What do we think? Is it a solid list?
>>741661680>majority of games are from the past 10 yearswtf /v/ told me gaming is dying
>>741661680No
>>741662017>it's only good if it's uncshit
>>741661680Holy reddit
>>741662085
>>741661680normalfaggot trash alert
Old Good. New Bad.
>>741661680RDR2 sucksGAA2 is worse than AA3>deltatroon>chrono nigger>uminegroKiseki sucks>tranny morganaAss Effect 2 is worse than 1 and 3Legend of Ruina is worse than LobCorp>tendie shit>xenosagaHades 2 sucksTLOU sucks2/10 see me after class
>>741662594>RDR2 sucks>Ass Effect 2 is worse than 1 and 3>Hades 2 sucks>TLOU sucksRetard alert.
/v/ will shit on this list then praise ACTUAL casual moviegames for retards like pic related >showers you in ammo and healing items>combat is incredibly simplistic and just involves tapping one button while the game perfectly autoaims >changing weapons, reloading, and healing can all be done while paused removing all tension>the progression is extremely obvious (the game even flashes/highlights where to go despite it being extremely obvious)>every area has a detailed map even for areas you haven't been and has color coded doors>"""puzzles""" are toddler level and just involve pushing three boxes into a row, moving two bookshelfs to match an illustration right next to it, and pushing a statue into a conveniently placed square >scenario B even reuses many of these braindead ""puzzles"" verbatim with identical solutions >there are no higher difficulties or arrange modes and even Max Rank is pisseasy to earn
>>741662683>1 has the best writing and atmosphere>3 has the best gameplay>2 is neither here not there
>>741661680Too much recent stuff, not having at least doom on there is ridiculous
>>741661680>not a single gaylo gameim impressed
I got rid of the ones I don't think belong. The ones I kept I think can acceptably be placed in the greatest games of all time list.
>>741663264What do you even see in Chrono Nigger? That game is awful.
>>741663264>BotW>Witcher 3>WLK>FF6Lmao. How do you remove some of the best games and leave trash like this?
>>741663264I'd take TLoU, RDR2, Silksong, AstroBot, Elden Ring or E33 over half that shit thereSome of you really have zero independent thought and just blindly praise the /v/-core "classics"
Any top game list without Warcraft 3 in the top 5 can be safely discarded
>>741661680Its ok. Here have a better list.
>>741663654says the tranny crying because /v/ says his normalfag games with shit gameplay are good because they've got high production value/are popular on discord
>>741663881Wtf is this trash listMad Max? BG&E? Greedfall? Control? Crysis? Conan? This has to be some kind of joke
>>741664012Crysis is actually pretty good. FC1 > Crysis >> FC2 > FC3Frostpunk 2 is the real headscratcher.
>>741663990TLoU, Silksong, and Hades 2 have better gameplay than damn near every game on your list lmaoBoomershit is certainly not praised for its deep and challenging gameplay see >>741662798You have fucking JRPGs, Mario Galaxy, and Witcher 3 talking about "muh gameplay". Get a fucking clue you poser faggot with no clears.
I'm sorry man but I disregard any list with Disco Elysium. Its barely a step above visual novels.
>>741664127>Frostpunk 2 is the real headscratcher.Frostpunk 2 is bretty good, people are salty that it's not the same as Frost Punk 1 but i unironically like 2 more.
>>741664185JRPGs can have good gameplay. I'd put Wizardry, SaGa games, Bravely Default and E33 over Hades 2 (which is worse than 1 in every regard)
>>741661680>shit, kino, mid, kino, kino, shit>kino, mid, mid, kino, shit, shit>kino, mid, kino, kino, kino, kino>mid, mid, kino, kino, shit, mid>kino, shit, shit, shit, kino, kino>kino, kino, shit, mid, mid, mid>mid, kino, shit, kino, kino, kino>mid, mid, mid, mid, shit, shit>shit, shit, shit, kino, shit, shit>shit, shit, mid, shit, kino, mid20 shit, 17 mid, 23 kino. Overall I was expecting much worse but still pretty dogshit.
