[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Roll dice with "dice+numberdfaces" in the options field (without quotes).

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1588786861205.jpg (211 KB, 1200x1199)
211 KB JPG
Ever get into a new RPG and think to yourself "Damn, that's an interesting world people wrote, I wonder what's the tax policy there?"?
>>
>>98956627
Sometimes I go "There's an awful lot of unoccupied territory that is perfectly habitable." but not really
>>
>>98956627
Ever read a tax policy and wonder how it would work in your favorite RPG setting?
>>
>>98956639
Feudal taxes were often meant to cripple potential rivals. And if you overtaxed your free peasants, they'd just go to someone else. So the best thing to do is tax everyone noble under you harshly and give your free men the least taxes to ensure your lands are the most visited and plentiful.
>>
>>98956627
I will never mention taxes, tax policy, or taxation in any way except the broadest sense unless the current quest is about taxes specifically
>>
>>98956640
Of course, this historically led to a lot of revolts. But what better excuse to imprison and ransom for an exorbitant sum with the reminder of what will happen if they rebel ever again.
>>
>>98956627
Said this and yet his books have about as much about taxation as Malazan, yet with half the story and depth, which amounts to some off- handed grumbling by soldiers. I fucking hate pseudo-intellectuals, fat ones even more
>>
>>98956653
a good rule of thumb is that if your players dont care, then you dont need to bring it up except in the absreact
if your players actually do go around asking questions, then thats a good jumping off point to go on some quest that involves working your way up the taxation ladder
>>
>>98956653
it's way too easy to rip apart martin's ridiculous pastiche of feudalism

The languages make no sense, the history makes no sense, the geography makes no sense, the architecture makes no sense, the customs make no sense, the army compositions make no sense, the battles make no sense, the theological institutions make no sense, the citadel's monopoly on education makes no sense, and the peoples make no sense.
>>
>>98956666
>>98956653
The takeaway is more just how low the standards for fantasy are
>>
>>98956627
I still find it funny how badly worded comments meant more to be a value neutral contrast what him and Tolkien valued in their stories combined with obnoxious secondaries dickriding the show but shitting on other fantasy media made the fat man into the mortal enemy of classic fantasy nerds when he is just a journeyman scfi writer who was really good at doing character PoV writing and developing a background political scene where one noble house has like 50 different named bit players that can become important at any moment without it feeling like an asspull.
>>
>>98956627
No, but I often wonder to myself "how is this going to end?"
>>
>>98956674
You're kidding, right?
Nothing about sci-fi makes any sense. It's just psuedo-science nonsense listed off for mindless retards to consume.
>>
>>98956679
Don't market your work as superior and accurate then if you don't want to be judged for the same thing your judging others for.
>>
>>98956686
Oh. It's you.
>>
>>98956679
It's just online Christians desperate for a win over The Bad Guy™.
>>
>>98956693
who lives rent-free in your head?
>>
>>98956627
no but i read the game of thrones books and i found it strange how there's no mention of tax policies anywhere. hell there's a important bank but it's not explained how they work or maintain their power. guess no one taxes them. oh well it's probably not important.
>>
Kek it's really him
>>
>>98956688
Pointing out a hypothetical for the kinds of things you care more about compared to one of your icons is not the same as denigrating said icon for not doing them no matter how many secondaries try to use it as an out of context dunking point.
>>
>>98956719
cope
>>
>>98956719
But he was denigrating him?
You don't seriously think Jaime can beat Aragorn in a fight, do you?
>>
so why are people so autistic about tax policy?
it can be fun for your players to be suddenly hit by the taxman and make a joke about how the players actually have to contribute to society once in the blue moon, but acting like its an imperative that you must include is just silly
>>
>>98956728
why did he say that stupid shit
jesus fucking christ
write your fucking book, fatass
>>
>>98956730
the greatest and most realistic fantasy author said that tax policies must be a focus element of all fantasy worlds. he gets to not include them in his own books because he's a genius, you're not a genius so just write about the local lord's tax policy ok?
>>
>>98956721
Nah i know George has his fuckup, dude is shit at scale and tries to solve writers block by shifting focus over to a different side tangent for hundreds of pages at a time (the first three books were meant to be book 1 of 3 and books 4&5 were meant to be a 5 year timeskip between books 1 and 2), but the man did not give that Tolkien comparison with malice in his heart.
>>98956728
I don't personally think so, but as I said, George generally is bad at scale, including the power scaling on his characters and for a character like Jamie who's arc is "master swordsman who thinks of himself as a weapon but is crippled and has to find a new purpose in life" he is going to bloat the capability of them.
ironically he isn't even the most skilled swordsman in the books, that would be the King Arthur Expy Arthur Dayne.
>>
>>98956653
Fat people, in general, seem to have weak intellects. Lack of self-control is a symptom of mental inferiority.
>>
File: seiginomihahaha.png (46 KB, 900x883)
46 KB PNG
>>98956719
You're right. And Martin tells greatly of feudal obligations and contracts, truly. Middle age customs, beliefs, and structures. Such astonishing accuracy! Everyone but the king is a lord! The faith is nothing but a tool for the ruling class! Commoners are retarded do nothing folk and everyone employed by nobles has free reign to do as they please as they magically have no family among the local populace or poisons in their terrain! Battles are won with a hearty cavalry charge! Honor is for fools who don't have their word immediately believed by everyone because why would an honorless back-stabbing noble lie? Oh yes! Such brilliance and detail. You could wipe out an opposing army or ruler under a peace flag and face no consequence nor adversity from such an act. I am astonished! ASTONISHED!

The damage Martin and "modern fantasy" writers have done to knowledge and understanding of the middle ages is worse than what Disney and 343 have done to Star Wars and Halo respectively.
>>
>>98956760
>uhmm it doesn't have the rank of marquis so it's le bad mmkay?
Who gives a fuck lmao, he's not writing the routledge companion to medieval europe here.
>You could wipe out an opposing army or ruler under a peace flag and face no consequence nor adversity from such an act
Wait a minute, you didn't read the books at all!
>>
>>98956760
Yeah, the moment the Warden system was introduced in book 1 as four ostensibly permanent high marcher lord positions when only the north with its 700 foot tall Hadrian's wall expy made of ice had contested territory on its continental border was the moment the feudal realism went out the fucking window in a bad way.
However the backstabbing is less a matter of "lol evil wins good is stupid" and more a matter of him not writing the last fucking books where the generations of upstanding conduct from the Starks that gave them an ironclad loyalty from most of the north that is willing to start the war back up almost immediately after a Stark heir was believed to be found is rewarded, while the coldblooded Lannister treachery led to the architect getting killed on the toilet by his son who hated him, leaving leadership to his idiot daughter who is tanking the whole project, and the guys who carried out the treachery directly fall into messy civil war, all pays off.
>>
>>98956782
Oh, I'm sorry? Were the basic system in which you have several plots revolve around not something you cared about?
>MUH NORTH REMEMBERS
Motherfucker, the entire continent would know after that. Every single lord in the Riverlands and North would openly rise up against the Bolton and the Freys. They wouldn't have armies because their men would know they're being led by absolute fucking madmen who've made them accomplices to a generational fuck up on every end of the social contract imaginable.

