[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Roll dice with "dice+numberdfaces" in the options field (without quotes).

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Venture-Bros.jpg (252 KB, 1400x700)
252 KB JPG
Showdown at Cremation Creek Edition

>Previous
>>98944799
>Pastebin
https://pastebin.com/WiCHizn0
>Mediafire
https://mediafire.com/folder/s9esc6u7ke8k5/CofD
>Mega I
https://mega.nz/folder/ePQ1BKhJ#RCosRCh59Ki2Mpb1M9H3Uw
>Mega II (also containing fanmade games)
https://mega.nz/folder/ZbQ2zLJA#DOT-3df6rS2lLet4_RmqJQ
>5e Mega
https://mega.nz/folder/7rQQ1LbQ#16_AiXVGo0P3_rVOJuoZyA
>VtM to VtR fan translation guide
https://mega.nz/folder/LhYTUD7b#cRDFTcMXSB_2TjD7eJoE5Q
>STV content folders
https://pastebin.com/9i9zhydQ
>General Creation Kit
https://mega.nz/#F!FWJgBTbb!f7d5rARWHYzuI8-8aI-Bxw
>Ideas: BJ Zanzibar's WoD
http://167.99.155.149/
>Anders Mage Page
http://mage.gearsonline.net/anders/
>White Wolf Wiki:
https://whitewolf.fandom.com/wiki/Main_Page
>Ananasi-anon's The Tapestry and the Work
https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/the-tapestry-and-the-work-world-of-darkness-human-into-spider-reincarnation.1325755/
>/WoDg/&/CofDg/ weremoth community project
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1wxUUfa3NNglvbgmJUAn_n84VYkPS08AKgeB7IqWpB1o/edit?usp=sharing

>Thread Question
The entire cast of The Venture Bros gets sent into the World/Chronicles of Darkness due to Rusty's experimental teleporter malfunctioning. What sort of shenanigans occur?

>Alt Question
What splat would each Venture Bros character fit into the best?
>>
File: yrr6kf3p42b61.jpg (844 KB, 1984x2806)
844 KB JPG
Happy Birthday, Shark!
>>
>>98953165
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XqZsoesa55w
>>
>>98953157
>What splat would each Venture Bros character fit into the best?
The whole Guild vs OSI thing is a perfect representation of the Ascension was.
>The Guild ranges from mad scientists of all sorts (could easily be Etherites / VAs) to wizards, mutants, ghosts and most importantly, evil failed musicians, to reprsent each tradition
>OSI is clearly all about fighting secret wars and using super science gadgets (I can't recall seeing them using anything mystical)
>>
File: 1582663226180[1].jpg (96 KB, 719x1192)
96 KB JPG
>>98953165
>>
File: Mina Haha.png (1.1 MB, 2972x986)
1.1 MB PNG
I guess you can assemble a Mina Ha in the new playtest. Still total ass.
>>
>>98954341
>Mina Ha
Ugh, gimme The Lash
>>
>>98954392
The Lash would be the type of individual with True Faith in himself
>>
>>98954583
Would true faith stop viper from molesting the poor heel?
>>
File: Lash shrugged.jpg (200 KB, 1500x2044)
200 KB JPG
>>98954583
Lash is literally a dude who's good at fighting, no gimicks or magic. I can see him being That Guy with a few dots in TF.
>>
>>98954615
Viper has TF in molestation, it might be over for our poor boy Lash. Alternatively she's just so slimy but inconsequential that she'll bypass everything
>>98954629
The Lash physically summons sparkles on his model and his physical feats are a bit more than beyond human. He's good.
>>
>>98954652
The things the Kami get up to, she just wants a strong blood for her kids and she is not taking a no for an answer.
>>
>>98954341
I can't see shit.
>>
>>98953165
Happy birthday to you shark!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJSN48XquGI
>>
File: 1791417764002168.gif (845 KB, 292x164)
845 KB GIF
>>98954652
>The Lash physically summons sparkles on his model and his physical feats are a bit more than beyond human
Sparkles exist because it's a sign of his Faith in himself and the other part is a pure skill issue. BitchBop keeps taking Ls.
>>
Was Athletics reducing fall damage added in 20th or am I somehow just not seeing where it's written in Revised or 2e?
>>
>>98954696
>Literal Gorgon
>Not Wyld related
That guy can't have shit can he?
>>
>>98953157
>What sort of shenanigans occur?
I don't remember enough about venture brothers to tell. I'm sure that there would be at least 1 nephandi willing to give crazy head to the guy who uses orphans as a crafting components.
>>
>>98955151
they made gorgons all non sentient non humanoid

they also made the 3 gorgon sisters nosferatu
>>
>Thread Question
Dr. Orpheus, the Alchemist, Outrider, Tatiana and Triana are Hermetics obviously. Dr. O may get radicalized by the Hermetics about the history of magic and receive a power boost.
OSI and Guild guys get divided among the Technocracy and Sons of Ether.
Dr. Venture falls under the protection of Technocrats but gets headhunted by Etherites.
The Blackula hunter gets Dominated.
>>
File: images[1].jpg (14 KB, 516x387)
14 KB JPG
Least malicious fae
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNDthC-lnYQ
>>
File: Masquerade 1e.jpg (153 KB, 862x856)
153 KB JPG
It's 1991, Vampire the Masquerade just came out, and this is what a health track looks like.
When did this change? I know it was some point before 2e came out.
>>
File: Ascension 1e.jpg (315 KB, 911x616)
315 KB JPG
>>98955755
It was already different by Apocalypse 1e. I thought that was because werewolves could shrug off pain more easily than vampire, but here's Ascension's health track, and those guys are physically indistinguishable from mortals.
>>
>Writing out plot for city, factions, politics, and the like
>Get to a point I'm happy with
>Realize I didn't include the anarchs anywhere
Do they have much any use in including besides being a potential power block to turn against the enemy sect?
>>
File: IMG_3419.png (1.52 MB, 832x1291)
1.52 MB PNG
>>98953165
>>98953190
>>98954740
Thanks a lot guys! Man today was fun, but most of all relaxing. I spent it all playing Ni No Kuni and helping my parents outside the house in preparation for winter. My birthday present is a green autumn jacket really soft and comfy.

Tonight we dined at an Italian restaurant. I ordered some duck confit pizza and despite pouring spicy oil, Tabasco sauce and pepper flakes, it barely was spicy. The honey topping made it taste like a dessert. Which isn’t bad, but I’m not into sweets. Anyway it was nice seeing the family.

How are you all doing on this most lucky day?
>>
>>98955812
Just make fun of them like I did.
>Ah hate wohkin foh da fuckin cahamal-ah. Ah hate da fuckin anahchs even mohe because they want all of da benefits but none of da responsibilities that come with it. Then again, theyyah also unintahested in da political powah games. Honestly, it's kinda fucked up ta imagine that no vampere hahe actually wanted ta be a paht of this.
He's from Maine and has a thick-ass accent, he talks really weird.
>>
>>98955816
>How are you all doing on this most lucky day?
Just lost my source for free deepseek cooming. Other than that it's business as usual.
>>
>>98955816
>How are you all doing on this most lucky day?
Stayed at work for an unreasonable 12 hours after dealing with maintenance and logistic bullshit, but hey things could be worse. Now I'm at home and getting as drunk as I can without making my family worry enough to do shit.

>>98955853
SHIIIEEET just dealt with Chat telling that my edits were too horny for him and now I am annoyed as hell.
>>
File: 73259684726586.jpg (275 KB, 1080x1816)
275 KB JPG
>>98955816
>How are you all doing on this most lucky day?
Irl
>Woke up early to make sure I didnt get usurped today especially because I wanted the very first post to wish Shark a happy birthday
>Walked 3 miles in 6 degrees (F) above freezing weather with my best friend
>Finished a major phase in my Library project for my friend's server in Minecraft
>Unsure if my boss gave me a raise without telling me because my last check and current one have at least $50 more than normal
>periodically wondered if Setite-anon and Ananasi-anon are doing ok

Bakeslave
>decided to try experimenting on more masculine forms but is having trouble with the chest, jawline, and hips
>>
File: Happy_Birthday_Sharky.png (407 KB, 600x359)
407 KB PNG
>>98955816
I'm sorry it's late, but Happy Birthday Sharky! Meant to do this sooner but passed out as soon as I got home and just woke up.

>>98956203
I'm doing okay. Work schedule has just been very hectic lately, and I haven't had much to contribute to the threads. Appreciate the thoughts!
>>
File: 1236980555800.jpg (3.1 MB, 2488x1436)
3.1 MB JPG
>>98953157
>>
File: owari da.jpg (26 KB, 595x626)
26 KB JPG
>scotland gets its own tribe of garou
>they're depraved chaotic evil psychotics
>>
File: Ceilican.png (215 KB, 891x1063)
215 KB PNG
>>98956514
at least you have your own tribe of Bastet!
>they're all psychotic bitches with DID, even worse than Fianna by a long shot
>>
File: hengeyokai khan.jpg (2.36 MB, 1881x2421)
2.36 MB JPG
Is this meant to be Sokto or Crinos from Hengeyokai?

Either way, ngl, would.
>>
>>98956514
This is the worst part about Werewolf the Apocalypse for me - if I want to be a cool ass Mokole I have to be black or something. And if I want to be my home country I have to be a fucking Fianna (they're not that bad).
>>
>>98956793
A bunch of lizards with a thing for fair-haired hotties with diabolical accents set sail for Scotland long ago. One of them is your distant ancestors and a confluence of factors led to you becoming a lizardman too.

There, you're welcome.
>>
>>98956792
99% sokto, crinos is full furry weretiger
>>
File: qhHbgd.gif (1.18 MB, 320x180)
1.18 MB GIF
>>98956792
Bastet are our masters.
>>
>>98956793
Do what my table does when we stumble upon stuff that disallows us from doing something: ignore it.
Mind, we do this only when it's minor shit like what you said.
>>
File: Chad on line 1.jpg (105 KB, 1024x576)
105 KB JPG
>>98953165
The Timetable has allotted you no more than 10 seconds of being wished a happy birthday. The wishes must follow guidlines listed bellow:
>The phrase "Happy Birthday" will not be repeated more than three times and no less than one time.
>The wishes will be delivered with a backing track
>The track can only be selected by personel with level 6 Gamma-Delta-Z clearance
>Operatives must insure that the track is of good quality and sufficent volume as to not interfere with the pre programme Mind procedure
>>
File: HXEdZNgWwAACRbz.jpg (396 KB, 1080x1397)
396 KB JPG
do haunted houses in vtm have to be wraith related or can i just do spooky shit in places where awful things happened before?

nosferatu claimed a mental asylum in germany that was discontinued because of what they did to the patients there in ww2 and wants to use it as haven
>>
So as someone who has played the first Bloodlines extensively, and read a few of the books across games, where the hell would I start with learning to DM Vampire? Hell, what edition would I start with? I think World of Darkness is one of the few series that I genuinely just don't know where to begin.
>>
File: 1446519384875.jpg (43 KB, 720x600)
43 KB JPG
>>98957375
core book! v20 or revised are your best options for vampire!
figure out what city you wanna set it in, if you dont wanna do a city IRL make up your own.
determine the political allegiance of the city, do they belong to the anarchs, cammies, or sabbat?
what's the conflict of the setting or conflicts?
are the sabbat invading the city? maybe the toreador and ventrue are having an interclan conflict and suffering a power struggle? maybe clan tremere summoned some elder horror from beyond the stars that stalks in shadows even making those that go bump in the night pale in fear? It can be all of these things and none of these things. You determine what is happening!
create mortal and vampires and ghouls to populate the city, each of them being fleshed out and full featured people who your players can meet with drama and lives and interconnection between the two of them. Don't have vampires be the cause of everything but have human conflict as well, perhaps a major company is buying up land in the area, perhaps gang violence is on the rise, maybe there's a drug sweeping the area or a cult that's growing in popularity that people are worried about.
create a history that influences the area and the general imports and exports of the city so you understand what the bases of power are.
Determine where the vampires are getting money from and what power bases they control so you can draw conflict from them and clashes between them.
if youre a cammie city, make a primogen and prince along with a sheriff and the other roles. If youre an anarch make a baron and their structure, if youre a sabbat city you need bishops, an archbishop and the various packs prowling about.
Don't be afraid to get weird, don't make vampires the only freakshit prowling around, make your players question what is and isn't possible!
werewolves, aliens, wizards, ghosts and other bullshit are around.
show them tulpas, extra dimensions and horrors beyond understanding!
Most importantly
Have fun!
>>
>>98957328
you can have it be like psychic hauntings from horrid energy and suffering. the world of darkness doesnt have to be uniform, do your own thing if other bullshit isnt your vibe!
>>
>>98957375
Start with the Core Rulebook from Vampire the Masquerade 20th Anniversary Edition (V20). That will be the book and edition you get the mechanics from.

The short way, if you just want more lore, would be reading Lore of the Clans and Lore of the Bloodlines, both from V20.

The long way, where you get to know the setting in greater detail, is to read from VTM Revised Edition:
Guide to the Camarilla
Guide to the Sabbat
Guide to the Anarchs
and the Clanbooks.
plus
from Second Edition, Chapter One on the Caitiff from Outcasts - A Player's Guide to Pariahs.
Ignore the Disciplines and Abilities found in these Revised books, read them just for the lore.

