[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/v/ - Video Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: file.png (96 KB, 312x312)
96 KB PNG
Now that the dust has finally settled. Why was she so hated by chuds on here again? Hopefully the remake finally ends the narrative that shes a bad character.
>>
>>740553101
Purg...
>>
File: Wtf.png (932 KB, 1512x565)
932 KB PNG
>>740553101
She is literally the cutest P4 girl.
>>
>>740553147
Because of retarded forced quirky dialogue like this
>>
File: 1598470235213.png (936 KB, 680x631)
936 KB PNG
>>740553101
>localised with shit fan-comic references
>is the ONLY mandatory missable SL for the true ending
>replaced the content for another SL
Mariefags really have to use secondary revisionism to protect their shit waifu.
>>
>>740553324
They're all cliche tropes, anon. All their dialogue is forced, real people don't talk like anime. Marie actually captures the awkward tryhard vibe that the other girls also go for better. And she's better looking than them and has impeccable fashion sense.
>>
>>740553101
she is poorly integrated into the party
>>
>>740553625
she's not a party member larper
>>
>>740553625
I disagree, they actually did the right thing. Instead of forcing her in, you don't even play as her. She just has an optional dungeon, that's it. The most you'll have to see her is in short cutscenes. And even then, when comparing her to Yukiko, Chie, Rise, it's not like those three's stories are high literature. These are all just shlock. Stop being pretentious and just be honest about who looks better. Marie is a sassy alt chick and is the best, love her.
>>
File: 312073.png (1.36 MB, 826x4421)
1.36 MB PNG
I hope we can still let the nurse molest Yu.
>>
>>740553101
Bad personality, can’t avoid her to use skill cards, forces herself on you, ruins the atmosphere of the velvet room
>>
>show interest in Marie by doing her S.Link
>receive more Marie
HOW COULD THIS HAPPEN TO ME?
>>
>>740553101
Back in the mid 2010s her character was seen as insufferable. These days tastes have changed and her mannerisms are seen as endearing now
>>
File: 1759345551266873.png (195 KB, 554x838)
195 KB PNG
>>740553101
Marie made me hate women even more somehow
>>
>>740553101
Atlus's DLC/re-release girl. Often shit, too Mary Sue, doesn't fit well.
>>
File: 1710734139896514.png (134 KB, 346x574)
134 KB PNG
>nobody liked Marie
>Fatlus forces her into everything P4 related.

