[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Roll dice with "dice+numberdfaces" in the options field (without quotes).

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: IMG_2250.jpg (41 KB, 1024x658)
41 KB JPG
Why are Aasimar and Genasi not as popular as Tieflings?
>>
Aasimar are competing with Elves, and elves always win.
Tieflings are competing with Half-Orcs, and pretty tieflings won because no one ever rolled the chart
Genasi are sorcerer backgrounds with delusions of grandeur.
>>
>>98950804
This plus the Starseed & Alexandria's Genesis memes lasted for maybe 15 years before getting splintered and absorbed into other things so they never obtained the same momentum as the evergreen that is the misunderstood demon child.
>>
>>98950769
tieflings have more customizations and are edgy because "hell demons"
>>
>>98950769
The popularity of tieflings is because they're in that middleground where all their funny monster features are costumey and practically cosmetic. It's like anime catgirls, who just have tails and ears. People view it as unobtrusive accessories they can mix and match and customize. It's why they're popular with women and gays especially.

Compare that to "you tried pale elf, you tried dark elf, have you tried red elf?"
>>
>>98950769
They were just a footnote in third edition because the write up doesn't really grab people and they also had a bad non-fan made roll tables for traits. 4th edition onwards is different because the writers don't like them, personally, besides a very small minority who dislike the "good guys are boring" trend. They are to date the only race who the writers tried to squat over the kender purely because they were "just Tieflings, but Celestial". Even though you have dozens of other races and monsters running on "X but Y" as a gimmick and the Aasimars eventually did grow a sizeable enough fanbase.
>>
>>98951498
I like how you had nothing to say about Genasi because there's simply nothing to say about Genasi.
>>
>>98950769

Very difficult to do them as nothing else than walking "will daddy love me?" issues.

Not that this means tielflings are Shakesperare's material, for the most part, but still I do feel like you can get waaaaay more inspo from them.
>>
>>98950769
Tieflings are very customizable and have lore that makes them interesting as an underdog. The edgy factor is there too.
Aasimars are also customizable, but they're basically nepo babies which are hard to make interesting as a PC.
Genasi aren't bad or anything, I think everything else kind of overshadows them.
>>
>>98951553
I also forgot, the flying ability tends to get a race banned, so another strike against Aasimar.
>>
File: bullshit.png (352 KB, 640x496)
352 KB PNG
>>98950769
They don't have The Metaphor™ where they're oppressed for their super special nonhuman traits that allows them to be a stand in for [insert minority here]
Basically they're X-Men
>>
>>98950769
>2027 anno domini
>I have yet to be player to a DM and table that would appreciate the full depth and rich history of a Gith PC
>came oh-so-close with a surprise mindflayer conspiracy game but I never got the chance to re-roll before it finished.
>>
>>98951498
4e also had them as being effectively a bloodline descendent of cursed demonic sorcerer society. 3.5 also had the problem of them being an LA race so a lot of tables just banned them outright.
>>
Aasimar have a stupid name. Like yeah “tiefling” is dumb but most people with a 3rd grade education can spell it
Genasi are a grab bag of ideas, the underwhelming trail mix of fantasy. You’re an elemental guy, but you’re also the child of a genie (who the fuck cares about genies), and you’re basically the “neutral” on the Aasimar - Tiefling spectrum, making you somehow less compelling than both. Also the awful 5e art.

Shantae is cute. But 5e Genasi are either homosexual anorexic white boys with fins or ghastly african women with pronounced nostrils and fire for hair. Neither “draws people in” the same way a busty devil girl with suggestive horns can
>>
>>98951567
Tieflings are cooler, being half demon is cooler than half...dirt
>>
Genasi were big in 4E because they made some very powerful combos
>>
>>98950769
D&d 4e+ tieflings fucking sucks.
There is a reason why people went to play Pathfinder 2e.
>>
File: 38GzY6U.jpg (53 KB, 471x330)
53 KB JPG
>on the left
Tiefling
>on the right
Draenei
>>
>>98951920
>a busty devil girl with suggestive horns
Exactly, Tieflings are all about sex. Thats why they are usually played as or depicted as athletic, acrobatic rogue sluts with a cute tail, cute horns and cute little fangs instead of hellspawned warlock mystics brooding over their alchemy in a lonely abandoned mine, which is more appropriate for the concept.
It has nothing to do with le "choosing to be a hero" or whatever, it has everything to do with wanting to fuck a hot BPD devil slut.
Tieflings are inherently magical realm content.
>>
>>98950769
>aasimar
Visually, they're just humans. Flavor-wise, they're less interesting than Tieflings, with the source of their divine nature muddied (tieflings as of 5th ed have origins for many potential fiendish legacies, aasimar have 3 shitty generic options instead of being descended from creatures/beings from the upper planes as they should be). Mechanically, tieflings get standard delayed magic, one of the best resistances in the game (Fire), and some of them even get flight with medium armor.
>Genasi
As of 5th ed, they hail from one (two technically with Multiverse I suppose) books, and as with aasimar their origins are kinda muddied. Visually they're cool, but mechanically they're kinda mid, and I'd argue most people don't know they even exist as an option in 2026.