No one in the other kingdoms would want to be associated with them. If the high septon or sparrow as it is now had any power or anything resembling ecclesiarchal authority which Westeros plainly fucking lacks, he would've declared everyone responsible for it excommunicated, meaning illegitimate and everyone has a sacred duty to depose them. But no. Martin's world runs off psuedo-intellectualism and vain dreams of being the American Tolkien.
>>
>>98956688
This, basically.
>>
>>98956782
>>98956795
And before your dumbass says anything
>hostages
Escape from lack of guards or with assistance of deserting guards.
>muh not grievous enough for excommunicado
The guy responsible for burning Joan of Arc was excommunicated. A Roman emperor for ordering a massacre. A French king for basic immorality. Everyone participating in a vile or heretical act. Most, of course, are for theological reasons and disputing papal authority, but you get the fucking drift. No way is the spiritual moral authority figure staying silent.
>>
>>98956782
who cares? the only thing i could think about when i read his books was "what's the FUCKING point in all this, it's all pointless i just want to see the starks's tax policy"
>>
>>98956795
I don't care the slightest about those systems mapping exactly onto our real life equivalents, no not at all. You really can not bring up "the customs in this fantasy world are not the same as in real life medieval europe" and expect me to take it seriously.
(Also if we wanna get into the nitty gritty there is the title of knight which is of lower rank than lord)
As for the red wedding shit, yeah bro all that shit is happening?
The freys are only in power because they're backed by the lannister-tyrell alliance who, for now, reign supreme (and controlled the high septon until very recently).
All their bannermen hate them, the north hates them, their neighbours in the vale hate them if I have my sansa chapters right, so even ostensibly neutral parties see through their lies of "they attacked first".
They're poised for a civil war once their 90+ yo patriarch dies, and members of their house are dropping likes flies because spitting in the face of guest right means others don't feel the need to respect it back to you (brotherhood without banners, wyman manderly)
Tldr read the books if you wanna whine. There's plenty of genuine shit to complain about
>>
>>98956795
NTA (I'm the other anon responding)
I mean the high sparrow did step in eventually and is putting Cersei on trial but the real reason its not as intense on that end of things is because in the LoreTM the evil Henry the 8th expy used his dragon and dragon derived military might to crush the faith's militant arm and then after he was killed his just and archetypical lawgiver nephew successor politicked the church into never reclaiming that military power.
As for the more noble side of things Essos is all a bunch of oriental schemers who don't care as long as they are paid and the riverlands just recently had to be militarily crushed into submission.
Meanwhile in the North things stalled out because the only Stark publicly accounted for until the Jeyne Poole deception was a bastard who was disbarred from the line of succession. That and Wyman playing 8d chess by faking subservience until the time is right since he knows Rickon is on Skagos.
>>
>>98956817
>You really can not bring up "the customs in this fantasy world are not the same as in real life medieval europe" and expect me to take it seriously.
Then you cannot bring up taxes in relation to a fantasy world and expect me to take you fucking seriously.
>>
>>98956818
The church had very little military power. What they did have was religious authority. This effectively gave them an insane amount of soft power that bordered on hard with how the pope could just excommunicate and socially fuck anyone he didn't like. Not having a military arm wouldn't mean a fucking thing if nobles were religious in any meaningful capacity, which they are not.
>>
>>98956829
Baelor the blessed 4d chessed the high septon out of all his power by building a bigass cathedral in the capital and having the high septon move there. Since then they've been nothing but puppets of the crown.
They've been permanently avignoned, except in this scenario avignon is paris.
>>
>>98956817
Knights are not nobility. They were contracted professional soldiers in real life and actually a vaguely religious title in Westeros. On another note, knights being le dudes with armor that ride horses is fucking retarded, but that's hardly here or there or unique to Martin.

It's "happening" in the same way erosion happens to a rock. In the same way grapes turn into wine. In the same way GRRM writes the Winds of Winter.

And this biding their time conspiracy shit is some literal comical nonsense. You'd think a man who made a plot all about how Dorne took too long to actually do anything for revenge would realize how ridiculous picking off the rival nobles seventh cousin by seventh cousin is.
>>
>>98956830
how convenient the western schism didn't arise
>>
>>98956830
>>98956838
In all the Targaryen's spent a good chunk of multiples rulers lives over their 300 year tenureship of Westros chipping away at the power of The Seven on the continent and taking that authority into the monarchy instead.
Which is why it took till Roberts Rebellion vaporizing the Targaryen authority and the War of the Five Kings subsequent au8thority and power vacuum for the Faith of the Seven to reassert itself.
Like off the top of my head, Aegon the Conqueror burned the rose of faithful knightly valor on the field of fire and erased the grand knightly order of the south outside of the Manderleys who had moved north in the centuries beforehand.
Maegor did the aforementioned destruction of the faith militant.
Jaehaerys got the church to back the belief in Targaryen Exceptionalism that let them do direct incest and in doing so undermine a core precept.
Then their was a lull in the faith being directly involved for 60 or so years till Baelor
And after that it was over and stuck for a century.
>>
>>98956851
What religious monarchal authority? No one has actual respect for the crown. Religion may as well not exist. Westeros has no right to be as together as it is even with all the rebellions, not after nearly 200 years without dragons to enforce anything.
>>
>>98956836
Knights are definitely low nobility in the late medieval ages aren't they?
Besides I meant knightly house in regards to titles, like the cleganes or templetons or conningtons.
>>98956858
Eh there's multiple great houses that really are only in power because the targs installed them, it was in their best interest to have the dynasty continue as that's essentially where they derived their legitimacy from.
Most notably the tyrells, but also the baratheons and to an extent the tullys and greyjoys.
Only when you get to a real nutjob like aerys ii where this loyalty starts to fall apart
>>
>>98956874
Knights explicitly could hold lands and declared oaths to give military service in return for reward and said land. They lacked legal authority and status as nobles did. It's similar but still not the same. Both have different rights and one clearly has more authority than the other.
>>
>>98956666
Amazing quads checked btw