>everybody liked Kasumire
>Fatlus tries their best to memoryhole her
???
>>
I hate Yukiko's laughter quirk. I hate Chie's tomboy gimmick where she barely does anything tomboy besides having short hair. Rise is just the easy girl, already obsessed with the protagonist. Marie is the prettiest and is an edgy dork.
>>
>>740553101
Emo goth stuff was incredibly unpopular and mocked at the time. I have a feeling gen Z will take more of a liking to her now that that stuff is coming back. It will be like how everyone hated Yukari and loved Aigis and now everyone loves Yukari and thinks Aigis is super mid.
>>
>>740554214
What's Naoto's cardinal sin? You mentioned all the girls aside from her
>>
>>740554210
Marie didn't try to gaslight me into believing that she was more relevant than she actually was by showing up during the tutorial section as a playable character.
>>
>>740554214
At least chie's favorite food is meat and not "teehee I like sweets because I'm a girl"
actually the biggest fat fucks who only eat sweets I know IRL are all dudes, I have no idea where this trope came from
>>
>>740553101
There was NO porn with Fuuka after Reload launched.
I really hope that this time there are more petite girls to wank it to, those models look really good.
>>
File: Marie.png (1.55 MB, 1758x998)
1.55 MB PNG
>>740554173
>Mary Sue
All she does is fail, you don't even know what that word means. She's so pathetic in not being able to find a good solution to her dillema she was just willing to die and was only comforted by happy memories. The little fun times she was able to have in her human body was enough to give her the resolve. She then has a speech about being wrong and looking stupid. Then she cucks Rise with a smile on her face showing she has a funny side too. Marie is based.
>>
>>740554745
Go easy on him. He hasn't played the game.
>>
>>740553101
She's objectively the best girl.
>>
>>740553101
4chan's just full of whiny faggots
>>
File: yoko.jpg (20 KB, 739x415)
20 KB JPG
Marie crawl so Yoko can run.
>>
>>740555116
is this the one who hates cars?
>>
>>740555116
God I wish SMTV had a good story or at least good characters
>>
File: yoko.png (2.17 MB, 1587x894)
2.17 MB PNG
>>740555186
Yes
>>
>>740555238
>wanting a story in V
I enjoyed 5 immensely BECAUSE it didn't put me through 40 minutes of bullshit before I started playing
the human party members are easily the worst part of vengeance
>>
>>740555379
I was disappointed because i loved IVs story
>>
File: Marie.jpg (439 KB, 1775x3612)
439 KB JPG
>>740553101
>>740553147
She is my wife
>>
>>740553537
>look mom, I'm pretending to know what I am talking about on the internet again
>>
>>740555546
built for rough painal
>>
>>740555627
>look mom, I have no argument
You could have just left the thread with your dignity intact
>>
>>740555238
I wish SMTV had dungeons
>>
>>740555240
So true sister, so true
>Spoons may be convenient, but the truth is they’ve caused the deaths of many people
>>
File: 1779706889731630.jpg (191 KB, 1680x943)
191 KB JPG
>>740555867
There's no worthwhile argument to be made against a bad faith shitpost about trying to attack "anime tropes" as if it's ever been a serious pejorative. Or bringing up irrelevant meritless comparisons to "real people".
>>
>>740553101
Same deal with Kasumi/Sumire
>Too forced, locks you from content, forced tropes to get her in love with the protag
She honestly shouldn't be a bad character, just like Sumire, but Atlus doesn't get that making those characters will push people away, even more so when it's on the "new" editions

For example, Aigis follows literally the same plot line as those 3 (outside of locking the content) and she's one of the best girls in P3. Even with the revisions from Fes.
>>
>>740555240
Chaosfaggots never recovered from being “smash the patriarchy ecofaggots” after SJ.
>>
>>740553101
People dont like Marie because her SL is extremely forced dogshit, not because she is a tsundere. I remember in the last 2 parts of her SL, it finally felt natural because she wasnt COINCIDENTALLY running into the investigation team and they werent all suddenly enamored by her despite being rude, instead just focusing on her comb bullshit. And I just remember thinking "wow, this would have been so much better if the SL was just this".

What SHOULD have happened is that she is just Yu's friend. No mixing up in the investigation team or anything. And then when all her shit happens, Yu is trying to help but keeps hitting a wall and is stuck and starting to despair. Enter the investigation team, offering to help. When you point out that they dont even know who she is, theyd be all like "who the fuck cares, a friend of yours is a friend of ours". It would have been a moment where Yu had some vulnerability, but then pulled through by his friends stepping up instead, underlining the entire narrative point of friendship instead of it being a one way street. And it would have led to fun interactions as you fought Marie, she'd be like "why the fuck are you even trying to save me, you dont even know me!" and they could just say some shit about friends dont abandon friends, blah blah blah, its time for them to be there for Yu like he was there for them, etc.
>>
>>740554463
Marie literally shows up the second you get off the train, are you fucking retarded?
>>
>>740553101
People hated Marie because the Golden anime sucked. Most didn't play Golden back then because it was locked to the Vita
>>
>>740556259
did youtube not exist? that's how I played royal
>>
>>740556123
There is really not a single time Chaos is a viable option, even in nocturne.
>>
>>740555379
People always say that SMT's story doesn't matter but anytime it comes up they are more than happy to talk about the games that do have at the very least entertaining stories. IV, III, and Strange Journey always have people talking about the cast and who they sided with because there is actual effort put into what little narrative is there. I haven't visited any SMT threads in a while but from what I remember alignment discussions were basically dead because of how little it mattered to people in V. I don't think V needed to be as story heavy as Persona but compared to other games it falls short in almost every category outside of music and gameplay. Not to say it's a bad game by any means, but it's missing a lot of the character that the rest of the series has. And it could have been a much more impressive game with it.
>>
>>740554214
I hate how Marie is forced into being "friends" with the investigation team, it comes off extremely forced. No Mariefag ever can refute this. Her social link is fucking SHIT.
>>
>>740553101
>Want to fuse personas
>Go to velvet room
>This bitch interrupts me for 10th time with her shit poetry
>>
>>740556336
Devil Survivor: Overclocked
>>
>>740556336
Raidou 2 is complete Chaoswank and even locks a bunch of content behind going Chaos.
>>
>>740553101
She was such a bad character she defined an entire archetype of atlus remake worst girls. Every forced in shitty bitch from her on is a marie(despite not actually being the first of her kind).
>>
>>740556259
Shes dogshit in game too.
>>740556308
kill yourself
>>
>>740556439
Counterpoint: the chaos rep is a retard and try to get everything
>>
File: 1670804705187453.jpg (85 KB, 680x680)
85 KB JPG
>>740556342
It's LITERALLY just Nocturnebabies saying that shit.
They're the same retards who actually defend SMTV/VV.
>>
File: Pouting Marie.jpg (61 KB, 600x600)
61 KB JPG
>Gimme gimme chicken tendies,

