>>
>>98950340
It says high level fighter so why not a high level monk? Also that monk has a 30 foot breath weapon it can use each turn as an action- that probably kills more than the fighter using Action Surge does.
>>
>>98950432
The difference between level 13 and 17 is vast
>>
>>98948941
Oh boy, now that would be a rabbit hole to get into considering I’ve been using 5e so long that there are very few things in it I haven’t played with at some point or another. As far as what I’m doing now I guess I can give a few vague highlights. These are the ones my players have enjoyed most:
>Standardized class progression and multiclassing. All classes now only have 18 levels though players still max out at 20, so you will multiclass at least a little bit. All feats related to giving class features no longer exist, so no getting basic spells, fighting style or expertise without dropping a level in the appropriate class. You give up progression on your main class to get access to features from another. Simple and easy trade-off. But, with the 18 cap you don’t necessarily lose out on final class features unless you want to dip heavily.
>Subclass progression standardized at 3/6/10/14. I already mentioned here >>98946385 first level subclasses are a balancing nightmare I didn’t want to deal with. It worked out perfectly with my changed class progression because to get access to gamechanging subclass features you have to give up the final level of progression on your main class. This means people only really do this when they have a concept in mind, which means it tends to work out really well.
>Proficiencies are now only gained if the class is taken at first level. This allows me to load them down with more interesting features since I don’t have to worry about them getting taken via class dips. On that note, there are now two major proficiencies: Martial Prof. and Magical Prof. They serve as powerful gates to the features those class types would want. Ritual casting, the ability to use a bonus action to disarm/trip/shove/etc. The kind of things that would be absolutely core to playing that class type.
>>
>>98948941
>I enjoyed the idea of the weapon tagging system of 5.5 so I stole it, but instead of tags letting you do something (since I already was allowing those things to be done by martials by default) I just made using a weapon with the tag remove the bonus action cost of doing the thing. So now they just do the special moves for free on attacks with the appropriate weapon. This also inadvertently ended up addressing >>98949667 because one of the options was cleave which let you make an attack hit another enemy in range and with heavy weapons this just becomes free on all attacks.
>Feats are now a separate thing from ASI’s. They are called talents and don’t give nearly the raw power of current feats (think GWM of SS), but rather they give options and abilities to characters.
>Spell caster levels from different classes no longer stack. If you want to class dip, you slow your spell progression, just like martials and extra attack not stacking.
>Half casters now have their spell level progression equalized to full casters (still capped at 5th level). However, their slot progression is still significantly slower. This solves one of the biggest frustrations half casters run into, which is that by the time they unlock a level of spells, the game has usually outpaced their useful window. So half casters really have almost no reason to ever take a damaging spell and instead just load down on utility and buff spells.
>Most of the spells as class features have been changed because that shit is fucking retarded and lazy design.
>Most noncore class features (think something indomitable might on Barbarian versus something core like rage) have been removed from progression and made into a class list that players get to pick things from at certain levels. Like Warlocks. So now non casters also get to actually build and customize their character.

Obviously there are a ton of class specific ones too, but I don’t really want to get into that unless there’s interest.
>>
>>98949667
>giving everything resistance to ALL BPS resistance instead of nonmagical BPS
Some creatures get that. Others just lose the resistances and get more HP.
>>
>>98950470
True, but there was no listed level- high level could be 13 or 17 even 11 for some. Regardless, The breath weapon is obtained at level 6, and kills 21 people in one action each turn, plus their Bonus Action can be used to punch 3 times or dodge (and punch 1 guy).

The Eldritch Knight Fighter can cast spells meaning they can accomplish the same feats that another spellcaster could.

The Arcane Archer Fighter has Piercing Shot which kills 30 people in one shot, then they have 5 more shots with Action Surge included.
>>
>>98950484
>>98950501
The changes to bonus actions has me most interested here. Enabling Trips/Shoves as a bonus action for martial characters, or having weapon specializations improve existing feats by reducing the bonus action cost.
Adding on more options while freeing up some of the competition for bonus actions feels like a great way to add some versatility.

Using Warlock Invocations as a basis for class features also seems like a big improvement. I find a lot of players really enjoy that aspect of Warlocks.
>>
>>98951270
>feels like a great way to add some versatility
That’s the idea. Casters get to feel like a swiss army knife because a single spell slot has so many uses. If martial class’ defining feature is meant to be attacking, then they should have a swiss army knife of options that they can choose from when doing so to augment those attacks. Giving them those options by default feels right, and making weapon selection matter is a nice addition 5.5 added. I just added it to my own stuff in a way that felt really good for players.
>I find a lot of players really enjoy that aspect of Warlocks.
I mean yeah, it’s everyone’s favorite part about Warlock. I could go on a very long-winded rant about warlocks as they are simultaneously the best and worst designed class in the game. I ended up altering that class more than any other because of their strange duality. But yeah, I shamelessly took their Eldritch invocation system for martials and their spell casting level unlock vs. slot progression as a basis for doing half-caster spell progression. Never be ashamed to steal a good idea for homebrew.
>>
>>98948941
My bullshit, which I hope to get back to updating fairly soon. Just have another fifty or so pages of notes to write for the upcoming campaign I'm going to be running in the new year.

https://homebrewery.naturalcrit.com/share/WYL_vcnY3bcN

Biggest things are martial maneuvers and forcing the mystic back into the game, but I'm also happy with a lot of the class revisions and everyone being on a 1/3/6/10/14 subclass progression.
>>
>>98951967
I tried the whole universal martial maneuver thing at one point, it just didn’t end up working out the way I wanted it to. Ultimately I went with giving each martial their own kind of extra stuff to do. I think that was actually one of the better successes of 5.5 all thing considered. The martials all feel like they have more going on now. Of course paladin and ranger got fucked sideways with the whole your class features became spells crap, but that was easy enough to fix.