Still want more?
Chaining the Beast
Sins of the Blood
State of Grace
The Book of Nod
Revelations of the Dark Mother
The Erciyes Fragments
>>
File: Elginia_BW.jpg (46 KB, 800x534)
46 KB JPG
>>98956793
There were dinosaurs in Scotland, so why not some remnant mokole?
>>
>>98957486
fera need to switch between human and animal kinfolk every few generations or they lose "it" and become normies
>>
What's the deal with the woof equivalent of ghouls? The wolf blooded or whatever they're called, because I'm reasonably sure the garou aren't going around feeding them blood
>>
File: Anguidae.jpg (67 KB, 700x523)
67 KB JPG
>>98957513
Slowworm kinfolk then.
>>
>>98957513
But mokole get ooooold, as evidenced in the existence of Nessie
>>
Where is hedgefag
WHERE IS HEDGIE
>>
>>98957524
Wolf-blooded is from Forsaken, in Apocalypse they're called Kinfolk. I'm not an Apocalypse expert, but according to the memes, they're just second class citizens used only for breeding. Forsaken's wolf-blooded on the other hand have powers of their own, and are valued members of packs.
>>
>>98957328
I think I read somewhere that the way ghosts work in oWoD is that ghosts are psychic aftereffects of traumatic or horrific events that have been imprinted on that place. The people in question have passed on to whatever comes after but the ghosts you are seeing are almost like a clone copy afterimage that is anchored to the area and acts out a set of behaviour inherited from the person. (Obviously this does not apply to Wraiths)
>>
>>98957577
That's CofD, not WoD.
>>
>>98957582
My mistake. How do they work in WoD?
>>
>>98957577
>>98957582
This stuff is actually also in Wraith as well but it depends on edition, and has way less emphasis than compared to Geist. Geist for some reason just goes out of its way to tell you these ghosts are clones...because cross splat or some shit.
>>
File: Vampire_14_21.30.40-muted.mp4 (1.51 MB, 1920x1080)
1.51 MB
1.51 MB MP4
Did you guys know the protagonist in VtM:B breathes, pretty fucking hard actually? I was taking some pics and just noticed this
>>
>>98958017
Probably just a reflex action. The Fledgling in Bloodlines is a brand new vampire and the story takes place over the course of at most a week probably less.
>>
>>98958017
Reflex. It's oftentimes pointed out how weird elder vampires look because they don't do normal human micromovements or reflexive actions like blinking or breathing.
>>
>>98958017
Not surprising. Even Andrei remarks how the fledgling can still make expressions of shock and horror because he/she has only been dead for a short while.
>>
>>98957328
with nazis you can have everything from psionics to infernalism. these guys been into all sort of occult nonsense and in wod most of those is real

there is a nwod blue book called asylum that's pretty setting neutral (because nwod was barely a setting back then) perhaps you can get some inspiration from that
>>
>>98958017
most vampires do. they only stop to breath and blink and such when they become elders and we are told that 90% of all vampires been embraced in the last 100 years
>>
>>98957328
happy screaming skeleton day to you too, anon
>>
>>98958017
I also want to point out how pale VtM:B protags are, they don't retract their fangs either(none of the vamps in VtM:B do) so you're basically playing a walking masquerade violation
Maybe that's why they breathe so fucking hard, it's overcompensating. "Guys I'm definitely human, look at how much I breathe"
>>
>>98956793
>they're not that bad
>said in the world's least obvious cope
>>
>>98958270
>they don't retract their fangs either(none of the vamps in VtM:B do) so you're basically playing a walking masquerade violation
I feel making the vampires obvious to the player was an intentional design decision.
>>
>>98957524
>feeding them blood
Not the only fluid you can feed serfs if you get creative anon. Jokes aside though, there is no real woof equivalent to ghouls in Apoc.
>>98957557
Kinfolk can have gnosis and learn smaller gifts or rites, or bigger ones if you're a spesshul OC from a dead bloodline of revenants. Otherwise, the only powers they can get are shit from like being a Mage or a Sorcerer.

To say their only use is for breeding is a bit reductive (other than Red Talons and Glass Walkers). Human Kinfolk are a good interface with society for most tribes and packs since Garou heavily struggle with passing as human long-term and Wolf Kinfolk (in mixed tribes) are good for keeping the Garou from being too homid-boo and abandoning their mission or their wilder side. Glass Walkers, Bone Gnawers, and Red Talons are sort of exceptions to this and are a bit weird for it though
>>
>>98956793
God I hate that kind of racial exclusivity
>>
>>98958346
It still sounds like the only use of wolf kinfolk is breeding. Maybe you can use them as shitty guard dogs. Taking kin background as a lupus is for the dogs.
>>
>>98958349
God I love that kind of racial exclusivity
>>
>>98958270
>>98958325
It's certainly a purposeful choice, every vampire has vampire eyes for instance. It sort helps the player internalize the setting better like "Damn these guys are hiding in plain sight" and "There sure are a lot of leeches in LA"
>>
>>98958409
They're smarter than your average wolf and keep the tribe more wild and in-mind of their duties. I guess it's for like keeping the pack more of a pack and less like a gang. I do struggle to see what actual use they have other than breeding but I'm pretty sure the writers do also. WoD is a human-centric game after all. Even Demon, the most alien setting, is basically the humaniboo larper game
>>
>>98958484
>There sure are a lot of leeches in LA
I almost got caught up in the autism of the ratio given in the 2nd ed VtM book of 1:100000 and comparing that to the number of npcs in the by night i was looking at and that being way off and wanting to adjust it and make sure my chronicle was correct before realizing that was pure retardation and accepting I will have as many as suits the game.
>>
>>98957375
What the others said. V20 is good as a first for Bloodlines brain, though I'd argue the best version of the system is DAV20. If anything just use Celerity/Potence/Fortitude from DAV20 and the rest is fine in V20.
>>
>>98958419
I like it when it's like, "Khan are all jeets or chinese...but some of them are Englishmen" like yeah I'll be a posh english khan cunt
>>
If a player wants to play a ghoul/revenant/dhampir in a vampire chronicle, how do you balance it with the rest of the group?
>>
>>98958591
I think ethnic groups I like should get cool content and the ethnic groups I dont like should get nothing. In that case jeets and chinese should have no cool tigermen
>>
>>98958607
I don't.
>>
>>98958607
Part of the fun of WoD is that it is not balanced. It is primarily a role players role playing game where the meat is how the players interact with each other and the world rather then each actor being on a retentively playing field. Perhaps offer unique opportunities to the odd player out due to them going against the grain but in terms of hard mechanics unless the player comes to you with something they genuinely think is unfair then leave it as is.
>>
>>98958503
I always interpreted that as 1:100,000 against the general population, but way more than that tend to congregate in major cities
>>
>>98957436
Nice, but what if I want to expand out, take some stuff from other systems for whatever reason? I know some people that are also interested more in Werewolves or even just being regular 'ol mortals. I'd assume that I'd still use the 20th anniversary equivalents for those, right? In fact, would it be good to read those as well any ways, to learn even more of the setting? Sorry I'm asking a whole lot, it's just a LOT of info to take in and go over.
>>
>>98958661
I dont know how accurate it is but in my own games the world wide number of vampires I give is around 1 million world wide. With some areas more densely populated then others
>>
>>98957410
>>98957436
And I forgot, thank the both of you for helping me start out, really does help a whole lot.
>>
File: Overpopulaton_2nd_ed.png (261 KB, 550x613)
261 KB PNG
>>98958668
>>98958661
It got specific in a way I understand the initial urge to do but have at this point realized nothing good will come from trying to math this sort of stuff out for the sort of game I want to run. Felt a bit out of place in the book itself when I read it but think its part of the era too.
>>
>>98958683
Yeah that’s just some good old fashioned WW writing to be ignored
I have such a hard time recommending these games to friends because they don’t have the same tolerances built up for reading something really really stupid and cringe and just ignoring and discarding it
>>
>>98958702
It was a fun internal moment reading it and going
>oh, interesting number, I should see what the number is for those cities now and blahbleblablah comapre to sabbat mass embrace to see if this is in the ratio blahablahb what about thin bloods blahbla I bet there's a way to make a table where average numbers per generation blahblahbl
>do not do that you fucking retard just have enough vampires its interesting
There is for sure a powerful urge there and I am glad I have not run with it.
It is weird that amount of deference to the literal interpretation there is given it, and most ttrpgs straight up tell you to change parts as you see fit.
>>
>>98958666
I say you start with Vampire if the goal is to run Vampire, you honestly don't need to know about the intricacies of werewolf politics and spirits and Gaia's war with Pentex when you just want to use one (1) wolf in your chronicle. Read the 20th edition of Werewolf the Apocalypse when you want to play werewolves.
>>
File: 5tprkwdhxx4h1.png (13 KB, 1608x831)
13 KB PNG
>>98958591
>>98958614
>India is a 100% Wyrm tainted subcontinent full of mockbreeds and fomori that the Khans are trying and failing to prune. (Tigers are being displaced by Jeet overpopulation and are now regularly hunting Jeets in villages.)
>Fera in general are exterminating Jeets when possible because of their wyrm stank and the inevitable pollution they cause to the environment, society and gene pools.
>The Technocracy, Nephandi and Pentex are collaborating to flood India into the rest of the world.
>Technocrat constructs are being staffed or run by unawakened Jeets or even Fomor Jeets. No one's allowed to call it out because "We're progressive now." and bullshit stats asserting Jeets are superhumans that are good for the GDP.
>Virtual Adepts, Glasswalkers and Nephandi just walk through Technocrat vulnerabilities caused by Jeets.
>Indians taste like actual poop to vampires who are forced to become extremely racist to protect their food supply.
>Verbena are having a race war with Indians to protect their Aryan ancestry that they paradigmatically rely on. Similar thing with Gets.
>>
>>98958830
This should be the benchmark for every WoD game
>>
>>98955761
1e mage came out after vtm 2e. mage is weird in context of wod editions because the first mage books came out between vtm 2e and wta2e but then it had a second edition in the middle of wod's 2e and then a revised book together with the rest
>>
>>98958830
This is now canon in my WoD, thank you anon
>>
>>98958830
Dreamspeakers are also tagging in with Verbena because of how Jeet infestations are affecting indigenous populations and nature everywhere. Native Americans and Polynesians aren't loving it.
Jeets are a Wyrm Race and they number 1 billion. Make your last prayers to Gaia because the entire liberal world is 100% ready to destroy everything for the sake of egalitarianism and individualism.
>>
>>98957645
>because cross splat or some shit.
I remember someone here griping about them getting downgraded to clones because cofd mage players were using them as batteries but getting uncomfortable with the implications.
>>
How fun is it to play a mokole? Dio’s scary monster makes it very tempting
>>
>>98953157
Which edition of Wraith is the best for mining ideas and inspiration?
>>
>>98959084
I believe they are actually busted, they have customizable warforms afaik?
>>
File: tweed.png (30 KB, 944x241)
30 KB PNG
>>98958830
>Well now that seems a little hars-
>See this
Oh...
>>
>>98958545
How different can Celerity, Fortitude, and Potence be across generations of oWoD?
>>
File: grainychad.png (123 KB, 474x474)
123 KB PNG
>Hey ST is it cool if I play a City Gangrel even though this isn't a Sabbat game?
>>
>>98959519
When people talked about City v Country Gangrel, I assumed this was some kind of divide separate from Camarilla/Sabbat politics
>>
>>98959525
in a just world it would be
>>
>>98959519
i believe the right nomenclature in that case is greek gangrel
>>
>>98959136
there are only 2 the normal one and the anniversary edition and the later somehow has nothing going for it beside playable orpheus characters in wod
>>
>>98959519
sabbat city gangrel will send packs to hunt you if they find out about this. to be honest that's just a fun plot hook
>>
>>98959551
>Celerity
>obfuscate
If they can find/catch me that is
>>
>>98959565
Don't have to find you to torch your car/haven. Hope you like walking city boy.
>>
>>98959084
My friend is playing one and she likes her a lot.
>>
Reading the ways to customize your mokole form and a stupid part of me is tempted to make a sea serpent that put everything in doubling the swimming speed. Basically spending 10 points to multiply my speed by 1024.
>>
File: ur.jpg (83 KB, 640x640)
83 KB JPG
>>98956793
He just has reverse vitiligo
>>
File: Whaaaat.jpg (146 KB, 1280x913)
146 KB JPG
>>98956793
If you're Aryan then all of Eurasia is yours.
>>
>>98959525
It sort of is. Gangrels don't really have a solid structure
>>
>>98959459
Excuse me what
>>
File: indian robotics.jpg (241 KB, 702x1007)
241 KB JPG
>>98959459
>Average amalgam in 2026
India is the Wyrm's playground and a vision of the future. Nephandi win instantly when people truly realize that's what the entire world will look like in the year 3000 instead of Star Trek. Black Spirals and Nephandi created a region-wide Wyrm cult numbering 1 billion people. They're worshiping a multi-armed black spiral fera and collectively ensuring the perpetual agony of the spirit of the Ganges River while Urge/Elemental Wyrms dance on its spasming body and nearly materializing through the gauntlet. Then there's the normalization of corruption, scamming and sexual depravity.
Nigga it's OVER.
>>
File: 437-1793489026-904786547.jpg (306 KB, 1920x1080)
306 KB JPG
Since I'm replaying VtM:B I checked out its Nexus and there are some interesting new mods there, most definitely thanks to the new AI coding boom. Not really interested in discussing AI coding stuff, just posting here in case someone else is also interested:
https://www.nexusmods.com/games/vampirebloodlines/mods?sort=createdAt
There are stuff like adding GTA style phone, camera reworks, weapon wheel(for controller use I assume), etc.
>>
>>98959386
Build-a-bear usually is really strong in these games, with Mokole / Kuei Jin / Demons being the stand outs. Zhong Lung Mokole are called out as being just stupid OP even within universe.

In the Kuei-jin's case, their OPness is marred by the fact their Methusalah equivalents kinda suck ass versus Vampires because of how small their resource pools are and how shit most of their +6 Disciplines are.
>>
>>98960613
From what I've heard a not insignificant amount of them are against this kind of stuff and want a cleaner environment, but they seem to be a small amount from the information I have.
>>
>>98953157
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KiI4YPCEW3s
I know very little about Mage when I watched this video and know I am curious. What is this generals takes on this video and what the guy says? is Mage just fundamentally incompatible not just with the wider WoD universe but basic reality as the passage of time has shown?
>>
>>98955812
Organized (see Isaac Abrams) opposition to the Camarilla that is not the Sabbat.
Or a fast growing, highly appealing threat to the Camarilla's order that may very easily snowball into waves of angry Brujah childer willing to fuck everything up for a short term goal that will leave everything as chaos or ruins. Then in those circumstances the Sabbat will thrive and have 0 issues besieging the city.

Make them political outsiders in general. A non-Camarilla cainite organization that can be moderate or actively oppose the Camarilla. Or a straight up rebellion movement, insurgency, etc; the Anarchs are exactly what an unruly childe wants and there may be literally nothing keeping one from joining. They can be as underground or as openly hostile as you see fit.
I hope this can give you inspiration even if its been a while since the post.
>>
>>98959964
>Actual "Aryans" are the Persians
>The Nazis co-opted the term for a sci-fi fantasy about how an "Ice World" carrying white supermen crashed into earth and formed the mythical city of Hyperborea, and that's totally where Germans descended from
>>
>>98960794
"I really wish there was a standardized way of making Mage."
But MtA is game about creating and recreating your own reality and PR being a full-contact sport. That this table/ST and that table/ST give you a completely different experience, setting, overall philosophies drawing the lines that divide the factions and drive the conflicts, is just a strength of the game. He doesn't have to like it, but clearly by not seeing that every part of the game and how it's played are consistent in their possibility for freedom, he completely missed the point.
He both fears the openness that comes with freedom, and envies his opposition who appear to have it easier, following a straightforward, well-trodden path, and having instructions that aren't unclear.
He is the bugman begging for a Technocrat to knock on his door and dictate him the standard way to run his game, which standard opinions he should be allowed to have and the standards according to which how he ought to live his life.
He also doesn't seem to know anti-establishment and anti-dictatorship rhetoric in the US right did not start in the 2010s and is far older than he is.
>>
File: I miss my wife.jpg (710 KB, 1080x2340)
710 KB JPG
How much damage should a brass coffin deal and what should be the difficulty to attack with it?
>ok but how
4 strength + 4 potence, don't worry about it.
>>
>>98961084
>He doesn't have to like it
A lot of people don't like it, it's why whenever Mage is discussed in this thread, the most common topic is how too many of the rules are too loose, too open to interpretation, too reliant on ST fiat and too reliant on roleplay. A lot of people would be a lot happier if there were much more rigid and strict rules that aren't open to interpretation and tell the reader precisely and exactly how the game should be played.
>>
>>98955812
Including Anarchs isn't mandatory, and I would argue including them makes your vampire politics less interesting, rather than more.
>>
File: 1000063284.jpg (236 KB, 1932x2048)
236 KB JPG
>>98959503
Just those particular changes becase for V20 Celerity goes from "gamebreakingly busted" to "pretty good option and reasonably strong" by not just giving you extra turns. V20 Potence also gets a nice tweak where it's no longer an I win button with a single dot, and Fortitude gets a buff it should've had from the beginning to actually help it soak instead of "maybe you get to soak". Considering they're such common Disciplines I think the small changes are worth it.

