Why every setting turned into dogshit in the 2010s?
Because the dogshit inside you built up to the point that it was all you could see.
>>98946378ESL moment
>>98946454>ESL momentIronic. OP's question answered itself.
DnD is the best setting ever and OP is wrong about everything
>>98946378If you don't like 5E you're a nogames.
>98946389>98946454>98946470>98946507>98946515Is this a bot? Wtf are these replies?
>>98946378Wokeshit happened.
>>98946378I don't know why nogames tards like you feel the need to post stupid things.
>>98946594this is the answer, every type of media went downhill starting around 2012
The Mayan apocalypse really happened in 2012, but it wasn't end of the existence. It was just end of the real world and beginning of the clown world.
>>98946594>>98946632>t. retarded nogames.
>>98946378>tfw you will never play again with the autistic cutie girl who wanted to be transformer based carforged
>>98946378Honest answer: nerd "culture" became mainstream in the late 2000s when normies stopped making fun of nerds and decided stuff like videogames and comic books were actually totes cool, and they were helped along with corporations who bought up all the small companies and turned them into fandoms. The double whammy of corporate and normie censorship erased everything potentially interesting about nerd settings and left them as sterile themepark larp lands where nothing bad or negative happens.
>>98946378We allowed fascists into the hobby.
Eberron is from 2006 you fucking retard
>>98946594I doubted this in 2015. In hindisght, it's pretty definitive of the 2010s.
>>98946645Either that or the world really did end and now we're in hell.
>>98947190So your reply to OP is derp.
>>98947190this
>>98946594The wokies have given us the worst decade of media. I'm so sick of this DEI shit. Woke sun is going to be complete shit.
>>98946661>>98946620>>98947622Why are you calling them gigachads?
>>98949066Only you know why you crawled into a man's butthole
>>98947200>We allowed fascists into the hobby.That appears to be ahistorical. The fascists were here before you faggot. And the games were better back then. How do you really get off on>OH THIS IS THE FIRST GAY RPG ITS SO GAY AND SO FIRST AND ITS THE VERY BEST OF THE NEW BEST THING EVER AND FINALLY SOME FUCKING PROGRESS PROGRESS THE NEW THING THAT DIDN'T EXIST BEFORE BECAUSE WE JUST GOT HERE AND WE'RE NEW AND NOT LIKE THE OLD BADSand then say dumb shit like 'you allowed' as if you had anything to do with the original state of the place. I mean its one thing to be retarded but could you at least be consistently retarded? Can you just truthfully be fake and gay? Why do you feel the need to lie about everything.
>>98946378Wokeness.
Why is every "why" thread garbage?
>>98949979Yes yes you are a retarded nogames who is 12 and has B.O.
>>98949979>The fascists were here before you faggotSays the poser who joined ttrpg in 2016. You guys were always bullying us nerds who were open minded but suddenly you went 'hey this is cool' and decided to make RPGs about you. You think TTRPGs, inherently about storytelling and cooperation are fascist-friendly, an entire ideology built on dominance and double cross in a rat race for biggest bully?
>Nuh-uh, we were here first, you're the tourist!Then why do you have to change everything to accommodate your dysgenic worldview buddy?Surely if you built all this shit, it'd already be designed to fit your inane faggotry from the ground up?
>>98951132Name one right wing ttrpg. No, 40k doesn't count its satire but you numbskulls missed that because you think a fascist bastard who loves gold is a god. Oh, wait a minute that does sound like something myes? Definitely not an orange dipshit being similar. No no. Not at all.
>>98951138ACKS, the greatest OSR RPG of all time
>>98951147>A game nobody plays made by a supporter of a murderous regime and known criminalYou know what? You might as well say MYFAROG or RaHoWa you little nazi bitch.