I did end up giving maneuvers to fighters base though. It really does just feel like their thing. Of course I changed how they work somewhat. I removed any kind of action cost to using them to compensate for Action Surge getting removed entirely. I made fighter specialized to doing things out of turn and as reactions to other things being done rather than just taking an extra turn themselves. I always hated Action Surge. Single worst designed ability in the game by a huge margin. Even the 5.5 nerf didn’t fix the actual issues that inherently come from it.
>>
>>98952029
If you didn't build a list of 90+ maneuvers, with each class having a different selection available to them the way different spellcasters get different spells, you weren't really trying maneuvers.
>>
love fighters, barbarians, rogues, and monks.

being a spell chucker is cool but its like playing easy mode. martial-caster divide is fine and spellcasters have relatively limited magic ammo. if theyre destroying game balance the dm is probably not being aggressive and/or frequent enough with encounters. if they're not spending spell slots sticking to cantrips they're not going to breaking game balance.
>>
Martials (or casters) run out of hit dice before casters run out of spells.
The solution is to hit your casters with (high DC) saving throws against having their spell slots expended.
>>
>>98952161
>you weren't really trying maneuvers.
Anon, if you are the one that made that document then I must congratulate you on your dedication. I just spent a bit looking through it right now. I’m going to try and be very polite right now as sharing one's work and opening it up to critique is always a difficult thing. I fundamentally disagree with and don’t like most of the changes you’ve made. Some of it is interesting, but as a whole it’s definitely not for me. Thanks for sharing it though.
>>
>>98949317
He's flat out supposed to be a genielock, but recycled in space
>>
I think I overdid these. Anything specifically I need to tone down?

>inb4 all of it
>inb4 kys
>>
>>98952339
i think you should rename the troll, but otherwise this is truly lovely little homebrew. nice work, anon!
>>
>>98952339
With how much of a restriction there is on what materials you can move through as a Ghost there, you could probably have it be a Bonus Action for 1 minute of flight+phasing.
Otherwise, it's basically either a Bonus action Dash or at best a way to get past a locked door. Which seems fine. Basically a worse Misty Step, but with more uses.

As for the Troll, the big question is what rules you're using around the character being Large. A smaller question is what rules you're using around injuries that could otherwise result in the PC losing limbs.
Those aside, the Troll Healing isn't that much better than say, a Beasthide Shifter gaining 1d6+double Prof in temp HP.

The Loathsome Limbs feature is interesting, since it's similar to the Orc's endurance feature, but with a tradeoff that has the character function without an arm for the rest of the day. That said, the Troll Limb that spawns counting as an ally is a bit much. For however much you were worried about a Ghost PC phasing through walls, I'm surprised you're not concerned at all about the party potentially growing an army of trolls out of severed limbs.
>>
What is arguably the largest unaligned, non-sapient creature in your setting?
>>
>>98947797
>>98950561
>>
>>98952422
>A Warforged dressed something like a Brelish noble
>Two human males in Cyran-style military garb; one armored, one not
>Bugbear mercenary woman holding up the rear guard, with far too many sheathed knives on her person than what should probably be allowed.
It'd depend quite heavily on where my party is in my Eberron. If they're in one of the 5 great nations it's probably an unusual sight, maybe some delegation from New Cyre.
>>
>>98952399
Probably the "corpse" of a demon that is still alive up to a point (missing most brain function though) and nearly caused a grey goo scenario before being contained.
>>
>>98952355
thanks, but why rename the troll if you don't mind me asking?

>>98952370
>As for the Troll, the big question is what rules you're using around the character being Large. A smaller question is what rules you're using around injuries that could otherwise result in the PC losing limbs.
this is assuming PC only rules

>That said, the Troll Limb that spawns counting as an ally is a bit much.
that's fair. I probably should have said something like, "it's Indifferent to you and your allies, and will not attack unless attacked"
>>
>>98952504
>Why rename?
To simply distinguish it from NPC trolls. It isn't necessary at all. It's a simple taste thing!
>>
>>98952458
I feel like most partys are unusual.
>>
>>98952399
Depending on the definition of “sapient” we’re using, potentially the bone monstrosity consisting of bones from hundreds of thousands of skeletons. It does have situational awareness, but it’s unclear whether or not it has any true internal experience of consciousness.
>>
File: kg6mu7dlkt491.jpg (184 KB, 1968x1440)
184 KB JPG
>>98952399
Cloud Rays or Mekillots depending on your definition. And now I'm realizing I haven't killed a mekillot yet.
>>
>>98952792
>And now I'm realizing I haven't killed a mekillot yet.
Pfft, amateur. Me kill lots.
>>
File: Knight and Nymphs SFW.jpg (341 KB, 1273x1080)
341 KB JPG
Books for this feel?
>>
>>98952324
That's nice, but "I don't like it" isn't feedback unless someone was suggesting something for your use, and it certainly isn't a critique. You haven't even bothered to explain or offer an example of what you disagree with and why you don't like it.