Also, DAV20 has a god damn index you should at least look at to get an idea of what mechanics could be in a game.
>>
>>98958830
>>98959964
Incredibly based. Please invite me to your group so we can be based together. I really need a game.
>>
>>98961109
Odd are you should make the damage bonus equal to the strength requirement, so about +8B. As for the TN, make it a 9 and any further penalties subtract dice like in ExWoD. You are dealing with the most unwieldy piece of garbage that you could possibly use as a weapon, presuming that your character can even hold the damned thing with handles or chains.
>>
File: 1792816884290678m.jpg (93 KB, 505x1024)
93 KB JPG
>>98961168
Anarchs are good fodder and introduction material because of their flaws. I just don't think they have enough of a point to make them the main characters outside of showing the Cam not being able or willing to control everything.
>>
>>98961372
Eh, I think they eat up real estate that would be better used by actual local opposition to large sects. I also think a lot of ST's overdo it when they try to prove the Camarilla "isn't invincible" and instead it makes them look weak/inept. It's the same phenomenon that causes ST's to religiously duck making their Prince a Ventrue, their Harpy a Toreador, etc.

I also find that low level Sabbat make for better fodder. Shovelheads especially. I'll freely admit I really don't like the Anarchs and would excise them from the setting entirely if my friends hadn't already played bloodlines, but I think my distaste for them is well-founded. They don't do anything unique, or that couldn't be done better by an OC local group, independent faction, etc.
>>
>>98956793
in one of the official anthologies there's a white person who has their first change as a lost mokole hatchling then has gay sex after realizing that his boyfriend is a garou
>>
File: 20251212_124818.jpg (1.26 MB, 1200x1200)
1.26 MB JPG
>>98961410
Oh I hate the fuckers in general, I'm just trying to make the best argument for their use cases over the Sabbat.
>>
>>98961425
There is no way this is real. It sounds like bad fanfiction. Can you post proof?
>>
File: BrujahGF.gif (425 KB, 500x459)
425 KB GIF
>>98961410
If you could re-write the Anarchs to make them a solid competitor to the Camarilla and Sabbat while still preserving their presentation in Bloodlines how would you do it? I like them conceptually but I agree that they are very lacking and need a big re-write.
>>
File: a.png (474 KB, 1080x988)
474 KB PNG
>>98961450
from songs of the sun and moon
i misremembered his bf wasnt a garou but just a regular mortal
>>
>>98961456
Copy from the Requiem counterpart and give their subfactions lore sheets. Like here's some tricks the American Anarchists have and why differ from the Russian ones in some major ways like communal herds an havens rather than ways to keep everyone from killing one another.
>>
>>98961436
Fair enough. I was just trying to let the original anon know that he isn't required to have an Anarch presence at all. Heck, you could technically run a game where only one sect is present.

>>98961456
>If you could re-write the Anarchs to make them a solid competitor to the Camarilla and Sabbat while still preserving their presentation in Bloodlines how would you do it?
I couldn't. Primarily because of:
>make them a solid competitor to the Camarilla and Sabbat

Many of the problems with the Anarchs boil down to trying to make them a third big sect. Which is a struggle, because they're insanely parochial, even if many of their advocates don't realize it. The Camarilla and the Sabbat on the other hand are fairly universal. The Anarchs very lazily co-opt most of their positions from post-enlightenment western philosophy, with a heavy bias on post-WW2 stuff, and rarely considering how being a vampire changes these dynamics. Whenever they try to expand beyond it, they try to staple other non-Sabbat anti-Camarilla actions to the roster, like the Brujah Council, to the movement, despite them having no actual connection. as an aside, wow does Rage Across Russia suck

The few places in which the Anarchs actually work, they work because they're not a major sect. Bloodlines' Anarchs aren't awful because it really embraces the parochial nature of their "movement." It also is novel because they're every bit as libertarian as they are American pseudo-socialist. Abrams' only real disagreement with the Camarilla is that he doesn't want anyone above him, and he only cares about ruling Hollywood. Nines' is the way he is due to the great depression. The only elder in their roster predates the Free State and is callous enough to be willing to sacrifice any of his "comrades" just to kill one mediocre Ventrue. They're a believable collection of characters that want Big Vampire out of their backyard, but that (good) concept doesn't work when scaled up.
>>
File: ttcurEBCMn288jnc.mp4 (398 KB, 498x282)
398 KB
398 KB MP4
how can you possibly stay angry at the garou when they do this?
>>
>>98961456
I just use them as a term the Camarillia puts on any kindred not full retard Sabbat who isn't vocally compliant to Camarillia traditions and fealty to the Prince. There's going to be a variety of reasons different vampires aren't into that who come together as ad hoc groups and drift apart depending on circumstance. Its a catch all term used by detractors and controllers of 'state' apparatus more than an internally cohesive grouping. There will be some shared origin mythology but it varies with the telling and many of them do not give a fuck about the history.
They're not competitors to the other two, they're independents doing their own thing which messes with everyone's plans but isn't as intrusive, are potential recruits and useful idiots, or a pitfall if focused on too the point the other more cohesive players lose sight of the Jyhad.
Also lets me use the term
>House Brujha
as a pejorative from some of them to each other which is fun.
>>
>>98961580
Hmmmm, new belt and fur lining for my winter boots...
>>
>>98960794
Yes Establishment vs Quirky Underdogs is too overplayed in WoD and falls apart after any examination. The Quirky Underdog is not always in the right, and the Big Bad Man not always actually Bad. The central conflict should be divorced from this, especially with the Union as not evil mcbadguys. This is another problem of people wanting to be The Good Guys. I have no problem playing a Witch that is objectively heinous and really does want to bring back Pagan Blood Sacrifices and throw us back into the Iron Age. Idgaf, that's cool. It never should have been portrayed as a good thing. Neither should the Union thus have been whitewashed. They're ALSO evil. It's World of Darkness.

He's wrong about Magick being weak, assuming arete3. Even in combat quick-casts are incredibly lethal. Run some calculations on forces attacks and you'll quickly see. This doesn't account for more creative attacks.

His understanding of the setting being "whatever you want" is misunderstanding what M20 is. M20 is an anthology, which is why it's so unwilling to give you a concrete setting, this is on purpose.
Should a theoretical M6 have an actual established setting and history? Probably yes, but only if Paradox does it well (Mission Status: Impossible).
As for building more concrete Paradigm(s), I would agree it would be better if there was actual mechanical effects and a toolkit for doing this as opposed to all fiat.

Then he goes on to complain about how Mage is about political thought, and the average ST has to sort of make it work for their own group, and it changes year by year how these different groups are seen. I think this is partly an issue of being unable to divorce your own political thought/belief from character roleplay and partially simply how the game is by design. Mage is inherently about defining Belief Systems, so you can't expect to not be confronted by that.

Overall: Meh. I still like Mage most, Werewolf has the same issues especially if handled by Corpo.
>>
>>98961456
I wouldn't. I WOULD make them total jokes and make sure to humiliate the Brujah
>>
>https://www.dexerto.com/entertainment/mysterious-3300-year-old-sword-found-at-bottom-of-lake-in-excellent-condition-3427318/
>A 3,300-year-old sword was found at the bottom of a lake in Italy

>Researchers say it is in “excellent condition” and is “still sharp”

>They also noted that research “will continue in the coming years” as they want to uncover further items linked to “ritual and cult practices connected to water.”

that shit was made before wear and tear was added to the consensus
>>
>>98961456
ironically take a page from the SI there are no "anarchs" anarchs are a term for malcontents in the Cam and the new anarch movement is made out of smaller factions who's only real uniting feature is the dislike for the ivory tower and are now acting up because the camarilla isn't a great position after the world wars (still recent in vampire terms) followed by two major sect wars against the sabbat in north america

and then actually flesh out these factions so have the ordea league be anarchs as is the soviet council, the free state, the native american vampires basicily everyone who is too small to be their own real sect but has a grudge against and power to atleast move against the local camarilla and with a understanding that the moment they would "win" in a major way the movement would be over and they would turn on each other like the council of traditions
>>
>>98961425
>>98961450
i haven't read that story, but this is the same game that had the white savior garou of a native american tribe and a (canceled) novel series about the technocrats bringing back sabertooth bastet as a suburban teenage white boy

so i'll believe it
>>
File: HXI0vbOXIAAqCnD.png (297 KB, 715x531)
297 KB PNG
>>
>>98960307
>Average Indian CEO
Why are these guys so sought after? I have never seen a product improve or a company do better under one save for cases of inertia like google
>>
>>98961580
>Garou 1% of the time versus Garou 99% of the time
Hmmm... This jewelry store should be flattened and turned into a garden
>>
>>98961972
indians had some hype in the early 2000 to 2010s and hype is enough to get investments even if it did end up amounting to nothing and if you have investment you are in that world and some people managed to laverage that "in" into positions at other companies
>>
>>98961956
>a (canceled) novel series about the technocrats bringing back sabertooth bastet as a suburban teenage white boy
wasn't this actually released, though its way more a traditions thing, why the fuck would a technocrat do this
>>
>>98962079
>wasn't this actually released
only the first of the three books got released
>though its way more a traditions thing, why the fuck would a technocrat do thi
Progenitors REALLY like sabertooths for some reason. one of their standard attack animals is also a cyborg smilodon
>>
>>98962105
>Progenitors REALLY like sabertooths for some reason. one of their standard attack animals is also a cyborg smilodon
>the origin story of khara/sabertooth Bastet/ancestor of all Bastet is a mage and smildon fighting together to create the first Bastet from their Bond
Mages CAN NEVER beat the allegations, not even fucking technocrats
>>
File: 24f.gif (153 KB, 450x450)
153 KB GIF
>>98961580
How can the garou stay mad at me when I do this?
>>
File: Lynx-Killer.png (209 KB, 457x493)
209 KB PNG
>>98962124
meanwhile Garou:
>>
>>98962219
based Qualmi
>>
>>98961456
the failure of the anarchs is the insistence to make them a sect on par with the cam and sabbat
>>
>>98962324
It's either that or being forgotten like the dozen lesser factions.
>>
File: IMG_3440.png (2.25 MB, 1304x2048)
2.25 MB PNG
Shark here. Can’t tell much about the game right now since I’m leaving it early, and I’m about to go to a party, but I can tell you all this.

Lyssa saved Hitler’s life. During the Night of the Long Knives a (former) Ventrue Primogen named Leon opened fire on the Fuhrer with a machine gun in auto mode. Lyssa stepped in front of Hitler and shielded him from all the bullets without suffering a single scratch. For saving his life Lyssa is going to be buddy with Adolf Hitler.
>>
>>98962329
Would help if they could write a minor faction that doesn't suck.
>>
>>98962105
>Progenitors REALLY like sabertooths for some reason. one of their standard attack animals is also a cyborg smilodon
They're the designated weird convention. Everyone else is using cybernetics or tools while these guys are busy spawning resident evil monsters and builing space slave plantations run by dinosaurs. Small price to pay for what they bring to the table.
>>
>the state of WoD VNs
>>
>>98962565
concurrent is a very bad comparison for vns, better look at reviews to estimate total copies sold or other such metrics.
>>
>>98962565
not sure about the rest but the new york ones SUCk when it comes to replay value when you compare them to stuff like nightroad or parlament of knives (which probably also don't have many players do to the lack of production value behind them) because most of your choice come down to route A pr B. it's like mass effect's paragon or renegade system without the shooter gameplay
>>
I always found it funny how humans are frequently more evil than the inherently evil monsters. Is it because humans have moral agency? They choose and go out of their way to do awful things that'd make vampires and werewolves blush?

Mages especially are considered the biggest monsters around.
>>
>>98962726
>Mages especially are considered the biggest monsters around.
mages are considered monsters by both versions of the world of darkness. in owod demons (devil's due) can even give mages a humanity rating which has some really funny implications
>>
File: 1783696923813849.png (3.18 MB, 1046x1600)
3.18 MB PNG
I'm reading extinction parade and I felt like posting about it here because I think some of y'all would like it if you haven't read it already.
>>
>>98962726
>Mages especially are considered the biggest monsters around.
By whom? The average mage is pretty okay compared to the average Vampire, Demon or even Garou. They CAN be pretty evil and fucked up, but they're just human levels of dickass, mostly. A really, really evil mage that's not a Nephandus isn't that remarkably evil for Vampire standards.
>>
>>98961084
>>98961131
Mage can be a game about consensual reality wizards without the following
>the general OWoD jankiness
>the haphazard way spheres are ranked with the soft but NEVER explicitly spoken implication that certain 'paradigms' can get certain sphere effects earlier OR have to include other spheres for no benefit
>the fact Paradox affects you in situations where human opinions literally would not affect you like most Umbral realms
>the fact certain parts of the setting uniquely have to kowtow to other gamelines and tax things, most prominently Wraith for some batshit reasons
>the fact the game has few mechanics to support the intended playstyles like having restricted paradigms and old grogs who have a list of internal rules and expectations write it and off and tell you to RP it out

inb4 "go play awakening". I play the homebrew Mage Translation Guide that brings 2e Awakening to Ascension. Even that game has some darlings that need killing.
>>
File: 1781156786692759.png (2.44 MB, 1041x1600)
2.44 MB PNG
>>98962784
Oh and to preface this it's not WoD but it's a comic about humans losing to a zombie outbreak and vampires figuring out that they'll die of starvation once the humans are all wiped out. Has cool art.
>>
>>98961484
do gay guys ever get mad that most of the gay guys in the wod books are just really faggy? like there's not a cool gay guy.
>>
>>98962887
yeah i was disappointed that his husband wasn't a garou, the pairing seemed hotter in my head
>>
Is there a kindred/vampire term for degrees of violence that separate
>violence at mortals or otherwise not very threatening
and
>violence between kindred or other creatures that is much more likely to cause final death
?
>>
File: The Last Unicorn.png (181 KB, 461x433)
181 KB PNG
>>98953157
We need a unicorn splat.
>>
>>98962726
>Mages especially are considered the biggest monsters around.
Yes, Nephandi are a thing, we know.
>>
>>98961956
>the technocrats bringing back sabertooth bastet as a suburban teenage white boy
Care to explain, citizen?
>>
>>98963116
given that he got backlash so hard it reached into another reality and made white wolf cancel the novel series i don't think he can anymore
>>
>>98963116
>https://whitewolf.fandom.com/wiki/Call_to_Battle:_The_Saga_of_Jay_No-Name
>>
>>98962219
>so called Garou after losing the spiritual battle (ragebait)
No wonder they're not winning
>>
>>98962831
>A really, really evil mage that's not a Nephandus isn't that remarkably evil for Vampire standards.
A vampire isn't particularly evil by mage standards since it's like considering a deer evil. Vampires are cows to mages. They chew grass (drink blood) sideways.

