[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


What is the most toxic race and class combo for a PC member of a party and why is it halfling rogue?
>>
>>98950412
You spelt "Kender" wrong
>>
>>98950442
just came to write this
>>
>>98950442
Kender is just a halfling rogue with kleptomania and author fiat "innocence" to handwave why people don't hate them.
>>
>>98950412
Thiefling Warlock
>>
File: 1772518370340.webm (127 KB, 800x810)
127 KB
127 KB WEBM
>>98950507
I vaguely get what they were going for. Cats and dogs steal shit (mostly food) all the time and we've forgiven them for this for thousands of years. I'm pretty sure even some ancient Sumerian had some honeycake swiped by a dog and relented because the dog looked remorseful afterwards (he wasn't remorseful in the slightest).
>>
>>98950412
Human Fighter
>>
>>98951256
The other big thing that people tend to get mixed up about Kender is their innocence or lack thereof and how it ties into what you said. The lore in the rpg books were wont to say that Kender antics were waved off as cute and benign by the "good" and wise, and that only those who were evil or cruel would wish them harm. Read any of the actual Dragonlance books though, and quite a lot of people make their distrust of kender verbal if they aren't straight-up hostile to them, not in least part due to their thieving ways and inability to listen when told "Don't touch that!"

That's the kind of mismatch that does not bode well when paired with That Guys who think that pissing off their teammates is the funniest shit, especially with a species of pranksters who are supposedly implicitly forgiven for being too retarded to know better despite that never being how it works out in any group who only see a bitch that deserves a good strangling.
>>
goblin female, any class
>>
>>98950412
Human paladin because they probably just want to police what other players do.
>>
>>98952170
>t. chaotic neutral
>>
>>98950412
Boy does this halfling rogue look sleazy.
>>
>>98952170
If you're not doing anything wrong, you have nothing to fear.
>>
>>98952223
He looks like he's going to try and sneak into a bunch of threads for no particular reason.
>>
>>98951310
From all the Dragonlance books I remember reading, people weren't usually very patient with a Kender's antics, but at the same time people routinely just asked for the Kender to return what they took, and the Kender would return it while explaining that the person must have dropped it.
That's usually why they're seen as benign, because any sort of thievery they perform is devoid of malice and easily resolved.

The reason only the cruel would wish them harm is simply due to how it's more akin to punishing an old person with alzheimers or a small child for picking something up and wandering off.
Yelling at them, strangling them, or chopping off a hand for theft is pointless because they are clearly incapable of understanding, and they'll return anything if you just ask nicely.

That said, this doesn't work well at all when it leaves the confines of a book and turns into a playable race, because 99% of players are just going to have the Kender steal everything that isn't nailed down, rather than properly roleplaying them as a childlike race who borrows things absentmindedly.
I think the only way you could really make it work would be rendering their inventory a black box that the player has no agency over, and even that's probably not worth the hassle.
>>
>>98952410
I remember it less rosily admittedly in that the kender were generally that benign and without intending to be rude or inconvenience others, but at the same time nobody treated the actual thieving as harmless. Even Tasslehoff, probably one of the calmest and most mature kender around, still regularly got reminded to stop taking shit and got yelled at more than once by his friends since after a certain point he did in fact know better than most of his kin.

But yeah, the main point is that even in the sourcebooks the kender habit of thievery was always a hassle and meant to be a learning experience, and the fact the player base warped it into a pvp tool shows why they should have just excised that out immediately.
>>
>>98950507
Personally, I think instead of a race, the Kender should be a faction of halflings who are devout anarchists. They don't believe in the concept of property so they don't think twice about stealing. The bit where lots of people like them despite being such a pain in the ass comes in is that as Chaotic Good anarchists, they jump at the chance to fight anything Lawful Evil. They're good to have around if you're expecting Devils.
>>
>>98950412
Tiefling Bard.
>>
>>98950412
Gnome Bard Chaotic Neutral
>>
>>98953038
Aren't Kender a form of Gnome in the Dragonlance mythology?
>>
>>98950412
>Human Fighter
They will be racist assholes with no redeeming qualities but demand to be the center of attention at all times despite making the most bland, forgettable dogshit you've ever seen.
>Human Paladin
They will also be racist assholes and then get mad at you when you make them fall for violating their oath by taking evil actions and committing genocide for no reason other than their own culture war retardation IRL.
>Changeling Rogue/Bard
You will never be able to run a social encounter again.
>Any kind of Wizard
You will never be able to run any sort of encounter again. If I was going to pick a race/species, anything with Magic Resistance, so probably Gnome or the old Yuan-Ti.
>Tiefling Warlock
Unlike the rest of you nogames faggots, I don't see the problem with tieflings. the technicolor bullshit is all streamer nonsense and made-up bullshit from what I've seen. However, you can garuntee a Tiefling Warlock is going to fire up the shadow the hedgehog intro every time they're doing something and are gonna be on some maximum edge type shit. No thank you.
>Orc/Half-Orc Barbarian
Human Fighter but green and instead of being racist they're retarded and will actively do the most retarded shit that screws over the party because "ITS WHAT [their] CHARACTER WOULD DO!"
>Tabaxi Monk
They're going for some sort of gimmick speed build that will be annoying to deal with as a GM and that they'll get bored of after 3 sessions and ask to make a new character.
>>
>>98952170
That's just the territory of playing a Paladin. I'm playing a Dragonborn Redemption Paladin of Bahamut and I've slapped the party artificer on the wrist a couple of times for unethical shit like looting the corpse of a dragon that was already in the process of being defiled by cultists (we stopped that at least), and stopping a fairy dragon we caught who had been manipulating kobolds by pretending to be an adult red dragon from being slaughtered by said kobolds, instead forcing it into working off the gold it basically stole from the kobolds in debt by joining a performer's troupe to put its illusory powers to better use.

It's all in what oath you pick really, the stricter the oath the more policing you kind of have to do to keep your class features.

>>98952240
Yeah but your definition of "wrong" is gonna be so broad that the party can do literally nothing. You're also going to define "not being a white male human" as "wrong", because you are a terrible person who probably should not have the right to be called human.
>>
>>98953591
Not being a white human male gives you a 70% chance of being an Always Chaotic Evil aberration desu.
>>
>>98953977
>Uses alignment
Retard spotted, argument ignored.
>>
>>98952915
Yeah, the thieving isn't harmless, because it's still depriving someone of their wares or belongings, but it's the sort of thing that's more easily resolved than a typical theft because the Kender genuinely has no malice and no qualms about returning the item.
It's a hassle, but in theory it shouldn't be any more of a hassle than people being superstitious and scared of Tieflings.

As you said though, in practice quickly gets warped by the player base who try to abuse it.
>>
File: Always bet on Blart.png (1.1 MB, 980x980)
1.1 MB PNG
>>98953591
The Mall is a place for all peoples, of all creeds, so long as they adhere to it's rules. If you want to shirk those noble charges placed within the trust of each and everyone of us who walk it's hallowed halls, well then sir, it you who'll be discovering the definition of wrong.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.