Is it possible or do they contradict too much?
>>98947877Anything's possible if the members of the group have the right kind of autism.
>>98947877Perfectly possible. What you DO need to have:NPCs, factions, fronts. There MUST be events and people in the world, they must happen enough the place seems vibrant, and they must be relevant to the party. A sense of how journeys happen, and ways to gate them. So you don't want to have PCs buying boots and beans. Fine. A point map with one route marked "takes days, must get someone to sponsor the journey each time" can be fine. Sense of open narrative. You have to be genuinely OK discovering your story, allowing players to necessarily determine pace, and time pressure can't be SO pressing that RP is a stupid idea.
>>98947877Sure, I've run them. Why would they contradict? Game style and rule style are orthogonal.
>>98947877Worked fine when I did it with Apocalypse World. Its built to be a sand box in a lot of ways. The Perilous Wilds series was useful for some fantasy sandbox game stuff I've done if you want more traditional fantasy. Most OSR is crunch medium and works great for sandboxes. There are mixed format ones like Beyond The Wall that manage to do narrative OSR play that's impressively put together. There are a ton of very light narrative games about exploration, most of them are only okay and have a few ideas at best but there sure are a lot of them if you look around itch,io
“Collaborative storytelling” is for troons and fags
>>98947877Could probably be done with something like City of Mist.
>>98949248Sounds perfect for you, then.
>>98947877sandbox is a videogame term. All TTRPGs are sandbox and on rails at the same time. Videogames need either an open world or a railroad to be made. Meanwhile in TTRPGs a GM is this gif.
>>98947877Cute jailbait
>Sandbox: An open ended game with an emphasis on a living world that the players can choose to engage with how they please>Narrative: A focus on the conflicts and characters rather than the mechanics of the gameThese don't clash at all really. The only thing that makes a sandbox different is the never ending choices in front of the players. Just make sure all choices have narrative pros and cons, then it will continue to be a sandbox.
>>98947885This lmao