Anyway. A Verbena would shit on a Tzimisce in terms of flesh horror degeneracies.
>>
I am owed sex by gangrel women
>>
>>98963280
A Verbena COULD shit on a Tzimisce in terms of flesh horror degeneracies, but only a Nephandi Verbena really would. A Vampire is a sapient being and thus capable of sinning as is shown by their humanity rating. Only a wight could be said to be absolved of sinning the way a non-sapient animal would.
>>
>>98962361
Lol what?
>>
>>98963287
What are you? A white woman and/or Garou?
>>
>>98963041
Isn't that just CtL?
>>
>>98963349
Nah, that's the bygones bestiary.
Sure you CAN build a unicorn with CtL with minimal effort but it will be a mostly normal human who becomes a unicorn rather than an actual animal.

Not sure why this feels like a big deal.
>>
>>98963368
nta. but i get you there is a difference between a inhuman character who has to either hide who and what they are. a character who becomes more human. a character who becomes inhuman and a character who has to balance a supernatural and mundane side

and different splats do mixes of these differently. but i am not familiar with the bygone bestiary (beside people having quoted dragon stats from it at me before) so would that character be fully playable?
>>
>>98963288
>but only a Nephandi Verbena really would
This is cope. A Traditions Verbena would Absolutely do it with the justification she's paying homage to the mother of monsters or something. That's before we get into "Horned God" bullshit.
The difference between a nephandus and one of the more fucked up tradition verbena is whether or not they went through the caul, there actions are indistinguishable otherwise.
>>
>>98963403
>would that character be fully playable?
Yeah, Bygones can be fully sentient and even those that aren't are still playable, even if the more animalistic ones are pretty boring to play IIRC.
>>
Growing ever tired of the substandard STs in PBP and the lack of games in my IRL table (I just moved), I have decided to dedicate time I should be using for unpacking, cleaning, or job hunting for designing my ideal standard for a VtM PbP server. Some thoughts as follows:

>Each IRL month equals a year, with each week equating roughly to the four seasons. This means each IRL year covers over a decade (with five years, were I so cursed, covering 60 years in game!) and if I were to be really frugal with time I could dedicate extra days beyond the standard 28 to special events and holidays.
>PvP would have a minimum number of mutually consented scenes over a course of multiple IRL months to represent the slow nature of the Jyhad. Your character would need to fear society enough to respect the whole "killing each other is really bad" social contract, no matter how badass they are.
>XP would be drastically slower, with vampires getting 2XP per IRL month and ghouls (and only ghouls, no revenants or mortals with numina) getting 3XP for being active IC at any point. If your character happened to be in a unique scene each week with at least 3 different players over the course of those minimum four scenes, you would get double the XP. Missing out a month of play would grant 1 XP.
>Due to the timeline, the fun powers that are character killers are now usable. Also due to the timeline, blood and willpower need tweaking. Vampires would spend 1 blood at the initiation of each unique scene (ghouls spend 1 blood at the end of the IRL month- failure means they lose their ghoul benefits), and all characters would regenerate 1 Willpower at the start of the IRL month.
>The tentative setting is NYC, due to the long timelines and fun activities I can operate in that setting's canon history.

Cont'd
>>
>>98963407
..What? I can only think you're baiting. A Verbena doesn't usually fleshcraft people into abominations, and the rest of the Verbena would probably fucking jump you for something so degenerate unless the target did something really fucking fucked up to justify this. A Tzimisce on the other hand does this shit for fun. The Horned God is just a fucking Pagan deity of life, fertility, hunt and so on so I don't see what your problem is with that. Similarly if you are non-consensually turning people into strange abominations and justifying it via some Mother of Monsters shit, you'd get a very, very dim view from your fellow mages. Probably to the point where they'd jump you.

And don't justify it with "a more fucked up Verbena", we are talking about averages here. Nobody cares about your 0.01% exception of a clinically insane Verbena that's fleshcrafting people when fucking 90% of tzimisce do this shit, get real.
>>
>>98963422
My big holdup is governing downtime activities (3 per IRL month, but I never want these to feel useless which mine always seemed to be) and backgrounds (I want to reign in the "I get a whole extra character sheet!" that ghouls seem to provide and I want to define exactly what contacts, allies, influence, etc are and do- likely during your downtime activities?). I also need to figure out other common pitfalls I'm setting up for myself before starting this endeavor.
>>
>>98963421
ah neat. gonna look into that book later then
>>
>>98963444
It's a neat book for WoD and useful for when you need something that's unrelated to the splats.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z0NgUhEs1R4
Genius the Transgression
>>
>>98963439
>A Verbena doesn't usually fleshcraft people into abominations
You’re straight up lying to yourself if you think having access to Life wouldn’t make such people think about all the fucked up things they could get up to — which is why the Tzimisce are so gross to begin with. Why WOULDN’T you play with the [insert ability to mold flesh like playdough here] power?
>>
>>98963439
Anon, both their traditionbooks have a section entirely dedicated to making permanent alterations using the Life sphere. They absolutely craft freakshit. Were the fuck do you think Chimera, Mantecores, Griffons, etc, Come from?
>>
>>98963294
Yeah, went exactly like that. Basically the former Ventrue primogen was worming its way into the Nazi movement since the start to get control of all of Germany. Adolf Hitler (who in our game is an ever growing True Faith user) and his crew got wise to the vampire shenanigans and are currently purging all kindred and their servants not allied with the Third Reich. Leon got scared about losing his power, also fumbled HARD his speech versus Hitler (1 vs 8 successes), and in desperation tried to kill the fuhrer.

Since Lyssa is currently inhabiting the body of a 15-16 year old she would probably receive some reward related to the Hitler youth for her “heroism”. That’s what ST said before I left but they might have changed plans. I don’t know. Also Lyssa (in her former life as Shark) received an autographed copy of a Mein Kampf, first 100 prints. This might play in their favour into becoming friends.

It was the head of the Brujah Council that helped us find that traitorous vampire. And you know how Brujah and Ventrue get along. Andromeda is feeling pretty proud of herself that someone responsible for the Salubri downfall met an horrific fate. I wasn’t there when it happened, but I saw her memes.
>>
>>98963572
I think that they are Bygones because they canonically are. Plus a Verbena creating some weird Chimera is not equivalent to what Tzimisce do. Doing weird freakshit stuff is not the point. It's active malice and disregard/contempt of others.
>>98963565
They COULD. Nobody is arguing that they can't. It's just that the AVERAGE Verbena won't turn you into a monstrosity for fun and experimentation. She's going to turn you into a toad if you mess with her, and that's pretty dickish even. A fairly "normal" Tzimisce will actively capture you to turn you into an abomination, not even as some sort of vengeance. Not just any abomination, but they specifically love turning humans into loyal, lobotomized pets that are nevertheless perpetually suffering. Other Tzimisce and Vampires find this more or less Okay. A normal Verbena Coven would not find this Okay. The Other Traditions would not find this Okay. This isn't equivalent. Thus the other argument: Even if you have an actual fleshcrafting horror Verbena, that is just a fairly average Tzimisce.

So the statement at the core of this "Mages especially are considered the biggest monsters around." is quite asinine.
>>
>>98963620
>Andromeda is feeling pretty proud of herself that someone responsible for the Salubri downfall met an horrific fate. I wasn’t there when it happened, but I saw her memes.

If I was a gambling man I would say the guy got torched or diablerized.

Tangential as hell but how have you been handling the personality bleed between the diablerized? (If I'm mistaken an they more separate characters let me know)
>>
>>98958830
honestly anon , you aren't being racist enough.

just make indians the metaphysical shit of an evil but also dead god , that want to super ruin everything.
thats metaphysical you are connecting an archetype.

indian the poop.
>>
>>98963663
I’m just wandering how he died. Catalina has the Brujah Council recruitment target, and its head is a serial diablerist that has nommed at least two or three different princes from different Russian cities. Did she offer the Ventrue to that guy? She also plans to sacrifice people to the Abyss, which would get her the benefits of a diablerie without the risks. Did she do that? Did Andromeda do something? I don’t know.

There is no personality bleed. Because we play with an all or nothing system (tried the normal way once, and it’s when Shark died). Either it’s 100% Shark or 100% the other guy. We flavour it as the soul being consumed/obliterated by the Wyrm living in Shark. Though it’s not impossible to free the souls with Thaumaturgy rituals. Possibly weakening Shark. Except that those are rare as fuck. We do say that what bleeds through is the knowledge. Like how this creature younger than most kindred knows occult stuff better than most neonates or elders. Or how Lyssa learned to read. Etc.
>>
My Hunter: the Vigil game this week was less eventful than the last few.
>Gina, Matheus and Robelle spent literally the entire session doing investigations
>Matheus and Robelle investigated the double list of workers
>The extra workers on the longer list were all on green cards, work visas, or illegal
>Meanwhile Gina looked into the Inspector Ernesto met with the day before his death
>Named Nathaniel Werther, he was also found dead the day before Ernesto was
>And whaddya know, his corpse also had no skin
>Gina also found his address at an apartment complex in South Palm Beach
>By the time she found all this out it was 9PM
>They decided to save going to the location for tomorrow
>They also decided to not share this info with the other Hunter cell since they don't want them charging in there
>meanwhile Oscar is out on his own little sidequest
>He follows the guy on the scooter to a house with a Camry covered in Hello Kitty stickers
>Worried that there may be more people with guns outside, he waits until the guy comes back out and nabs him
>Dude doesn't even fight back and gets carried into the back of Oscar's truck like a sack of potatoes
>Just then El Toro texts Oscar if he's seen the news about the stray shooter
>Oscar says that he caught the guy and is gonna turn him in to the police
>El Toro asks him to drop him off at the salvage yard instead
>Oscar accepts and takes him there
>When he arrives, only the mysterious woman from before is there
>Not even other gangsters
>She has him bring the man into a room with ritual circles and lit candles on the floor
>she takes one look at the man and sighs with disappointment
>"You can take him; he's not my problem anymore"
>Oscar, confused, starts asking her questions
>She won't answer any of them, saying that "Truth begets truth"
>Oscar decides to tell her about the encounter with the Skin-thieves at Rachel's
>Satisfied, she says she will answer one question of his truthfully
>Oscar asks why El Toro wanted this guy
1/2
>>
>"El Toro thought that this guy might've been possessed by a murder spirit"
>Oscar, still confused, asks for her name
>She refuses, once again saying that "truth begets truth"
>He insists, saying that he can't continue referring to her as "weird bathroom lady"
>She relents and shares a moniker: El Estoque
>Satisfied, Oscar leaves with the stray killer and takes him to the police
2/2
The apartment complex they want to investigate is also owned by Tequesta Coast Management, which means that WPQS will also be acting as security there. I'm sure the next session is bound to be more eventful than this session was.
>>
>>98963661
>I think that they are Bygones because they canonically are
Anon, Bygone is a catch all term for anything supernatural that gets affected by concensus.
Living Mage creations are under that category.
Fucking Changelings and Wraiths are technically bygones since they both get hit by concensus.
>Plus a Verbena creating some weird Chimera is not equivalent to what Tzimisce do.
This is cope and you know it.
>>
>>98962565
Even thinking that these aren't niche, all of these are mediocre
>Woof game has one game with excellent presentation and bad story and one game with bad presentation and slightly better writing
>New York has exactly 1 good game, one bad game, and a mediocre game. Great art, but the last uses AI
>The other vamp VN is new in a niche IP without much fanfare or advertisement

VNs by their nature will never be high concurrent players, but WoD VNs are for the most part unambitious or not well directed, though few VNs are.
>>
>>98963041
Why need a Unicorn splat, when the Arts of Metamorphosis and Spring can already do anything a Unicorn can do, traveller?
>>
>>98962784
>>98962883
Hell, you should read Crossed. Now THAT’s a comic!
>>
>>98963783
>Bygones are a catchall term for what gets affected by Consensus, living mage creations are under that category
Kind of but not really. In the context of this argument Gryphons, Manticores and so on - they are not necessarily things Verbena create. Same with changelings.. And Changelings absolutely aren't Bygones by any classification.
>This is cope and you know it.
Explain to me how hypothetically creating a Griffon is the same as magic-lobotomizing a human being and turning him into some sort of grotesque blood tap for your own enjoyment. What's that, Verbena don't really (statistically, on average) do the latter, whilst Tzimisce do? Curious. Not all body alterations are made equal, and the average Tzimisce will be far happier to create something grotesque, inflict suffering and callously accept human misery for literally no purpose.

Are you REALLY saying that a Verbena giving their black cat wings is the same as a Tzimisce turning a human into a Szlachta? Because these two are about the average use of Body Alteration from both sides.
>>
>>98963736
>>98963738
Set-up sessions happen now and again, and pacing generally improves as the PCs get more comfortable with themselves and others. You seem to have a lot of split up segments.

Have your Hunters actually bagged any supernaturals, or are they more the paranormal investigator types?
>>
>>98963009
Can't you just say lethal force?
>>
File: wod vozhd.png (477 KB, 663x806)
477 KB PNG
>>98963783
>>98963565
>>98963572
>>98963407
>>98963280
>>98963280
>>98962726
>A Verbena mage with Life 5 could technically do all sorts of hideous things that are worse than anything that a Tzimisce elder could ever do with Vicissitude, therefore your average Verbena must be more fucked up than the Tzimisce, even though there is no canon example of the Verbena ever using the Life Sphere to make anything half as demented as a vozhd. Manticores and chimerae could have theoretically be made by a Verbena therefore I am going to assume that they absolutely must have been made by the Verbena, and I am going to assume that their creation must have been far more nightmarish than anything that Vicissitude could ever do, even though Life 5 could be used to create such a creature without harming anyone or anything that already exists in the process, if these creatures were even made using Life 5 at all, which isn't actual canon.
Unless people can provide evidence from a book that the Verbena do anything half as twisted as creating armies of humans fused together into tortured abominations who are enslaved by their addiction to the blood of the monsters who transformed them, I call bullshit on 'the Verbena are way worse than the Tzimisce.' Human sacrifice might be a part of their paradigm, but that still isn't even a tenth as insane as the shit that the Tzimisce do to make vozhd.
>>
>>98964197
The average Verbena is a woman, and also celtic aka BRITISH. I rest my case.
>>
November is a dark, cold, and wet month. It saps my energy.
Little writing done.
>>
>>98964197
just wanna say that most of the hype vicissitude gets is Graft Life to Life and most vicissitude powers can't even do that shit kek. Graft Life to Life was a later addition too I think?

