>DM wants to do a pre-session 0 to hammer down the details of the setting and 'vibe' of the game>Session 0 is where we will actually make characters and know what we are doing in the gameHas anyone else experienced this? Shouldn't the DM have a strong concept of their own to begin with?
>>98965371Yes, this is quite common. Helps to pre-emptively get rid of any tonal inconsistencies or misjudged expectations that may arise and allows the GM to better adjust his game to the type of characters the players want to play
>>98965371I haven't had separate "pre-0" session, but my group's session 0 has often been hammering down the details of the game, with chargen being something every player does himself after everyone's on the same page and before the game starts. In other words, our session 0's have been what your GM apparently wants to do before session 0. It's a red flag if the GM has no idea whatsoever he wants to run and wants to start brainstorming with nothing to build on, but unless he has specifically said that's the case, I wouldn't assume it to be the case. It's possible to have a solid idea but to want to give players a change for input before the game starts. Best campaigns I've either run or played in have started like that.
>>98965389Is there a term for it? I've been calling it Session -1
>>98965392Does it need a term more specific than "talking to our players" or "normal campaign prep"?
>>98965389>Helps to pre-emptively get rid of any tonal inconsistencies or misjudged expectations that may ariseCan be done in regular conversation, you don't need an entire session for it.>allows the GM to better adjust his game to the type of characters the players want to playAdjustments are ideally made on the GM's own time, not during a session where the players are present.
>>98965392The term is "redundant".
>>98965371I've never ran a session zero before. As far as tone, expectations, and character details go, those are all discussed beforehand.
>>98965392I mean, if it's also where you make the characters, it's just a more extended session 0You can obviously also establish these things by just sending your players a bunch of questions to answer and/or sending them some short info about how you envision the game and what's okay/not okay, but in practice it's often easier to properly communicate and settle down these things IRL - some people (both players and GMs) are surprisingly shitty in clearly communicating what they want or comprehending others, so it helps to have a slightly more involved talk about it.>>98965403>Can be done in regular conversation, you don't need an entire session for it.But that's literally what it is, you meet and talk about those things, usually for a shorter period of time than a regular session takes. If you don't want to call it a "session 0" then don't, but that's just arguing semantics>Adjustments are ideally made on the GM's own time, not during a session where the players are present.Yes, once again, that's literally what this is for: the GM collects info from the players and adjusts what he had in mind in his free time before the actual campaign starts. You can do it by contacting them privately, or you can do it by meeting together and talking, both have their advantages and disadvantages in my opinion
>>98965431>that's just arguing semanticsCool.FATAL is the world's greatest TTRPG, then.
>>98965449Anon, it seems like you want to argue just for the sake of arguing, I literally agree with everything you've said, I'm just saying that what OP is describing IS what you've said.If I'm wrong and it isn't, describe how instead of whatever the fuck this answer is
>>98965371>Shouldn't the DM have a strong concept of their own to begin with?They probably do but A) They need to communicate it to you and B) Depending on the system your characters may have a large impact on how the game starts out.
>>98965455>arguing for the sake of arguingI'm not the one insisting the meanings of words aren't important.A session is something you have to set aside time for, to schedule. Things that can be discussed in casual conversations and done on personal time don't need or are actively hindered by spending a session for. I can talk to individual players outside of session time or send group texts about tone and expectations; it isn't something you need to seat everyone around for.And as far as what OP said, the choice of game should already let the players know what they'll be doing, and their characters should be ready for the game session.
>>98965488Session 0 literally does just mean taking the time to have that discussion, though. You're the one who seems to be arguing that it means something else.
>>98965460Should I be worried if there was no strong concept at Session -1 and it was mostly spitballing ideas from a rough world concept the DM had?
>>98965509Have you played with this GM before? If you know he's solid, don't worry. If you know he tends to mess things up, do worry. If you don't know, just give it a chance and see how things work out.
>>98965371Yes, it’s quite common. It’s usually for the benefit of the players more than the GM, since it’ll give them time to think over if they want in or out of the game after what they heard and say with it for a week. Though every group is different. I usually have those Session 0 type of meetings to give a general overview and discussion so that I can help those who need more pointed help during the week before the official first game.
>>98965528I have, he's run some good campaigns. But our last campaign fizzled out because he lost inspiration for it. Then our last attempt to start we did a Session -1 and it fizzled out because he couldn't think of a good opening concept. This is our second attempt to get a game going
>>98965506You don't need to devote an entire session to talking about those things, and the GM should be adjusting things on his own time.