Yeah, I’m gonna have to check your work where on these chief. Like this seems like nitpicking. I don’t like the guy for choosing to make an post modern deconstruction of fantasy, then loving fantasy too much so he makes a bunch of side plot lines and then gets stuck because wrapping them up sucks dick. Like at some point stories have to collapse and become stories otherwise you are just making an academic ethnography. No thank you.
>>
>>98956874
Baratheon is directly from Durrandon's female line. The River Lords settled on the Tully's and never disputed it, so their rule is legitimate enough. The Greyjoys were voted in too and somehow not once disputed, so they're legitimate enough. Only the Tyrells have any standing to lose. Frankly, it's a miracle they've lasted as long as they have when apparently every house has a dynastic claim on the throne.
>>
>>98956838
I mean, would the western schism have erupted if all of catholic europe was united into a single political entity?
>>98956901
Like half of asoiaf's issues can be traced to george absolutely falling in love with the targs
>>
>>98956653
>story and depth
Filling your book with unexplained proper nouns is not depth, Erikson.
>>
>>98956901
>Languages
Westeros alone is the size of South America and everyone speaks the same tongue after millennia and two subsequent foreign invasions with massive land barriers between each other to prevent communication and thus language cohesiveness in a time before fucking common literacy.
>History
The houses have ruled for thousands of years. The same ones. In the exact same territories. Do I really need to go into how unlikely this is? Even the longest reigning dynasty in Japan is only so because it's just a tradition and not like they have any real authority.
>Geography
Dorne is on the same line of the equator as Lys and Lys isn't a desert. Same could be said of Ibben and the North in regards to arctic climate. Common fuckup but still.
>Architecture
For fuck's sake, must I point out the ridiculous size of the castles requiring a country's worth of quarry to even maintain?
>Customs
Three words. Trial by combat. This simply destroys whatever legal system that is never really elaborated on. Because this was only an option when a verdict couldn't be decided. Giving nobles this utterly ridiculous get out of jail free card is some Disney villain shit.
>Army Composition
Why on god's green earth would you go into battle with literal inexperienced and unequipped fucking peasants? No, levies were not the primary military unit because someone needs to work the fields. Why is the Vale so cavalry focused in a fucking mountain range? Where are the damn archers?
>Battles
No, you are not turning an army in the middle of a battle against itself by dressing up in distinct armor. You are not willingly sending a small army to die as a distraction or even getting away with it. How the fuck does everyone get caught off-guard by armies in the tens of thousands? You'd fucking hear them coming. No, do not split your force by a dozen time, you retarded fuck.
>Theological Institutions
Man, read the thread. I couldn't' have put it better myself.
>>98956829
>>
>>98956901
>The Citadel
Modern education came from religion. That was the entire point of monasteries and the like. Before that, nobles hired tutors and what not or people reputed to be knowledgeable. Why does everyone confide in the maesters? How the hell do they have so much academic authority to begin with? They have to literally travel across entire countries worth of landscape. It'd be too easy for them to get waylaid and lost. Why not hire someone local who knows a thing or two?
>The peoples
In the same way language should've been different from social isolation, damn near everyone should be an entirely different race and separated into racial groups of ethnic tribes. One group of relatively isolated mountain men from another. One group of ice wasteland dweller from one reach of the north to the other. Valemen all hating each other for being from a different tribe settlement in each crook and cranny. The Dornish are somehow the most like how it would be but for all the wrong reasons.
>>
>>98956627
I also think about how they shit, where, how often, and what it smells like.
>>
>>98956968
>languages
Actually a valid point, but imo understandable given this is a story at the end of the day
>history
The thousands of year stuff is doubted in-universe, it's probably more like irl trojan larp than actual history beyond a certain point.
Besides, westeros seems to have a tradition where if the last surviving member of a house is female, her husband and children take her name. The lannisters are one such example, the current heir to the arryns a hardyng who will probably take the arryn name. There's a counterexample with the baratheons to be fair, but that was a bit of a special case.
>geography
I mean I'm sure I don't have to tell you this but there's more to climate than just latitude. London is at the same latitude as the southern hudson bay, same with new mexico and georgia.
>castle size
I mean, aside from harrenhal, are they?
>customs
Trial by combat is retarded yeah, but on the other hand ...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_by_combat
>battles
Actually a valid complaint
>>
>>98957069
>The thousands of year stuff is doubted in-universe, it's probably more like irl trojan larp than actual history beyond a certain point.
Cheap post-modernist bullshit. They wouldn't doubt what little records they have, especially in that goddamn time.
>Besides, westeros seems to have a tradition where if the last surviving member of a house is female, her husband and children take her name. The lannisters are one such example, the current heir to the arryns a hardyng who will probably take the arryn name. There's a counterexample with the baratheons to be fair, but that was a bit of a special case.
They would've been overthrown by a claimant from a married off daughter that preferred their own name to their grandmother's eventually
>I mean I'm sure I don't have to tell you this but there's more to climate than just latitude. London is at the same latitude as the southern hudson bay, same with new mexico and georgia.
they are literally right across sunspear and share the same ocean
>I mean, aside from harrenhal, are they?
Yes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZdbpfcxfSk
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_by_combat
For fuck's sake anon this is literally here: was a method of Germanic law to settle accusations in the absence of witnesses or a confession. There is massive difference between this and just letting everything be settled by it. It even goes into detail about settling land disputes through it instead of war. Jesus.
>>
>>98957069
>>98957094
Must've been those le heckin maesters trying to control everything.
Why did GRRM keep adding retarded plots that will go nowhere?
>>
File: Jodhpur-2.jpg (139 KB, 800x600)
139 KB JPG
>>98957094
>they wouldn't doubt what records they had
The forged donation of constantine was exposed in the early 15th century, and was (apparently though I can't vouch for this) contested since the 11th.
>they would've been overthrown by a claimant [...] that preferred their own name eventually
Now you're just making headcanon up for no reason lol
>they sit across the same ocean
Cape verde is a stone's throw away from the sahara
>castles
Idk I'm not seeing anything impossibly large. Real life has shit like picrel too. Also stuff like osaka, mont saint michel, osaka castle, the arg-e bam, krak des chevaliers, ... shit could get proper big
>trial by combat
Like I said, retarded but could be stretched into something more believable if you headcanon some stipulations. Since you're already doing that I will too :)
>>
>>98957069
>it's probably more like irl trojan larp than actual history beyond a certain point
Romaboo here. The claims to Troy Rome made weren't completely unfounded. And by that, I mean there were Greek (Hellas) thinkers, Hellanicus of Lesbos and Damastes of Sigeumt, that thought Rome may have been founded by the outcast Trojans by Aeneas. The Roman statue of Romulus and Remus originates around the same time. Pyrrhus larped as Achilles and named Rome Troy centuries after the initial claims. So they accepted it. Rome then fulfilling the sentiment and forewarning that Troy would return for its lost land only helped.

