[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: IMG_3615.jpg (226 KB, 1170x1707)
226 KB JPG
>violent pillagers
>culture based around extreme boasting for honor
>cruel to animals
>no appreciation for art or nuance
>>
>>98941018
Yes, we know Orks are all football hooligans, grass is green, sky blue, etc.
>>
>>98941018
>culture based around extreme boasting for honor
What fucking version of orcs is this? Not LOTR, not D&D, not 40k or Fantasy, what's your source?
>>
>>98941062
His wife's boyfriend.
>>
>>98941018
>Lust provoking image
>>
>>98941062
warcraft
>>
Imagine having the luxury to create a barbarian culture and race and have it be considered politically-correct. That's a privilege not all cultures enjoy.
>>
>>98941018
LOTR Orcs are modeled after raiders and bandits in general. Not a single group of people, the idea of a people who steal and don't build. Overtime people added more to it from middle eastern themes, saxons, etc. Hooligans, etc. The Orcs are black BS happen cause of Blight cause they just wanted a "black fantasy race" and some fag tourist activist push it and got it to ruin orcs. Like that indian trying to do standup that got Apu removed for the Simpsons cause he was called Apu once or twice as a kid. (Which I call BS but whatever)
>>
File: 1566972307231.jpg (113 KB, 720x720)
113 KB JPG
>>98941018
i dont see it

>>98941141
what are you, gay?
>>
>>98941018
>culture based around extreme boasting for honor
No.
>>
>>98941403
>Blight
For some reason people always say this in threads about orcs.
I assume you mean Bright. But bright is 20th-century American with orcs and elves, so black people exist as a marginalized minority, and orcs also exist as a marginalized minority even lower on the hierarchy. I don’t know how you could miss this, because Will Smith’s partner was an orc, and the whole movie revolves around the differences in privilege between the two of them. It truly belabors the point that orcs are not black people.
>>
>>98941527
firstly nobody watched bright
secondly
>continental US dark skinned minority in the ghetto doing crack and forming gangs and shit, where the point is race relations
you dont see me filling my fantasy setting with cat eating "chingchongs" in straw hats then getting mad people say they're Chinese. if you dont want the comparison dont use the symbolism...
>>
File: HTkT9ewWcAAACZj.png (1.49 MB, 1536x1024)
1.49 MB PNG
>>98941018
Way to describe the middle east
>>
>>98941541
You are an idiot and you don’t have a point.
>>
File: 1702831190227845.jpg (314 KB, 2048x1614)
314 KB JPG
>>98941141
Let's not pretend /tg/ is really a blue board.
>>
>>98941403
>The Orcs are black BS happen cause of 40k orks that metastasized to the rest of fantasy
You kids do not even understand the history of the hobby.
>>
>>98941572
>Most intelligent bright defender
>>
I thought the Men of Rohan were modeled after the Anglo-Saxons? Orcs are modeled after the Normans during their invasion of England.
>>
>>98943646
Orcs are WW1 Germans.
>>
>>98943810
Why? Were WWII Germans too classy to be orcs?
>>
>>98943646
Those niggas are the same they live right next to each other
>>
>>98941018
orcs are based on all races , this makes them the least racist race imaginable , we can all see them in us. (expet indians , those are goblins.)
>>
>>98943646
They're germans
>>
File: Screenshot_1.png (72 KB, 197x146)
72 KB PNG
Hey guys I'm thinking OP doesn't know anything about anglo saxons and only just heard the name in a youtube short with AI voiceover.

That's just a hunch though.
>>
>>98943834
Too retarded more like it.
>>
>>98943834
I swear, they make one uniform a select few special security officers wore and hollywood spent the next 100 years portraying them as all being super stylish and suave, when outside of that one uniform they were objectively the least classy and worst dressed military in the whole war, and a massive downgrade from the first war.
>>
File: dildohat.jpg (26 KB, 554x554)
26 KB JPG
>>98944199
They literally wore dildo hats int eh first WW.
>>
>>98944215
At least that had character. Line them up in a row and they look like a bit of gothic architecture. But everyone in the second war went for the "soup bowl on head" look, but the Germans somehow managed to make one of the most boring but over designed helmets.
>>
>>98941359
So, not orcs at all.
>>
>>98944253
>the Germans somehow managed to make one of the most boring but over designed helmets.
those Hugo Boss uniforms though
>>
>>98944253
>>98944215
Stahlhelms and pickelhaube both look amazing. You two have shit taste.