Now how do we fix this? Pretty simple.
>Aasimar
Aasimar need more visual variety. Rather than humans with pretty hair or glowing eyes, they should be given a full list of lineages similar to 5e tiefling, with aasimar having legacies that draw upon divine creatures and/or popular deities similar to how the tiefling lineages draw upon the various lords of the nine hells, and their divine nature should be more ingrained into their flavor and lore. If tieflings are gonna be the retarded braindead woe is me types all aasimar should be hopecore types who reach out to those in need and have mechanical abilities to aid that. Also, standard delayed magic from the cleric/paladin lists for the most part.

>Genasi
Again, their flavor should lean hard into the elemental planes or otherwise be changed so that they're basically normal people who have been cursed/infused with that power. Give them an elemental resistance, give them delayed casting as normal instead of their useless weird shit they have now. Also, lean harder into the elemental aspect of their designs.
>>
D&D races are all equally boring, because they are like Star-Trek aliens; superficial pastiches of human cultures and personalities, magnified to absurdity, and wearing a prosthetic rubber foreheads.
>>
>>98952426
Star Trek aliens are great.
There's a reason people still talk about Klingons, and not "actual alien" alien races from other settings.
>>
>>98953204
Star Trek's most iconic alien races start with simple templates (humans but something's different about them) and then make sure that the 90% of the alien factor comes down to their societies and cultures. The Klingons are alien mostly in their culture, same with the Vulcans.

I don't mean it as an insult though. I fact, I think that this is the reason why the characters such as Worf resonate with the people so hard. They are human enough to feel like the people from an alternate society.
>>
>>98952426
see
>>98953204
I would rather have a million more species/races like what you describe than some weird unknowable horror that is physically unattractive, mechanically obtuse, and nonsensical in terms of lore.
>>
>>98953573
>>98952252
TRVTHNVKE
>>
File: 83574435454.png (528 KB, 590x660)
528 KB PNG
>>98950804
>because no one ever rolled the chart
resonably so. Why would anyone want to play some hideous freakshit if you can have a badass( if male) or sexy (if female) fiendish looking character just like that?
>>
>>98950769
A large part of it is the lack of ready-made roleplay inspiration concerning their origins. Demons and devils have been very well fleshed-out in the lore and novels, not just within D&D or even within the fantasy genre but in real-world occultism and religious apocrypha. Angels and archons, while they have had some amount of development within literature, are always just kind of flat and boring unless/until they turn evil. Joe McGood the archseraph of righteousness who's a champion of Heironeus and brings justice to the planes is your great grandad... so what are you then? Mini great grandad? Meanwhile elementals/primordials have had the least amount of fleshing out. Even in animist religions they're not really defined identities. They're just kind of... THERE. And again, flat simple and boring. You're a fire genasi and your grandmother was a magmin. She's a mischievous pyromaniac. Her goals in life included igniting stuff and... that's it. Now go piss of the DM by trying to set everything alight.
>>
>>98953927
Read In Nomine
It's probably the single best, played completely straight RPG about angels and demons.
>>
>>98953204
>People still talk about Klingons
Are trekkies really people though?
The original series was aight, but TNG was overrated, and I'mma say it; Picard was a shitty inconsistent peacenik.

>>98953573
The thing is though; they serve no narrative function that a faction of weird humans also couldn't.

That and non-human races are usually just visual shorthand for X type of foreigner.

And relying too heavily on racial characteristics as motivation;

"Klingons are angry and fighty, so when Klingons appear, they will be angry and fighty"
>But what about Worf?
Worf proves my point; he's a "Humanized" klingon; Humanizing him allows him to be a better written character, with an arc, whereas your average gub-gub Warbird jock's entire motivation boils down to "I am a Klingon".

Human writers write human minds; their attempts to write inhuman minds basically boil down to taking extreme human traits, dialing them up to 11, and breaking off the knob.

You can do that with human characters too.
But it takes a bolder writer, capable of going to uncomfortable places within human nature, whilst recognizing it as such.

A scene where your Always Chaotic Evil fantasy sword fodder are massacre a farming community is innately less horrible than seeing human beings do it to other human beings.

The alien serves as a mere abstraction of the extremes of human nature.

And human nature can be more extreme than many writers outside the horror genre will credit.

tldr; rubber forehead aliens are lazy writing, because it excuses sloppy characterization and vague motivations, and externalizes the savagery of human nature onto some "other", so that it can be poked with a sword, and symbolic victory over it declared.
>>
>>98950769
Because they aren't edgy
>>
I did not realize until Ixalan came out that aasimari make excellent vampires.
>>
>>98954144
I feel like the plural of Aasimar should be Aasimar; like Sheep and Sheep.
>>
>>98954192
That's because it is that. I just accidentally put my own homebrew of it to put them phonetically closer to genasi.
>>
>>98953337
>The Klingons are alien mostly in their culture, same with the Vulcans.
That's why the main badguy from Undiscovered Country was quoting shakespear.

Or in Mass Effect where the giant aliens have a rendition of Hamlet that takes 14 hours to do and watch.

It's really difficult to come up with really unique or interesting cultures and then you have the fill in the gap so you have the aliens talking about human history and culture in stead.
>>
>>98954073
You now remember the Faringi were weird dildo laser whip wielding monkey dudes who moved all weird before Quark came into existence.
>>
>>98954265
Tbh, they just acted like normal Arabs.
Bit weird that they named them after the Persian word for "Frank" mind.
>>
>>98954073
>The thing is though; they serve no narrative function that a faction of weird humans also couldn't.
Untrue, because unless you intend to lie to my face and tell me that a species that has an innate resistance to extreme heat or extreme cold would live identically to a human group that's just not the case.
>That and non-human races are usually just visual shorthand for X type of foreigner.
This hasn't been the case for decades.
>And relying too heavily on racial characteristics as motivation;
So basically, you're a retard who is talking out of his ass. You want a species to be distinct but you also argue that if they are distinct it's "relying on racial characteristics as motivation".
>tldr; rubber forehead aliens are lazy writing
Nah, you're just subhuman contrarian filth.
>>
>>98954542
>Physiological traits
Genetic engineering and technology.
Also, if temperature preference is a key theme of your writing, you are a boring fuck, straight up.

