[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1784604845802853m.jpg (63 KB, 724x1024)
63 KB JPG
How should camaraderie between evil PCs work?
>>
File: difficult.jpg (76 KB, 680x680)
76 KB JPG
>>98944965
>hello fellow evil person, do you have the same goal as me?
>why yes, yes I do
>wanna work together to achieve it?
>sure
>>
>>98944965
Sure, both because of shared goals and because bad people can still crave acceptance and belonging, be capable of feelings of love and friendship and so on.
>>
>>98944965
At the risk of sounding edgy: Just look at real life politicians. Unironically they work together to do some heinous shit because they know they will all benefit. Meanwhile there's no benefit to rocking the boat or trying to betray their allies, because all it will do is get them thrown off the metaphorical boat.
>>
>>98944965
allies of convenience with benefits
>>
>>98945084
It's not edgy to point at the sky and say it's blue
>>
>>98944965
I like this subject and would appreciate reading recommendations. It does of course depend more on politics because you’re dealing with self-interested people, their best friends will tend to be their most profitable friends and they’re always worried about betrayal, but they’re still human. And it’s nice to have some kind of mask-off space in your life, you see that in drug culture, “amoral people are winning, we are so winning, also we aren’t really less moral we’re actually just smarter than them” and so on.
>>
>>98945112
>would appreciate reading recommendations
The Black Company by Glen Cook if you mean fiction.
The Protocols of the Elders of Zion otherwise.
>>
>>98944965
Look at how evil groups work in the real world (gangs, communists, irish revolutionaries, etc). These groups have genuine camaraderie despite having goals inimical to the rest of civilisation.

In fact these groups, through their nature as deviants, tend to have more close knit bonds - at least among the rank and file due to the fact that they cannot associate normally with civilised people.

It's only at the leadership levels where the deviants have gained varying degrees of power that the backstabbing occurs, even so the major internecine conflicts happen after the main goal of the deviants has been completed. Looking at historical examples: The Irish Civil War, The October Revolution when the Bolsheviks seized power after the successful February Revolution and all of Africa post-decolonisation show how once the deviant group has achieved its aims the various factions start to fight.
>>
>>98945140
*Dialogue Aux Enfers entre Machiavelli et Montesquieu
>>
>>98945112
Read about Nazis. They were vile as fuck but there was genuine camaradarie there, maybe not among the high command with its power struggles, but in general. Even high-ranking Nazis were still humans with genuine ties. For instance, Hermann Göring, who was, ideology aside, a greedy, corrupt opportunist, was also by all accounts a loving husband and a doting father.

If you want something more fictitious, well, Black Company was already mentioned, but I'll second that. I'd also recommend Second Apocalypse, where a lot of the characters are pretty fucked up by modern standards. In particular, Scylvendi are a quite cohesive culture largely defined by glorification of brutality and united by that shared sentiment. Dunyain are cold, ruthless and manipulative enough to count as evil in my books, and they're brought together by a shared grand goal. That book series provides plenty of examples of villainous camaraderie, really.
>>
Holy fucking tankie
>>
>>98945210
a) I'm not an american.
b) I live on the capitalist DMZ and can see from my apartment the 'wonderful' conditions the commies live in.
>>
>>98945222
So you probably know how they (and you) would have been living right before the violent communist revolution happened. You know why communist revolutions happen, whether they’re the violent ones or the peaceful ones, they happen because modern capitalist shit-holes (and the associated meddling from western governments, western banks and/or the Pentagon) produce insane and intolerable living conditions.
Where are you, Korea? lol aren’t they a “democracy” now? What I said about blasted post-capitalist shit-holes still applies here, because of how the west ran all of Asia in the centuries leading up to that, but you must realize in this case that the whole concept of capitalism and communism in Korea comes purely from foreign powers using it to fight a proxy war.
>>
>>98945215
I know right? How weird and abnormal am I for wanting to reduce the overall power level of the global ruling class in The Year of Our Lord Two Thousand and Twenty Six? People like me are clearly evil, and you should bring this up during any discussions that you may see here related to contrived villainy in fictional elf-games, this is clearly on-topic here and doesn’t seem forced at all.
>>
>>98945222
Thinking that North Korea is communist rather than a de facto monarchy sure is something. To be fair, though, while it is factually true that real communism actually has never been tried, the fact that every attempt at building a communist society has pretty much immediately devolved into something that's communist in name only pretty strongly points towards communism just being unworkable. It's kind of like libertarianism or anarchocapitalism: a pleasant fantasy that's too divorced from realities of the world to ever become anything more than fantasy. Social democracy, on the other hand, is pretty nice.
>>
>>98945311
I live in Korea and am employed in Korea (by the local government) but I am not Korean.


