TTRPGs are supposed to be fun but it will be my turn to DM soon and I don’t want to run a published adventure. What are the necessary ingredients for a fun homebrew campaign?DMs: when you have completed a campaign that your players gave you positive feedback on, what are some of the common elements that you got feedback on?Players: when was the last time you gave positive feedback to the DM at the end of a campaign and what did you tell them?Pic unrelated.
>>98952545If youve never ran anything before, don't worry about campaign. You're going to focus on single session adventures for the foreseeable future. Don't worry about how the characters met, don't worry about bridging the gap between adventures for now. Focus on something that you can do in 3 to 5 hours. Something like 2 combat encounters, 2 skill encounters and 2 social encounters can eat up a surprising amount of time. The dungeon is a perfectly good place to start. A simple dungeon with 8 to 12 rooms and maybe 20 enemies is plenty. I really recommend Justin Alexanders book "So You Want to Be a Dungeon Master" for simple, foundational advice and how to prep and run adventures. I'm sure it's been yo ho ho'd by now.My other peice of advice is to start late. Do not start the players in the tavern, meeting each other for the first time, and getting a map to the haunted manor from the old man. Start them at the front door to the haunted manor give them a brief set up like " you think back to meeting the weird old man in the tavern who gave you the map to this haunted manor..." Start at the adventure, preferably at a place where the players are immediately making a choice. Choices are good, you want to get to decision points asap.
The five room dungeon is a good concept for a new gm, google it. It doesn't need to be a dungeon, and it doesn't need to be literally five. The point is to have a basic structure that is achievable in a session.Another tip is to avoid adding filler. D&D especially has some game math based on doing multiple combats per day, so a lot of published scenarios will have a string of meaningless one sided fights that only serve the purpose of incrementally draining player resources. I've never come across players who actually enjoyed that (though it can be fun in video games). So I aim for fewer, but more meaningful encounters. This skews game balance if you're playing some game, like d&. But as a GM you can adjust and most groups don't make a real attempt to optimise anyways.>>98952565Good first reply.
>>98952545>DMDepends what you mean by "completed"Every campaign I have ever run has ended in a TPK; this is not a failure state for the GM; it is simply an opportunity to break out the Evil Wizard laugh.When I'm not killing them through their own stupidity though, my players tend to appreciate that I encourage broad styles of play, and that I am an absolute no-fudge purist; if the dice say you're all fucking dead I'm not going to contrive a do-over; you dead nigga, your quest failed.Appreciate the journey, because some characters are destined to be trampled into a ditch by two horsemen in a random encounter, and for their bones to be pecked clean by jackdaws.The DM does not owe you victory.The player's job is to secure it.>PlayerI appreciate regularity.If you can get four people in a room once a month to play pretend wizards, and keep that up for a year, then you are doing OK.
>>98952545>What are the necessary ingredients for a fun homebrew campaign?Knowing what your group has fun with, because this is different for everyone.>when was the last time you gave positive feedback to the DMNever.I've never had fun with a D&D campaign, nor anything positive to say about it itself.
If your playere seem like they are having fun, do more of that thing. If they seem bored, pivot your game in a new direction.
>>98952759>they seem boredboot them and find new players
>>98952639>It doesn't need to be a dungeon, and it doesn't need to be literally fiveThen don't say the five room dungeon is a good concept. You can skip the first two sentences you wrote just by leading with your point about the basic structure.The note in parentheses about video games is irrelevant, too; the right tabletop game with resource management can be fun for individuals and groups who have fun with that sort of thing.
>>98953281Wait, you mean there's more than one way to have fun, and that different people have fun with different things?Holy shit, what a concept.
>>98952565>>98952639OP here. Thanks for the replies. I should clarify that I’m not a brand new GM but I’ve only ever run published adventures. My big fear is I’ll homebrew a world and the players will all think it’s lame and boring.
>>98952545What edition of DnD are you running this changed at lot of the advice for gameplay and camapign generation.
>>989534635th is what we settled on
>>98952545There's some good advice in this thread, but I think the absolute best is >>98952653>>What are the necessary ingredients for a fun homebrew campaign?>Knowing what your group has fun with, because this is different for everyone.There's no one size fits all solution here. Since you say that it's your turn to DM soon, I assume there's a specific group you already know that you're going to be running for. You probably know their likes already, but if you feel unsure, just sit down and have a discussion with them about what they'd want to see in the next campaign. That doesn't mean you have to fulfill their every request. If there's something you'd want to run, you can just lead with explaining the general idea to them and letting them make suggestions that fit that idea. If you don't have a strong idea, you can have a more open-ended discussion. I mean, you don't have to do that at all if you don't feel it's necessary, just know your audience and work with that knowledge. And remember that you're also there to have fun rather than to provide a service as a GM, which is to say, don't go so deep into catering to your players that you'll end up running something you don't enjoy.