>Be they crispy or from Wendys.

>Spend my hard-earned good-boy points,

>on Kid's Meal ball pit burger joints .

>Mummy lifts me to the car,

>To find me tendies near and far.

>Enjoy my tasty tendie treats,

>in comfy big boy booster seats.
>>
>>740554249
I'm a zoomie who played p4g in 2022 (blind, so no fandom bias) and I still hated her
>>
>>740556483
She isn't even the worst. She's third-worst.
Rin from Full Body is the second worst.
Alex from SJR is the absolute worst.
>>
RELEASE YOURSELF
>>
>>740553625
>Party
S6ge is not even playable.
>>
>>740554249
>Emo goth stuff was incredibly unpopular and mocked at the time.
lmfao, you Mariefags are so fucking retarded. No, it absolutely was not. Goth girls were not "mocked" at the time, at fucking all. Maire just fucking suck and is a half assed edition that was forced into the game. Thats it. Stop trying to do mental gymnastics to justify it. She is hot, but thats it.
>>
>>740554745
yeah i agree even thou yukiko is my favorite girl marie is ten times better than rise
>>
>>740556206
Marie was a social link character that was never anything more. They changed the entire opening of persona 5 to shove Sumire into it so they could false advertise her as being in more of the game than she actually is because they didn't want to bother changing anything else about the base game to include her.

Which is how we ended up with a scene where you literally tell Sumire she cant come to the dungeon and has to wait outside when she asks because atlus really didn't want to put in anything more than the absolute bare minimum which is also why all the flashback seeds were cut content for a $60 rerelease.
>>
>>740556342
Vengeance was almost great (even if it's basically galge choices), but they're either lazy or ran out of money so 90% of the final chapter is just vanilla 5 again and it's very anticlimactic.
>>
File: file.png (58 KB, 170x161)
58 KB PNG
>>740556336
>>740556123
>>740555240
I honestly want ONE SINGLE atlus game where law seems like the best route

not even because I agree with most lawfags, it's just never EVER even attempted, its always the worst route by 1000 miles with 0 writing behind it and also clearly has the least amount of effort into it as well

