[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


>Excel at adaptability and can be found anywhere
>Short lived
>Numerous, breed like rabbits, both within their own race and outside
>Love war, inherently violent and expansionist
>Looked down on by other races

Let's face it, Humans have way more in common with Orcs and Goblins than any other race. They even fit in perfectly between them, adding Human's higher intelligence to Orc's might and Goblin's cunning.
A union between the three would be unstoppable.
>>
>>98945201
We've done it! We've finally found the warrior mage thief trio of dumbasses!
>>
Damn those steam mages sure know how to cast the most conspicuously placed steam clouds.
>>
>>98945201
Orcs and goblins add nothing man already has. They can learn craftsmanship from dwarves and more elegant magic from elves. Greenskins just get in the way of expansion.
>>
>>98945201
This is the tolkienesque take. Elves and maia look at humans, and they can see us as kin, they can see the creator’s hand in us, but they’re always like “why do you have to act so orcish?”
>>
>>98945213
It’s obviously a function of some stock magic item that every bath house has (in christian manga).
>>
>>98945219
>Greenskins
Go away GW-fag.
>>
>>98945247
Go away nogames.
>>
>>98945219
Counterpoint:
Sexy shortstacks and sexy muscle mommies
>>
>>98945219
>Orcs and goblins add nothing man already has

Orcs are absolute powerhouses, a lot of our human invention can be improved 10 fold by using their raw strength. And all all they want is to fight. Imagine a team of human craftsmen that basically gets to treat an orc like a living battle machine, outfitting them with any armor and weapons they can possibly think of.

And goblins are what every human empire always dreamed of having - a hoard of expandable servants with two opposable thumbs and no regards to their own safety.
>>
>>98945326
I’m exhausted on shortstacks and I cringe every time someone unironically refers to a woman as “mommy.” I want a woman roughly my height, with feminine features. Like a noble elf with a braid that goes down to her hips, or a short-haired human tomboy with a smile that brightens the room.
>>
>>98945201
>A union between the three would be unstoppable.
Unless a couple of Hobbits manage to sneak the Ring into Mordor, because the bad guys in Lord of the Rings were Orcs, Goblins, and Humans.
>>
so what's the reason the orcs did not simply become humans but stronger? lack of physical coordination? the inability to actually throw things with any amount of accuracy? pure mental retardation?
>>
>>98945611
Lack of organization. Tribal connections does not mean that the tribe is bound up with strict loyalties. A weak chieftain will be deposed and replaced by a strong one. A chieftain with no loyalty among his tribe will also be replaced by one who can unite the Orcs together against him, even if only for a time. Orcs live off raiding other settlements, which means that they die young often to. So a chief might not have any issue aside from picking a fight he can't win and getting killed by his would be victims. Nor is there anything that binds one tribe together with another, so intraspecies warfare is just as likely. Until Orcs find a means of collectivizing deeper bonds between them as Humans, Elves and Dwarves did, they are not likely to create anything resembling a proper civilization aside from a warband seeking refuge in straw huts behind wooden palisades. Even the more successful tribes that manage to conquer a town or keep will only hold onto it until disrepair ruins it beyond use, thus returning the tribe to straw huts and wooden palisades. Living poorly as such likely does a number on general health and life expectancy too, so without swift repopulation efforts, many tribes might die out so thoroughly the survivors either fend for themselves, join another tribe, or possibly try to eek out living among other Humanoid cities that would welcome them. Though each instance makes the Orc a pariah in some way or another, no doubt.
>>
File: 1724899601392494.gif (442 KB, 220x220)
442 KB GIF
>>98945201
>>
>>98945201
>Humans have way more in common with Orcs and Goblins than any other race
well yeah, that's the reason they inherit the world
>union between the three
what makes you think we wouldn't exterminate genocide the other two?
>>
>>98945611
the Tolkien answer would be that without a dark lord-style leader, they don't organize that much. Easy pickings for any good centralized kingdom
>>
>>98945412
Sauron should have gone straight for Gondor. Shouldn't have wasted resources on a steppe shithole like Rohan. In my essay I will...
>>
>>98945611
They are belligerent, including among themselves, and they tend to let their emotions blind them. They don't usually care about long-term plans, so they tend to just throw themselves at situations instead of thinking things through, which isn't good for any developed civilization.
>>
generally humans have aspects of all races.
>>
>>98945611
In lord of the rings they had a kingdom in the east that hated Sauron for a while
>>
>>98947694
That's so boring, I hate when humans are the generalists in a fictional race lineup
>>
>>98948000
It makes sense if you take the human as the baseline, which we do since we are humans.
Every other race has characteristics that deviate from the human norm from our own perspective.
>half-orcs are strong, when compared to humans
>elves are gracious, when compared to humans
>halflings are small, when compared to humans

It takes away some of the fantastical elements if you make the human the strong ones, or the smart ones, or the fast ones, since for us we are normal. It'd be kidna weird to have humans being the strongest ones in a fantasy setting with several other creatures for example, since humans aren't particularly physically strong in our own world.

