[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


>sweating is extremely rare IRL
>Humans, horses, some bovines, and a small pool of apes sweat to cool down and nothing else

So, what other races/species do you think would sweat?
>>
>>98948345
>Elves
Unlikely. They don't really live in areas with extreme temperature variance or have to do long distance running. They can do long distance running but it's kind of effortless to them
>Dwarves
Underground dwellers with fairly static temperature as a result. No long distance running at all. Heavy smithing work, but al fair amount of smithing can be done away from a heat source. Sweating is unlikely.
>Orcs, goblins, etc
Unlikely to sweat. More temperature variance but extreme long distance running is very uncommon.

Honestly, most fantasy and sci-fi stuff comes from fairly static environmental biomes that the given species evolved/adapted to in order to maximize effectiveness in that biome making sweating exceedingly rare in those settings. Sweating is effective at preventing overheating but is extremely inefficient at maintaining hydration and most evolutionary traits would focus much more heavily on the latter more than the former.
>>
>>98948345
Pretty sure all mammals sweat (or possess the structures nesessary to develop sweating) since a mammary gland is a modified sweat gland. Anything that breastfeeds, lives in a hot or arid climate with ample water supply, and cannot cool itself by panting ought to sweat to some degree
>>
>>98948372
...oh god.
Dwarven head and hair is probably like mole hair and thus incredibly soft, flexible and dirt resistant. That's how they have such massive beards while laboring underground
ELF CLOTHES ARE MADE OUT OF PEOPLE
>>
File: dudepeebalmao.png (77 KB, 400x495)
77 KB PNG
>>98948960
Dwarves probably aren't mammals. They're the only non-cannonfodder race that's predominantly depicted as male and they're all about being in many ways more fey like than most depictions of elves. Thus I venture that a dwarf has to make a new dwarf using everything he learned in order to become a Master Craftsman.
>>
>>98948987
reasonable phylogenetic speculation. however, i would still suggest that dwarves would greatly benefit from sweating when forging.
>panting increases fume inhalation
>hot forge gas makes transpiration /radiation inefficient
>hot forge gas is extremely dry, making perspiration increasingly efficient
>access to aquifers makes fluids abundant
>>
>>98948987
Self-propagating homunculi?
They probably realise mammalian races would find it creepy, so they use parent-child vocabulary instead of maker-creation to keep low profile.
>>
>>98948997
>>access to aquifers makes fluids abundant
So why sweat it? Just pour water over yourself, or have walk-though shower in the forge.
>>
>>98949000
>internal waterfall in front of the forge that both sluices off the grime and acts as a screen against smoke getting further into the dwelling
>>
>>98948997
Forges are indeed hot, however, it would be fairly simple to have the hot areas compartmentalized so heat is kept isolated.
Doing so would require a fair amount of building complexity which is pretty par for the course for dwarves.
>>
All of the standard fantasy ones because they're clearly very closely related to humans.
>>
>>98948997
This is all assuming that dwarves have been smithing for long enough to have a serious evolutionary pressure on them. Even if they've known the secrets of metal for half a million years I doubt they would have evolved much in the way of adaptation.
>>
>>98949007
That is a steam explosion waiting to happen.
>>
>>98948372
>A fair amount of smithing can be done away from a heat source
WRONG
That's how you end up with shitty brittle steel.
You should NEVER allow a billet you're working to cool down past a dull orange glow before it's ready to be quenched, ESPECIALLY if you are trying to make a quality tool.

Your anvil goes right next to the forge, because realistically, you're gonna be trying to maintain a relatively stable workable metal temp, and not letting it cool too drastically while it's on the anvil.

Letting it cool down too far then heating it up again creates microscopic fractures, which can swiftly become macroscopic fractures under stress, and you ARE hitting the fucking thing with a hammer.

Fucking novices.
Go back to the nailmaker's shed, and stay there.
>>
>>98952824
ROCK MUNCHER MELTY
Go oil your beard and calm down
>>
>>98948372
Wouldn't all humanoids sweat?
>>
>>98956148
No? Humanoid means "has a human-like body construction" e.g. walks upright on two legs, has two tool-handling hands and usually is sapient, that's it. Such a category still leaves plenty of room for other significant physiological differences.
>>
>>98956148
Yes
>>
Humanoid races should sweat. Most of them, maybe not kobolds etc.
>>
>>98952144
Tolkien's dwarves were basically made for smithing by their creator, so why wouldn't a creature like that have the proper adaptations
>>
>>98956148

I think most mammals sweat, actually. It's just that we do it more and across the whole body.

As far as evolutionary bullshit is fun to think of I tend to picture your usual tolkienian-ish races as correlated enough to be in the same homo genus or something like that, so yeah, sweaty. Golems or lizardmen don't need to apply. Not sure about your anime cute beastfolk, maybe they put our the long tongues, erotically or not.

If anything the only ones that I see that could make less sense are dwarves, funnily enough for forge's implications: being undergound mean less need to overwork yourself running and more stable temperatures. Which is DEFINITELY not the case for forests - yes, shadow is cooler, but anyone that went innawoods in july would laugh at the idea that there is no heat there.
(I generally don't picture them as full-fledged stygobiont, but more like "amphibians" of the two worlds that have distinct shit to under and above ground, but whatever)



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.