>>98951150Kek seething troon. ywnbaw
>>98951138ACKSLiterally anything OSR that isn't made by the Mongrel Banquet Club, up to and including OD&DAD&D was so Mormon that they created Kender to avoid having 'heroes' 'stealing'Traveller is off an off the chain capitalist funhouse grounded in being self-employed traders as the de facto position.Paranoia, oh boy, Paranoia.Every RPG that isn't explicitly Gaylords the Communists Antifascist adventure (And there are a few like that, Sigmata being the most on the nose example) tends to cleave towards:>Great Man theory>Colonial ventures>Your characters being self-made through their actions and improving their station through their own choices>Tabula Rasa being bullshit>A Lockian if not outright Hobsian perspective on existenceYour turn you scrape of dogshit, name an explicitly progressive ttrpg that isn't dogshit.In fact, I'll even give you a headstart.Beast: The Diddling was explicitly Progressive in nature.Have fun with that one.>Having been provoked by some other rando poster, the proglodyte immediately starts touching himself to the idea of rendering punishment unto the outgroup for having the temerity to call him a cultural Imperialist (Which he is)Lel.
>>98951183>Your turn you scrape of dogshit, name an explicitly progressive ttrpg that isn't dogshit.Lets see shall we?:-Pathfinder-Every single World of Darkness book-Exalted-Hell, all of White Wolf really-Lancer-The entire PBTA ecosystem and games
>>98951204>PathfinderWasn't originally, new stuff is dogshit and gets more so with each new book>Everything WhitewolfoWoD is 90s liberal hippy shit, nWoD has no political identity, stuff after nWoD is, again, dogshit and in some cases the source of international incidents and/or written by nonces, claim it as you like.>LancerAgain, I said not dogshit, do try to keep up, Communist Wankfantasy 4e but with Mechs is absolutely dogshit>PbtAI'll give you that one.1 out of 4 though, my, someone thinks their ideas are far more popular than they are.Still doesn't explain how you're not tourists though does it given every single example you gave is recently made.What was that about you 'being here from the start' again?Oh and for the record>Inherently about storytelling and cooperationIf you think storytelling is somehow inherently left wing then you might just be the stupidest person I've met on all of 4chan, ever.Which is a remarkable achievement.Go print yourself off a special shiny start and wear it like a North Korean general, you absolute unwunderkin.
>>98951234owod is very left wing stuff.
>>98951240Ah-ah, I said Progressive, not 'left wing'The closest you'll get to seeing yourself represented in oWoD is Doktor Totentanz.Off you go to go google that particular name, go on, doddle off, we both know you're not immersed enough in tabletop culture to get the joke.
>>98951204nta>pathfinder He said good. >WoD Explicitly Judeo-Christian morality with heroic struggles for redemption. Doesn't get much more conservative than that. VtM about being the privileged elites stalking mortals and playing power politics to stave off boredom or trying to become all powerful. WtA is 90s giasm and manarchist primitivism, both deeply conservative ideological models with noble savage appropriation. MtA is about egoist will to power, literally, and self becoming a godhead. Changeling is about subservience to the monarchy and a race based cast system. No one cares what wraith, the one about frankenstien or the one about mummies is about. Probably some other sort of righteous hierarchy as innate soul characteristics. >Exalted Again about super special will to power through divine bloodright. >Lancer Totalitarian centralized police state with 3d printed warcrimes as diversions for the bored kids of technocrats. >PBTA lol Apocalypse World is about the american conservative post apocalyptic fantasy of being able to recreate how the west was won where you can shoot the injurns but not be bad because they're 'raiders' Really, the key point is that if progressive whateverism you want to identify as was always at the heart of ttrpgs, why did there need to be so many calls to decolonize ttrpgs? Its fair to say there have always been political associations with games. War and economics with ideological trapping being the primary focus of the majority of them for the majority of their existence and how the majority of them are played makes that difficult to avoid. But you whatever dumbbullshit juice you're on at the volume you spout it is very much new and comes with the over politicization of personal hobby spaces and the leverage that can be used for financially and socially at this point. That's quite new. You and your ideological opposition are both reactionary and shitting in everyone's games and game spaces and we're tired of it.
