[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: me afffffffffff.png (2 KB, 680x175)
2 KB PNG
What are some good middle fantasy settings you guys like?
>>
>>98953646
dnd
>>
>>98953646
Asoiaf :)
>>
>>98953646
What about wide vs narrow fantasy?
>>
>>98953660
its high fantasy
>>
>>98953680
low fantasy and dog shit

>>98953705
tell me some then
>>
harry potter
>>
>>98953714
No, its a nice middle ground.
>>
>>98953741
ur retarded
>>
>>98953756
nou
>>
File: hyboria.png (133 KB, 885x600)
133 KB PNG
>>98953646
The OG.
>>
>>98953646
>Let's add another term to the list of terms that mean fucking nothing!
>>
I kinda liked Diablo's Sanctuary in the first two games
>>
>>98953646

High fantasy doesn't mean what you thinks it means.
>>
>>98954003
ok wat is it then PROFERSOR
>>
>>98954045

I'd suggest reading the definition that the guy who invented the term gave.
https://liteka.ru/english/library/6277-from-the-december-1971-issue-of-the-horn-book-magazine
>>
>>98954060
Give me the high concept version of it.
>>
>>98954003
Eh sure originally it didn't but the term has morphed so much to the point most people just use it as a shorthand for "how fantastical is your fantasy"
>>
>>98954003
>>98954060
Words change over time even if I don't want them to, an argument I use IRL is that if you plagiarized LOTR and changed the names only to the point of being unrecognizable but kept as much as possible, and then presented it as your homebrew RPG setting, it would get called neutraldark, ultra-low-fantasy, and low-magic, despite it being cited by name as an example of a noblebright setting which is High Fantasy (due to how its Secondary World works) and has a soft magic system which can alter the landscape when used by gods. LOTR still carries that reputation despite the words changing, because it acquired it when the words meant something else, and the people who lowered the bar for what it means for something to be "dark" or "low magic" or "low fantasy" did not consider how an established benchmark would be affected.
>>
>>98953646
Would WoD be considered mid-fantasy? (the world of vampire the masquerade, werewolf, mage:the gathering, etc.)
>>
File: images.jpg (40 KB, 405x719)
40 KB JPG
>>98954109
I was going to argue with you that nobody would consider lotr low fantasy even under the new definition as its got ents and orcs and elves and all that shit but then I remembered people call warhammer fantasy low fantasy so I preemptively concede
>>
>>98954175
It's a low sample size, but the impression I get online and IRL is that as soon as you track injuries for longer than the immediate aftermath of a fight, or you add negative consequences to magic, or evil motivations exist that are rational rather than caricatured, or the average person is likely to lose a fight with a wild carnivorous animal unless armed and prepared, it's considered "dark fantasy" now, with the context being me wanting to add those to D&D but otherwise keep D&D mostly the same.

Nobody of importance will accept this, but I also think that whimsy and grand visionary ideas should be part of the high vs low fantasy distinction, for example having multiple planets that can be traveled between as opposed to planes, or having handheld energy weapons despite them not being feasible IRL, yet adding those to the already very high fantasy D&D is considered in poor taste by the people who reject appeals to historical/mythological accuracy for any other reason.
>>
Greyhawk.
>>
It's important to understand what purpose genres serve. Autists like classifying things for the sake of it, which is how you end up with shit like TVTropes and its extensive taxonomy of minutiae. But the basic function of genre is to guide the audience in what to watch and how. Knowing something is a tragedy or comedy helps you know if you're in the right mood for it, and to get into that mood. More modern genres appeal to particular groups of people in particular ways, and that justifies their existence. Sci-fi is distinct from fantasy because there is a significant group that's a fan of one but not the other. I don't see that to any great extent with high and low fantasy.
If anything litrpg is more of a legitimate genre because a lot of fantasy fans can't stand it.
>>
>>98954813
>litrpg
The what now
>>
>>98953769
Low Fantasy.

>>98953680
Low Fantasy.

>>98953660
High Fantasy like >>98953714 said.

>>98953797
High Fantasy.

>>98954296
High Fantasy.

>>98954155
Yes but I'd say it leans more towards High Fantasy if you approach topics like Gehenna.
>>
>>98954098

Seconday world=high fantasy.

>>98954108


"High fantasy" means whatever in the current usage, meaning it doesn't mean anything. It is stupid as fuck, even more than using "low magic" to describe LOTR.
And actually "how fantastical" may be... even worse? Is Conan (magical immortal aliens, lovecraftian shit on the side, dinosaur-reanimating necromancers) more "fantasy" than LOTR (thinking foxes and flying ships)? Where would Dunsany sit? Hell, where would Miyazaki?