>>98965371Yes, we had this on the start of our current campaign because it's DM's own setting and we were supposed to make a noble family (characters related to each other) who are somewhat familiar to the cultural and political situation of the land.
>>98965539Alright, so he knows how to GM. Based on that last campaign and the attempt after that he seems to be stuck in a rut right now. Maybe he's got some shit going on with his life, maybe he's burned out on GMing, maybe it's something else, but if he has difficulty finding an idea that really excites him as a GM, that doesn't bode well. Do you know if he's running this game out of habit or a sense of obligation, or if he genuinely still enjoys GMing and just has difficulty coming up with ideas? If it's the latter, a good evening of brainstorming with the boys and hopefully hitting on a cool concept together might genuinely be what he needs. If it's the former, it might be a different matter.
>>98965371It is good to set common ground on how the setting and thus campaign pan out thematically before thinking up your characters as that allows you to create characters fitting into the theme and style of the setting and campaign, creating a more immersive and self-propelling experience.
>>98965581I'm not entirely sure, he said he was having trouble being creative after we went on hiatus for a few months. Nobody else really has the want to DM and I already run my own game that he and some of his group play in as well.
>>98965542No, but I can if I want to. In my experience the most fruitful way to have a discussion about an upcoming campaign is to sit down in person and with no one in a hurry to be elsewhere, and if the discussion doesn't take that long, then you can spend the evening just generally shooting shit with the group and maybe having a few beers while you're at it.
>>98965488>A session is something you have to set aside time forYes, agreed. In this case, they schedule a meeting to discuss the upcoming game and how they'd want it to look like>Things that can be discussed in casual conversations (...)Yes, agreed. I already said this is one of the ways to do it, and another one is to meet and talk (which is called making a session 0). Also, like I already said, I think there are pros and cons to both approaches and I mentioned some of those in my answer to the Anon above> the choice of game should already let the players know what they'll be doingThere are tonnes of different ways you can run most popular RPGs, both in terms of tonne and in terms of what actually happens in the session. While you don't have to do it, clearly establishing what everyone wants or expects out of it helps in avoiding disappointments Also, while some GMs may have a very clear idea of what campaign they want (in which case they should communicate that clearly and the players should accommodate to that), in other cases the GM might just want to run *some* campaign for the group and is fine with heavily adjusting it to what the players would like to do. Nothing wrong with that. And adjusting the campaign for what sorts of PCs will be present in it is always a good idea. >their characters should be ready for the game session.I actually do prefer if the players do their PC in free time and send it, but doing it together during session 0 does have its merits. You can often create a party that works together much better this way, both mechanically and narratively and also it makes it easier to help newbies who don't feel confident doing it on their own. I dunno Anon, I generally do agree with you, but I feel you have a misjudged understanding of what most people mean by "session 0"
>>98965371>Has anyone else experienced this? Shouldn't the DM have a strong concept of their own to begin with?Yes. Payed and run things like this. Pretty normal for games that aren't standard Wizards of the Coast trashfires. There's usually is a working concept of the game to begin with that is opened up to player input. Gives the runner more ideas to work with, helps everyone else feel more connected to the game world and make a cohesive group or at least an interconnected one. There's usually an obvious launch point into an adventure from the initial outline and new player inputs so there's gameplay as well, very few session zero as designed I've encountered are just making characters and the world. Some games have a more open world starting session but they tend to be world building games like Miroscope or that sort of thing.
>>98965371>Shouldn't the DM have a strong concept of their own to begin with?Not at all mutually exclusive with Session 0. I might know the main sources of conflict that I’m going to include, but coaxing the players into developing their place in the world can be a great source of secondary and tertiary conflicts to weave into the game. It’s also very helpful to have people building their characters together so that they’re building to the same vision of party power level.
>>98965403A regular conversation with each player, plus with each other players thoughts (you surely aren't new enough to not know about interparty dynamics being a thing to watch for) as well as the time spent thinking about solutions, denials and additions should add up to a short session lengths worth of time.
>>98965615>>98965639They're not asking about a session 0, but a session before session 0. Which is far more retarded
>>98965371I periodically talk to each individual player about what everyone is expecting and what I'm trying to accomplish as a DM before the first session. Beyond that? I rarely do an official Session 0. It's more just a group text or chat and they decide party composition after I give them the premise. We have dinner and drinks while rolling stats and jump into session 1.
