Hey DM, my character->Has amnesia>Just wants to see the world!>Is quiet and reserved>Just here for the rideWhy do most players make NPCs instead of Player characters? If I wanted to bloat the party size so they can handle a tougher task then they could hire retainers or ask NPCs for help. Why should I waste my time and energy keeping an NPC player happy? 9 times out of 10 they aren't going to add anything to the table anyway, just slowing it down and bringing down the vibe
>>98954399>t. NPC DM
>>98954419Yes it is the job of the DM to run NPCs and the world
>>98954399They do that because they're noobs. They're insecure because they don't have any practice as artists. This is the first time they've performed in front of other people, they have no actual voice of their own yet. The super-passivity and blankness of their character is an attempt to avoid scrutiny or criticism. It doesn't work, but that's what they're trying to do.
>>98954442I've seen people who have played for years and only made characters like this. They are NPCs brained people who just like following others around
>>98954399Why is every "why" thread a garbage thread?
>players come to play rather than narrate their 5 page angsty backstory >this is apparently a bad thing
>>98954399Because I wanted to play D&D but the rest of the group wants to play Bugchasers and Baristas.
>>98954399>Has amnesiaI don't know why this bothers you. This is an excellent thing to have because it lets you, the GM, easily slip plot elements into the game that hint at their past, and it gives the character a strong, clear goal to work towards: uncovering their lost memories and finding out who they were.If you work with the player, very fun and easy way to have them engaged and involved.>Just wants to see the world!Also nothing wrong with this, it's a good motivation for a naieve character and can lead down many interesting paths for said character as they learn more about the world. Will they become jaded? Will they be disappointed? Will they see the evils of the world and bend to them, or stand stalwart against them?>Is quiet and reservedNot an issue if it's a player who isn't confident in their ability to RP, and/or if there's an "except when..." tacked on, which can be a good path for character growth over the game.>Just here for the rideThis is less excusable, but again if the player is more reserved or less confident then letting them participate at their own pace is fine. When they show interest in getting involved, encourage them and let them.>Why should I waste my time and energy keeping an NPC player happy?Because usually, they won't need much to be happy. They'll be content to be along and occasionally contribute. They're low maintenance players.
>>98954511I have never had a player do both>Bring a character with no backstory>Engage with the game in any serious wayThey might pay attention, and will chime in from time to time, but backstory length is correlated with excitement for the game.>>98954518Your party is playing DnD, you are a silent NPC that the GM has to pay attention to>>98954560>It isn't better that the GM has to do more work and play the player for them>There will be no interesting path for said character, they are flat and static with nothing to start from>An unconfident, quiet player is ok if they are just starting, they should grow out of it quickly>Why is it the GM's job to carefully manage the excitement and engagement of low effort players? If you don't want to play rpgs, just don't play them>Low effort players are notorious for dragging game down. They never pay attention and will bring things to a halt if anything beyond silence is required from them
>>98954619>It isn't better that the GM has to do more work and play the player for themWell considering you're an illiterate retard, all work for you is more work. Why should the GM not be involved in building their world? Why should the GM not be making sure players don't make something that doesn't fit the game they're running? Being a GM requires you to put in the effort, if you're a lazy faggot don't be a GM.>There will be no interesting path for said character, they are flat and static with nothing to start fromBut enough about white male human fighters.>An unconfident, quiet player is ok if they are just starting, they should grow out of it quicklyThey don't have to. There's nothing wrong with them being there to spend time with their friends, and if you aren't playing with your friends you are objectively playing the game wrong and deserve every misfortune that falls upon you.>Why is it the GM's job to carefully manage the excitement and engagement of low effort players?It's the GM's job to spot what the players are latching onto and provide more of it. Otherwise, you should just go write a novel.>Low effort players are notorious for dragging game down.You're conflating (erroneously) low-effort with introverted. A white male human fighter who wants to make money is low-effort, for example.>They never pay attention and will bring things to a halt if anything beyond silence is required from themThis is just not true. They often pay more attention, and you shouldn't be brute forcing your players to do shit they don't want to do.