So: don't be stupid. Use the actual definition, or don't use the word. You can use other words, anon. They don't cost you.
>>
>>98958253
It's not about what the setting contains but how it's presented. If you want to be a pedant, do so at your own risk. Fantasy 'grading' is all about where your point of view is, not about whether or not the setting is fantastical. If you're a shit-eating peasant on Grimdark 5 in a setting where Gods are made manifest and they travel the universe in giant yachts made of ice cream, it doesn't matter to you until you're in a situation where you need to deal with one of those Dairy Dieties. The truth of the matter is, you're living in a low-grade fantastical world until you encounter something that changes that.
>>
>>98958253
>So: don't be stupid. Use the actual definition, or don't use the word. You can use other words, anon. They don't cost you.
I take a prescriptivist stance on these things. If most people use a word in the sense of definition B, it makes very little sense to go "umm well actually definition A is the official one (lol) so xyz".
For what it's worth depending on the story I think conan can definitely be higher fantasy than lotr.
>>
>>98958311

I'd grudgingly agree, but there is no consensus on the newer defintion. See this: >>98958202
Why would the hyborian age be less "high" than third age ME?
It could be for a whole plethora of distinct reasons, and they're all used by nerds around. This is when people don't say ME is lower fantasy than the other, of course.

>>98958286
>It's not about what the setting contains but how it's presented

Seems even more vague.
>>
>>98958331
Yeah I agree it's a very nebulous and contentious term. I've seen people describe some shit as "low fantasy" which makes absolutely no sense.
I do kind of agree with the other anon you cited that low/high fantasy is more about a specific story than a setting. Taking asoiaf as an example, there's several storylines where absolutely nothing fantastical ever happens, and there's others where it's essentially the main focus. Tyrion chapters are low fantasy, jon or dany ones not so much.
But idk the discussion is half the fun. Sure, the older definition is a lot clearer, but it also doesn't really change much, genre-wise I mean? Whereas just how common magic or fantastical creatures or all that other shit is really does matter to how people engage with the story. If that makes sense.
>>
>>98958253
>>98958202
>Seconday world=high fantasy.
dnd default as faerun is connected to irl earth like narnia.
This would make dnd low fantasy to the classic definition.
>>
>>98958371
I mean, that happens in LOTR as well.

>>98958372

Yeah, well, that's not what secondary world means.
(if you really want, you can easily find partial examples, but those aren't).
>>
>>98958387
Personally I consider basically everything that has fantastical creatures like hobbits and elves and shit to be a pretty major shift towards high fantasy, though I understand not everyone thinks that way.
Also I've always wondered how something like narnia fits onto the secondary world dichotomy.
>>
>>98958387
>Yeah, well, that's not what secondary world means.
>looks it up
>its tokien discovering set theory.
lol
>>
>>98958407

I'd say Narnia (or 99% of trapped in another world/portal fantasy/isekai shit) is firmly set in secondary world territory, by Lloyd Alexander's definition. Hell, he DOES refer to Lewis in the paper!
The real exceptions might be something like Inuyasha, the world being a heavy magical shift on real history (at least theoretically). But the portal thing is inconsequential, the crux of the matter is the worldbuilding.
>>
>>98958486
Yeah I can follow that. What about stuff like conan where it's technically supposed to be earth but in some crazy mythological time period where for all intents and purposes it is a secondary world? I'm pretty sure lotr does this too.
>>
there is no middle fantasy, everything is on either the right or the left of the mid point
>>
>>98958491

Eh, so TECHNICALLY is Tolkien indeed, which is the prime example of high fantasy.
(yes, nowdays "high fantasy" is kinda of a generic assumption for fantasy, to the point that people have problems with Gaiman being just fantasy now and then)

I think a more apt example of something borderline might be Harry Potter. Atrocious as JKR's worldbulding is, it's pretty heavy, there is a whole "unseen world" to it AND there is still our world more or less cohexisting (which doesn't happen with isekai).
>>
>>98953646
Dungeons and Dragons 5.5 edition produced by Wizards of the Coast (a subsidiary of Hasbro Inc.)
>>
>>98953646
>Middle-earth
>Nix's Old Kingdom
>Hyborian Age
>The Night Land
>>
>>98959144
I forgot to include:
>Wizarding World
>>
>>98954060
While an interesting read, this isn’t actually helpful for the discussion and you’re just being obtuse
>>
>>98953646
Frieren is a good middle fantasy.
Magic is a thing and people can learn it but often it's low level and used to do basic things. If you're a skilled caster you can make some money doing basic task, but it's not like every mage can one shot an army. (Hell, in fact skilled warriors have a slight advantage.)
>>
>>98958516
>>
>>98959330

Filtered
>>
>>98958491
I'd argue that Conan and Middle-earth are a sort of middle-ground, because they're both their own world but also connected to ours by time.
>>
>>98959865
A skilled warrior should always have an advantage against a lone mage.
>>
File: 1669297797041392.gif (483 KB, 750x1000)
483 KB GIF
>>98958516
But where is the mid point? What's the threshhold where "low fantasy" becomes "high fantasy"?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.