>>98951132If you played tabletop games and not just rubbed your retarded ass on your keyboard you would understand that all the things you are assblasted about existed in one form or other because by the nature of the hobby allows it. The only nogames like you get butthurt about the gays are allowed sidebar or images of gay dwarves because those who play tabletop games went that was always allowed.
>>98951183So ACKS is for people too retarded to play tabletop games. Can you really call it a game if you know no one will play it?
>>98951269Youre clearly not educated enough to get everything in that is satirical yeah?
>>98951362>shit punctuationkek
>>989463783e was made by Jonathan Tweet. If the last name isn't telling, I don't know what is. I saw a post where he was giving away his unreleased MtG RPG manuscript from the 1990s in exchange for a "hefty donation to Planned Parenthood". I'd push dogshit starting year to 2000.
>>98951362>everything I dislike the implications of being honest must be some sort of ironic joke or satire this is why you're so transparent. You're hollowed out at the core of your being because you can't allow anything you disagree with to be meaningful and your only response it to lie in as pithy and uninvitingly as possible way instead of trying to learn and understand or listen to different perspectives (or even classic readings of texts that are the foundation of your ideological trappings). It shows you don't even believe your own professed posturing. All you want to do is claim things as your own when it suits you and denigrate when it suits you, you have no other goal and its very obvious. You think games are a platform for yourself more than anything else. Its typical narcissistic garbage.
>>98951321You will never enjoy things on their own terms. Your incessant demands that everything cater to you exclusively will always turn away those around you.And you'll never even enjoy the things you make into a reflection of yourself, because once all is said and done?Not even you, really like you.Because you're completely fucking insufferable.Cope about it harder.
>>98951400Yes yes, the reason you are nogames is because you have retardation. Everyone can tell.
>>98951384>baited by the most baity bait that ever baited
>>98951423>can only distance ironically and pretend it makes them cool to anonymous strangers on the internet they will never meet but still need the approval of
>>98951384>You think games are a platform for yourself more than anything elseYes, its called individuality y'all something you drone bootlicks would never get. I am a unique individual, expressing myself in complex ways that reflect both my traumas and success in equal measure. You're just a drone. A slave. You find only worth in your skin tone and your genitals.
>>98951362It's my favorite cope. >iT's SaTiReNo it isn't. 40k Imperium ARE the good guys because the other guys are worse. Eclipse Phase Jovians are the good guys because they recognize the world for what it genuinely is - a raw struggle for power over yourself and others. In fact every single worthwhile RPG that isn't the one where you take turns raping one player or having mermaids suck your dick is based on the one true fact that ultimately the ONLY thing that matters is how powerful someone is and how they choose to exercise that power.
>>98951518Er, sorry not the Jovians, but the Ultimates.
>>98951518>>iT's SaTiRe>No it isn'tThe writers said its a roast of Thatcherite fascist england
>>98951557Not the OG writers, but the bandwagon jumpers, yes. Also I'm very curious what part of Thatcher's England had tech priests, killer robots, space marines, and so on.
>>98951566>Also I'm very curious what part of Thatcher's England had tech priests, killer robots, space marines, and so on.too stupid to understand allegory
>>98951557
40k is about badass space dudes and monsters fighting each other, it doesn't have any fucking satire or moral messages you faggots
>Thatcherite fascist englandIn todays episode of 'Everything I don't like is Fascism'.Just keep pushing that boundary and telling people that every alternative to you is fascism.I'm sure there aren't any unfortunate second order consequences to such things in the long run.
>>98951251>Ah-ah, I said Progressive, not 'left wing'why dont you explain how owod doesnt count? What's the difference here?>The closest you'll get to seeing yourself represented in oWoD is Doktor Totentanz.Ah, I see your tranny paranoia is acting up. Making a reference to the tzimisce isn't exactly super obscure knowldge.
