Can we finally admit that this was trash?
>>740632002I'm still in the tutorial
>>740632002No. It was the 2nd best game of the series.
>>740632002Even Nintendo's biggest fanboy Dunkey admitted it was trash.
>>740632002I've only ever played the first one. which ones are worth playing?
>>740633682That's not saying much when only the first game was good.
>>740633870Only the first 3 really. Dream Team was ok so you can play it if you want. Paper jam was hot garbage and brothership was...not great but not all that bad (it mostly just overstays its welcome and goes too hard on its themes)
>>740633808>Even Nintendo's biggest fanboy Dunkey admitted it was trash.No that's VinnyDunkey shits on Nintendo on the regular
>>740632002No, Brothership was great, and this goofball of a villain was the highlight of the game.But it would've been better if they shaved off most of the side quests, reduced the length to 20 hours, and added a boss arena (+superboss) and some hidden unlockable Bros. Attacks. Then it would've been an excellent game.
>>740634735None of them are worse than a 6/10, dumbass.
What we actually need to admit is every single M&L game bar Superstar Saga is dogshit, and Alphadream deserved to go bankrupt.
>>740635482>>740634735SuperstarsagaCHADS rise up
>>740635482Correct, SS was also just a 6/10 game
>>740632002No, all M&L are good in my book
>>740636041>the obligatory contrarian
>>740635482Alphadream was actually a very soulful (but retarded) company
>>740636179SS was good but it isn't anything spectacular, everything else after only progressively gets worse and worse
>>740632002it's technically competent completely void of sovl and whimsy.
>>740632002are you on fucking crack? it is outright the best M&L.Yes, it has a VERY rough start buy once it gets going it gets going.
No, I loved it. Though I emulated it and played it at 60fps, which may have helped. Anyway, its my favorite of the series.
>>740632002Superstar Saga (original) >>> Partners in Time > Bowser's Inside Story (original) > Dream Team >>>>>>>>>>>>>> literal shit > Paper Jam > remake slop >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> brothershit
>>740632002Superstar Saga and Bowser's Inside Story are great games.Partners in Time and Dream Team are flawed but good.Brothership is fine but kind of boring.Paper Jam is the most rancid, putrid dogshit to ever exist and every moment I remember it exists I get angrier.
>>740636360>One of the best RPGs of all time >it wasn't that good, aktually
>>740636507Paper Jam's combat was great. That's it though
>>740632002It's better than the 3DS ones at least. What really sucks is the soundtrack since other than the Fortress Zokket theme (which you can never visit again, thanks game), nothing stood out.
>>740632971This. I dropped the game around the 3rd island because it was still treating it like a tutorial. Like holy fuck.>B-but it gets good right after, I swear!I don't care anymore.
>>740636698Even that was bad because they functionally made Paper Mario immortal.
>>740632002I liked it more than Dream Team. It definitely has issues though, whoever decided that the whole first sea needed to be a tutorial should have been fired.
>>740632002Shut up, nerd.
>>740636617>One of the best RPGs of all timeMaybe if it's the only RPG you've played, otherwise no, it's not even close
>>740632002it has starlow so it's still an 8 out of 10
>>740637283
>>740637213Was Sparks of Hope bad? I thought I heard people enjoyed that one.Super Paper Mario in B tier might be controversial, but since everyone either really loves it or really hates it, I guess it averages out.
I was enjoying it at first but by the time I got to the bank heist island it was such a fucking slog
>>740637387I liked it far more than the first, the only mistake was making the Rabbids talk.
>>740637569Funny, I had the opposite opinion. I thought the first sea was mostly boring, and then Lottacoins was when the game started to get interesting. I thought it was fun finding all those clues scattered around the building before the puzzle is "properly" introduced, and then getting the piece of paper that makes all the clues add up.
>>740637213Where's origami king? I just started playing that.
>>740632002No
>>740637569I got bored by the 3rd sea with the entire thing about the couple even if the plot started to pick up. Only when Bowser ENTERED it got interesting again but feels like the writers ran out of ideas since they recycled 2 islands and the last Great Lighthouse was an elevator sequence (even if possessed Bowser is technically the boss when you include the brief Fortress Zokket visit, but it was kinda too soon for a "rematch").
Nintendo first AI powered game
>>740636903Sorry for your shit taste anon
>>740638557Chilliam and Burnadette were quite annoying characters IMO. It was also silly that they did a baby version of Romeo and Juliet when SPM had a serious Romeo and Juliet plot where someone actually got killed (...mostly).
Its crap
>>740638557Sorry anon the twink made of ice gets the fire BBW I liked the music at their wedding
>>740636701Soundtrack is composed more like movie music than Yoko's style was. But it makes some of the scenes sound really grandiose and epic. For example, I love this particular song for how it sets up the motivational mood leading up to the final boss battle: https://youtu.be/VO3J9Tyo2Xk
Were are the bossfights?
>>740635482THREAD SHOULD HAVE ENDED HERE
>The game is great, just gotta play it for like 10 hoursBrotherhood is literally that meme come to life.
>>740632002It was trash from day 1>A button for Luigi actions>30fps>unskippable and extremely lengthy poorly paced tutorial and beginning segmentIt was an insulting game by design. Fuck brothership, M&L should've remained dead
>>740633870all of them except the two remakes, which are more curiosities
>>740632002I only beat a few islands, I'm still waiting for the fucking Switch 2 upgrade.
>>740632002>mario WITH luigi brothership
>>740632002IGN’s review was far more closer to tge truthAt least comparing to those who gave this shit 9s and 10s
i honest to god do not know how i managed to beat this game, because these days i drop a lot of games and can only finish ones that really grip my attention. of course i do come back to the ones i dropped eventually but i actually finished this shit straight throughhonestly, it is a fucking slog at many points in the game. having to navigate the ship and wait in real time is fucking gay, yes i know you get a faster option later but still. the game just goes on and on forever and when you think its about to end, it keeps going. this happens like 2-3 times. the battle system though is definitely the peak of the franchise. the game isn't really that easy either. i think one of my biggest gripes with the game is the battle music. they really needed some variation in battle themes and boss themes. i ended up selling the game, and i would consider buying it again if it got a switch 2 upgrade.
>>740646756> i think one of my biggest gripes with the game is the battle music. they really needed some variation in battle themes and boss themes.Funny you mentioned thatFucking Myimoto himself laughed at the composer and said something like “what are you? A filthy gaijin? This OST is so American”They tried to bring that woman who composed all M&L soundtracks but it was too late for that and she herself was busy for 4 projects around that time
>>740632002you didn't have to wait this long to call it shit anon, we all knew from the trailers alone
>>740635216I don't know why this Hazbin Hotel motherfucker never clicked with me, even if he is genuinely threatening.
>>740632002I think it's good in spite of its glaring flaws.
>>740632002https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hwz7YN1AQmQ
>>740635942I wish my boy would return in a game as the main bad. Closest the series has to a mad scientist villain.
>>740647547He's dead. He can't come back. He exploded.
>>740632002The game starts with a tutorial to teach you how to place objects into receptacles (that's called gameplay) by telling you to make sacrificial offerings to some faggy idol statues. Luigi got stuck in a fence and started making faces like he was taking it up the arse until you press A enough times. It got so gay so fast that I dropped it in the first half hour despite having very little to play at the time.