>>741664012>Wtf is this trash list>sees kino list>calls is trashThis is what tranny hormones do to a motherfucker.
>>741661680>xenosaga 3okay that's surprising>no metroidtrash list
>>741664348Wizardry is not a jRPG.>inb4 what about the slop that the japanese produced after buying the rights from SirTechLOL:LMAO even! Those games are TRASH!
>>741661680Astrobot was such a psyop. That said 95% of this list is unoffensive and filled with legit good games.What's between Hollow Knight and Kingdom Hearts 2 though?
>>741664348>JRPGs can have good gameplayThey could but they almost never do, and certainly not the ones you have included in the image. They usually just involve braindead grinding, shallow button mashing combat with simplistic decision trees, repetitive random encounters, and zero semblance of balance or intentionality. Strategy/tactic games almost universally have better combat than JRPGs and with the added benefit of no grinding bloat bullshit or wandering around towns speaking to every tom, dick, and harry to progress the story.Funny you talk about "muh production values" when that's basically all JRPGs have to offer (and Witcher 3 and Mario Galaxy for that matter)
>>741664690Library of Ruina. Some deck-building slop.
>>741664690Legend of Ruina. Its inclusion is a surprise to me, as Colonoscopy Corporation is better in practically every way other than production values.
>>741664351>BG3 and E33 shitNot even past the first line you are already you are delusional retard tranny. You are a subhuman and your opinion is worthless.
>>741664838BG3 is an insult to one of the best vidya series of all time.E33 is postmodernist wank dressed up in an ugly UE5 palette.Neither are close to good. BG3 in particular is one of the buggiest games I've played in my life.
>>741661680I just can't get behind SH2. Is it a first come, first served sort of deal? Psychological horror, gaming as an art form etc whatever etc was in its infancy, so it'll always be on the list?I just always thought the voice acting was bizarre. Not intentionally bizarre, shit bizarre
>>741665036You are brown and have 70 IQ, no one cares about your opinion champ
>>741665117Might not want to open with "you're brown" when defending games associated with shitskins.
>>741661680>flower, sun and raindangerously based
>>741665036Only people I've seen dislike BG3 are either terminally online /pol/tard schizos or literal retards filtered by the combat.Similar to E33, except swap /pol/tards foe brainlets who can't comprehend or appreciate the story.Half that list is games you've never played and just download opinions on regardless.
>>741661680Is Astro Bot really a better 3D plataformer than every single mario game ever released?
>>741661680most of them are decent, only a few are bad games, quite a few mid games tho
>>741661680All great games, to be honest.Contrarians can stay mad
>>741665195BG3 and E33 are both developed almost exclusively by whites for whites.I know you have a very warped view of reality, but these games almost entirely appeal to high IQ, discerning, white westerners.
>>741665458*by trannies for tranniesfify
>>741665442trails in the sky sc is a great game?you can't honestly think that right? i mean i like it but... great?honestly almost every jrpg on that list is painfully mid, all of the best ones are absent
>>741665294Probably. It's certainly better than vast majority of them
>>741661680>Hello Charlotte that highNot that I disagree but huh.
>>741665249>Only people I've seen dislike BG3 are either terminally online /pol/tard schizos or literal retards filtered by the combat.I don't give a shit about the 'wokeness' or whatever and the game is piss easy. It's just bad, and a direct insult to the BG series.Very early on in the game (first dungeon) I ran into a ladder that was entirely unusable. Clicking on it did nothing. Tried everything, eventually just had to backtrack through the entire dungeon to get out.Vampire dude is obviously a vampire and yet you never get the chance to call him out for being a vampire, you have to give him the chance to attack you and then not retaliate, when any character in that position would of course kill the guy who just attacked you in your sleep.UI is terrible, multiple times the game would say I have enough movement speed to get to a certain location, then fail to get me there because it failed to calculate a bit of mud or whatever that reduces movement speed. Doing anything in the game is slow and immersion-breaking as shit because the retarded insistence of flashing a big spinning die on screen whenever you want to scratch your ass.And of course, the game takes a steaming shit on the achievements of the original series. Viccy is still a cunt working for Shar. Jaheira is still working for the Harpers. Sarevok never found his own purpose, he's just Bhaal's bitch. And somehow Melly is alive and working for Bhaal as well. You didn't even get rid of all the Bhaalspawn. It's actually disgusting.>Similar to E33, except swap /pol/tards foe brainlets who can't comprehend or appreciate the story.E33's story is extremely simple: nothing matters, everything is fake. It's your typical demoralizing postmodernist horseshit, the TLJ of video games. It's only interesting to people who have never been intellectually challenged by any media before in their lives.>>741665458If Whites made BG3 it would be RTwP. E33 wouldn't be ugly UE5 cancer.
