>fail forward
>>98974792>D20+modifier for any rolls in the system
>it has letter 'e' in the title
>game has a preface lecturing you about the creator's political views
>>98974807There is not a single game that does that.
>>98974792Why's everyone so afraid of judgment? Judgment is a useful skill set, you have judged fire to be hot don't touch it. Good call. Being open to reevaluating your judgments based on new information is important but its goddamn stifling when everyone has to pretend they're above all the things for fear of doing something incorrectly to the point no one can say what it is they actually do. Fail forward works great for narrative based social drama games. Everyone's running around doing things and making mistakes that complicate and compound and eventually there's a gun fight or something. Its been used oddly in a lot of more traditional fantasy milieu stuff recently, if dungeon world and all its derivatives even counts as recent anymore, and I think leads to a lot of disconnected or seemingly out of nowhere scrambling for the gm to hold things together. If everyone's on board with the suspension of disbelief range it still works but its harder to pull off or I think there's at least more room for friction there. As a gm technique it can be ported to different systems but I'd be hesitant to put it in something more traditionally mechanical. It does highlight an interesting divide between game methods where some are more focused on making an interesting story and some find seeing how the choices about dice outcomes unfold, different sorts of games. Figuring out which you like more will help keep the grackle of judgment a bit less pissy. I am at this point very wary of anything rules light or that does minimal explanations with lots of sloppy art in a zine style, or anything that uses AI art regardless of other content. I might still look at it, but either case increases my skepticism its going to be anything I will use or pay for.
>>98974823Clearly you haven't played eclipse phase.
>>98974792This feels likes Blades slander and I will not stand for it.
>>98974823yes there is
>>98974792>advantage/disadvantage system>every class can do everything
>>98974928Shithead BTFO'd.
>>98974792whats wrong with fail forward?
>>98974807Not quite in the game itself but the Thousand-Year Old Vampire author starts out with this on his website and it's the funniest thing to read.
>>98974921>>98974954A door shouldn't be unlocked regardless of a roll. If you fail the roll, you can try again, but each roll runs the risk of a random encounter as well as draining light resources.
>>98974928Wrecked that stupid tourist
>>98974990Its fora totally different kind of game. Dungeon World doesn't even have a fixed dungeon, the lock picking example would be for when there's an exciting or tense moment where failure becomes interesting storywise and builds the dungeon rather than a dungeon where the game is exploring a set area. FitD and its various offshoots are more about contested narrative control and personal exploration rather than resource control and location exploration. Its a common problem for people with minimal experience with one form or the other to make mistakes like this, similar to when people think a dungeon crawl is just combat or rocks fall you die.
>>98974823nearly every single commercial game now comes with a foreword that mentions or is about identity politics
>>98974928>JaquaysOh the ironing
>>98974928How ironic coming from Paul "Jennell" Jaquays
>>98974990>If you fail the roll, you can try again, but each roll runs the risk of a random encounter as well as draining light resources.so, without wandering encounters, fail forward simply means the enemy on the other side hears you trying to break the door down and is either prepared for you or escapes to another roomthats not a better or worse way to play than wandering encounters
>>98974990>YoU cAn TrY aGaIn.Why not just give them a participation trophy, you fucking nancy boy sissy. If you fail to pick the lock, that means that your skillset and/or tools are not up to the task of picking that particular lock. That is it. Find another way through that door, find another route, bypass it in some other way or fuck off.
>>98975089what are you even arguing about?all of the proposes ways to approach a locked door are fine from a gameplay perspective>failing lockpick, roll for wandering monsters, fight them, then try again, until either you succeed or get tired of fighting wandering monsters>fail lockpick, you hear "whats going on there?" and proceed to a combat encounter at some kind of disadvantage >fail lockpick and then shrug your shoulders, and then ask the barbarian to use strengthlike, none of these are particularly bad ways to approach a locked door and the only time one of them would fail is if the DM has no idea what to do if every player rolls low
>>98974823>What is World of Darkness
>>98975106If you can't pick the lock, you can't pick the lock. That's the end of the discussion.
>>98975243i dont understand what your problem is, since from a gameplay perspective all of them are perfectly fine and fun ways to keep things movingpreferring one over the other is a matter of subjective taste
>>98975246You replied to a bot.
>>98974792female designers, no greater indicator. Dick chopped Chapmans don't count as female.