>>this hasn't been the case for decades
Say that to the Mexican Orcs.
You SAY that they aren't visual shorthand for a type of person; but if they aren't, then they are just funny coloured humans; pick a lane.
>So basically, you're a retard who is talking out of his ass. You want a species to be distinct but you also argue that if they are distinct it's "relying on racial characteristics as motivation".
Yeah, because human beings have to have an inner life to be credible in their motivations, but a Klingon is always just a Klingon, until you Worf him.
Klingons do what Klingons do.
And trying to play them "Against type" is only creating a Drizzt scenario, where the character is defined by a monopolar axis of how much they fit a stereotype.
>Nah, you're just subhuman contrarian filth.
Sounds like you are a frustrated failed writer, who feels personally affronted by my preferences and arguments, but are incapable of refuting them.

Sad for you.
>>
>>98954574
>Sounds like you are a frustrated failed writer
Weird thing to say considering the most popular races in fiction are exactly the kind of race you're shitting on.

Sounds like you're a contrarian who is frustrated that no one cares for your hot takes.
Elves and space elves will always be present, unlike your "original" races or your "human-only" boring sc-fi/fantasy settings.
>>
>>98954574
>Retarded nonsense
So you still have yet to define what something that isn't just a "colored human" is, because you can't, because it's either going to be:
>Race has stats therefore different
which is stupid or
>Uhhhh [random nonsense that sucks shit]
and I'm going to laugh at you.
>are incapable of refuting them.
Your arguments are reductive to the point that they are essentially meaningless. Your argument is:
>Everything is colored humans, except this mysterious thing I refuse to elaborate on because I can't

You're mad about something that's been a staple of fiction all the way back to ancient history where gods were just "Human but with magic powers" because it's popular, and as subhuman contrarian filth, you need to feel special because you are an insignificant spec who has no talent, no skill, no value, and knows that the world would not miss or care about him if he died.
>>
>>98954614
He has yet to present any alternative, which proves you right btw. He won't, and if he does it's going to be something predictable that's not even something interesting, like Xenomorphs or some shit.
>>
>>98954614
>Appeal to popularity
Do you make those often?

Besides, Fantasy is on a deader, and so is sci-fi.
In fact, Western fiction is dead, dead dead.
Because people like you can't write for toffee.

You mistake superficialities like skin pigment or temperature preference, for the matter of a good story.
Your rudeness also indicates mild hysteria.

Let me say it plainly;
Your blue skinned waifu race are just as boring as a badly written, poorly characterized human with vague motivations; you literally do not understand what makes stories worth reading.

If you retold Lorna Doone, or The Cask of Amontillado but replaced the entire cast with fire-breathing reptiles, the cumulative effect would be zero to negative; the same can be said of most fantasy literature that leans heavily into fantasy race tropes.

Besides.
Human beings are greater, and more terrible, more beautiful, and more immediate than any of your abstractions of human traits rebranded as something else.

You evince a preference for shallow trivialities of aesthetic detail.

For instance; what exactly would make a story set on a planet with a boiling methane atmosphere interesting from a character perspective?

You could have some leeway with the science that could make such a habitation possible, but are you REALLY going to write a whole-ass book about imaginary geoengineering?

And when you get to the characters, their minds will still just be human minds.

And juding by your own, probably very stupid ones.
A man can't write a character smarter than he is himself, you know.
>>
File: 1794493848458830.png (98 KB, 400x400)
98 KB PNG
>ALIENS AREN'T ALIEN ENOUGH REEEEEEE
It's not gonna catch on, dude.
Hard science dorks have been screeching about this for 35+ years and it's just not gonna happen.
The Moties are the furthest it'll go and they're still just basically monkey people.
Nobody gives a shit about the aliens in Eclipse Phase.
Nobody gives a shit about the aliens in Orion's Arm Universe Project.
Nobody gives a shit about species 4016 or whatever from Star Trek.
It's just. Not. Happening
>>
>>98954648
>HFYtard
That explains it.
>A man can't write a character smarter than he is himself, you know.
Then all your characters must be drooling retards who shit themselves because again, you have yet to provide any good examples of the contrary to what you're shitting on. This is because you cannot, because you lack any and all creativity, and you lash out at those more creative than you as a result.

You are a failure as a creative, a failure as a human being, and a failure as a living creature, so you should probably just kill yourself.
>>
>>98954669
Thing is, nobody really gives a shit about the rubber forehead aliens either.
Or the fantasy races.

What's the most popular mainstream modern fantasy fiction?
It's GOTY.
A majorly human centric setting, with a strong focus on interpersonal drama and character writing.
I am not actually much a fan of ASOIAF, and I think GRMM writes better sci-fi, but if we're making appeals to popularity, then I have to point to the squatting gorilla in the corner.

