She was the correct choice, right /v/?
>>746477174I haven't beaten the game. But logically you've been with her a long while and she's just asking for some babies and a wedding ring how is she the bad guy.?
Socially yes but you do you, no one can dictate your life.
>>746477174Katherine is definitely the best choice in the base game. I wanted to choose the waitress though.yeah yeah I know
actual best girl
>>746478243>>746478189
>>746477174>used goods>correct choice
the first ending i got, vincent ended up single sleeping peacefully
>>746478189>>746478243I wanted to fuck the tranny too. Is she fuckable in the 2nd version? Never played it.
>>746477174>Will you choose the sex demon who loves you and wants to build a life together?>Or the sex demon who has spent the entire relationship manipulating you and literally trying to murder you?It's a difficult choice, man.
>>746477174It's every man's dream to fuck DEMON PUSSY so hard he becomes the lord of hell
>>746479928No she's not but weird enough Full Body did add a separate femboy as the third option
>>746480107Attempted but ultimately futile babymaking sex and loving cuddles with Rin.
>>746478001She's not. Vincent's inability to make a decision is what makes him the bad guy and is the point. Stay with K, break up with K, Vincent's indecisiveness makes things worse for everyone.
>>746480562>>746480107Rin is the actual worst Atlus Expansion "Girl". Yes, worse than Space Yukiko SJR.
>>746477174Yes she was. Scenes and context shows she was a loyal and caring partner. Women have a limited time to start a family. Stringing along a woman for sex and robbing her of that limited time window that she chose to give to you because you're too lazy is highly immoral. Start the car or get out, it's that simple.
>>746483804It's her fault for sticking around that long.
>>746485453She loved Vincent, and he could have been, intentionally or not, been acting in a way to manipulate her and make her feel uneasy about walking away if he didn't do something as drastic as cheating.
>>746478001Lying about being pregnant to force the issue is her being the bad guy.She's 100% absolutely justified in having her own wants and needs until she withholds something as massive as that.They had to write her that way because otherwise yeah Vicent is a fuckhead throughout but since it does happen anyone sticking with K is a fool.
>>746481026You only say that because Rin has a penis.
>>746485683>She loved VincentEvery chick loves their shitty bf and they choose to stick around in a relationship going nowhere. Same old tired story. No matter the excuses, it's their choice to stick around and they will be left with the consequences. No getting around it. And here's what K simps and similar ilk don't want to acknowledge: she was okay with being Vincent's mommy gf and enabling his manchild ways. The "good one" in the "good partner"-"bad partner" relationship tends to get psychological gratification from being the "selfless" one, the dependable one, the one keeping it together, the one with the real power. She only started getting antsy because of fomo from seeing her peers married with children and her parents getting on her, basically societal pressure to conform.
>>746486035I don't like it because it's about obligation, not love. Not committing to your pregnant gf is a scumbag choice. But the basis of commitment is a lie that will come out sooner or later.On the one hand, it fits the Law/Chaos alignment thing. On the other hand, this is real world serious business; you don't play around with this kind of stuff.
Glasses stay on
>>746487028Not much to say because I think we are just agreeing at this point.But I'll say that obligation can lead to love and love can lead to obligation.I know an arranged marriage that seems to have created a lovingly and functional family and a few friends who'd "never have families" step up after knocking someone up.But lying about your obligation to trick your partner into love is just an active villain move so K can go fuck herself.>>746487121But we can all agree on this.
>>746487307>>746487028Obligation and love are so intermingled that it leads to some pretty fucked up circumstances. For example if you're gf is hurting then as her partner, you're obligated to be her pillar of support until she recovers. But what happens if you're hurting too. And you can't be her pillar of support? Is her having a breakdown your fault? If she snaps out of pain, how much empathy do you offer? Or flip it around, if you're so fucked up that you act in ways you never would in normal circumstances, is she wrong for telling you to fuck off? It's why Xitter relationship trauma is fucking stupid because there's way too many nuances that don't fit into Twitter's character limit to be interpreted by people who don't know the poster.All that to say K choosing a fucked up decision to try and keep her bf, whom she genuinely loves, is the type of messy shit that does happen in even "stable" relationships. But in the best case scenario, people outside the house will never see it. But because we're piloting an actual manchild, now we have to reckon with (you) putting her in a position to make a desperate decision and K making the decision in the first place. Because I tell you now if K didn't do it but just chose to leave immediately, everyone would be calling her a bitch who didn't even try
>>746487521Whatever the fuck you are trying to say in that first paragraph is really dumb and self obsessed so the advice is "Stop being in your early 20's" or stop thinking your twitter GF is real or whatever the fuck you are on about.I'm pretty sure the characters in Catherine are in their 30's. At that point you don't get to pretend to "genuinely love" someone you are trying to manipulate into a life long commitment.You are an actively evil person and no if she just chose to leave immediately to pursue what she herself wanted but Vincent didn't she wouldn't be an evil bitch regardless of how many morons called her that.Morality isn't a democracy and I sure as shit can better argue why a person is doing the right thing when the otherside is "Lying to your boyfriend about being pregnant to get him to marry you"
>>746487307Guess I'm saying it's too much of a given to be with K if she's pregnant, regardless of whether you really want to. Having it be a lie was the right choice narratively even if the character took a hit morally, it balanced the characters out.
>>746488451Yeah we are just agreeing with each other. It had to happen to make a more interesting narrative even if it turns K from being in the "right" to badddddddddd.And then for some reason they remade the game and added a Q that I can't even begin to add as part of the overall narrative.Full Body really really sucks.
>>746477174There was no right choice. That's one thing Atlus got right, for once.
>>746477174She's the definition of toxic relationship
>>746480107>>746480562Bunch of unironic homos
