[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Roll dice with "dice+numberdfaces" in the options field (without quotes).

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: R.jpg (166 KB, 1024x682)
166 KB JPG
As a fairly new gamer when it comes to air combat wargaming/boardgaming, the story of /tg/'s Planes and Mercs has been told to me in whispers. A cool forum adventure that had wild hijinks and a cool market system. I have a few question about those adventures if anyone from the old days cares to chip in.

>What happened to it?
>Are the rules available anywhere?
>How far did the Firestorm variant get?
>How would that crowd feel about starting up again if the ruleset could be recovered?
>>If not, would running Missle Threat or a merc oriented variant of Air Power be doable?

Here's some rulesets to discuss and put eyes on.

C21's Air War
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rNvtxEgR5dDgAoXmOG5B-NJXsgubmU39/view?usp=sharing

Missile Threat (V1.6)
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1J2GahgLam8da2oXDlAT4cunk47uJSa8z?usp=sharing

Air Power (V2.4)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1q53KemS6R5OSrBLzTNp8iy31Dmz-H1x6/view?usp=sharing

Lmk if any of the links are broken. As always, post planes, memes, and anything Ace Combat/Project Wingman <3
>>
>>98945328
god damn it, I made a typo. That's Missile Threat V1.8, not 1.6
>>
>>98945328
Someone collected up and polished the Firestorm rules and made a PHB out of it while back, it's full of spelling errors and there's a bunch of missing images and lore, but the rules look more or less complete.
I only found out about Planes and Mercs after the forum was well and truly abandoned, but it was still up at the time, so I nabbed the PHB and a bunch of other stuff from their google drive before the forums went down which might be useful.
One day I want to play it with my regular group but I don't know if they have a sufficient amount of plane autism to stay engaged with it.
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1Tbqd5kQktZt8dQFRAR5hkXr8pbJMXdN9?usp=sharing
>>
Not a clue about Planes and Mercs, but I wonder if you could maybe make headway with Lancer or Maharlika as a base.
>>
File: 1783668726269308.png (1.92 MB, 1696x954)
1.92 MB PNG
Bumping with my latest minis to show up
>>
File: 20261111_084136.jpg (3.86 MB, 4000x3000)
3.86 MB JPG
>>98945777
Thank you so much! Now to hope there's someone out there that has the entire thread history saved, I think I'll give the sup/tg/ a shot, but holy cow, that really is the entire ruleset. What a thread contribution.

>>98945792
This is a plane thread, sir.

>>98945803
Very based, pic rel are mine
>>
>>98946049
The sup/tg/ only has thread discussion about the game. Still not sure where they played.
>>
>>98945803
>SU-47
I like the weird fucker. Also the weird mixture of minis made me think, a battletech style game where you can design your own fighters would be pretty badass
>>
>>98946066
There was a zetaboards forum that was being used, but that's been down for a while, the only working archive I've found is from 2018.
https://web.archive.org/web/20180621114803/http://s1.zetaboards.com/PlanesAndMercs/index/
>>
>>98946342
It's actually a macross model, I am sure the underside is more sci-fi-ish. I've got some cold war planes too. I am not a big plane guy but I wanted to run some combined arms stuff at some point. So i've got lots of 6mm tanks, mechs, planes and infantry.
>>
File: MTPhantom.jpg (84 KB, 1600x1196)
84 KB JPG
>>98945328
Are you the guy asking about Missile Threat on the historical wargaming thread?
I have no knowledge of Planes and Mercs, sadly. It does appear that jet tabletop wargaming for some UNFATHOMABLE reason ain't as popular as it should be.
I'll never get it: low barrier of entry, awesome models, easy to paint.
>>
File: file.png (1.86 MB, 868x1213)
1.86 MB PNG
Looking forward to the new Digimon set.
>>
>>98950145
Yeah fuck it, I'd run a game about her piloting a jet. The parachutes have lace. Mandatory teatime between sorties.
>>
File: file.png (3.63 MB, 1200x1911)
3.63 MB PNG
>>98950401
Jets are more efficient when cute girls pilot them.

Also I just realized there are two /acg/s now for some reason. I thought this was the other /acg/.
>>
File: cheetahmedusa.jpg (23 KB, 866x246)
23 KB JPG
>>98945777
>>98949271

I was one of the people in the Planes and Mercs Zetaboards, the "Firestorm" rules anyway. I even ran one of the campaigns on there.