>>98975246>I'm a post modernist. Everything is like subjective, maaaaaan.No. You are wrong. If the dice say you can't pick the lock, you can't pick the lock.
>>98975089Okay, I bypass it by lockpicking it a different way, I'll be rolling another lockpicking check now.
>>98975333"You'll have a tall order justifying it. Let's see you try and if the explanation is particularly compelling and specific to this situation, I might allow you to make that roll."
>>98975389I kick you in the balls, push you down a flight of stairs, and take over GMing myself because you're shit at it and I can tell you're a limp-wristed skinny faggot from how much of a control freak you are since you want to push the party down storyshit railroad.
>>98975406Lol. You should get better at controlling your emotions, boy.
>>98975389>>98975406what are you even arguing about?
>>98975406All the while you would be screeching, "REEEEEEEEEEE! MOMMY SAYS I GET INFINITE REROLLS!"
>>98974928where is this even from
>>98975427I'm not even sure. All I said was to just follow what the dice result is. Not sure what this faggot's major malfunction is, but he keeps replying to me for some reason.
>>98974928Chalk another one up for horseshoe theory, zamn.
>>98974928Lol. This guy must be feasting in the podcast era. "I'm a POLITICALLY INCORRECT GAMER." *turns baseball cap backwards* "I don't follow SOCIETY'S RULES!" *sits in chair backwards* "I touched BOOBS once."
>>98975429>>98975419>t. illiterate retardsGo read the original argument against single rolls. Each successive roll incurs increasing risk in the example situation.>>98975427Retards can't read and don't understand that one and done rolls are for midwits who can only see the world in black and white like a literal child. Their argument already got thrashed with >>98975106>>98974990.
>>98975429no one is saying getting infinite re-rollsjust that a dice result shouldnt simply result in "nothing"so youre basically arguing for the same thing, just with diferent means>you can re-roll again, but risk bumping into a patrol>you cant re-roll, because you should try a different skillyoure literally arguing about the same thing
>>98975480>diseased D&D brain babbling>"I want redos. I might miss something I want. I should be able to force access to everything. No one should tell me no. Gimme gimme gimme. Mine mine mine."
>>98974792>dice pools
>>98975255So you never played any tabletop game and you have retardation.
>>98975488This is the exact issue. He doesn't want to use a different skill. He doesn't want to change his approach. He doesn't want to search for a key. He doesn't want to bash the door down with an ax. He doesn't want to yank the hinges. He doesn't want to use acid on the mechanism.As indicated in >>98975333 he just wants to roll lockpicking again on the door we already established he wasn't capable of picking. That is just a fucking re-roll.
>>98975545As for patrols risk raising and other shit like that, that is already happening by virtue of the fact that you failed. That still doesn't mean I am giving you a reroll.
>>98975545>This is the exact issueliterally the same outcome, re-rolling comes at the cost of rolling on the wandering monsters encountersthis isnt infinite free re-rolls, this is risking an enemy patrol to keep picking the same lockyoure arguing over nothing
>>98974823Lancer.
>>98975564whats the problem here?you are trying to pick a lock, you fail, you roll for a possibly dangerous encounter, and then you try again knowing that if you continue to fail you will keep encountering more patrolsif your argument is that they get infinite re-rolls, its only as "infinite" as their patience is to keep fighting wandering enemies or the amount of HP they can regain after each fightabsolutely no one here is arguing about simply brute forcing the lock open without any cost or penalty
>>98975577Again. When you fail a roll, the consequence is you can't succeed at that + whatever the time pressure is (including random encounter chance) goes up. That is already baked in and has nothing to do with the reroll question. Again, it has absolutely nothing to do with whether or not you get to roll the same skill and use the same approach. You can't. It failed.You fail to bash the door down. You aren't strong enough. You fail to pick the lock. You can't pick it. You run through your bag of tricks and nothing works cause you are rolling like shit, maybe you need to take an alternate route if there is one. If there isn't another route, you just don't get to know what is behind that door.
>>98974792>Compatible with 5e
>>98975604i dont know what your problem isyou pick a lock, the price of failure is monsters possibly finding youso the player has to make a choice between choosing to brute force the lock at cost of more encounters or to find another way around itif your argument against it is that it allows infinite re-rolls, then it really doesnt because its limited by the amount of patience or HP the party hasyour proposed solution of telling them to find another way around it is literally what wandering monsters are supposed to do, tell them what the penalties are for trying and failing again
>>98975618Careful with that. The D&D zombies are out in force in this thread.