Hilariously Dionysius of Halicarnassus tried to double back and say Romans were Greeks all along.

Rome was obviously influenced by Hellens and Etruscan civilization due to its proximity to both. It was obviously closer and more inclined to the Etruscans, adopting their customs and culture while syncretizing their gods with the Greeks'. The Etruscans were closer and better linked to Troy but lack the same mythological outcast aspect. Rome advanced so much and was on the border of both but outside of Greek influence to the point they could very well be Troy, so they may as well have been to everyone else.
>>
>>98956653
You should read the context, literally taken out of context 99% of the time
>>
You autistic faggots always do this shit.

He was talking about how he loved LOTR when it was big in the 70's but he wanted a more realpolitik fantasy setting. He wasn't literally demanding to know what Aragorn's tax policy was like.
>>
>>98957147
>The forged donation of constantine was exposed in the early 15th century, and was (apparently though I can't vouch for this) contested since the 11th.
Are we really going to compare maester book keeping to a multi-continental religious administration?
>Now you're just making headcanon up for no reason lol
How do you think houses like the Tudors came into existence?
>Cape verde is a stone's throw away from the sahara
Yes
It's a fucking desert.
It's only green during raining season.
Holy fuck, dude.
>Idk I'm not seeing anything impossibly large. Real life has shit like picrel too. Also stuff like osaka, mont saint michel, osaka castle, the arg-e bam, krak des chevaliers, ... shit could get proper big
I can just post the biggest castle fanart and that'll probably get by you, won't it?
>Like I said, retarded but could be stretched into something more believable if you headcanon some stipulations. Since you're already doing that I will too :)
Fuck off.
>>
I don't know anything about any of this, but the fact there's so much that can be debated in the first place is a bad sign.
>>
>>98957069
>>98957117
>>98957147
>>98957183
I do think houses being in power for thousands of years is bullshit. But also them forging it is also bullshit? Why would you even do that? And why would you make it last thousands of years? It's just ridiculous. All of it's so damn ridiculous.
>>
>>98956743
>tax policies must be a focus element of all fantasy worlds.
It's literally impossible to read Martin's statement as saying that.
>>
>>98957211
For the same reason Martin added the Sand Snakes. The entire Dornish plot, really. Fucking Faegon. Euron. He just started spiraling in circles and making up weird shit or adding new characters and plots that make no sense or waste your time.
>>
>>98957213
But when he was reading Tolkien he was really wondering about that tax policy.
>>
>>98957183
>Are we really going to compare maester book keeping to a multi-continental religious administration?
That actually seems very comparable yes. Don't know how that relates to the donation of constantine.
Besides nobody's forging anything per se, it's just that written records only go so far back and beyond that it's just shrouded in legend. There's no way to really verify that say the durrandons were really in power for however many thousands of years. They can't even read first men runes iirc.
>how do you think houses like the tudors came into existence
Right, and I'm saying when that sort of stuff happens in asoiaf they *usually* just take the name of the previous ruling dynasty for legitimacy. Even in the counterexample of baratheon they still took the arms and motto of the durrandons. Read next time.
>climate
Cope. The damn thing is called cape verde. Verde.
If you want another example, java and western australia.
>fanart
Who gives a fuck, again fuckoff huge castles existed in real life. This is not a serious concern for anyone reading fantasy, you just wanted an extra reason to whine for some reason.
>fuck off
:)
>>
guys, why is greenland not green?
it's got green in its name!
>>
>ASoIaF is realistic fantasy ACKSHULLY
>WAIT NOT LIKE THAT
>>
>>98956627
>Winters can last 10 years bro

So why doesn't everyone fucking die?
>>
>>98957260
Don't think about it. GRRM certainly didn't.
>>
>>98957252
Actually the southern part would genuinely be really green a thousand years ago
>>
>>98956627
Whenever I get into a new RPG (that I didn't write myself) my only thought is if it's going to be yet another waste of time with any combination of dice pools, storyteller-may-I, preachy preludes and flavor text, and/or theater kid bullshit.
I enjoy games, not what /qst/fags like to call games.
>>
Martin cannot into scale
>Army of 250,000!!!
Would strip the land bare in days without a robust supply chain
Or social impact of religion
>Sept of Baelor blows up; no one cares
Set the Vatican on fire and watch Catholics around the world just shrug
Or politics
>Bran has best story so is best king
Honestly an elected monarchy, chosen by powerful nobles isn't the worst idea, and I'm sure it's happened in real life. But it would be the head of an established House (or their puppet), not Fantasy Professor X
>>
>>98957094
>Cheap post-modernist bullshit. They wouldn't doubt what little records they have, especially in that goddamn time.
People in the past absolutely considered the validity of the text they had. e.g. here's Plutarch on the Amazons:
> 27 1 Well, then, such were the grounds for the war of the Amazons, which seems to have been no trivial nor womanish enterprise for Theseus. For they would not have pitched their camp within the city, nor fought hand to hand battles in the neighbourhood of the Pnyx and the Museum, had they not mastered the surrounding country and approached the city with impunity. 2 Whether, now, as Hellanicus writes, they came round by the Cimmerian Bosporus, which they crossed on the ice, may be doubted; but the fact that they encamped almost in the heart of the city is attested both by the names of the localities there and by the graves of those who fell in battle.

