After playing RDR 2 and playing RDR 1 again, do you let him live or kill him? Nigga left you in the dust
Reminder RDR1 means Red Dead Revolver btw desu
Killing him is most moral. He's going to die either way, either the Pinkertons humiliate him and drive him all the way back to America to be tried and then hanged publicly, or you can just put him out of his misery then and there.
i always give john the pleasure of shooting his rattiest ex "comrades"
Maybe I didn't see enough optional dialogue but Bill and Javier were handled way too soft in 2. By the time of 1 they completely hate John and his family and other than them taking Dutch's side in the end they didn't really transition them there.
>>746139094The only one I feel sorry for killing is Bill Williamson
>>746139216No because the games actually have nothing to do with eachother except for a reference made by a random npc and 1 easter egg.
>>746142214>games actually have nothing to do with eachother>Both are from Red Dead series>Made by the same guys>In the same in-game universe>Using the same topics and themesSettle down, RDR1 IS Red Dead Revolver
>>746141914>implored to reconsider>doesntWTF was his problem??
>>746142372i fucking loved red dead revolver as a kid and i always felt that my love was rewarded when redemption and 2 came out
>>746141562This. RDR2 did a poor job of showing them turning into absolute scum, especially Javier.
>>746144369Always thought the same. Even if they were utter ratfucks to their core all the time, RDR2 doesn’t really portray it well with most of the cast beyond Dutch and the RDR1 portrayals feel jarring after playing 2.Obviously they can’t change 1 afterwards, but they could have made those guys more ratty in 2 to make it work smoother, now 2 basically has Micah and Dutch carrying the shitbag torch alone. Yeah yeah, they all are criminals in 2, not good people, but the differences in portrayals is still massive.
>>746141562They didn't change that much, they were just hired guns for some mexican dictator, its isn't that much of a change.
>>746139216No, RD1 is Red Dead Revolver. Both Redemption and Revolver at the first in their own continuity. For the sake of specificity I stop the specification at the D then add the number. In this there's no mistake. People call RDR RD1 and RDR2 RD2, that's where there's no debate to be had and where correction isn't mere autism.
>>746139094he's just a funny little ripa ripa andalewhy would you kill him?
>>746139094RDR2 isn't canon and shouldn't be taken into consideration