Verbena CAN do something more twisted than Tzimisice, undeniably, because of how the Life Sphere works. But unless they're Barabbi, a Verbena master is sooner going to turn you into a tree and let woodpeckers and other termites infest you than the nasty stuff Tzimisce can do. Barabbi Verbena on the other hand? Yeah, they're worse than Tzimisce, because Nephandi in general are worse than even the worst vampire.
>>
File: s1i1.png (523 KB, 736x823)
523 KB PNG
As somebody doing a mage campaign, mages are the ultimate batman preptime argument. Assuming they succeed their arete roll, Assuming they don't get paradox backlashed. Assuming they don't get surprised by a guy with a shotgun who blows their head off.
Mages are essentially potential man the splat. If everything goes right yeah mages are the most powerful. There's so many chances for it to go all wrong though lol.
>>
>>98964332
Did someone try to go full bunker-mage and get punished for it?
>>
>>98964332
Yeah, as a long time dedicated magefag, most people are assuming long ritual extended rolls from miles away.

Arete margins are so small. And you are rarely ever going to be able to increase the dice pool. Willpower works, and there's a certain merit in the Spirit Ways book that adds a single die as well. The dice pools are just too small really.
>>
>>98964360
Nah, more just seeing my players interact with the game and how arete and how 1s work in wod in general means there's not an unlikely chance of botching
>>98964361
I should give that to my players as a reward for finishing another story or two given how fucky rolls can get. Lmao.
>>
>>98964378
Why are they casting any magic that is remotely risky as a non-ritual and outside of their sanctums? Are they retarded?
>>
>>98964417
Because it's cool.
>>
>>98964438
Tell me that they at least ritually buffed themselves so they're good to go for the next six months.
>>
>>98964481
They're baby magi right now so I'm softballing them. Decently strong though, arete 2 and arete 3s
>>
>>98964542
That's enough to ritually buff themselves for the six months. Why haven't they done it yet?
>>
>>98964332
IF you give a mage chance to prepare, then Arete rolls, Paradox and even Shotguns are super trivial. So you CAN assume those. It's when they don't. Depending on how degenerate they are with rituals, the average mage ranges from "Dude in a gay little Robe" to "Garou except way worse" in combat dangerlevel.
>>
>>98964553
They don't know it like IC yet. As I said they're starters one of who's mentor is asking them to do a favor to meet up with the traditions
>>
>>98964580
Paradigm and knowledge doesn't prohibit a mage from doing anything. If they have the Spheres and the Arete, they can do it. There's no RAW anywhere saying that they need to "know it" to do it.
>>
>>98964599
RAW also lets the ST do whatever the fuck they want. It's not completely unreasonable so I think Anon is completely within their rights. Mage is basically all homerules anyways.
>>
>>98964605
So you're not actually playing Mage, you're just a bunch of retards playing make-believe.
Because if you were actually playing Mage, straight out of character creation, there's nothing stopping your players from effectively permanently giving themselves -3 difficulty on all rolls and +3 difficulty to enemies for anything that they want to do to them.
>>
>>98964685
>you're just a bunch of retards playing make-believe
That's what Mages are, yes.
>>
>>98964698
Truth nuke
>>
>>98964685
..So you're saying any houserules in a highly broken gamesystem makes you play not-mage and instead what? A made up system? I could maybe understand this in some sort of Tourneyfag game, like a wargame or a TCG.

But in fucking mage? A game about making up your own fucking spells and shit? A game about being cool with your Paradigm and not a powergaming retard lest you shit all over the table? A game whose very rulesystem doesn't even present a cohesive fucking logic?

And a rule this fucking milquetoast which is arguably supported by the fiction, if not RAW?
>>
>>98964751
Yes, Mage is retarded, but so are your players for not using the RAW to their advantage and so are you for disallowing your players from using RAW.
>>
>>98964751
He’s a mage powergamer
Can you imagine anything so silly? A MAGE powergamer. That’s like being an offensive coordinator for a Calvinball team
>>
How do I turn into a big fucking dragon in
>Masquerade
and
>Requiem

Yes I know Werewolf has dragons in it, I just wanna know about these two vampire games.
>>
>>98964580
>>98964599
Is this another episode where people are pretending like paradigm is some set hard thing that restricts spheres and abilities rather than aesthetics?

Only game that ever blanket restricted things on paradigm was...Dark Ages Mage, which is a game no one here is playing except me and the two hapless retards I roped in to play it.
>>
>>98964685
how common are unironic people like this IRL I'm scared enough to play with other people as-is
>>
>>98964805
Yeah, this retard is forcing his players to limit what their characters cast based on their "knowledge."
>>
>>98964816
I wouldn't even necessarily be opposed to this, but Mage the Ascension's system is just not interested in it. Ars Magica has systems and detail on it, MtA doesn't, so restricting players to this extent just feels like speedbumps.
>>
>>98964763
So you acknowledge that the rules are retarded, but are against the ST making them more reasonable or introducing chronicle specific elements.. But you are pro the players abusing the system in opposition of the intended playstyle..?

Like, sure, you can have your mages buffing themselves with 20 different rituals that last months and nothing in M20 actually prevents this. But it's a really, really degenerate tactic that is a borderline exploit ever since the concentration rules were hastily rewritten without any comprehension of the consequences.

And the fiction of the game completely supports this sort of thing, the rules simply do not mention it. Probably because the M20 Corebooks pages were getting tight after the 16th tirade about random nonsense.
>>
>>98964832
Players have no reason to not exploit the game for the maximum possible power output, even if the means of doing so are retarded, and the ST is an asshole for forcibly applying limits.
>>
>>98964840
https://youtu.be/yEbdLlxqtyE?si=BDVLiRQnhDWyAHGC&t=9
>>
>>98964840
A retarded take with a kernel of truth. This reminds me of the argument a few threads ago about the RAW text of Mage and how powerful it makes mages but divorced of the understanding of analyzing a RAW text vs playing an actual chronicle.
>>
This has to be a troll. It is not impossible to find an autist with powergaming fixation, especially itt, but "players has no reason not to exploit the system" takes it too far.
>>
>>98964840
The ST is never the asshole for telling you not to be a munchkin, especially in a game like MtAs
>>
>>98964799
>Masquerade
Vicissitude 9 - The Last Dracul, it's in the Core Rulebook for Vampire the Dark Ages 20th Anniversary
>>
>>98964858
>"players has no reason not to exploit the system" takes it too far.
Fair enough, even if I understand that sentiment given how WW designs the character creation.

You could have a character that best represents the concept you have in mind but of you do that you are going to be stuck with those choices for a long time while the guy that min maxed gets to bolt on the fluff with XP 10 times faster.
>>
>>98964197
That one magefag who brags about turning himself into a giant tapeworm to thread through werewolves “like a beaded necklace” would like a word with you
>>
>>98964858
What a load of cope
Fuck off
>>
>>98964937
What book, what page?
>>
>>98963966
I like the comic storytimes posted on /co/ for these things. It's very neat
>>
>>98964937
Is this a human-centipede esque situation or am I reading this wrongly
>>
>>98964981
He's talking about a mage transforming into a giant tapeworm, going up a werewolf's ass and crawling so far through the werewolf's intestines that he comes out of the werewolf's mouth.
>>
>>98964983
To a dozen werewolves at a time. As a statement of art. Beautiful. Brave.
>>
>>98964983
Why are wizards like this
>>
>>98965001
It's just a 4chan poster's wild fantasy.
>>
Always liked the hypothetical scenario of a werewolf getting molested by a Life mage tbqh
>>
>>98965028
“Oh a lost puppy dog. I should return it to its owner…”.
>>
>>98965030
I’m reminded of those stories of retarded Americans thinking coyotes on the side of the road are lost dogs and end up bringing them to confused vets
>>
>>98965037
To be fair coyotes are very cute
>>
>>98965037
>"Get off my ridge, you, Vietcong bastard!"
>>98965043
>>
>>98965050
Kek
>>
The Twilight guy is the new Bond bros
>>
>>98964937
the deplorable mage powergamer vs the chad creative thinker
>>
>>98965072
at least he's white
>>
>>98964685
>effectively permanently giving themselves -3 difficulty on all rolls and +3 difficulty to enemies for anything that they want to do to them.
The +/-3 limit only applies to Arete rolls. Everything else can be stacked until you roll everything at difficulty 2.
>>
>>98964863
>munchkin
Anon, that's a powergamer, not a munchkin.
Munchkins are players that outright break the rules whenever it favors them. They're the little shits that try to bring loaded dice, lie about their rolls, lie about their character sheet, etc, the moment they think you aren't looking.
Powergamers are a different kind of annoying. They autistically maximize numbers at the expense of everything the game was mean for. They're the fuckers that go into a dungeon crawler and turn it into a borked tower defense game because of obscure base-building rules in a book no one else bought.
>>
>>98964983
>All this because a Garou denied them sex once
Hermetics are not reasonable people
>>
>>98964799
In masquerade you need Vicissitude 7.

In Requiem you need to find and eat one when you have Protean 3. If you can't do that eat an alligator and use Protean 4 to get wings like the world's most scuffed pterodactyl.
>>
>>98965122
A single source of modification only providing up to +/-3 is a common rule, though there's nothing saying that it applies to every single modifier.
It's also one of those "good luck finding an ST who will let you successfully cast a single magical spell that reduces every single roll you make to Difficulty 2 for a six month duration at Arete 3" things.
>>
>>98964038
They’ve mostly been paranormal investigators for now. When it comes to combat I don’t want to flatten them with something supernatural so I’m keeping it mortal v. mortal for now, hence the WPQS goons. Hunter always seemed like a “slow burn punctuated by quick and violent action” kind of game, and my players are coming off of D&D 5e, so they’re getting a bit antsy…? I’ll probably have something happen next session.
As for the split up segments, most of them aren’t initiated by me! They’ll split for investigation stuff, then gather together to execute their plans all on their own. I wanted to have their characters feel individual yet cohesive as a cell, and I think my split intro for the first session really helped set that sort of tone.
>>
>>98965028
Werewolves are hand-crafted to be molested by sidhe.
>>
>>98964799
For requiem you can buy a dragon at a goblin market as a 5 dot merit, then eat it to gain it's body as a protheion option. Alternatively you can get funky with Scales and Coils if you're in the Ordo and have no inhibitions.
>>
>>98963141
>Progenitor
Nevermind, this is within what our intelligence reports predict when it comes to their animal experimentation. At least it wasn't an Iterator.
>>
Mallavian gym twinks taking selfies of themselves (and their ripped hallucinations) at the gym
>>
>>98965521
Like a Jojo stand?
>>
>>98965562
Yes
>>
>>98964840
players have to act in-character and temper their expectations to what their character knows
only a paranoid schizo hermeric would have a bunch of wards on themselves but reasonably, the moment a character sees vampires shooting laser beams, they reasonably should be protecting themselves

jumpchain needs to stay in their containment general
>>
>>98965621
Stop trying to impose retarded limitations that don't exist in RAW. A mage can do anything that their Spheres and Arete allow them to do. No one cares about paradigm shit.
>>
>>98965636
raw a mage's isnt even aware they can go beyond their limitations until they have enough arete
you have to roleplay not having a correct view of reality, sorry
>>
I am a mage
You are a vampire
I AM the superior life form
I blink, you die
>>
nobody post the rules where it explicitly states that seekings and gaining arete are a matter of ST fiat
>>
I am a werewolf
You are a vampire
You ARE my knot sleeve
I breed you, you moan
>>
>>98965670
we have struck gold
paradox hire this man!
>>
>>98964127
I could but I was wondering if there was something sexier or more formal and dramatic like a lot of their vocabulary.
Rolling around words like terminus or casus belli, looking for a medieval term for 'total war'.
Maybe
>True Violence
sort of implying everything mortals are up to is a bit of a joke or a lie, ties in with the masquerade concept.
>>
>>98965679
If you absolutely need a Latin word for spilling blood, gore, and slaughter you could use cruor.
>medieval term for 'total war'.
The thing is the phrase total war started during WWI, before that Clausewitz had absoluter Krieg.
I prefer a third option: bellum universale.
>True Violence
Vera violentia? I still like cruor better, it's visceral, grim.

You also have the tradition of Destruction, which Cammies forbid, sooooo attempted Destruction? I would just call it conatus in Latin, literally attempt, without the murder/destruction, or cruor conatus, attempted bloodshed/slaughter.
>>
>>98965704
>The thing is the phrase total war started during WWI, before that Clausewitz had absoluter Krieg.
I was looking at that too and figure there must have been some sort of papal decree about certain kinds of marauding being bad compared to regular levels of pillage.
Cruor is good, doesn't even have to be 'real' latin, pseudolatin is workable. Crux even as a wordplay on it being the central and difficult problem and a cross is good.
I think the destruction part would be useful to describe violence not condoned by the prince, I was more thinking a way to describe it as 'shit got real' or serious violence between vampires rather than play violence with mortals.
>>
File: vs2x5ss4ofte1.jpg (123 KB, 640x644)
123 KB JPG
>glance back in thread
>shitstorm
I should mention my PLAYERS also didn't know to do that and they literally found a node after killing a nephandi like a session or two ago so they wouldn't have had a safe place to ritual cast regardless so the entire thing is moot regardless?
>>
>>98965670
Isnt it a metis wyrm compulsion to fuck corpses?
>>
>>98965813
Why did none of them take Sanctum?
>>
>>98965846
Because it is a game about baby bizarre learning to become badass magi???
>>
>>98965858
They can still do that. Why did none of them take Sanctum to have somewhere they can safely make all of their magic coincidental?
>>
>>98965907
Because I believe making players earn shit is more interesting when they can feel the value of having something versus not having it?
>>
>>98965193
Can you do the same thing (Requiem) in Masquerade with Abombwe?
>>
Is there anything you've incorporated in your games from urban fantasy games other than oWoD/CofD? Did you find anything worth stealing?
>>
>>98965923
By RAW they don't need to earn anything. You're prohibiting them from taking a gameplay option that is a valid and optimal part of standard Ascension gameplay. It's bullshit.
>>
>>98966103
oh no his players were allowed to use freebie points on other shit during creation how horrible
>>
>>98966132
It's tyrannical control freak behaviour to bring down the ban hammer on anything that you consider too optimal for the players. A good ST would be able to handle players with Sanctums, instead of prohibiting them.
>>
File: 1793653295583512.png (524 KB, 960x720)
524 KB PNG
>>98966103
Actually the book says the ST determines what merits, backgrounds and shit are available to your character one, two you aren't welcome at my table if you're gonna be an autistic and shit yourself at the idea of not getting a piece of candy now when I'll get you a bag of candy later lmao.
>>
>>98966171
The game is meant to be played according to what's written in the book, otherwise the book wouldn't have been written that way. Of course the ST can determine whatever they want, but they're deviating from the intended style of play by making decisions contrary to the book, in which case they're making it apparent that they're not suitable STs for Mage.
>>
>>98966185
Holy shit get a grip man, it's not DND it is a white wolf game. Nobody ASKED for Sanctum at character creation one, two i was willing to give a character a node who dropped out before deciding it would be a plot thing two, three you don't always need to be optimal otherwise every vampire game would be celerity and protean or tremere lmao
>>
at this point it feels very safe to assume it's fishing for replies, whether it be a brit/brit-adjacent or a bot
>>
>>98966208
I give people benefit of the doubt
>>
>>98966204
Stormwind fallacy. Roleplaying is never a reason to not play an optimal character.
>>
>>98966227
I see why Hedgefag used to bully retards like you. Crawl back to DaveBs discord
>>
File: 1792625989883656.webm (2.71 MB, 1400x1080)
2.71 MB
2.71 MB WEBM
>>98966227
Bro this is world of darkness not dnd, it isn't that type of game.
>>
>>98966357
Stormwind fallacy applies to all games. Roleplaying is never a reason to not play an optimal character, when a character always has every reason to be optimal from an in-character point of view. A mage has no reason to not establish a Sanctum from which they can safely perform their magic, when that is the most optimal course of action.
>>
>>98966389
They are doing that???? Theyre literally trying to get into the traditions? I think you arent paying attention to literally anything I've said.
>>
>>98966083
I routinely toy with directly porting over Lovecraft creatures (kinda counts because of the CoC game), but I never quite pull the trigger on that one because even with very selective cross-splat, we really don't need to fuck up the cosmology even worse. Don't want things to be too busy.