I can tell you that my players have observed the following:
>even though it's harder for a character to permanently die, lower hit point totals and an unavoidable action economy penalty to getting knocked unconscious make hit point resource management a much more active part of encounters
>increased focus on reactions heavily incentivizes paying attention during others' turns
>maneuver distribution across classes and subclasses, along with the selection process, make it much easier to differentiate martial and half-caster characters from each other
>scaling rules on maneuvers don't just make them feel like spellcasting with a different name
>supplemental features and increased number of feats likewise allow for a greater degree of customization in a character's role and capabilities
>classes like monk and ranger get more defined core mechanics that have made them interesting to players who previously would have passed them over
>subclass interactions with base class core mechanics make them feel more like proper developments of the class concept
>multiclassing rules facilitate true multiclass characters while getting rid of dips
>character customization rules are very forgiving of mid-campaign pivots in a character's direction, rather than effectively requiring that a player have planned out their final build from the first session
>psionics feels mechanically and flavorfully distinct from magic to a large enough extent to justify its existence

If you have actual criticism, I'd love to hear it. I don't think I'll ever consider the bullshit "finished"--there will always be room for improvement and revision based on meaningful feedback and table play experience.
>>
>>98943144
At this point I just smear together the 5e, 5.5e, and homebrew rules I most prefer. For example, I hate the subclass revamp where everything always kicks in at Level 3, so I backport the Cleric's Domain spells to start at Level 1 where they belong, while keeping other rebalancing tweaks. Nobody complains because few player care about the rules as such anyway, and the few who do are persuadable to my perspective.
>>
>>98953275
>they managed to even tempt the horse
>>
>Reflavor a Club or Light Hammer (for Nick) as a Brass Knuckle or Cestus
Dual Wielders could have some fun with these I could see. A Fighter, Battle Smith Artificer, Bladesinger Wizard, Paladin, Barbarian, even Hexblade Warlock would all make for good punch guys with some knuckles/cestuses.
>>
>>98954359
Monks should also be able to use Caesti, and they should benefit from any class feature or feat that interacts with Unarmed Strikes.
>>
What does actually good monster statblock design look for 5e/5.5e?
Far as i can tell the official monster manuals were all designed with kid gloves and monsters tend to be comically weak in comparison with players that would be expected to meet them at their CR, whilst homebrew/third part monsters are a wild ride of unpredictable bullshit
>>
>>98954618
You'd need to make it a new weapon at that point and create a new trait for that, but I don't disagree. It does make monks a little stronger cause now your Unarmed Strikes can deal extra damage from magic weapons, but eh- Fighters, Paladins, and Rangers are able to attack 4 Times each round starting at level 5 with Nick + Dual Wielder. The Monk being able to attack 4 times at level 5 and 5 times at level 10 is fine, they gotta burn resources for that anyways the others don't have to.
>>
What are good AOE builds? Still Evoker?
>>
File: Evocation Adept.png (114 KB, 769x712)
114 KB PNG
>>98955116
Tell me, are these spells and the Fueled Evocation trait on this feat enough for you? If so, any Full Caster can be a good AOE blaster. Evoker can protect their teammates, but they don't get good AOE boosts until level 10 and 14; otherwise, they aren't much different from any other caster. Sorcerers can get Empowered Spell, which doesn't increase the damage ceiling but does increase your damage, and they also get Careful Spell to protect teammates. Innate Sorcerery also boosts their spell save DC, making it harder for foes to succeed on their saves. Dragon Sorcerer gets a damage boost for AOEs at level 6, but that's all they get.
>>
>>98955252
Oh, that's pretty good. Still, the rest of the party is a warlock, a paladin and a barbarian, so I feel like throwing in some Int would be better
>>
>>98955260
Then play a Wizard! Evoker is fine, 6th level Sculpt Spells can save your teammates and level 3 Potent Cantrip works well with 2024 Acid Splash. If you don't want to play the Evoker play any Wizard that catches your eye, because they can all blast really well by just picking up the spells you want that causes explosions. Some of my favorites include:
>Thunderwave
>Rime's Binding Ice
>Fireball
>Distorted Distance
> Sickening Radiance, Wall of Fire, Gravity Sinkhole
>Synaptic Static
>Chain Lightning, Freezing Sphere
>Meteor Swarm
>>
>>98955280
Gotcha, thank you. Seems simple enough
>>
>Playing wizard in 5e
>Cast haste on our fighter
>He slaps the crap out of the enemy with extra attacks
>Fighter about to be crit and I cast silvery barbs to make it into a miss, then give the rogue advantage for sneak attack
>Later I counterspell hold person that would have targeted the fighter
>Anon why is your character so weak? You dealt no damage that fight
I feel like my talents are wasted on this party.
>>
>>98955299
wish I had you when I was playing my fighter, wizard in my team was full into dealing damages, almost never utility
>>
>>98955299
Just tell them damage is the fighters job, and all haste damage is yours.
>>
>>98955306
Wizards can be a glass cannon or a buff/battlefield control engine. I find it more fun buffing and controlling the battlefield. The enemy did save against my mind sliver the one time I used it but that's just RNG.