Claiming that Russia, China and Cuba were better off under their various communist dictators than under free market capitalism is retarded. The death tolls under Mao, Lenin and Stalin show your argument to be retarded.
>>
Regardless, the discussion should be about games not about some tankie's delusions about communism.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ut5Sqyk9lBg
>>
File: Screenshot_15.png (607 KB, 1000x563)
607 KB PNG
>>98945161
>evil groups in the real world
>(gangs, communists, irish revolutionaries)

Really can't tell if you're a brit, a pajeet or just retarded.
Kill yourself regardless please, you're are wasting good oxygen.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z6q8FEkotCQ
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0d2LAs-WL_4
>>
>>98945161
>The October Revolution when the Bolsheviks seized power after the successful February Revolution
December Revolution forgotten (again).
>>
>>98945406
When are they going to have a comfy Summer Revolution. I want to smash the system in shorts and sunglasses!
>>
>>98945421
That's vacation season. That's no time for a revolution!
>>
>>98945013
Thread should have ended here.
>>
File: 1685474510655.webm (2.24 MB, 1334x720)
2.24 MB
2.24 MB WEBM
>>98944965
>>
>>98945406
Decemberists weren't really communists and the December Revolution occurred nearly a century before the 1917 revolutions.

That said if the Decemberists had succeeded the constitutional monarchists and republicans would have turned on each other in a heart beat.
>>
>>98945161
Reading about the French Revolution and its structure in-depth was mind blowing.

Basically having 3 factions: nobility, state, and church. As the state begins (rightfully) attacking the overpowered old money nobility and church, more radical factions split off and demand more and more action be taken even after the state has achieved its goals. And from THOSE radicals comes another division that begins open bloodshed, following ANOTHER division when lesser radicals believe no more violence is necessary while (and this is the part we hear about) Robespierre starts purging not only clergy and nobility, but their own former violent radical comrades, including Georges Danton, effectively ending the reign of terror as people realized they just executed the most reasonable and admired man in their movement just because he said to stop executing people.

I’d argue you rarely start with an evil character. You start with a morally neutral character among good characters, then as they acquire power they naturally justify increasingly immoral acts for a greater good until somebody wakes up and realizes they’ve completely overshot and missed the greater good and anyone who agrees with them is now doing evil shit while maintaining a “morally neutral” or “lawful” guise.
>>
>>98945674
It's arguable whether they can be called evil at all. They saw contemporary what Europe looked like and realised how far behind the Russian Empire has fallen. And wanted to do something about it, but the whole uprising was such a shitshow of incompetence (on both sides) it's not even funny.
>>
File: Spaceballs - The Gif!.gif (1.32 MB, 640x336)
1.32 MB GIF
>>98944965
>>
>>98944965
Depends...
>>
>>98945684
It's even funnier in wider context. Benjamin Franklin talked Louis XVI into providing financial support / loan for American Revolution ("to spite the Anglos"). When rebels won, they told Louis to fuck off they ain't paying back a dime. Which is the money France was later missing to quell grain crisis that spiralled into their own revolution.
Which also became a vehicle for Napoleon's rise to power.
>>
>>98944965
the whole "my enemy's enemy" thing can get pretty messy
>>
>>98945259
>the fact that every attempt at building a communist society has pretty much immediately devolved into something that's communist in name only pretty strongly points towards communism just being unworkable

I like the analogy that "Real Communism" is like one of those exotic isotopes that can only exist in a laboratory and has a half-life of like 0.03 seconds.
>>
The Orzhov Syndicate from Mtg combines White community minded conformity with Black selfish greed. Essentially you have a bunch of people who have decided the best way to look out for number one is to join a group. They tend to be lawful evil. They're pretty much a marxist view of capitalism and religion, which is gay as fuck and very nu-wotc, but fun to role play. I had a character in a D&D group who was LN and kind of a jerk but in a funny squidward kind of way. Quark and Charles from M*A*S*H* were his biggest inspirations.

Also I'm about to DM a Paranoia game, the book describes playing a troubleshooter as "like an evil party but without the intelligence or swagger". So being a bunch of doomed petty backstabbing dickweasels is perfectly okay as long as that's what the players are expecting. I think that's what Fiasco is about too.
>>
>>98945259
>>98947969

"Socialism only works in two places: Heaven where they don't need it and hell where they already have it"

Ronald Reagan
>>
File: 1791800367363403.jpg (199 KB, 1024x1024)
199 KB JPG
>>98944965
One must imagine that at some point being evil would be really alienating. You've raped and murdered and tortured hundreds or thousands of people, you've been party to demonic rituals. How on Earth could you just have a cup of coffee with some normie and not feel completely out of place? What would you even talk about?