I think one of the devil survivor games had an okay-ish law route and that is literaly it
>>
>>740556613
She is the worst in 4. And she came first so the latter two worst girls are Maries forevermore.
>>
>>740556832
SMT2 literally is at its most badass when you go law.
>>
>>740556916
Every route in 2 is great to be fair.
>>
File: 1771014079506439.png (348 KB, 736x715)
348 KB PNG
I mained marie in ultimax and never played golden. I have zero idea what her character is actually like
I only picked her because she's easy as fuck to play and I mashed the fuck out of her j. C divekick
simple as
>>
>>740553101
tsunderes are shit and will always be shit if their name isnt taiga aisaka
>>
>>740556832
SMTVV Law paths are good. Especially the Vengeance Law path
>>
>>740556206
Meanwhile Sumire
>shows up in the casino because she was somehow able to tail the entire party without being detected
>shows up multiple times during the main story to have conversations with joker
>shows up on the hawaii trip to have a moment despite not being in the grade that's taking it
>has a super special social link that is initially broken so they don't even hide that she's unique
>is a party member but only during the third semester because they couldn't bother animating cutscenes to include her
It's not even a contest of who gets shoved down your throat more between Marie and Sumire.
>>
>>740556832
Vengeance and SJR had viable Law routes.
>>
>>740553101
I mean I'd pump and dump her. she's hot as fuck and I've a weakness for tsunderes but Naoto and rise have my heart.
>>
>>740556998
SJR had SHIT writing in general for all the new content.
>>
File: 1761012963125895.jpg (597 KB, 688x1000)
597 KB JPG
Anal fuck Marie
>>
File: marie ultimax.png (298 KB, 900x1301)
298 KB PNG
>>
>>740556982
>especially
*only
Vanilla law is shit, both narratively and in-universe
>>
>>740553101
I didn't mind her. She was a cute dork to add to the cast.
>>
>>740557051
>naoto
Lmao. Enjoy the remake retconning her trans.
>>
File: Yoko.webm (3.78 MB, 1258x966)
3.78 MB
3.78 MB WEBM
>>740555116
yoko has a hotter personality, but Maries is hotter looking.
>>
>>740556991
i dislike them both, but at least marie has a cute design. there is nothing good about sumire, her story is shit and gets screentime shoved into your face at such weird times. also isnt she the only persona girl to ever be the one to confess to (You)? so fucking cringe.
>>
>>740556991
And still remains best P5 girl and canon love interest... Amazing
>>
File: 1639158441263.jpg (377 KB, 1626x1578)
377 KB JPG
>>740556832
>>
File: file.png (432 KB, 622x543)
432 KB PNG
>>740556832
WELL SAID, SON OF MAN!

But this is a PERSONA thread, not SMT! Please read the room. Do not worry, Persona enjoyers - you can trust me to keep the thread on-topic.
>>
>>740557221
just say you hate p5 and move on. you arent special.
>>
>>740557209
>also isnt she the only persona girl to ever be the one to confess to (You)? so fucking cringe.
Holy fucking secondary
>>
File: 1769900214508799.png (55 KB, 214x291)
55 KB PNG
>>740557113
nice. very cute!
>>
How will they even handle kanji? If they make him gay, his world doesn't work. If they kept him as is, it'll get roasted to oblivion.
>>
>>740557346
I like P5R thoughbeit
>>
>>740556832
Law is alright in devil survivor. Then again, all routes are pretty good in devil survivor. Even Yoohoo's somehow manages to become so retarded that it wraps around to being based at the very end
>>
File: 1780150769933628.jpg (78 KB, 1080x1080)
78 KB JPG
>>740557447
I genuinely think 60% of the people following the P4 remake are only doing it to see how Naoto and Kanji end up
>>
>>740557447
>look mom I made the shitpost again
>>
>>740556342
>People always say that SMT's story doesn't matter
fyi the only retards that say this are 3tards. Nocturne is a good game but it very much was the first and only SMT that just went full retard with the story and barely even pretended to have a narrative.