>>98955328
I just said there's more to combat than dealing damage. The fighter player is new so doesn't seem to get it. I do sometimes feel like I'm the protagonist in one of those animes where the healer/buffer is secretly carrying and they flounder after he leaves.
>>
File: Tiefling 4e.jpg (6 KB, 320x180)
6 KB JPG
I love tieflings! They're pretty and they're fun!
>>
File: gnome im a monster.gif (672 KB, 480x360)
672 KB GIF
>>98955528
Gnomes are superior.
>>
>>98955528
Tiefling Draconic Sorcerer
>>
>>98936485
Playing Rogue in melee feels so sucky... I don't want to end up forced to play at range doing pew pew gaming with light crossbows every time, I want to get into the action and be able to play a backstabbing little shit but the system does nothing to reward that playstyle
>>
>>98955649
Never has
>>
>>98955663
I'm kind of wondering if I just don't understand the rogue concept that well. How are you supposed to play the "skillmonkey" role without constantly begging the dm to allow you to utilise your proficiencies? I normally play casters where I have a huge spell list to pick rp prompts from but when I need to play a martial I feel so lost in how to be useful.
>>
>>98955680
Rogue is basically the old thief class. You had the warrior who was great at low levels and carried fights. The mage who got amazing at high levels but was pretty garbage at low levels with only a few spells. Then you had the thief who was only good if he could surprise his enemies but was important for exploration. He would deal with traps, opening chests, picking locks, scouting etc.

These days rogue has been made decent at martial combat too. The key is you can deal lots of damage without worrying about spell slots. If you do the 6-8 combats a day that matters compared to a glass cannon caster. But the reality is most parties will only do a handful of combats a day which makes casters simply better. Factor in how good cantrips are at ever level and rogue is a relic of the past.

I still have had way more rogues than clerics in my games though.
>>
>>98955708
I find Rogues probably the most satisfying to play out of the martials. Rogues and Rangers. I'm really not fond of how unga bunga the fighter, Barb, Paladin trio is and in general I prefer being able to actually help my party in other ways.
The thing is that I kinda hate a lot of the main features of both classes. Rangers I genuinely want to find any excuse not to have to waste concentration on hunters mark so I can do cool shit with spike growth or conjure animals...
Then with Rogue, I just find the subclasses a bit underwhelming. Like I'd almost always want arcane trickster to a fault if just for the access to cantrips... I know stuff like soulknife is really good but limiting yourself to just throwing the same weapon constantly feels sucky and I do prefer melee. I also kinda like the concept of Mastermind, with being able to freely hand out advantage and play a supportive role but that again doesn't work well with cunning action so you're deliberately gimping yourself. Also soul of deceit should have been available way WAY sooner since being able to tell point blank lies would make the social game of mastermind far more worth the subclass slot
>>
>>98955560
4e ruined gnomes for generations to come
>>
Why couldn't WotC just let Soulknife psychic blades scale with rogue level?
>>
>>98955902
Why didn't they make Rogue sneak attack scale equal to Rogue level?? They made a feature that burns dice for the potential for an effect (Cunning Strike) but didn't do anything to help them with their damage problem.
>>
>>98955902
because as jeremy crawford once bragged, they don't even have a statistician on staff
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPzEfo82LBQ
Is this a good philosophy for a D&D party?
>>
>>98955299
Next time cast haste on him and end concentration just as he steps in front of an enemy
>>
>>98955972
You can tell.
>>
>>98955299
What's statistically the better option: haste on the fighter (or paladin, or barbarian)? Or bless across the party more broadly?

My sorc could do either with his concentration, he has Bless and will be able to get Haste next level, but which of the two is generally more effective? Assuming low levels to start with, but the plan is to get up to T3 eventually (not T4).
>>
>>98956861
Impossible to say without going into specific circumstances. The interesting thing is that how good Haste is depends solely on your party, but how good Bless is mostly depends on what you're fighting (though party composition also matters, the attack bonus is less useful if party has casters who rely on saving throws instead of attacks). And, of course, there's the fact of spell slots to consider.

Generally, fighter benefits the least from Haste when it comes to damage, as you only get one attack, which means the more damage you deal with one hit, the better. Paladins benefits less than they used to in 5.5 after the smite nerf, barbarians benefit more as they can rage more freely, the rogue is still king, as Haste can lead to off-turn sneak attack. Magic weapons and other ways to do more damage change the formula too. The defensive benefits of Haste are great for everyone, but particularly to a frontliner, the speed is better for ranged characters.