DnD 5.5 e tried to change this by removing the fixed racial attribute gains (for example, goliaths no longer gain any bonus points in strength), but it feels extremely artificial IMO.
>>
File: 1782532103207385.jpg (520 KB, 1814x2000)
520 KB JPG
I was kinda hoping this would turn into a green pussy thread but oh well.
>>
>>98945201
>Humans have way more in common with Orcs and Goblins than any other race. They even fit in perfectly between them, adding Human's higher intelligence to Orc's might and Goblin's cunning.
>A union between the three would be unstoppable
You just know the big orc lady would be the "leader" of the human male, orc girl and goblin girl group. Not that I wouldn't mind if I was the human male.
Generally though I think it is for the best that interspecies unions don't produce offspring in TTRPG fantasy settings when different races have different stats so the GM/DM isn't overburdened with hybrid race stat brewing.
The lack of offspring production wouldn't stop those crazy humans from trying to have fun with humanoid women of other races. If anything not producing offspring would make them more aggressive seekers with other races for recreation and their own human women for procreation after the human male has settled down. If they ever do.
>>
>>98948019
That's not why 5.5e dissasociated stat bonuses and races. It was mostly because of politicial reasons. Specifically because it's no longer politically correct to say that any race, even a fictional one, is inherently stupider than any other.
>>
>>98945350
>goblins
>expandable servants
Hehe.
>>
>>98948913
Yea, and it doesn’t even sidestep the matter of genetic ability because the nonhumans all still have unique genetic abilities, it’s about taking two solid steps away from the phrase “racial intelligence bonus”. 1) it’s species not race and 2) intelligence bonuses come from background.
Point 1 is actually good, like Redcloak said in OotS, he hates all humans equally and that makes him a species-ist.
>>
>>98948913
>It was mostly because of politicial reasons.
I know, and I do hate it, it wasn't my intention to defend it. Races are incredibly bland now, they are nothing like they once were. I find it silly that a goliath isn't naturally stronger than a halfling for example. It just doesn't make sense.
>>
>>98948206
Same.
>>
File: 1768003704473.jpg (273 KB, 800x820)
273 KB JPG
>Dwarf Fighter, Elf Wizard, and Halfling Rogue are on a sacred quest to find a gem that will unite the kingdoms
>Orc Fighter, Human Wizard, and Goblin Rogue keep popping up and foiling their plans with their sheer stupidity and brash natures
>It's a reverse Team Rocket situation where the "good guys" get blasted away because of something stupid the "bad guys" were doing entirely separate from them.
>>
>>98945201
Didn’t Drowtales group humans with Goblins, IIRC? What are some other settings that have a similar take not mentioned here already?
>>
>>98945611
Orcs = Anglo Saxons
Goblins = Chinese
Humans = South Asians
>>
>>98945611
Well it depends on the story setting now doesn't it? Across the mediums it's some mix of barbarian behaviors but the specifics depend.
>>
>>98950911
Drowntales is the one with a lot of sex and story mixed together right?
>>
>>98947671
He invested in Saruman to go after Rohan. Sauron was focused on Gondor and finding the Ring.
>>
>>98948000
Nice trips. Because of it, what I'd do is make humans the social butterflies of the world. They are just generally able to get along with anyone, adopt their world of view, and integrate into their societies. That's why you have humans of vastly different cultures all over the world, why they typically work withe very race, and why they are often associated with the biggest sex addict classes of the world.
>>
File: 1674347042523258.jpg (725 KB, 1600x1167)
725 KB JPG
>>98950853
We can still make it happen.
>>
>>98951643
All I have is Goblin femboys.
>>
>>98951834
Anon that's fucking gay.
>>
>>98951850
Yes.
>>
File: 1424055541649.jpg (102 KB, 649x839)
102 KB JPG
>>98951850
>Pictured: me returning home to plap my goblin femboy and his sisters full of my seed
>>
>>98945213
kek
>>
File: lls8ruw25ju81.jpg (77 KB, 841x889)
77 KB JPG
>>98948019
>removing the fixed racial attribute gains
Been out of the loop, did they remove these to make it seem less racist or something along those lines? Are the races just aesthetic now or do they still have some mechanical differences?
>>
>>98945370
Good taste.
I do still like gobbos though.
>>
File: 1739760451123414.png (145 KB, 1185x528)
145 KB PNG
>>
sex
>>
>>98957301
>did they remove these to make it seem less racist or something along those lines?
I believe they claim that they removed the fixed racial attribute bonuses/penalties in order to '''give the players more freedom''', since it allows one to make builds that would be difficult to pull off in the past, but it is the general belief, specially between older players, that there was also some degree of political correctness involved too, as if to avoid saying 'this FICTIONAL SPECIES is better than THIS OTHER FICTIONAL SPECIES'. This rings specially true when combined with stuff like removing half-elves and other hybrid races entirely, not to mention the art overall feeling more inclusive and adapted to modern times.