I would also remind you that the Stahlhelm is a product of Imperial Germany during WW1 as well. In terms of raw shape, it was the best helmet of both World Wars (best coverage), but I will admit, though the British Brodie had the worst outer shell, it was cheap to manufacture, and had a superior internal liner to that of the German one. And during WW2, the American M1 helmets are almost as good as the Stahlhelm in coverage, while being vastly more comfortable and less likely to cause head injuries if hit by shrapnel due to a good suspension system.
>>
>White D&C thread #4572348975813497
shalom
herbs
>>
>>98941018
They're a vague mix of every soldier of every belligerent party of WWI, with the most prominent ones tending to being cockney and mongolian for some reason.
>>
>>98944174
They're a reddit fag pushing everything evil is white culture or something. What else you expect a brownshirt to be, I swear. They think if they cheer for "white" death they be forgiven for being white or some gay shit like that. That or the classic white girl saving the minority BS that flooded media in the 90s and 00s
>>
File: boarorc.jpg (66 KB, 800x600)
66 KB JPG
I just shape my orcs after boards. Clannish family units, territorial, tough as nails and recklessly violent when it comes to it.
>>
>>98941062
Also that's about the least Anglo-Saxon thing. The British were renowned for NOT boasting, and often making their contemporaries look like fools for boasting about their achievements when those of the British far surpassed them. Sadly this culture of humility and modesty has led to many modern Britons being demoralised, and many foreigners mistaking British humility for a tacit admission of inferiority. One of the more humorous culture clash moments for me was my American ex and my English mother making roast dinner; and my mother stated in typical self-deprecating and humble English manner that she is not very good at making gravy (when she had been making it for decades and makes the best gravy I've ever tasted), while my American ex announced how amazing she was at making gravy. She then proceeded to explain step by step to my mother how to make gravy, and my mother was too polite to stop her and I had to intervene.

Very different cultures. The American ex had a lot of Italian ancestry, and I think Italians like most Meds are extreme braggarts despite having nothing to brag about. They ignore hundreds of years of incompetence, failure and occupation; and brag endlessly about tomatoes and cheese.

Italians are hardly the worst though. Asians, Turks, Indians and blacks all seem to think they are worthy of respect when their cultures are complete filth. Another crazy event was some Turkish woman trying to lecture me about the participation of the English in slavery. Stupid cow genuinely thought abducting children to be janissaries was a good thing and was flat out ignorant of the Ottoman slave trade.

What do they know of England who only England know?

The moment you become aware of other races and cultures is the moment you realise how great England and the British Empire was.
>>
File: Look at these Foos.jpg (52 KB, 636x424)
52 KB JPG
>>98941527
>>98941403
The Orcs in Blight are Latino, not Black. Their entire visual design takes more from LA Chicano street culture than Black. The Orc cop is supposed to be a representation of how most of the LAPD is Latino, and most of their arrests are Latino as well.The film has a line where they compare racism against Orcs to blaming Mexicans for the Mexican-American war.
>>
>>98945079
I’m pretty sure the cop who brings up the Mexican war is the actual Mexican. These orcs served an evil wizard in his army of darkness, which isn’t directly analogous to anything in US racial politics the Irish and Welsh know that feel though lmao, but there was a Mexican in the room so he made the comparison.
Also, orc cops were unheard of, Jakoby was supposed to be breaking new ground. Bright orcs are a bit dwarf-like, inhumanly strong but heavier and less agile, they can make a positive (or at least negative) id by smell, they love death metal and they hate guns. I’m telling you, man, they’re supposed to be orcs.
>>
File: 124145151514356775.jpg (88 KB, 1280x720)
88 KB JPG
>>98941403
>The Orcs are black BS happen cause of Blight cause they just wanted a "black fantasy race"
The whole 'orcs are black people' came from people seeing how orcs in modern fantasy are portrayed and described as 'savage, unintelligent, violent, and tribal' and people then thinking 'hey these are black people'.

Tolkien’s orcs were inspired by Western European fears of the Mongols and Huns.
Tolkien even used the phrase "... least lovely Mongol-types" in his notes on orcs
When the LOTR films first were first released they were accused of making orcs negative Asian stereotypes and playing in to
'yellow-peril' and their depiction of orcs were even compared to WW2 anti-Japanese caricatures.