>>98965706>but a session before session 0.>checks notes Yeah that is far more retarded. My bad. GM should make 5 questions, send it to everyone a week ahead, have that as material to review at session 0 and play the game.
>>98965371I always do a character making pre session and I usually explain the situation and context at that time
>>98965371yeah this is bullshit. this only happens when someone decides to dm just to get a game going without any idea of what he ll do with it.The only good campaigns i have ever played were ones where the dm just said: "the game will be x and y and the theme will be z, make your characters accordingly. If you wanna incorporate something about your backstory in the setting tell me and i ll help you"
>>98965371the only caveat to this >>98966120 is when you are all learning a new system or at least your players are so you could help them with character creation and a few other stuff before actual play and explaining the rules once to everyone with some examples works better than doing so individually
>>98965371Our group will do things like that because it's an online one and we tend to change up games a lot, so it's helpful to have a session that's "hey, remember this game and how it works? Let's go through chargen and bounce ideas off each other for what we want and if anyone's forgotten the rules there's a bunch of people here to help"We're also a pretty player-directed group, so it's nice to have everyone on more or less the same page about what they want out of a campaign. We also do a lot of original worlds, so it's nice to nail down that sort of thing too. One time we played an entire session of Microscope to work out what we wanted the world in our next campaign to be like. It was fun.
>the setting and "vibe" of the gameYeah your campaign is going to suck. A campaign ONLY succeeds if the GM has a strong vision. Your GM basically wants the rest of the party to run the game for him, while he GMs passively and reactively, occasionally calling for an "evens or odds" role because he lacks the agency to even make decisions about what happens in his own world. Your campaign is going to be X conflicting visions from X different players, and a passive beta male söycuck DM who just goes along with their "shenanigans" as they roll natural 20s to accomplish whatever wacky thing they want to, "for the meme.". I guarantee that whatever "vibe" or "tone" you agree on for your campaign, your players will be completely incapable of executing to any satisfactory level. There is absolutely ZERO point in trying to decide the "vibe" of your campaign beforehand, because it simply is going to develop a certain way and your attempts to force a certain aesthetic will fail, because you simply lack the talent to achieve what you envision. It's that simple. It doesn't mean you should stop playing roleplaying games. It doesn't mean you should stop taking them seriously. It means you should stop trying to do this gay-ass redditor söykike behavior of trying to determine a "tone" for your campaign during (((session zero))) as well as trying to predetermine and preplan every other aspect of the game like the control freaks you are, and then as soon as the actual game starts you, like all reddit söykikes, immediately devolve the game into lolrandumb shenanigans, interrupted by you showing each other anime memes saying "DUDE DUDE THIS IS TOTALLY MY CHARACTER'S FACE RIGHT NOW", because you are ADHD-riddled retards who are fundamentally incapable of taking anything seriously. That's why you watch Marvel slop.movies, which immediately insert a faggy joke as soon as a scene approaches any level of gravitas or emotional depth, because you are not a serious person.
>>98966207Tl;Dr But I’m happy for you anonOr sorry for your lossWhichever
You're only ever really meant to do session zeroes with a committed group that is for sure gonna stick through the campaign.
>>98965371
>>98966228Looks like that ADHD accusation was spot-on. >tldrCry of the reddit söykike with the attention span of a gnat (unless it's a 5 hour Marvel movie)
>>98965371That seems like a lot of work. Usually we just hammer out those details during breaks or side bars of the current session.
>>98966526No, I think you just let your brain worms take over your nervous system for a second, you spaz
>>98966567Dude, your post is an improperly formatted shit show. Learn how to use paragraphs.
>>98966567>brain wormsYeah you're definitely a reddit söykike. Fuck off back there and rejoin the discussion on Bartenders and Bugchasers or whatever RPG is popular there now.
>>98966873Considering you're incapable of even remotely typing like a human being, let alone pretending I'm you via >>98966660 just to feel better about yourself, I really have to conclude that you've permanently fried your brain and mistaken this place as your personal toilet. Take your meds, you schizophrenic meme spouting nogames retard. Seriously.
>>98965403>Can be done in regular conversation, you don't need an entire session for it.A session is a point in time when everyone has gathered with the intention of focusing on the game, it's the best occasion to discuss anything concerning the game without worrying about distraction or miscommunication, with everyone present so that the GM doesn't need to worry about different players being told different things or getting different impressions.>Adjustments are ideally made on the GM's own time, not during a session where the players are present.Yes, they are, but the GM can only make those adjustments are talking with the rest of the group during an occasion when they're all present and focused on the game, so they can all communicate about what they want from the game together.