>>98951092>suddenly you went 'hey this is cool' and decided to make RPGs about you.what are you gonna do about it faggot? cry?
>>98951269>Explicitly Judeo-Christian morality with heroic struggles for redemption. Doesn't get much more conservative than that.That's not what conservatism is about. Judeo-christian morality is a vague buzzword and is too broad to nail down. Further more a lot of owod takes heavy influence from non-christian sources.> MtA is about egoist will to power, literally, and self becoming a godhead.mainstream Conservatives are mostly against mta stuff.
>>98951725You've done nothing but respond with vague buzzwords and skipped all the other points. WoD is fundamentally about the struggles for salvation of the human soul (or the humanist transposition of the sol to gia for the wolfs) in a universe made by the Judeo-Christian God. That's the constant theme, they even have an entire series about lucifer and demons dealing with their rebellion and sin. The main and most popular line is about the progeny of Cain, cursed for slaying Able. Its all biblically rooted even the gnostic stuff. >Further more a lot of owod takes heavy influence from non-christian sources.All deeply filtered through orientalist cultural appropriation lenses that portray the noble savage, the ideology of untouched pristine nature and the inscrutable mask of bad takes on Confucianism which is an even more conservative mode. Nietchian and Stirinite egoism will to power found in MtA is less common but doesn't end up on the progressive side very often.
>>98951773>You've done nothing but respond with vague buzzwords and skipped all the other points.which part of this post was vague buzzwords: >>98951725
>>98951786>mainstream conservatism is mostly against...Go ahead and define that without buzzwords and be more specific. >a lot of owod takes heavy influence from non-christian sources Vaguest nothing statement possible there, no description of what material it is or what the sources would be. >That's not what conservatism is about.With no elaboration on what it IS about. Put a bit of effort in.
>>98951798>>a lot of owod takes heavy influence from non-christian sources >Vaguest nothing statement possible there, no description of what material it is or what the sources would be. Are you serious? This is the sort of question you'd ask if you've never read anything at all about owod. Werewolf and mage are both blatant examples.
>>98951856Yeah, so you have nothing and don't want engage with the discussion about how various background readings tie into the game thematically. That's too bad.I guess get back to yelling about your /pol/ garbage of choice.
>>98951870Is the Akashic brotherhood christian? What about the Verbena ?
>>98951798>Go ahead and define that without buzzwords and be more specific.outside of mormonism, american Conservatives belief system doesn't typically center around aiming to become god, the godhead, or godlike beings, or whatever. ascension in mage is more vague than that, but you mentioned the godhead.>With no elaboration on what it IS about.>Put a bit of effort in.I don't have to explain what it is to tell you what it ain't. For one, Judeo-Christian morality is actually something vague, unlike the things you are accusing of being vague. There's a lot of different branches of christianity, and pretty much every human moral system has major overlaps. If you are just talking about the idea of redemption, that's not unique to christianity. And american conservatives aren't exactly pro-forgiveness, pro-redemption, or pro-mercy. (For instance, televised executions are something the catholic church would frown upon).Being christian or religious doesn't inherently make you conservative for one. They also disagree with a lot of christian thought, "It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich person to enter the kingdom of God" is a good example of something many disagree with.Demons and vampires and monsters can be redeemed isn't really a position most rightwingers take. Look how people react to frieren or goblin slayer.