What happened is that Zetaboard was gobbled up by tapatalk and shut down so we migrated over to a Jcink forum. I won't link it because its also dead now, unfortunately.

The migration basically killed all the momentum for our campaigns and a Discord server killed it further. We've all gotten to know each other from our campaigns so we just hang out there and play tabletop and milsim games online there.

It's a shame because it was great while it lasted. That PHB was made by a player to consolidate all the new rules that were being introduced in gameplay.

I might have some of my campaign notes and houserules lying around somewhere.

>>98946342
Fuck yeah, I like the Berkut too.

picrel. It's one of the custom paintjobs for the PCs in the campaign.
>>
>>98950120
I am not, unfortunately, maybe I should go hit that guy up! I've been wanting to introduce a ruleset to the planefags on /tg/ for the purposes of running a campaign. Here's the issues I've run into:

-Air War was the system used for Planes and Mercs, and has some jank in adapting it for campaign play but I found the old player-made PHB for it and could reasonably run it if people wanted it
-Air Power has the best energy retention and bleed mechanics and has the easiest UI since it's hex-based instead of relying on the GM to chart things out freely on a map.
-Missile Threat has the only dedicated Mercenary Campaign concept, but the time dilation with each mission counting as 1 month isn't my thing, neither, and it has a strange economy

I suppose I'll just have to bite the bullet and pick one of the three!

>>98949271
Thank you!

>>98950816
Shit, is there another one somewhere? My bad, I thought it had been bumped off the board.

>>98950857
Such a shame all those old forums got destroyed. What's the best way to run it here, taking things to /qst/ or something? Very nice plane pic, btw
>>
>>98951177
>Shit, is there another one somewhere?
Yeah on /tg/. /ace/ sounds cooler than /acg/.
>>
>>98951356
I can't find it, can you please link it? thx
>>
>>98951403
Just ctrl+f /acg/ you retard.
>>
>>98951437
Oh, you meant the card games general, my bad, I thought you meant there was another ace combat threat lol!
>>
What's the consensus on AC8's campaign? There's a lot of features and levels that I liked, but I thought the story was weaker than AC7. Having wingmen you care about is cool, but the actual course of the war was really weird and some things just weren't as awesome in 8 as they were in 7.

The Megafloat attack was nowhere near as cool as attacking Stonehenge in 4, or Chandelier in 6, or even taking on the Arsenal Bird at Stonehenge in 7. I think even the mission to take out the Calaeno and the third Land Battleship were better in 8. For something that was supposed to be the climax of the entire war, it was just too easy. And it should've given you that sense that this was the desperate final battle, dozens of your allies show up and get blown out of the sky as the mission progressed, and that huge navy you escorted to Cima Island should've been there just to get sunk. It didn't have that
>Climb Nuggets!
>Form up on Trigger
sort of feeling that it could've had. It felt even easier than the Land Battleship levels.

The 2nd Battle of Cima Island was no Daredevil, not at all. Yeah, it's cool that some of the squadrons you met returned for this battle. But you don't really know them the way you know the other squadrons from AC6 when they come to save your ass or Sol Squadron and the other minor squadrons who join you in Daredevil. And kicking up the tension by claiming there's 1,000 planes and then they get shot out of the sky by 60 fighters? Not even any naval support? It was just too easy. Shadow 22 doesn't even get a standout moment in the battle.
>>
>>98951574

Hortus Regis Alti was so good it should've played at least 2 more times in the campaign. Song of Wings is also great, and was used well, but Hortus is so good it's a shame it only took center stage once. And then the actual boss fight didn't feel as epic or as dangerous as the battle against the two ADF-11s at the space elevator. The stakes felt so artificial because there never was a feeling that there's any choice but to shoot down Tewy. Despite both of you wanting the same thing, its set up so that there's no philosophical or political conflict, you're just trying to stop someone from setting off a nuke in the capital.

You just killed hundreds if not thousands of her students in a completely unrelated battle. There's no acknowledgement of this. This duel isn't one-on-one like that with Mihaly, and even if it were the locations and goals of the two battles are completely separate from one another. It's like if you fought Pixy in 0 but Pixy was actually Kupchenko and instead of fighting in Belka you flew over to B7R after taking out the Avalon Dam.