The issue is that 3tards think this should apply to every SMT game for some reason and then they get pissy when that's not a thing even though SMT 1 and 2 also had large narratives.
>>
>>740557447
>it'll get roasted to oblivion.
Literally nobody gives a fuck about danger hairs on twatter.
>>
File: labrys.jpg (234 KB, 1280x720)
234 KB JPG
We can all argue about who the worst spinoff/remake girl is. But we all know who the best one is.
>>
>>740557078
And it was still leagues better than the OG endings which are easily some of the worst written in the series and the most boring because only a total retard would ever pick anything but neutral.
>>
>>740557447
Nobody gives a fuck about the irrelevant opinions on japanese media from the ancilliary western market. You can enjoy the games but your value ends there.
>>
>>740557634
>Yosuke gets to fuck this
ITS NOT FAIR
>>
>>740557634
>i'm walkin ere
>>
>>740556342
>IV, III, and Strange Journey always have people talking about the cast and who they sided with
>III
Ain't no one talking about the merits of the reasons lmao. It's basically true demon or neutral and even then the only reason to do true demon is the mega boss.
>>
>>740553147
I want to BREEEEEEEEEEEED Her
>>
>>740557674
As it should be. Ive thought about making a translated post and spamming it across nip twitter on how nobody that actually enjoys anime in the west wants them to change, with a huge document on how every western game that gave into the "modern audience" shit immediately ate shit.
>>
>>740557634
Extremely low tier character with a terrible gimmicky mechanic and outshined by shadow lab almost the entire relevant tournament run
but whatever she has a funny accent I guess
>>
>>740557674
Atlus cares or they wouldn't tone down the gay jokes in royal
>>
>>740557447
>>740557502
Its not just Kanjia and Naoto stuff, Yosuke and the others all basically aren't comfortable with gays, so modern Western Atlus will probably try to censor them because they are fags.
>>
File: 1759991619597274.jpg (14 KB, 222x289)
14 KB JPG
>>740557447
>How will they even handle kanji? If they make him gay, his world doesn't work.
I never got this logic. Kanji's dungeon works either way since it's not about rather he's gay or not, it's about how he views himself as a man. Rather he likes dicks or not doesn't matter, that's literally pounded into your head over and over.

Also he has a bunch of moments where he does shit like get a boner over Yu during the campout and clearly thinks about the protag in a kinda gay way. Making him hard gay would be stupid, yeah, but making him a little bi for Yu specifically and Naoto wouldn't be the end of the world.

Now Naoto ever being anything remotely close to trans would 100% be a way out of character retcon. She just wants her gender to not matter to her idealized self and a big part of her social link is making her realize she can be both a girl and a cool detective.
>>
>>740553917
Erm gulp at least she raised my courage
>>
>>740557840
They're just going to tone Yosuke down a bit which is honestly probably a good thing since he was way too much of an asshole to Kanji at certain points. Dude implying Kanji wanted to rape them was just wtf tier from him.

And of course HIM being the faggot with the cut gay link doesn't help either.
>>
File: lxmndx9kgj0e1.png (1.09 MB, 1432x1664)
1.09 MB PNG
>>740558102
to be fair Yu and Yosuke literally fight HIS GAY THOUGHTS manifested
>>
>>740557954
Because it's a shitpost that newfags are trying to push again because they think larping as normalfags will derail the thread.
>>
>>740558102
>And of course HIM being the faggot with the cut gay link doesn't help either.
If it was cut, it means it doesn't count. They never added it back in
>>
>>740558258
I hope they make the fight even gayer. Also make it even more obvious Larry's Shadow has a thing for Chie.
>>
>reads thread for 10 minutes straight without realizing this isn't the crossdressing girl
>>
>>740558637
retard
>>
The only Marie content I've consumed is the doujin where some guy cums in her hat and makes her wear it

Best girl
>>
>>740554356
nta but Naoto is for Kanji.
>>
>>740559423
Kanji and Rise have more chemistry together. Naoto matches Yu the most.
>>
>>740553101
I don't like women who dress like retards.
>>
>>740559675
P4 was the last game where the cast would go off and do their own thing(s) with each other without your involvement in between missions right? I hope the next game has more of that and less orbiting around the PC.
>>
>>740559797
Correct. You'd just run into the others doing their own thing. Made the game feel more alive.
On that note, you find Rise and Kanji together quite often.
>>
>>740553147
damn she’s actually hot enough now to where I can forgive her annoying quirks
>>
File: Labby Marii raffu.png (24 KB, 438x469)
24 KB PNG
Sour grapes.