If the enemy has low AC and you hit anyway, Bless may not make much of a difference, and there's a plenty of monsters with low AC but a ton of HP. If the enemy doesn't have abilities with saves, the save part is wasted (though I don't have hard statistical evidence, I feel there are less saves in 5.5, as many of the riders on monster attacks are now automatic instead of a save, and many spellcasting enemies got attack-based "super cantrips").
>>
is 200 HP for a Huge giant with 16 natural AC and Legendary Actions a lot?
Keep in mind I am using a 5e system rework where hp bloat was reduced (but everyone can Power Attack and Surge again)
>>
>>98957137
yeah we have no info of how many players you have, their level, their class, where you pulled the statblock from, how you run your campaigns (many fights or a single big one) so we can't answer a question like that you know ?
if your players have ressources to spare and it would have been an adequat monster to fight without any HP changes then it should be fine
>>
>>98936485
Does anyone happen to know where I might be able to find a link to peruse the contents of the newly released World of Warcraft book?
>>
>>98957192
like that ?
https://5e.tools/book.html#wow
>>
Now that World of Warcraft is dead and forgotten, and Dark Sun is all but guaranteed to pass us by unnoticed, how about that Greyhawk?
>>
>>98957384
What about Greyhawk?
No really, what's there to even say about Greyhawk.
>>
>>98957137
No, the fighter in my campaign will nuke it in 1 round without expending resources.
>>
>>98957137
Considering we don't know what the intended CR of the giant is and what exactly the houserules do...

How the fuck should we know?
>>
> two of the players in our campaign are married.
> They have a baby
> They said we can resume the campaign after 6 months
> 8 months have passed and they won't let us resume the campaign because they say we are too much of a risk for getting the baby sick
> They take that baby to Disneyland
> They take that baby to every family function
>They take that baby to daycare multiple times a week

Oh but we are too much of a risk? That's so insulting.

I'm talking to the other players to agree to just get some replacement players and continue the campaign without them. If they wanted to just stop playing D&D with us they could have just said that rather than leaving us dangling like this.
>>
>>98957137
Yeah, that's a pretty brutal match-up for a party of 3 level-2 druids.
>>
>Player's agree to help underdark tribe attack their enemies
>Only thing I've decided is that they're going to have to lure them to the surface and attack there
>No idea what else to put in the session
Any ideas what else might be interesting? Puzzles, non-combat encounters, etc. We play for four hours and "Ambush encounter" is like an hour worth of content tops
>>
>>98957703
Oh I read this one before!
>>
>>98957168
>>98957498
>>98957511
>>98957757
Ok. I’ll raise the hp up by like 20 or 30. In terms of importance it is equivalent to a Storm Giant but the party are likely to encounter it wounded.
There will be two level 3 players, a Glory Paladin and a Artillerist Artificer and one NPC that has a spell list focused on healing, so they don’t immediately die. The party has a choice between participating in an arena with fighters from all over the world, which will include the giant.
The party can only Short Rest between fights
>>
File: 1718999113986200.jpg (117 KB, 1024x770)
117 KB JPG
>>98958266
Great plan anon, let us know how it goes
>>
>>98958219
An ambush takes time to prepare, you talked about lures but also have them find traps to create, and then have them build the stuff. Just hiding in a bush is lame and unlikely to succeed. You could even have them survey terrain to have them find which battle map to use if you have several at disposal (even better if you have small ruins too). If your players are as fast as we are on my table that's an hour gained before reaching a decision
You could also have a scout party from the underdark before the main troops. that makes it two encounters, and the goal of the first one is to leave no traces nor fleeing witnesses
other random stupid ideas
>if your party comes out close enough to a town/the exit is fairly well known, maybe some guards patrolling the area find them and proceeds to control them. They could be convinced to help in the ambush
>if they aren't out of the underdark yet, have them get lost in the tunnels and needing to find a way out by mapping the area. Alternatively, split the party and they need to regroup (bridge too weak for the heaviest team member, rock that fell, ...)
>monsters to flee from
>can have them unironically 'play' something like dragonchess, I'm not sure someone else here even remembers it exists
>fighting for loot can take a while too, esp if you add cursed gear to analyse or solve
>can put a skyrim tier door to open on the way up (dragonclaw ones), and to close without hinting at it being opened recently
>convincing any passerby like peddlers or travellers to leave the area for the next few hours
>>
>>98958266
>CR13 storm giant
>basic attack deals 2x 30dmg in a single round with +14 to hit
>against 2 level 3s with nerfed HPs
>That have 25 and 18 HP respectively even when optimistic on their stats
please do tell us the results
>>
Participated in a DnD one-shot today
I chose to play as a Warlock and since the mini they had for the warlock was a female elf, I decided to name her after a german goth-slut who does porn
I unfortunatly wrote her name wrong (a little bit) and I mixed her up with her gf and partner, who is also a goth-slut who does porn

Anyway, no idea if I ever gonna use Leah Obscura again, but if I will, what's the best way to goth-slut max in the game?
>>
>>98958386
they have an escape plan anyways. It was a nat 100 on a weekly event dice roll. I didn't expect to happen so soon. It is up to them to participate. Maybe I'll give them a side-quest that results in a level up so they have a better fighting chance
>>
>>98958539
if you make them gain 5 levels maybe yeah
>>
you know what? I'll just make them fight the normal contestants. Why make it more dangerous than it needs to be? I am not gonna be the DM who TPKs because he thought the Young Red Dragon was easy prey
>>
>>98958625
Pussy
>>
>>98958625
at least this way there isn't a risk for first hit insta kill no save so yeah sounds like a better choice. If you want something dangerous for level 3 you have a lot of choice that wouldn't also destroy a much higher level party
>>
>>98956660
That'll show him how I'm not useless lmao.

>>98957046
>fighter benefits the least from Haste when it comes to damage, as you only get one attack
A fair point. He has a pretty good magic item and duelling though so does deal decent damage.