Instead, I tend to take very strong inspiration from other urban fantasy and horror works. Less so games (at least tabletop ones), because I haven't really read Cult or Unknown Armies. I liked WoD/CofD enough to not really look for alternatives.
>>
>>98965958
Kinda, you would need a more lenient ST than usual because they don't have rules for wings for some reason.
>>
>>98965266
>A single source of modification only providing up to +/-3 is a common rule
In mage only games sure, but that houserule is unusable in crossover. It breaks multiple core powers in other splats.
>>
>>98966427
i mean you can just use the nephandi who worship eldritch horrors and youre encouraged to steal from CoC if you wanna have a Lovecraftian type scenario.
>>
>>98966460
I know. Issue is I don't really fuck with Ascension and I got that kind of autism where I go back and forth on if I should just shrug my shoulders as to where the eldritch horrors come from.
>>
>>98966459
Crossover is broken and unusable fullstop.
>>
>>98966475
there's always the Lasombra's Abyss bullshit then and Daimonion, hell even Pentex and Wyrm cults can sorta have that lovecraftian vibe.
>>
>>98966486
Yeah, I know. Idigam from Forsaken are also fairly eldritch. It just feels weird to cannibalize Lovecraft's stuff outright, you need to divvy it up between a half dozen different things.
>>
>>98966479
Only with mage included. Crossover is honestly all right if you remove the one splat that shits on everything elses themes.
Other splsts are even neatly categorized in the ways groups already split up roles. Vampires are the party Face, Werewolves are muscle, Wraith are the Sneaks, Changelings are the squishy caster, Mummies are the Crafter/Healbots, etc.
Mages are the only splat that fucks this up.
>>
>>98966525
>Mages are the only splat that fucks this up.
You mean as players? Mages make fucking amazing antagonists. You can throw literally anything at the party and the technocracy is the perfect reason for why all the player splats can exist without magic becoming public. It's one thing to say the local elder vampires are controlling legacy media to try covering things up, but its another to say that the fucking demigod illuminati will Nuke any unfixable masquerade breaches from orbital, Reset the timeline to before that poor bastard made the biggest mistake of his life, and then release a mind virus that deletes any evidence he ever existed from any memories or written words.
God I miss 2e Mage.
>>
>>98966525
Not really. Clashing themes, vastly different power levels in different areas, entire aspects of different games that the other splats won't have access to, and rules conflicts means that crossover is a garbage fire.
>>
>>98966552
>God I miss 2e Mage.
Sorry, sweetie, now every mage has to ponder on why they used to be le bad and elitist while Elon musk in winning (just like IRL, totally relatable xister!) the ascension war.
I can't imagine how shit M6 will be. Why can't Control come back and fix this clusterfuck?
>>
>>98965813
Hey, I started prozac recently. It feels good to be seen :)
>>
>>98966459
As in, it is a common rule for a lot of modifiers, though there's nothing saying that it's universal. Modifiers that alter a roll by more than +/-3 are extremely rare, with lots of instances of wording like:
>up to a total reduction of -3
>reduce the difficulty of a roll by up to -3
>up to a maximum reduction of -3
>up to the usual modifier of +3
And this is for non-Arete rolls.
>>
>>98966552
>Nuke any unfixable masquerade breaches from orbital, Reset the timeline to before that poor bastard made the biggest mistake of his life, and then release a mind virus that deletes any evidence he ever existed from any memories or written words.
>God I miss 2e Mage.
I really have to question wtf the writers of Revised were smoking, and said substance didn't have more bans than enriched uranium smuggling.
>>
>>98966570
Can I ask you something?
Why do you seem to love him so much?
>>
File: Power stance.jpg (116 KB, 960x960)
116 KB JPG
>>98966630
I'm gay? Are you fucking retarded or something???
>>
>>98964858
I'm pretty sure it's the same 13-year-old who used to do the 'werewolf players are thin-skinned' bit.
>>
>>98966630
i don't think he is. he is just making fun of the fact that in m20 the technocracy is amde so weak they can't swing a election in the US away from trump while it's usually accepted that elon did swing a election towards trump once

which would make elon more influential in the US than the entire technocracy
>>
>>98966440
Well the level 4-5 power technically allows you to transform into a dragon. But you get none of the supernatural powers it has.
>>
>>98966804
Rather than go with a weak Technocracy, I prefer a Technocracy whose leadership has gone full Nephandi and is in the process of completely subverting civilisation to go full throttle towards an apocalypse scenario.
>>
I personally like to write factions this way.
>The Technocracy and Traditions are way in over their heads and delusional about how much influence they truly have
>The Anarchs are scum suckers who want the benefits of the Camarilla but none of the responsibilities
>>
>>98966804
Revised was the mage version of 9/11 for both sides.
>>
File: Ecstatic hubris.jpg (802 KB, 1406x678)
802 KB JPG
I AM A SEX SLAVE FOR VAMPIRES I AM A BLOOD DOLL I LOVE FANGS IN ME I GIVE DIVINATIONS IN EXCHANGE FOR BEING BITTEN OH GOD I LOVE USING SPHERES TO PLEASURE MY DOMITOR
>>
>>98966924
based chorister has the right idea, though the ecstatic is based for trying yet cringe for failing
>>
>>98966910
Let's expand on that.
>Camarilla don't control governments in any shape or form, they're just delusional retards who have paid off a few state politicians and precincts at the very most
>The Sabbat are so retarded that they're on the verge of extinction at all times and the only thing keeping them from burning out are the constant mass embraces
>Pentex's retarded tactic of prioritising environmental destruction over making profit means that its subsidiaries are constantly be bought up by other corporations who manage them more intelligently
>>
>>98966924
i thought that was more of a hollow one thing

>Hollow Ones who traffic with vampires are nicknamed Blood Bags by their peers. Surprisingly, Blood Bags are rarely actual ghouls but often serve as part of a vampire’s herd. The life of a typical Blood Bag is rarely long. To hang with vampires, you really have to be a combination of crazy, suicidal and a complete adrenaline junky and have to possess nerves of steel. Despite all of these obvious flaws, some goth definitions of cool are just that stubborn. A surprisingly high number of none-too-experienced Hollow Ones learn a few tricks they think might be useful to a vampire, such as minor control over fire or warding from sunlight. They then trek off into the night, heading for Los Angeles, New York or Mexico City — just like in the movies — to find a vampire friend. Most Blood Bag wannabes are never seen again. A small number of them actually survive… for a while
>>
>>98966950
kinda different. most mages like in anon's pic think that they are the ubersplat and can easily push around other splats and then sometimes find out why they shouldn't fuck around with out studying said splat and preparing well for what they bring on the table

hollow ones meanwhile really want to be friends with splats in part because of the gothic stuff and in part because they are so disgusted by the masses and other mages, but then tend to find out that these guys are considered monsters for a reason
>>
>>98966950
That's so hot. Imagine how good it feels to get headpats from your master and live in their haven doing magic for them.
>>
>>98966944
Actually I do this.
>Camarilla are better than the Anarchs
>Sabbat are also better than the Anarchs
>Both due to having an actual structure with real organizational power behind it
>Pentex are terrifyingly dangerous and tend to exploit supernatural beings for shit
>>
>>98966995
So you empower the factions that you like and turn the factions that you dislike into jokes?
>>
>>98966944
This is demonstrably untrue. Pentex is powerful enough to make the Technocracy its bitch and owns the United States and India. So long as Late Stage Capitalism thrives Pentex and the Camarilla rule all. The only real danger Pentex has is when the Camarilla gets too many complaints from its constituents that the kine taste like shit from all the environmental and spiritual pollution.
>>
>>98967010
Nah, appeasing shareholders and generating revenue comes first and foremost. Any company that puts destroying the planet before those things would collapse under its own weight in under a year.
>>
File: 1527361521388.gif (3.24 MB, 181x144)
3.24 MB GIF
>>98967017
Destroying the planet IS profitable nigger. What's going to happen IRL is corporations will keep getting richer while the proles will be driven insane, living in tents and eating cardboard under constant threat of being fired, arrested or killed by police. Pentex is king.
>>
File: 1793076546278393.png (157 KB, 529x432)
157 KB PNG
>>98967010
>Pentex is powerful enough to make the Technocracy its bitch and owns the United States and India
>>
>>98966919
>9/11
Nah, 9/11 didn't really do shit to the US as an economic or military power.
Revised was more like their version being on the business end of a decapitation strike like a few middle eastern countries have gotten. The leadership is gone, the strongest military units are gone, and what's left has fractured and started following their own retarded directives, which include fighting each other as much as fighting the actual enemy.
>>
>>98967024
Priorities, anon. Even if it is profitable, putting environmental destruction before revenue generation equals a dead company.
>>
>>98967024
It is not profitable to destroy the planet, that is a mere side-effect. If destroying the planet is the goal, and money is a means to an end, then it is Pentex. If making money/generating value is the goal, and destroying the planet is a means to an end then you're thinking about the syndicate technocracy corp.
>>
>>98967030
I mean that as more of a mass tragedy that shakes up the current order and causes long-term side effects but yes, revised did shake things up (for the worse).
>>
File: Technocracy vs Pentex.jpg (207 KB, 640x415)
207 KB JPG
>>98967028
>NuWoD says the Technocracy is fighting Pentex openly now.
>Pentex is more powerful than ever while the Technocracy jobs to Donald Trump and Elon Musk.
TASTE THE WYRM BITCH
>>
>>98967050
>NuWoD says the Technocracy is fighting Pentex openly now.
Book and page citation?
>>
File: Deus Vult.jpg (27 KB, 399x501)
27 KB JPG
>>98966950
>>98966984
I'm genuinely amazed by how cucked some anons are with zero irony.
Put the Leeches to the fucking Pyre.
Blast the Werebitches with Blessed Silver Buckshot.
Drown the ghosts in Holy Water.
Throw the Otherkin into Cold Iron Maidens
PUT DEMONS TO THE SWORD IN THE NAME OF THE LORD!

...Mummies are cool though. We can hang out.
>>
>>98967052
Technocracy Revised and Reloaded
>We totally found out about Pentex and we're the good guys now so we have absolutely NOTHING to do with anything bad coming from modernity that's ALL Pentex we're totally fighting them no-PENTEX-SAMA NO PLEASE NOT THERE NEIL DE GRASS TYSON SAVE ME AIEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
>>98967064
More like the syndicate found out that pentex absorbed their r&d department and are now trying to cover up the fact
>>
>>98967050
Pentex is more powerful than ever..? How? Compared to the 1990s Environmental Consciousness in Business has gone up thousands of percent.
>>98967064
..? Pentex is a Megacorporation, not a political institution. Pentex is blamed for about 0% of modern politics, they are a complete non-sequitor. Especially to the Technocracy, who basically does not as a whole know about Pentex so they could not be blaming Pentex for their failings..? Also Revised and Reloaded isn't NuWoD what are you schizobabbling about? It's also not what those books says on the topic of Pentex vs Technocracy at all.
>>
File: 1759113180484153.png (4 KB, 500x1350)
4 KB PNG
>>98967062
>...Mummies are cool though
You're one of them, aren't you? The Lord was pretty clear when it comes to dealing with satan and his minions.
>>
>>98967064
Technocracy Revised is not a book that exists. Technocracy Reloaded does not contain that quote or anything resembling it, it only has the SISD investigating and covering up the disappearance of the SPD. There is zero conflict with Pentex.
>>
>>98966924
She looks about as huge as Lady Dimitrescu lol
>>
Guys, I think it's just a new form of bait. Don't give him the (You)s
>>
>>98967005
I don't. I just do the thing that makes the story fun.
>>
>>98967099
What's fun about a competent Camarilla and Sabbat? Watching those retards trip over themselves would be hilarious.
>>
i am re-reading dtf right now and it's kinda funny how it goes against the revised trend of making the stories bleaker and smaller

the books especially the last chapter of house of the fallen pretty much scream at you to not limit your game to a single city because demons can talk over planetary distances with a base template ability and build portal networks so you can sword fight werewolves in sweden and pick up artefacts in baghdad in the same session and then go to a alternative dimension who's only entrace is at the buttom of a now considered fictional sunken continent (lemuria) or chill in the largest mountain that ever existed which is now in someone's briefcase etc

mastery is also meant to be as broken as it's ingame as earthbound destroying cities in another country is actually mentioned in the text

so what was the problem with other splats not being street level?
>>
Watching James Bond: License to Kill
Currently at the bar scene and I’m surprised… 3.50 USD FOR TWO BEERS? Nowadays it’s like over three times the price for a single bottle.
>>
>>98967081
I love how Mage is the game that turns everyone into an optimist before they go back into the real world and see articles of forests getting wiped out for data centers and Trump legalizing the hunting of endangered species to drive them into extinction. Defending the Technocracy is synonymous with people defending liberalism IRL where you have to argue nothing is wrong. It's uncanny the brain damage Mage can give people.
>>
>>98967122
I am not an optimist, merely somebody who is not at all moved by sensationalism. I can look at actual, real data and trends instead of crying and shitting my pants about how things used to be so much better in some vaguely defined way x years ago.

Forests are always cut down for factories, forests are also always replanted for various things. This was no different in the 90s. If I look at actual data, I can see it was worse in the 90s.
>>
>>98966227
>Roleplaying is never a reason to not play an optimal character.
what?
what is even the logic in this.

what if you are playing the role of a dumbass who is weak.
>>
>>98967084
>Uses a satanic cross
Nephandi-anon, you weren't even Trying to be subtle with your lies this time were you?
Anyone who read The Book knows that converting and guiding the lost, but well meaning heathen is rightious. Satan isn't simply those that don't follow The Word, for he often comes quoting passages of The Book itself to wesponize with his lies.