It could sort of have worked if Hortus Regis Alti or the Promised Land were a little more detailed in the story, at least to the level of the Hand of Hope, but that doesn't happen until the epilogue cutscene. It was definitely in the wrong place to finally explain it since it was so important to the final level's story. If they had played it up a little more, and could've tied that into the Hand of Hope/Terminus Fingers contrast, then I think the story of the war would've worked better. As it was, it's just mustache-twirling nomads fighting the good old boys of the FCU over nothing but land, despite all the window dressing of faith, economy, climate, etc.
>>
>>98951580
At least for me, I came away from the story thinking Sotoa deserved to win. Notwithstanding the war crimes that are a staple of the series, Sotoa was fighting the war from a much smaller industrial and agricultural base, and were tremendously successful. The strategic use of unsupported land battleships was a little stupid and just felt like they were wandering Usea aimlessly until the second one moved to the Space Elevator, but then the Space Elevator didn't tie into the Promised Land narrative at all. It was just to launch another SOLG into space.

But the Sotoans as a whole are just cooler than the FCU. The pilots believe and trust in their nation. They are united in their patriotism. The FCU has tens of thousands of people who didn't want to be part of the FCU, and who had grievances against the FCU. The FCU has been fighting wars and rebellions since AC2, and ends up dissolving by AC3. Who cares about this POS nation that can't even hold its citizen's loyalty?

The FCU can't even control its own superweapons. I know it's not really an Ace Combat tradition to use them on the good guy side, but having Stonehenge take out the Arsenal Bird in 7 was awesome. I would love to just be Sotoan and fly escort missions for the land battleship as you hunt down FCU squadrons and aces on the march to the Space Elevator, and defend it the way you did in AC7 to try and send up Tonitrus satellites with the whole battle on a timer, only to end up failing and seeing the sacrifice of the Land Battleship in defeat. There's just so much more cool things that could've been done with Sotoan protagonists.

For me, AC7's campaign is just better. The gimmick levels were more entertaining. And while the wingmen and comrades in 8 are much more fully realized, they don't justify what was lost.
>>
File: Azaloth.jpg (59 KB, 300x419)
59 KB JPG
current /acg/ is nowhere near bump, why's this so early
>>
>>98945803
cool
>>
What colour should I paint my cockpits
>>
>>98945803
3mm? I have some pico armor for my cold war homebrew.
>>
>>98946342
>a battletech style game where you can design your own fighters
Has existed for over 20 years. I couldn't tell you which book has the rules for it these days, but it used to be part of the AeroTech series.
>would be pretty badass
Ah. Well, maybe some other game then, lol
>>
>>98955687
Silver/blue is always kino
>>
>>98945777
If that's the phb I think it is, it's missing some stuff like criticals and economy elements. There was a much later version that saw a really limited distribution meant to test some ideas and might be better described as a fork of the firestorm stuff. That wasn't a fully complete set of rules either and sort of experienced rapid unscheduled disassembly due to internal strife.

>>98951177
I painted a bunch of the planes for firestorm, there was kind of a superstition that your odds of surviving a mission improved if you had a painted plane. While I downplayed it, I can't deny it helped my flight team's budget some.
That cheetah was one of two from a later side theater, both planes had Greek pilots, if I remember right. Jesus, it's been a literal age. I'd post some of the other planes, but I don't expect to be home to dig around on a drive for another few days at least.
>>
File: airmercslogo.png (410 KB, 1000x277)
410 KB PNG
>>98945328
HELLO! I was someone who was in a very similar boat once upon a time and figured I'd "do it myself" after Planes and Mercs evaporated. I'm currently working on a game myself that uses AirWar as a base, smooths out the jank, and then builds on it to make a more playable campaign not too dissimilar to Battletech. I post updates for the PnM dudes and the BPL, but figured /tg/ was well past the old days that it wouldn't be interesting to folks here. Either way, things are going quite well with Foundry implementation where most of the base combat systems are in in some capacity. Working on the economy and soon missions, and once all those are together... it's effectively ready for campaign play-testing.
>>
>>98956312
>If that's the phb I think it is...
Woe, once more...

>I painted a bunch of the planes for firestorm...
That's unbelievably cool, I do like seeing all the unique art.