>Haste can lead to off-turn sneak attack
You're going to have to explain this one to me.
>>
Are you gonna let the new class options from the WoW book into your campaigns?
>>
>>98959442
I might rewrite some of it into my homebrew doc, but not straight out of the WoW book, no. If nothing else, we aren’t using 5.5.
>>
>>98959429
>You're going to have to explain this one to me.
Sneak Attack only happens once per turn. Not round, turn, which means you can do it twice if you have a way to attack outside of your turn using a reaction. Normally, that's an Opportunity Attack, but getting those is on the enemy, not the character.
With Haste, you can use the Haste action to attack (and get SA), then Ready with your regular action (trigger can be whatever, as long as it's something that's likely to happen when it's not your turn, like the enemy making an attack, casting a spell, or doing anything at all) to get a reaction attack (and also get SA, as it's not your turn anymore). And unlike opportunity attacks, the rogue doesn't have to be in melee.
So, for a fighter, Haste is ~50% damage increase at level 5, ~33% damage increase at level 11, and ~25% damage increase at level 19, not counting any bonus action attacks or other limited ways to increase damage. For a rogue, paladin or a barbarian, it's ~50% increase. For a rogue, it's always a 100% increase, again, not counting bonus action attacks (and rogue has other uses for BA), as long as you can get a sneak attack.
>>
>>98959639
>For a rogue, paladin or a barbarian
Ranger, not rogue, obviously
>>
>>98957703
>6 months
Absolutely not. This kills the campaign.
>>
>>98959442
Lol
>>
>>98959639
I hadn't considered the held action but that does make sense. It feels a little munchkiny but it's within the rules as written.
>>
Well part one of the Arena (because the side-quest to gain a level took a little longer so we couldn't finish) is over with a PC victory. The Artificer (who has multiple ways of dealing fire damage) and the Paladin (who received a Coral Blade from their employer so he can properly tank) successfully tagteamed the conjoined Plant-Cyborg.
There was one opportunity for me to use release swarm, which can function like a Mage Hand, to lift up the Paladin's sword after the monster disarmed him, but I didn't think of it in the moment.
The players are in high spirits and at full hp thanks to the Eldritch Cannon, but they both used a spell slot and they are only allowed to short rest between fights,so it isn't over yet
>>
>>98939434
Obviously barbarian
>>
>>98940568
This general is already shit, no worries
>>
>>98942595
Yes, several times
>>
File: sanjani-zakia-sketch2.jpg (748 KB, 1920x2715)
748 KB JPG
>>98959442
>Creature Type: Humanoid
>Size: Medium (about 7 feet tall)
>Speed: 30 feet
>Bloodied Frenzy. While Bloodied, you have Advantage on attack rolls.
>Darkvision. You have Darkvision with a range of 60 feet.
>Troll Healing. When you expend Hit Point Dice to regain Hit Points after a Short Rest, you regain Hit Points equal to the maximum roll of the dice plus your Constitution modifier.
>Zandalari Troll. If you roll a 1 on the d20 for a D20 Test, you gain Heroic Inspiration at the end of the current turn.
These guys read like a really good martial or attacker!
>>
Update on my most recent session:

In the previous session, the players did a quest for a red dragon and came into contact with a rival party of adventurers who were at the dragon's lair in order to slay him.

Instead of slaying the dragon, the players freed him. As a result, they became enemies with the rival party of adventurers. The conflict culminated in a duel in the town square.

The duel was broken up by the town guards who came to arrest everyone. The rival party escaped by flying away because they were Aaracokra.

The players were arrested, and had to appear before a judge. They were ordered to do community service: a quest for the mayor of the town.

The players are shipping a wagon load of carpets to a nearby city for the mayor. Their wagon hit a rock and flipped because the horses were scared by wolves.

When the wagon flipped, carpets spilled out all over the ground. One of them unrolled and the players discovered that there was a dead guy rolled up in the carpet. That's where our last session ended.

The players think I have a mystery prepared. I have nothing prepared, and no idea what I'm doing.

I am open to suggestions.
>>
>>98961994
I have two suggestions
1. Use a premade dungeon, something short. I like the Dan Coleman ones generally although some are better than others
2. Use the lazy DM's guide method (which despite the name is actually a fair bit of work) to brainstorm.
>>
Fuck i'm happy i didnt put anything more into social shit for my character. DM doesn't seem to do anything for it or any other player. Persuasion, deception, no matter how detailed or thought out or eloquent attempts at social shit (character is party face too) it just goes how the DM wants it to go. Everything just either works or gets shut down, no rolls. The most i've gotten out of my deception skills have been in combat when doing some kind of feint or misdirection, like playing dead or creating an illusion to make an enemy go in another direction (2 rolls in over a year). Kinda just glad i went mostly combat focused stuff instead of doubling down on feats and shit for social situations. Fuckin annoying sometimes.

I come up with in character shit too, practically begging for rolls, but after a year, fucking zero. ZERO. Complete stonewall of "the NPC doesnt believe you/says no" or just "yeah he agrees/believes you".

Kinda mad.
>>
>>98961994
A few options:

Mayor had a guy killed, stashed body in carpet and the carpet was being sent to someone the mayor trusted. Maybe they're planning to scapegoat someone else for the murder, maybe the trusted guy is the one who wanted this guy dead in the first place so it is confirmation.