In early D&D at the time/and retrospectively people compared/compare the orcs to Native Americans. Early D&D was very frontier based, ie isolated settlements surrounded by wilderness, and orcs were the inhabitants of these frontiers resisting and raiding 'civilisation'. I don't think they were deliberately based or inspired by Native Americans it think this may be due to the American cultural references of that time that these early writers used as a frame of reference for their works.

1/2
>>
File: Mexican_Orcs.jpg (82 KB, 840x540)
82 KB JPG
>>98945235
2/2

Now I can not speak for all works of modern fantasy fiction but it does seem that in some more modern American fantasy works (modern D&D, WOW, etc) some leaned into more 'black inspired' orcs (which may not have been deliberate), some modern works give orcs dreadlocks (not exclusive to black people but heavily associated with them) and for example Shadowrun uses some hip-hop and rap inspiration for their orcs. Now this also may be in part due to some modern fantasy works becoming increasingly urbanised and people linking the modern urban world to these fantasy ones and as what often happens this may be due to the cultural references of the time that these writers are using as a frame of reference for their works.

You can see how modern D&D is trying to lean away from any potential ambiguity by making them explicitly Mexican coded, dressed as Vaqueros alongside saguaro cacti.

You mention Bright but as >>98945079 said they are explicitly Chincano inspired. However many people, based on their own frame of reference, believed they were based on black people.

>TL:DR Orcs have traditionally represented 'the other' and it is our own unconscious pattern recognition that leads us to link orcs to real life ethnic groups based on our own unconscious biases. However in some works orcs were indeed inspired by real world groups however they are not meant to be representative of these groups (unless the writer is lazy, stupid, or trying to make a point).
>>
>>98945235
>>98945237
Apologies if my points are incoherent or nonsense but I can't be bothered to expand or tidy them up anymore
>>
>>98945067
>The moment you become aware of other races and cultures is the moment you realise how great England and the British Empire was.
>We don't boast, tho
Hysterical.
>>
>>98944678
>those Hugo Boss uniforms though
hardly anyone got those though. That's the hollywood part. To hollywood all germans were wearing that, but then you look at photos and the majority looked like trash in one size fits all shapeless nonsense.

>>98944788
what's weird is that the American ones look the least offensive. Like I've only been talking about looks, and those things bring the whole uniform together nicely and look good because they're so big but simple. Everyone else wanted little dents and visors and side wings on their bowls instead of just making a bigger bowl.
>>
File: Orc Low.jpg (1.7 MB, 1533x2300)
1.7 MB JPG
How should orcs act culturally? Should they be evil savage brutes (pic rel)? Or should they be a civilized misunderstood and proud people/race?
>>
>>98945444
You can be both, depending who is looking at you.
The mongols were considered unwashed barbarians to the people who knew only their war footing and not their civilization.
>>
>>98945444
>puckeeslop
>>
>>98944199
The worst-dressed power in WW2 were the Chinese, both the KMT and PLA.
>>
>>98945444
Battle Brothers has my favourite depiction of them despite it being your archetypal Orc but with extra steps. I really like how they used bear roars mixed with the voices. So to answer your question, evil savage brutes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zyUytaAOdXw
>>
>>98945444
Obviously Orcs are Hellenistic.
>A bunch of tribes that constantly fight each other
>the most civilized are a scattering of city-states who constantly fight each other
>they only ever unite when it means fighting some outsiders
>one citystate is known for bragging about being the greatest warriors but they're mostly full of shit and lazy from their conquered slave cast and got really gay about oiling each other up before a fight
>another citystate is known arguing to the point that they invent politics around it
>the greatest contribution to culture is a form of arguing about arguing they called philosophy
>their greatest philosopher is named for his size and was a professional wrestler
>all their poetry and plays involve dick jokes
>the moral of every story is "the gods are assholes" because their gods are all assholes
>they have a grand epic about the fall of another culture that they use as a basis for their own origins but it's very likely they were the savage invaders from those stories and that's where they acquired the stories and culture.
All that and they'd pull of togas and marble columns pretty well.
>>
>>98945444
prompt?
>>
>>98947386
Hellens were one of the most sophisticated races of the ancient world.
>>
>Another thread seething that leftists noticed the constant orcs = niggers spam, and trying to shift the blame
lol
>>
File: IMG_0540.gif (803 KB, 240x135)
803 KB GIF
>>98941018
>>
>>98950620
They liked to say that about themselves, yes.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.