What's the best historical Roman RPG? Is it Lex Arcana? BRP Rome? Mythras? GURPS? Something else?
>>98940494GURPS, of course. It even has supplements for Greece and the Eastern Roman Empire.
>>98940494>Lex Arcana Looks like magic stuff to me not really historical, but I like this at first glance. >BRP RomeMight work too if the BRP system is actually good. I think Chaosium has CoC which uses the same system so hopefully BRP is a good system.>GURPS Install gentoo response of /tg/ to be honest. Hopefully it actually is good in a "just works" meme but instead of for computers and OS meaning it is for traditional games.
I don't mean to impose, but a close examination of this civilisation reveals that everything was a footnote to who did what militarily. You're better off playing a wargame campaign with rules like Chainmail, Age of Hannibal, L'Art de la Guerre or Hail Caesar. I would subsume it within a Barons of Braunstein game for amazing roleplay and intrigue.You can simulate everything from the skirmish level to battles on the magnitude of Cannae. There is no limit to how detailed you want to make this, with omens and auguries restricting player actions, or Senate politics interfering with their plans.Depending on how many players you have, everyone can control various factions. You can maintain a civil war flavour like Caesar vs Cato/Pompey, or introduce foreign enemies Hannibal vs Scipio, or the conquest of the Hellenistic Kingdoms.
Honestly a lawfare based game would be pretty cool, imagine orators who make up what ever they wanted legally while rallying the mobs into fighting
>>98941305>Looks like magic stuff to me not really historical, but I like this at first glance.Lex Arcana is, even theoretically, pseudo-hstorical and not historical, as it should be more or less depict a first/second-century like society that continued up to 475. This is before the reverse X-Files sheaninigans the game is about (the idea is that yes, magic is real and that's mostly known, some people can do it, and you're the special agents between bad evil shit and the Empire).It actually isn't, as even skimming the setting book would tell you - the authors didn't really bother to check out their factoids for dates, you will find shit like plebeians still being a thing, but you might like it nonetheless.
>>98940494depends what you want to focus onlegion life? politics? plebeian life? gang of Rome?
>>98940503Have you actually played this? If so. How did you convince people to play GURPS?
>>98941389Who did what militarily is largely decided by realities of civilian life, though.
>>98940494There is Mercator for Classic Traveller to play it as a historical trade game set in Roman Empire. Mercator is free, but it does require also having Traveller or some of its derivatives. https://www.zozergames.com/classic-traveller.html
>>98943203I want sword and sorcery style adventurers, of course, but in the ancient roman world.
>>98947620Counterpoint: roman history isn't particulary good for SS, at least the one we tend to think about. Definitely too much state/elites control and, I would argue, the feel is too "down to earth" for us for various reasons.Ffhard and the Mouser started out in the real ancient world, true, but that was not by chance the hellenistic period (THAT seems to me pretty good to go, at least in Egypt/Middle East). I see you raising the point about Conan and Aquilonia: true, but while Wolves Beyond the Border is a fantastic story, it's hardly about a Rome parallel. Others feature big C as the king, so no good.(I think you could do a good thing or two OUTSIDE of Rome itself, in a far-off municipium, but being it out of the Senate's eye would make players feel robbed out)
>>98947673The very early republic where all the Latin, Sabines, Etruscans, Rutulians, Aequi, and Hernici city states were their own power in Italy would be cool
>>98947673There's whole games about adventuring in roman Britain, like 43 A.D. I don't see the problem with adventuring outside the imperial core, so long as there's latin and a common currency, it's a fun way to explain why characters from disparate parts of the world are thrown together.
>>98943078NTA but I specialize in dominate-era Rome. I die inside every time I'm reminded of how little history buffs care to learn about that period. It isn't even that complicated. Just stop looking at it through the lens of 1st century legions and the senate. Get into the Chinese warlord period mindset.
>>98947673I feel like Crisis of the Third Century fits almost every possible situation you would need for adventures, and if you're talking about specifically "Rome's Peak" there are still many MANY opportunities for a game of globetrotting murder for hire and intrigueYou could have a game start during the Sertorian Wars and go straight into the events that cause the fall of the republic, the punic wars, the semi-mythical invasion of Rome by Brennus, theres just so much room for chaos and multiple "OFFICIAL and REAL Senate for TRVE ROMANS" desperate for any edge over any one of the three existential violent conflicts they are embroiled in at any given moment
>>98947996Mind you, the space for playing (and playing action games) is certainly vast, even outside of shit hits the fan periods like that. I'm just not sure if I can see something particulary swordy and sorcerous in the usual early imperial/late republican (and close to center of powers) ones.>>98947909I dunno tough. Frontier shit sounds good (see Conan himself, of course), but I mean, it seems to me easy to just call the fucking legions in. Especially when there is loot to be had - not on the germanic limes, but on the parthian one.I dunno, the more I think about it the more it screams smaller states in which your PCs can be outside of the estabilishment, or at least be in the middle of two estabilishments (rival cities, at the very least).It might be just me seeing Rome in a (still) somewhat Enlightement-like way, so to speak.(also, while I think REH's hate of Rome doesn't make sense at all, I think he would point out that SS heroes are outsiders. Which doesn't mean per se no roman or roman-alligned hero, but who do you see more as inspo: an hypotetical Conanius of Mediolanum or someone more on the lines of Bran Mak Morn and the other guys in his stories?)
>>98948101Is there a game like Zenobia but for the immediate post-empire Dark Age?
>>98947673Completely wrong.Check out Sorcery Against Caesar: The Complete Simon of Gitta Short Stories, if you want S&S short stories set in the Roman empire. The empire was full of guilds that operated like gangs, cults, civil wars and political intrigue. Just the series Spartacus shows you how Batiatus a middle-level patron operated in the late Roman republic , tons of story ideas if you build around a locale/city and thene expand to a network of patrons/intrigue.Also with regards to periodization, for the imperial Romans after Augustus, the Hellenistic/classical age is the near/middle past like renaissance/middle-ages are for us, but anything Minoan, Mycenean, Hittite, Sumerian and Egyptian would be the utter ancient past for them. So you definitely have ruin exploration within the Roman empire and beyond.
>>98948393Some story advice/fluff for anyone running Roman late Republic/imperial Rome campaign.1. The gods are alive, even in the absence of a magic system (Ars Magica, Lex Arcana, Cthluhu Invictus) , 9 out of 10 of the general population believe the gods are real and are active in the world through signs and portents, and 7 out of 10 are extremely superstitious (maybe a sceptic/aristotelian greek rationalist philosopher or a christian/jew would be the outliers).2. Each medium to major urban center has a at least a dozen cults/factions beyond the official magistrates. The governors/magistrates in the Roman empire were very hand's off, this middle economic and religious space was occupied by guilds, rich and middle patrons and cults. These can all be a network of patrons for the pc's. 3. Everyone has an opinion about imperial or regional politics: There was an active mercantile middle-class in imperial rome since the time of Augustus that became suddenly extremely wealthy, they accrued civic and magestrial posts and had an active stake within the imperial politics. 4. Anything beyond the Empire's borders is "Here be dragons", Ptolemys Geographia is the grandfather of this, quoted as far as the european renaisance. 5. Wealth is transitory: the pc's should be incentivised into spending as much money as possible, for travel, carousing, offerings to the gods, investing into patrons business oportunities, gladiatorial or chariot racing games and maybe into buying a domus as a base of operations.
>>98941389>I don't mean to impose, but a close examination of this civilisation reveals that everything was a footnote to who did what militarily.I do mean to impose: you are a mental midget.
>>98947673Holy awful take, Batman!
>>98948577So basically rewrite it.