Notice that he's willing to believe that the Amazons are definitely real because of the gravesites, but he's like yeah I don't think the Bosporus iced over bro. People in the past weren't retarded, they just had way lower quality sources and fewer people looking them over with a fine-toothed comb.
>>
>>98957281
elected monarchies were incredibly unstable
and bran is immortal so why go with elective anyway
>>
>>98957281
Most of this shit is post-martin show nonsense to be fair
Also isn't bran the head of house stark st this point?
>>
File: 1794664629466240.jpg (93 KB, 1024x1020)
93 KB JPG
>>98956760

Interesting list of complaints no doubt *entirely* grounded in purely historical interest.
>>
>>98957287
My point, which I should have really specified, is that Westerosi are fucking retarded and don't bother to write anything down, so why doubt? They're already too stupid to do something as simple as that. All their records are kept by maesters for whatever reason. And they're fine with the multi milennia lineages. They have no local wise men. Man in tower say so. So it must be true.

This kind of, it was probably something else tho lol, shit just reeks of post-modernist nonsense. Even in the record you gave, the man at least gives credence. He's still wrong because steppe societes were extremely confined to sex roles. The Scythians, basis of Amazons, buried their women with weapons as a custom.
>>
>>98957302
Is it really hard to believe I am in love with middle age history and utterly fucking despise the absolute misunderstanding and slander by people who cannot even be bothered to read?
No, tiktok AI videos narrating do not count.
>>
>>98957303
>My point, which I should have really specified, is that Westerosi are fucking retarded and don't bother to write anything down, so why doubt?
Because they are humans endowed by their creator with reason.

If your argument is that the entire setting should be written as full of retards, then I don't find that to be a credible or compelling argument. If it is written that way elsewhere, that's bad; it is a corrective to write them as less retarded in other scenes.
>>
>>98957303
>The Scythians, basis of Amazons, buried their women with weapons as a custom.
Specifically, some of them were. Which is enough to denote a special status, likely nobility or just being prized as tools like weapons are valuable. Muh battle wounds were in all likelihood from just falling off a horse or hurt by a raiding rival horde.
>>
>>98957316
>If your argument is that the entire setting should be written as full of retards
But, anon... it's already that
that's my point
like, the entire point of my list

nothing about grrm's fantasy world makes any sense
>>
>>98957319
>buried with weapons
>has battle wounds
>contemporaries mentioned them having female warriors
>we know many societies, including our own, had a non-zero number of female warriors even if war was typically male
>but they weren't warriors okay
okay bro
>>
>>98957330
Damn, you can't disprove god exists, so he exists.
>>
>>98957334
You can find a body buried with weapons and battle wounds that was assumed to be a man, until people looked at the pelvis and saw it was a woman, and that actually doesn't prove anything. What truly defines historical gender roles is not something so mundane as evidence, but Romaboos on Xitter complaining about "the longhouse" (a thing they basically made up).
>>
>>98957324
No anon, you started bitching that it should be impossible for people to disbelieve records (despite multiple people providing real life examples)
>>
Traditional games?
>>
>>98957341
This is just us talking past each other at this point.
>>98957340
what did he mean by this
>>
>>98957351
Yeah well whose fault is that
>>
>>98956627
No, because it's never going to be relevant to any game run in that setting.
>>
>>98957201
I'd argue the exact opposite
>>
>>98957366
okay
>>
>>98956627
Leave the murderhobo mindless dungeon runs to the new players who have to ask every time what to add to their attack roll.

For veteran players if your GM hasn't at least hinted at enough of the setting for you to infer the tax policy, then it's your job to force the issue with the local Lord.
>>
File: We live in a society.png (580 KB, 742x748)
580 KB PNG
>>98957340

>longhouse
>made up

According to archaeology, anthropology, and history we were disorganized cavemen for over 250,000 years. The first great kings and priests realized that they could motivate normal guys to work and risk their lives in battle by making sure they had wives and children so we rapidly saw stuff like metallurgy and space travel in a geological blink of an eye.

Whereas women seem to want a return to the prehistorical social dynamics where the women would run out and get impregnated by Cave Chad from the next valley over and older women and a handful of surviving beta males would help raise the children when they were born.
>>
>>98956649
>this led to revolts
the opposite led to revolts in the best case, but famines in the worst case.

Overtaxing nobles led to coups, wars, assassinations, and general nobility infighting that made up the politics of the time. A balancing act of keeping the right influential figures on your side.
>>
>>98957400
>Whereas women seem to want a return to the prehistorical social dynamics where the women would run out and get impregnated by Cave Chad
you were doing so well until your retarded incel brainwashing kicked in.
Literally no women think like that. You have your history but it's time to actually talk to people outside.
>>
>>98957418
you don't know a lot of women do you
>>
File: 5NationsExpansion[1].jpg (45 KB, 441x443)
45 KB JPG
>>98957400
No, this is all total bullshit that you made up.

There's a real society in actual history that was called the People of the Longhouse, they're also known as the Iroquois or the Haudenosaunee and they comically stomped all over with a tiny-ass population of like 10k people total. They were matriarchal, too.

>The first great kings and priests realized that they could motivate normal guys to work and risk their lives in battle by making sure they had wives and children so we rapidly saw stuff like metallurgy and space travel in a geological blink of an eye.
Nope, it was caused by the consistent environment enabling agriculture, that's why agriculture is almost simultaneously developed across the planet including in totally disconnected places. This enabled increasing population densities, which improved tech development for the same reason you expect tech to be developed in San Francisco or Shenzhen, not Montana or Qinghai.

>image
Not true, also. Just a complete misreading of the data. Patrilocal societies produce relative genetic concentration of surviving Y chromosomes because all the guys in a village end up with the same Y chromosome after a while, and then if anything happens to that village, that Y chromosome disappears. The inverse happens in matrilocal societies: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11528385/
>>
>>98957422
>no u
the way he folds.
>>
>>98957431
>it was caused by the consistent environment enabling agriculture
NTA, This part can also be described as "finding a river valley delta in a temperate climate". Isn't it funny how every single instance of that bit of geography happening seems to have an ancient civilization that formed on it.