ASOIAF would not have been any better if you speckled it with elves and dwarfs; in fact, it would likely have lead to shallower character motivations, and more authorial hand-waving.
Because humans have to have motivations, precisely because they don't have a fallback archetype that applies broadly to the entire species; our fallback archetypes come from more interesting things like social class, personal history, and inner desires.
>>
>>98954683
Lmao.
Go jerk off to Tau porn, you dog-fucking retard.
Nobody cares about your green spacemen with three arseholes and seven genders beyond what they say about the sorts of people they represent.
Which is probably that their society is dumb, and their biology is convoluted.
>>
>>98954710
>still can't provide an example of something contrary to the norm
I accept your concession.
>>
>>98954714
I don't actually owe you an answer to any of your questions, because your initial salvo was just a torrent of low-tier invective.

Do you think you are important or something?
>>
>>98954721
Uh oh, anon's having a melty!
>>
>>98954702
I agree. At the end of the day most people will only care about the humans, it's just the way of things. You can have a sad moment featuring an aliens species or a cool alien, but the humans will always be the focus. Also completely agree about the ASOIAF take. I can only imagine how much it'd suck if it did have fantasy races. For starters I think it'd legit push people away, and second I think it'd make things even worse.
>>
>>98954732
Yup.
I'm not actually unilaterally against fantasy races, but there's a reason nobody is calling Dragonlance high literature.

Tolkien is maybe a counterargument, but I maintain that the core of his plot could have played out between tribes of humans, with little or no fidelity loss.

>Elves
The decaying remnant of an ancient high culture
>Men of The West
Unchanged
>Hobbits
Rural peasantry
>Orcs
Hostile barbarian hordes with an inimically alien ideology

You might lose some of the metaphysic, stripping the fantasy races from Tolkien, but he was doing FAR more with his than JUST using them as stand-ins for types of human being, which is as far as Star-Trek or some licensed D&D or Warhammer novel tends to go.

>>98954730
Yes, you've been having one since you read my initial post.
>>
>>98954754
>I'm not actually unilaterally against fantasy races
Me neither, I actually do like them when they are well done, but it's just my perception that in most books that features humans and other races, the humans will most likely be the focus.
>>
>>98954777
Yup, and the juxtaposition between the humans and the non-humans will inevitably be that the non-humans are pushed towards being characterized the only way humans can; by extremes of human temperament, wherein they become analogous to "That type of people"

In a sense, a setting that is entirely non-human gives you a lot of the same advantages of an anthropocentric setting mind; easier if it's an alien planet with a single sentient population, because anything else just devolves into a hackneyed commentary on "intercultural relations", which god knows we have enough of, and one half of the side always gets the short end of the stick; usually whichever flavour of alien is more fuckable gets "proxy human" status, because authors naturally gravitate towards viewpoint characters that they can flesh out confidently.
>>
>>98954702
I disagree because imo you are missing the point.
ASOIAF is an old school literary work. Modern fantasy on the other hand is heavily influenced by video games and tabletop. Video games are obviously a visual medium, and while tabletop isnt inherently visual, it does heavy rely on artwork to garner interest. Official or fan artwork is a big part of selling a game, whether commercially or privately. Thats what "old school" means in this context, GRRM didnt commission artists to illustrate his shit because thats not the point.

And thats why ASOIAF doesnt have freakshit, because its focused on characters an narrative. Fantasy on the other hand is focused on visuals and "vibes". Settings are supposed to look a certain way more so than tell a story, which is up to the players. Fantasy races arent there to serve a deep narrative purpose, they are there because they are visually interesting. Human visuals get exhausted quickly, especially since you cant just mishmash different eras. Nobody wants to see a guy in a toga in a medieval style town. The possibilities are hard capped by what you feel to be the "right" aesthetic for something human.
But change the anatomy of the characters and your imagination is the only limit. An elven archer looks different from a human crossbowman. A dwarf warrior different from a knight. An ork berserker different from a human barbarian, etc.
Thief-things are especially versatile because you can mix and match different, non human skin colors, horn shapes, tails, eyes, ears, claws, hooves and basically everything else. They arent popular because they make a deep point about nature vs nurture or good vs. evil, but because they look cool and have an erotic undertone as >>98952252 pointed out. Thats true for all fantasy races: if they have cool artwork and look fuckable, they become popular.
>>
>>98954822
Naw, ASOIAF has a better writing quality than most contemporary tat, but GK Chesteron, GRRM is not.

>Human visuals get unintresting
Are green people REALLY all that though?
If they have two arms and two legs, you can clothe them in much the same way.

The aesthetic argument IS legit, but only really applicable to visual media, and theater of the mind is as variable as men are.

Looking outside the usual milieu of fantasy settings, aka, the ancient to early modern eras of Europe and the near-east, there's plenty of strange-ass shit to draw on.

And frankly, humans can be made as strange as you need them to be.
>Here are some humans from a high gravity world who evolved to be squat and hairy

>Here are some humans who live in the forest and chase game all day; they are whip thin, agile, and fear and adore the spirits of the wood and the old powers of the earth.

>Here are some humans who live as brains in jars, and fly through space by manipulating gravity

I mean, you DO have a point; aesthetics ARE a kind of substance too, I don't see a sheer split between the two.

However; the aesthetic is superficial in a sense, and moreso when the medium is not a visual one.

And jamming in more sparkledogs never makes a story better, but ratcheting up the character work always does.