/v/ has been full of poor thirdies who only played ps2 P4 because it was so easy to pirate.
They couldn't play Golden so they cried endlessly
>>
>>740559920
I miss Labby. She was fun.
>>
File: marie dance.jpg (161 KB, 1280x720)
161 KB JPG
>>740559903
>now

She was always hot as fuck.
>>
>>740559797
The general consensus for a long time is that P4 actually feel like friends where every other game they feel like coworkers
I can easily imagine kanji hanging out with chie or teddie just for the sake of it, but I can't imagine yusuke wanting to hang out with morgana or makoto outside thief shit
>>
File: 1654641324691694.jpg (616 KB, 1280x1873)
616 KB JPG
>>740560047
I hope the remake causes an influx of new doujins. I think 4 had some of the best.
>>
File: 1701788039895 (1).jpg (118 KB, 725x1024)
118 KB JPG
>>740559675
Rise is built for birthing Yu's many children
>>
>>740559920
Knower
>>
>>740559675
Wrong and wrong
>>
>>740560672
Factually correct on both.
>>
>>740553101
>Chuds
>(s)
It's just one autist
>>
>>740559920
Mariefags blatantly ignore valid criticism like >>740556124 because they are shallow faggots that only like her for looks
>>
>>740560065
>The general consensus for a long time is that P4 actually feel like friends where every other game they feel like coworkers
For Persona 3, thats intentional. They were all just in a shit situation and they were recruiting anyone they could to investigate further. But its cool because by the very end, you feel like you grew to be friends and are a perfect team.
For Persona 5, they were trying to ape Persona 4 friendship and it just fell really flat aside from like Ryuuji.
>>
>>740562209
>mariefag so in denial that he pretends only one person thinks Marie is shit
>>
>>740559675
>Kanji and Rise have more chemistry together.
What an utterly shit opinion
>>
>>740562770
Persona 5 tried to make the characters way more important than they should have been. Persona 4 was a bunch of kids in the middle of bumfuck nowhere, a detective, and an idol.