Must have been clever chad priests though. There's no way there's any other explanation.
>>
>>98957177
So then why didn’t he write a more realpolitik fantasy setting?
>>
>>98956653
>>98956935
>check wiki page
>makes a point of noting the author's attention to "gender equality"
yes yes. sounds like topnotch organic worldbuilding.
>>
>>98957701
Because he didn't know how. That has nothing to do with whether wanting a more realpolitik fantasy setting is wrong, though, nor does it change the context of what quite into Martin actually shitting on Tolkien or asking for details on literal tax policy or anything like that.
>>
>>98957808
>in a world with supernaturally strong humans there exist supernaturally strong women as well as men
just admit you hate women. it's not great but honesty is superior to hypocrisy
>>
>>98957247
you are going to break my brain with your climate retardation.
Yes, asoiaf has retarded climate but your example sucks and actively negates your point.
climate is heavily dependent on wind movements and therefore currents movements along with a ton of other atmospheric conditions etc etc
latitude means very little.
Sahara was a lush region filled with large lakes not that long ago geologically.
the reasons why dorne being a desert is retarded are so many but latitude isnt one of them really
>>
>>98957930
Yeah I know anon, that's what I am arguing for lol
>>
File: greasy pepperoni fart.jpg (111 KB, 1163x912)
111 KB JPG
>>98956627
>>
>>98957983
yeah i wanted to reply to the anon you were talking with but i fucked up
>>
>>98957900
Look, for posterity, here’s the whole quote
> Ruling is hard. This was maybe my answer to Tolkien, whom, as much as I admire him, I do quibble with. Lord of the Rings had a very medieval philosophy: that if the king was a good man, the land would prosper. We look at real history and it’s not that simple. Tolkien can say that Aragorn became king and reigned for a hundred years, and he was wise and good. But Tolkien doesn’t ask the question: What was Aragorn’s tax policy? Did he maintain a standing army? What did he do in times of flood and famine? And what about all these orcs? By the end of the war, Sauron is gone but all of the orcs aren’t gone – they’re in the mountains. Did Aragorn pursue a policy of systematic genocide and kill them? Even the little baby orcs, in their little orc cradles?
It’s a stupid quote. It’s the same kind of Cracked/Reddit gotcha thinking that makes people ask if every single dancing fork in Beauty and the Beast is a former servant or ask if there were any civilian contractors on the Death Star. It’s refusing to accept a mythic archetype, willfully ignorant of symbolism
But beyond that, it’s not even about realpolitik like you said. It’s just about how even good men can screw stuff up in power. But he literally is saying ‘Tolkien didn’t answer the questions about taxes, standing armies, disaster relief, etc.’ in a way that implies that’s what he set out to do
And then he didn’t
It’s a stupid quote and everyone in this thread is right to clown on him, and I can’t wait for him to die and have some two-bit fantasy writer finish his books so we can all collectively get over the whole thing
>>
>>98958382
Is it stupid? It's just pointing out that, as great as tolkien's legacy is, it didn't bother engaging with some stuff that grrm wanted to engage with.
>>
>>98956629
>let's all be bugmen
>>
>>98956627
Are adventurers taxed?
>>
>>98958397
And then GRRM didn’t engage with the stuff he said he was going to! He’s just trying to look smarter than he is by saying
>um actually guys kings have to do a lot of paperwork and stuff
and then building just the most flat, uninformed picture of feudal society anyway
>>
>>98958397

That would be fine, but Tokien does touch on the topic.

>And the King pardoned the Easterlings that had given themselves up, and sent them away free, and he made peace with the peoples of Harad; and the slaves of Mordor he released and gave to them all the lands about Lake Nurnen to be their own. And there were brought before him many to receive his praise and reward for their valour; and last the captain of the Guard brought to him Beregond to be
judged.

I think George generally points out fine criticism about the genre, but he just had a brain fart with that one.

>>98958403

He DOES have plot points about taxes and money. They... aren't that good (in general terms he doesn't really have a solid grasp about the middle ages or the many basic mechanics of a pre-industrial society), but he does engage with it.
>>
>he doesn't know what a latidunal zone is
Pointing out Dorne is literally surrounded by water would've been better, I'm not going to lie. The mountain ranges sepearating Dorne from the rest of Westeros aren't preventing that water to land air drift. But that still raises the question as to how the places close to Dorne aren't desert as a result of it being a desert too.
>>
>>98958455
NTAYRT but. It really just sounds like he's an Ideas Guy left unattended for too long. Engaging in other's works ≠ executing it yourself after all.

And that's assuming he's actually interested in the topics he yaps about in his blogposts.
>>
>>98958588

Yeeeeah wouldn't say Tolkien passes much climatollogy checks either tough.

Funny thing is, if Dorne was on the western side of the continent it would be already something. You certainly couldn't make the Neck rivers make sense but still.
>>
>>98958658
Martin released his first ASOIAF book in the late 90s, he really has no excuse to not just do some more research on this stuff
>>
>>98958658
>Yeeeeah wouldn't say Tolkien passes much climatollogy checks either tough.
Tolkien also has the issue of him letting his map's proportions wrong on purpose.
>>
>>98958658
The Neck being the only marsh in westeros and oh so conveniently placed between the North and the rest, an arctic tundra and grassland. Yeah, yeah. Children of the Forest. Where does the water still flow into it to keep it a marsh in the first place?

And there's the nonsense that is the rivers. Does Martin really not know when a happy cold wind and a really high peak love each other very much it makes a water baby? Where are the mountains? The Vale should be the Rivers.
>>
>>98958735
There's bogs in the crownlands for what it's worth
>>
>>98958672

True, but I think rainshadow was pretty common knwoledge in the fifties, which doesn't sound good for Tolkien's forest placement patterns. Or, if you prefer, sometimes I wonder what the fuck keep Eriador that much treeless. My money is migrating neekerbreekers hjinks.
No, that doesn't ruin it, anyway less than GRRM's strange mediterrean climates. Still, this is up to what do Misty Mountains orcs eat in my top ME worlbulding funny questions.

(ME get a free pass cause generally the "magical special effects" are what causes the stranger geographical phenomena, but for someone loving trees so much he... could've done something more realstic from time to time)
>>
>>98958740
It rains and snows that much? There isn't a single river that flows through it. How do they even live there?
>>
>>98958740
>>98958751
And I mean the entire eastern part, not King's Landing of course.
>>
>>98958735

I think he basically wanted to do a colder Florida with added geographical chokepoint-ing (so far so good, at least not considering sea transport) and just winged up the Trident's river system another day. Funnily enough it would probably be pretty simple to just put the Green River'source somewhere else. Oh well.