Gooners however, just want to goon.
They could care less if the story is dogwater and all the characters are hollow; they just want to have a wank.
>>
File: SavageRedSonjaQotFW.png (2.69 MB, 1249x1920)
2.69 MB PNG
Aasimars just need that one thing that will make them a mainstay in pop media. Something like a video game that features them heavily. Pic unrelated
>>
>>98954857
>>Here are some humans from a high gravity world who evolved to be squat and hairy
>>Here are some humans who live in the forest and chase game all day; they are whip thin, agile, and fear and adore the spirits of the wood and the old powers of the earth.
>>Here are some humans who live as brains in jars, and fly through space by manipulating gravity
Thats all immediately less interesting to look at than dwarves, elves and space squidwards.
I mean yeah, when you just write about it then insisting that these obviously human characters doing human things are actually totally not human is pointless and gets exhausting when the writer has to remind you the hot chick is actually an elf for the 1000th time. But once it comes to drawing these things, thats a whole different story.
And it turns your whole point around too, if they dont need to be alien then why do they need to be human ?
>>
>>98951553
>but they're basically nepo babies which are hard to make interesting as a PC.
play them not as nepo-babies
play them as slightly gifted kids with korean parents, except in their case the entire world is their korean parent
they get expectations of being angels put on their shoulders while still being fallible mortals
>>
>>98954911
>Saving the world just means trying to keep civilization away from drinking itself to death while it yells at you
Y'know. That honestly works.
>>
>>98954874
>>98954911
>they get expectations of being angels put on their shoulders while still being fallible mortals
>videogame popularity
They're prissy and stuck up, sympathy for the asshole does better with americans when the asshole is the everyman or anti establishmentarian. Asimar's default position is the smug asshole from the rich side of town our entire pop cultural milieu is based around defying and seeing get their comeuppance. Only way to have it be more popular would be to lean into the deus vult crowd and that's not where wotc is at.
>>
>>98954902
Because humans almost can't avoid writing humans.
They do it by accident.

And when you get down to it.
What makes Elves and Dwarfs not human?
Is it the magical phylogeny?
The word itself?
The nature of discrete objects as differentiated by thinking beings?

Is it just the WORD "Elf" that makes "Elves" more appealing than the same thing, just couched as a weird human?

I think it's all in the shorthand implications.
Which is a tool, of course.
But it's a broad headed, dull implement, great for coverage, poor for detail work.

Some of the best "Elves" in fiction aren't even really called Elves.
Melniboneans for instance.
>>
>>98951521
2e were just spiteful mutants. 3e tried to hide the fact that they are descendants of people who shagged sentient and sapient inanimate matter. 4e made a big spiel about them and their culture only to then casually reveal they are all actually a slave race(s?) of Otherkin (replace animals with a lumps of dirt or cups of water).
>>
>>98954946
Noblesse oblige is also strong sentiment among upper middle class Americans and beyond so you really it's not a cultural issue but really just a popularity one.
>>
>>98954955
Maybe, but they only apply that concept to their "client groups", which frankly, are not the average person, but the outliers and "minorities", because they find it easier to manipulate a weak coalition than to play to the concerns of the everyman, whom they mostly despise.
>>
>>98954955
I'm explaining to you why its not popular.
Just in case its not obvious, there are less upper middle class americans than middle and lower class americans. That's what pop culture gets made for.
There are no magic tricks or marketing or propaganda that will make asimar popular in america except maybe sexing them up as big titted trad wives but even then there would have to be enough reason for that to be more popular than human choices that would appeal to that audience.
>>
>>98954985
Pop culture at present is less an attempt to appeal to those classes, and more an attempt to modify their internal schema, to better fit the desires of those who control the media apparatus, be that television or film studios, or publishing houses.
>>
>>98954985
>>98954963
You are forgetting that the most populous economic strata of Americans are upper middle class. The nation is practically a one-way ticket into being upper middle-class hence its popularity in immigration. The traditional middle-class hasn't been its core middle class since around the 2010s.
>>
>>98955002
I'm not sure I really believe the "land of opportunity" narrative.
I see plenty of poor Americans.
Not always through fault of their own.
Especially in the current climate of rampant lysenkoism.

It seems to be in a better position than say, the UK, in terms of social mobility, but there are plenty of people who hit a wall placed there by a higher power, and never find a way to circumvent it.
And the myth of the individualist society is that if you just break your balls, you will be rewarded.
The "client groups" don't play that game though.
Nor do your social motiles.
They play naked identity politics, against the majority of middle America, who are still to their detriment, largely operating as atomized individualists.
>>
>>98955070
The land of opportunity narrative is and still is truer than it is false. It's not universal; the presence of poor people doesn't really negate it.
>>
File: Aasimar_01.jpg (329 KB, 1000x1505)
329 KB JPG
>>98950769
The thing with Aasimar is that they don't have built in tragedy associated with them. Tiefling are naturally discriminated against because they are born often of a union of demon or devil union or they had the misfortune of being in their vicinity.

One idea I had for Aasimar is that they are purposefully made to be replacable soldiers in the eternal meat grinder of the Blood War. While a faithful mortal is good, a mortal with divine blood would be a +1

So imagine being born into divine blood, trained, and having to earn your place in the celestial hiearchy where you are at the lowest on the totem pole and have to measure up to others who may and will upstage you.

Imagine those Aasimar who can't measure up or break under the pressure and fall away; some still try to do good and others work to try and earn their way back into their masters good graces and some stop caring and become fallen.

