I'm afraid /v/
>>743414273>*Kills, mugs, and pillages with no remorse*>*Gets AIDS*>”Oh no, better Red Dead Redeem myself before I die”Insincere writing
>>743414414Anon, you understand that remorse happens after the fact, right? He feels guilty over all of his actions and him facing his own death is what causes him to reflect on the lives he's taken and regret it. Just because he didn't regret it previously doesn't mean his regret now is insincere. at most, you could argue ludo-narrative dissonance, because you could go right back to killin civies immediately after this cutscene lmao. But that's a player issue. The game's story is basically made for high honor arthur
>>743414414That's quite realistic for a criminal or just people in general actually
>>743414414>Uhm, this character is hypocritical and has contradicting values, therefore, not well written!You never opened a book, I assume.
>>743415629the writing failed by not starting at a point where the gang was actually getting along. you’re supposed to feel tragedy for a group of characters you hate, and feel the weight of Dutch’s mental decline and fear despite him being retarded the entire game. it’s poorly written from top to bottom
>>743414273WE MUST BE BETTER MEN!!
What is with /v/ and trying to make fun of any male character who isn't a one dimensional,?mission-obessed autist who refrains from talking or having an opinion for 90% of their games?
>>743414414times were different in 1899
Where the fuck is this mission? Played this game so much but I must have missed this one.
>>743416206arthur is a cuck who has no growth. he is always doubting yet doing what dutch says the ENTIRE game
>>743416389>he missed the most important mission for the character arcLol
>johns death scene>*takes a deep breath, opens stable doors, gets riddled with bullets and dies* >arthur's death scene>takes like 3 hours to die, flopping all over "I gave you everythin i gawt dutch...*cough*... duuutch... *cough*" some gay pussy ass way to go out, fucking marvel type shit, had me literally saying fucking die already you dork I'll never understand RDR2, it's like it's specifically tailored for retards.
>WE ALL HAD HER>BUT HE MARRIED HER
>>743416469Arthur went out beating the shit out of Micah while terminally ill
>>743416705after he let Micah destroy the entire gang, sure
Best girl passing by
>>743416808>I hate this piece of shit, but hell his plan might work. Lemme see how this goes..
>>743416832I want to rub her butt a little
>>743414273I really dont understand why are people using this as some kind of emotional thing in this gameArthur was a greedy piece of shit who killed hundreds of innocents just for money. I am not saying I didnt enjoy the game, but the decs wanted me to forget his past and feel sorry for him just because he was dying. kek, no.
>>743416841what the fuck plan was that lel
the actual reason why GTA5 and RDR2 didnt hook me is because they relied too much on the narrative and it didnt feel right to simply explore and do what you want. Nico was a foreigner and it was just natural for him to explore Liberty city on his own.
>>743416930Tah-hiti or bust, but first we gotta make a ruckus
>>743415502oh give me a break. It is like you should feel sorry for the guy who killed and raped hundreds just because he is afrad on his death row.The story is retarded, and no ammount of mental gymnastics is going to help that.
>>743416902The emotional connection is to people who were misled by someone they trusted or cared about a lot. A lot of people have friends that went off the deep end, Arthur watched as a father figure of his lost control and drove half of the gang to their deaths. Despite what people he help out near the end say, Arthur wasn't a good man and I think in the end the game tries to make it clear. But for me..I'm a pretty bad person too. But I try to be...better. That's what Arthur did, and he died while trying to make it work.>"I tried. In the end, I did.">fuckin died
>>743417142holy reddit
>alright im done with all this murder, looting, and polluting its time to settle down with muh wife>wtf why wont the cops leave me alone i said i was over this cowboy shit
unironically don't care, it's a kino moment love redemption stories and making the best out of what little time you have left on earth
>>743417234But they SAID they would let me live! They LIED to me!
>>743414273
>>743417019>retarded>ammount Dealing with the people who've infested this board has become so fucking tiresome.
>>743417265>Frau Juinge, I am afraid>I know the allies are near at our bunker, and I did many shit, but during my last days at the bunker I gave some money to the bunker janitor, am I reedemed now?
Why did she do it /v/ros... I spared him...
>>743416832oh have people finally got over their hatred for her?
>>743417142>Put in charge of rescuing the most obvious wormtongue betrayer ever >don't just blast him during the shootout and blame it on the lawmenWhole narrative hinges on Arthur being totally retarded. Micah was so obviously the rat I thought it was meant to be a fake out.
>>743417324I accept your surrender
>>743417394I still think a good twist would have been that he wasn't the rat and that Milton lied. Micah never flat out admits it, the closest thing is when Arthur calls him one and he says "I'm a survivor!". Him being a rat just seems too obvious
>>743417378who's "people"? fags?
>>743414273Low honour arthur has a better story
>>743417374because she’s a fucking badass girl boss
>>743417516you know the kind, those who seethe because women exist.
>>743417516Mmmmm...hey how did people clean their asses in the 1800s?
>>743414414Fear of death and the resulting reflection on one’s life and the state of one’s soul in the face of it is such a primal human experience that I don’t even know where to begin. So ignoring that, are you upset that Arthur has a character arc? Would you rather play as a one dimensional villain like Micah?
>>743417394yeah the fact that you actually have zero choices as Arthur sucks
>>743414273Good, fuck you. Shouldn’t have been practicing usury.
>>743417657>THEM INTREST RATES WERE REASONABLE! REASONABLE!
>>743416864why only a little
>>743417718I'm not greedy
>>743417718have you seen how tiny it is
8 years later and I'm still going "AAaaAAHH I broke the goddamn [x]" during mild inconveniences a la Arthurhttps://youtu.be/1qPUp4ZyzfQ?si=cl4exYAjcbQMExNA&t=13
>>743417761that perfectly describes Arthur
i liked Charlotte but she walled pretty fast
>>743417019Nobody is asking you to feel sorry for him???
>>743414273Kratos of wild west
>>743415502>lemme redeem myself by doubling my kill count
>>743414273me too
>>743417761>insisting
>>743420757it has 100+ hours of gameplay after that OP is a faggot
>>743417761Damn I think i might be autistic
>>743414273Poutslut