Now begone minion of the adversary. Yee who has sold their soul is but chaffe.
>>
>>98967122
Honestly, Mage makes a lot more sense in the 2020s, because it has become apparent that there is no longer any shared culture or reality. Even facts are meaningless, as objectively true data can be twisted to represent any number of completely different subjective interpretations, depending on the framing and what it supposedly correlates with. Truth no longer exists, the world works the way people believes it works, and the only interpretation of the world that really matters is the one backed by the people with the most resources.
>>
>>98967135
One, you're an asshole for forcing your group to play with a suboptimal party member.
Two, even the dumbass who is weak will always strive to make optimal choices depending on their circumstances. Even the dumbass who is weak can see the benefits of a Sanctum, for example.
>>
>>98967098
Can I has (You)s instead? I-I'll do a little dance for them!
>>
>>98967132
>Ummm if we look at the stats the GDP is still up
We'll find out that food is being turned into fake garbage due to shrinkflation and people being dependent on it. People having to work harder and being more anxious over being fired no matter how hard they work while they're managed by useless parasites who steal their wages and offload expenses onto the government through taxation and inflation. This is paired with utilities being raised by things like data centers and corporate greed realizing they can get away with it. Workers and customers have no leverage to argue for themselves anymore. Meanwhile every person is even more deranged because they can't live up to the expectations of society and are constant under threat of their entire sense of self dissolving if they can't bully others. And while consuming AI slop that gets even more meaningless living in fantasy worlds orchestrated by a tech cartel based out of Israel.

But go ahead, tell us everything's fine and that Kamala Harris will save us or something like Technocrat simps do. You should say the line where colonization was worth it to invent HRT for third worlders too.
>>
>>98967145
>One, you're an asshole for forcing your group to play with a suboptimal party member.
thats different , although I see that. you must vibe out how usefull you will be to not be dead wieght , even then you can be usefull for something that the party needs while being suboptimal in other parts.


Two, even the dumbass who is weak will always strive to make optimal choices depending on their circumstances. Even the dumbass who is weak can see the benefits of a Sanctum, for example.
not if they can't see the optimal choices , someone having different priorities and as such making different optimisations is part of the fun in roleplay.
you can absolutly bend this rule if it would cause problems , but why destroy it?
>>
>>98967147
(you)
>>
>>98967175
If you're playing a character so retarded that they are incapable of determining what is a useful course of action, you are intentionally playing a character who is dead weight on your group and you should feel bad.
>>
>>98967147
>>
>>98967137
You have no soul to save, demon. The only place you're going is the lake of fire.
>>
>>98967180
doesn't that depend on the optimisation and how common that is?
>>
>>98967164
>We'll find out that food is being turned into fake garbage due to shrinkflation and people being dependent on it
Food Regulations in most Western Countries have improved since 1990. So this is simply untrue. You'll have to go to before the invention of muh evil preservatives and so on to see "all whole natural foods".

>People having to work harder and being more anxious over being fired no matter how hard they work while they're managed by useless parasites who steal their wages and offload expenses onto the government through taxation and inflation.
Not true. In most developed nations, work culture has improved and employee protections are stronger than ever. The bla bla yapping about ebil corporations stealing from da goobermint is the same as always. Never changed. Part of the system.

>This is paired with utilities being raised by things like data centers and corporate greed realizing they can get away with it. Workers and customers have no leverage to argue for themselves anymore.
The Price of Utilities since 1990 has remained stable or even decreased. The second part is again just yapping about [CURRENT PROBLEM] and things you have told yourself but do not reflect any greater societal truth.

>Meanwhile every person is even more deranged because they can't live up to the expectations of society and are constant under threat of their entire sense of self dissolving if they can't bully others.
Mental Health cases have gone up. But we also started paying vastly more attention to it.

>And while consuming AI slop that gets even more meaningless living in fantasy worlds orchestrated by a tech cartel based out of Israel.
There is nothing inherently meaningful or meaningless about AI Slop. These are just things you associate with it.

>But go ahead, tell us everything's fine bla bla bla..
All Is Well On Heaven And Earth + stop being a faggot reactionary retard doomer, people say and have said these empty things every timeperiod.
>>
>things can't get worse , since people have aways talked about how things can get better or worse.
>>
File: 1791542845072356.gif (1.13 MB, 492x576)
1.13 MB GIF
>>98967147
At this point anything is better than low-quality bait and thinly veiled /pol/ shit
>>
File: 1786049426280156.png (150 KB, 280x450)
150 KB PNG
>>98963966
I read the original run of Crossed and then Wish You Were Here. Both pretty good. I really liked the main cast in the original and there's a few standout emotional moments. Hated the main character in Wish You Were Here but the story was still pretty good.
>>
File: unnamed.jpg (196 KB, 900x842)
196 KB JPG
>>98967199
TL;DR This is literally what the Technocracy would be if the writers weren't retarded and trying to assert that the Technocracy is Democrats. Technocrats should be going full "Colonization was worth it for the GDP HAIL ELON MUSK!." so that Traditions and Fera stop fighting and start mauling Technocrats instead. I'd love to be a Hermetic cracking a Redditor GDPcultist's skull in with a Dreamspeaker and a Garou.
>>
Been reading through bits of Werewolf the Essentials and damn, I don't like a single original thing they did with it.
>>
>>98967232
Unsurprising, SpeakerD (and I guess the rest of the HtP cast, I don't really know if anyone else there actually has strong opinions on WoD) has outed himself to have dogshit taste in WoD related stuff time and time again.
>>
>>98967193
>The only place you're going is the lake of fire.
Anon, demons go the the Abyss.
You really need to stop going of pop bible cosmology and read the actual book.
>>
>>98967232
do we have it in one of the troves?
>>
File: Moggtrix.gif (1.41 MB, 224x294)
1.41 MB GIF
Sometimes I wish the Technocracy was real so all these shizos would actually get their brains fried before being 1984'ed out of existance.
>>
>>98967105
Because they're not boring like the Technocracy are.
>>
>>98967271
The schizo's would still be 100% correct, and the Technocrats silencing them would only prove it.
>>
>>98967271
The Mossad, state-backed tech cartels, child trafficking and blackmail rings are already real though?
>>
>>98967278
So your idea of fun is empowering the factions that you like and turning the factions that you dislike into jokes.
>>
>>98967216
Not only was the Colonization justified, Imperialism is generally a good thing. I am under no obligation to look at retards dancing around fires in their huts and not take all their shit. Vae Victis - All justice is ultimately based upon who is mightier. The Progress of Humanity is the ultimate good.

The reason Paradox can not write a good Technocracy is that they have never been confronted by such viewpoints, can not argue for them or against them and if they could, they would consider portraying them to be a moral evil. They have zero context for how actual western Imperialists think. So they substitute for what they do know: Surface Area Modern Politics. And since Republicans are evil, they can't even use those politics. And this is before we even get to the Mystic aspects that define actual Mage, this is just real politics.
>>
>>98967264
g0f1le /d/9JaINiYA
>>
>>98967257
Tbf, they just did an advertisement for it. I really doubt they know anything about the project other than they got paid to boost it.
>>
>>98967306
neat thanks
>>
>>98967299
I'm willing to concede Traditions be insane megalomaniacs who coincidentally do good things due to scarcity if the Technocracy is a human trafficking GDP cult blackmail ring that backs Israel and Elon Musk and has little remorse for colonization, slavery and genocide. I, in fact, DO want to be an incidintally justified insane person teaming up with other racists (some happen to be indigenous nonwhites) to murder redditor soientismcucks.

This is why WoD should be written by chuds.
>>
>>98967260
Abyss, lake of fire, same thing. Go play word games with someone else. My Faith is True and God has sent me on a mission of vengence against all who have wronged Him.
>>
>>98967320
I think this is sort of the actual vibe Mage was originally built on. My evidence for this is the fact that all other WoD games have you not playing a good guy, but rather an incidentally less bad guy. Sounds familiar?

There's also the fictional Elements. First, the wonders of the modern age are not quite as gilded as they are for us, no matter your opinion of them. The world is ours but SHITTIER. So they are doing a WORSE job. Regardless of what anons say about Epstein or whatever, the World of Darkness is that but worse. When you think of Pentex as a Captain Planet Villain, then think about what those writers were doing: They took current social issues (Pollution, lack of Corporate Enviromentalism..) and amplified them a lot.

Then there's shit like religion, mysticism and magic being undeniably real, the past was filled with wonders and things beyond our current imagining and they took that away from us. In World of Darkness the past is NOT our past. The harmonious and idealized noble savages living in tune with nature? Real. Ancient Pagan Witches? Real. Dragons flying about in Europe, immortal wizards? Real. Healing potions from your local wizard/witch/shaman? Real and not full of mind pollutants, maybe.

Only if you consider those things does the Technocracy as a villain really make sense.
>>
Never has 2020's WoD politics been so clear.
>>
>>98967292
I'm just being somewhat reasonable.
>Anarchs have no central power or infrastructure, and are essentially parasites on the Camarilla.
>Camarilla and Sabbat both have actual organized power structures and rules
Thus, treating the Anarchs as the jokes they logically should be seems sensible to me.
Now, making the Traditions and Technocracy both jokes is a bit easier to explain actually. See Mages, both Tradition and Technocrat, are notoriously know-it-all hubristic solipsists who think they know way more than they actually do about reality. Thus, it makes sense to have them be far too in over their head on a metaphysical level. I see the Technocrats more as the Weaver's useful idiots in the same way Pentex is for the Wyrm.
At least that's how I see it.
>>
>>98967334
>Abyss, lake of fire, same thing
No actually. They're genuinely different places. Abrahamic cosmology is not earth, heaven, and hell, that's hollywood bullshit.
>>
>>98967401
I mean the Technocracy literally bombed and harvested the Middle East to the point that one of the former traditions had to pull out of the Traditions to devote 100% attention to fighting them. We can just say that the Technocracy is an analogy for liberalism where it developed obfuscation and deception to gaslight you into thinking everything bad that's happening is your imagination. They just exhaustively employ individualist-egalitarian bullshit rhetoric where they rob you and say you're the bad guy for caring. And the consequences of not having the money they stole from you they'll say is your own failing.

All this progressivism "Technocracy is pro-trans and helps everybody I FUCKING LOVE SCIENCE" is typical rainbow liberalism that justifies violence and explotation. The redditors who think that's how the Technocracy actually IS are the same as the Destiny-watching redditors who skew and cherrypick statistics to defend the status quo. Like you'll repeatedly find liberals demanding the carpet bombing of the third world for not having gay marriage or trans surgery. Which leads to African witch doctors and domestic terrorist Aryans joining forces to bomb all their constructs.

It's painfully easy to deduce where WoD's modern politics are but alas.
>>
Why is the anti-technocracy anon conflating the HRT crazies and the "Colonialism was good actually" crazies like they're the same? Those two political factions want to KILL each other.
>>
Honestly, an interaction between an Awakening Mage and an Ascension Mage would be hilarious.
>You're arguing over the shape of the cage I've already left
>>
File: payorelse.jpg (208 KB, 712x618)
208 KB JPG
>>98967306
I'm starting on this, the opening is a little on the nose.
Also I've downloaded a few PDFs so far and what the fuck, over 300MB? The biggest ones in the mega are like 80
>>
>>98967476
Because he's a shitposter trying to get a rise out of anons in those factions.
>>
>>98967476
The HRT crazy is their proudest soldier who thinks the other guys aren't doing that. The HRTechnocrat literally projects that aspect of the Technocracy onto the Traditions to argue we're not bombing the third world enough for not being gay enough. The rainbow progressive is the Technocracy's #1 simp while his boss's boss is literally the ultimate poor-hating eugenicist.

The Technocracy is LITERALLY pic related. They're both working together to fuck us.
>>
>>98967476
Spoiler: It's all bait. Something musy have upset the /pol/acks
>>
>>98967476
nta but goatboy kinda does the same in victorian mage
>>
>>98967476
its a double false flag by tradition and technocrat players trying to psyop each other
>>
>>98967547
I fucking HATE Mind Mages! Everyone using that sphere is an asshole!
>>
This is why I'm into Mage the Awakening.
IDK why people hated the Atlantis thing.
>>
>>98967565
>Everyone using that sphere is an asshole!
Thst or they go irrevokably insane. Oftrn both at once. People really don't think through the implications of making all your thoughts semi-sapient with sphere 1, they see the "Books Mental Ability Scores" line and disregard everything else, only to wonder why they're now a lovecraftian psychic horror.
>>
>>98967582
Awakening is genuinely fucking boring and the seers aren't an ounce as compelling of a villain as the technocratic union.
>>
>>98967147
>Can I has (You)s instead?
Absolutely.
>>
>>98967592
I personally like Awakening more because instead of the whole human belief shapes reality stuff, you're outright leaving it.
>>
>>98967483
>>98967306
>the BSD cons the cub with a bullshit story about the Tenderloin
>half of the moot is arguing over petty nonsense
This writing is brilliant
>>
>>98967587
>People really don't think through the implications of making all your thoughts semi-sapient with sphere 1
I know you're probably tired of hearing this shit, but that sounds like Disco Elysium
>>
>>98967601
>>98967592
Actually, let me explain what I mean by that.
Ascension feels weirdly hollow. It's saying "Reality is shaped by human belief" and then says that the mage's endgame is for everyone to ascend to godhood so they can sit in their own personal little bubbles of omnipotence forever. It's basically saying "Literally nothing you care about matters at all or has any meaning."
Awakening, meanwhile, states that there is an objective truth, and instead of imposing your beliefs upon reality, you understand the true nature of the world more deeply. It feels like it actually matters, if that makes any sense?
At least that's what I think.
>>
>>98967622
having your own horizon bubble is an archmage thing, getting to actual arete 10 is leaving reality for some nebulously defined state that is objectively good
>>
>>98967612
>Disco Elysium
We really just can't escape this thing can we?
>>
>>98967634
So a nothingburger
>>
>>98967310
That's worse honestly. Shilling for something without really understanding what it is.
>>
>>98967612
>I know you're probably tired of hearing this shit, but that sounds like Disco Elysium

I'm putting in a Disco Elysium swear jar in tomorrow.
>>
File: Mind mage vs demon.gif (1.18 MB, 640x911)
1.18 MB GIF
>>98967634
I hate that sleepers interpret this as Archmages living in sex palaces banging infinity sex slaves forever or some other doomed pursuit of satiating desire. In reality you become devoid of all content and synonymous with the emptiness of being. You cease to exist without being conventionally killed. Your are de facto non-existent by lack of determination. Your options as an archmage is suicide or to lobotomize/reincarnate yourself so you can return to a form.
>>
>>98967651
your avatar won't let you stagnate in hedonism or depression
its RAW as of m20
>>
>>98967634
Honestly, about the only 2 things I prefer from MTAS are the Technocrats and the variety of Mage "Aesthetics." Awakening doesn't really give you the ability to make a crazy gadgeteer Mage like Ascension does. The rest, I prefer from MTAW.
>>
>>98967472
>Technocracy is an analogy for liberalism
It is not. It is an "analogy" for Imperialist Paternalism. This is merely not really mutually exclusive with some streams of thought you likely consider liberalism, or that consider themselves liberal but is a very poor description of this ideology.