Persona 5 needed your generic friend, the hottest girl in school who is also a super model, the class president who is the strongest and smartest person to ever exist and is also closely linked to the case, an ugly billionaire heiress, SUPA HACKA GIRL, and this generations Picasso. There is zero reason for any of these people to ever interact.
>>
>>740562770
>But its cool because by the very end, you feel like you grew to be friends and are a perfect team.
It didn't feel that way at all, though
>>
>>740556362
The problem with Marie's social link is that instead of having her show up in the main story occasionally, everything about Marie is gated behind the SL instead.
If they had scenes of her meeting the rest of the Investigation Team outside of the SL, it'd have given the dynamics they wanted to build with her more time to be properly fleshed out.
They added new scenes like that beach trip where there wasn't really any reason why Marie couldn't have tagged along and gotten to know everyone in a more organic manner.
Since they didn't do any of that, the SL had to cut corners and jump around to showing the rest of the team acting friendly with her, as if they had moments to get to know her off-screen.
>>
>>740563124
Precisely
>>
>>740563052
Maybe you should try playing the game.
>>
>>740562770
Also aside from yusuke and futaba the p5 group doesnt banter enough there way to friendly with each other. And if they do its the same exact thing over and over
>>
>>740563287
I have, a bunch
Maybe you try playing the original or Fes and not Reload
>>
File: 1780859652491610.jpg (317 KB, 2048x1366)
317 KB JPG
>>740553101
Marie got a huge improvement from the new art style change so I think she'll have even more fans now than she did during Golden
>>
>>740553101
I think Marie is sexy but she’s unbearable, even as someone who finds danganronpa funny
>>
>>740557778
You can give it a try, but don't force it if it doesn't work out, so they aren't annoyed by it and the western side doesn't see it too quickly.
>>
>>740557113
Margaret needs more screen time in Revival.
>>
Would Marie be more popular if she had a new jersey accent?
>>
>>740563616
Coconut Head my beloved
>>
>>740555627
NTA, but are you actually arguing they're not all one-dimensional anime tropes?
Have you heard how Futaba speaks?
>>
File: 17789 nanako persona_1.jpg (136 KB, 916x1007)
136 KB JPG
>>740553147
Lmao nah
>>
>>740559920
Pretty much. P4G and Marie is for rich people, P4 is for the poors.
>>
>>740563616
HOLY MOGGING
Marie cutemogs the other two bitches so fucking bad.
>>
File: shadow marie.jpg (284 KB, 1848x699)
284 KB JPG
>people try to argue that Marie isn't the main girl
>her theme in ultimax is literally called XOXO For You
>>
>>740565561
Like Labrys? Nah, I don't think so.
>>
File: HKP5jtqW8AADnIk.jpg (825 KB, 2560x1440)
825 KB JPG
Seeing how they changed the tutorial fight and added karaoke it seems they're not against changing the game. I wonder how much they'll change Marie after all that backlash she got from Golden.
>>
File: 123908312.png (1.23 MB, 1280x1021)
1.23 MB PNG
>>740560123
Q Labyrinth effectively made them canon.
>>
>>740553101
CUM ON HER STOCKINGS AND MAKE HER WEAR THEM
>>
File: file.png (267 KB, 482x599)
267 KB PNG
>>740570553
STUPIDFAGGOTLITTLECOCKSUCKER
>>
NO MARIE NO BUY
>>
>>740557664
You are actually retarded. The original's writing was great and you clearly missed the point of the game because you are too ass blasted that there wasn't a happy ending.
>>
>>740554356
Naoto is a boy
>>
>>740559797
>>740559871
??? what you talking about shrek
you can't run into people hanging outside of forced story segments and SLs
otherwise everyone stands in their designated cuck spot waiting for you to turn up
>>
File: marie sprite.jpg (745 KB, 2611x1799)
745 KB JPG
>>
So whats next after P4R?
P5RR?
>>
>>740553101
I've always liked her. Hating someone for being an anime cliché in "Anime Clichés: The Game" feels kind of arbitrary.
>>
>>740572253
Wow, that's one hell of an improvement
>>
>>740574505
At least her new design will look great
>>
>>740556832
Chaos and law is a false dichotomy, chaos is the ultimate form of lawfaggotry, it is acting in accordance with the natural order of the universe
>>
>>740553101
I get some of the criticism about Marie as a character, for people that played P4 before P4G her inclusion can be seen as someone inserting their OC in a story that was already cohesive enough. But, as someone who played P4G without any prior knowledge about P4 i don't mind her at all, in fact she's my favorite persona girl
>>
>>740553101
She's the best girl. That's why they hate her.
>>
>>740559675
Yukiko is for Yu
Chie is for Yosuke
Naoto and Rise is for a weird (but fun) love triangle with Kanji
Marie is for me
>>
>>740578145
You're for a weird love triangle with a black man and a transgender woman.
>>
>>740578268
>Black guy and trans woman out of nowhere
>>
File: chew.jpg (105 KB, 930x860)
105 KB JPG
>>740553101
OC donut steel whore that has 0 dynamics with the core team
And marietroons are obnoxious
>>
Marie is hated because she's a weak addition to a strong cast. Sumire is loved because she's a strong addition to a fucking atrocious cast.

It's that simple. If you switched them over wholesale, people would hate Sumire and like Marie, because the most important element is context. P4 didn't need any new characters, P5 needed a complete fucking rewrite because it was dogshit.
>>
>>740562770
Found it ironic, how Ryuji was one of the least liked team members in Japan, despite the game's themes.
>>
https://files.catbox.moe/6koi1z.jpg
>>
>>740563590
>implying I played the demake
So youre just retarded then
>>
>>740578407
Based!
>>
File: 1756763455310568.jpg (59 KB, 274x330)
59 KB JPG
>>740578407
For a guy who hates Marie, I find it strange that you saved fat fetish porn of her.
>>
File: Marie BIG.jpg (269 KB, 1024x1280)
269 KB JPG
>>740578407
Amateur hour
>>
>>740556259
The meme of people hating Marie existed well before the P4 animes were even announced.
>>
>>740578145
retard yosuke will never touch best girl, fuck off, retard
>>
File: 1778100761502731.gif (2.01 MB, 200x177)
2.01 MB GIF
>>740578556
>Sumire is loved