>>98954655Being a player requires effort too, why should the DM be providing 100% of the effort to the game?I have seen boring characters of all typesIf they want to spend time with friends they should suggest things they enjoy rather than waste everyone's time, especially the GMWhat about players that don't latch onto anything because they have no investment in the game or setting? All NPC players do this, even if you directly engage them with something they like you will see a flicker of interest before they go back to NPC modeIntroverted behaviors are inherently low effort, this is a social game. "A fighter who wants to make money" is an NPC the GM could generate on the fly and offers nothing to the gameEven when they do pay attention it matters little, they are just there, sucking up energy and your own attention for no gain.
>>98954399"Has no strong feelings or prior commitments" is quintessential PC design because it leaves maximal room for the player to decide their actions without restraint. How could you be this retarded?
>>98954820Because those characters are incredibly boring and provide nothing to the game itself. I don't want to preplan a campaign and have the characters "run through it", I want to make a world and have the story naturally result from their choices. When they have no character to speak of the choices are always surface level and lazy
>>98954826Anon, most players WANT to "run through it". Your core issue comes from expecting players to entertain you, that Not their Job.It's the Forever DMs job to entertain the players. The forever DM's entertainment comes from building the world and getting to share his creation. If you need to be entertained by others, quit being a DM. DMing won't give you what you want.
>>98954862That's what I will never understand, why players choose to be NPCs and inevitably bore their DM's to tears.
>>98954873Anon, most DMs don't care. They don't get bored because they DM for the chance to show people their model trainset autism project. If the doesn't appeal to you, DON'T DM. You're clearly not having fun.
>>98954894I have fun with my sentient players, who clearly are also having the most fun. But for NPC players, which are the vast majority in my experience, I just cannot fathom that "playstyle". The point of GMing is to make a setting and watch your players fuck around and orchestrate how that works
>>98954781>Being a player requires effort tooA fraction of it. All you have to do is show up on time, play your character, and roll dice. A Gm has to create NPCs, prepare encounters, set up the game, decide what the world is like, find or make maps, and so, so much more.>why should the DM be providing 100% of the effort to the game?They aren't, but it's close to 90%. They just have more work to do by virtue of their role, but without them there just isn't a game.>If they want to spend time with friends they should suggest things they enjoy rather than waste everyone's time, especially the GMWho's to say they aren't enjoying themselves?>What about players that don't latch onto anything because they have no investment in the game or setting?Then it's the GM's fault for not being up front about the type of game and setting the game will be run in.>Even when they do pay attention it matters little, they are just there, sucking up energy and your own attention for no gain.If you view playing a game with your friends as a form of personal gain, then those aren't your friends.
>>98954399Some people play games to hang with their friends and shit. One of my players is usually pretty quiet, I'm fuckin fine with that. That's my relatively low stakes beer and pretzels game, if dude wants to chill and occasionally kill goblins, that's fucking fine.
>>98954995Yes which is why players should be expected to do the bare minimum of playing an interesting character with goals and takes action beyond following the herdYes which is why players should take on more effortThey may be, but to the active detriment of everyone aroundIt's the players fault for not vocalizing what they are intoWhat "personal gain" I want to play a game with my friends, and some friends who dont actually want to play the game continue to show up for the social aspect. You dont see people do this with sports, but you can be very low effort as a player and just sit there, making things shittier>>98955006Why would I run or play a boring game like that and not just play a video game or wargame and get the same result for far less effort
>You know the worst player is a good player. A bad player is fine because you kick that person right away. A great player is phenomenal, you want to keep them and cherish them, they're fantastic. But a good player, you never sort of kick them, but they never lead you to the next level. They just keep their spot, they're sort of too good to be kicked, but they're not good enough—you're never going to do great. So I always say the worst player isn't a bad player. It's just a good or average player.
>>98954826Again, they aren't supposed to "provide anything to the story", they're game elements for player interaction. This is literally the opposite of an NPC.
>>98955032>Yes which is why players should be expected to do the bare minimum of playing an interesting character with goals and takes action beyond following the herdone player who doesn't do this is not an issue.>Yes which is why players should take on more effortFuck no I don't want them ruining my shit. Too many cooks spoil the pot.>They may be, but to the active detriment of everyone aroundNo, only your autistic ass.>It's the players fault for not vocalizing what they are intoThe GM should make the tone and themes of the game known upfront. If someone doesn't vibe with them, they don't join. You sound like a lying little faggot.>What "personal gain" I want to play a game with my friendsYou don't have any of those.>some friends who dont actually want to play the game continue to show up for the social aspectYeah, that's why I'm here as a GM, to hang out with my friends. The social aspect IS the core of the game.>You dont see people do this with sportsbad comparison, sports are a competitive team-based game, TTRPGs are a cooperative storytelling game.>but you can be very low effort as a player and just sit there, making things shittierI'd rather have someone quiet and passive than That Guy who constantly does retarded LOLRANDUMB bullshit to ruin the game for everyone.