>>98965371>pre-session zeroFly, you fool!
>>98966917>nogameslmao this coming from the reddit söykike who can't get a game to last more than 6 sessions (and probably unironically considers that to be a "campaign")
>>98966993Had to invent an entire backstory in your head for someone you've never even met just to feign oldfag status for internet cred, huh? Which I guess is the most you'll ever get to actually playing a tabletop rpg instead of wasting your life on 4chan ranting at strawmen with memes that were outdated years ago.
>>98965371Other people have explained how this is a normal and thoughtful approach to running games, but I'm going to point to a couple benefits I didn't see mentioned.- Scheduling pre-sessions in the usual time-slot can let you see who will or won't have problems showing up on time. It also helps to get people into the game night mindset if you've had a long hiatus between campaigns, or have never played together before.- Having all your players in one place and time makes it easier for a good GM or player to read them and wrangle them. Watch and listen for signs of enthusiasm about your ideas. Encourage quieter players to share their thoughts.- If you set aside a special pre-session for going over the game mechanics, it can have the same learning and retention benefits of a group study session. So hopefully less incidences of "Hang on, I'm looking up the rules."OP, if your'e the same poster as >>98965539 and >>98965588 I would advise you to pay attention to the GM's enthusiasm and energy level during your pre-sessions. If he doesn't resonate with the campaign concept or characters, then that is not a good sign. As a GM, my ability to keep running is predicated on enjoying the cast and feeling invested in the story we're building together.
Session 0 is for faggots. Here are 20 premade characters to pick from, you're in front of the dungeon/in a prison/at the tavern, go.
>>98967371Doesn't sound like you put much thought into your game, but you do you anon.
>>98967077Yeah I definitely have to make more of an effort to go with his enthusiasm.
>>98965371The DM probably does have a strong concept. I have these session 0 talks because I want everyone on the same page. You posted LOTR; so if one of the players is expecting LOTR, but the other is expecting Game of Thrones, and the other is expecting Berserk and they show up to the game with different characters and the DM has only said "we're playing high D&D fantasy, here's a brief overview of the setting" the game is doomed.You'd know this, if you ever played.
>>98967521No concept survives five minutes with the player
>>98965371Two sessions of not actually playing the game seems like a recipe for a game that stalls out and loses momentum and eventually falls apart.
>>98965391Yeah your GM should be using session zero to clear things up with players about the setting but to also establish what the player expectation is for gameplay. If everyone just wants dungeon crawling/exploration then great, all that setting becomes a side note. If one player wants political intrigue, one wants to smash shit, and another wants a brutal survivalist/logistics experience, you’re going to have to put some real thought into structure.
>>98967371Campaigns like that might be fun for the sake of variety every now and then, but nobody in my group would want to play like that as the primary thing.
>>98967003The fact that you're holding up playing a TTRPG as if it's some grand accomplishment confirms you're a fucking loser who can't get a day off to run a campaign.
I feel like a lot of modern players are far too concerned with planning things out to make sure their games go perfectly and it's causing them to overthink and overwork it so much that it can't even survive on it's own. Having an outline is well and good and I'd even encourage it but learn to let things go. Take stuff in stride. Go by the seat of your pants once in a while. Maybe you'll create the next great fantasy epic or maybe you'll all just die like retards but learn to live and play in the moment. You're going to look back far more fondly on the time spent with friends than you are the nuances of your world building or your tone. The time Scott made Jeff laugh so hard his drink shot out his nose will be what you take away, but you're not gonna remember what even your own class was. It's just a game.
>>98968193>the rpg equivalent of LIve. Laugh. Love
>>98965371yes I have a strong idea of the game and if you want i can give you a prebuild that is basically the perfect party to play my unironic open world linear cinemetic storyslop westmarches abomination, but usually, when players join a game its because they have a concept in mind already and its much easier to work that shit in from the start.
>>98968111Coming from the schizo who posted >>98966207, sounds like projection
>>98968478lolwut? What about that post implies inability to run a game? You realize people post about other people they've known, as well as themselves, right? You know that people can belong to more than one RPG group right? Or are you just a tourist from /criticalrole/ board on reddit
>>98969600Do you even have a point to what you’re doing here anymore, or are you just desperately accusing everyone else of being the onions-sucking lad so nobody will look to you for that?