>hey bro here's a better magic system than vancian magic >is another "verb" + "noun" slop
>>98957745>>is another "verb" + "noun" slopWhat did he mean by this?
>>98957750Dunno, don't expect too much of /v/'s leftovers.>>>/v/751607360
>>98957745What if I do madlibs spell casting with vancian format and preset starting lists to encourage resource management and planning but as the party ranges further and wider from home the spells become stranger and less familiar? Because I've been doing that and it works great. >The witch coven has Blood Screaming, short range causes 2d6 dmg, save vs magic, distracting yelling inside target's head >>98957750Things like the tables in Maze Rats or Freebooters on the Frontier I think. They have some good tables, not games I run as is but have taken parts from that were useful and interesting. Was a trend in 2012ish-2018ish osr scene games, most of the imitations I've seen of it more recently are a lot smaller and less useful as people have gotten further from well made tables in the indie milieu and more towards tables as a list of 6 or 8 things to pick from or read as vibes.
What are gu?
>>98957827Those aren't elements.
>>98957864Not too worried about it being literal. Most of the word salad magic tables are aimed at inspirational and thematic compared to a granular breakdown of what each term means and does.
>>98957762Doesn't even make sense there. Vancian Magic isn't really a thing in video games outside of ones based on TTRPGs.
>>98957827This looks verb + noun with extra steps
>>98957963>extra steps You will indeed have to use your imagination and mix that with gameplay experience. Not everyone's idea of fun, some people like having everything very spelled out and prewritten. There's tons of books of spells for that too.
>>98957762>5 repliesYet this thread has more sloppy seconds replies
>>98957745im going to verb you noun if you know what i mean
>>98957956The only popular example I can think of from /v/ is Dark Souls (excluding 3, which uses a mana bar). Everything else I can think of is stuff like, as you said, Baldur's Gate and other IPs that were TTRPG systems to start with.
>>98957750it's explained using words
>>98957926Drive tomatoes.
>>98957750Presumably like Ars Magica’s Technique + Form system
Freeform magic is rad though.
>>98957745but is magic that isn't science also balanced around the same as martials OP?
>>98959510depends on if they're non-scientific martials