>>98956330
dude. sick. are you going to run it here? my discord is natertatertot, I'd love to see what you've got
>>
>>98956373
Once it's in a more playable state I'll probably see about running it for either my circle or the PnM peeps. Still got a ways to go before there's a campaign system ready to go, and the rules still need to come into focus a bit. The idea is something like a 6 or 7 out of 10 in terms of arcade to realism scale. As I said I want to smooth out the jank of AirWar, but also make things more approachable so as to not require people to actually play a studysim to enjoy shooting shit down.
>>
>>98956373
>Woe, once more...
What?
So there's a pbh that was put together to help onboard players but it's not the complete Firestorm rules. I don't think Sukhoi, the author, ever shared the criticals rules and table(s). At least two of the gms for the spinoff theaters created their own stuff for that but I wasn't privy to those discussions.
The later fork I mentioned was an attempt by one of the original firestorm players to refine and add a little more granularity to the rules. They were trying to get playtesting done but got frustrated at herding cats, and it fell apart.
>>
>>98950857
Hi, The Player of Sabine "Hamlet" Eichler here too.

Pretty much this. There was plans to actually do a fully fleshed game system, but it needed to be built from the ground up and not a heavy modification of existing game systems for copyright issues.

The anon who out the PHB together was heading the project, but it ran out of steam due to IRL and all of us just being busy IRL, we are no longer college students/part-time workers/military members. So life has kept it busy.

Out of respect for a majority of the heavy lifting being done by anon, we have decided we cannot carry the project on without again, rewriting a new system from the ground up, which is nonsensical and inefficient since he had a framework in place already.

What you have here is essentially 80% of the players idea stuff, but eveb those of us who ran campaigns didn't have access to all the documents and formulae Sukhoi was using to run the games. We still had to ask for new planes to the game to be converted into game stats. A lot of us made our own house rules to fill gaps. The Critical Damage charts in the PHB were charts I devised based off my experience as a military aircraft mechanic. I also created a way for EW aircraft to be useful using the capabilities we are aware of in the public sphere.

>>98956330
This anon has somwthing awesome brewing up, watching and reading about his progress. And in an application format it really takes care of the incessant mathing we had to deal with in a clunky and clunkily adapted system. It's hard to capture modern air combat accurately unless you go full grognard/math like Birds of Prey from AdAstra Games, but abstracting enough for ease of play.

Having a computer handle all that adds a lot of options.
>>
File: 1763287109262891.png (5.82 MB, 2160x3840)
5.82 MB PNG
>>98955721
6mm with the odd 3mm plane/mech that fits nicely with the scale.
I've painted the majority of the BT mechs. I think I want to work on the tanks next.
>>
Anon that did the PHB here.

Game's pretty dead desu.

There were two PHBs. One was Sukhoi's rules with very little added. There was a second set that deviated a little more.

There were a bunch of playtest materials that were a legit road to getting the thing published, fixing some issues, filling in the massive gaps, and making aircraft play more like their IRL counterparts. Had a plan for what to finish, polish, make from scratch, etc.

The playtest stuff is still floating around my Google Drive somewhere. It had a much better take on turning, climbing, and maneuvering than the base game, and also allowed the tech and traits of the aircraft to come to life a hell of a lot more than the base game. (Holy lol at an F-14D being outturned by an F-14A in the base game, Jesus Christ.)

But it was never endorsed by Sukhoi, and trying to get help other than idea guys was impossible.

With my IRL aviation career ramping up, I left it out of frustration. There were also elements of the old crew that never grew up.

It's a shame, because the concept has legs.
There was a revival attempt a few years back, again, mostly idea guys.

I looked at going back to it, but a lot of the same issues from when I gave up remained, plus I had the burden of working in the industry. I didn't want to have to answer questions about statting aircraft in a game from someone in my management. Wasn't worth the admittedly small risk.

If you are going to do something similar, find a good group of core people who give feedback or produce good work and stick with that core.

Don't open the floodgates until you are ready.
I would also say that getting a basic air combat system is hard, but not the most difficult part.

Statting the aircraft is fraught, again, because of classification, people's opinions, and conflicting data.

The real rub is getting the economy to work, downtime, etc.

But then again, we didn't have AI to figure it out like folks do these days.
>>
>>98957326
sick
>>
File: nuke.gif (6.44 MB, 514x289)
6.44 MB GIF
Creator here. Pretty much everything else has been said.

We all got older, had jobs, didn't have time, and lost access to the free software we used to run our games. (Forum and Illustrator).

I keep paying to maintain our server because of nostalgia, and re-reading some of our threads is pretty cool.
>>
>>98957326
For my homebrew, I went 3mm because Pico Armor is a cool boomer, and you can put them on 1" hex bases and not have fighters bang wings when lined up.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.