If you allow the celestials to have a little edge it opens up a lot of opportunities I think.
>>
>>98955213
Your narrative about innate tragedies only works for roleplayers that want an innate tragedy that's tied to its aesthetic. That doesn't actually come from other races, particularly the trinity of human, dwarf and elf. If anything the "tragedy" of an aasimar is similar with the tiefling, with that of their lineage. The unholy union is often Faustian when tiefling players write about how they came about. People innately would carry biases associated with the iconography of grace, even real world history is fond of trying to debase the holy or sneer at people who seem more righteous.
>>
>>98954951
>Because humans almost can't avoid writing humans.
>They do it by accident.
It's not by accident. Humans CAN ONLY write about humans, it is the only way that a human can perceive and have perceived the world. Fantasy is anthropic.
>>
>>98955248
That's because the righteousness comes with a particular flavor of insincerity and arrogance that people are keenly aware of and naturally scoff at which makes them (rightfully) skeptical.

Then again, the overall "presence" of the Aasimar is more than just how players play them since they are just as inspired by popular media as anything else. If you play on the burdens they carry and show the range of someone struggling to succeed to those who fall to dispair in a genuine way in media it could probably be just as impactful as the way Tieflings are usually showcased and allow people to relate to them.
>>
>>98954648
>Appeal to popularity
I didn't make an appeal to popularity you absolute retard, I mentioned popularity because YOU used "failed writer" as an insult, when the successful fantasy/sci-fi writers (as, in, the popular ones) all use normal races and not weird unique ones or even human-only.

YOU started talking about popularity, don't change the subject you coward.
>>
>>98950769
Tieflings have a variety of potential appearances, barring 4e bullshit, and those who end up as PCs make for a good way to be a hero with a few vices.
Every aasimar I've ever seen was either a glowy, blue eyed blond or maybe had a sparkly metallic sheen added to skin, hair and/or eyes.
Genesai have soe potential but really need to lean harder into the elemental nature. Give them immunity to their element, add a bit of energy damage to their attacks or anyone touching them, or give them alternate traits that lean more into the genie lineage where they have some innate SLAs but can be commanded if one learns the right words for a particular one.
>>
>>98955520
>Give them immunity to their element
How can they not have this? Does 5e give players any cool abilities?
>>
File: 51 - SZG3WBU.jpg (371 KB, 650x999)
371 KB JPG
>>98955520
>Every aasimar I've ever seen was either a glowy, blue eyed blond or maybe had a sparkly metallic sheen added to skin, hair and/or eyes.
You are not playing with creative people.
>>
File: Sweaty Tiefling.jpg (134 KB, 640x910)
134 KB JPG
>>98950769
Because you can't pull a chick's hair when it's literally just fire, where as handlebars are always accessible.
>>
>>98955526
5e hates cool abilities, and too many editions hate the idea of PCs veering too far into having monstrous abilities. Genesai often have a teeny bit of resistance to their element, but can still be harmed by it. I believe there are feats or alternate race abilities to heal from contact with their element, but hp each day and always at risk of taking more damage than you heal anyway.

>>98955601
I don't think anyone I've ever played with has even made an aasimar, it's mainly official art as the culprit because no one else cares enough about them. PF helped a bit with specific celestial lineages, but it was too little too late. 5e has to be the worst, as aasimar aren't even the source of their own abilities but "destined heroes" with secret guardian angels providing their abilities and will abandon the aasimar if they stop being Good.
>>
>>98955766
I'm telling you, the writers have it out for the Aasimar race.
>>
>>98954669
Rocky...
>>
>>98955213

The problem Aasimar have is that they are the "chosen one" race/archetype. They are Cecil Harvey (and his brother Theodore/Golbez) in Final Fantasy 4, Gandalf in Lord of the Rings, the Heroes in Dragon Quest, the Saintesses in Japanese and Korean Romance Fantasy settings and those with special constitutions in Xainxai. The problem is that the race/archetype needs to be mechanical better than other races to actually work. Ever since 3e came about all races have arguably needed to be "equal" and balanced and this in many ways hinders the archetype.
>>
>>98955266
I think you've confused arrogance with responsibility. Let's be honest here, people play Tieflings to be faggy theater kids who can use their pseudo-demonic/devilish nature as an excuse for their shitty actions. They want the boo hoo woobie sue story but without any of the "problematic" stuff like actually facing prejudice they can't just cry or throw a reddit tantrum for the world to coddle and suck them off.

As you said, if the Aasimar is shown to be crumbling over the heroes journey because they're overworked, outmatched, and even with their divinity they can't save everyone sure. But most Tiefling plays see accountability & responsibility as anathema to their very being which is why the Tiefling crowd is filled with randumbs who want to LARP as "oppressed ones" while having all the personality and protections of a stereotypical gay kid from Glee or Degrassi.
>>
>>98950769
Genasi are dumb and Aasimar aren't stand ins for muh discriminated minority so the legions of mentally ill nitwits who infest nerd hobbies aren't drawn to them since canonically they're a bunch of noble gigachads/staceys.
>>
>>98955526
>>98955520
>Give them immunity to their element
This should absolutely be true. I've always found silly how the character art showed a dude with fire-for-hair and sometimes lava cracks showing on their skin, yet they somehow only get resistance to the element. Shit doesn't make sense.