>>741661680>expedition 33
>>741666619>browntard gets filtered and has a melty>wah!! stats too confusing!! quest too hard!! UI too complex!! it not fast paced like muh fortnite!!Kek
>>741666619>E33's story is extremely simple: nothing matters, everything is fake. It's your typical demoralizing postmodernist horseshit, the TLJ of video games. It's only interesting to people who have never been intellectually challenged by any media before in their lives.I thought the media illiteracy thing was a meme but some people really are this stupid lmao
>>741666868>>741666994I accept your concession.
>>741666619>E33's story is extremely simple: nothing matters, everything is fake.
>>741666619>another retard seething about BG3 because it filtered him>another retard seething about E33 because he never played it and/or was too low IQ to understand the story and its themesIt's tiring
>>741661680Glitchwave's list is marginally better but they have less ratings. More japanese games at the top than western ones as well
>>741662683>RDR2 sucks>Ass Effect 2 is worse than 1 and 3>Hades 2 sucks>TLOU sucksYou are a humongous normalfag if you think these deserve to be "top rated" in any capacity.
>gay sex the game>you got filtered bro
>>741667187>great game bad because popular (unless old in which case it's still good)Don't you get tired of being an insufferable contrarian faggot?I've been gaming for 30 years, I've beat over 1000 games, and cleared everything from casual to hardcore. I can form and express my own opinions on games from my extensive history with the medium and my high IQ, white skin, and good taste. I don't just blindly follow public consensus, nor the same but reversed by just being a constant contrarian to public consensus.
>>741667182One thing both sites need to fix is to reduce weight for newer games, things like dem4ke won't be on this list in a few years for example. E33 has already been knocked off so hard that it's not even in top 50 anymore
>>741668195>yume 2kki that high????????????????????
>>741668195Somehow an even more trooncore list
>>741667675>I've been gaming for 30 years, I've beat over 1000 games, and cleared everything from casual to hardcore.It clearly doesn't show given your retarded opinions.
>>741668195>check E33 pagekek
>>741668532Woah you showed me
These rating sites will never take off because videogame players are stupid
>>741667174>seething about BG3 because it filtered himAre you schizophrenic? What are you even referencing?>too low IQ to understand the story and its themesAny themes the story has are tossed out the window when the game says "by the way literally nothing that's been happening matters at all because everyone involved is an NPC in a fake world". The creators nuked their own creation. You might as well try to create a compelling story about someone deciding whether to delete a save file in a video game. There's absolutely nothing of value there beyond the novelty of "DUDE WHAT AN EPIC SUBVERSION BRO". You can't even pretend to bring up anything deep about the game because there's nothing there. It's subversion for subversion's own sake.
>>741661680>Final Fantasy 3
>>741668805>when the game says "by the way literally nothing that's been happening matters at all because everyone involved is an NPC in a fake world"You're retarded, we know, no need to keep rubbing that in like this.
>>741668897>he's still not saying anything
>>741661680the ultimate larp list
damn ive only played 4 of those games and only 6 I'm willing to try
>>741661680>Discuck ElysiumOpinion discarded
Could use a sega arcade game or something. Outrun 2. I dunno im old
>>741661680>Silksong Lol that shit is already forgotten in the big 2026
>>741669430It was the only decent release of 2025. For people who actually care about video games, it was a huge deal.