>>98975625If they chose to brute force the lock by hitting it with a rock I would fucking applaud. They just don't get to try to pick it again. Well, they can, they would just automatically fail cause we have already established they can't pick it via the original dice roll. That avenue is cut off. You have to do something else.
>>98975640you arent making an argument for why repeated attempts balanced out by wandering monsters is a bad ideafailure is met with a consequencetrying again means risking the exact same consequenceso they either risk the consequences or try a different pathif you want them to take a different path, the wandering monsters already do that by telling the players sitting here trying the lock again will risk bumping into them again
>>98975647The wandering monsters isn't even germane to the argument. As said, when you fail a roll that chance goes up. It has no bearing on whether or not you get to try to do the same thing the dice just said you can't do.
>>98975655>The wandering monsters isn't even germane to the argumentwandering monsters are the balancing factor to multiple attemptsyou are framing it as mutually exclusive to the party trying to find another way around the door, but the purpose of the wandering monsters is to encourage them to find a different path alreadyso its just a soft cap of "you can keep trying this, just be warned you will fight if you fail" wheras you propose a hard cap of "you can never do it again"but in the end, its just a harsher way to accomplish the exact same goal
>>98975655And mind you not only does this have nothing to do with rerolls it is also dependent on me playing a system that even uses encounters like this, which isn't a given.
>>98975671No. Wandering monsters is a consequence for failure. The balancing factor against multiple attempts is that you can't use the same approach and the prospect that if you run out of methods, you don't get whatever is behind the door.
>>98975684>No. Wandering monsters is a consequence for failurethats literally what was saidyou fail the lockpicking roll then you roll on wandering encounters>The balancing factor against multiple attempts is that you can't use the same approach and the prospect that if you run out of methodsthats pretty much what wandering encounters doif you lockpick, and fail, then you fight monstersif you try it again and fail again, you fight more monstersthis is perfectly valid game design that presents the players with a choice between trying to keep lockpicking the same door and risk the same failure or trying a different method rather than risk the same consequence
>>98975688No. Again. If you lockpick and fail 2 things happen.1.) You roll on wandering encounters cause you failed a roll.2.) You can't pick the lock because the dice just told you that you can't pick the fucking lock.
>>98975704>2.) You can't pick the lock because the dice just told you that you can't pick the fucking lock.you can actually just skip this part because part 1 already encourages the player to find a different path around the doorif they want to stay and force the lock with more rolls, which could fail several more times, then yeah they deserve to fight several more encountersbut in practice, your step 2 isnt really necessary because players who fail multiple times, and fight multiple encounters, are very unlikely to keep forcing a door they have little chance to succeed at
>>98975715No, you can't just skip that part of it. That is the main part. That would be fucking retarded. That just means that the party just gets to roll their best thing against this door for as long as their willing to stand encounters for it and they'll probably eventually get through. There is very little prospect of them not eventually getting past this door. There should always be the chance that they run out of methods and they can't get through. That they don't get to whatever is behind it. That that route is closed to them. That they took all that risk and it just didn't work out. That is a crucial part of the experience. In fact, the threat of that happening is one of the most crucial parts of it. Without the prospect of abject failure a locked door is just a speedbump with no tension beyond maybe making them roll for an encounter a couple of times. That's some weak shit.
>>98975741>There is very little prospect of them not eventually getting past this door.except for the part where encounters can potentially be dangerous enough to kill the players which will provide a physical limit on the number of times that the players can attempt lock picking attempts to the amount of HP they decide they can afford to sparebut even weak encounters use up real-world time, and unless your players are deeply autistic, then they arent going to sacrifice 2-real world hours trying to lockpick the same door over and over just to make a pointyou are basically just trying to argue an abstract principle rather than a realistic thing that can happen in a gamesimply telling the players that if they try again and fail, they will get jumped by another monster accomplishes the exact same thing as just telling them they cannot do it againthe only difference is that if they want to stand there like idiots instead of finding another way is penalized by combat rather than just shutting it down as an avenueif they wanted combat in the first place instead of lockpicking, they wouldnt be sneaking around unlocking doors in the first place
>>98975768>except for the part where encounters can potentially be dangerousOh give me a break. All that does is turn the game into a series of risk assessments without the prospect of being hard denied access despite their potential ability to defeat the encounters. Sometimes the door wins. Be a man about it.