I don't know if it'd end up being OP or not, but to me it makes sense that it should be something like
>air genasi - while conscious and unhindered, has constant feather fall, can glide, can cast levitation when level is high enough
>earth genasi - tremor sense, can cast stoneskin, more times per day as they level up
>fire genasi - immune to fire, access to a few fire cantrips or adds fire damage to attacks or reflects damage taken against melee attacks as fire damage
>water genasi - breathes underwater, has swim move speed, fights normally underwater, can cast create/destroy water
>>
>>98950769
How many answers do you need?

https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/thread/93083731/
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/thread/93014929/
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/thread/92249811/
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/thread/91531509/
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/thread/90863656/
https://archive.4plebs.org/tg/thread/89473831/
>>
>>98955070
>I'm not sure I really believe the "land of opportunity" narrative.
Opportunity =/= capacity or outcome. Never has. Its always been a mixed sales pitch, but like the lottery sometimes there have to be winners.
>>
>>98955807
>I'm telling you, the writers have it out for the Aasimar race.
Because they're fancy lads in positions of innate power and privilege and there's a strong american bias against that. You'd essentially have to change their lawful divine nature entirely aka make them not Aasimar.
This is the real answer. Don't worry so much about them being popular, play the race you want, tailor the game you run the way you want. Playing one well being a rare and cool thing is actually great and a lot more special and interesting than somehow watering down the concept so its easier to churn out as off-brand draenei.
>>
>>98950769
Tieflings appeal to the romanticized struggle against oppression.
>>
>>98950769
The answer is if the race isn't in the PHB then it's not as popular. The fact that a certain group of people have identified themselves with Firbolg of all things is what I find surprising.
>>
>>98951920
>who the fuck cares about genies
I do. Me. I care.
>>
>>98958035
>and there's a strong american bias against that.
Americans have a strong bias against supernatural powers. They are fine with nobility and kingship.
>>
>>98955213
>>98955248
>>98956211
This "problem" in the aasimar setup just begs for a "hero disgraced/betrayed by en evil plot".

>winged half-angel sent to humans to help them
>evil machinations make the humans turn on him/her
>decades of improsonment/torture/public shaming
>ex-hero/heroine finally escapes due to circumstances
>the land still needs saving only it's much harder to pull off now, when they shot themselves into leg and had 50 years of deterioration AND nobody who discovers your identity trusts you
>feels good doing Good when they don't appreciate you.JPG
>>
>>98961487
Though perhaps the issue is that lots of people are apparently into such stories only as a pretext for the protagonist to be "justified" in brutal revenge that for """"some reason"""" involves raping people and all those isekaishit tropes.
On second thoughts, perhaps it's better if this Aasimar showpiece thing doesn't happen if it isn't going to be made properly.
>>
File: dnd-genasi-5e-group.jpg (271 KB, 1920x1080)
271 KB JPG
>>98950769
Yeah, we need more Genasi! What are ways we can make them less generic that haven’t been mentioned here already besides giving them animal features related to their elements like feathers for Air Genasi, etc., and/or having non-humans be the base for them more often?
>>
>>98950769
>aassholimar
>not popular.
>>
I feel like Aasimar would work better in more of a Greco-Roman or Babylonian setting instead of a medieval Europe setting. More semidivine people like Hercules and Gilgamesh rather than guys who look like Gabriel and talk like the teacher from Sunday school.
>>
File: genasi.png (323 KB, 500x390)
323 KB PNG
>>98950769
i played a lot of 4e during its time, and contemporarily i can tell you genasi were definitely at least as popular as tieflings, probably even more so.

i have no idea why they didnt carry them forward into 5e as a central race, but they were very popular during 4th

aasimar were never that popular though, and i suspect a lot of it has to do with that players want to play a character with some internal conflict, and aasimar are more blessed by the divine than cursed by it. also the name sounds stupid and is spelled stupid.
>>
File: 1765456415769911.gif (971 KB, 366x229)
971 KB GIF
>>98962529
Oh fug I finally get it: it was a visual pun all along.

People of COLOR
>>
>>98950769
No one becomes a water genasi because they hate their dad
>>
>>98950769
Not in the core book. D&Drones are sheep, what the fuck did you expect?

>>98950896
This. All of which stems from them becoming a core race.
>>
>>98952296
>>98954874