>It appears our superiority is causing some controversy
>>741661680OUT OF THE WAY! MY SUPERIOR TASTE OUTSHINES ALL OF YOU HERE! BASK IN MY GLORY!
>>741669776If you dress in silly costumes at a formal event you're a cunt. Everyone hates these special snowflake types.
>>741661680I really loved only 4 games from that list.
>>741661850welcome to review sites nigga. games released recently get the most hype.
>>741661680Three of my top five are in the first row, so looks good to me.
>>741669902still more respectable than wearing a suit
>>741669984>BG3 shit>E33 shit>Final Fantasy GOATLmao, you are about as stupid as they fucking come. Jarpiggers are not fucking human
>>741669984You have some of the worst taste I've ever seen in my life. I'm glad fags like you are miserable and seethe about the current state of gaming.
>>741661680>Baldur's Gate 3Why do people think this game is so good? I guarantee a lot of the people who love it don't even like CRPGs as a genre. Is it just some kind of strange hype contagion?
>>741670492BG3 is dogshit, kys tranny
>>741670619>Why do people think this game is so good?Because it is.
>>741670689/pol/tard incel crybaby
>>741661680>Recency bias>VNs>A handful of canon classics>and also Rhythm Heaven Fever
>>741662085>it's only good if it's uncshitGenerally, yes
>>741670736>it is a tranny after allOf course, you freaks try to invade crpgs like you try to invade women's bathrooms
>>741661680the faggots on backloggd all have the same personality
>>741669984>RDR2 good>Outer Wilds midkill yourself
>>741661680lol
>>741670864Because their jannies ban people whose scores they don't like. I got banned for "vote manipulation", whatever that means.
>>741670619It's a masterpiece.I did 3 playthroughs (Balanced, Tactician, Honour) and I just can't get over how far and above better it is than every RPG in existence.It has absolutely top-notch>sense of adventure, immersion, world-building>free-form, challenging, open-ended combat with strong focus on environmental interaction>deep mechanics, strong strategic elements, high replayability>tons of classes, build variety, spells, playstyles to tinker with>memorable fights against a huge variety of well-designed enemies & bosses in unique scenarios that take part in context of a greater narrative/quest, instead of just braindead throwaway trashmobs>limited, unique combat encounters and exponential level system remove the trash mob farming of most RPGs and ensure proper balance throughout the game>incredible intricate, inter-connected world design packed with secrets>memorable, open-ended and branching quests with tons of interactivity/reactivity>vast amounts of player choice & freedom>satisfying power fantasy story where you are a divine being honing his power and gathering strength>lighthearted, downright funny writing that still knows when to be serious or somber>well-written characters with nuanced and engaging arcs>attention to detail, ability to interact with anything, go anywhere, go in any interior, steal anything, kill anyone, story always adapts to your actionsThere are many games that are strong in one aspect, and weak in others. BG3 is as strong in its weakest aspects as most RPGs are in their strongest aspect. It is just such an incredibly well-rounded game, and it especially excels in open-ended environmental-based combat, player choice and freedom, and interactivity/reactivity that are completely untouched by any other comparable RPG in existence (except other Larian RPGs). This is what a true 10/10 looks like. I just compare any RPG to it, and it's no competition, BG3 is better in every conceivable way.
>>741662798>>combat is incredibly simplistic and just involves tapping one button while the game perfectly autoaimsSimple isn't bad, and you still have to manage your position. You can't just stand in one place and destroy everything.>>the progression is extremely obvious (the game even flashes/highlights where to go despite it being extremely obvious)No it doesn't. Only the keys.
>>741670569>I'm glad fags like you [...] seethe about the current state of gamingI'm not though
>>741671079Based Meanwhile average BG3 hater is a drooling terminally online /pol/ retard>>741670619>>741670689>id bad cud it hav gay>it too hawd for me :((((>wher guns and ackshin???
