So I found the thread, which was started about 4 days ago, earlier today and kept the tab open to reply once I could. Once I did it was archived but I typed a WHOOOLE THIIIIING before realizing bc I didnt update it. So now im making a continuation thread that directly replies to OPs request.
So I believe the game RuneQuest does it in a way that fits well a historical setting. First Ill give some background on the game and then explain the mechanic.RuneQuest is set in a Bronze-Age high fantasy setting. The various factions act and hold cultural beliefs that are relatively coherent with those of real life bronze age civs (ofc modified by their own magical setting lore).The game is d100 so skills are between 0 and 100 and you roll under for success, (so your swordsmanship is 70%, you must roll 70 or less to succeed an attack). A d100 is two d10s, one for Ones and one for Tens, so 2 and 5 is 25.Now, the Reputation Mechanic.You get a reputation sheet, empty, and as you complete significant events (say, helping people, commiting crimes, killing fearsome monsters) you can add the event to the sheet and then roll a die depending on how significant it is notable 1d3significant 1d6heroic 2d6the game provides examples of what counts as each. Reputation always goes up it never increases, you just become famous for other things. Multiple instances of the same event can modify the same entry instead of always making a new one. Now this represents how well known you are. If you encounter an NPC, the game master might roll to determine if they know of you, a player might also choose to use their reputation to boost other rolls (like persuassion and intimidation). You can roll it as if it were a table instead of a skill if it feels more appropiate, so each entry determining for what reason do they recognize you (bc you're a criminal in that city or bc you saved the other caravan?), landing blank means they dont.Finally. theres instances where the roll is modified bc of context, so if your in another city or another country theres a pentalty to the roll. Likewise if the NPC is well-travelled and informed it might be easier to be recognized. Hope this helps :)
>always goes up, never DEcreases
>>98941327Not that anon.>You can roll it as if it were a table instead of a skill if it feels more appropiate, so each entry determining for what reason do they recognize you (bc you're a criminal in that city or bc you saved the other caravan?), landing blank means they dont.This is cute, I like it.
>>98941326I'm not keeping track of all that shit.
>>98941348I understand not everyone has the brain capacity to track the addition between two numbers, but reconsiders wether youd be more at home Larping with theater kids instead
>>98941327which edition of RQ?
Legends of the Wulin has Loresheets, although I've never played it and honestly I find it a bit hard to understand from the book. But I like the idea that you earn rep that other players spend for you.
>>98941352ESL
>>98941327I feel like some of this hasn't been explained. Do you have a total reputation score that increases for each event? Or does each event have a separate reputation score, and you pick which one to use when modifying a roll?
>>98941724It's runequest, famously badly written and organized. Nobody knows how it works.
>>98941724you have a single reputation score that is the result of all the notable things you have done.It only ever increases, it does not decrease.But it doesnt mean that it's positive reputation.Once when drunk you killed somebody in a brawl, this has given you the reputation of a mean and dangerous drunk and others in the tavern avoid you if they know who you are.But you may also have hunted and killed a large wolf that was plaguing the clans goat's herd.And the list goes on. So depending on the sum of your notable actions your reputation is build.So both fame and infamy are part of the same number and are distinguished by roleplaying and the situation itself. Depending on the situation someone's reputation might be a boon or a bane to them.i also like to include high level skills in your reputations as well. For example you are well known for being a master weaver because you have 80 in craft cloths. So even if you haven't done anything notable you might be known simply for being a highly skilled member of your profession
>>98941410current edition of RuneQuest: Glorantha, however that edition is setting specific, so I'd reccomend either only borrowing the mechanic or going with something like BRP, Age of Vikings or Mythras (for the archived OP's game set in medieval europe)>>98941724Each event has a reputation value % and the total is tracked next to the name at the top of the sheet. So you might have two events on the list (Killed dragon near Paris +12% , killed bandits +6%) the total reputation of 18% is marked at the top of sheet, if you show up to a King's court you might want to roll 18 or lower on a d100 to be recognized for these deeds. Though if its the king of Paris youre talking to, the GM might give you a +30% bonus bc its reasonable he'd know who exactly saved his city that time, so you'd have to roll 48 or less to succeed, much easier. If youre talking to the King of Berlin instead, it might be modified with a -10% instead bc its distant. The GM might modify the values as seems sitting these are just examples i came up with, tho the RQG core book has tables with more specific reccomendations.
>>98941912So what happens when you hit 100?
>>98943074you can go beyond 100unless you have a penalty for whatever reason then you almost? automatically succeed but by then you are an epic hero for the legends
Bump because I love these kinds of immersion mechanics
>>98941737That's why someone released Player's Companion, fixing the shitty rules and telling you how to play.
This feels like it unfairly punishes characters who want to do things that are sneaky, friendly, clever, etc. and just promotes all conflict all the time.
>>98946822why would this promote conflict when most of it's use is for social encounters and solving things cleverly with rp using your fame and reputation as collateral.If you wanna be sneaky you can just be sneaky
>>98946822I dont see how, if youre sneaky but you accomplish some great deed im sure people will still know about it if the character dosent choose to hide it after the fact, I can imagine a reputation entry like (Snuck into Imperial Palace +12%) or as for the diplomatic thing (Brokered Peace Deal +12%).Like its there to mark great deeds that'd be known about, i gave the examples of killing bc thats the bulk of RPG quest but heck you could have (Cucked Tom the Banker +6%) if thatd be notable in your table. The point is literaly just that this determines wether people recognize you when you tell them that you're the Dragonborn or whatever.
>>98941804>i also like to include high level skills in your reputations as well.For example you are well known for being a master weaver because you have 80 in craft cloths. So even if you haven't done anything notable you might be known simply for being a highly skilled member of your professionDude I hadnt thought of that but I'll incorporate it when I play, tho prolly for those that achieve 100 in my case. Would also make way to introduce someone famed for being a great swordsman without that someone necesarily being battle-tested, maybe the guy just trained that much and ppl know it.
whoops only managed to green the first sentence instead of the whole quote
>>98946955the way i see it above 75 or 80 is notable and above 100 is significant.the moment i saw this it screamed famed bard or any other character really, like a speaker know for his high oratory skills, stuff that really happened in ancient rome for example and it clicked to me that characters should be getting famous for high skill numbers because it's what happens irl and it makes sense in the game as well either way glad i inspired you.
I like the idea of a reputation system.
The real question about any reputation system isn't you getting points for whatever you actually do, but how your reputation develops on its own
>>98952925Care to elaborate?
>>98953605The interesting part about reputation isn't having a list of everything you got goodboi points for all cut and dried, it's how the story around your character interacts with the people in the world
>>98955235uhh sure. sounds like u didnt read the thread tho