They were going to replace Aasimar with the Ardling in 5.5e, which were a more flavorful version of a celestial realm descendant but people complained they weren’t humanoid enough or pretty enough.
The problem is people complained about a decision that would have made them ore interesting and still don’t play the boring option they defended
>>
Tieflings had their own Drizzt to blow up their popularity in Annah from Torment.
>>
>>98966433
>Ardling
That is not fucking comparable at all, the ANIMAL head is a big aesthetic point. Whoever the fuck decided that had an Aasimar hateboner for sure.
>>
>>98950769
>why are good guys not as popular with npc satanists as gay demons
Gee I wonder
>>
>>98952062
That's actually a good point. Tieflings weren't popular in 2e because they were just "rambunctious elves". When they were made darkly monstrous while still not being deformed enough to prevent sex appeal, that's when they became something edgelords wanted.
What Aasimar probably need is something that makes them less human while still retaining the core humanoid features that allow sex appeal. Animal heads, hands and feet while still having washboard abs and perfect physiques would suddenly make them the only race anyone would want to play - without competing for the edgelords' attention directly. Why? Because edgelords want darkness.... it's a different demographic entirely that wants flouncy, noblebright golden halo smexy angels.
>>
>>98966472
Then those guys really have no say on whether or not Aasimar should change or not.
>>
>>98966472
PF1e had a table for rolling alternative physical features for aasimar. You could end up with metallic skin, extra digits, natural stigmatas, etc. It was all flavor, but I thought it was a cool contrast to tiefling appearances. If you rolled multiple times you could end up looking like a chimeric freak.
>>
File: psg.jpg (657 KB, 5000x2810)
657 KB JPG
>>98950769
play them as rebellious teenagers
>>
File: 82pigeon.jpg (212 KB, 1019x1506)
212 KB JPG
>>98966472
angels are about wings, eyes and glowing are they not?
>>
I'VE GOT IT
Aasimar should lean more into the goth aesthetic. That's all it takes for them to gain popularity, some sort of sexy meme.
>>
File: avacyn Gabija.jpg (4.01 MB, 5180x4327)
4.01 MB JPG
>>98966810
maybe
>>
>>98966889
Looks like we cracked another case, /tg/.
>>
>>98950769
because aasamir are outright perfect where tieflings give a false flaw that adds to the oh so speshulness
i'll just play a normal ass human or a half-elf
>>
>>98966464
I don’t agree I think it would have been better to replace Aasimar with Ardlings.
>>
>>98966889
Basically almost the look of Aylin from BG3.
>>
File: Kneel.jpg (125 KB, 636x952)
125 KB JPG
>>98966810
to be fair, "like tieflings but ALTERNATIVE instead of mainstream established thing everybody is into" should by itself be a contrarian bait
>>
>>98951498
well, some of those are uh-oh (3 12 20 22 31 83 85 97) but many go fucking hard
>4 6 10 11 14 15 17 19 21 25 26 33 36 47 48 49 51 59 60 62 64 69 73 75 82 86 90 91 93 94
KINO
>>
>>98966810
>>98966889
>>98967432
just make assamir innocently wear sexy clothes and be unaware most people find it inappropriate
being so pure they dress like sluts just because it looks really fancy
>>
>>98950769
Maybe we could make Genasi a modifier to Tieflings or Aasimar?

Also, please post more Genasi art.
>>
>>98968999
Part of the issue is that they are all their own things.
Make them all planetouched (like in 3.5 MM) as a base race to represent generic "humanoid influenced by extraplanar nonsense" and then make the specific influence (lower, upper, elemental, whatever) a subrace. You can expand it into other planes with splatbooks.
>>
File: 1716293535665283.jpg (288 KB, 1920x1920)
288 KB JPG
>>98968999
They're different planetouched. Tieflings are fiend-touched, Aasimar are Celestial-blooded, while Genasi/Geniekin have either an elemental being as heritage or some other origin related to the elemental planes. You could maybe have some kind of mix but that's a very special snowflake.
>>
Are there specific terms for people with a touch of each of the sixteen (seventeen (26)) planes? Something like Hadesborn, Chaos Child, Devakin, Bladeborn, Firesoul, Helltouched, Abyss spawn, whatever.
>>
>>98950769
Not "not like the other girls" enough
>>
>>98962546
Anon, just because your friend's dad yelled something about "this is a Christian household" when they told heir parents they're a faggot, doesn't make God bad.
>>
File: Renne.Bright.1024.3745029.jpg (526 KB, 1024x1470)
526 KB JPG
>>98971661
if you're commenting on my picture that loli is a 6 year old rape victim wash out of a groups attempts at creating a god through enhancing aasimar-like inborn characteristics.
if you're talking about my joke statement aassholimar its a table joke for the kind of optimize maxxxer who plays them; basically everyone at the table except the dm at least once.
>>
>>98972061
No prizes for guessing what's on this guy's hard drive.
>>
>>98950769
Aasimar kind of just became just "Good Tieflings." Less Angel, and more of "good demons."

As for Genasi, it's more of just a elemental people, but it's often just fire/water hair. Maybe stones/gems popping out of their body here and there, etc.

Also the goth/emo players played Tieflings, then the queers and theater kids claimed them and now basically made them the "queer" race or "Demons aren't all bad" race.
>>
File: 1745403585586029.jpg (27 KB, 249x250)
27 KB JPG
>>98972078
safe for work jrpg tokens?
>>
>>98972097
Homos and performing arts wankers don't tend to have the best grip on theology or metaphysics.
>>
>>98966780
Could work
>>
>>98972078
Team Fortress 2?
>>
>>98952296
>Mechanically, tieflings get standard delayed magic, one of the best resistances in the game (Fire), and some of them even get flight with medium armor.
Mechanically tieflings are one of THE most boring races in 5e. I've never seen a winged tiefling play because they're usually banned and/or no one touches the SCAG any more. Their popularity is entirely aesthetic/flavour-based.

The last thing genasi is need for their features to be even more generic. That won't make them more popular.
>>
>>98950769
Because one lets you be a sexy devil person. That's it.
>>
>>98951521
Genasi been getting some love lately tho
>>
I fucking love my genasis, i just think there cool.
what they need to do is make them less a race but more a modifier to other races so you can have eath genasi elves etc. so many more cool combinations
>>
>>98952062
>>98952062
This, their horns aren't exaggerated enough. Their heads should be mostly horns like drained. Not elves with devil horns taped on. Good take anon.
>>98952252
The brooding over their alchemy is key in this or whatever magic or divine/eldritch/demonic worship they abide too. They should be on par with drow in terms of how more "normie" races precieve them. Like stated theyre seen as "cursed" with an unholy connection to the 9 hells.
>>
>>98950769
tieflings have more opportunity for friction and drama. also sexy devils.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.