>>741671094>You can't just stand in one place and destroy everything.Except you literally can do that even on the hardesr difficulty and still get max ranks. The game also gives you an absurd amount of health and ammo to allow you to do just that and still finish with a shit ton of resources
>>741661680>Never played any of those dogshitfeels so good
>>741671160But you admit you are miserable, would explain the shit taste.
>>741661680>strong recency bias (impossible to evade without tipping the scale like other websites do)>almost all RPGs/JRPGs are memes. BG3 and E33 topping the category is absurd>the 2D platformers are hollow knight/ss and sotn. Great vanias, but nothing else?>FPS only gets half life 2 way at the bottom>puzzle games are just portal 2 and obra dinn>entire genres completely muscled out by le cinematic masterpieces thank you kojimbo>everything released before the year ~2003 was either a generational, earth-shattering hit, or has funny memes on youtube for zoomers to recognizeIt's pretty good besides being pretty lopsided towards the average tourist loser. I enjoy many of these games, but gentrifying everyone's tastes into one big bland mix always feels depressing.
>>741671079I concur.
>>741671562BG3 and E33 are the peak of CRPG and JRPG tho, better than delusional boomer picks like Fallout and Chrono Nigger
>>741671079I mean, it does some things well, but personally I can't get past what I consider to be goofy writing and presentation, the incredibly slow encounters and the obsession with sex. It's got a ton of stuff to find but there's so much of it it almost feels like a theme park, and combined with the overly progressive sentiment that kind of ruins the world building for me. The mind flayer/tadpole stuff railroads the story too much, also.I never got far enough to confirm, but I hear everything is front-loaded and Act 3 is complete garbage.I'm not sold on it and probably never will be, but I'm glad you're able to articulate your reasons for thinking it's great.
>>741671702How convenient is it that both came out very recentlyYou must have played a vast wealth of RPGs to come to this assuredly reasonable assessment
>>741671702You must be 18 to post here lil bro
>>741671702I just played Chrono Trigger last year with zero nostalgia and I can honestly say it's one of the best JRPGs ever created, easily.
>>741670619It's designed for DID YOU KNOW shortsbait. Zoomies will see a tiktok pointing out there's some pointless detail like "if you make everyone naked and throw a barrel to glitch out an NPC's pathing while having the chicken fucker feat then your companion will have a unique line of dialogue before the game forces you back on the rails". It's good at making people who don't like games gasp at the sheer amount of DETAIL as they completely ignore the story, gameplay, worldbuilding, etc. as a whole.
>>741671976>goofy writing and presentation>incredibly slow encounters>obsession with sex>feels like a theme park>overly progressive sentiment>Act 3 is complete garbageTrying way too hard, just throwing out every buzzword you've ever heard about this game. Either haven't played it or are just a grade-A retard who is obsessed with /pol/shit and endlessly seethes about it rent-free.The writing is better than most CRPGs and more than makes up for it with its humor, dialogue choices, branching paths, player agency, and top-tier companion quests.It has some of the absolute best turn-based combat out there with unique, well-designed non-repeatable enemy and boss encounters that are challenging and memorable and well-integrated into the environment and questlines, so your only complaint is "it's slow" because you actually have to think and make decisions instead of just mindlessly mashing like most RTWP slopTheme park used as an insult is always hilarious to me because theme parks are designed to be fun as fuck, just like theme park games are fun. A game is meant to be a scaled down version of reality, it shouldn't have vast deserts of emptiness and copy-pasted environments just to stimulate real-life. Theme park means your game is incredibly dense with interesting content with minimal bloat. Classic Zelda is a theme park, Souls is a theme park, RE is a theme park, Mario is a theme park, WoW is a theme park, DKC is a theme park, KH is a theme park, etc. This isn't the insult you think it is.Act 3 is a slight downgrade, but only because Act 1 and 2 are so incredible, that a 9/10 can only ever look "weak" compared to a 12/10 and 11/10, but only a fucking moron would consider a 9/10 as "garbage"
>>741672379And yet E33 mogs it to death.>>741672039And boomer retards think every good CRPG ever came out during a 5 year span in the late 90s-early 00s.DOS2 and BG3 are some of if not the absolute best turn-based RPGs of all time. Larian is on a generational run.