Some assassin/crime group killed this guy and stashed him in the carpet, was planning to take the body away later only to find out the carpet with the body is being transported elsewhere, probably hot on the PC's heels to ensure silence on the matter.

The corpse is actually UNdead and the mayor or someone around him is either scheming to start an undead plague in this nearby town or was sending it to some necromancers who were planning to experiment on it "safely". Cue this Resident Evil-style fucky wucky.
>>
File: brown.jpg (981 KB, 2526x4096)
981 KB JPG
Well, anon? Started that WoW campaign yet?
>>
File: Wizardess.jpg (1.2 MB, 2638x3500)
1.2 MB JPG
How nerdy do you like to rp your wizards?
>>
>>98963044
Literally every single person I know who plays D&D and has any experience with the Warcraft franchise is appalled at this nonsense and refuses to touch it.
>>
>>98963044
I might use it for an isekai game, being isekai'd to WoW would be funny.
>>
>>98963044
Still writing notes for it. I want to do something Classic-era but that kind of necessitates removing a lot of canon characters. The solution I came to was to just wholesale throw quite a few characters to the Scourge, so that there's no "ahaha I meant to lose all the time lmao" up until Icecrown. Then have Onyxia's manipulations of Stormwind go a lot further and wide-reaching, throw almost all of Burning Crusade out the window, and then go from there.
>>
>>98936485
>Look up how to make the Conjuration Wizard more fun while playing since the Tasha summons are pretty weak
>It's just people conflating Minor Conjuration's usefulness when it's highly dependent on what the DM will allow you to get away with
Right, guess Benign Transposition with a Misty Step combo is the best this subclass has to offer
>>
>>98963044
Probably not a WoW campaign but more options is more options, just taking a look to see if theres stuff that maybe should be excluded
>>
Would WoW have the same problem as other settings? The problem being that all the interesting things have been done by the setting main characters.

Eberron is always stuck in a brief period of tentative peace so at least when the plot advances every time it's your own.
>>
>>98959442
>Are you gonna let the new class options from the WoW book into your campaigns?
Only the specifically updated from 5e ones, like Swashbuckler Rogue and Mystic Brews/Drunken Master Monk
>>
>>98963902
It might be even worse in WoW's case
>>
Is Rime of the Frostmaiden a good adventure to run to celebrate winter approaching soon?
>>
>>98964392
I remember that I read it. I don't remember too much about the adventure other then I read it.
>>
Is it me or are the monsters in the WoW book kind of wimpy, they don't seem that strong
>>
>>98964392
I think it's pretty fucking solid, but quite long and the players can often encounter enemies that they are too low or high level for
>>
Is the Battlemaster really as good as everyone says compared to the other 5.5 Fighter subclasses?
>>
>>98963125
>puckeeslop
>>
Requesting any scans (preferably in good quality) of Phandelver and Below: The Shattered Obelisk for 5e please!
>>
>"that guy" cheats
>griefs
>derails
>drives people away from the table
>smothers most attempts to actually play the game
>after being called out for the Nth time he silently storms off and goes on indefinite hiatus without even acknowledging anything
>expect a few solid months without him
>everything is immediately and noticeably smoother
>surprise! hes back after 3 sessions
i love my dm but what the fuck
>>
>>98966695
Some people are bad at conflict. Last time I had a "that guy" I had the entire world ignore him. He cancelled more sessions than he showed up to and eventually just stopped coming completely. Which I think was very much for the best.
>>
>>98966733
it just pisses me off since he actively and knowingly throws the game all the time, and yet the dm doesnt want to just drop the hammer on him despite our grievances. that guy has openly stated multiple times that he goes out of his way to cause problems for the rest of the party "because somebody has to" and that "it keeps us on our toes" and whatever other shit
>>
>>98963942
Not gonna let Death Knights roam the world?
>>
>>98966695
>cheats
>griefs
>derails
>drives people away from the table
>smothers most attempts to actually play the game
Examples?
>>
>>98966858
>cheats
he had a massive streak of luck across months while he was playing remotely, to the point where it was very obvious. we started recording his rolls and did the math on his odds/distributions/etc and found they were several orders of magnitude higher than any string of rolls that could have ever naturally occurred. we brought it up to the dm and he was forced to do roll20 rolls only, at which point his distribution magically returned to a completely average level
>griefs
during both combat and rp he intentionally takes the worst options such as the most recent example where we had successfully talked our way out of the lair of an angry god, only for him to poke his head back in to aggro the guy and cause us to nearly die and/or become inflicted by a debilitating curse that lasted multiple full sessions. hes also just slow as fuck during combat (on barb)
>derails
similar to the last one, he just constantly goes out on his own and winds up leading us on massive spiraling goose chases which invariably become massive time sinks
>drives people away from the table
my best friend, not wanting to concede so much to the guy ruining everything and stress over a game, left. he came back once he found out that guy was going on hiatus, but now that hes back it wont take much for him to leave again at which point ill probably follow him and half a decade of campaigning will unceremoniously end
>smothers most attempts to actually play the game
the worst was right near the start of the campaign when he told someone straight to his face multiple times that nobody cared about the sorts of backstory elements he was trying to interact with, which resulted in that character becoming significantly less engaged overall. i used to banter about how little he contributed towards the story, but i didnt know this at the time and it only very recently came to light. thats multiple years of altered trajectory just because this one guy was being an asshole for no reason
>>
>>98966899 (Me)
i hate to sound like such a bitch but it just baffles me how much the dm is seemingly willing to let slide. apparently hes gonna start really cracking down on whatever new table agreement, but thats just another form of detraction in my mind and without that guy then none of this would even be necessary.
>>
>>98966929
>i hate to sound like such a bitch but it just baffles me how much the dm is seemingly willing to let slide
Speaking from experience, DMs struggle with putting their foot down, either out of fear of killing the group entirely or because they're just beta as fuck.
>>
>>98967130
yeah but its just one fucking guy that everyone has similar complaints about. whatever, i just dont get it. i hate feeling like such a great game is liable to fall apart on a whim because of one retard being unable to function within a social setting
>>
>>98967206
NTA, but speaking as a DM, it's hard to shake off that desire to be even-handed. There's sort of a worry about being seen as a tyrannical or unfair DM.
Which is why, assuming everyone else is on board, you basically have to give the ultimatum yourselves. You don't really need the DM's permission to kick the guy out. It might seem like you do, but you don't.
>>
>>98963125
Does she look nerdy?
>>
>>98964392
>Rime of the Frostmaiden
Oh man, so I guess I get to sound off a bit here about a campaign I've been running for a group for about 18 months now. It’s a Rime of the Frostmaiden campaign with a bunch of heavy editing by me. The main campaign has weird consistency issues with difficulty as >>98965859 points out due to the more open nature of the map and the random encounter tables. Then for some reason it pulls it’s punches in places where thematically I was expecting more danger for no apparent reason, while simultaneously having some pointless difficulty challenges that just feel like it’s meant to kill a character because fuck you that’s why. Also, there are more than a few scenarios in the campaign that are really hard to fit in unless you rewrite things to make them relevant and also a few wasted opportunities where something is put in there that wasn’t utilized as much as it could have been.