>>98958756

My impression was that there are rivers, but they're comparetively small. After all the Stormlands don't have that many rivers either on the map, but it sure rains.
>>
>>98958768
I guess they can subsist off lakes, but you'd need quite a few close by to sustain an entire population without a proper river
>>
>>98958741
>Eriador that much treeless
isn't it doggerland?
>>
>>98958774

No, I meant they're there but too short to make it on the map.
>>
>>98958816
Yeah but at that point you may as well just say nothing on the map or peoples' description of the terrain is really accurate. I've seen this a lot in ASoIaF fanfics. Where people just make up shit to fill in gaps GRRM left about basic living in his world. Guilds, actual codexes of laws, bridges, river boating services, and the North having complexes of green houses to survive winter with or grow anything at all instead of just Winterfell having one
>>
>>98958841

Eh, I think it makes sense - the scale of the thing is higher than it would be to have those rivers show up. To each his own, I'm not gonna defend fatboy to any particular degree on this.
>>
>>98957915
women becoming "as strong as men" doesn't make them equal either. you're confusing your mind's one-dimensionality with mine.
>>
>>98960019
You're right, it makes them superior, since they combine physical strength with the superior wisdom and compassion of womankind.
>>
>>98956730
George "I Didn't Finish my own novels" Really Retarded Martin, made some dumb crack about world building and how we didn't know what King Aragorn's tax policy was. Because that was super fucking important to the message of Lord of the Rings. Oh and fun fact; WE FUCKING DID KNOW HE TAX POLICY! HE RULED JUSTLY AND FAIRLY.
>>
>>98960076
eeeh, lost causes
>>
What is ASoIaF even about? Putting aside all the "world building" all the different POV characters all the "tax policies" what is the ultimate end objective and who is our protagonist.
>>
>>98960237
that's something not even martin knows at this point
>>
>>98960019
doesn't it? what makes you different from women besides having a bit more muscle on certain places and some different hormone percentages?
Are you stupid enough to think you are mentally superior somehow because you were born male?
why does tg gather the dregs of rpg humanity?
>>
>he doesn't know the honest to god physical differences between a man and women's brain
>>
>>98960294
You must be a woman to equate "unequal" with "superior". Men and women have different strengths and structure, that's it. Men cannot become women and vice versa.
>>
>>98960241
Something about winter..... and perchance a dragon
>>
>>98960237
Noble families squabble over dominion while the lost heir of the previous dynasty plots her return and a dark power in north threatens to destroy them all
Climate change allegory o algo
>>
>>98958672
>Martin released his first ASOIAF book in the late 90s, he really has no excuse to not just do some more research on this stuff

Oh there's a perfect excuse: climate doesn't fucking matter you spergs. No one gives a shit if a fantasy book's climate is realistic. People don't even care about REAL world's climate. It literally does not cross anyone's mind a single time unless they're severely autistic.
>>
>>98960306
>you must be a woman to disagree with me in such a stupid way
>btw I'm not saying women are inferior
Okay retard.

Women are superior because they'd never make such a stupid transparent argument.
>>
that's certainly a lots of words, but why has no one explained yet why martin never describes any tax policy in his books? don't tell me he's a shit storyteller who doesn't understand the importance of tax policies?
>>
>>98960789
what do you expect from a setting where each season lasts for years at best and more than a decade at worst?
this is a setting where human societies wouldn't even exist in any recognizable form
asoiaf has such a retarded background that you cant take it seriously no matter which way you look about it
>>
>>98960814
But characters swear and have sex so that means it's reaslitic right?
>>
>>98960814

I fail to see how the seasonal erratical behaviour is a problem per se, tough. If anything it's a lowkey deviation from "realism" in a setting with quite some bizzarre human genetics, fire-breathing dragons or full-fledged undead. Just say that the solar system has some fucked up gravitational pulls and meisters don't give too much of a fuck about planets to get it.
This isn't really relevant to how GRRM doesn't quite understand medieval socio-economic shit, as well.
>>
>>98956627
I often find myself reading fantasy and wondering if the local port authorities regulate the difference between fat and medium pink masts.
>>
>>98961858
Are you fucking serious?
how isn't it relevant that meaningful production f food during winter is almost zero in preindustrial societies that depend entirely on the summer harvests and preserved foods.
Well fields take the time to replenish in nutrients during that time but a continuous summers doesnt help with that really or you spend half the summer with empty fields and also food doesnt keep that well or that long so what the fuck do they even eat after a couple of years
we have records of great volcanic eruptions that basically removed summer off the seasons for one year and it had major famines and societal upheavals
Even if by some magic way food kept long enough and production was high enough which is less believable than fucking dragons they should have granaries and pantries the size of modern industrial storage facilities and way to maintain them, easily access them, organise them etc etc
Do you think under these conditions the socioeconomics would remain the same as they were in our world?
The forgotten realms is a more realistic setting than asoiaf and its not even close
>>
>>98962002

Meant about the astronomical bullshit.

Anyway we already have eternal summer zone, those are called equatorial climates. While they generally are bad for agricolture, especially for a cereal-based one, that's a thing. I wouldn't think a... ten-twenty years? Worth of summer-spring climate would DESTROY a wheat farm, altough I suppose it would make sense to describe Westeros's fields more often going fallow.

GRRM doesn't show us how winters happen in his world: for what is worth, it's more than thinkable than if there are sickness-carrying butterflies with some people immune by genetics to it, long term grains' storage is easier - ASOIAF biology is not ours one-to-one. I'll easily concede that he could've said SOMETHING about it tough.
>>
>>98962069
The problem is not the long ass summer anon, the problem is the long ass winters.
A setting with that kind of pressure would basically be unrecognisable from generic western middle ages in society, let alone all the ecological stuff. How the fuck is a bear going to hibernate for years? Even if you consider the specific examples nitpicking there are going to be enough of them to have a wildly different result.

Westeros is basically like if Harry Turtledove wrote about how aliens invaded Earth in the middle of WW2 but still had the cuban missile crisis happen.
>>
>>98962069
they donty have an eternal summer. they dont have seasons.
instead they have a wet season and a dry season and this cycle works differently from the 4 seasons but it is still a yearly cycle.
Are you also aware of how sparsely populated were these regions preindustrially?

What are you on about?
What will these mofos eat?

He doesnt show us what happens during autumn either which the season we are in. He doesnt give a fuck.
Do you think you can have any relevant monetary policy when you have handwaved how the fuck do people survive and what do they eat in your fucking setting?

