[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: warhammer.png (6 KB, 233x216)
6 KB PNG
Speaking to some more normie friends they vaguely know of GW and they assumed 40k was some titanic ur-succes and it supports everything else that is below it.

When any long in the tooth warhammer enjoyer can tell you for a couple of years now Warhammer 40,000 has been Games Workshops worst product. Worst new sculpts. Worst new rules. Worst release cadence and structure. Its a bad game where every rulebook is outdated weeks after release at the latest, is churning out new editions so fast that they can't even keep up fixing the last editions issues and are being buried in multi generational edition design debt and cater to competitive tourney waacfags while marketing to ultra mainstream goyim. Costing the fun of the game, its tone and in general just feeling like they are trying to spin too many plates and the floors tripping them up with all the ones the already broke scattered across it.

Like it still makes money of course. But everything it does another product line they put out does it better and has an overall happier playerbase.

Can you name the last time you saw a happy 40k player?
>>
>>98943213
You're really mixing up completely unrelated statements and assertions.
>Uber success
It is.
>That supports everything else
That's the LOTR license.
>Worst product
Yes.
>Can you name the last time you saw a happy 40k player?
No.
>>
>>98943213
I saw someone new in my local discord this week. They had just started 40k and bought/painted their first models yesterday. They were pretty happy I think.

You can also see a lot of GW cumguzzlers in 40kg if that's what you're after. Half of them would probably commit suicide rather than play any edition before 11th's current release.
>>
>>98943228
Honestly I genuinely admire people who can obsolesce non-perishables.
Like it's fucked and against my values.
But I admire the craft.
>>
I'm happy GW barely pays attention to LOTR, its rules are the best the company has by far, and if they cared too much, they would inevitably fuck it up.

I'm still mad so many armies went to Legends, though. Give me back Khandish Chariots and my Mahoud Camel Riders.
>>
>>98943316
That's my local community's opinion on ToW. They got some gripes but are happy GWs barely touching it.
>>
>>98943213

People act like the popularity of DnD, 40K, and MtG are a curse but it's actually a blessing. The most popular game of each type acts as flypaper to catch all the worst players.
>>
>>98943213
I have put warhammer games in general at the bottom of my list when it comes to tabletop miniature games and im having much more fun building and painting minis again. Only time i get warhammer models now is as gifts or if they release characters i like, for example ciaphas cain.
Current focuses are moonstone, starcraft tmg and pinup miniatures and the enjoyment im getting is so much higher than sticking to gw models. Currently getting a full escher warband printed using sculpts from another company.
>>
>>98943213
Until 10th edition dropped MESBG was the worst game by a lot. No other GW has such absolute dogshit core combat mechanics, the game has several cool and novel features but ultimately the combat is just 1995 necromunda/2nd edition but fucked up and retarded and also dull, there's a reason that game is not more popular, and it's not that lord of the rings isn't a popular IP, the game is just bad and i think they keep it that way on purpose.

11th edition 40k went absolutely wild on being a shit experience though and now beats everything else out by quite a lot. Not having a complete rulebook is annoying, effectively demanding the use of predetermined placements of proprietary terrain footprint shapes is literally the gayest shit I've ever seen in a tabletop game and makes it take an extremely long time to even set up a game, and the level of accountancy involved in scoring is tedious and boring. If I have half a dozen different wargames I could play, why on earth would I play one that wants all that shit for so little reason?
>>
>do people not realize that my opinion is objectively correct? Could people who agree with me come here and help me create an echo chamber?
I don’t understand you people at all. Do you not have friends and really want some but only if they autistically agree with you all the time?
>GW touched the rules! Oh nooo!
You can play whatever you want. It’s imaginary. You and your friends can decide you really like Xth edition and never buy another product ever again. You can copy and paste rules from other books. You can do whatever you want. It’s such an obvious truth I have to assume that’s not really the issue you’re complaining about.
>>
>>98943213
Every 40k player i see at the LGS is happy, why the fuck would they play it if they werent?

Also yes 40k is there worst game, But has the best lore and factions. I am hopefuly the new AoS lore will make it not ass, as I would like to play it.
>>
File: 40k tournament.jpg (254 KB, 1024x768)
254 KB JPG
40k is their lowest quality game but also they're most profitable. There is an inverse correlation of popularity and quality in GW games. Once a game or variant becomes popular it immediately becomes total dogshit
>Sigmar 1e is a mess, 2e is a fun beer and pretzels game that got popular, 3e is turned to tournament slop
>Kill Team is a fun optional mode with an emphasis on customization and narrative. It got popular so GW turned it into tournament slop
This always happens. The ideal life cycle of a GW game is
>Launch messy in 1e
>Refined and expanded in 2e
>Dead and picked up by the community
No game EVER needs a 3rd edition
>>
>>98943213
As an awg and hwg chad all I know there's 40k and 40k fantasy version and everyone was sperging TF about the fantasy version a while ago.
Like all big extremely popular things what I glean from these threads is that everyone hates it but can't bring themselves to do something the herd isn't doing.
>>
>>98943213
It's the setting and story of 40k that makes it good, not the wargame, not anymore.
>>
>>98943213
>Can you name the last time you saw a happy 40k player?
Oh I forgot to say, me! I was overjoyed as a GK player when the Decree was revealed, the salt that flowed as a result was hilarious.
>>
Mid-large scale wargames have always been dogshit to play. It's more about painting and having yourdudes and using your imagination than raw gameplay.
>>
>>98950583
Wrong! 40k used to be fun and broken, now it is overlycomplicated to the point where it isn't fun at all. They removed fun mechanics like flanking and scatter with 15 overly worded teleportation mechanics
>>
>>98950593
half of that is because armies are 2-3x as big as they used to be
>>
>>98943213
I'm a happy 40k player. But I play 4th edition
>>
>>98950603
True and on tiny boards. I still remember in 8e which GW suddenly said that 2000 points was a "standard" game of 40k. 1000-1500 used to be standard! 1850-2000 used to be a big game! Now the average unit is cheaper, has 2-3 times as many special rules and is on a larger base
>>
>>98943213
40k the sin eater of GW and lets them release other better games. Even AOS is more interesting.
>>
>>98943213
GW has made plenty of worse games than 40k.
>>
>>98952701
>I'm a happy 40k player. But I play 4th edition
That doesn't count and you know it.
>>
File: IMG_2886.jpg (3.37 MB, 4032x2695)
3.37 MB JPG
>t.nogames



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.