DnD 5e had already sort of started doing this from the beginning, since it removed the fact that some races had penalties in certain attributes (for example, half-orcs used to gain str but lose int, or dwarves who used to gain con but lose chr, etc.)

>Are the races just aesthetic now or do they still have some mechanical differences?
There are mechanical differences yeah, stuff like size, having darkvision or not, or special abilities like fire breath, having some cantrips, having additional skills or a feat, etc. depending on the race.

Still, I think the different races having their own advantages and disadvantages was pretty neat. It gave them character, made them feel more well-defined.
>>
File: cityborc.jpg (79 KB, 800x600)
79 KB JPG
>>98945201
You could make city orcs a thing and the humans are the invading barbarian blight.
>>
File: 1e-races.jpg (109 KB, 500x612)
109 KB JPG
>>98945201

Ah... I miss the day when orcs were only as tall as humans at best, and half orcs even shorter. Humans being the tallest was peak. Now humans are just the midground of everything, average everything. Orcs have changed so much... what even are they any more.
>>
File: galadriel.png (850 KB, 1280x720)
850 KB PNG
>>98945201
white humans have a much higher level of trust than the other two, who are likely to betray or make shallow connections. basically r vs K selection.
>>
File: 1792088974558136.jpg (279 KB, 1390x2048)
279 KB JPG
>>98951834
>Heart eyes before sex, OR intimacy
What a waste
>>
>>98967873
>Orcs have changed so much... what even are they any more.
According to terminally online freedom fighters: Africans.
According to Hasbro: Mexicans.
>>
>>98945201
What would make a human an appealing partner to an Orc or Goblin, assuming that both races have both genders and don’t need other races to reproduce like some media depicts them?
>>
>>98969008
According to /tg/: Green sex creatures.
>>
>>98969622
If their women looked this beautiful then there men would be hunky chads the likes of which the world had never seen. You could not possibly compete.
>>
>>98969768
their*
>>
>>98945231
This explains everything
>>
>>98969768
Unless it's a dimorphism thing and their males are goblins. Of course that means no female goblins but pick your poison.
>>
File: 1766411248619034.jpg (185 KB, 1200x1600)
185 KB JPG
>>98969768
No they'd actually be extremely attracted to human men who look and act exactly like me.
>>
>>98951834
>shanefrost doing monster men instead of monster women
shamefur dispray
>>
>>98969622
based
>>
>>98969768
Human men are the males of orcs (orcs and goblins are the same thing by the way), dwarves, halflings, dragons, ogres, elves, lamias, harpies, giants, fey, djinn, mermaids, naiads, succubi, gnomes (somehow not the same thing as dwarves), and beastwomen.
>>
File: 1772098105963662.png (40 KB, 325x85)
40 KB PNG
>>98975729
>and beastwomen
>>
>>98965298
I think it ultimately failed. Every species still has their specialties and power gamers will still look at attributes for the sake of power and optimization. Goliaths are still good Fighters and Barbarians, you won't see them as a Wizard unless a creative player tries to take on that challenge. Which they would anyway. So with this new system, a Goliath is now just as strong as a Halfling.

Speaking of those two, the intent for Half-Orcs and Half-Elves was to make half-species more acceptable by combining traits and making more combinations available. So Orc became a more acceptable species as Half-Orc was basically the most humanly possible version of an Orc without being persecuted outright. But with that in mind, Half-Halfling/Half-Goliath would also become possible...

The political correctness also takes way a lot of lore and culture. A lot of the species feel like watered-down versions of themselves. They're afraid of making a statement and being good or bad at something. The newly added species already had no culture before '24 was introduced. It's now a strange combination of 'we don't want to step on people's toes that they keep buying our products' and 'with everyone special, nobody is'.
>>
>>98975729
>orcs and goblins are the same thing by the way
In Tolkien's world, yes. But outside of that, who knows. You could group them together as 'green skins'. As a European, I could say that Goblins and Kobolds are the same. But in D&D that stark difference was designed from the start.
>>
>>98971498
not enough hair/10
>>
>>98945370
I understand and agree, but won't deny my weakness for shortstacks. And she better be stacked, not that gay psyop chestlet trash.
>>
>>98945201
>A union between the three would be unstoppable
That is why the (((elfs))) are always scheming and falseflaging to keep them fighting each other
>>
>>98945201
Source on pic?
>>
>>98951834
>saying femboys instead of traps
tue toi sil vu plaits merde
>>
>>98978574
Justifiable, he's up front about being a guy, so femboy fits, trap would try to keep the ruse going or dodge the question.
>>
>>98945611
most settings, they infight massively unless someone is decidedly in charge
>>
futa goblins are kino
>>
>>98979432
>futa

fuck off retard
>>
>>98979628
Agreed. Flat chest or go home.
>>
>>98979308
Hey, humans really do fit in with orcs more.
>>
File: IMG_1060.png (2.78 MB, 4224x5280)
2.78 MB PNG
i like my greenskins primitive and retarded.
>>
>>98948206
Autism was too strong
Actual lore and discussion drowned it out
>>
>>98982530
I like em with huge tits.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.