>>741672643Why do you just make delusional headcanons about games you've never played and know nothing about just as an excuse to hate them? You sound like a fucking 70 IQ retard right now
>>741663264anyone that keeps Baldur's Gate 3 in the list is a giant faggot whose opinion must be immediately discarded
>>741673001This but the complete opposite. It shows you are a completely mentally ill, terminally online schizo /pol/tard who is willing to overlook a genuine 10/10 masterpiece just because it contains slightly progressive shit that is completely OPTIONAL.
>>741673109Claiming the game is a 10/10 exposes you as being disingenuous. The bugs alone knock it down to a 7 at most.
>>741672719>Trying way too hard, just throwing out every buzzword you've ever heard about this gameI won't pull you up for this since you actually chose to engage with my points, but I will point out that not liking my wording doesn't invalidate what I'm saying.>obsessed with /pol/shit Only one of my points could be characterized as /pol/shit, and I do think it negatively impacts the integrity of the setting, yes.>The writing is better than most CRPGsI didn't say it's terrible, just that it's goofy. I'm including presentation here because the narration and character animations absolutely do not do it for me.>It has some of the absolute best turn-based combat out there with unique, well-designed non-repeatable enemy and boss encounters that are challenging and memorableThe encounter design is good.>so your only complaint is "it's slow" because you actually have to think and make decisions instead of just mindlessly mashing like most RTWP slopThere's no reason that those encounters should take as long as they do. It's not just having to take turns, it's the weird and unnecessary pauses in between that add up to excessively sluggish combat.>Theme park used as an insult is always hilarious to me because theme parks are designed to be fun as fuck, just like theme park games are fun.Sure, but a setting shouldn't feel like a theme park. Unless the setting is a theme park.>Classic Zelda is a theme park, Souls is a theme park, RE is a theme park, Mario is a theme park, WoW is a theme park, DKC is a theme park, KH is a theme park, etc. Those games all hide it better than BG3. BG2 is very dense in terms of content but also hides it better than BG3.>Act 3 is a slight downgrade, but only because Act 1 and 2 are so incredible, that a 9/10 can only ever look "weak" compared to a 12/10 and 11/10, but only a fucking moron would consider a 9/10 as "garbage"Like I said, I never got that far, so I'll take your word for it.
>>741661680I'm glad we all agree TGAA1/2 aren't just the best AA games, but top 10 greatest games of all time.
>>741661680these sites are the social media of gamingit's just one big hivemind of FOMOs and vibes>look at me, i played it too, yeah it's GOTY man
>>741673109>completely OPTIONALYou don't have to engage with it, but it still suffuses the setting. It's not "optional" as part of the experience.
>>741661680Final Fantasy III
>>741671702>BG3 and E33 are the peak of CRPG and JRPGIf you are a millenial maybe. Both are mediocre games and both only shine in soundtracks and combat, the rest is complete bullshit. My god even the boomers have made better games than you morons. Millenials shouldn't be allowed to breathe let alone speak.
>>741675078>If you are a millenial maybe. Both are mediocre games and both only shine in soundtracks and combatI don't disagree with you, but which games would you say are peak CRPG and JRPG?
Millenials are a damn embarrasment to the entire earth. They don't belong anywhere. They are what you call a "generation" of "outcasts". They can't even pick a side.Kill all millenials in minecraft obviously
>>741675153>JPRG Obviously Persona 5 Royal . Not even a debate.>CRPG Now that is very difficult to answer. I am not a tabletop expert. I have played the following CRPG games - Pathfinder Kingmaker and WOTR, BG3, DOS 2, Disco Elysium, Warhammer 40K Rogue Trader. I don't I am qualified to answer that question, because there must be many games Underrail (for example I heard is very popular amongst, but also very difficult so I didn't touch that game). Anyways for me it is Pathfinder WOTR, but this is an unexperienced answer.
>>741661680I want to see (you)r backloggd, anon!