>>98946470lmfao
>>98951204Pathfinder was originally the "edgy" setting
>>98946378Marketability and tumblr shitters infesting the hobby. Eberron is a good example of this because Keith Baker gave into the modern audience at the time and his official discord is now overrun with a bunch of tumblrites and instagram faggots crying about everything beimg problematic to the point of turning Eberron into a Disneyland Themepark for HR Redditors.>For ExampleWar is too edgyEven though the campaign setting was heavily based on a not postWW1 world with magic overcoming the tragedies and destruction that entailed.>Eugenics bad/eat the rich modern mindsetsWhen the campaign has built in bloodline magic with the dragonmarks where houses want to consolidate power and miscegenation with other dragonmarked races does run the risk of creating an abberant dragonmarked individual who'd be seen as a leper. Now instead of playing that as a reasonable fault to the setting, everyone has to circlejerk thenselves silly to whitewash it and defang the issues because someone's feelimgs could get hurt even though Keith Baker himself isn't endorsing it, but stating it's a basic have and have not arc one eould face in the world.>Don't believe meFunny enough, one of the Discord mods literally called Keith Baker and all the Eberron Writers as out of touch white male saviour while going on a rant on how everything problematic in Eberron such as stakes, rising political & racial tensions, and how terms like Daelkyr Half-Blood were triggering them and everyone was too scared to call that Mod Out lest he go on a powertrip abd ban/blackmail them since he has access to their private info thanks to account linking to D&D Beyond/DriveThru for content he also had a hand in writing. And the fact that Keith is too afraid of his own modteam not to put that shit in check shows how shitty the books will be because he's writing stuff to coddle that behavior.
>>98956837tl;dr retarded nogames sounds made while rubbing keyboard on ass.
>>98958126Yep, you're a nogames projecting again. Back to your Discord server with the rest of your redditors.
>>98956837>Mod Out lest he go on a powertrip abd ban/blackmail them since he has access to their private info thanks to account linking to D&D Beyond/DriveThru for content he also had a hand in writing...holyshit wut? Why is this even an option?
>>98958200Officially a lot of author discords do that to give their subscribers/fans unique badges, tags, roles, etc to show off to everyone else. However since the account has to be linked to a payment processor, it's essy to dox people who link said accounts based on purchase time/reciepts, especially if they have other stuff linked like their Youtube/Twitch account let alone shit like a Bluesky/Instagram/Twitter Account.>TL;DRRetarded "notice me senpai" shit from normies with zero OPSEC.
>>98958227jfc how retarded. Shouldn't there be a >don't share my information tab or similar selection option in discord?
>>98958173Then get back to Discord retard, where people want to see your big dumps of nogames faggotry in text form.
>>98958268Yes, you should return to your Discord Jarrod and stop acting like a fake janny to save face.
>>98958234You can private your account to not show your linked accounts but it'll be shown to anyone you friended at best and all it takes is one snitch on the list to dox you.
>>98956837>Literal blackmail because of funny elves in a fantasy gameAt what point are they going to realize "are we the baddies?"
>>98958297You are the only one here who thinks whatever shit happens on some Discord matters, retard.
>>98958330Jarrod, you need to stop and go back to your Discord Kittens and Reddit hugbox. You're not supposed to be here.
>>98958316Every time I get a bit bummed about how here can be sometimes its nice to have reminders of all the worse options.
>>98946526The future . Get with the times or get left in the pasture
>>98958347You are not on Discord, Sir Fagalot the Nogames. No one know who Jarrod is.
>>98946526>Is this a bot?Quite likely that and mixed disengagement agents. There's going to be a few really irritated and trapped oldfags who have everything they dislike hidden but are stuck here and can only be pithy at anything infront of them too. You learn to filter it after a while, its very formulaic, like the back and forth happening above this post.
>>98958441You're projecting again. It's okay you're a nogales faggot but keep it to yourself.
>>98951240I don't know. oWoD was a little too based in Werewolf by saying the Jewfur Shadow Lords ruled the banks and media as a way to cull and corrupt humanity. Leftists wish they had the balls to say that without chopping them off at the altar if progressiveness.