What easier long term storage. Do they eat scifi nutrition pills? Where are all the granaries and pantries stockpiling a decade worth of food at minimum for the coming winter?
What crop do they have that lasts 10 years in premodern storage? Most foodstuff that isnt sealed cant last that long under modern world proper storage

You think the fat fuck has a monetary policy? Taxation in medieval societies where based upon the harvest of crops or the export of certain goods like bales of wool.
There are people in medieval england whose job is to go from village to village and do exactly that.
Well the medieval world wasnt a monolith. Feudalism wasnt even real. It is a made up thing from the 19th century to simplify whole centuries of medieval societies in many different countries across europe.
Certain places had at least at some point independent peasant land owners paying some form of local tax the same way it worked during the romans.
So how does taxation work in Dorne compared to the Vale and the Stormlands?
The fat fuck for sure doesnt know and he doesnt care.
He just wanted to make the commentary that good king doesnt mean good country and vice versa
>>
>>98962233
>they donty have an eternal summer. they dont have seasons.
>instead they have a wet season and a dry season and this cycle works differently from the 4 seasons but it is still a yearly cycle.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tropical_rainforest_climate
>>
>>98962250
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tropical_rainforest_climate
sure, this exists in a small percentage of the lands in the equator, mostly in indonesia which is by the way largely uninhabited and in the norther amazon which is entire uninhabited

Also this doesnt answer any of the other things mentioned in my post

Now unless you are g.r.r martin or his nephew stop defending the fat fuck already. it's embarrassing
>>
>>98962274
>indonesia which is by the way largely uninhabited
Nta but lmfao
>>
>>98956627
I do occasionally wonder "what the fuck do these people eat".
Coincidentally, a major question that ASOIAF never answers. Martin has no concept of logistics whatsoever. How anyone, much less entire armies, gets fed in ASOIAF is simply politely ignored. He just throws out, oh, 100,000 men on the march, for four months.. how the fuck do they manage that in a preindustrial society. They should lose half those men to famine and plague.
It's like everyone has the resources of the roman empire without the massive fields of taxed farmland that the roman empire was actually comprised of.
>>
>>98962292
Java has 60% of the population because it is the only properly inhabitable island. It is around 7% of the total land of Indonesia.
Borneo is 40% of indonesia and has around 5% of the population.
It is the place where the said climate is found
>>
>>98956627
Mystara D&D had BECMI, you find the tax policy part in the C and M manuals.
Have fun. I will.
>>
>>98962327
Idk if the wikipedia map is accurate, but if it is it does apparently cover about half of java. Not to mention sumatra, which isn't exactly sparsely populated either. Malaysia too.
>>
>>98962322
There's obviously lots of bullshit in asoiaf but george does mention supply trains all the time.
>>
>>98962292

Technically it is true that Java is the exception, but it's not like Westeros' geology excludes an abnormal fertility/fertility for longer periods.

As I understand the low fertility of "western" agricolture in the perennial rainforest is because the humus in the forest is very thin and erodes fast. Which is another situation altogether, GRRM's world would suffer from nutrient depletion from consecutive harvests (arguably? Couldn't they still rotate the fields even in a long summer?), not erosion.


>>98962322

Yeah, true about the logistics being on the fly (way better than the HBO endless empty countryside, to be fair), but one does wonder what the orcs eat in the misty mountains as well.
>>
>>98962322
>>98962404
You see, this doesn't make sense when a big deal is made about capturing territory and all the sneak attacks.

Because on top of not hearing the 20,000 in armor attacking you in the middle of the night, not a single fucking word comes out among the literal army of peasants following the actual army about their next moves?
>>
How many times did Harrenhall get taken over during the War of the Five kings? Like six? Fucking hot potato with the biggest fort in the setting
>>
Alright /tg/, let's enjoy a bit of our favorite brand of autism. Worldbuilding autism!

Say that GRRM, out of his wits and desperate because he realized he dun goofed, asks YOU how to remake Westeros/Essos in a more believable sense, retaining at least the general gist of the plot he weaved.

How would you make the agricoltural cycle of long summers/winters more believable?
>>
>>98962604
it would have to be set in modern times where we could set up hydroponics and you could kill people at a wedding and not be condemned by everyone
>>
>>98962604
- Cut size of continent by a lot. It's unrealistically politically and culturally unified for a continent that size.
- Reduce army numbers by a lot. They're incredibly large for the very poor logistics of medieval kingdoms, and there's no attempt in the story to introduce a substantial civil service to enable Chinese or Roman-style army sizes.
- Mention a lot more granaries/etc (and them getting looted) because that's the only way to make the long winters work. (They're still likely implausible but we can pretend they have better storage methods because they have to.)

>>98962619
In fairness, I'm pretty sure the idea of the Red Wedding is that yeah, the Freys did fuck up by doing that, and it ultimately leads to the destruction of their house. The problem is that Gurm takes too long to write, so the comeuppance takes forever to arrive. (Also that the Freys would know this, and so not do this.)
>>
>>98962604
In several Conan stories he would visit lost cities that had various means of growing food and light even in the darkest depths. Seemingly magical luminescent plants and jewels allowed people to grow food even in pitch blackness.
>>
>>98962603
>starts of the war team stark
>gets captured pretty early on by team lannister, left in the hands of mercenaries
>mercenaries defect to team stark some time later
>red wedding happens, most mercs desert and lannisters take back the castle
>>
>>98957303
>All their records are kept by maesters for whatever reason
The easiest no-prize is that the maesters are actually a guild.
>>
>>98962632
I am willing to hand out an olive branch to Martin on the subject of armies as it is late middle age setting and knights are a thing. Now I will choke Martin with it because he does not properly differentiate nor even know what a knight is or the contracted soldiers that replaced levies overnight when the King of England realized peasant armies were retarded and reformed, which made the King of France also realize peasant armies were retarded and reform.

Arguably, the most professional force before that in Western Christian Europe (Byzantium retained professional armies from the actual Romans) was Spain purely because of the amount of militias and holy templar orders the Muslims had them found over the years. When they broke out the Tercios, they outshined everyone else at the time.
>>
>>98962672
A guild implies competition, not an undisputed monopoly.
And there would be competition from the sheer size of Westeros.
>>
>>98962604
>How would you make the agricoltural cycle of long summers/winters more believable?

Literally all you need is some kind of magical refridgeration, which they already have since the fucking Wall was built with ice magic.
The real answer though is that it simply doesn't matter. Autistically nitpicking a facet of the world that's explicitly magical (decades long winters aren't real in case you didn't know) is fruitless.
>>
>>98962693
Taxes though
>>
>>98962679
Late medieval wars like the War of the Roses or the Hundred Years' War fielded armies in the thousands. Nobody could move 20,000 guys around in western Europe because they didn't have the logistics to feed them.
>>
>>98962714
The duke of Brittany gave Henry Stafford 15,000 men for his rebellion.

I doubt men could be raised long in those numbers but they could be raised nonetheless. The goal would likely be to do as much damage and subsist off the land and plunder for as much as possible.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.