>>98954511Who are you quoting?
>>98954518Then why didn't you make a character?
>>98954560Won't contribute at all, you mean.
>>98954619>backstory lengthI would like to correct this from backstory length to how much the backstory was thought out (someone find a better word).A ten page backstory of all the cool things a character did can also be a problem. You can convey your character's history, goals, motivations, and relationships with a bullet point list. Supplementary written works are fine tho
>>98955374No, it's a perfect comparison. Do you show up to a chess game to not play chess? Do you attend knitting clubs if you aren't interested in knitting? Do you go to golf courses to not play golf? Of course not. You don't have to play games to spend time with your friends. If you want to spend time with your friends, you can just do that, without pretending to be interested in something you're not.If you don't want to participate in the game, STAY HOME.
>>98954399Playoids will signal what they want out of a campaign with their characters. Amnesia, parents killed by orcs, etc = I just want to bash some monsters with my friends. Joke character = I'm going to sabotage your campaign for fun. Angst bucket = I enjoy challenges and want to be put through the wringer but you'll have to carefully manage how much time I spend in the spotlight to avoid alienating the other playoids. Character involved in a romance or romance-related quest like finding a cure for her lover's vampirism = Will be an intense and loyal playoid, but as with the angst bucket try not to exclusively focus on their character even though they're more engaged than the others.
>>98955181Yes which is why they should aim to be more interesting than an NPC, many fail
>>98955032>There is one person who is more there for the social aspect>That means the entire game and the experience of the other 3 players and the game master at the table is bad, actually!You're really outing yourself as a nevergames, bud.
>>98954560>They're low maintenance playersIt's not the amount of maintenance that is the problem, it's the ratio between maintenance effort and contribution. They might be low maintenance but that ratio is fucked.
>>98954655>>They never pay attention and will bring things to a halt if anything beyond silence is required from them>This is just not true. They often pay more attention, and you shouldn't be brute forcing your players to do shit they don't want to do.If they don't want to speak, interact or make decisions then what are they doing being at the table?
>>98954399They're insecure, if they don't give the group anything they aren't giving it anything they can be judged for. Lots of seethe ITT from insecure people who feel called out.
>>98954399>Just wants to see the world!This is actually usable for the DM and allows that person to be part of the force driving the group to actually get out there and not just sit in town for the next "four day walk at best" adventure site to magically spring up.All the other ones are hot garbage.
>>98957232Which part of "this is backwards" do you not understand? The NPCs are supposed to be interesting, the PCs are supposed to be means to interact with NPCs and the rest of the world.
>>98955374>The social aspect IS the core of the game.If you just want to hang out you're far better off playing simple card or board games. RPGs are utterly terrible at this.
>>98954399>Has amnesia>Just wants to see the world!Because my character is unfamiliar with your world.>Is quiet and reserved>Just here for the rideI'm a retard introvert IRL so how could I possibly play an extrovert without dying of cringe?
>>98954399>Has amnesiaIf they have amnesia, then they would lack any memory of their combat abilities. There are lots of types of amnesia one could have, but none would work like this. Also, remind the player that their character not remembering is not an excuse for them to not tell you their character's backstory.
>>98954399>Has amnesia?Rookie mistake. That's just asking the GM to fuck you over.Never seen a player dumb enough to choose that, desu.>Why do most players make NPCs instead of player characters?Never felt that as a GM, but then again I don't ask for detailed backstory, just the bare minimum to get the game going.As a player, I remember a GM doing the opposite just to ignore them in the end, total waste of time.How about letting players build their character's story by playing the game?
>>98954399NPC players are whatever, they're fine. Boring or uninspired, sure, but ultimately harmless.Main Character players, though? Ugh...
>>98961611>taking the initiative and driving the plot forward is bad for some reason
>>98954399I hope that the first time you get to play a game none of your players challenges you with one of these simple concepts.