There is literally a mod on gamebanana that removes her completely from the game and it's around 2.5k downloads.
>>
>>740580853
>2.5k downloads.
How many people bought Royal?
>>
>>740580896
The better question is how many people even know game banana exists
>>
>>740555627
Anon... You don't really think that Japanese people talk IRL like in anime, right? You are just shitposting or being annoying for the sake of it, right?
Or do you think people in west talk like in cartoons?
>>
>>740578145
Yosuke is for Yu
Chie is for Yukiko
Rise is also for Yu
Naoto is for Kanji
Marie is also for Yu
>>
>>740553101
All the complainers played it in English voice which has absolute dogshit voiceacting.
Remember the original Western version on the Vita had no option for original VA.
People had to either rewatch the game with Japanese on YouTube or run a modded version on emulator before the Steam release.
It was truly a dark time...
>>
>>740581617
Nobody but zoomers gives a fuck about this
>>
>>740557301
This seems like a very trust worthy angel.
>>
File: kill me now.webm (279 KB, 378x326)
279 KB
279 KB WEBM
>I actually lived long enough to see retarded secondary revisionism tourists try to make it seem like 4chan always loved the golden slop content and the retarded cunt that is Marie
>>
File: 147458421212133.jpg (276 KB, 600x531)
276 KB JPG
>>740558102
>Dude implying Kanji wanted to rape them was just wtf tier from him.
Because Yasuke wants to suck cock
>>
>>740554356
being a wiseass and not helping, just stating the obvious after it already happened/was discovered
what people hate makoto for, naoto does 10x worse
>>
>>740560065
I'd say P5's party had decent chemistry up until Makoto. Christ it's insane how Makoto ruins everything the moment she joins.
>>
>>740578145
Kanji x Naoto
Brosuke x Chie
MC x Rise, Yukiko, Ai, Ayane, & Margaret
>>
File: 1773062207632394.png (478 KB, 860x566)
478 KB PNG
>>740580983
>shitposting or being annoying
That eclusively applies to halfwit tourists who come to this site and who fell for the shitpost that liking anime and manga is a tongue in cheek joke or treat it as something that is enjoyed ironically. It doesn't apply to the anons who love everything about it with 100% sincerity. How new are you?
>>
>>740581739
That's literally where the "hate" comes from but these faggots with try to pretend
>>
We're not actually shitposting so hard on a Monday to entertain the fallacy that EN dubs have ever been an acceptable alternative the undisputed better JP talents or history of undubs older than the majority of newfags being alive are we?
>>
>>740582736
That has nothing to do with what the anon said you mindbroken retard
>>
File: DORK!!!.webm (2.09 MB, 640x360)
2.09 MB
2.09 MB WEBM
>>740553147
Built for giving gloved handjobs to me under the table at Junes, and her hat is made to be cummed inside and then forcing her to wear it.

Also what >>740557086 said
>>
File: 1772723227813441.png (257 KB, 512x512)
257 KB PNG
>>740583339
You seem overly upset and hostile, that's no good for a monday morning pal. Try to watch some anime and cool off yeah?
>>
File: 1657297593869.jpg (468 KB, 1237x2477)
468 KB JPG
>>740560120
https://e-hentai.org/g/1133576/02630cdf72/
>>
>>740583339
Ogey shitposter
>>
>>740573870
Anon, right is the old one
>>
>>740582259
I can respect that, haremfriend.
>>
>>740583615
>>740583709
>samefags because he has no argument
concession accepted
>>
Running an Inn together with Yukiko sounds pretty comfy and I'm sure you could convince her to have a threesome with Chie pretty easily.
>>
File: 1756704833592723.png (9 KB, 448x121)
9 KB PNG
>>740583775
but what anime are you watching
i'm still curious
>>
>>740553101
Bad character design and forcefully inserted as filler that doesn't belong
>>
>>740580853
2500 incels is not really a big number
>>
>>740553438
>True ending

Golden shit ending is not a true ending.
>>
>>740585016
It is now.
>>
>>740572253
STOP! I CAN ONLY GET SO ERECT!
>>
>>740585016
>directly references P4A and is referenced in P4D
(You)



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.