Puzzles.Oh how I dread making them.At their best they get players looking creatively at their sheets. Acting in character. They can give breathing space between combat. Make a dungeon feel deeper. Be genuinely fun.At their worst though they can take too long, players can get stuck, they can take too long to make. Be too easy or just unfun.And that's when you have an idea for one.I try to include a diverse range of encounters but I've wasted hours of prep time staring at an empty sreen. Am I the only one who struggles, do other dm's bother with puzzles?
>>98945156"Puzzle" frames it wrong. "Problem" is right. Non-combat situations that block progress or threaten harm, where the players are free to engage with them as they see fit. If you're doing dungeons, then just make sure you have a looping overall design. If the players can't figure out a solution, then they'll have to find another route. Alternatively, put rewards behind these obstacles in a dead end, and now it simply becomes a piece of treasure they didn't get, not their overall objective. Better still, if their objective is just "loot" then they are never guaranteed to get everything anyway. Guess they're missing out.
My advice is don't do it. Especially if you don't like making them. >ancient ruin forcing you to perform a logic puzzle to activate some mechanism before you can proceedIt's bullshit that makes no sense in the game world, is guaranteed to either be way too easy and quickly done for how much work you put into it, or to stop the flow of the game in its tracks and kill the pacing as the players sit around in frustration for way too long. It's a video game feature that doesn't work in a group setting unless sitting down and solving puzzles together is explicitly what your group decided to do that day. I have no idea why it has become an expected part of dungeoneering.>a boulder is blocking the way? Just roll your strength and see if you can move it>guard is blocking the way? Try to persuade him with your charisma or fight him with your combat skills>door is locked with a weird puzzle? You can't roll your intelligence for that, you gotta solve it in real lifeI second what >>98945194 says, don't make puzzles, make open-ended problems that can have many potential solutions, and do not ever make them mandatory for progress.
>>98945156Who told you to put puzzles in your game?
>>98945439>It's bullshit that makes no sense in the game worldSuch things exist in the real world. For example, bear-proof bins.
>>98945156You're gonna hate this, but I just google the solution surreptitiously, then float it as a suggestion if nobody has any good ideas after fifteen minutes.I take no pride in it, but I am the reason your campaign didn't stall at session three when the party fails to solve a standard logic puzzle to enter the macguffin dungeon.
bro think we don't see him LOL