Invading a country to enforce your ideals on somebody (Gay Marriage, whatever you want), that is itself an attempt to bring Consensus everywhere. It's the entire purpose of the Technocracy. They are the peak of Globalization and it's good and evil.

And worst of all, they aren't even cool Imperialists like Hermetics.
>>
>>98967666
its an analogy of value decay from wanting to make magick accessible to all humans to wanting to control it for the sake of humanity
>>
>>98967663
it was already a thing in lore before m20. your avatar could even try to mess with your magic if you don't go to your quests

that's why there are merits to reduce the avatar's role in the story and why those been so expensive
>>
>>98967663
You would stagnate if you grew powerful enough though. Like you could not actually prove you exist anymore and everything becomes utterly meaningless. So you have to either suicide or shatter yourself into component parts so you can return to life and the search for meaning. MtA mechanics does nothing to deviate from the innate mechanisms of abstract reason itself.
>>
>>98967663
makes me wonder how that works with npcs who don't have enough "talent" to become master mages
>>
>>98967676
no i mean as of m20 its explicitly stated that in order to even reach archmage levels of arete you had to overcome apathy, complacency or hubris, becoming a better developed person
>>98967680
there is no personal horror as arete is explicitly knowledge and greater appreciation for your place in reality. you would only stagnate due to void adaptation and being cut off from sleepers. this is why horizon and many archmages keep sleepers as native citizens in their dimension.
>>98967690
not all games finish with archmastery anyways, because its possible for players to fail seekings if the ST says so. presumably its just a matter of not having enough time, or just actually ascending but not bothering to tell anyone
>>
>>98967712
>there is no personal horror as arete is explicitly knowledge and greater appreciation for your place in reality. you would only stagnate due to void adaptation and being cut off from sleepers. this is why horizon and many archmages keep sleepers as native citizens in their dimension.
You know everything and your place in reality. Now what? Now nothing. You become something formless with nothing more to know. There is no more relation to be made by which to have self-determination. You do not know your exist anymore. Best case scenario an archmage fades into the background of the universe as a force and possibly lives on in a component part as a sleeper or mage.
This isn't even Mage anymore, this is reason that applies in any universe wherever there is a consciousness to reason. Your magic and the things you get to see are effectively a treadmill going no where.
>>
Why doesn't Asia ever figure into these Technocracy conversations? I feel like the "oldschool" Technocracy would still be present in places like China or Singapore.
>>
>>98967719
you have the knowledge that ascension is objectively good, unless you were the shitposter trying to claim that avatars are parasites
>>
>>98967723
Technocracy is obviously strongest in China while the western Technocracy is a Pentex subsidiary. Not that China doesn't have decay, but they are clearly closer to old school Technocracy complete with worship of control.

>>98967724
>objectively good
>Mage
You are basically arguing that mages will get better at playing tic-tac-toe and this will never get old. They'll just be infinitely entertained by tic-tac-toe for eternity. Having magic powers means fuck all in the end.
>>
>>98967723
because asia was a land of mystery and fantasy back in the 90s

watsonian it's because the technocratic union was tied heavily to the british empire during queen victoria and that's why they are so global but western
>>
>>98967734
Yes because it being objectively good is both RAW and RAI
you can practice death of the author all you want but ironically, it disproves your original argument that there wasn't objective truth in mtas
>>
>>98967742
Go ahead and read the Wagner play Tannhauser, watch the Twilight Zone episode A Nice Place to Visit, read Hegel or Buddhism. I don't think you understand that reason still operates through fundamental abstract categories like "desire" which is self-consciousness.
>>
>>98967755
What word salad is this? Nothing can beat the word of the author that says This is an objective good because the author defined it so. You can't look at something that is defined by being ontologically good and say it is not because then it is not that thing. It's just a fundamental.
>>
>>98967663
That has been inconsistent in the lore since 2e. Your avatar isn't Supposed to let you stagnate, but it's just as fallible and prone to vice as it's mage. Back when Psychopomps were still around, Mages being perfectly in tune with their avatar turned out to be Bad because the Avatar and Mage would have the same stupid, self-destructive desires.
>>
>>98967763
>word salad
Oh you're retarded, so it's a waste of time explaining to you that reason functions exactly the same regardless of magic powers. This is actually the ultimate final point of Mage is to realize that the true fundamentals aren't the gibberish on your character sheet. You realize it when you meet aliens that are also awakened or find other splats who can do the same thing outside of your character sheet gibberish. >Literally forgot that Mage is about philosophy.
Lmao.
>>
>>98967765
>Mages being perfectly in tune with their avatar turned out to be Bad because the Avatar and Mage would have the same stupid, self-destructive desires.
And it was better that way. Fuck this enlightenment shit, I want my horizon realm full of horny catgirls!
>>
>>98967771
Anon, thinking like that prevents being able to get the horizon realm Arete is enlightenment.
>>
>>98967755
an archmage can literally make up a force that blurs the distinction between the concept of gender (this is literally given as an example power)
you can just alter metaphysics to change the relationship between desire and consciousness and whateverism
this is just theodicy again, except with true omnipotence you can just use it to avoid all consequences of such
besides that, your only argument of "it cant be objectively good even though the authors say so" because you imagine everyone to be psychologically trapped by the human condition regardless of what state of being they are in, is basically you arguing at shadow puppets of the supposed limitations of a setting that you created from your own imagination rather than the game that everyone else is playing
>>
So, Vampires huh?
>>
File: images[1].jpg (67 KB, 475x646)
67 KB JPG
>>98967771
>I want my horizon realm full of horny catgirls!
And then what?
>>
>>98967770
No, you are being an idiot. I mean yes, you can make Ascension actually a scam, sure. But the core rulebook portrays it as the ultimate human good. You're just a midwit who has "reasoned" himself into misunderstanding how fiction works. You can not "reason" against a magical, mystical ultimate good defined by a fictional author, numbnut. Whatever argument you can present is always automatically wrong because the universe changes to make it so.
>>
>>98967771
>I want my horizon realm full of horny catgirls!
I feel this in my Sovl
>>
>>98967776
It doesn't matter if there's gender or not for abstract reason, you utter retard. You're actually projecting onto me that I'm being human centric, when that is exactly what you're arguing. You don't have to be born on Earth, have two eyes, two legs, two arms, because reason is the same in any universe. Having magic powers to troon out doesn't change the fundamental categories you think all thoughts through.
>>
>>98967777
Wasted
>>
>>98967770
>ummm wraiths cant actually reach transcendence because.... its vague okay????
>ermmmmmmm true golconda.... its vague hurrrr durrrrrrrrrr
i didn't know that paradox writers posted in here
>>
>>98967771
The Horizon Realm Full Of Horny Catgirls (tm) is an integral stepping stone to ascension.
>>
>>98967779
>And then what?
Be happy and mildly bored for however long I have until I kick the bucket. My next incarnation can chase enlightenment, I need a break from the rat race.
>>
>>98967780
You're the ultimate midwit. The game points you toward philosophy when you find out things like "mages don't have to be human" and "awakening doesn't actually mean enlightenment". You find out most mages are idiots because they have random magic powers but are still subject to reason. You genuinely are too retarded for philosophy, give it up. Stick to Vampire.
>>
>>98967784
>no you cant use omnipotence to negate suffering born of human desire
>therefore im just going to pretend that omnipotence, as defined by the ability to do anything can't exist, even though we're engaging in discussion about a setting where it theoretically can
>>
File: HXEUUita4AAr_9l.jpg (234 KB, 932x1222)
234 KB JPG
>>98967777
>So, Vampires huh?
apparently have a steady diet of hollow ones and ecstatics

and yet the tremere in my city won't shut up about how mysterious he is because that's the only pick up line he knows
>>
>>98967803
You absolutely, in a million llifetimes, would never understand the actual meaning of the word omnipotence and what it would be like. You think it just means having a high level in Skyrim or something.
>>
>>98967800
You are literally dodging the argument. Explain to me how you can ever be right against the Author defining How Something Is, inside a fictional setting? You can't reason against an axiomatic truth which Ascension=Good is.
>>
>>98967800
>awakening doesn't actually mean enlightenment
because awakening is just realizing you're a mage, getting higher arete isn't awakening its "ascension"
holy shit if you're a nogames atleast read the wiki
>>
>>98967808
it seems you don't understand it, anon-kun, because otherwise you would have a more compelling argument besides pretending that omnipotence can't exist in a fictional setting
>>
I think anon is confusing lore from ascension with lore from awakening. Awakening doesn't treat it's ultimate end state as an absolute good in league with enlightenment, Ascention Does do that.
>>
>>98967808
You just told everyone to read about buddhism, whose state of leaving the cycle of reincarnation contains the same vagueties of state of being that you were seeting over.
>>
>>98967813
Getting higher Arete isn't ascension, it's a separate thing. You can ascend at low Arete iirc.
>>
One of my amalgam is bonkers, after they just killed an entire werewolf pack they have been hunting for 2 games the progenitor arete 5 decided to spare the female red talon lupus and asked me if he can experiment on her as he wanted to make super soldier wolf men hybrids with his DNA and hers in some fucked up sex punishment science shit. I didnt know how to answer him and honestly everyone knows hes the creepy mad scientist giving off stranger danger vibes, the syndicate in the group decided he could cash in on this and supports his efforts while the rest are like whatever since the garou kinda deserved it for genociding an entire town on a stupid whim there was some wyrm taing. If he succeeds what do I even give him?
>>
>>98967930
>You can ascend at low Arete iirc.
No, you got your lore mixed up. Youcan ascend with low SPHERES. The books make it clear that SPHERES aren't a requirement, high Arete is a requirement though.
>>
>>98967476
anon , I am sorry to break this to you.
but its actually based on a real type of redditor.
>>
can characters talk while shapeshifted into a animal?
>>
>>98967930
IIRC it's hard gated to Arete 8 minimum. I vaguely remember some magefags griping about it. Even 1e is explicit that Arete is a prerequisite.
>>
>>98967978
Yes but no. They can not speak human languages, because they can't form the words. I assume you meant this? Bastet for example can speak a feline language called Kheuar/Querl in feline form and have it understood by a Bastet in Homid- this involves chirps, body language and whathaveyou. I think Garou have something similar.

So no to human words but yes to communication. You could theoretically develop some language an animal can speak. To make a trivial example, morse code with long and short whines.
>>
>>98967777
Based
>>
File: images.jpg (43 KB, 447x447)
43 KB JPG
>>
Does bloodbonding have to happen via ingesting vitae, or could it also be done by contact of vitae with an open wound?
>>
>>98968370
I actually did shower Syndicate, you cannot take my water from me.
>>
>>98967622
I think you're just too attached to objective thinking and the idea of there being truth and facts that matter infinitely more than beliefs and falsehoods.
Once you open yourself up to the concept of subjective reality, everything matters and has meaning. The crazed fertility druid's understanding of the universe is just as relevant and important as the austere scientist's understand, both have innate value and are worthy of consideration. It isn't a case of your character's beliefs not mattering because nothing is real, in fact, they have profound importance because they are real and it is their right given to them by the universe itself to manifest that belief in the universe. Everything is real and everything has value, even the beliefs that your character might want to decry as falsehoods. There's so much meaning in the universe that's being created by humanity that reality is overflowing with the stuff.
And honestly, considering how the actual consensus reality that exists in the real world is shattering thanks to the internet, embracing a little subjective thinking might even be healthy. It's the only thing that will allow people who exist in completely different ideological bubbles with completely different interpretations of reality to communicate with each other.
>>
File: pentex.png (486 KB, 499x443)
486 KB PNG
Is Dees Illustrations the best way of representing Pentex/Technocracy lmao?
>>
File: NWO.png (504 KB, 500x500)
504 KB PNG
>>
File: Technocracy.png (1.9 MB, 1080x1398)
1.9 MB PNG
Technocracy
>>
>>98967676
>>98967712
>>98967724
Here's the thing, there's nothing stopping a mage from cultivating the understanding, wisdom and realisation of the universe required to reach Arete 9... and simply disregarding it. There is no Arete backsliding. There is nothing compelling the mage to obey their Avatar, beyond a single negative modifier to Arete rolls for acting against its interests. A mage can absolutely be on the cusp of Ascension, only to reconsider their options and go
>nah, even though I understand that I will be wallowing in the banality of the material universe instead of further cultivating my consciousness, I'd much rather spend the rest of my life fucking a harem of every sort of woman that the mind can conceive than spend another second contemplating existence, thanks. I see the scope of infinity from here and I'm not really into it, thank you very much. Bring on the catgirls and ambrosia.
>>
>>98968515
Aren't oracles basically mages that COULD ascend but decided to stay behind to help?
>>
>>98968527
Yes, but the point is that high Arete doesn't turn mages into cerebral, wisdom-focused robots who don't care about anything but cultivating ever greater understanding. Greater understanding is required for Arete progress, but once that threshold has been reached, regression and/or distraction from the pursuit of ever-higher Arete is more than possible, and there isn't a single Storyteller out there who will punish their players with negative modifiers just because they're not doing Seekings 100% of the time. The +1 to +3 difficult modifier comes from a mage being in conflict with their Avatar, not from a mage neglecting their metaphysical advancement.
>>
With three dots of Spirit, could I force a spirit to possess a mortal?
>>
>>98968543
No, binding spirits to things is generally Spirit 4, which is what I would classify "forcing a spirit to possess a mortal" as.
HDYDT's rulings are:
>Spirit 4 for just thrusting a spirit inside of a person and letting them duke it out for control.
>Spirit 4 / Mind 2 for using the bound ghost to influence the mood and personality of the possessed person.
>Spirit 4 / Mind 4 for total control over the possessed person's actions.
But if you want to say 'fuck you' to HDYDT, I think you could just use Spirit 4 to accomplish all of the above, as long as the spirit comes out on top in the battle of wills between spirit and mortal.
>>
>>98968565
What's HDYDT, ns where would I find it?
>>
>>98968594
I would not recommend using how do you do that lmao, it fucking sucks.
>>
>>98968594
How Do You Do That, a book for M20 found in the Mega in the OP. It's a book full of suggested Sphere requirements for a lot of different spells and occasionally, how those spells might work.

Word of warning, it suffers from something called Sphere bloat. A lot of the spells listed in HDYDT require a crazy amount of Spheres in order to cast them, even though they're relatively simple spells. Stuff like mages requiring Time 4 before they're able to delaying the casting of magic. For this reason, a lot of people ignore HDYDT.
>>
File: New Bread!.png (179 KB, 640x548)
179 KB PNG
New Thread
>>98968666
>>98968666
>>98968666
>>
>>98967938
>If he succeeds what do I even give him?
Depends on the edition you're playing.
>M20 - a visting from the ethics nerds
>2e - a pat on the back from his convention and a lot of questions as to how this will advance the war effort and the timetable
>>
>>98967938
Wyrm Taint.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.