>>98958479>formulaicindeed. is the same copy-pasted answer in every thread that is not a general
>>98946378>>98946594Without getting too deep into politics, the real answer is that a sizeable portion of Millennials saw what was happening in the US & tried to prevent it when they came of age in the 2000s. This culminated in Occupy Wallstreet which, while it failed, scared the shit of the American upper class causing them to resort to political & social divide-and-conquer tactics. A sizeable chunk of all American generations drank the Kool-Aid deep and then...>>98947190>nerd "culture" became mainstream in the late 2000s when normies...As this anon said, the normies who fell for the divide and conquer tactics flooded the nerd hobbies and compulsively had to "fix" anything "problematic" or (if their eyes) controversial. In parallel to this (and already happening way before the political issues), corporate leadership that was detached from the actual customer base took over these hobby companies and focused on milking it for as much profit as possible. Which, in turn, fed back into the "normies" problem because they needed to try to market to as wide of a customer base as possible to continue making profits as their previously-loyal fan base began shifting to alternatives or leaving the hobby altogether.
>>98960026I think the jannies are in on it. When the bot halluncinates and says something that could get them flagged by SEO, it self-reports to the jannies along with a secondary webtrawler acting as a minder so Jannies can delete the posts so the bots don't get reinforced on "bad behaviours" and wipe evidence. It's probly why the desuarchives get raided/taken down every so often in hopes of covering up the logs/evidence there too.
>>98959981>nogalesYeah, I am not a fan of gales. I don't like it when it gets too windy.
>>98946515what?
>>98946594Conservatives have always hated RPGs.
>>98946594They will seethe about this but it's the actual reason. The most embarassing era of shitcolor in the history of western art?
>>98962652Or at least that what nogames think.
Post a story about playing an Eberron campaign, Anonymous.I've read through the manual so many times but playing it never happened and this book's still in my basement in a box.Some regret their life choices i regret all the DnD i never played.
>>98962454Gygax himself was a lolbert, which in America at least is a very conservative position just not Conservative Inc. But that's the whole point: Being edgy is fun and it's where the interest is. Stodgy conservatism creates an environment where things actually CAN be edgy in a fun way, and this creates an environment where creativity can actually flourish on the margins. You reverse the situation and everything becomes gay as hell. The stuff that everyone still likes is all holdovers from the last era like 40k where everything hasn't been fagged up yet. The moment a company cracks and starts trying to "appeal to the modern audience" it starts sucking shit.The greatest periods of art are always ones in which artists are definitionally periphreal to the culture. The moment anything becomes mainstream it also necessarily becomes sanitized and dumbed down. There are no exceptions to this rule. It was better to be a TTRPG fan back when it was considered a weird satanic fringe activity. I grew up being an autistic WWII enthusiast in California where having a book with a picture of Swastikas in it was like having a Sonnenrad tattooed on your neck, and I miss it, now I live in the South and people actually know what an M60 is and I have to pretend I don't.
>>98960048This post basically wins the thread. It is neither right or left-wing bias just an accurate observation.
>>98962680I played Cyberpunk yesterday. It's absolutely true. Nobody serious thinks we're in a good crop of games right now. The 00s kicked the living shit out of everything that came afterwards.
>>98962711I'm considered a "far-right" person by the standards here in Canada. This is because I actually read historical works like Plato, Khaldun and Hobbes and have more than the public school approved knowledge of history. It is pathetic how so many people with a cursory grasp of history will accuse me of being a fascist just because I'm talking about things they don't understand. I know some of them are playing dumb because Plato, Khaldun and Hobbes are not exactly obscure by the end of debate they'll literally pretend to not understand what you're talking about so they don't have to say unpopular things back to me.
>>98962744That's fine, now you too can bask in the masochistic joy of being a victim of vague social norms that don't actually impact your life in any meaningful way.That's what our ancestors fought for, from greek mystery cults to judeo-christianity onwards, and now both sides of the political spectrum get to be victims whilst also enjoying all the privileges of modernity.It is a time of plenty.
>>98962744Who is Khaldun? I've heard of the other 2 but never read them.