>>98975704>rolling on a random encounter table because of a failed lockpick roll What sort of storyshitter garbage is this? >oh this will increase the tension its so much more like a movie hurh you fucking idiot. You roll on encounter tables at the rate for the dungeon and it sure as fuck isn't every time someone fails their lockpick roll you railroading storyshitter. The dungeon doesn't just become more dangerous because of a failed skill check. That's the opposite of what you're pretending to care about.
>>98975781>All that does is turn the game into a series of risk assessmentsso a game?> without the prospect of being hard denied access despite their potential ability to defeat the encounters.its essentially the same thing, preventing the players from performing an action that leads to no further actiontelling the players "no you cant do this" and "if you do this and fail, a monster will attack" are functionally identical in purpose>Sometimes the door wins. Be a man about it.the door winning because you told them it won and the players deciding the door won because they are done to 2/5ths health and dont want to risk another encounter are functionally identical outcomes
>>98975781>>98975741Oh I get it. This is a sad larp man.I know your 'the osr must die' bait didn't go the way you wanted and people still somehow like osr games but you don't even know what you're talking about enough to pull off the bit.
>>98975849>>98975858>>98975859Smooth d20 brains melting at the prospect that they might not be able to get through a door in spite of their best efforts. Sometimes you don't get into every room. Don't be a baby about it.
>>98974798
>>98974798>every WoD book has "the" in the title, we're fucked
>>98975768While I ultimately believe you should be able to retry a failed lockpick, I wouldn't call their opinion abstract principle. There is a very concrete difference between players deciding they don't want to risk another failure vs a DM telling them they are out of reasonable options and need to move on.I can see the case for playing it the way they are suggesting for a certain style of game, but I don't think my players would appreciate it in the kind of games I, personally, run.
>>98974792Fail forward is a good principle, but I'm ambivalent about it as a default rule.
>>98975887>dung[ E ]ons
>>98975942
>>98975942>dung [E]onsShadow of the Demon Lord?
>>98975978The sun is green.If you tell me it isn't, the joke has gone over your head.lol I'm such a comedic genius geef internet social credit nao
Could be neat to run one try per method rolls in a average joes in the post-apoc sorta game. Fits there. Come to think of it, Red Markets is kiiiiiind of like that as I recall, though if you fuck up you can usually burn resources to force a success. Fuck, I miss red markets. I wish I could find players for 2E.
>>98974928The lady doth protest too much.
>>98976001Of course sun is green, because sun is mesh of every colour. People take it for granted, but when was the last time you've taken proper focused look at the sun? Preferably with binoculars, so that you can properly see the green tinge and all the other colours.
>>98975874Oh lmao I called it.
>>98975994>dEmon lord
>>98974954Fail forward means failure just doesn't happen in practice and instead is just succeeding with some negative stuff attached.Just be comfortable with player's missing shit, death is a possibility, and the world state can change into something else entirely that the players have to deal with.
>>98974963Holy fuck I thought I was gonna get a chuckle, not a gut-buster. Seriously, what is with that fucking Humungus reference?
>>98974990IT IS LITERALLY HOW FITD GAMES WORK YOU STUPID NOGAMES RETARD.
>>98974954The only thing wrong with it, as the followup posts show, is that some people are retards who don't know how it works. Some of them run games too, (badly) and they blame the mechanics for the fact that they are retarded.
>>98974823Pathfinder 2e, Lancer, Daggerheart, Delvers, ICONS. Just to name a few.
>>98976439again, it just a different way to handle progressing through obstacles and it isnt any better or worse way to handle moving forward>and instead is just succeeding with some negative stuff attached.this isnt bad on the face of itusing the same locked door example, breaking through the door but with the enemies on the other side having been alerted and either prepared for a fight or just leaving with whatever they were guarding is just a different way to resolve a problem compared to rolling for wandering monsters until you succeed or just telling the players to take a different door
>>98974928>1991Time is truly a flat circle.
>>98976086Holy shit.The joke went over unc's head.:skull: :fire: :skull:
>>98975477He trooned out.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jennell_Jaquays
>>98976590Can you show us some good, non-retarded examples of how to run it well and intelligently?
>>98974954People not getting it, apparently.Fail forward is basically not cockblocking your players - which should be like, common sense. I can agree that it's not necessarily to be done at the single move/roll equivalent, but still.