At least among other evil fucks you can just be yourself, you don't need to tiptoe around why you have a necklace made of human fingerbones or why you have a mason jar of human teeth sitting on your desk."Yeah I collect the incisors, Bruce over there gets the bicuspids, Celia used to collect the canines but she--yeah she summoned Yog-Cincagua at the end of last season and the hero disturbed the circle and she got dragged down to Hell, so we've been saving those for her in case she comes back."

I imagine this breeds a rather robust in-group preference for evil people. They're actually probably more likely to present a unified front than other groups because they know that even if they go straight sooner or later someone is going to find out that they used to scalp 12 year olds. If your friend group ALL used to scalp 12 year olds they won't find this weird, but if you've started hanging out with Paladins the "Hey it was during the Spellplague everyone lost their minds" line isn't going to work.
>>
>>98945684
The French revolution is a tragedy from the republican side, inspiring from the Bonapartist (ie correct) side but a fucking comedy from the royalist side. Seriously, the extent to which the Bourbons fucked up was hilarious.

Even when everything was fucked, Mirabeau used his quadruple digit IQ to create a "this is how the monarchy can still win" plan, and Louis decided to do the exact opposite. And then there's Duke Philippe, the best example of
>"I never expected the sharks to eat *my* face" says man who voted for and endorsed the sharks eating people's faces party

I hate the Bourbons so much it's unreal. The entire revolution could've been prevented if exactly ONE Bourbon was competent.
>>
>>98945311
please understand that communism can't be "tried" anon.
It's the end goal at which point all states have been dissolved along with private property worldwide, labor is no longer exploited and a lot of other stuff as well.
As i am sure you are well aware this has never happened before.
What was tried were various forms of authoritarian socialism with the very theoretical goal of achieving communism in the future and i say very theoretical because no authoritarian regime ever did anything to further this goal. Quite the opposite, the USSR did more damage to global socialism and the eventual goal of communism than any other country on earth.

This is not because socialism doesn't work. It's because authoritarianism can never pair with it and produce anything other than a typical dictatorship where the dictators hold the means of production unlike typical dictatorships where the capitalists still hold the means of production and act in support of the regime and the regime in support of them.
>>
>>98950536
oh yes the senile president that removed a ton of regulations left and right that allowed among other things the scummy banking bullshit that caused the 2008 market crash and ruined middle america forever
>>
>>98952812
You have to understand something. The revolution was certainly prevented in the past because there was one or more competent people around.
The thing with history is that people look at positive outcomes especially and they seem inevitable.
A faulty system will eventually break and that is what happened.
When you have a system producing incompetent petulant hedonistic retards at scale then of course it will break eventually
>>
>>98947813
>main participants
>main
>>
>>98952812
Duke Phillip is the sort of character who should be taught in every class room next to the Haitian Abolitionists and the Russian academics. IRL version of that guy from Crossed who got his wife and baby raped and tortured to death testing a retarded theory.
>>
File: 401454.jpg (65 KB, 280x475)
65 KB JPG
>>98945112
>reading recommendations
Villains by Necessity is almost mandatory reading on the subject.
>>
>>98945202
>They were vile as fuck
A perspective among many.
But not all.
You don't have to virtue signal for good boy points here anon.
We already assumed you believed everything you were taught by the government.
>>
>>98954876
>A perspective among many.
>But not all
Indeed. I don't really hold to the kind of extreme moral relativism where everything's a matter of perspective, though.

>You don't have to virtue signal for good boy points here anon.
I'm not going to vicesignal, or whatever the opposite of virtue signaling would be, for good boy points, either.

>We already assumed you believed everything you were taught by the government.
Nah, I've read enough history to come to my own conclusions. Nazis were pretty fucked up. There are fucked up people in all times, of course, and some of the fucked up people in our times have latched onto Nazis and decided that they were actually good and cool and based. I get that. Again, though, I don't really agree with kind of extreme form of moral relativism that'd be required to consider these people as having some kind of a valid point.
>>
>>98945259
North Korea is a democratic republic.
>>
>>98944965
Alliance out of convenience because good parties won't have them that turns into genuine comradery over time.
>>
>>98944965
The history is written by winners. You see them as evil ragtag bunch of misfits, but once they defeat the "good" guys, people will finally realize that living among undead and donating a few virgins to keep sun rising up every morning isn't that bad of deal.
>>
>>98956742
not always, its not unheard of for the losers to go home, write some seethe about how they lost for unfair reasons, and then in the future we mostly go by the losers accounts rather than the winners for political expedience
>>
Watch a mafia movie



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.