>Replaced dungeons with gay bing bing wahoo collectathon bullshit>Killed the atmosphere and now it's just generic UEslop>Dogshit writing>More casualization than a persona game>Zero creativity, most shit is just "DUDE REMEMBER [THING] FROM NOCTURNE?"What were they thinking?
>>739443519it was kinda boring but I only played canon of creation, people said canon of vengeance is better but I don't think it fixes most of the issues
>>739443519SMTVV was a fun and good game. It just needed some more depth- like an equipment system for the deemans. Those superbosses were aids, though.
pretty much killed smtdo you see any threads in the last few years?before V people would make IV threads or devil survivior threads, now nothing
>>739443519>>739444019I dont have any hopes for smt 6 after this piece of shit
>>739443519complete lack of vision which is what atlus has been into for the last decadeThey even gutted metaphor from its initial interesting pitch into generic anime shit
>>739444082dont worry smt6 wont happen for another decade, they still need to even hint at persona 6 then make like 10 persona 6 spinoffs and 3 animes before they even think of coming back into the dry well of smt
>>739443519I had fun
>>739443519DDS > 5V > 3 > everything else.
>>739444226yeah bet you had a blast
I know exactly how all of you feel put me in the screenshot.
>>739443519I was really into this game at the start - then I got into the super boss challenges and I realized you literally have to run certain builds to win.I've seen people post shit like "you can use any kind of demon and any kind of team setup and strategy to beat anything in the game" and that's such a lie.Take that shit to Satan and tell me you can do that again.
>>739443962I wish he was my gf
>>739443519My mermaid fishslapped Luci and flopped on my penis.
>>739444260blast havers stay winning
>>739444323no way you took that shit to the end.
>>739443519For me it's the dungeon part that sucked the most
>>739444019I feel like that has more to do with how /v/'s demographics have changed, there just aren't as many SMT enjoyers here as there used to be
>>739443519>>Replaced dungeons with gay bing bing wahoo collectathon bullshit>>Killed the atmosphere and now it's just generic UEslopNon-criticism, literally means nothing. If you think SMT5 is open world, you are a fucking moron that doesn't get game design. >>Dogshit writingLike all mainline games>>More casualization than a persona gameSmoothest gameplay in the whole series. Better balanced and design than 4 and 4a.
>>739444304SMT superbosses have always been like that though
>>739443519one of the hottest SMT protags tho
>>739443519>smtiv watcher upset he cant larp about atmosphere and vibes anymore and has to play the game instead
>>739443519It's the best 3D SMT game. Since it has jumping and fast travel it makes sense for it to be 3D.
>>739444372It was close, but I proved my penis superioreir.
>>739443674The writing and combat are better. The collectathon stuff and maps are the same. It's definitely an improvement for me, but I wish SMT would stop bouncing between "Remember 3?" and "Remember 2?"
>>739444426>>739444479>IV out of nowhereobsessed troons
>>739443519>>Replaced dungeons with gay bing bing wahoo collectathon bullshitYes, they replaced the bland copy pasted dungeons with coherent and interesting levels. That don't all look like samey slop. >More casualization than a persona gameNah, I died more times in this game than I ever did in p5.
>>739444504you are the big dick.
>>739444372You underestimate fish appreciators.
>>739444426he didn't say open world though
>>739444586SJ > 3 > 2 > 5 > 1 > if... > 4 > 4A > NineReminder that SJ, If and Nine are still considered as part of mainline. https://youtu.be/jXleV24zgws?si=RyhUV2lmNukTEmyy
>https://youtu.be/IiBZ_iH3BVw?si=W32GSe4rM3YDdSA7 starts playing>ARAMASAkino.
>battles slow as fuck compared to IV/IVA>barely any actual dungeons; just empty wastelands.>the few actual dungeons are dogshit I'd expect from a dev like Compile HeartAtlus didn't bring their A-game with SMTV.
>>739444721gameplay of 5V is best in the series.
>>739444463No they haven't
>>739443674It's still dogshit
waiting for the Switch 2 version that will save the game
>>739444628Thats a big fish
>>739444316Same. How did Atlus create a protagonist with 3 cute appearances?
>>739443519V was pretty disappointing. VV is great tho.
>>739443519I played 3 different endings and I stopped having fun long before I finished the 1st.Open world areas felt sloppy and combat fast turned into mindless "+2/-2 all and crit buff to finish"
>>739443519You can just ask for an SMT5 thread and I'll participate, friend.I thought it was a little strange making a companion piece to SMT3 after like 20 years but it turned out pretty well in spite of being 4 deserts in a row.
>>739444768They have. SMT superbosses are dogshit and always have been.Elizabeth is probably the most "fair" one and she's still a "simon says" boss where you have to do things perfectly or you die instantly.Joker in P3 Reload was insultingly bad. A parody of Atlus superbosses.
I've heard that vengeance fixed some things, but honestly vanilla was so bad that I'm not going to risk money on Atlus again for a bit longer.
>>739443519>More casualization than a persona gameFunny bait. Anyways, stop being a retard. V may be mid, but it's miles better than any persona minus the original 3 and 1
>>739445193I was gonna suggest just getting it on sale but if raidou is any indication it probably hasnt been that cheap even on sale
>>739445042P4 and 5 aren't SMT retardkun
>>739444804>>739444804>>739444804>>739444804
>>739443519>Replaced dungeons with gay bing bing wahoo collectathon bullshitNo they removed the endless hallways with infinite random encounters.>Killed the atmosphereA complaint that continues to be vague because no one knows how to actually elaborate on what they're even complaining about, they just see UE and know everyone says UE bad so it must be bad.>Dogshit writingYes unlike the rest of mainline SMT which is famously praised for its writing and people definitely don't complain about it.>More casualization than a persona gameYou have never played a Persona game if you think this.>Zero creativityIt sounds to me like anything they tried to do different you hated anyway so this is a moot point due to you sabotaging your own credibility.
>>739444768>You block more than a single enemy>You didn't kill one of my demons on time>You are just taking too long>You broke one of my arbitrary invisible rules>Gaea RageSilly anon
>>739443674its like 5% better so instead of a 6/10 its a 6.5 lol
>>739445506ok play DDS and tell me the demi-fiend fight is ACKSHULLY good then.
>>739445669Swapping the 3rd abysmal dogshit region to Shinjuku in Vengeance was a huge upgrade.
>>739445627>they just see UE and know everyone says UE bad so it must be bad.I didn't care but once I started seeing shit that looked like lazy asset flips all over the place I got disappointed. the exact moment it hit me was when I jumped off the tall building neko shogun was on and entered "the desert".
>>739444475>>739444828MORE
>>739446536Do not lust after Bean-kun.
>>739446536>>739444828>>739444316>>739443962kill yourselves you brain mangled fujoniggers
>>739447271>fujoniggersrare fujianese insult
>>739447271