>>741675556>>741675078This has to be some kind of bit or a falseflag troll. No way you are actually this much of a transparent poser retard.
>>741676173Sorry for the grammatical errors. Explain why you disliked my post.
>>741676226Because you're a brown retard seconary trying to larp as some expert. Your taste is hilariously bad.It's like shitting on The Godfather and Seven Samurai and then saying your favorite films are Infinity War and Star Wars The Last Jedi
>>741675556Why P5R out of all the Atlus JRPGs? The gameplay is strictly worse than the SMT games so it can't be that and the writing in P5 is the weakest out of the post-P2 Persona games. I'd say SMT:VV and Metaphor are easily better than P5R even if they have glaring weaknesses in level design and story respectively.
>>741675556E33 pounds your shitty VN dating sim with a combat system for babies into the fucking dirt.
>>741676537P5R is a brilliant fusion of style and soul. The game’s pacing and loop which is balancing schooldays, confidants, and palaces creates a satisfying rhythm. Something which is absent in SMT games. My only qualm with it was it not having a gay confidant. Akechi came pretty close but I don't think Atlus is going to allow any kind of LGBTQ represenation despite how subtle (the way I like it). Metaphor is just straight up bad, cause it lacks the "rhythm", the "flow" which P5R developed.
>>741661680>Oot>Mass effect 2>Deltarune>Yakuza>Trails in the SkyHoly slop Batman!
>>741675556I've beaten P5 twice, and E33 steamrolls it. Persona's fancy presentation can only carry it so far before you realize it has simpler gameplay than Pokémon.
>>741661680Each row only has 1 or 2 good games. More than 2/3s of these suck
>>741676987>The game’s pacing and loop which is balancing schooldays, confidants, and palaces creates a satisfying rhythm.Every Persona game does this.>Something which is absent in SMT games.That's a good thing to me.>My only qualm with it was it not having a gay confidant. Akechi came pretty close but I don't think Atlus is going to allow any kind of LGBTQ represenation despite how subtle (the way I like it).This is a plus to me. Fujos and gays must suffer.>Metaphor is just straight up bad, cause it lacks the "rhythm", the "flow" which P5R developed.Okay, but the gameplay is undeniably better even if it isn't a high school slice of life simulator. Also P5R didn't develop that, Persona 3 and 4 are the exact same and P3 even used the calendar to better effect than the other games.The way you described it it literally just sounds like you primarily like it because of the "aesthetic" and "vibe". It is a very stylish game, but games are way more than that and visual design and pacing alone can't carry a game so that it's "Not even a debate." it's the best JRPG.
>>741676987Is this a trollpost?
>>741673109by mentioning /pol as ad hominem tells me you are tranny lefty redditor/chatbotter, ergo your opinion is completely worthless. ill never play your shitty game.
>>741677571P3 and P4 have an outdated interface. Even the remasters are terrible to look at, blocky dialogue boxes and bad text that looks garbage (even though I play on a 4K OLED). While you can say the stories are good, they are still not good as the main story of P5 (let us not include Maruki, because then the comparision would be unfair, as Maruki's story was one of the greatest in gaming, you know it is KINO when you don't want to even fight the antagonist). P5 developed and mastered the foundation that it was laid on. >>741677284Not every single game has to be a fromsoft copycat with Soulslike elements. If you want to play Elden Ring 1925152152, that is your buisness but I am tired of fromdrones and their OCD over higher difficulty.
>>741661680>OotHoly fuck millennials need to hurry up and die off already.
>>7416781201. E33 is not even remotely a soulslike2. Difficulty the main draw of E33 in the slightest3. that's not how you use the term OCD. OCD is not just interchangeable with 'obsession'So tired of reading these garbage posts from ugly turd world mutt retards
>>741664351>Yakuza 0 mid>Hollow Knight Silksong kinoFucking retard.
>>741661680>Umineko>Outer Wilds>RDR2Holy reddit
>>741661680I hated Baldur's Gate 3, so I would discard this list. Also, real Silent Hill players know 2 isn't so indisputably the best one, so I immediately know this is based purely on hype and popularity.