The backgrounds also vary from useless to game changing and you really need to work with players on those. I wanted all of my players to be someone from the valley, so I ended up with a dwarf, goliath, a Reghed tribeswoman, and a human from Ten towns (who actually was the doppleganger from character secrets card). It really helps if your players are playing characters that have at least some vested interest in Icewind Dale. All in all, the campaign is really fun, but you will probably have to do some rewritting if you want to make it feel a little more coherent. If you’re curious I can drop some of the changes I ended up making in case you feel like stealing them.
>>
>>98963044
I have one player who is interested in playing a dracthyr.

I'd rather just port it to the setting we actually play in though.
>>
>>98967846
Yeah sure! Though, as I've been thinking of running it, I'm considering maybe just excluding the final part about the ancient city and every plot point related to it. I feel like I've had enough of official D&D products with plots that center around some ancient Netherese relic and it would be more interesting to focus on Auril and her curse, which I've heard doesn't actually get much focus overall.
>>
Today, my character will likely become more monstrous.

Way back, my sister told me about the game she was running that, at the time, it seemed like was out of the question for me because of work scheduling, in which the players were way too nice, and since she was running exp based progression (it was her first time GMing, forgive her), they weren't leveling up at all.
When things at work changed, and I was able to play, I intentionally made a character that was secretly a murderer and she loved it.
As I did some evil stuff, and drank a questionable drink, I have gained a more outwardly evil appearance, and a hunger for violence.

Fast forward a year, and the entire party seems fine with this. I don't know if it's their unwillingness to confront my character, thinking I'll take it personally, or that they are just ok with "the devil they know" because I am a useful killing machine, and they're all complicit.

I'm beginning to wonder what it's going to take for their characters to think "maybe this person is dangerous." I'm looking forward to seeing what happens to my character after eating hag-flesh last session.
>>
>>98967846
It's gone well for me - the party TPK'd in Sunblight so I've been running a campaign to destroy the Duergar new world order for the last 10 sessions or so, with three minibosses, a corrupted fiendish Xardorok, secret weapons lab, haunted mansion and a return to the Termalaine mine.

>>98968121
>it would be more interesting to focus on Auril and her curse, which I've heard doesn't actually get much focus overall
It doesn't get much.

I've tried to add some extra flavour for my Auril. Basically:
>she was kicked out of her divine realm during the time of troubles
>the Rime is converting Icewind Dale into a demiplane to be her new divine realm
>this process is making reality glitchy with spell sigils, glyphs, spontaneous ice sculptures and architecture forming, portals opening up to similar realms, planar travel malfunctioning etc
I've leaned into old lore where she's mistaken for/impersonated by the Queen of Air and Darkness and made the two fragments of a broken archfey, with Cegilune the hag goddess (previously an impossible sister of the Queen of Air and Darkness) being the third part of the Maiden, Mother, Crone dynamic, like Auril already has with her forms.

What this actually means in game is I can give Auril a court of sunlight hating dark fey when I'm bored of using coldlight walkers and snow golem minions.
>>
File: IMG_20261117_170131_930.jpg (102 KB, 1280x798)
102 KB JPG
I really want to do an Astral Sea campaign.
The official rules are TRASH. No ship combat rules in a ship game...
what is the best 3rd party adaptation?
>>
>>98963044
Dark elf



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.