>>98953487Understandable. This >>98952639 and >>98952565work fine then. Look at some of the modules you've run, what did you like about them and what seemed like it got in the way when you were running it? Not a 5e campaign so DM and player feedback will be distorted. >Common elements Immersive world, cool setting, dangerous, choices, weird. But its for basically the opposite end of a 5e story arc gameplay design. Best I can link up from what I tend to run is make sure the player choices actually mater rather than trying to trick them into thinking the choices matter, its less work. You can give an array of choices, doesn't have to be a freeforall but the differences have to be clear and their inputs having effect in the world. Having a clear way to let them know what's going on in the background while they adventure is good too, things like a town cryer or gossip snippits that have reoccuring references makes it seem like there's other stuff going on. Doesn't have to be much or dire all the time but a few active groups you make note of interspersed with the direct game related things can add to it.
>>98952545The most important thing is to know your friend group, know what they enjoy, and run that. While running, you pay attention to what the players latch on to; NPCs, locations, types of quests/missions, that sort of thing, and then you give them more of that.
>>98953422I still wouldn't worry about "homebrewing a world" at this point. At most, you need a town or a city for the players to based in, and some adventure sites outside of said town. I recommend reading the GM advice in any of the Sine Nomine books (Worlds without Number is the fantasy one), he gives good advice about setting and session prep. This big thing is: keep most things broad and vague, and only worry about prepping for as much as you need for the next session.
>>98952545>Pic UnrelatedNot anymore. Stat out a realm-space clown that "pied pipers" kids to kidnap them.
>>98953281I mention "five room dungeon" because that's the easily searchable term. But just like you don't literally have to include dragons in a d&d game I thought it valuable to point out that the name used for the concept doesn't have to be taken literally.
>>98953905Don't argue with autism, anon, it doesn't matter that you're right, the autism is just too strong.
>>98953905>it's an easily searchable term so that means I don't need an argument!Drink anime.
>>98954313That it's an easily searchable, which OP can handily find more information on and ideas for if he wants to, obviously was the argument.
>>98954380The term itself is massively flawed.Justifying its use with the fact that it's easily searchable is just as bad as appealing to popularity.But if you're fine with that, do as instructed before; drink anime.
Never plan out a full campaign, have elements of the world that the players *could* come across, but leave it mostly to the players themselves. This is not to say not to have hooks, but if the players want to explore the goblin camp in the cave on the way to the fortress, let them do that (and you might get mileage out of it depending how well or poorly they do).
>>98952545>DMs: when you have completed a campaign that your players gave you positive feedback on, what are some of the common elements that you got feedback on?Above all: listen. It was never my plans, plots, NPCs, handouts, or anything else. It's my ability to listen this session (and after the session where the feedback really happens) and have your shit ready for you next session. You want to be a famous bard? I really think about that shit and have opportunities for fame force their way into your life. Watch some rock band movies and have the beats come up. You want to be the greatest swordsman? You're god damned right I'll have memorable duellists call you out in dynamic locations that highlight your skill?Your hot bitch sorceress is a hot bitch? Oh fuck yeah I'm having lovingly described outfits laying around next to tomes of forbidden knowledge and NPCs who love fawning. Give them what they want. Then tell them what they want is behind obstacles. Repeat to fade.
>>98952545>Plan short campaigns4-10 sessions. Short enough to drop it if things get fucking without anyone's feelings being hurt, long enough to have a coherent story where playoids can do some planning for their characters.>Start with the campaign endingWhat are the characters supposed to do in the end. What is the big rewards and/or achievement. If you can dangle a good endgame bait for PCs, railroading becomes much easier. Once you have a clear end, start working the campaign backwards to the beginning.>Limit your players resourcesMake them scavenge, beg, negotiate, craft. Force them to climb that hill. Use sunder, rust bugs. Destroy their beloved swords, bows. It's incredible how much better the RP is when DBZ powerwanking is out of the picture
>>98954883Based
>>98954883As someone who's playing in a game right now, this. Unironically, listen to what your players want out of their characters, and when they latch onto something you roll with it.Like the game started with meeting a literally who glup shitto from the setting's canon and a joke on my part which has spiraled into a full character arc for my character and integrating that NPC into the party as someone essential to everyone in it.You gotta listen to your players and roll with what they want, and they in turn need to engage with the larger stuff you planned to some degree. That's what /tg/'s nogames don't understand, that it's a mutual compromise. The players get the stuff their characters want through struggle and hard work, and the GM gets them to at least try to play along with the larger stuff they prepare.